@mAnNyElLaTiNo33 Oh gosh, I love what she did with the key! So many C5s! Thank you so much for sharing. I will try to use all of these in my future Demi video. I bet it will be something like Demi, Miley and Jojo hehe =] Btw that F5 was spot on brilliant, love it.
when jojo was singing on stage, demi was still a little kid in her barnie show -_- 1. kelly clarkson - older and more experienced - AMERICAN IDOL duhhh. 2. jojo - dude she debuted at age 13.... 3. demi - still above average..but nowhere near kelly and jojo.
Where the fuck you even get that? Her high notes were shrill, too much lightness and nasality. I go for Demi her high notes were not even shrill as hers. Most of Jojo's high note performance were shrill.
Nice job! I thought visually you did very well & I liked the new effects with the picture &overlapping video :) However I thought you could've used better clips for all of them :P
you picked the most random notes for all three of them...anyway JoJo's my baby but Kelly is definitely the winner here. her voice is amazing!!!! Jojo is light years ahead of Demi tho
"Wherever there is a light, there are also shadows. As long as the concept of winning exists, there will be losers. The selfish desire of wanting to maintain the peace causes wars and hatred is born to protect love." We need to forget all the differences between us and remember that we are all humans...
I think their all talented. all of them need to work on something. JoJo and her high notes. Kelly and her control. and Demi and her hesitation. they are all great and they can all be compared equally. so please everyone, don't fight over who sings best. just be happy they are all good.
@stardusth2o Haha thanks. You're probably hearing the F#5 in it :D Only the "Breath" and "Sleep" are Eb5s. the "Hanging" is a F#5. And the performance is the BTHE live at the today show. :P
@mAnNyElLaTiNo33 To be honest, I just checked Tommi's live range notes for Demi's best. There were hardly any notes featured there and since I'm not an expert in Demi's live range myself I just went along with them thinking they were the best. I did see the C5 in your video but I had no idea where it was from. Regarding the E5 I chose the note that Demi rarely hits live. After going through quite a few live clips of Got Dynamite only did I find that and thought to give a proper use. [continued]
Ooooh i love how you made the video!!! Demi is princess of F5 and i dont kniw about Jojo.... First Kelly then Demi(even if i love her the most) and then Jojo But they're all great singers!!!
Ok. All three of these girls are drop dead gorgeous and MEGA talented so that's why this is a super hard decision. My favorite is easily Demi Lovato. But talent-wise, they all have separate but equal amounts of talent. I'd say they're easily the single most talent girls OF THEIR OWN GENERATION. And this is weird because JoJo and Demi are friends, and Demi idolizes Kelly, and Kelly loves Demi to death because they recently performed together live. I say they all win, but I love Demi the most :)
@mAnNyElLaTiNo33 Regarding the F5, I know there are far more sustained F5s in "Can't back down" but I just thought, this was a nice example for it seeing how it peaks at a F#5. Jojo has far better D5s in Leave (Get Out) but they are used in every video so i thought I should change it up. there are also great D5s in Too Little Too Late's accoustic cover but she only touches them and seeing how this was sort of resonante and sustained, i'd give it a chance. But by no means is her best D5.
can't hit a note above E? are u kidding me? have u heard of her song called "too little too late?" the part where she's like going above E5 and singing like there's no tomorrow. She actually sounds almost like christina aguilera hitting F5.. no offence but im just saying.
@BladeAndSoul Wow, haven't seen you post in any kelly videos for a while, where have you been :P. Actually Jojo and Demi have exactly the same range, only Demi has a far higher tessiture and more shaped technique. Jojo sort of makes for it with her unbeatable melisma and resonance. Jojo just belted a G#5 yesterday. Shame, if I heard it before I could've gone to a G#5.
The more i create these videos, the more I realize that people only vote for artists that have something currently selling or in the public eye. Screw everyone else.
@mAnNyElLaTiNo33 You're the second one to tell me that but nobody is telling me the worst notes lol. I'd love to know which of the ones I picked were bad as it seems every C5 from Jojo has a little Eb5 in it and Demi's D5's usually follow by E5s but then again, demi's D5 was pretty decent lol. Just tell me which note I should replace and I'll gladly will, when I revamp the video :P
actually... it's a battle between demi and kelly... jojo is great, but she can't hit a note above E.. kelly is older and has more experience than demi, so she's a bit better. but demi isn't that far away anymore.
@kellyclarksonismygod I agree with youwith JoJo, but as for Demi, her C5 from my video is from Cambio Cares "Remember December. As for E5 I agree as well. As for F5, she hit a GORGEOUS F5 in Here We Go Again at Wembley :)
@shortyeffect13 Glad you liked it :) Well, Demi and Jojo have very similar upper chest belting abilities. I'd say she's the queen of the E5 or F5, weird thing is, so is Jojo. Name a f5 from Demi and I will give an equally impressive F5 from Jojo and you'll see how they are in the same league.
@musicguy713 Well, even though Jojo and Demi don't have as much experience as Kelly, they are by NO means amatuers. But I see your point. Thanks for commenting. :)
god! they're all so talented! well, kelly and demi are my two most favorite vocalists ever, so i guess i pick them. jojo is amazing too, i just prefer the others. :)
of course for me it goes 1) Kelly Clarkson 2) Demi Lovato 3) Jojo. Demi has alot of potential, she is great and im a huge fan of hers but kelly has been doing this for 10 years and still surprices people everyday with what she can do with her vocals so yea :)
@TBarlow01 The hypocrisy in your comment is that Kelly has a bigger range than Demi. Another of Kelly's trademarks is that she's never off-key and neither is Jojo. Demi is also great at keeping track of her key.
This is MY opinion: JoJo has a good voice & range, but doesn't have a lot of control so she is off key sometimes. Kelly has control and is on key most of the time and a great voice, but she doesn't have as much range as some of the other artists and can sound monotone at time. Demi has great range, a great voice, great control, and hits all the notes on key. To me, she is the best. So, 1. Demi 2. Kelly 3. JoJo I love them all though and they're all fantastic singers!
@SetingSun I don't get it? Flat Fs? You mean F#s? Well, She does quite a few F sharp 5s, and I displayed them all in my video of Jojo great high notes. :] Demi's F sounds very supported although a bit throaty as she was sort of adding stamina to the performance. i personally LOVED it. Well, Kelly's F#5 even though they're not sustained are personally the best f#5s in "Yeah" so I figured I should use it, again love the ease on them. Hit in Neutral larynx. Jojo belted a G#5 yesterday.
That's because Demi suffered a lot when she was younger but she never gave up on her career! So when we see people saying bad things about her, we can't just keep quiet you know! Lovatics can do anything in order to protect her and see a happy smile on her face! We are super devoted fans!! Now I said that... you can hate us but please just don't hate Demi! This is one of the most unfair things you can do in life!
hmmm... Besides the fact that they use their voices diffrently for diffrent genres of music. I think Jojo's like a first alto at this point, while kelly is a second saprano, and so is demi. If i'm gonna compare, i'd take Jojo outta the running since she does mostly pop r&b.I'd have to rate demi as having more power in her range (which keeps her voice from sounding reedy, but is limiting in its own way), and Kelly as having more control (which allows her to use more of her range more often).
Demi is fucking 19 and she has less exprince than jojo and kelly and yet she is at their level - her voice is beautiful, powerful and pure ! SHE IS THE WINNER WITH NO DOUBT !
@SetingSun Really? Which notes? By no means am I critising your opinion I just want some feedback to improve my future videos. There's always room for improvement :)
Jojo, Kelly, Demi. Jojo kills all because she is amazing all around. Kelly is the idol of every generation. And I hate to judge Demi because of the eating disorder but if I had to, this would be my order.
Well, Jojo obviously has the most overall control, because her runs are always impeccable. She's all a musical genius, always reinventing songs, which I don't see the others doing as well as her. Jojo's low notes would beat both Kelly and Demi easy, seeing as she's a real contralto. Jojo also dominates in head voice extending up to an Eb6 live with a great tone. Kelly and Demi dominate with belts, but Kelly is more consistent and has a slightly better tone. Demi's vibrato needs some work is all.
@kellyclarksonismygod I didn't say anything mean.I like Kelly.Wasn't at ALL saying she isn't the best idol.Like her I JoJo and Kelly but Demi's mind-blowing
@kellyclarksonismygod I think Demi has better C5's, E5's, and F5's, I don't watch much JoJo but I think she has better D5's. And as for Kelly I think you should of used more of her sustained upper-chest notes. By the way Kelly wins this hahaha :)
@kellyclarksonismygod I really hate that. I'm a fan of all these talented females. Although Demi is my favorite, that doesn't cloud my judgment at all. I hate that people aren't able to put aside biases and judge objectively.
Demi... There all good but it's just Demi is amazing & more of my style, more edgy... :D then I would say Kelly is next, then Jojo... Jojo is really good, I just don't like the sound of her voice when she hits the high notes... My opinion...
Jojo is off key most of the time! She does too many rifts and fancy stuff that she can't hold a key properly. I adore Demi but the clear winner is Kelly, and Demi is very close second.
![Alicia Keys vs Kelly Clarkson Vocal Battle (Live) A4 - B5 [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4aRD5C_JFzg/mqdefault.jpg)
![Alicia Keys vs Kelly Clarkson Vocal Battle (Live) A4 - B5 [HD]](/img/tr.png)
![Kelly Clarkson: Best (Low/Belts/Head) Live Early 2011 F3 - C#6 [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XjwiQVmC16Q/mqdefault.jpg)
@mAnNyElLaTiNo33 Oh gosh, I love what she did with the key! So many C5s! Thank you so much for sharing. I will try to use all of these in my future Demi video. I bet it will be something like Demi, Miley and Jojo hehe =] Btw that F5 was spot on brilliant, love it.
when jojo was singing on stage, demi was still a little kid in her barnie show -_-
1. kelly clarkson - older and more experienced - AMERICAN IDOL duhhh.
2. jojo - dude she debuted at age 13....
3. demi - still above average..but nowhere near kelly and jojo.
Where the fuck you even get that? Her high notes were shrill, too much lightness and nasality. I go for Demi her high notes were not even shrill as hers. Most of Jojo's high note performance were shrill.
Thank you for posting this, it made my day to hear Kelly.
Nice job! I thought visually you did very well & I liked the new effects with the picture &overlapping video :) However I thought you could've used better clips for all of them :P
1.demi
2.kelly and jojo
you picked the most random notes for all three of them...anyway JoJo's my baby but Kelly is definitely the winner here. her voice is amazing!!!! Jojo is light years ahead of Demi tho
"Wherever there is a light, there are also shadows. As long as the concept of winning exists, there will be losers. The selfish desire of wanting to maintain the peace causes wars and hatred is born to protect love."
We need to forget all the differences between us and remember that we are all humans...
I think their all talented. all of them need to work on something. JoJo and her high notes. Kelly and her control. and Demi and her hesitation. they are all great and they can all be compared equally. so please everyone, don't fight over who sings best. just be happy they are all good.
During this time, JoJo voice was sick, and she got vocal support, and now she has a 2020 ALBUM! Her notes are executed perfectly.
OMG this video is so old 💙
demi can sing A5 and she peaked at Bb5
Demi and Kelly are clearly much better than Jojo, she doesn't know how to control her voice, and it sounds very shaky!
@stardusth2o Haha thanks. You're probably hearing the F#5 in it :D Only the "Breath" and "Sleep" are Eb5s. the "Hanging" is a F#5. And the performance is the BTHE live at the today show. :P
@mAnNyElLaTiNo33 To be honest, I just checked Tommi's live range notes for Demi's best. There were hardly any notes featured there and since I'm not an expert in Demi's live range myself I just went along with them thinking they were the best. I did see the C5 in your video but I had no idea where it was from. Regarding the E5 I chose the note that Demi rarely hits live. After going through quite a few live clips of Got Dynamite only did I find that and thought to give a proper use. [continued]
@ 3:22 , can someone please tell me what song is kelly singing?
Ooooh i love how you made the video!!!
Demi is princess of F5 and i dont kniw about Jojo....
First Kelly then Demi(even if i love her the most) and then Jojo
But they're all great singers!!!
@Fabiuguz That F#5 has been disproved. It's a F5 with short peaks in F#5.
Jojo...hands down!! Can't do better, she was a legend=']
Ok. All three of these girls are drop dead gorgeous and MEGA talented so that's why this is a super hard decision. My favorite is easily Demi Lovato. But talent-wise, they all have separate but equal amounts of talent. I'd say they're easily the single most talent girls OF THEIR OWN GENERATION. And this is weird because JoJo and Demi are friends, and Demi idolizes Kelly, and Kelly loves Demi to death because they recently performed together live. I say they all win, but I love Demi the most :)
@mAnNyElLaTiNo33 Regarding the F5, I know there are far more sustained F5s in "Can't back down" but I just thought, this was a nice example for it seeing how it peaks at a F#5. Jojo has far better D5s in Leave (Get Out) but they are used in every video so i thought I should change it up. there are also great D5s in Too Little Too Late's accoustic cover but she only touches them and seeing how this was sort of resonante and sustained, i'd give it a chance. But by no means is her best D5.
1. Kelly
2. Demi
3. Jojo
Love all three though. Pop stars that can actually sing!
@kellyclarksonismygod I know right! They're both fantastic performances :D & Very interesting, can't wait :)
@ElectrikkPaperClipxx hahahah a dying cat ! haha
woow.. All 3. Also my favorites!
can't hit a note above E? are u kidding me? have u heard of her song called "too little too late?" the part where she's like going above E5 and singing like there's no tomorrow. She actually sounds almost like christina aguilera hitting F5.. no offence but im just saying.
@BladeAndSoul Wow, haven't seen you post in any kelly videos for a while, where have you been :P. Actually Jojo and Demi have exactly the same range, only Demi has a far higher tessiture and more shaped technique. Jojo sort of makes for it with her unbeatable melisma and resonance.
Jojo just belted a G#5 yesterday. Shame, if I heard it before I could've gone to a G#5.
The more i create these videos, the more I realize that people only vote for artists that have something currently selling or in the public eye. Screw everyone else.
@mAnNyElLaTiNo33 You're the second one to tell me that but nobody is telling me the worst notes lol. I'd love to know which of the ones I picked were bad as it seems every C5 from Jojo has a little Eb5 in it and Demi's D5's usually follow by E5s but then again, demi's D5 was pretty decent lol. Just tell me which note I should replace and I'll gladly will, when I revamp the video :P
This is my opinion:
E3 - JoJo (+3) > Demi (+2) > Kelly (+1)
C5 - Kelly (+3) > Demi (+2) > JoJo (+1)
C#5 - Demi (+3) > Kelly (+2) > JoJo (+1)
D5 - Kelly (+3) > JoJo (+2) > Demi (+1)
Eb5 - Kelly (+3) > Demi (+2) > JoJo (+1)
E5 - Kelly (+3) > Demi (+2) > JoJo (+1)
F5 - Kelly (+3) > JoJo (+2) > Demi (+1)
F#5 - Kelly (+3) > Demi (+2) > JoJo (+1)
G5 - Kelly (+3) > Demi (+2) > JoJo (+1)
Kelly has 24 points, Demi has 17 points and JoJo has 13 points so Kelly > Demi > JoJo
actually... it's a battle between demi and kelly... jojo is great, but she can't hit a note above E.. kelly is older and has more experience than demi, so she's a bit better. but demi isn't that far away anymore.
@IceMoonPetal It was my pleasure =]
@kellyclarksonismygod I agree with youwith JoJo, but as for Demi, her C5 from my video is from Cambio Cares "Remember December. As for E5 I agree as well. As for F5, she hit a GORGEOUS F5 in Here We Go Again at Wembley :)
@shortyeffect13 Glad you liked it :) Well, Demi and Jojo have very similar upper chest belting abilities. I'd say she's the queen of the E5 or F5, weird thing is, so is Jojo. Name a f5 from Demi and I will give an equally impressive F5 from Jojo and you'll see how they are in the same league.
@musicguy713 Well, even though Jojo and Demi don't have as much experience as Kelly, they are by NO means amatuers. But I see your point. Thanks for commenting. :)
god! they're all so talented!
well, kelly and demi are my two most favorite vocalists ever, so i guess i pick them. jojo is amazing too, i just prefer the others. :)
of course for me it goes 1) Kelly Clarkson 2) Demi Lovato 3) Jojo. Demi has alot of potential, she is great and im a huge fan of hers but kelly has been doing this for 10 years and still surprices people everyday with what she can do with her vocals so yea :)
Francisco Vargas ❤
@TBarlow01 The hypocrisy in your comment is that Kelly has a bigger range than Demi. Another of Kelly's trademarks is that she's never off-key and neither is Jojo. Demi is also great at keeping track of her key.
This is MY opinion: JoJo has a good voice & range, but doesn't have a lot of control so she is off key sometimes. Kelly has control and is on key most of the time and a great voice, but she doesn't have as much range as some of the other artists and can sound monotone at time. Demi has great range, a great voice, great control, and hits all the notes on key. To me, she is the best. So,
1. Demi
2. Kelly
3. JoJo
I love them all though and they're all fantastic singers!
@SetingSun I don't get it? Flat Fs? You mean F#s? Well, She does quite a few F sharp 5s, and I displayed them all in my video of Jojo great high notes. :] Demi's F sounds very supported although a bit throaty as she was sort of adding stamina to the performance. i personally LOVED it. Well, Kelly's F#5 even though they're not sustained are personally the best f#5s in "Yeah" so I figured I should use it, again love the ease on them. Hit in Neutral larynx. Jojo belted a G#5 yesterday.
That's because Demi suffered a lot when she was younger but she never gave up on her career! So when we see people saying bad things about her, we can't just keep quiet you know! Lovatics can do anything in order to protect her and see a happy smile on her face! We are super devoted fans!!
Now I said that... you can hate us but please just don't hate Demi! This is one of the most unfair things you can do in life!
Well, Demi improved since this by a lot.
hmmm... Besides the fact that they use their voices diffrently for diffrent genres of music. I think Jojo's like a first alto at this point, while kelly is a second saprano, and so is demi. If i'm gonna compare, i'd take Jojo outta the running since she does mostly pop r&b.I'd have to rate demi as having more power in her range (which keeps her voice from sounding reedy, but is limiting in its own way), and Kelly as having more control (which allows her to use more of her range more often).
i don't know jojo sings so good!! great voice!! but my fave is demi!! so young and that voice together...WOW!!
Demi is fucking 19 and she has less exprince than jojo and kelly and yet she is at their level - her voice is beautiful, powerful and pure ! SHE IS THE WINNER WITH NO DOUBT !
@stardusth2o Oh, it was just in case. I knew it was unfair to leave the F#5 in >.< I didn't want anybody to get confused :P
DEMII
@SetingSun Really? Which notes? By no means am I critising your opinion I just want some feedback to improve my future videos. There's always room for improvement :)
Jojo, Kelly, Demi. Jojo kills all because she is amazing all around. Kelly is the idol of every generation. And I hate to judge Demi because of the eating disorder but if I had to, this would be my order.
Well, Jojo obviously has the most overall control, because her runs are always impeccable. She's all a musical genius, always reinventing songs, which I don't see the others doing as well as her. Jojo's low notes would beat both Kelly and Demi easy, seeing as she's a real contralto. Jojo also dominates in head voice extending up to an Eb6 live with a great tone. Kelly and Demi dominate with belts, but Kelly is more consistent and has a slightly better tone. Demi's vibrato needs some work is all.
Kelly, then Demi. But Demi is 18 years old, so she will reach Kelly's level (and more, IMO) when she's older.
Kelly wins, and she is the queen of the F#5. Jojo and Demi sing very well, but they have to develop their vocal abilities more.
@kellyclarksonismygod I didn't say anything mean.I like Kelly.Wasn't at ALL saying she isn't the best idol.Like her I JoJo and Kelly but Demi's mind-blowing
1- Kelly Clarkson
2- Demi Lovato
3- Jojo
actually demi's queen of a5 notes
also i hate it when people say someone has a better voice because of vabrado. That's not true you can have a great voice without vabrado
kelly owns both, she's not an amatuer. Jojo and Demi got alot of potential but still got some way's to go.
I can't choose D: THEY'RE ALL MY FAVOURITE!! haha :)
Jojo, Kelly, Demi. Jojo kills because she is so amazing falsetto and vebrato
LMAO!
JoJo then Demi then Kelly
@qqappleaa1 American idol doesn't always pick the best people so don't be too quick to say that
Im kellys bigest fan i love her songs
demi is the youngest one of them and I LOVE HER VOICE
@kellyclarksonismygod I think Demi has better C5's, E5's, and F5's, I don't watch much JoJo but I think she has better D5's. And as for Kelly I think you should of used more of her sustained upper-chest notes. By the way Kelly wins this hahaha :)
Kelly clarkson she the best girl singer ever i love her music like the song stronger and brake a way and walk away and more songs i pick kelly
The queen of the e5 is legendina godlera and buh Bionic on 11.11.13 watch your body and let
there be love
DEMI all the way!! She's not purging anymore and her voice is 100 xx more stronger!!!
1.Demi
2.JoJo
3.Kelly
Demi♥ JoJo♥ Kelly♥ :]
1. kelly/jojo
2. kelly/jojo
3. a dying cat
4. demi
I would consider JoJo queen of low notes!
Im kelly bigest fan i love her songs
@SetingSun It's absolutely gorgeous :]
@kellyclarksonismygod I really hate that. I'm a fan of all these talented females. Although Demi is my favorite, that doesn't cloud my judgment at all. I hate that people aren't able to put aside biases and judge objectively.
3 generations
it could be
Kelly , Jojo and Demi :)
they are all amazing singers but i prefer Demi :)
JoJo SLAYS both.
JoJo is the best ! you didnt even put jojo's best videos !
Demi... There all good but it's just Demi is amazing & more of my style, more edgy... :D then I would say Kelly is next, then Jojo... Jojo is really good, I just don't like the sound of her voice when she hits the high notes... My opinion...
demi lovato demi lovato demi lovato !!!!!!!!! WHAT AN AMAZING VOICE !!!!!
@kellyclarksonismygod Demi can actually hit a C#6 (in the song "You're My Only Shorty")....oh yea!! lol
@EDDsp2009 Well, see. I know Kelly's f#5 are amazing, I still think owns those Gs. Especially during the breakaway era.
try comparing demi now with her new vocal talent. just try.
kelly clarkson obviously
WT? I don't get it LOL
Kelly, Demi, Jojo
1.demi
2.kelly
3.jojo
@SetingSun Yea I did see that one & I think the Wembley one is MUCH better.
Kelly
Demi
.
.
.
.
.
Jojo
@daiell09 Thanks for commenting. =D
Jojo is off key most of the time! She does too many rifts and fancy stuff that she can't hold a key properly. I adore Demi but the clear winner is Kelly, and Demi is very close second.
Kelly Clarkson is perfect
*laughs at the people who listed demi as number 1*
Demi ♥
demi might be the F5 princess, but nowhere near to be the queen of A5.
DEMI DEMI DEMI DEMI DEMI DEMI DEMI :) I JUST LOVE HER
DEeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeemiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii loooooooooooooovvvvvvvvvvaaatooooooooooooooo
Demi Lovato For Sure
Stay Strong
JoJo.The End.