The Dam Busters a la Star Wars

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 505

  • @terryl3138
    @terryl3138 9 років тому +103

    Lucas even took dialogue directly from this script. "How many guns would you say?" "I say about 20 guns, some on the towers, some on the surface."

    • @percyprune7548
      @percyprune7548 6 років тому +17

      "lost Harry, lost Hutch" - Hutch was Hutchinson in the Dambusters, a radio operator.

    • @redactedagentdataexpunged9431
      @redactedagentdataexpunged9431 5 років тому +7

      Not just that
      You should see it by now
      "I reckon you should be able to see it by know"

    • @kimleechristensen2679
      @kimleechristensen2679 4 роки тому +1

      You mixed the two movie quotes.
      Fields not surface; In Dambusters.
      How many guns do you see Gold 5; Star Wars.
      😉😉😉

    • @ryanmoore3381
      @ryanmoore3381 3 роки тому +9

      @@kimleechristensen2679 to quote James Berardinelli . But, like all great craftsmen, Lucas has managed to fashion this material in a manner that not only honors the original sources, but makes it uniquely his own. Hacks rip off other movies; artists synthesize and pay homage to their inspirations. Compare to and the difference will become apparent.

  • @HenryvKeiper
    @HenryvKeiper  17 років тому +61

    Admittedly I was a bit worried people would think I was making fun of the bravery of the original pilots, which of course I wasn't - I was satirizing the similarities between two films.
    I have the utmost respect for any pilot who would fly a bomber low above a river right into enemy fire, all while targeting a bomb.

    • @emiliodesalvo7024
      @emiliodesalvo7024 6 років тому +2

      I would have said more Squadron 633 than The Dambusters, but probably I am not the first... :-D

    • @MrHarvester82
      @MrHarvester82 6 років тому +7

      This epic mission of Sq. 617 has been the greatest inspiration for first attack on the Death Star, so this footage can be considered just as a tribute, i think.

    • @usetheforceluke12
      @usetheforceluke12 4 роки тому +2

      Of course those pilots didn't have laser guidance systems and smart bombs available to them, or they would have made full use of them.

    • @AdmiralAckbar.
      @AdmiralAckbar. 4 роки тому +2

      MrHarvester82 indeed it was, it’s mentioned in a Star Wars doc. It’s almost plagiarism tbh lol almost

    • @ryanmoore3381
      @ryanmoore3381 3 роки тому +5

      @@AdmiralAckbar. James Berardinelli summed it up. Hacks rip off. Craftsmen synthesize material and make it their own. Lucas did the later and it shows

  • @QuorkEx
    @QuorkEx 10 років тому +49

    The Star Wars sequence must surely owe more than a little to the final reel of the film "633 Squadron".

    • @blackjac5000
      @blackjac5000 8 років тому +6

      +QuorkEx I suspect Y-wings were inspired by Mosquitoes. TIEs are definitely Zeroes. Perhaps X-wings are Spitfires, if not P-51s?

    • @blackjac5000
      @blackjac5000 8 років тому

      +QuorkEx I suspect Y-wings were inspired by Mosquitoes. TIEs are definitely Zeroes. Perhaps X-wings are Spitfires, if not P-51s?

    • @BillThompson1955
      @BillThompson1955 8 років тому +8

      +blackjac5000 I recall seeing a collection of storyboards from the original Star Wars, not long after the movie came out. One pair from the collection showed a Zero chasing a Mustang over a tropical landscape, while the adjacent drawing showed a TIE fighter chasing an X-wing over the Death Star. Same positions and perspective. The SW production crew never tried to hide the copying; in a way, it was a tribute to the dramatic impact of the visuals in the original movies.

    • @momthree789
      @momthree789 8 років тому

      +BillThompson1955 If Star Wars was a tribute, it should have been marketed as a tribute. After seeing some other videos, is anything about Star Wars original???

    • @BillThompson1955
      @BillThompson1955 8 років тому +6

      momthree789 The music and Chewbacca's lines were original. Star Wars is far from the first movie to copy from other sources. When Kurosawa's friends told him that "The Magnificent Seven" was a rip-off of "Seven Samurai," he laughed and said "Do you know how many Westerns I ripped off to make 'Seven Samurai"?" The difference is that Kurosawa was brilliant. (When I saw SW in 1977, my first thought was that the credits should have read "based on James Schmitz's 'The Witches of Karres.'")

  • @greenseaships
    @greenseaships 16 років тому +24

    I love how when the guy says "we should be able to see it by now" there's a shot of the navigator looking at his chart! This parody is complete from start to finish!

  • @christopherfisher6293
    @christopherfisher6293 3 роки тому +4

    A fine tribute to some very brave young men, some of whom never got any older. RIP.

  • @scribe56
    @scribe56 8 років тому +15

    This was a great movie. I remember watching it on TV as a kid. I think the pilot in the lead plane is Richard Todd. And back at their headquarters, the civilian is Michael Redgrave. Really thrilling movie.

    • @mariacornwallis1602
      @mariacornwallis1602 6 років тому +2

      Jane Sellman :- That civilian is Barnes Wallis, the inventor of the swing wing jet, the 6 ton Tallboy and the 10 ton Grand Slam deep penetration earth quake bombs which penetrated the U boat pens, sank the Tirpitz and destroyed many other reinforced targets

  • @brotherbelcher1
    @brotherbelcher1 17 років тому +7

    Great stuff!Lucas has admitted to being inspired by WW2 dogfights and used actual combat footage in the place of unfinished effects during a test screening of S.W.I`m sure he had Dambusters and 633 Squadron in mind when he made the trench sequence.

  • @StillLateToTheParty
    @StillLateToTheParty 9 років тому +21

    Impressive... most impressive

  • @cvk308
    @cvk308 17 років тому +3

    As a fan of both films, (20 years+) I give you a big WELL DONE!!!! Thanks for a new look at a classic.

  • @RoJayEmm
    @RoJayEmm 10 років тому +1

    Great to have the sound back on this video - it's an absolute gem!

  • @moviesgalore9947
    @moviesgalore9947 2 роки тому +2

    Only thing missing is Baron von Vader in his Stuka fighter saying "I have you now young Brit-talker" and a heroic American pilot named Solo saying "You're all clear kid! Now let's blow this damn dam and head for home!"

  • @northside7776
    @northside7776 7 років тому +3

    I love both movies and this is very clever and fun. Congratulations!

  • @Pappy55
    @Pappy55 6 років тому +2

    Lucas was heavily inspired by WW2 air combat films for the space batles so I'm not surprised this works so well.

  • @nervouspete
    @nervouspete 16 років тому +3

    Excellent work, sir! Dambuster's is one of my fave films, and I've always noted the simularity. Not long ago I was lucky enough to see it at the cinema and brought a mate along who's a big Star Wars fan but hadn't seen the film before. He was left comically open-mouted at the end - "That was essentially the Death Star run!" - My fave bit - "Luke, you've switched off your targetting computer!" (Officer drinks tea nonchalantly.) Shame Star Wars didn't have tea drinking dude.

  • @alanmoss3603
    @alanmoss3603 8 років тому +5

    Yep, that is the best YT video I've seen so far! Well done! And I don't find it at all disrespectful of the Dambusters raid - it is just comparing the film-making process of two different movies!

  • @lazyhazeldaisy9596
    @lazyhazeldaisy9596 3 роки тому +1

    Very good, it's funny seeing the Dambuster's film against the Star War's one extremely similar in action I would say.

  • @SantiagoRevecoLepeReborn
    @SantiagoRevecoLepeReborn 2 роки тому +1

    May the Royal Air Force be with you!

  • @HenryvKeiper
    @HenryvKeiper  16 років тому +1

    I'm pretty grateful it got 100,000 views, which I completely didn't expect. Like I said in the commentary for it, I only made it because I was bored one Saturday night.

  • @funkyprepper
    @funkyprepper 9 років тому +11

    amazing work
    brilliant

  • @Laceykat66
    @Laceykat66 10 років тому +14

    You know, that bomb is not much bigger than two meters . . .
    (gad I am such a nerd)

  • @tsu8003
    @tsu8003 7 років тому +1

    This is a work of art! Don't need to remake the Dambusters anymore! Thank you from a fan of both movies!
    P.s. Just like in Star Wars where Red Squadron has a pilot who was played by a British actor called Dennis Lawson the Dambusters actually had an American pilot called Joe McCarthy!

  • @allatoonabass1418
    @allatoonabass1418 9 років тому +6

    Well done, very enjoyable. Thank you.

  • @Ikaftl
    @Ikaftl 16 років тому +1

    Ha ha ha! I was half-expecting the Praxis effect at the end!

  • @KrillLiberator
    @KrillLiberator 6 років тому

    Ten years later, still a fine tribute to two classic movies.

  • @macejean-luc1886
    @macejean-luc1886 7 років тому +12

    Look at Wallis' wife hair in The Dam Busters. It might have inspired Princess Leia's.

    • @MothaLuva
      @MothaLuva 7 років тому +2

      More like Chewbacca.

    • @elliottbronstein1214
      @elliottbronstein1214 4 роки тому

      No. The inspiration for her hair comes from Mexican revolutionaries.

  • @RobertLawtonHamilton
    @RobertLawtonHamilton 14 років тому

    one of the coolest videos i have ever seen...great editing.

  • @-Gumbo
    @-Gumbo 7 років тому

    This is brilliant, I'm laughing all the way through.
    Great job

  • @Palifiox
    @Palifiox 10 років тому +6

    Luke and his uncle Obi-Wan Kenobi walk into a bar to get passage off Tatooine, a desert planet. They meet a spaceship captain with a dubious past who is torn between indifference and morality but agrees. They get past the imperial soldiers and take off in the space ship.
    In Casablanca, Ilsa and Laszlo walk into a bar to get papers to allow them to leave the city (in a desert region) from the proprietor of the bar whose past is dubious, Rick Blaine (H Bogart) who is torn between love and morality. Morality wins. They get past the German troops in the city and eventually take off in an airliner.
    Round up those directors who are usually suspected of making reference to other movies in their movies.

  • @calebrimer2870
    @calebrimer2870 4 місяці тому +1

    “Remember, the RAF will be with you…always.”

  • @philld8279
    @philld8279 14 років тому

    There are are a lot of these so called 'funny' mixes on youtube but this is the exception. It's well edited and very funny. Excellent job.

  • @wewantourdarbyback
    @wewantourdarbyback 16 років тому +1

    Brilliantly done, I wouldnt say any of it was in bad taste, the film was a great memorial to those who lost their lives that day and this is excellent, I'm sure those who served would have found it funny as well.

  • @alexanderross1979
    @alexanderross1979 6 місяців тому +2

    Remember Luke, the Force will be with you always.....the Royal Air Force that is.......

  • @HenryvKeiper
    @HenryvKeiper  14 років тому

    @MechaGojira00 Basically I put the trench run sequence into WMM, then cut it up by each individual shot, separated the audio, and put in video from The Dam Busters over each shot. If you watch (or listen) to the "Commentary" I did for it in the video responses, I explain a lot of how I did this.

  • @orangelion03
    @orangelion03 15 років тому

    Well done sir!!!!
    I knew of the connection but you made it perfectly clear just how close they were to each other. Reminds me a bit of "633 Squadron" as well, which was itself inspired by Dambusters.

  • @RomanesEuntDomus
    @RomanesEuntDomus 17 років тому

    Well done Henry, I enjoyed all three films, Star Wars, The Dambusters and yours. Thanks, you get a DFM...Damn Fine Movie.

  • @waratah08
    @waratah08 14 років тому

    An absolute ripper of a video. The editing is great and the dialogue fits perfectly. Bloody well done.

  • @narfanoid
    @narfanoid 16 років тому

    This was really well done. The selected shots were perfect for each section.

  • @sgunn
    @sgunn 16 років тому

    Class, good job you've done there, two of my favourite movies of all time.

  • @paulharrison3926
    @paulharrison3926 2 роки тому +1

    Excellent the (Royal Air) Force was with you

  • @autham
    @autham 16 років тому

    I remember this movie from the same times that it was first shown on tv. because as us kids were watching, my father came in and said the dam bastards? And we said no the dam busters. and to see it in this light of the post star wars era, it was done with a the same frame of mind the last time i saw this movie. thanks for the memory and the parallel conection in my consciousness.

  • @TJDOZIER1
    @TJDOZIER1 15 років тому

    Excellent. Best thing I've seen on youtube in a long time.

  • @abmackay
    @abmackay 15 років тому +1

    Man... even hearing the audio from this SW scene makes me smile, even after so many viewings. This video is dead-on though.

  • @ejvideos07
    @ejvideos07 8 років тому

    I love how you synced the R2D2 sounds with shots of the bomb aimer - laughed my arse off.

  • @Klamath2046
    @Klamath2046 16 років тому

    Truly wicked. I never considered just how similar these elements of those two films are until I saw this.

  • @plugs313
    @plugs313 16 років тому

    Oh! mygod!!!! that was absolutely masterful, a work of genius.

  • @malcs0
    @malcs0 13 років тому +2

    Actually, it's not just clever, some of it is quite inspired. The bit where Obi Wan Kenobi is telling Luke to "feel the force" is conveyed quite brilliantly with Richard Todd's facial expression beneath the mask changing as he hears the voice. Indeed, it is quite amazing how so many films have that type of premise and the same types of scene. Didn't Lucas admit that the Deathstar attack was somehow inspired by the Dambusters?

  • @txst8cat
    @txst8cat 16 років тому

    This video most definitely deserves its rating but it also deserves exponentially more views! This is brilliant.

  • @kwokwing
    @kwokwing 8 років тому +4

    Star war is unreal and dambusters is history.

    • @MothaLuva
      @MothaLuva 7 років тому +1

      How do you know?

  • @wayneralph945
    @wayneralph945 2 роки тому

    I've been saying this for years but the young ones have never seen this classic great.

  • @tangopapatp
    @tangopapatp 13 років тому

    Superb.
    And I love the comparison between R2 and the navigator/bombadier

  • @Pheonixfromtheshale
    @Pheonixfromtheshale 17 років тому +1

    I know where you're coming from Judge, but you're wrong on Spielberg - I saw an interview with him marking his 60th Birthday a while back, he cited 'The Cruel Sea' and 'The Dambusters' as two of the best war films ever made.
    You have to understand that it's the Sutdios (Fox, Paramount etc) who make films which are 'All American' because they believe that's the only audience and that's what they want!

  • @HenryvKeiper
    @HenryvKeiper  15 років тому +1

    There are some definite similarities besides scene composition. The part where the pilots read off their call-signs to let the leader know they're on cue is very similar to both Star Wars and the Dam Busters. Although you could argue that's just how a military unit would have done it, again the style of film making and the use of it is similar to both the films.

  • @Diego5
    @Diego5 15 років тому

    Outstanding. Masterful editing prowess.

  • @zedzedzed2
    @zedzedzed2 14 років тому

    superb! epic!bloody brilliant piece of editing work!

  • @wilmanric1
    @wilmanric1 14 років тому

    This is GREAT. Thanks for getting the clip from this classic old movie. And BTW, just in case anyone complains about the tracers from the light flak looking "Hokey" I have it on VERY good authority (a guy who flew Lancs in WWII) that light flak looked exactly like that....

  • @jocmccreary
    @jocmccreary 10 років тому

    Thanks for that. Just finished watching some clips from Dam Busters and found this - very very funny! Nice job.

  • @Pheonixfromtheshale
    @Pheonixfromtheshale 17 років тому

    Brilliant stuff there Henry - 5 stars.
    When the 1st Rough Cut of Star Wars was made in 1977, Lucas didn't have any of the Death Star/Trench Run sequence completed, so he spliced in bits of The Dambusters and Battle of Britain to make up the final combat sequence. Even when the final footage was completed, the influence of Dambusters is still there in the film.

  • @moxlox
    @moxlox 17 років тому

    The force is strong with you HenryvKeiper! Awesome! Made my evening! lol

  • @ZenMondo
    @ZenMondo 17 років тому

    I am a huge star wars fan, and am always happy to see some of Lucas' roots. So yeah lots of Kurosawa films, other sci fi influences like Dune and Foundation and everything Joseph Campbell wrote. So this just adds to it. Thank you. Gave you 5 stars!

  • @naughtypersian
    @naughtypersian 14 років тому

    This is great man. EPIC WIN! awesome job dude!

  • @sharkyjones
    @sharkyjones 10 років тому +2

    I understood Star wars trench run was based on the movie 633 squadron (and influenced by dambusters) would be interesting to see starwars with 633 squadron soundrtrack and Ron Goodwin's music!!

  • @jrssm
    @jrssm 17 років тому

    Cool! Good to see that he made a considerable cotribution to our success!

  • @N720MF
    @N720MF 17 років тому

    That was beyond outstanding. Well done.

  • @TK42100
    @TK42100 17 років тому

    The use of Red Leader's scream with the look on that Bombardier's face was hilarious as well.

  • @pronto355
    @pronto355 14 років тому

    THAT WAS BRILLIANT
    Loved both movies

  • @leopardbasement2915
    @leopardbasement2915 5 років тому

    3:30 the" use the force Luke" transition to resolve is quite majestic - well done :)

  • @greenseaships
    @greenseaships 16 років тому

    YOU DID THIS? YOURSELF??? OMFG!!! THIS IS HANDS DOWN THE FUNNIEST dam (hehe "Dam") thing I have ever seen on UA-cam. Funnier even than Chad Vader!
    Anyone who knows the upkeep missions AND Star Wars will fall out of their chairs at this. My hat is off you you man! Wish I had thought of this.

  • @alanhutchins5221
    @alanhutchins5221 4 роки тому +1

    ...May The Royal Air Force be with you.....

  • @HenryvKeiper
    @HenryvKeiper  17 років тому +1

    I didn't even know you had done something like that until after I uploaded this. It was inspired after I had seen it with my parents and told them how I had heard many people compare Star Wars to it. I wouldn't say I "copied" you, since you weren't the first to compare the two.

  • @ScreamingTc
    @ScreamingTc 16 років тому

    This is a slice of editing genius. I haven't been so amused in a long time.

  • @Soervin
    @Soervin 17 років тому

    Excellent made Henry! :)
    Couldn't stop laughing... the sounds were so awkward combined with the film but then again it fit so perfectly that it's almost scary.

  • @ChamplainValleyRailSnapshots
    @ChamplainValleyRailSnapshots 6 років тому

    This makes me chuckle! Love it!

  • @robertnorth9679
    @robertnorth9679 8 років тому

    Oh, that was such a hoot! Now let's see what can be done with Dr Stangelove!

  • @Eagle_the_18th
    @Eagle_the_18th 4 роки тому

    3:36 - 3:49 I love how the music and Obi Wan’s voice perfectly fit the scene

  • @joylunn3445
    @joylunn3445 5 років тому +1

    Also John Williams used many British composers themes.

  • @carbo73
    @carbo73 16 років тому +1

    Amazing. Extremely well done sound edition!! In fact, seen now, Star Wars is a complete copy to that Dambusters raid!

  • @MatlockJack
    @MatlockJack 14 років тому

    One of my neighbours was an RAF navigator during the war and had friends killed on the Dambusters Raid and on the successive raids the survivors were sent on thereafter. Real war, where soldiers don't get up when someone shouts 'cut'.

  • @lilwartorian
    @lilwartorian 15 років тому

    The audio reminds me of Airplane, where the jet made noise like a B-25, only the opposite. Well done.

  • @freakyflow
    @freakyflow 9 років тому +15

    Lucas and steven spielberg were big on taking WW2 and making movies or plots around it ..Like the two AAA gun towers on the dam same as the Laser Cannon towers on the death star "StormTroopers" ..Watto Long bent nose slave dealer that talks yiddish> Jewish? ewoks short had there land taken over by the empire> Chinese had there land taken over by the Imperial empire of Japan.. Jabba the hut Big fat slob that sat around and made orders to everyone not caring if his own men die ..(Luke falls in the trap door with 2 guards to the monster below) = Russians I.E. Stalin ordered His troops to fight Germans with or without guns and if they ran away from the German lines he had a reserve line to shoot any russian troops falling back and label them as cowards ..There are sooo many of these But its too long to list

  • @WeissVogel
    @WeissVogel 15 років тому

    Dam it indeed...Nice splicing! Can't stop smiling!

  • @shanemills3879
    @shanemills3879 2 роки тому

    I'd say the original Dambuster survivors who lived to see "Star Wars" would have been flattered by the comparison :)

  • @TroyOi
    @TroyOi 16 років тому

    Beautiful piece of work!
    By the way, I'd never heard of The Dambusters before, or of the whole story behind it... Just happened to find my way here after it was mentioned in an episode of the British version of the sitcom "The Office". Am eagerly looking for to Peter Jackson's remake.
    Anyway, thanks so much for the creative work.

  • @1701spacecadet
    @1701spacecadet 9 років тому

    Ok, this was totally brilliant!

  • @southlondon63
    @southlondon63 14 років тому

    fuck knows how you worked out or even thought of combining these 2 great movies but the result is brilliant

  • @bonzohart
    @bonzohart 17 років тому

    Absolutely brilliant! It also REALLY makes me want to see "Dam Busters." I know the story but have never seen the film. Masterful editing job, buddy!!

  • @HenryvKeiper
    @HenryvKeiper  16 років тому +1

    Ha ha, glad you enjoyed it. Unfortunately there weren't any fighters going after the Lancasters (well, FORTUNATELY for the RL guys) so I had to edit out Vader.

  • @RyanTheHero3
    @RyanTheHero3 6 років тому +1

    I feel a disturbance in the dam

  • @603mac
    @603mac 15 років тому +1

    "Luke,you've switched off your targeting computer!!" yeah that would be the stick with two nails in each end would it?Brilliant!

  • @Jabber-ig3iw
    @Jabber-ig3iw 4 роки тому

    The Star Wars Death Star attack is basically the script from dam busters with the visuals from 633 squadron. I love all 3.

  • @dave41184
    @dave41184 16 років тому

    Spot on Vogonford - is a well known fact that the battle sequences in the first star wars film are largely based on the 1955 Dambusters Movie

  • @stephenfocosi7075
    @stephenfocosi7075 5 років тому +1

    Thank you for letting me see the footage. I stand corrected. But did you check Dr. Strangelove as well? Just asking?

  • @charade97
    @charade97 14 років тому

    Well done. Tremendous job of work!

  • @FairlyFamousFilms
    @FairlyFamousFilms 9 років тому

    Very cleverly done. Good job. It raises the question; what element is most important to making an interesting movie scene? Is it cinematography, editing, pacing, or screenplay? Because all of those elements are in you video, and it's as gripping as the original of both films.

  • @jamesmasztalerz5930
    @jamesmasztalerz5930 Рік тому

    His computers off, Luke, you switched off your targeting computer what's wrong, nothing I'm alright

  • @RMSBoston1
    @RMSBoston1 13 років тому

    This is awesome....thank you so much!!!!! Haven't laughed this much in ages!

  • @samuraitim2
    @samuraitim2 16 років тому

    Two of my favorite movies. For all the technology, some things about combat are forever the same. Big difference though, the men who died in that WW 2 raid really died.

  • @jonnybottle
    @jonnybottle 16 років тому

    Hi Henry. You are hereby inducted into the ranks of the Mad Buggers. Great work ;0)!!

  • @ForsetiTemplarJaster13
    @ForsetiTemplarJaster13 10 років тому +3

    Well, Star wars was made after the shadow of WW2, so I'm certain it was inspired by it, at least the use of fighters are concern.

  • @Karagianis
    @Karagianis 16 років тому

    the Deathstar attack has got bits from three ww2 movies in it that I've seen, the Dam busters
    "I see about ten guns, some in the fields and some on the towers" and others.
    633 squadron for the trench run. and Guns of Navarone for that final set of shots dotted around the death star preparing to fire before it explodes at the last moment. :)

  • @merman1974
    @merman1974 17 років тому

    Superb piece of editing!