Picture the scene. It's 2012, my childhood best friend has just been broken up with by a boy named John, we're on a geography school trip to the lake district and she is weeping at the top of the mountain. Cut to 2024. We're in Cardiff. We've joked all day about how funny it would be if she plays the lakes. We're clinging to each other as she's singing I hate it here, and then she sings 'so take me to the lakes' we lose our minds. What a full circle moment
I know no one but me loves Epiphany but I am a frontline healthcare worker and that song was so special to me during the pandemic. So Mirrorball/Epiphany would have had me on the ground sobbing.
Understandable! I do not connect to this song, personnaly, but your experience is valid and I think it is beautiful that this song helped you through a tough time ! Thanks for sharing, I promise not to skip next time it comes on and to pay more attention to this song from now on ! 😊 Kind regards ❤
when they say the relationship between one girl and her surprise song is everything trust them. I've been listening to mine on repeat since it happened. And i get emotional EVERY SINGLE TIME.
I was present for the first ever mash up, is it over now? X out of the woods. So in my very objective and humble opinion, that will always be the best mash up ever made.
I feel like that mashup and to a lesser extent the first Australia mashup are the most interesting and best ones because they were the first ones. We were shocked when the out of the woods x is it over now? happened!!! The surprise element was fun!!!
I was there for I hate it here x the lakes and it killed me in the best way. Truly a gorgeous mashup and I still can't quite believe I witnessed it with my own eyeballs (and ears) 😭
This was my dream mashup! You got so lucky, I was happy with mine (Guilty as Sin x Untouchable) but Cornelia Street x Maroon would have been even better!
Me watching with the "Us" performance being my laptop background, and you guys dragging it through the mud. 😭 It was hilarious though. Your videos always make my day! 🤣
noo you are in love x fresh out the slammer was my mashup and i loved it! i loved you are in love live with the echo from the crowd. it was munich n1 btw not hamburg haha
As someone who got my boy x Coney Island I can confirm I was so confused when she started singing Coney Island as the mashup 😭 still clapped and cheered tho 🫡
Thank You Aimee X Mean is probably my favorite mashup, just based on Taylor’s execution and the performance quality alone. The way she so seamlessly injected Mean in was beautiful. Thank you Aimee was not my favorite song on the Anthology by a long shot…but that mashup made me appreciate it!
Those were my surprise songs! I loved both of them so much even before i saw them live and when i heard Taylor sing the opening line i just started crying. Mean and thanK you AImee have a very special place in my heart.
@@ShadowTiger.4000 Amazing! I think the timing of that mashup was so poetic too, cuz that just happened to be the same night Dave Grohl decided to run his mouth about Taylor. 🙄 It’s almost like Taylor could sense it and knew it was happening AS it happened haha.
47:37 thats Warsaw N3 in case anyone was confused. I was there and I cried like a baby when I heard the piano intro for Exile. All Warsaw mashups were AMAZING anyway
this was me for today was a fairytale...sooooo perfect. So glad I got that obstructed view ticket for Warsaw just to be safe after I had gotten my Vienna ticket :') .
I was there front row lower stands ❤ shaking and crying 😭 the guitar 🎸 was my dream come true. For a black dog I was like eh well… but then Exile had me crying and shaking again ❤
I have been waiting for this!! I feel like she should have stuck to playing songs she hasn’t played before (happiness for example) in whole and mashed up songs she has!
You are right, Crazier was the holy grail for surprise songs. The only thing I hoped for going to the Eras Tour was getting ANY debut song! And I got Teardrops On My Guitar 🙏🏻
I'm extremely biased because i got Fresh out the slammer × You are in love and Ivy × Call it what you want in Munich N1 so i thought it was actually the best thing that ever happened😭
Samee, especially Fresh out the slammer x you are in love was soo good. I thought that Ivy x Call it what you want was kind of weird to mash up, but those songs are so great, I was shocked when it came up in their 10 worst Mash ups🥲
When she started playing ivy it was one of the best things that has ever happened to me, and I loved the Errors Tour moment at the beginning 😂 I'm not crazy about the mash-up, but there are very few songs I would have been happy to hear interrupting ivy. The dream was ivy/loml, but she played loml on night 2 instead 😢 I certainly feel like I won tho
My surprise songs were "The Tortured Poets Department" with "Now That We Don't Talk" and "You're On Your Own Kid" with "Long Live" I cried so much when I heard " Long Live" because it's one of my favourites songs of all time.
In Madrid we all were pretty grateful and happy for King of My Heart and Sparks Fly, I mean it!!!! lmao I mean Sparks Fly is one of my favs of all time and she sang it bc it was the last time she was in Spain (that era), it felt special ^^
LOVE THE NEW EPISODE! Btw the black dog x exile and today was a fairytale x I think he knows was Warsaw night 3 not night 1🫶 I love how Warsaw stays winning
as a gelsenkirchen night 2 girlie, those surprise songs were everything to me for real. bla bla bla many reasons why but it should truly be studied how intense the connection between eras tour concert goers and their surprise songs is. i only went to one show so i am clinging onto them for dear life and love them to pieces. i’m just glad that they were perfect for me and my tastes, and that i know all 4 songs inside out. once again thanks for the upload, love your dynamic with each other!
I feels you so much! I went to Gelsenkirchen n3 and I got paper rings x stay stay stay. Before the concerts I was the biggest stay stay stay hater and here I am: extremely connected to those 4 songs 🥹
@@jeab8662 it’s truly wild how the eras tour experience can totally influence our opinions on the songs played! huge props to taylor because she is really the queen of creating a connection with the crowd every single show. each person who has went feels special and feels like it was made for them or that songs were picked for them, it’s the wildest experience for sure. the best thing that’s ever happened to me tbh
@@monar8487 oh that’s a shame:( i’m a super sentimental person and slightly delusional so maybe that helped my experience… i’m sure many songs could’ve played and i would’ve found it perfect. for me it was the rush of being there, the amazing view i luckily got, and then some songs that i actually liked! i agree that there wasn’t really a storyline there and it was quite random. somehow the germany surprise songs weren’t exactly the best
sooo ofc such a good episode, love your takes i started watching you like a month ago & i love your videos but about my eras journey... i went to 3 shows in warsaw. truly the best 3 concerts i've ever been to. so here's something about every surprise song. warsaw n1 guitar: mirrorball x clara bow i was actually gagged cause i wore my folklore outfit with a mirrorball cowboy hat so she "def saw me back in those nosebleeds ijbol" and decided to sing that and well the mashup was pretty cute i liked it. great gowns beautiful gowns. n1 piano: suburban legends x new year's day i remember when she started singing suburban legends & i was singing along... i was like what's that?? but after few seconds i figured it out and was like ohhhh... well i'm gonna sing along anywayyy. mashing it up with new year's day was def a weird choice like what those 2 songs have even sth in common? but def i enjoyed new year's day much more than "i didn't come here to hear that vault song i was born to get holy ground or happiness..." n2 guitar: i can fix him (no really i can) x i can see you sooo i got a flop like my face faded from a smile to straight line 😭 but when she started playing those i can see you notes i was on cloud 9 nothing can go wrong with i can see you SHE IS A DIVA so yeah that song def saved me n2 piano: red x maroon (the way i actually predicted maroon cause earlier i told somebody omw to the stadium "i'd be pretty funny if she sang yoyok or maroon today cause it's been some time since she done them" and well she did it) when taylor started doing mashups so many people were saying about those songs especially cause yk a little parallel and later most people forgot bout it. well red is one of my fav taylor songs so happy i got to hear it live, well yes it was a moment!!! n3 guitar: today was a fairytale x i think he knows i was actually on the floor that night being so close to taylor and when she said "every day is a fairytale in polish crowd" i was over the moon and the way those 2 songs blended perfectly? omg diva, bellissima, gorgeous mashup def some magic was in the air that night n3 piano: the black dog x exile one thing about me i'm the black dog and imgonnagetyouback stan since the release of the anthology & it was all i wanted from that album so when she just sang one word i already started bawling my eyes out and she mashed it up with exile which was actually so good that woman will never get tired of crowd sining back other part of the song and you can't even blame her. THAT mashup in my opinion was a highlight of my eras tour journey
Portuguese people were really clowning for Red x Daylight in Lisbon because the stadium she performed at is basically called Daylight Stadium (Estádio da Luz) and the whole stadium is red 😂 Like she would've known that beforehand ahaha. It was fun though and we got great songs both nights, including The Way I Loved You!! 😍
I was at LVP N3 and LDN N3... And I just wanna say, the bind between the girl and her suprise songs is so real. I didn’t know carolina, the mega mix saved me, but i am obsessed now and i genuinely think it is one of the best fitting mashups. I originally wanted Ni body no crime when the US leg was going on because I knew she didn’t do it every night, and then it was never on the movies and she completely removed it so to get it in such a cool mashup too was honestly fate. Now LDN N3? Well didn’t care about Gracie icl but its still a slay to get a guest so I'll take it. But I kept saying at work when the radio was on and theyd play her pop singles that i would be seeing the songs live in so many weeks and when Is it over now came on, I'd say "im not seeing this one live because its not on the setlist" and then i got it. Also it was the Harry styles megamix, i clocked her saying 89,000 people in the stadium instead of the 90,000 at the start of the show, and then my bestie saud for the 1989 set, she looks like a watermelon. And then she mashes up 3 1989 songs about harry after referncing water melon sugar in 1989 and saying 89 at the start of the show. I'm sorry but thats iconic.
the realisation that August is essentially Tim McGraw (reminiscing about a lost teenage summer love) has genuinely blown my mind. we truly woke up to find that summer gone into a moment in time because it was never mine
You didnt mention hamburg night 1 but you shat on night 2 (Nothing new x Dear Reader) which is fine by me LMAO!! but like i need your thoughts on my surprise songs for n1, which were teardrops x the last time on guitar and happiness x we were happy (two lives debuts!!!) on piano. I thought for sure you would've mentioned how weird of a mashup the piano one was? like namewise both about happy blah blah but like why debut Happiness and mash it up with a fugly ass fearless vault...When i tell you everyone was up for Teardrops then it was crickets and everyone sat down during We were happy...
I was at Paris n4, and the sound and feeling of the crowd when she went “So when I… put your lips close to mine as long as they don’t touch” cannot be described or compared to anything ever. Watching 80,000 wristbands trickle from white to red. Insane. Indescribable. Incredible. Also hearing Begin Again mashed up with PARIS!!! Hearing Paris in Paris is unforgettable. When I realized she was playing Paris I SCREAMED. I look back at my videos and it sounds like I’m on the verge of tears “MAKE BELIEVE IT’S CHAMPAGNE!”
as someone who got the setlist graveyard on London N7, I enjoyed it (since I saw the shows when long live wasn’t on the setlist) but at the same time I was just really wishing it was still in the setlist with the full production
hi loves just a quick note 47:33 - Warsaw night 3(!!!) got “Today Was a Fairytale”/”I Think He Knows” and “The Black Dog”/”Exile” not night 1 :) immediately noticed the mistake with nights because IT WAS RARE I WAS THERE!! Warsaw n1 got “Mirrorball”/”Clara Bow” and “Suburban Legends”/”New Year’s Day” xx
Warsaw N3 with Today Was A Fairytale x I Think He Knows and Black Dog x Exile was my show, the only one I got to go to and I was having a near death experience during entire acoustic set. So good to see it recognized!
My diva is Should've Said No x You're Not Sorry, which wasn't in Europe but anyways, and I'll say it again!!!! (also, your pronunciation of Gelsenkirchen is sooo funny xD)
I was at LND 3 and felt the exact same way !! Was so excited thinking it was “you’ll always find your way back home “ and realising it was a Gracie song no one knew
As someone who attended the Ed Sheeran mega mashup show……..I wasn’t suuuuper excited when he first came out, but by the end of the set I was on the ground shaking. Something in my brain clicked during end game
Having all of my shows on your worst 10 list kinda hurts 😂 (Stockholm N1, loooooved the I think he knows x gorgeous mashup, Gelsenkirchen N3 not the biggest fan of the piano mashup but hearing better man live killed me and paper rings x stay stay stay was bellisima, and Munich N2 hearing my all time fav song CIWYW live is just making me sobbing with whatever it would have been mashed up 😅)
I went to gelsenkirchen N1 and my surprise songs were invisible string x Superstar and slut! X false god. And i loved them. I dont think a lot of people knew superstar so no as many people cheering, but i felt proud as on OG fearless swiftie from the beginning lol
Safe and Sound + Untouchable were my surprise songs in São Paulo (Brazil) and I know this video is about the European surprise songs but I just wanted to mention that Safe and Sound was THE SONG that made me REALLY go deep into Taylor (yes, because I was such a huge fun of Hunger Games haha) so when she started singing it I PANICKED (in a good way). Both these songs were not the ones that I would’ve hand picked but it was pretty special for me. And “Untouchable” was my most listened song on spotify 2 months before the concert (Idk why) so… that was bizarre!
Okay I'm glad I'm not the only one not understanding the Suburban legends x New Year's day mashup, and it was my night 😭 I tried so hard to make some connections but if someone has any ideas why these two were mashed up I'd love to hear it! Also I refuse to forgive you for not putting Mirrorball x Clara Bow on your lists, like how are we not freaking out about this???
I was in Madrid night 1, and it's so true that sparks fly and i can fix him was a weird mashup, but we all love sotb and ilipw, because we thought lana would come
Indeed, Buenos Aires had the most iconic night with Travis and Taylor kissing for the first time... and the mash up of the century: OUT OF THE WOODS, IS IT OVER NIGHT AND END GAME. (By the way, will we ever get Safe and Sound? QUESTION...?
I was sobbing to loml and I knew she would mash it up with Coney Island cause it just makes sense. “You were the love of my life and now I’m sitting on a bench in Coney Island” It’s the only loml mash up I would accept and love… then she came up with Don’t You… I wasn’t silent I was silenced🥲
I love the mashups. I love the surprise. Not knowing what song is next and I've gotten emotional listening to some when the lyrics all mesh well together to create a vibe.
I was happy with Amsterdam N3. Sweeter than fiction was really fun and holy ground sounded really good too. It was annoying hearing so high school twice but marys song was good and EVERYTHING HAS CHANGED was AMAZING
im NEVEr not grateful that gracie was inflicted upon you guys it makes me laugh every time when you mention it like its the plague of egypt and you're right!
Also Liverpool night 2 was this is what you came for x gold rush and the great war x ylm. I was there and i loved it but my kids weren't feeling those two 😅😅 Carolina was night 3!
the gag of the brazilian fans was getting me! in rio because sao paulo fans were asking non stop on social media for that to be played in rio.. and there she goes "i heard you guys love this one" right in the first rio night
Liverpool night 3 was our night! While I wasn’t like overwhelmed by the murder mashup, I did really enjoy it because it was my night, I think unless you hate the song it does make it more appealing to you because of the memories. Also red and the manuscript was ACE, also because Liverpool is my husbands team and the whole stadium lighting up red and her singing ‘re e e e eeeed’ was such a vibe. ❤
Get evolution of a snake TWICE A WEEK on our patreon: www.patreon.com/swiftologist
I don't know why we started to get two videos a week but I'm seated
both snakes are full time snakes this month!
It’s from their podcast so it’s not really an extra video but either way we love it!
Picture the scene. It's 2012, my childhood best friend has just been broken up with by a boy named John, we're on a geography school trip to the lake district and she is weeping at the top of the mountain. Cut to 2024. We're in Cardiff. We've joked all day about how funny it would be if she plays the lakes. We're clinging to each other as she's singing I hate it here, and then she sings 'so take me to the lakes' we lose our minds. What a full circle moment
To think the EX IS JOHN
so cute!!!
Madeline refusing to acknowledge the Sweet Nothing x Hoax mashup is everything. She is one of the few shooters for Hoax, she needs to stand up! 😂
hoax deserves everything! Madeline is RIGHT!
470 likes and no comments? I’ll fix that!
Please the autotuning on Madeline's singing killed me 😭😭😭😭
Editor be wilding 😭😭😭 keep up the good work man 😂
UUUUUUUS killed me
That was hilarious 😂
king tyler editor
We need more Madeline karaoke now..!! 😋
I know no one but me loves Epiphany but I am a frontline healthcare worker and that song was so special to me during the pandemic. So Mirrorball/Epiphany would have had me on the ground sobbing.
Same!!!!
i love epiphany!!!
Epiphany is a gem and so is Peter, I told my truth
I adore that song. You are not alone ❤
Understandable! I do not connect to this song, personnaly, but your experience is valid and I think it is beautiful that this song helped you through a tough time ! Thanks for sharing, I promise not to skip next time it comes on and to pay more attention to this song from now on ! 😊 Kind regards ❤
when they say the relationship between one girl and her surprise song is everything trust them. I've been listening to mine on repeat since it happened. And i get emotional EVERY SINGLE TIME.
mine were stay stay stay and all of the girls you loved before… my 2 least favorite
OH SAY IT LOUDER... I still get chills from listening to Mr. Perfectly Fine x Red
Me with fifteen 😭😭😭
not the swiftologist slowly becoming jack antonoff with all the bleep-bloo-bees and voice modulations in this vid lollllllllll
I was present for the first ever mash up, is it over now? X out of the woods. So in my very objective and humble opinion, that will always be the best mash up ever made.
I feel like that mashup and to a lesser extent the first Australia mashup are the most interesting and best ones because they were the first ones. We were shocked when the out of the woods x is it over now? happened!!! The surprise element was fun!!!
@@asherlong6015 the 1998 vault songs are amazing from mash ups cause they sound like they could use another verse. Other mash ups are less smooth
Girl same, we paved the way. Ofc were being VERY objective and that’s the best mashup, period
@@summerchild_ ICONIC 💙
now that was history
justice for my show mirrorball x clara bow 😩 „promise to be dazzling… like a mirrorball” gagged
I was there too and it was amaaaazing
I was there on a grainy livestream and it was so good!
the autotuning on y’all’s singing is KILLING MEEEEE
I was there for I hate it here x the lakes and it killed me in the best way. Truly a gorgeous mashup and I still can't quite believe I witnessed it with my own eyeballs (and ears) 😭
I got Cornelia Street x Maroon (Liverpool N1) ❤
"And I hope I never lose you" into "And I lost you" 🥺
That was OFFENSIVE!!!
This was my dream mashup! You got so lucky, I was happy with mine (Guilty as Sin x Untouchable) but Cornelia Street x Maroon would have been even better!
Zack's non-interest in Exile is actually piercing my heart
HOWWWW
nothing new x dear reader broke my soul in pieces and i’ve never been the same since
36:00 - ‘I’ve never forgiven anyone for anything’ Madeline that’s you and me both. And Taylor, obviously
Me watching with the "Us" performance being my laptop background, and you guys dragging it through the mud. 😭 It was hilarious though. Your videos always make my day! 🤣
SDKLFNSDLJFNLSDKNKFDS
noo you are in love x fresh out the slammer was my mashup and i loved it! i loved you are in love live with the echo from the crowd. it was munich n1 btw not hamburg haha
It was sooo good
I was there, too and loved it! Also followed by ivy x CIWYW on piano afterwards just broke me 😅
i was there as well😊and absolutely loved it
Omg Im imagining it in my head and I feel the songs would go so well together!!
@@schakalakaboomsame dude I also went Munich night 1
As someone who got my boy x Coney Island I can confirm I was so confused when she started singing Coney Island as the mashup 😭 still clapped and cheered tho 🫡
@@Emmy-rw8yl SAME!!! We were soo lucky to get I Did Something Bad that I was seated for anything else
I was there too! Was a slightly weird mash up but sounded amazing! And obvs getting idsb in full was the best thing ever!
@@nickybull2361 absolutely!! 🫶
Thank You Aimee X Mean is probably my favorite mashup, just based on Taylor’s execution and the performance quality alone. The way she so seamlessly injected Mean in was beautiful. Thank you Aimee was not my favorite song on the Anthology by a long shot…but that mashup made me appreciate it!
Those were my surprise songs! I loved both of them so much even before i saw them live and when i heard Taylor sing the opening line i just started crying. Mean and thanK you AImee have a very special place in my heart.
@@ShadowTiger.4000 Amazing! I think the timing of that mashup was so poetic too, cuz that just happened to be the same night Dave Grohl decided to run his mouth about Taylor. 🙄 It’s almost like Taylor could sense it and knew it was happening AS it happened haha.
47:37 thats Warsaw N3 in case anyone was confused. I was there and I cried like a baby when I heard the piano intro for Exile. All Warsaw mashups were AMAZING anyway
this was me for today was a fairytale...sooooo perfect. So glad I got that obstructed view ticket for Warsaw just to be safe after I had gotten my Vienna ticket :') .
i went. best day of my life.
I was there front row lower stands ❤ shaking and crying 😭 the guitar 🎸 was my dream come true. For a black dog I was like eh well… but then Exile had me crying and shaking again ❤
i got red x maroon on warsaw n2 and i almost started crying, i couldn't believe i was hearing that mashup live. and the stadium went crazy for it too
@@nagiach.102 I saw it outside the stadium! Insane
The Way I Loved You x Red x Daylight is such a good concept pipeline mashup😍
I have been waiting for this!! I feel like she should have stuck to playing songs she hasn’t played before (happiness for example) in whole and mashed up songs she has!
You are right, Crazier was the holy grail for surprise songs. The only thing I hoped for going to the Eras Tour was getting ANY debut song! And I got Teardrops On My Guitar 🙏🏻
Dear John/Sad Beautiful Tragic...I was SHOOK!!!
Never thought we'd get Dear John again after she read us the riot act the first time she played it.
I'm extremely biased because i got Fresh out the slammer × You are in love and Ivy × Call it what you want in Munich N1 so i thought it was actually the best thing that ever happened😭
Samee, especially Fresh out the slammer x you are in love was soo good. I thought that Ivy x Call it what you want was kind of weird to mash up, but those songs are so great, I was shocked when it came up in their 10 worst Mash ups🥲
Same dude I got that too ❤ I screamed at you are in love
When she started playing ivy it was one of the best things that has ever happened to me, and I loved the Errors Tour moment at the beginning 😂 I'm not crazy about the mash-up, but there are very few songs I would have been happy to hear interrupting ivy. The dream was ivy/loml, but she played loml on night 2 instead 😢 I certainly feel like I won tho
the mashups made little sense but it was four great songs so i would have been happy anyway😂
"The murder mashup" killed me... NBNC IS MY FAV SING SINCE I HEARD IT AND WITH CAROLINA?! EXCUSE ME TAYLOR?!
OMG YOU INCLUDED THE FRAGMENTS!!! IM SO HAPPY!!!!!!
Madeline’s makeup looks so good in this vid!!
I always love the colors on Madeline but this orange might be my very favorite! So stunning ✨✨
@@jessapuff her makeup always looks stunning! I need to know what eyeshadow palette she uses YESTERDAY lol
To think MY surprise song was ME!
The trauma, the drama the memories
ooooooooh, that sucks like CRAZY. i'm sorry for you
Yea i saw on tiktok that she played that as a surprise song and i was shocked! You should sue
but it's so good, stop hating her :
@@moonbookish look we have our reasons. But just know that me! Is and always be a mistake by Taylor swift
@@moonbookish we're not hating her! we just hate the song haha
My surprise songs were "The Tortured Poets Department" with "Now That We Don't Talk" and "You're On Your Own Kid" with "Long Live"
I cried so much when I heard " Long Live" because it's one of my favourites songs of all time.
Lisbon N2! I was there!!! Also cried so much when she went into Long Live and then I died. Dead.
@@aeristifa
In Madrid we all were pretty grateful and happy for King of My Heart and Sparks Fly, I mean it!!!! lmao I mean Sparks Fly is one of my favs of all time and she sang it bc it was the last time she was in Spain (that era), it felt special ^^
LOVE THE NEW EPISODE! Btw the black dog x exile and today was a fairytale x I think he knows was Warsaw night 3 not night 1🫶 I love how Warsaw stays winning
as a gelsenkirchen night 2 girlie, those surprise songs were everything to me for real. bla bla bla many reasons why but it should truly be studied how intense the connection between eras tour concert goers and their surprise songs is. i only went to one show so i am clinging onto them for dear life and love them to pieces. i’m just glad that they were perfect for me and my tastes, and that i know all 4 songs inside out. once again thanks for the upload, love your dynamic with each other!
I feels you so much! I went to Gelsenkirchen n3 and I got paper rings x stay stay stay. Before the concerts I was the biggest stay stay stay hater and here I am: extremely connected to those 4 songs 🥹
@@jeab8662 it’s truly wild how the eras tour experience can totally influence our opinions on the songs played! huge props to taylor because she is really the queen of creating a connection with the crowd every single show. each person who has went feels special and feels like it was made for them or that songs were picked for them, it’s the wildest experience for sure. the best thing that’s ever happened to me tbh
surprise songs are VERY personal.....a flop to some is a slay to another....
Gelsenkirchen night 2 as well and those surprise songs did nothing for me
@@monar8487 oh that’s a shame:( i’m a super sentimental person and slightly delusional so maybe that helped my experience… i’m sure many songs could’ve played and i would’ve found it perfect. for me it was the rush of being there, the amazing view i luckily got, and then some songs that i actually liked! i agree that there wasn’t really a storyline there and it was quite random. somehow the germany surprise songs weren’t exactly the best
I was at London night one and it was truly unforgettable. You were actually sitting just to the left of me!
Have I already listened to this episode? Of course! Will I watch the video?? Well Yes!!!!
sooo ofc such a good episode, love your takes i started watching you like a month ago & i love your videos but about my eras journey... i went to 3 shows in warsaw. truly the best 3 concerts i've ever been to. so here's something about every surprise song.
warsaw n1 guitar: mirrorball x clara bow i was actually gagged cause i wore my folklore outfit with a mirrorball cowboy hat so she "def saw me back in those nosebleeds ijbol" and decided to sing that and well the mashup was pretty cute i liked it. great gowns beautiful gowns.
n1 piano: suburban legends x new year's day i remember when she started singing suburban legends & i was singing along... i was like what's that?? but after few seconds i figured it out and was like ohhhh... well i'm gonna sing along anywayyy. mashing it up with new year's day was def a weird choice like what those 2 songs have even sth in common? but def i enjoyed new year's day much more than "i didn't come here to hear that vault song i was born to get holy ground or happiness..."
n2 guitar: i can fix him (no really i can) x i can see you sooo i got a flop like my face faded from a smile to straight line 😭 but when she started playing those i can see you notes i was on cloud 9 nothing can go wrong with i can see you SHE IS A DIVA so yeah that song def saved me
n2 piano: red x maroon (the way i actually predicted maroon cause earlier i told somebody omw to the stadium "i'd be pretty funny if she sang yoyok or maroon today cause it's been some time since she done them" and well she did it) when taylor started doing mashups so many people were saying about those songs especially cause yk a little parallel and later most people forgot bout it. well red is one of my fav taylor songs so happy i got to hear it live, well yes it was a moment!!!
n3 guitar: today was a fairytale x i think he knows i was actually on the floor that night being so close to taylor and when she said "every day is a fairytale in polish crowd" i was over the moon and the way those 2 songs blended perfectly? omg diva, bellissima, gorgeous mashup def some magic was in the air that night
n3 piano: the black dog x exile one thing about me i'm the black dog and imgonnagetyouback stan since the release of the anthology & it was all i wanted from that album so when she just sang one word i already started bawling my eyes out and she mashed it up with exile which was actually so good that woman will never get tired of crowd sining back other part of the song and you can't even blame her. THAT mashup in my opinion was a highlight of my eras tour journey
Portuguese people were really clowning for Red x Daylight in Lisbon because the stadium she performed at is basically called Daylight Stadium (Estádio da Luz) and the whole stadium is red 😂 Like she would've known that beforehand ahaha. It was fun though and we got great songs both nights, including The Way I Loved You!! 😍
Oh girl I would switch daylight x red for the 3 song mashup we got any day
I loveeeee watching the podcast on your UA-cam channel! You two are absolutely hilarious together. I loved “marked safe,” I laughed so hard 😂
Did y’all do a ranking of the other, non-mashup surprise songs and I just missed it? Cuz I would love that video ❤
Madeleine - I 100% agree on the That's The Way I Loved You x Red x Daylight
Zach - the pipeline is loud and clear open your ears!
I was at LVP N3 and LDN N3... And I just wanna say, the bind between the girl and her suprise songs is so real. I didn’t know carolina, the mega mix saved me, but i am obsessed now and i genuinely think it is one of the best fitting mashups. I originally wanted Ni body no crime when the US leg was going on because I knew she didn’t do it every night, and then it was never on the movies and she completely removed it so to get it in such a cool mashup too was honestly fate.
Now LDN N3? Well didn’t care about Gracie icl but its still a slay to get a guest so I'll take it. But I kept saying at work when the radio was on and theyd play her pop singles that i would be seeing the songs live in so many weeks and when Is it over now came on, I'd say "im not seeing this one live because its not on the setlist" and then i got it. Also it was the Harry styles megamix, i clocked her saying 89,000 people in the stadium instead of the 90,000 at the start of the show, and then my bestie saud for the 1989 set, she looks like a watermelon. And then she mashes up 3 1989 songs about harry after referncing water melon sugar in 1989 and saying 89 at the start of the show. I'm sorry but thats iconic.
I got Begin Again and Cold as You in Houston. Happy to have got a Debut song! I'm so curious what the rerecord will be like!
i was so scared to see any of Warsaw nights in worst nights, but glad it's not included! we had best mashups, not even one was bad!
23:41 "give me Tied Together with a Smile as a surprise song" that was my surprise song!
jealous
WHY is no one talking about we were happy x happiness. both criminally underrated BEAUTIFUL songs
the realisation that August is essentially Tim McGraw (reminiscing about a lost teenage summer love) has genuinely blown my mind. we truly woke up to find that summer gone into a moment in time because it was never mine
The Prophecy/ Long story short mashup is what made me like The Prophecy, I think she changed the key slightly and it suits her voice so well ✨
never clicked on a video faster tbh, but I can already tell I'll love it
Getting back from school with this video posted is a blessing
Frr, the best feeling
You didnt mention hamburg night 1 but you shat on night 2 (Nothing new x Dear Reader) which is fine by me LMAO!! but like i need your thoughts on my surprise songs for n1, which were teardrops x the last time on guitar and happiness x we were happy (two lives debuts!!!) on piano. I thought for sure you would've mentioned how weird of a mashup the piano one was? like namewise both about happy blah blah but like why debut Happiness and mash it up with a fugly ass fearless vault...When i tell you everyone was up for Teardrops then it was crickets and everyone sat down during We were happy...
I was at Paris n4, and the sound and feeling of the crowd when she went
“So when I… put your lips close to mine as long as they don’t touch”
cannot be described or compared to anything ever. Watching 80,000 wristbands trickle from white to red. Insane. Indescribable. Incredible.
Also hearing Begin Again mashed up with PARIS!!! Hearing Paris in Paris is unforgettable. When I realized she was playing Paris I SCREAMED. I look back at my videos and it sounds like I’m on the verge of tears “MAKE BELIEVE IT’S CHAMPAGNE!”
I was there too, and I’m so glad I recorded my reactions to both moments when she played Treacherous and Paris 😭
Already listened to the pod but I will watch again to see your little faces! Love the chaotic energy
as someone who got the setlist graveyard on London N7, I enjoyed it (since I saw the shows when long live wasn’t on the setlist) but at the same time I was just really wishing it was still in the setlist with the full production
I hate Labyrinth on midnights but the This is me trying x Labyrinth on piano was out of this world and she sounded sooooo good.
I love the fact you can go from fully being on the same page to not understanding each others vision at all. I clap and cheered 😄
hi loves just a quick note 47:33 - Warsaw night 3(!!!) got “Today Was a Fairytale”/”I Think He Knows” and “The Black Dog”/”Exile” not night 1 :) immediately noticed the mistake with nights because IT WAS RARE I WAS THERE!! Warsaw n1 got “Mirrorball”/”Clara Bow” and “Suburban Legends”/”New Year’s Day” xx
Warsaw N3 with Today Was A Fairytale x I Think He Knows and Black Dog x Exile was my show, the only one I got to go to and I was having a near death experience during entire acoustic set. So good to see it recognized!
Same same, I was waiting for it to get mentioned.. it was a painfully perfect night ✨
i went to amsterdam night 2!! im proud that my show made it to both of yalls top 5 taylor really ate
Love the editing!!! ❤
this video SHOCKED me as a glitter gel pen, lover-loving, pop princess but you guys are literally so funny and i can never get enough of you two 😭🫶
LOL Zach your face when Madeline said “it’s nice to have a friend x Dorothea” at no. 5😂 I had the same reaction… not my faves
Yallllll I listened to this earlier this week on Spotify but I’m obligated to watch this all the way through again 🫡
My diva is Should've Said No x You're Not Sorry, which wasn't in Europe but anyways, and I'll say it again!!!! (also, your pronunciation of Gelsenkirchen is sooo funny xD)
I was at LND 3 and felt the exact same way !! Was so excited thinking it was “you’ll always find your way back home “ and realising it was a Gracie song no one knew
48:30 It was King of my heart and the Alchemy 😭😭
I’m seriously so shocked why she hasn’t mashed up I Look In People’s Windows with Death By a Thousand Cuts
I'm not a mashups person, but I am a Swiftologist person, so I watched all of this
I was there night 3 in London and the silence for Us was so deafening and uncomfortable. Everyone sat down. 😬😬😬
Im cracking UP at Madeline saying Sweet Nothing/Hoax didn’t happen 😂😭😭
As someone who attended the Ed Sheeran mega mashup show……..I wasn’t suuuuper excited when he first came out, but by the end of the set I was on the ground shaking. Something in my brain clicked during end game
I don't want to live forever Chicago was iconic. Taylor was feeling that song. Everyone was saying Joe when Matty was the muse.
You commented 13 minutes ago
Having all of my shows on your worst 10 list kinda hurts 😂
(Stockholm N1, loooooved the I think he knows x gorgeous mashup, Gelsenkirchen N3 not the biggest fan of the piano mashup but hearing better man live killed me and paper rings x stay stay stay was bellisima, and Munich N2 hearing my all time fav song CIWYW live is just making me sobbing with whatever it would have been mashed up 😅)
I gagged hearing I Think He Knows x Gorgeous mashup. I love those fun songs. And Peter was just cherry on top. Chef's kiss ❤
Yes! Stockholm N1 was magical ✨️
Oooo we been getting fed by the video podcasts!! is this now a constant thing? You're always going to upload the podcast video on youtube?
yep every thursday!
@@theswiftologistwhat did we do to deserve thissss ❤❤
I was there London N4 and N5 and it was my birthday it was amazing! Amazing video guys you both absolutely kill me!!!! 😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤❤
23:09 i personally loved this mashup. i think they're both her young songs and they're so cute together imo
I went to gelsenkirchen N1 and my surprise songs were invisible string x Superstar and slut! X false god. And i loved them. I dont think a lot of people knew superstar so no as many people cheering, but i felt proud as on OG fearless swiftie from the beginning lol
It was rare, I was also there 😢❤
Safe and Sound + Untouchable were my surprise songs in São Paulo (Brazil) and I know this video is about the European surprise songs but I just wanted to mention that Safe and Sound was THE SONG that made me REALLY go deep into Taylor (yes, because I was such a huge fun of Hunger Games haha) so when she started singing it I PANICKED (in a good way). Both these songs were not the ones that I would’ve hand picked but it was pretty special for me. And “Untouchable” was my most listened song on spotify 2 months before the concert (Idk why) so… that was bizarre!
im an Edinburgh N1 truther (i was there and it was beautiful)
Ahaha same I manifested for daylight so bad I cried when it came on
Okay I'm glad I'm not the only one not understanding the Suburban legends x New Year's day mashup, and it was my night 😭 I tried so hard to make some connections but if someone has any ideas why these two were mashed up I'd love to hear it!
Also I refuse to forgive you for not putting Mirrorball x Clara Bow on your lists, like how are we not freaking out about this???
I was in Madrid night 1, and it's so true that sparks fly and i can fix him was a weird mashup, but we all love sotb and ilipw, because we thought lana would come
my all-time flex is i got dbatc x babe and fifteen x yoyok 😭😭😭 it's everything i could ever wanted
Technically, Travis's first show was Kansas City Night 2 😊
Indeed, Buenos Aires had the most iconic night with Travis and Taylor kissing for the first time... and the mash up of the century: OUT OF THE WOODS, IS IT OVER NIGHT AND END GAME. (By the way, will we ever get Safe and Sound? QUESTION...?
Idc how many times Taylor plays yoyok it is THE eras tour song and it was my surprise song and I wouldn’t change it for anything ❤
I was sobbing to loml and I knew she would mash it up with Coney Island cause it just makes sense. “You were the love of my life and now I’m sitting on a bench in Coney Island” It’s the only loml mash up I would accept and love… then she came up with Don’t You… I wasn’t silent I was silenced🥲
yesss i really was hoping you guys would do this! so excited to watch, thanks for the upload for us peasants.
I love the mashups. I love the surprise. Not knowing what song is next and I've gotten emotional listening to some when the lyrics all mesh well together to create a vibe.
I was there for imgonnagetyouback x dress!!! lives were changed that night 💖💖💖💖💖
I was happy with Amsterdam N3. Sweeter than fiction was really fun and holy ground sounded really good too. It was annoying hearing so high school twice but marys song was good and EVERYTHING HAS CHANGED was AMAZING
The transition from I Can See You into Mine on Liverpool N1 deserves more from you!
This was unexpected, but I do agree with Medline' sister songs.
Thank you both for a beautiful-joyful-fun (more than an) hour! 🙏❤️
im NEVEr not grateful that gracie was inflicted upon you guys it makes me laugh every time when you mention it like its the plague of egypt and you're right!
Also Liverpool night 2 was this is what you came for x gold rush and the great war x ylm.
I was there and i loved it but my kids weren't feeling those two 😅😅
Carolina was night 3!
The autotune you used on Madeline killed me 😂
This is the podcast episode I didn’t know I needed
Thank you
Did you previously do Americas surprise songs?
Must have missed 😢
the gag of the brazilian fans was getting me! in rio because sao paulo fans were asking non stop on social media for that to be played in rio.. and there she goes "i heard you guys love this one" right in the first rio night
I was there for I Hate It Here x the lakes... magical
Liverpool night 3 was our night! While I wasn’t like overwhelmed by the murder mashup, I did really enjoy it because it was my night, I think unless you hate the song it does make it more appealing to you because of the memories. Also red and the manuscript was ACE, also because Liverpool is my husbands team and the whole stadium lighting up red and her singing ‘re e e e eeeed’ was such a vibe. ❤
That was N3 though x