I loved the Trois Gnossiennes on the piano but when it's played on the flute and harp it gives it such a different feeling as if I'm wandering the forest in an elf's world.
@@stephanieh2045 It's Bird Song, Lillting and flowing with the wind against the swaying of the trees, trilling up to and descending from the drone of a heat bug.
The awesome way to awake aspiration for the pure. This performance is far more awesome than I expected , and perfectly embodies the aesthetic and intent and spirit of Gnossiennes
I can't listen to this in the background. It takes me so much. Yours is a truly remarkable interpretation and performance. Julie, you make the flute sing and cry. Thanks
this really captures the spirit of the piece.. each performance is somewhat different because of the free time aspect of the song, and it's flowing time signature.. This is an absolutely beautiful rendering of the piece
Thank you so much!! I have a new CD out if you are curious: The complete Bach Flute Sonatas I recorded with my daughter- Julie Scolnik and Sophie Scolnik-Brower:)
+Moses Saldana Do any men play the harp? There must be some I suppose, but I've never met one. Of all the orchestral instruments I know of, the harp is maybe the least gender-diverse. Though to be fair you don't see a lot of women playing the tuba I guess.
You would spend your time being her moving crew. I did a gig this Thursday & Friday at Baylor University in Waco. I was beat to death dragging that harp, stool, speaker, etc. I didn't realize how easy I had it being a wind player. Grab'n'Go.
I loved the Trois Gnossiennes on the piano but when it's played on the flute and harp it gives it such a different feeling as if I'm wandering the forest in an elf's world.
Very true. I'm sitting outside listening now. It seems as if the trees are creating the music. It flows as the air through the leaves.
Thank you to both of you. Such poetry!
@@stephanieh2045 It's Bird Song, Lillting and flowing with the wind against the swaying of the trees, trilling up to and descending from the drone of a heat bug.
There was no one else like him. Thank you for this beautiful performance.
I imagine Bill Evans,must have known of Erik Satie
thank you!!
The awesome way to awake aspiration for the pure.
This performance is far more awesome than I expected , and perfectly embodies the aesthetic and intent and spirit of Gnossiennes
Good flute, sounds mysterious just like it should in this music.
thank you!
Gnossiene #3 at 3:52 - thank you for this very nice version!
I can't listen to this in the background. It takes me so much. Yours is a truly remarkable interpretation and performance. Julie, you make the flute sing and cry. Thanks
thank you so much. JS
Beautiful renditions of these wonderful tunes.
this really captures the spirit of the piece.. each performance is somewhat different because of the free time aspect of the song, and it's flowing time signature.. This is an absolutely beautiful rendering of the piece
thank you!
Meravigliosa e sensibilissima interpretazione...il meglio che si possa immaginare per Monsieur Satie, unico e carissimo...Brave!
This is the most beautiful thing I've heard so far in 2022! Thank you.
Very nice performance. This is exactly how i imagine the double notes, very subtile, love it.
Discovered this very recording on NPR this evening. Had never heard the piece before, had to rush home and look it up. It's absolutely beautiful.
thank you!!!
hola Julie desde Argentina te saludo, estoy escuchando la musica, y es hermosa
It is very beautiful, thank you for this wonderful version of one of my favorite compositions!
Thank you so much!! I have a new CD out if you are curious: The complete Bach Flute Sonatas I recorded with my daughter- Julie Scolnik and Sophie Scolnik-Brower:)
In flute🥹 thank you
Splendid. What a joy to have discovered this.
thank you!!
Haunting yet gorgeous.
Beautiful music and album art!!
Hauntingly beautiful!
Happy 150th birthday, Erik.
Very beautiful. Thank you. Will be saving this in my favorite folder. This is the third version that I hear and love it. Thnks.
Number one. Sublime, truly. My mind simply floats aloft to this haunting piece so beautifully played. Thank you
Thank you so much for telling me this.
@@shadeofbleu what is the name of that flut?
I want to cry.
me too, everytime i listen it!!
thank you🙏
Bravo! That was fantastic.
jes, brilliant played
a true pleasure to listen to your interpretation
This is absolutely spectacular!
Makes me want to find a flute and start playing again. Lovely!
Bello, sublime... La música de Satie es simple y tan profunda a la vez, que no cabe en una simple partitura.
it is a cool interpretation ! Wonderful !
Beautiful
thank you!
Stunning!
Elizabeth will love the Satie's music.
Please do 2 and 4-6.!! This is sooo pretty/amazing/indescribable/made my LIFE! Thanks for sharing!
Hello, I want to buy the CD but it is not possible on Amazone. Can you help me ? Thank you 🙋
you're so kind thank you! JS
Gnossienne 1 is based on the Romanian style called Doina.
Beautiful rendition!
Yeah-yeah, everything in this world is based on something Romanian...
hahah.:)
Yes it is! Thank you! I worked hard to find the right cover, so I appreciate your kind words! Even prettier in person. :)
Beautiful! I also love the opening image...perhaps it is the cover of your album? Lovely!
Me encantó esta versión de las gnossiennes, con la flauta la música siempre transmite más esperanza.
Excellent performance :)
Enthralling, compelling, absolutely beautiful..
Love it.. Played slooow as meant to be.
fantastic
nice transcription !
Hermoso tema.
Lovely!
Precioso, amo esa melodía!!
I love this so much :)
These are precious. I often feel that solo piano versions rarely carry the message of these songs through.
heart breaking music but,l love it !!!!!!.
Ein meisterlicher Hochgenuss
Stupendo.
What is the name of the flute
This is a cunting brilliant arrangement.
hermoso!!
The Gnossiennes don't sound right played on many instruments besides the piano, but the flute and harp do suit it...nice version!
What kind of flute are they using?
Muhteşem
Julie, do you play on a Brannen? I have a Brannen-Cooper I bought in 1985. Tone is eerily similar to mine.
HI Excalibur! sorry I never saw this comment! * I am so untechy! YES I do play a Brannen, but the HJ is a Sheridan.
@@shadeofbleu thanks for verifying. Good ear, huh?
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
@Zephas99 thanks so much... help me get rid of some of my cd's! cdbaby.com! :)
:D
I wish I could date a woman that played harp.
+Moses Saldana Do any men play the harp? There must be some I suppose, but I've never met one. Of all the orchestral instruments I know of, the harp is maybe the least gender-diverse. Though to be fair you don't see a lot of women playing the tuba I guess.
You would spend your time being her moving crew. I did a gig this Thursday & Friday at Baylor University in Waco. I was beat to death dragging that harp, stool, speaker, etc. I didn't realize how easy I had it being a wind player. Grab'n'Go.
hayır...
nooo
erik sati bu değil
saçma
bizim erkan oğur
Hello!! Can you tell me what that means in English please? Google translate didn't understand either:)
not that erik sati
walk...walking
or standing
erik sati is not that
bunu ben de çalabilirim sazla
SAZ ÇALDIĞIMI KANITLARIM
erik satinin ne söylediğini değil
Sorry, I don't like it. Well played though.