This band (ensemble) is absolutely fantastic! What a discovery this is! Refreshing, lively, playful, absolutely solid prepared and carefully practiced. Have not heard any version so brilliant as this. Pure delight! So happy everytime I hear it (and watch it). Must have been 12 times already.
❤so wunderbar, herzlichen Dank für diese so schöne Interpretation des ,,Ehre sei Dir Gott gesungen" ! Allen einen guten Rutsch ins neue Jahr und uns allen ein friedlicheres Jahr 2024❤
Enjoyable from top to bottom. Exceptional musicians and singers. Performance is top quality. Confidence in interpretation is to praise! No one is pretentious, just talented! Cesareltenor 😊
Thanks Gina! Are you on our mailing list, so you know when/where all our concerts are? If you live in London and support us, even at a low level, you can come to our rehearsals!
@@ginacrusco234 depending on upcoming visa cost decisions…it’s not impossible that we’ll make it over in the next year or two. If you know any promoters who might like us, spread the word!
Fantastic, great momentum! Thank you! (PS Your performance of the Bach B minor mass at Shoreditch Town Hall a few years ago was the best I've ever seen.)
One of my favourite Bach choruses. Relatively rarely played live at least in Germany, where often only cantatas 1-3 are performed. The two singers per voice works very good here. A lot better than in the opening chorus of cantata 1 (jauchzet frohlocket). BTW, as a native speaker I can say: your pronunciation is spot on. I just find some (not all) of the final Ts too exaggerated, but that's more a question of personal taste. Probably the best live performance of this specific piece of music that I have heard. Personal favourite of Christmas Oratorio remains Gardiner, but of course that's a studio recording.
Das jazzt dermaßen, dazu noch mit den jungen Leuten ! Noch schöner wäre dieser Ohrwurm, wenn auch die letzten 3 Männer die Noten weglegen könnten. ( Das haben die andern ja auch geschafft.)
@@solomonsknot Auf jeden Fall in angemessenerem Tempo als mehrere Geschwindigkeits:Fans, die dieses Bravourstück in Rennfahrer - Manie durchheizen. Wahrscheinlich wollen die schnell ins Wirtshaus.
Oh, you meant put the scores (Partituren) away, not put the notes away! I don't have any problem with singers or instrumentalists performing from scores.
This is the most difficult section in the whole oratorio, isn’t it? As I recall from when I save this piece long long ago no other part of it was anywhere near as hard as this one.
@@THyperon Have you sung the piece yourself? "Herr, wenn" has long melismas but you can "stagger" your breathing, and the music is easy to follow and entrances are easy to get right.
@@ColonelFredPuntridge Yes, I sung the whole Weihnachtsoratorium over years. First as a boy soprano, later alto, tenor and finally bass. We sung Ehre sei dir Gott gesungen a bit quicker than here.
Está bom. O que, para mim, não ficou muito bem, foi a dinâmica dos tenores: em muitos momentos eles cantavam forte e ficavam por cima de outra voz que estava com o "motivo" mais importante, principalmente nas entradas e retomadas.
I agree- it is very pretentious in some ways. The first soprano and female altos virtue signalling style off the copy is so distracting. They both look ridiculously tense and the stiff necked, lighthouse- like swivelling looks ridiculous. The basses manage it with less pretence- best of all is the tenor section who communicate beautifully even though on copy. It’s all very well to use the gimmick of no scores to give the impression of communcating better with the audience but REALLY? ! Does it have to look so ridiculously self aware? 🤢🤮
Ich kann es auch so gut und im selben Tempo singen, es gefällt mir aber gar nicht. Es klingt gehetzt, als wenn die Sänger durch die Töne gepeitscht würden. Ohne jede Seele, ohne Glanz und Tiefgang. Ich werde es als abschreckendes Beispiel teilen.
@@solomonsknot ah! Thank you. I was really just making a joke. I have only recently discovered you guys and I am quite smitten. My niece in Berlin sings with Rias Kammerchor and I’ve made her a fan of Solomon’s Knot also. I am a lowly banjo player, with a massive crush on Bach. 🤣🪕. They don’t go well together. Thanks again for your music. I hope to see you live someday.
@@solomonsknot I would love to, but I live in California. But, hey, if you allow me to accompany you on my banjo perhaps I would make the trip. BTW, do y’all have an email mailing list. I would love to receive notifications about your happenings and upcoming gigs.
@@friendlybanjoatheist5464 yes! solomonsknotcollective.us4.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=2c15220ebd67543d348c732c8&id=632adeff68 We hope to make it to California one day...do you know any nice promoters or agents who might invite us??
Just wonderful and joyous. Thank you.
This band (ensemble) is absolutely fantastic! What a discovery this is! Refreshing, lively, playful, absolutely solid prepared and carefully practiced. Have not heard any version so brilliant as this. Pure delight! So happy everytime I hear it (and watch it). Must have been 12 times already.
The beautiful lady wearing purple gives me great demonstration and good interaction with majestic funny interpretation and movements
"Soli Deo Gloria!" ❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉 Giuseppe Perego Monza 16.2.1962 Grazie
Yes, indeed. SOLI DEO GLORIA!!!!!!!!!!
Präzision, Tempo, fantastic voices...Bach would have loved it
Stunning. Best version I have heard. The gorgeous alto in the purple dress is just fun to watch, and can she sing!
She is staring into your soul…
what spirit!!!! BRAVO!!!!
Wonderful Music Bach 🎉❤
The most ebullient rendition of a Bach piece I’ve heard in 60 years of listening to him.
Bach Forever 😊❤👍🥇👑🎼🎶🎹🎺🎺🎻🥁
❤I'm with you on that1
La mejor interpretación que hay en UA-cam, perfección total tanto en las voces como en la música.
I could claim that Bach has reached the perfection composing music and these people have here reached it in presentation of his music! Splendid!
Wunderbar ❤
The lass in the purple frock 🥰😍
A mystery that there are not way more views..
Bravo!
❤so wunderbar, herzlichen Dank für diese so schöne Interpretation des ,,Ehre sei Dir Gott gesungen" !
Allen einen guten Rutsch ins neue Jahr und uns allen ein friedlicheres Jahr 2024❤
The three female singers ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ The tall blonde is my absolute favorite !!!! She gave me the true feeling of baroque exhilaration.
Huh?
@@herrickinman9303 Huh what . . . ??? What do you mean ?
@@I-am-what-I-am Put it back in your pants.
This is just wonderfully done…so joyful!
Glorious. You made my day!
meisterhaft, wunderschön
oh my what beauty.
Perfect performance. Great!❤
Sublime
Lea , un totale assoluto piacere sentirla e vederla
Fantastic thank you,greetings from Utrecht the Netherlands
Enjoyable from top to bottom.
Exceptional musicians and singers.
Performance is top quality.
Confidence in interpretation is to praise!
No one is pretentious, just talented!
Cesareltenor 😊
Espectacular, un tema con tanto contrapunto en las voces y la perfección es absoluta.
I so love this.
Super
Lovely! Great! Beautifull!
Amazing! Amazing! Amazing! 😱
Bravissimi!
Extraordinari grup seleccionat del cor Monteverdi ....ni igulat ni superat per ningú.
Congratulations
I would follow this ensemble anywhere.
Thanks Gina! Are you on our mailing list, so you know when/where all our concerts are?
If you live in London and support us, even at a low level, you can come to our rehearsals!
@@solomonsknot I wish! Do you ever make it to New York or Boston?
@@ginacrusco234 depending on upcoming visa cost decisions…it’s not impossible that we’ll make it over in the next year or two. If you know any promoters who might like us, spread the word!
But since you would ‘follow us anywhere’…😉
@@solomonsknot Please look at my email.
Fantastic!!!
Hammering each and every note ... this is beautiful.... one day
Bach is nothing if not relentless.
So skillfully done, brought a big smile
to this old boy’s face.
I am old and it brought a smile to my face.
Very Beautiful Bravo Congratulations 👏👏👏👏👏💐
Fantastic, great momentum! Thank you!
(PS Your performance of the Bach B minor mass at Shoreditch Town Hall a few years ago was the best I've ever seen.)
Thanks! 😃
Quel swing !
One of my favourite Bach choruses. Relatively rarely played live at least in Germany, where often only cantatas 1-3 are performed.
The two singers per voice works very good here. A lot better than in the opening chorus of cantata 1 (jauchzet frohlocket).
BTW, as a native speaker I can say: your pronunciation is spot on. I just find some (not all) of the final Ts too exaggerated, but that's more a question of personal taste.
Probably the best live performance of this specific piece of music that I have heard.
Personal favourite of Christmas Oratorio remains Gardiner, but of course that's a studio recording.
Fantastisch!
@@middelkoop10 danke!
really good
ALLES. IST. BACH.
Das jazzt dermaßen, dazu noch mit den jungen Leuten !
Noch schöner wäre dieser Ohrwurm, wenn auch die letzten 3 Männer die Noten weglegen könnten.
( Das haben die andern ja auch geschafft.)
Wir hatten 3 Einspringer…
@@solomonsknot Auf jeden Fall in angemessenerem Tempo als mehrere Geschwindigkeits:Fans, die dieses Bravourstück in Rennfahrer - Manie durchheizen.
Wahrscheinlich wollen die schnell ins Wirtshaus.
@@ausbavaria5661es ist nunmal Vivace überschrieben... mit meiner Kantorei hab ichs auch noch einen Tick schneller genommen als hier.
Oh, you meant put the scores (Partituren) away, not put the notes away! I don't have any problem with singers or instrumentalists performing from scores.
The guy in the middle wearing ancient beard have my fancy too
eensio thanks agree/. Fine sound/.
This is the most difficult section in the whole oratorio, isn’t it? As I recall from when I save this piece long long ago no other part of it was anywhere near as hard as this one.
I think "Herr, wenn die stolzen Feinde schnauben" is more difficult to sing.
@@THyperon Have you sung the piece yourself? "Herr, wenn" has long melismas but you can "stagger" your breathing, and the music is easy to follow and entrances are easy to get right.
@@ColonelFredPuntridge Yes, I sung the whole Weihnachtsoratorium over years. First as a boy soprano, later alto, tenor and finally bass. We sung Ehre sei dir Gott gesungen a bit quicker than here.
Beautiful performance of very difficult piece! Poor camera work though.
Wow - how do the women singers manage without notation?
Actually as a rule we always sing without scores, but for this project we had three short-notice replacements.
Top-quality replacements, too!😊
Como podéis cantar sin partitura la mayoría de vosotros? Pues es una pieza con mucho contrapunto y mucha complicación.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Está bom. O que, para mim, não ficou muito bem, foi a dinâmica dos tenores: em muitos momentos eles cantavam forte e ficavam por cima de outra voz que estava com o "motivo" mais importante, principalmente nas entradas e retomadas.
Es gibt langsamere Interpretationen von diesem Stück.
Schön gesungen. Aber zu schnell. 🙂
How can this repertoire be sung in a pretentious way like this! 😭
What's pretentious about it exactly?
No tienes mucho oído musical, así que mejor estate calladita guapa..
I agree- it is very pretentious in some ways. The first soprano and female altos virtue signalling style off the copy is so distracting. They both look ridiculously tense and the stiff necked, lighthouse- like swivelling looks ridiculous. The basses manage it with less pretence- best of all is the tenor section who communicate beautifully even though on copy. It’s all very well to use the gimmick of no scores to give the impression of communcating better with the audience but REALLY? ! Does it have to look so ridiculously self aware? 🤢🤮
I think those who object are the pretentious ones!
It is not pretentious. It is called Confidence and being well prepared . They are excellent in what they do.
Cesarthetenor!
It would be more beautiful if It was Catholic.
Ich kann es auch so gut und im selben Tempo singen, es gefällt mir aber gar nicht. Es klingt gehetzt, als wenn die Sänger durch die Töne gepeitscht würden.
Ohne jede Seele, ohne Glanz und Tiefgang.
Ich werde es als abschreckendes Beispiel teilen.
Too showy/showing off 😮
Been on stage any time?
Why do the women have their parts memorized but the guy singers need the book? 😉🪕
Due to illness, we had quite a few last minute replacements.
@@solomonsknot ah! Thank you. I was really just making a joke. I have only recently discovered you guys and I am quite smitten. My niece in Berlin sings with Rias Kammerchor and I’ve made her a fan of Solomon’s Knot also.
I am a lowly banjo player, with a massive crush on Bach. 🤣🪕. They don’t go well together.
Thanks again for your music. I hope to see you live someday.
@@friendlybanjoatheist5464 Thanks for liking us! We just played in Eisenach, and will be in Regensburg on 9th October. Come!
@@solomonsknot I would love to, but I live in California. But, hey, if you allow me to accompany you on my banjo perhaps I would make the trip.
BTW, do y’all have an email mailing list. I would love to receive notifications about your happenings and upcoming gigs.
@@friendlybanjoatheist5464 yes! solomonsknotcollective.us4.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=2c15220ebd67543d348c732c8&id=632adeff68
We hope to make it to California one day...do you know any nice promoters or agents who might invite us??