A very nicely scripted scientific report. Good information , very instructive and educative. Congrats. I had visited the BRS site 3 weeks back ! The Rock paintings need more protection, and should also be saved from erosion from elements. Glass enclosure is the need of the hour. An Archeaological Interpretation centre at the site is much needed. Thanks
2:43 madam, can you not mention Horses? When you say this paining is 6000-8000 years old and depicts horses then it clearly tells that Warriors in India have been using horses for battles. Debunking the horse theory which some historians use to validate Aryan Invation/Migration Theory
@@himanshushekhar2808 But it means that Horses were already used in india contrary to the aryan invasion theory that Aryans were outsiders because they rode horses which were not known to Indians.
You really need to name the team of geologists as a proper scientific correspondent. The lead scientist and his team must always get credit. Other than this omission an interesting piece.
Very informative piece, very well covered Thank you! Love to see more scientific segments of general interest presented in a straightforward and deep coverage like this.
Brilliant Story ! Sandhy Ramesh .. These shelters are not in isolation. They commence from Udaigiri Caves in Vidisha to Hoshangabad. With some significant art work a km away from CMs bungalow on Shamla Hills.
In so many ways this makes sense. The Indian sub continent fits like a jigsaw between the conjunction of West Africa and East South American coast. Hence the similarity of similar megafauna in this regions like elephants, rhinos, leopards, lions as well other animals like honey badgers. The continued extension of these similar facets is evident also with several insect and reptile species in the Western Ghats to Ivory Coast, Gabon as well as French Guinea and Brazil. These are more recent evolutions, so the fact that the same species of Dickinsonia would be spread across geographical locations not seperated is not surprising. That with sheer volume of population in the sub continent through its history due to its fertility, that something that is 635 million years old remains untouched is in itself is a fantastic feat of survival.
I hate the idea that ancient Indian civilization is represented by Indus valley civilization while rest of subcontinent is discarded from discussion. Indus wasn't even the major river, instead it was Saraswati. The fact that Indus valley civilization is part of discussion because we found the sites of the cities and we found them because no body lived there after that. It doesn't mean that rest of the green arable land would be vacant for nobody to live. People continued to live here, so you won't find old remains. Probably Bhimbetka caves are even older than IVC. Also, AIT is complete crap.
Being the residence of Bhopal, it was very astonishing & obviously informative to see such informative video. Gratitude to #SANDHYA Mam & The Print..!!
Superb coverage and very well explained. Indian peninsula can be a cradle of many more such discoveries given its geographical position in the past and the journey that it has seen through millions of years. This is one of the examples of the rich diversity that we may have and i strongly feel that we have just scratched the surface.
As usual, a nice episode from Sandhya Ramesh. This discovery, just before the pandemic hit the country, is a great one. It could lead to solving some mysteries. Sandhya has good voice and her diction is very clear. This, I guess, contributes in making the topic interesting. Keep it up Sandhya!
This channel is simply wonderful... Selection of interesting topics... Beautiful presentation ... Explanation in layman's language... Looking forward to see more, from this channel... Keep posting...
Quite comprehensive in its scientific reporting of the facts...going to the extent of telling about views of lead author on dickinsonia....great scientific reporting sandhya ramesh👍
Great job Sandhya! Welcome change from routine, useless news emanating out of India. Very educative , time well spent on watching. Good luck, awaiting more productions of science and technology.
She is very careful not mentioning people riding horses. I wonder why. May be mentioning Horses would crumble the entire left wing History like a house of cards.
@@selenophile410 he's talking about Aryan invasion crap theory one of its claims are that Aryans who invaded India brought horses before that India didn't have horses
@@opm3193 could have been that india had horse before (10,000yr ago) then they kind of migrated eastwards or were hunted to extinction and then aryans brought them to india again.it has happened with cats too ua-cam.com/video/CYPJzQppANo/v-deo.html
Painting of site is 10000 year old. But human settlement are earlier from this site. Because Acheulian stone tools also found. Acheulian stone tools belong from Lower Paleolithic Age.
Great video. I wish we had more resources to do this kind of research in India... + Fantastic discovery. I live less than 300kms from Bhimbetka but never visited the place. :( Question though: why do the photos in this video have such low quality? Are these photos very old or there are no better quality photos of the place actually available?
There is nothing like that..i just visited the place last week ... That was just Bee hive residual that is imprinted .. and our guid was also like "sir ye toh zabardasti wala hai..😂😂😂 and i feel it same ..
So fascinating... the real origin of Indian peoples and culture... wish I could go check out Bhimbetka myself, does anyone know if it’s open for tourists/ visitors?
What a coincidence, how less we know about our history. I think the vindya and the nallamalla beds have some great fossils hiding around and yet to be discovered
It could have lived only in the oceans and got trapped inland as the continents closed in to form Pangea. Not saying it did. Saying it's a possibility. As you stated we need more info. Great presentation. Thanks
@@kaamdev810 it means horses were way before than earlier estimates. I'm no scientist or historian but I believe Aryan migration happened after end of last ice age.
I visited Bhimbetaka after watching this video. It is being argued by local geologist and members of ASI that the said fossil is actually remains of a burnt bee hive. The hive was burnt around 1979 and the mark exists after that. It is likely that the discovery does not hold true. Please review the news item based on latest evidence
What a coincident I have just completed evolution chapter where bhimbetka rock shelter of raisen district of mp is mention for its cave paintings of pre historic humans.
True. She needs her own channel. This type content is not suitable for the psudoscience loving fans of you know who, the typical audience of this channel as a whole.
It's refreshing to see a knowledge based video which is competent without being narcissistic which usually stems from self assurance, right knowledge and when the overriding desire is to illuminate and set things on record, other outcomes are coincidental. I hope you are able to stay the course. Good job!
@@mastrammeena328 Just answer me one question ! Why it is so bad and untrendy if you talk good things about our Hinduism which started its root from this subcontinent but if you mock hinduism and praise other religion which comes from outside that shows intellegence and diversity?
Why don't "they " publish an official paper on the issue and exhibit the findings ? Pillars , vishnu avatar, ram lala , janam bhomi etc etc , all is fine . Where is the proof and authentication? Why this reluctance to debate the facts ?? If there was a temple below the mosque , does it prove that Lord Ram was born at that spot ? All one is asking for are truth and facts .
Such a great piece of reporting. Really contextualizes the finding in a way you can appreciate the significance of it. Thanks Sandhya Ramesh.
Reporting is good but few information are completely wrong
This is so underrated. Good work.
These videos are fantastic nuggets of information. Keep this going, The Print!
Very well explained and presented. Please bring her more frequently in the news since she explains really well.
1% comments:- actually talking bout the video
99% comments:- dickinsonia jokes
You mean Sonia Gandhi jokes.
A very nicely scripted scientific report. Good information , very instructive and educative. Congrats.
I had visited the BRS site 3 weeks back ! The Rock paintings need more protection, and should also be saved from erosion from elements. Glass enclosure is the need of the hour. An Archeaological Interpretation centre at the site is much needed. Thanks
2:43 madam, can you not mention Horses? When you say this paining is 6000-8000 years old and depicts horses then it clearly tells that Warriors in India have been using horses for battles.
Debunking the horse theory which some historians use to validate Aryan Invation/Migration Theory
2:57 she did mention rider on animals
Aryan theory is a theory not a confirmed fact
It can be prove what is truth by evidence only.
Paintings of horses are from historical period....need to understand that the paintings belong to mesolithic to historical period
@@himanshushekhar2808 But it means that Horses were already used in india contrary to the aryan invasion theory that Aryans were outsiders because they rode horses which were not known to Indians.
@@Jkjeetkr8t8 right..
1:07 thank me later 😒
Thanks
What a remarkable discovery it is, thank you to update us with a beautiful explanation
You really need to name the team of geologists as a proper scientific correspondent. The lead scientist and his team must always get credit. Other than this omission an interesting piece.
She need to brush up her chronological knowledge of indian archaeology first...so that she dont provide wrong information
I went there in 2018. Being there hits you hard when you realise that thousands of years ago our primitive ancestors where there at that same place.
Not thousands but millions
Very informative piece, very well covered Thank you! Love to see more scientific segments of general interest presented in a straightforward and deep coverage like this.
I am a student of Anthropology, and I thank you so much for the information that was apt as well as well analysed and well presented too
Brilliant Story !
Sandhy Ramesh ..
These shelters are not in isolation. They commence from Udaigiri Caves in Vidisha to Hoshangabad.
With some significant art work a km away from CMs bungalow on Shamla Hills.
Good Job. Calm way of telling and explaining things.👍
Excellent video as always
Maam is back ...🥰
Always waiting for pure science...
In so many ways this makes sense. The Indian sub continent fits like a jigsaw between the conjunction of West Africa and East South American coast. Hence the similarity of similar megafauna in this regions like elephants, rhinos, leopards, lions as well other animals like honey badgers. The continued extension of these similar facets is evident also with several insect and reptile species in the Western Ghats to Ivory Coast, Gabon as well as French Guinea and Brazil. These are more recent evolutions, so the fact that the same species of Dickinsonia would be spread across geographical locations not seperated is not surprising.
That with sheer volume of population in the sub continent through its history due to its fertility, that something that is 635 million years old remains untouched is in itself is a fantastic feat of survival.
Superb video. Intriguing insights brought to our notice about these beautiful caves. Well done Sandhya Ramesh!
I hate the idea that ancient Indian civilization is represented by Indus valley civilization while rest of subcontinent is discarded from discussion. Indus wasn't even the major river, instead it was Saraswati. The fact that Indus valley civilization is part of discussion because we found the sites of the cities and we found them because no body lived there after that. It doesn't mean that rest of the green arable land would be vacant for nobody to live. People continued to live here, so you won't find old remains. Probably Bhimbetka caves are even older than IVC. Also, AIT is complete crap.
Being the residence of Bhopal, it was very astonishing & obviously informative to see such informative video.
Gratitude to #SANDHYA Mam & The Print..!!
Thank you sandya for taking us to ancient India
# Sandya Ramesh 🙌🙌🙌
Superb coverage and very well explained. Indian peninsula can be a cradle of many more such discoveries given its geographical position in the past and the journey that it has seen through millions of years. This is one of the examples of the rich diversity that we may have and i strongly feel that we have just scratched the surface.
As usual, a nice episode from Sandhya Ramesh. This discovery, just before the pandemic hit the country, is a great one. It could lead to solving some mysteries.
Sandhya has good voice and her diction is very clear. This, I guess, contributes in making the topic interesting. Keep it up Sandhya!
I have been to this place for a short period. Seems like I learnt more through this showcase.
Excellent video! Thank you for putting all the facts together and sharing in a simple yet cogent manner. Kudos! :)
Thank you; very comprehensive.
Sandhya you’re perfect from every aspect 😍
Simp 😁
@@sensei3265 +1
Well researched and well made video. Quite satisfying and informative.
Perseverance!!!! Hope to watch it soon.
ty for posting this!
This series is quite informative..Thanks
The way you explain is as good as me going and seeing bimbetka caves myself , excellent... Job....
Serendipitously found this video and the news is interesting! Thank you presentor!
Excellent work!
This channel is simply wonderful... Selection of interesting topics... Beautiful presentation ... Explanation in layman's language... Looking forward to see more, from this channel... Keep posting...
Hi Saugata. So happy to hear that you appreciate our endeavour in giving holistic news to our viewers! Do keep following us.
One the best video i have ever seen
This video is probably the best video of bhimbetka
Thank you very much THE PRINT TEAM
THIS VIDEO HELP PASS MY S.S EXAM,
Nice work...keep it up...Perceverance awaited...👍
Quite comprehensive in its scientific reporting of the facts...going to the extent of telling about views of lead author on dickinsonia....great scientific reporting sandhya ramesh👍
Great job Sandhya!
Welcome change from routine, useless news emanating out of India.
Very educative , time well spent on watching. Good luck, awaiting more productions of science and technology.
I only watch her sub-stream in ThePrint. Well, . . . . sometimes Cut the clutter as well. :P
amazing content. keep it up!!
Amazing reporting! Which is par for the course for Sandhya Ramesh.
Thank you for covering these story
Excellent information
She is very careful not mentioning people riding horses. I wonder why. May be mentioning Horses would crumble the entire left wing History like a house of cards.
How
@@selenophile410 he's talking about Aryan invasion crap theory one of its claims are that Aryans who invaded India brought horses before that India didn't have horses
@@opm3193 could have been that india had horse before (10,000yr ago) then they kind of migrated eastwards or were hunted to extinction and then aryans brought them to india again.it has happened with cats too
ua-cam.com/video/CYPJzQppANo/v-deo.html
@@rahultiwari-dx8qo kuch bhi
At 3:26 you can also see a white horse painting.
She's very good orator .Loved the video
Thank sandhya for another interesting video
Love the way she explains. Love her too much.
@Devvrat Mishra 😄😄😄
Fascinating account....riveting and informative.
Painting of site is 10000 year old. But human settlement are earlier from this site. Because Acheulian stone tools also found. Acheulian stone tools belong from Lower Paleolithic Age.
Abhi ghoom k aya hun wahi se waha ka care taker bol rha madhumakkhi ka chhatta tha to aisa design bn gya h😂😂
I am in absolute awe.
Great video. I wish we had more resources to do this kind of research in India... + Fantastic discovery. I live less than 300kms from Bhimbetka but never visited the place. :(
Question though: why do the photos in this video have such low quality? Are these photos very old or there are no better quality photos of the place actually available?
There is nothing like that..i just visited the place last week ... That was just Bee hive residual that is imprinted .. and our guid was also like "sir ye toh zabardasti wala hai..😂😂😂 and i feel it same ..
Awesome information 👍
👏👏..informative Nd as exciting as reading a Yuval Harari book...
Good initiative for our history
Mam you have explained very good
A very clear description of an extremely interesting finding.
So fascinating... the real origin of Indian peoples and culture... wish I could go check out Bhimbetka myself, does anyone know if it’s open for tourists/ visitors?
I Love the explanation............
Nice Explanation
Very good discoveries by our scientists nonetheless. Hope more and more discoveries are done in near future.
What a coincidence, how less we know about our history. I think the vindya and the nallamalla beds have some great fossils hiding around and yet to be discovered
Also have a read about the Narmada human. It was also an interesting find but rarely anyone knows about it.
Great work
'Dickinsonia' 🤣🤣 This post was brought to you by Rajiv Gandhi gang
Very informative . I have hone to bhimbhetka few years back. But this info of fossils is very new
Sandhya's expression is woww
sandhya
good work
Very Exciting
It could have lived only in the oceans and got trapped inland as the continents closed in to form Pangea. Not saying it did. Saying it's a possibility. As you stated we need more info. Great presentation. Thanks
550 million ago, the Indian subcontinent was a part of the Gondwana super continent, and at a great distance from the Eurasian plate.
2:58 Riders on horses
Aryan invasion theory debunked
Yes indeed...horses..
@@kaamdev810 it means horses were way before than earlier estimates. I'm no scientist or historian but I believe Aryan migration happened after end of last ice age.
Damm that was easy to debunk that shity Aryan theory 😂
‘Beehive imprints’, not 550 mn-yr-old fossil: Bhimbetka find proven false, scientists accept mistake. - The Print, Feb 2023
Sandhya is ❤️❤️
Scientists and historians need to collaborate at a larger scale
Plz be the voice of students to support us. Thanks
👍🏻 good information ☺️
Dickinsonia! Interesting..
I visited Bhimbetaka after watching this video. It is being argued by local geologist and members of ASI that the said fossil is actually remains of a burnt bee hive. The hive was burnt around 1979 and the mark exists after that.
It is likely that the discovery does not hold true. Please review the news item based on latest evidence
I told you so
What a coincident I have just completed evolution chapter where bhimbetka rock shelter of raisen district of mp is mention for its cave paintings of pre historic humans.
Good insights
Thank you 😊
sandhya ramesh. 👍
The only information i love in print is purescienc
True. She needs her own channel. This type content is not suitable for the psudoscience loving fans of you know who, the typical audience of this channel as a whole.
Amazing
It's refreshing to see a knowledge based video which is competent without being narcissistic which usually stems from self assurance, right knowledge and when the overriding desire is to illuminate and set things on record, other outcomes are coincidental. I hope you are able to stay the course. Good job!
Her eyes❤️
Texas freeze mein kya hua? Pls explain in next pure science
Very good.
Paleontology is extremely neglected in India.
Latest research says it is fossilized impression of beehives
Very nice cave give in hindi or gujarati
Thanks
Thank you for your support Vivek!
The so low views on this video gives an impression on where most people's interest lies. That's so unfortunate.
they did not find Ram Lalla
@@drury2d8 Ya lets mock hinduism and that will show how smart person we are !
Ye are right wingers only interested in criticizing opposition
Shayad fuel price k liye bhi congress ko hi blame kr rhe honge
@@mastrammeena328 Just answer me one question ! Why it is so bad and untrendy if you talk good things about our Hinduism which started its root from this subcontinent but if you mock hinduism and praise other religion which comes from outside that shows intellegence and diversity?
Why don't "they " publish an official paper on the issue and exhibit the findings ? Pillars , vishnu avatar, ram lala , janam bhomi etc etc , all is fine . Where is the proof and authentication? Why this reluctance to debate the facts ??
If there was a temple below the mosque , does it prove that Lord Ram was born at that spot ?
All one is asking for are truth and facts .
How come its found now ?
Whats the plural? Dickinsonias or Dicksinsonia?
Sad that it was just a bee hive imprint.😢
Hope, more videos about science and facts, and a separate section just showing about Indian history, culture and just facts not opinion.