Interstellar’s Editing Is Out of This World
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 вер 2020
- Editing is that thing that travels through time. Do you want to learn how to edit feature films? ➜ MY FREE MINI-COURSE- secreteditinghacks.com
Looking at every cut of Interstellar, I created a visual board (thisguyedits.com/interstellar) of anything that I noticed and eventually arrived at Murph's room, to be the key to the film's structure. Six scenes takes place in Murph's room prior to the 3rd Act climax with Cooper inside the Tesseract. Notably, Cooper witnesses seven moments as he skips through the different time layers. And there's a reason why.
#Interstellar #FilmEditing #TesseractScene
-----------------------------------
THIS GUY EDITS (TGE) is a youtube channel by film editor Sven Pape, an A.C.E. award nominee, whose credits include work for directors James Cameron, Joseph Gordon-Levitt and James Franco.
------------------------------------
Check out my editing setup at kit.co/ThisGuyEdits
★- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ★
Want More THIS GUY EDITS?
☆Connect With Me On My:☆
➜ PATREON MEMBERSHIP-
/ thisguyedits
➜ INSTAGRAM-
thisguyedits#
➜ TWITTER-
/ thisguyedits
➜ FACEBOOK GROUP-
/ thisguyedits
➜ ONLINE EDITING COURSE-
thegotoeditor.thinkific.com
★- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ★
Music By:
Envato Elements - Check out this playlist for specific songs: elements.envato.com/collectio...
All Rights Reserved
© Copyright 2020 This Guy Edits™ - Фільми й анімація
Since the movie “Interstellar” released, only 45 minutes and 34 seconds have passed on Miller’s planet
Fuck this is a crazy underrated post
Nah
NAH
NNNNNAAAAAAAHH
Dayumn son
Oh Ghaad
Pin this comment!
My one regret is never seeing this in cinemas. That soundtrack is ethereal!
I was in cinema and really had to pee and i went at the worst moment... When i came bakc i lost like 20 years hahaha
i think you can rent out a theater during this quarantine
same bruuh
It was replayed once this year in UK in the cinema , after the first lockdown, I can tell you even though I have seen it many times, twice in the cinema, it still took my breath away
I saw this in theater when it came out. I was in complete awe. A truly unreal experience.
I guess you could say the editor did a stellar job
Editors
out of this world, perhaps
Good God people in comments didn't get the simple reference 💀
badum tss
Yeah... But... There's a problem, the moment the slam into a cloud that turns out to be ice, for a realistic film we don't even a moment to the see the crew react nor does anyone talk about it at all, the speed and impact of that should of broken the thing a part or at least impact them in some way.
If you want to know how impactful Interstellar was, I still remember the night we watched it at the movies and I was sleepless for hours just staring at the ceiling 😐
If you wanna know how impactful it was, I cry anytime I watch a story/editing breakdown of the film. And every time I even think of the ending scene with Old Murph. Really I cry thinking about the movie in general. And i legitimately don't cry almost ever normally.
@@Alex-bw6yd same it had me at the edge of tears so I stopped it for a short while. Kinda regret I did, its good to let the emotions run free. Guess I gotta rewatch it haha
I remember as well. I also just watched it a couple of days ago and I could not fall asleep. My mind kept going back, reviewing scenes, asking what if.
It was a beautiful night for me to be able to see it in the big screen with only few watchers.
thats beautiful
The soundtrack is literally the peak of film music.
Ludwig goranson he also does it for Mandalorian and Tennet
@@pwned2bad nope, its Hans Zimmer
Hats off to Hans Zimmer
I read somewhere that the soundtrack is so amazing that has its own fan base inside movie.
I remember seeing Interstellar opening night at my local AMC IMAX in Spokane and I’ve never forgotten the way I felt watching this film. To date, it’s my favorite Chris Nolan film I’ve seen opening night (I’m still waiting to see Tenet in theaters out of respect for Nolan’s wishes to the fans).
this movie is what pushed my interest in physics, astronomy, quantum mechanics, and spirituality and now i’m dead ass working to become an astrophysicist lmfao. *movies have impact*
have you ever seen 2001 a space odyssey?
I saw that one before interstellar came out and thats what did it for me. when I saw interstellar in theaters it blew my mind just like 2001... both amazing film
Watch the movie Contact it's the only movie better than this one
@@City0fTroy I watch that movie again last week in memory of Arecibo Telescope :(
Same! I started studying physics this year and Interstellar played a big role in that decision
This movie and Nolan’s Dunkirk are the two movies that made me want to become a filmmaker. So I’m starting to write stories now.
This video makes you understand how vital it is that the editor
a) understands storytelling
b) understands the story the director and writer want to tell
Interstellar is a masterpiece of our time. Chris Nolan + Hanz Zimmer music = Epicness
*Hans
"Epicness" for dummies.
???@@cinemusicberlin
Nah bro it's a masterpiece ahead of our time. This movie won't ever get old, and i don't think i will ever get tired of it.
that movie no matter how many times i watch it, it doesn't get boring at all
Exactly, the other film is « Children of Men » for me
True that
@@Xationch Children of Men is one great movie.
write to google: Trastler
True bro
"Interstellar's Editing Is Out of This World"
*Your puns are interstellar*
No, your puns are.
I'll slap you into space
BIG BRAIN TIME
His puns are truly astronomical
@@lilarav689 jokes on you we are already IN space.
“What I did understand was the emotion.”
This is the basis of most Chris Nolan movies. This is why Nolan movies are so popular, because they’re cerebral, well plotted stories laid on a carefully, precisely constructed framework based on emotions of characters, leading them to be tense, exciting, unpredictable and yet somehow understandable to the audience in an emotional way.
And in addition Nolan movies possess brilliant direction, cinematography, editing, special effects, and of course, music. Nolan has built a solid, highly capable creative team which dovetails with his style perfectly.
"...Emotion."
Yoko Taro be like: "this mf' spittin'..."
....and then Tenet came out
@@masterwindu1234 That movie is special in it's own way. It doesn't have emotional connection, True. But, it didn't had that aim, what it aimed is to show what can happen if some 'parts' of Theoretical physics is applied to movie. It's kind of like Nolan experimenting with his movie making skills. Yes, I do understand that's it's not easy to understand even after watching 2 times. Due, to dialogue being inaudible etc. But it's a movie of it's own kind, which is completely different in a way that it applies time travel...
I liked it but the first thing i expected from tenet was a great emotional story because thats something nolan film always promises . I was disappointed but still the plot was appreciable
Depends which one. Batman Begins and Dunkirk didn't have very good cinematography.
i wish i could watch this film for the first time again
I feel this comment.
Enter the Tesseract and this may be possible.
Everytime i watch this it feels like the first time
I wish i would had watched this movie in the theatres..not in my phone
Without Hans I don't think this movie would have hit the way it does.
The scene where he's crying at himself not to leave his daughter ...Having lost my father at a young age, that scene crushes my heart everytime
im sorry for you mate, stay strong :(
my condolences. I remember the moment exactly, when I sat in the Imax, and this scene came up - everyone cried. I went for a second screening in English language, a month later, and there where probably 15 guys in the room - everyone cried. After a year, watched it at home with the wife, everyone cried.
It was 23 years ago now... but that child-like innocence of simply not understanding it, as she does when he leaves her....My Father died in a hospice, and I was walked in to say my final goodbyes at the age of 10 which is diifficult when there's so much drugs in his system to keep him pain free..The way the Father cries out to be with his child in this scene, I felt the same in my Fathers eyes looking at me for the last time...Kills me
Thanks for the kind messages guys.
I get very emotional as well in this scene. My view on this scene is that what I do in the current time and the mistakes I have made make memories with friends or family or even someone I like and doing something I should have asked her or mistake why someone I like don't like me back what I have said. I look into the past and think about what I could have done for the better or mistake I made in the past has caused me to be where I am now sad with nobody to give my love and affection to. This really hits deep for me. I hope whoever is reading this doesn't have the same issues I do as I need to live life to my fullest and say yes to an opportune life gives them and not worry about why woman you approach don't accept who you are as a person.
^_^ God bless you ♥♥♥ :")
The fact that we are still discussing this movie so many years after it's release is amazing. Truly a masterpiece
So many years? It's only 6 years.
@@persona83 He's travelling near light speed.
@@persona83 If he is 12, this is half of his life
its not even 1 hour in millers planet
2001 a space odyssey was released in '68 and that movie is still discussed
after years people are still talking about this movie. just comes to show that this film is a modern masterpiece.
The internet has unleashed the potential of a lot of talented people like this man. Otherwise, he would've probably been stuck at some corporate office doing what they tell him to do and bury his analogy and editing skills.
Amazing video, man. Just amazing.
Amen
This comment!
"THIS GUY EDITS (TGE) is a youtube channel by film editor Sven Pape, an A.C.E. award nominee, whose credits include work for directors James Cameron, Joseph Gordon-Levitt and James Franco."
17:05 "At this point about 60% of the audience..." is FULLY CRYING THEIR EYES OUT
isn't this so fascinating?
Lets make that 75 %
Lmao I cried my eyes out just watching the breakdown. It's been 20 minutes since i finished it and i still think about it for a second and start crying again.
this was the only that could make me cry not lying
@@hairylegs1319 I understood that reference
No movie have ever made me feel this certain feeling.
try "Arrival"
@@birseyleryap true.
@@glozzas9305 fr tho is it that there is a scarcity in these kinds of films. Like creative and epic yet heartbreaking movies. Idk when i was young i was really invested and taken into the narrative of movies (prob cuz i was yound and dumb lol) but i don't recall any other movie that brought me that feeling other than interstellar
@@birseyleryap Arrival is probably my favorite Sci-Fi movie. I'm beyond thankful I saw that and Interstellar in IMAX, since I like to watch movies knowing nothing about them beforehand. Too many trailers that completely ruin movies buy overexposing and putting key parts and characters in them.
Imagine if you knew Matt Damon was going to be in Interstellar. That really caught me by surprise.
@@birseyleryap Can't agree more. These two are my favourite films, they make me feel like no other movie ever did. I've watched them both multiple times but every damn time I end up devastated but weirdly not in a bad way.
I'm gonna say it people who like Interstellar are my family. I don't care where you are from , what you are , you are FAMILY
Yes my Dear Brother , I'm from Chennai I too feel as you feel.
I have been crying after heard 'Don't leave me Murph'
Hello new brother😀
@@AliAhmadi-dk8ht Hello bro
Hello there! 👋🙂🚀🌌
@@omicronceti42 hello
When I tell people that this is my favorite movie of all time and they reply with ''eh, it wasn't that good'' I honestly start feeling sorry for them.
Not because I don't respect their preferences, but how can a human being not love this movie.
This movie makes you think, wonder, cry, it gives you answers, and most importantly it separates itself from the classic and tbh boring plots of movies that are being released today.
It's a classic and in my opinion, the best movie humanity has ever produced.
I know what you're talking about. I found out that the people I had a discussion with over this movie were unable to grasp the concept of a black hole, spacetime and more than three dimensions. One needs an IQ well above average to understand this movie and only then one can enjoy it.
@@Osmone_Everony Did…did you just…I…Do you also watch Rick and Morty?
I don't think it's even close to the best movie humanity has ever produced. I mean, it's not even the best science fiction movie ever made. It's basically a worse version of 2001. It does certain things better, but as a whole it really doesn't come close
@@Osmone_Everony hmm yes, a fellow Rick & Morty enjoyer
@@errwhattheflip also doesnt really have anything at all to do with 2001, other than space
This movie is a goldmine of small details, One of my favorite is when Dr. Mann tries to hijack Endurance and causes an explosion in Endurance, You can hear the part of the explosion for a very brief moment since the Endurance was pressurized at that time but then it depressurized instantly and we cannot hear any more of the explosion.
This scene felt odd at the start, Because movies usually exaggerate explosions. But later thinking about it, All of it made a lot more sense because sound doesn't travel in vacuum of space, So they literally made us experience that scene as if we were physically there!
It's not easy to make a silent scene in space without it being very boring. In Starwars and Star Trek there's always noises because otherwise it looks boring af. Imagine Kenobi and Skywalker shooting at vulture droids and massive battle ships breaking in half without any sound, even I would probably fall asleep.
Christopher Nolan had a lot of courage to stick with silence in that scene, it really is a feather in his cap, and he's proven that it's possible to do a realistic space movie that is always entertaining.
What video editor is he using?
kinda thinking kipp thorne happened by while that was being foleyed, picked up on the scene and told them that same exact thing.... as the air ran out, so would the sound. he ran it by nolan, and nolan said to the production, 'kipp is my jesus, do as he says. '
@@iActuallyLiveinUtah FCPX
@@JeremiahBostwick (Final Cut Pro X)
The entirety of human race was not ready for this movie ..
but you
Speak for yourself.
The true message of this movie is not about the intergalactic travel but how we slowly destroying our planet, and we actually notice it but we didn't do anything to change it, i actually notice it but iam powerless.
No, not yet.
But one day.
is it "Underrated"?
“Don’t you just love how Matthew Mcconaughey mumbles his lines” 🤣
2001 A Space Odyssey is looked at more as a piece of art. Interstellar is going to be remembered as an experience. Literally every aspect of this movie, whether its the acting, direction, cinematography, the editing, the sound design, THE MUSIC, set design, and writing(debatable)...is firing on all cylinders. It represents the peak of filmmaking. It also has 2 scenes that I think will go down in history as some of the greatest scenes put on film; watching his children’s messages scene and the docking sequence.
I remember seeing this movie in IMAX on the first day of release, planned it perfectly to make sure i got there early to get center seats and not too close to the screen. Right after Cooper pleads to Dr. Mann not to dock and then Mann blew himself up, Cooper accelerates towards the Endurance and Dr. Brandt then asks Cooper what he's doing, and he just says..."docking" (Cue Hanz Zimmer's score). I lost my shit in the theater, I got goosebumps and literally leaned forward and audibly said pretty loudly "what...the...fuck!?!". As the scene went on I remember thinking, Nolan... you crazy bastard , you just cranked the intensity up to a 10. Then the music tipped it over to an 11. That moment, that sequence with that music and the sound just blasting. Sensory Overload...I will never forget the experience.
Seriously, if you sat down and really thought about "what" this movie is about, like really thought about all its themes, all its layers of depth and what its trying to say, your gonna come to only one conclusion. Its about Everything.
just watched this masterpiece and I'm addcited to this kind of genre. Do you have something to recommend like this movies ( interstellar & a space odyssey) ? would glady to watch more of it. Thanks a lot in advance.
@@kristelgicana3235 The movie Contact in my opinion beats both of the movies you named. There is no other movie that's similar to it. If you just go in and watch it without knowing anything about it prior it will be even more insane, which is how I watched it. Also a Matthew McConaughey movie with Jodie foster and more
...its not evrithing....its a piece pseudo imagining.... a replacement of God...in other words... quite silly...
@@joebangs5616 your god is a construct of you own imagination. A projection of your own conciousness, if you will.
Legends have it, editors have to take an IQ test for editing Nolan's movies.
@spim randsley I don't have enough iq to answer that.
I mean I can surely buy this
Probably true. You can't have an IQ over 70.
This is the cringiest comment I've read in a while.
IQ tests are BULLSHIT
If this movie is released again in theatres... It would still be Superhit.
I've heard IMAX offers some reruns at select IMAX theaters every once in a while.
It's being projected in Barcelona. Watched it yersterday!!
it's being projected in India as well. TENET is also releasing on 4th .
last year I got to see a rerun in the cinema, I'd seen the movie twice at home but seeing it on the big screen was one of my best movie experiences ever. Funny enough, it couldn't beat the first time I watched it at home on a 19'' computer screen.
Was lucky and had a local theater show it for during space week last year. It wasn't IMAX, but still the big screen. Left awed just like the first time I saw it.
Interstellar is one of them movies that makes everyone feel like they're an astrophysicist
Tbh if you weren't interested in it beforehand I just don't think you'd experience the movie in the same way
This
we all love, so we all can insert our love into time and fiddle with the dark matter inside the black hole
Wow, impressive breakdown!!
thats what she said
@@justADeni 😆
@@justADeni Is that a good thing?
she said: Wow, impressive breakdown!
How could that be good?
meh not really
I get chills every time I hear him say ‘we brought ourselves’
Can you give me an explanation why he said that
It's such an incredibly powerful statement
@@kidomar6165 "Them" is actually the human civilization in the future. This is what I think he meant anyways.
u7yukjguygj
@@kidomar6165 it was his decision to go into the black hole, hence he brought himself there
“Isn’t it amazing how Matthew McConaughey just mumbles his lines” The key to Interstellar right there.
Hahahaa when I heard him say that I was like this is so true. MaConaughey is saying something so significant like it's nothing. Great actor
Literally his whole career. Mumbles McConaughey.
Ryan Gowler haha didn’t realize how popular this comment became
It's funny as the youtuber mumbles even more.
Editor: You can not edit like this, it’s impossible
Nolan: no, it’s necessary
So, He's in 3d space, in the representation of a 4d object created by beings who can perceive the 5th dimension. in the 4th dimension you can see your beginning and your end, but in the 5th dimension you can see all your beginnings & all your endings. These beings, they, are the future humans in that time line who allow Matthew to open the path to that time line so that they can create this tesseract & save humanity..
I think I lost myself trying to explain this.. Some help & critiques would be appreciated.
I think you nailed it.
Yep
You got it. 👍🏻
huh? we already experience the 4th dimension every day.
@@LeNoLi. uhhh.. No. we are 3rd-dimensional creatures, living in a 3rd-dimensional world. The retina is a two-dimensional surface, everything it observes is limited to being 2-dimensional; our eyes can only perceive and therefore show us the second dimension. Seeing in the 3rd dimension is simply a trick of the eyes: and by extension the brain. It's a simple byproduct of our evolution putting the eyes on the front of our faces.
This movie is in my heart and I feel sad when people says they didn't like Interstellar.
Don't mind them, not film is liked by everyone
Probably a snobby, pretentious Tarantino fan who thinks hating Nolan is a personality trait
SAAAAMEEE!
I really don't understand either, it's not just about sci-fi, space and stuff. The most understandable thing in the film whether you like sci-fi or not is the emotions. This film is a rollercoaster of emotions, I get sad when cooper leaves murph, I feel heartbroken when I see him crying in the tesaaract when he sees his daughter and their last moments, I am happy when the equation is solved and there's hope for humanity. Especially the scenes where murphy is so old and they are finally reuinted and she sends him away to brand who is just alone on a planet a galaxy away, so he won't have to watch his own child die in front of him just after they find each other again. How you not like this?
same for me
In the theater, when Coop falls into the tesseract, we collectively made involuntary loud sounds out of our faces
and i swear i could **hear** minds getting blown, including my own.
As an (film)editor myself, I’ve noticed that there are very few films where I don’t watch it like an editor...this was one of them. It’s just perfection
This is one of my favorite films. As someone who knows absolutely nothing about film editing or really, the film-making process, I absolutely loved this. Thank you
My favourite thing about interstellar is I must have seen nearly a hundred good videos on UA-cam breaking down different aspects of the film. Nolan puts so much work into details, it's an absolute treat to know others appreciate it too
Sometimes it seems like low hanging fruit for some creators but like ThisGuyEdits really does it in a really insightful way. I've been putting my own favorite films in my editor and analyzing scenes to learn stuff. I hadn't even thought about pulling apart the 3 different story lines that are presented in this one!
I see so many videos of these film youtubers just bashing the film and saying they hate it
@@lukekelly3627 my best friend hates it, I love it. We're both movie buffs. Different things appeal to different people
@@AquaticImages ye I think some people just feel the emotion of the film and the love. And some just don't feel it
I've heard too many people say they didn't appreciate this movie, and I really think it's because Nolan was beyond his time with this one. It really is his most profound work so far, as a statement on love, science, family, the Earth... the list goes on. It's going to take years, maybe decades for people as a whole to catch up to the genius here. It's always been my favorite of Nolan's and in my top 10 ever.
I mean, when a movie makes an actual scientific breakthrough in astrophysics with it's vfx you know it's beyond it's time. (the wormhole render)
its a blackhole render.
Ok, so if someone doesn't appreciate this movie is behind times (at least the time you and nolan live in).
I would love to hear from you what are the movie statements about:
1) Love
2) Science
3) Family
4) The Earth.
P.s. There are no scientific breakthroughs anywhere in this movie, but some mistakes (and some naive screenplay choices, but not even the people beyond their time will recognize many of them, as I can see).
@@TheRaretunes love travels through space and time.
Science : life beyond planet earth and what space exploration might look like if we can somehow travel through wormhole. (Though in this section there are many loopholes in the movie but it atleast intrigues many viewers read more about space exploration.)
Family : I think it's a beautiful story about father and daughter. And thier relation through time and space.
The Earth : the rate that we are destroying mother earth there might be a day where we have to find new one.
Though I am not on board with breakthrough in science part.
One might say it is a breakthrough movie making. But not in science.
Interstellar is not a perfect movie. Still I love it.
Tell me your top 10 movies...
I want to know if there's still something for me to discover....
@@davidjuneja "Love travels through space and time". This isn't a "profound statement" about love, not even for a high school agenda.
- there's no statement about life outside Earth. There are people searching for a new home near a blackhole. When we have possibilities in our solar system.
- There is almost no development in any character outside the main one, let alone the "family". The only decent scene is a cry for longing. Nothing more.
- The only statement about Earth is "we're screwed and we don't know why", nothing more
You love it and you deserve to love it. But this doesn't mean is objectively a good flick.
2:21 "It's like the film holds the answer to how we exist and what will happen to us when we don't anymore." There's something so raw about that line. Gets me every time I watch this.
....wow...do u understand what u are saying?...this thing holds the answers to evrithing?...u cant b serious...look around u...this made-up thing holds the answers. ..
Amazing film, cinematic masterpiece. Loved this breakdown it actually helped me understand the film more than when I first saw it.
Glad it was helpful!
It wasn't you who didn't understand the film more. It's the cinematic masterpiece that's so clunky that not much can be understood from it. Ooh, he pushes books from within the teseract... with his love..
@@criztu Just admit you're stupid and can't grasp the concept of the movie.
What an amazing breakdown of my favourite film, this film means so much to me and to see you break it down was great!
Wow, thanks!
Honestly, same 💕
Please tell me you've read the screenplay? It is so insightful and some of the notes left in the margins of some versions are really cool to see what Nolan was thinking about and to see his process as the story sort of unfolded for him in awe just like it did on screen for us! The Best honestly!
Thank you for this
Same here my man. Love this movie forever!
6 year i've been waiting for this analysis. Thanks
Nice!
That’s about 51 minutes on Miller’s Planet 😂
@@nikolaipulido8785 This little maneuver's gonna cost us 51 -years- minutes.
I get Goosebumps everytime I hear that soundtrack
I remember when I saw Interstellar in a packed IMAX theater. When the movie ended and the credits started rolling, not a single person moved said a word for... 60 seconds? Three minutes? An eternity? [What is time, anyway?] EVERYONE was left wide-eyed and speechless. Hardly anyone spoke as we pulled our minds back into our bodies and walked out of the theater. I've never experienced that before or since.
Hans Zimmer's soundtrack is what takes this movie to a whole other level. I get goosebumps everytime I listen to it. This is Nolan's masterpiece.
This Breakdown was not possible it was necessary
well that's contradictory
@@THEaxz95 English, evidently, is not his first language. Or he's American, which is pretty much the same thing. Either way, I do wonder what word he accidentally substituted for 'possible'. If we knew, it might actually be a really deep comment.
@@cristonsloan he meant to say sufficient, not possible.
Clarification: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necessity_and_sufficiency
@@kraxhaug2279 Ah ok, thank you Anders, that does make sense, although in my opinion, in order to remove room for confusion entirely, one needs to add the word "only" (and maybe even "downright" for good measure) - as in, "this Breakdown is not only sufficient, but downright necessary". That, for me anyway, makes it very clear. Thanks man! And also to the OP, I totally agree.
you should EDIT your comment with proper punctuation
don't let me leave murph :( actually shed a tear in this movie at the part where he saw his kids older than he was ;___;
I straight up broke down at least three times ToT
i love how you have the past on the bottom layer, present on the main timeline, and the future on the top.
Great vid.
Glad you liked it!
You said, "This scene...took me to a place very few films ever do anymore." I felt this way about so much of this film. I've seen this film at least a dozen times since its release. Thank you for this video. It allowed me to watch this powerful sequence and to see it from a different perspective. I appreciate you and I'm a new fan of yours.
On my first viewing of Interstellar I thought it an interesting intellectual exercise. But on many, many subsequent viewing, I realize the movie for what is is, an imperfect masterpiece.
Nolan dares to ‘swing for the fences,’ and although he doesn’t succeed 100%, he dares to go where other filmmakers are afraid to tread.
Interstellar is a beautiful love letter. And love is always messy.
Well, maybe we should change the words we are using. "Perfect" "imperfect" what do those even mean? What in this universe is perfect? It's for sure a masterpiece, and a story that scales something we NEVER consistently get from Hollywood and only a few select directors have ever had the opportunity to go there you know? Love is messy, and if we get really philosophical which is where the movie goes, these emotions and memories of heros of the past, and dreams of the future, isn't that just our way of expressing our love for this place? The imperfections, the riots, the gull and daring nature of us? It's fantastic to see a small, imperfect, living breathing human creature falling into a black hole... like THAT is what stories are, overcoming the black.
This is one pretentious ass comment thread
@@icecreamvendor8245 bro I agree with you 😂 some Nolan fans can't tolerate the word "imperfect " and starts justifying it with terms and words and I bet you they don't know that not all can be fooled by Pretentiousness
Well said man...
@@abhiruproy8592 "Pretentious," and "ambitious," are two sides of the same coin, and it's up to each individual viewer to decide for themselves which side the coin lands. You not a big fan? Okay. I can't argue with that. Peace.
Interstellar is by FAR my favourite movie of all time, and the soundtrack is amazing
That organ hits hard with emotion
12:35 audience learning while protagonist learning is the structure of entire films, like Men In Black and The Matrix. Exposition is not always bad. Good point-out.
Some scenes made me cry.
Having a daughter of my own, this films went all in on the emotions a father would feel.
Thank you for going over this film.
I simply cry each time i see the scenes to understand Nolan's thinking, the thought behind the movie, each scene, heroes sacrifice, return to his daughter...true art always touches the heart coz its made of pure vibrations..
Malappuram??
@@mercesletifer6625 yep manjeri
We need more Christopher Nolan MOVIES in our life.
Have you watched tenet?
@@agussastrawan3671, IT IS BETTER THAN INCEPTION!
I haven't watched it cause Im 16 and quarantine :< I wish I was there before Nolan can't make movies anymore
@@coolphoenix_0724 who.. still does not... stream any movies or TV series... free of charge on Stremio...
@@the_real_atlas IT IS NOT.
The tesseract scene was the scene that made me fall in love with Interstellar. It makes so emotionally and it’s full meaning and transcendence. My favorite movie after so many years.
What struck me was how "Interstellar" is really a ghost movie, on many levels. Ghosts of time we lost with our loved ones. Ghosts of our past selves, and those of our family. And of course the actual manifestation of an invisible conscious agent interacting with the real world, which happens to be the same person as who is being interacted with. These are also elements of "A Ghost Story" another great movie from the last few years, about an actual ghost, interacting with himself. Edit: And Casey Affleck is in both movies, I just realised.
As a parent the "Stay" scene... it breaks me everytime...
my favourite movie ever , studying physics rn and this movie is what inspired me to do it. The tesseracts music "quantifiable connection" hits so hard
I'm a medical student, would kill to be doing some juicy physics right now. Enjoy your delicious physics
@@hareecionelson5875 ty bro
10:20 that scene still makes me tear up a little and I've rewatched it 3 times, this movie man... Such a masterpiece.
Far and away the single best breakdown and analysis of a film I've ever seen. Incredibly good work here. Makes me appreciate the brilliance of this remarkable film even more!
Literally yesterday I was watching the scene STAY purely for the piece of music but I loved when he is driving away, we hear the countdown and move straight to him in the rocket. We’re still left with the emotion of him leaving his kids just as he would be in those final moments left on earth before lift off.
Brilliant analysis!🔥
Atmosphere, pretty much everything, so solid, to me this film is watching someone with a team of people working at the peak of creative talent! This was the first script I bought just to study, this was a real like prospective shifting movie for me at least!
From heartbreak to absolute deafening awe.
That reel made imax theaters disturb the other movies playing in the other rooms.
Every bookshelf is trying to talk to you, just you won't listen.
The whole movie is out of this world .
The concept .
Acting .
Cinematography.
Vfx
All are top notch
I saw this movie in theaters as kid the same week our school did a trip to the JPL center in Pasadena California , when I was in middle school. I realized then that I wanted to become a high altitude pilot. I joined the airforce rotc program durring college, but unfortunately I was hit by a car that drove through a red light when I was on a morning run, and that marked the end of my dream. Years later I went back to school and slowly finis hed my degree in electrical engineering recently. I now work as a defense contractor where I help design avionics systems for fighter jets. This movie made me realize what I loved as a kid until today as an adult and that was space and flight. So I hold Interstellar true to my heart.
It's not just a movie, it showed how it all might come to an end and still we would be able to flourish...and it might just be true..SOMEDAY!
I've watched this movie many times but I still cried at 19:00
Shit i was curious as to what was in 19:00 but i didn’t click it because i was in the second minute. Then i cried at at the end and came back to see this comment and it was exact 19:00 😭
Wow. I'm blown away of how well done this analysis was. Thank you for explaining it to us in a manner that is comprehensible.
Easily my favourite film for so many reasons - and that scene in particular is so impactful that I get a lump in my throat even watching it being broken down in your video. A true masterpiece 🙌
Nolan is an astro-physicist who became a movie director by accident
Nolan in his lab writing formulas «Oh shit, was tryna write the formula for interstellar travel, guess I wrote an award winning, 2 hour long movie. Better make it happen»
Lololol. You wild.
Nolan is clearly an robot sent back from the future to save us all from ourselves.
Also thanks to Kip Throne!
People will analize this masterpiece for years. One of the most unique experiences I ever experienced in cinema.
Amazing analysis, it nearly brought me to tears all over again. The power this movie holds is something truly wonderful and awe inspiring.
Even now just watching these edited scenes evokes so much emotion in me, that at the time of watching this film I was going through the most painful time in my life for my own daughter and never knew if id see her again when she was just 4 - the power of love on this level holds no equal and this film is exceptional in portraying that.
This film gave me that rare feeling of wanting to cry do to the raw emotion evoked and the feeling of laughing at just how I'm feeling.
Im having Dark Night of the Soul for not watching this masterpiece in cinema.
I did. You missed a great visual experience. ç_ç
Not to add salt to the wound but I saw it in Imax too. what can I say you missed big on this one! But hey theres always re-release's of Nolans films in Imax!
Now that I want to travel through a black hole and fall into the tesseract to tell my younger self in 2014 to GO WATCH THIS MOVIE IN CINEMA!!!! 😭😭😭.
my best decision was to watch it in the cinema
I fucking swear im gonna rent a cinema just to see this on the big screen
Your content is awesome. Love you style, the calm you use to explain everything and of ocurse, how your videos are edited. Keep pushing!
Great work taking this apart and putting it together for us. This truly is an amazing piece of art.
Editor: How much edits?
*Director: yes*
This makes absolutely no sense
I dont understand how this didnt win Best Picture.
Because the concept, although complex was actually very simple and has contradictory. It wasn't a very good movie
because it had no "wokedness" in it, and thats what "they're" selling. :(
@@mattbecker743 You didn't like the movie, fair enough, but why do you have to pretend like it's because it's beneath you? If the movie hits the audience's emotions exactly how it was intended to, that's a pretty sure sign that it's a good movie. You're talking like your opinion is object when all the evidence suggests that you are in the minority. I'm not aware of any other hard sci-fi films based around the concept of higher dimensional travel but from the way you're talking it sounds like there are a few that I've missed. Would you mind sharing some recomendations? I'd genuinely like to experience these superior films. Thanks.
@@mattbecker743 Bast movie ever made. One day you will see it to.
because it's trash
Incredible analysis of these scenes. This is my favorite movie for many reasons, and I love watching/reading content that helps me have a deeper appreciation for the art and science behind it. Thank you!
Glad you enjoyed it!
imagine shooting an emotional quiet scene while the RATATATATATATA of the imax camera is constantly in your ears.
This movie is just a true Masterpiece
I can't get over how this movie is from 2014.
Astro physics already interested me as a child and for some reason I always thought this movie was old like Star Treck.
But yesterday I actually watched it and I'm so sad that I didn't watch it sooner. It is one of my favorite movies ever after just one watch, ugh it's great.
Even those short clips of the movie made me cry and feel like something else I cannot describe. Interstellar is truely a masterpiece.
They had some of the smartest people on the planet working on structuring the science for the movie.
And yet, a shitty ending. So crap it seems a studio thing. Sure, the guy returns 80 years after saving humankind, and "nah, this station's name is not an homage to you, dumbass".
@@persona83 bcs his daughter wrote the formula to launch that station of course it's going to be name after her
@@JSNtheArsonist Yeah, because if an equation can save mankind let's keep it secret and try to solve it alone for decades, so we can have the name.
@@TheRaretunes well technically prof brand solved the equation. Murph fixed the equation based on the quantum data she get from coop. Even if there's hundreds of physician that help her to solve the equation, she still gonna get the recognition bcs people on earth believe the quantum data came from her even though she said it came from the "Ghost" in her bedroom
@@JSNtheArsonist Who cares about the recognition. My point was that their sit on the equation the whole movie.
This flick declares to be scientifically ahead of the others but all I can see is science being reduced to something ridiculous. This is not how science works and how it's done, and neither how would have been done in similar circumstances.
I really don't care much about the whole movie message (and frankly it's not even a clear one), but the world building, and these premises are absurd. First of all a wormhole inside a star system.
When a movie is so perfect, that even after 6 years, UA-cam talks about it.
The movie, the soundtrack and just everything is pure perfection.
Thank you to all who helped make this masterpiece. 👌
Wow, by far one of the most interesting breakdowns in UA-cam history. Thank you for your time.
I just want to say that is one of the smoothest, most genuine integrated sponsorship ad I've ever watched. Also, incredible analysis, gave me goosebumps. That ad though...
Mine was a Planet fitness ad, totally killed the moment lol
One major thing to keep in mind is that inside the Tesseract, Cooper wasn't time traveling. All instances in time from Murph's bedroom has been showcased in front of him. So, any kind of entropy he makes is applied to all the time periods. That's why the watch's second hand movement was visible to present day Murph even though Cooper passed the quantum data through the watch which was from the past. Same goes for the books & space toys on the bookshelf.
Seeing someone analyse one of my favourite movies is next level entertainment. Great video!
This was simply beautiful. The illustration of quantum mechanics through editing is nothing short of a dream come true. Time to start a new playlist.
Going in, I didn't know exactly what to expect, then as a physics aficionado, I think this movie is brilliant . painfully underrated, for me Nolan's best ,
I mean yeah, the editing is literally out of this world.
literally
Nice
Thanks, Captain Obvious
Almost like that was the entire point
Pun
Seeing this at the movies with my dad is one of the best experiences I’ve ever had in my life
I’m learning editing now and I come across a GEM like YOU and your channel! Onwards to watch all of your videos! I salute you!
It’s been almost 6 years since this film was released and I never stopped thinking about it. I remember it every year. This movie changed my life.
Same here.
It really changed my way of thinking.
I still watch it twice a month, every month. I cannot appreciate this movie enough.
This is the most emotional part of the movie for me. I noticed it the whole film, it was heartbreaking and brought the whole film together. I cried on a first date.
Awesome breakdown. I liked the comment about the camera angles from the space ship, it really sells the story and makes it feel like you're experiencing it.
Just a quick more info about relativity complimenting your excelent explanation at 9:20. I'm referring to the 3 ages of Murphy as: kid Murphy, adult Murphy and older Murphy. Murphy wasn't in her adult age when Cooper was inside the Tesseract. Relative to Tesseract Cooper, Murphy was the older one. Kid Murphy became Adult Murphy right after Cooper came back from the water planet mission, the one with big waves, because that planet was closer to the black hole and made Cooper move much more quicker throught time relative to kid Murphy on Earth. Murphy was in her adult age only until he came back closer to the black hole before jumpingg into it, and, as he "fell" more and more through the black hole, adulp Murphy started to age faster and faster as Cooper travelled faster and faster to the center of the black hole. She aged enough to become old Murphy, and only stopped aging right after Cooper crossed the boundary between the mass of black hole and the tridimensional space of the tesseract. That's why she is old Murphy aboard the Cooper station when they reunite, old Murphy is the present Murphy relative to Cooper. Pretty cool, right? They nailed relativity.
That scene fucked me up for a whole three hours when I watched the movie for the first time and even this video made me realize new things about it again. It's incredible how layered everything in this movie is and how everything is intentional.