ua-cam.com/video/-6UeZNVKm6M/v-deo.html 💟💌✝️❤ 지옥은 쉼이없습니다 창조주 하나님의 성경말씀이 증거하는 오직 진리 구원자 예수님 믿고 회개하여 죄사함받아 사탄마귀귀신우상 지옥사망영벌 에서 벗어나 하나님의자녀로 예수님의신부로 영생복락천국 누리시길 예수님이름으로 축복합니다 성경 요한계시록 예언의말씀 대로 예수님께서 이땅의 심판주로 곧 오십니다 십자가로 성경으로 돌아갑시다 죽음후에는 심판이있습니다
@@edenpffen What? Why can't she bring it up? She's honouring Sulli's memory and telling her to rest peacefully. She didn't say anything wrong. By telling people not to mention Sulli, you will make them forget her... there's nothing wrong with keeping a beautiful memory of Sulli alive.
@@SMAnthonyW There's nothing wrong with keeping Sulli's memory alive, I completely agree with that. However, it's annoying to constantly bring her up by mentioning her death. We should remember her for how she was when she was alive. Not constantly remember her because she died. Op can comment that Sulli should rest peacefully, but op, and others, don't need to bring her death into every conversation.
10 years later, I've just found this after Sulli's gone. I used to watch their MV for million times when I was 19-20. I miss the old days. I miss you guys, f(x).
Even without makeup and with sweat all over their faces, I think they still looked fresh and cute! And gosh, they looked so young, especially Vic, you can't tell that she's like 6 years apart from Amber, who is the oldest among the rest. WOW! f(x) DAEBAK!!!
Sulli, we miss you and we still love you. We will never forget you no matter what and no matter where you are, you will always be in our heart and mind. You did well Sulli, you can rest now. Rest in peace our beautiful innocent sweet angel giant baby Choi Jin Ri
다들 밝고 즐거워보여서 이 시점에서 보니까 참 씁쓸하네... ㅠㅠ 인생은 정말 한치 앞도 알 수가 없다. 데뷔한다고 얼마나 설렜을까? 생기 넘치는 모습들 보니까 참ㅠㅠ 굳이 연예인들 뿐만 아니라 일반 사람들도 다 똑같겠지? 다들 초심이 있고 설렘이 있던 시기 생기가 넘치고 의지와 희망이 있던 시기들이 있었을텐데ㅠㅠ 진리 씨 편안하게 쉬세요.
Amber looks soooooo pretty from 1:45 to the end. i mean she does the whole thing but like she shines at the end. fun to see the girls working hard. ^-^
Victoria: Flexible and great dancer Krystal: Amazing voice Sulli: The cutest of them all Luna: So pretty and good voice Amber: She's got style man! = F(x)
Omg! So young! 😥😥😥 sometimes I wonder if stanning these young idols is right thing for me to do. Looking back into the past (I've been a kpop fan for more than 10 years), I didn't notice that they were children put to work long hours just for the applause while their companies get richer and richer... after Sulli and Jonghyun's tragic lost, it feels like mere explotation. It doesn't matter if there's a troupe of fans loving them since the amount of wrong exposure and hate they receive is out of this world... Sure, idols get a lot from fame and popularity, but what's the value of it if they are miserable most of the time...
quiaan agree, i’ve been following kpop idols for 9 years, it’s kind of sad that we as a fan get to growing up happily listen their music but they are actually suffering all these years😭
I completely agree! Its insane to sign children as young as 10 then put them through so much excruciating training, combined with ridiculous rules that should absolutely be illegal, for anywhere between 4-10 years, then make them debut (if they’re lucky) and put them through 20+hour work days 7 days a week only to not pay them hardly anything!! I’ve only been into kpop the last couple years and as someone from the west I’m used to celebrities, even teen celebs, being at _least_ upper-middle class wealthy, if not actually being quite rich. So when I learned by watching so many idols struggle even ones who are very popular I was shoooooook. Its a complete scam!! Like just recently on the show queendom, there was a situation where hyejeong from aoa and Minnie from gidle was having trouble with a song and a producer said he could do it for $80, minnies face was reallyy sad and she was like “I don’t have any money”. It seemed a bit deeper than “I don’t have any money with me”. On top of all that they have to deal with the public and media and fans it’s heartbreaking. They can’t even have fun at any kind of event with other idols, they can’t enjoy each others music, they can’t even date because they’re “already taken” by their insane fans who don’t give a fuck about the artists well being and happiness, they can’t even have fucking _cell phones_ or social media accounts_without *permission* from the company and even then they’re monitored like prisoners. It should be illegal for the companies to ban them from having phones. I haven’t even gotten to the worst part which is the mental and physical abuse they have to endure during all this. Even the people who are supposed to help make it worse for them. Poor jonghyun went to his psychologist bc of his depression and was told that it’s his own fault because of the way he was. Poor Sulli was treated like a dart board for everyone to throw their hatred at for no fucking reason. Most of the time I fucking hate this world so much.
@@meowzy2439 you're right! This is a whole new level of slavery from which we're feeding of, that's why when we as fans are struck by tragic news about the idols we like or know, it's impossible to avoid some kind of accountability for being just a bystander.
I know right! 😢 I totally agree! I've been thinking the same thing since I realized how demanding and exploitative the kpop industry really is. Isn't it child labor? Sulli was 15 and Krystal 14 years old! The same happens with many other idols, with many other children, who start training from a very young age 😔
Yes!!! I've been following K-pop for about 10 years as well and I definitely didn't realize back then that they were kids as I'm the same age as Krystal. When F(x) debuted in 2009 I looked up to them and fantasized of becoming an idol myself. I guess that's why they choose children because they lack the wisdom to realize that they are being exploited for money. It's so disgusting they do these things and I wish their parents didn't sell off their kids to these greedy companies!
![[Fx f (x)] - The first wisdom teeth @ Popular Inkigayo 130728](/img/n.gif)
2019 : UA-cam Recommendation
Here We Go
Wow funny and really original -_-
와 옛날영상보니꺼 진짜 다 다르게 생긴 에스엠상이다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그중가장 빛나는 진리 ㅠㅠ 그곳에선 평온하길
Rest in peace 진리....
ua-cam.com/video/-6UeZNVKm6M/v-deo.html
💟💌✝️❤
지옥은 쉼이없습니다 창조주 하나님의 성경말씀이 증거하는 오직 진리 구원자 예수님 믿고 회개하여 죄사함받아 사탄마귀귀신우상 지옥사망영벌 에서 벗어나 하나님의자녀로 예수님의신부로 영생복락천국 누리시길 예수님이름으로 축복합니다 성경 요한계시록 예언의말씀 대로 예수님께서 이땅의 심판주로 곧 오십니다 십자가로 성경으로 돌아갑시다 죽음후에는 심판이있습니다
설크 조합 이제 더 못 본다는게 진짜 ㅠ
Sulli i'm sorry the world didn't treat you right..rest peacefully
I miss Jinri too, but please don’t bring that up here.
Lets let her rest in peace. Please don't mention it.
@@edenpffen What? Why can't she bring it up? She's honouring Sulli's memory and telling her to rest peacefully. She didn't say anything wrong. By telling people not to mention Sulli, you will make them forget her... there's nothing wrong with keeping a beautiful memory of Sulli alive.
@@SMAnthonyW There's nothing wrong with keeping Sulli's memory alive, I completely agree with that. However, it's annoying to constantly bring her up by mentioning her death. We should remember her for how she was when she was alive. Not constantly remember her because she died. Op can comment that Sulli should rest peacefully, but op, and others, don't need to bring her death into every conversation.
I miss her too❤
진짜 유튜브 알고리즘 너무 신기해.. 진리야 우리 모두가 너를 기억해 너가 얼마나 용감했었고 빛났던걸
어리고 어린 날들...
데뷔 할 날 기다리며 땀흘리며 열심히 했을텐데... 얼마나 힘들었을까
one of the few kpop groups who are not afraid to show their faces on camera WITHOUT MAKEUP but still look so pretty!
They all are natural beauties
Yup ✨
이놈의 유투브 알고리즘..,, 왜 자꾸 띄워줘 뜰때마다 눌러서 보게되고 맘아파지잖아..
00:34 와씨 순간 너무 예뻐서 깜놀했네ㅠ 수정이 존예ㅜㅜ엉엉
꾸미고찍는것보다 저모습이 더이쁜듯ㄷㄷㄷㄷㅌㄷㄷ
나도 저부분 진자 헉소리 나오더라 와...이게 모태미녀의 아우라 라는건가
Cg처럼 예쁘다,,,,,,,,, 와우
You are right 100%
Yes, it’s time for f(x) content marathon. Was supposed to study, but here I am (zero regrets)💜
맑은 영혼 진리야 사랑해
RIP Sulli..We miss you so much..😭😭😭
f(x) is timeless, i will forever be a MeU 💜
어떻해서든 이겨내고 잘 되면 살아남고
안 되면.., ㅜㅜ
사회적 물의외엔 피해 없는이상 모라 하지 맙시다.
설리가 고등학교 2학년? 내지는 3학년 재학 중일때 실물을 본적 있었는데 진짜 억 소리가 절로 나올 정도로 예쁘더라.
그리고 같은 소속사 이연희 보고 기절할뻔 함
복숭아 설리 이제 좋은 곳 가서 쉬어요
RIP sulli this world didnt deserve you
이거 진짜 오랜만에 본다... 추억 넘쳐
10 years later, I've just found this after Sulli's gone. I used to watch their MV for million times when I was 19-20. I miss the old days. I miss you guys, f(x).
울 언니들 웃는거 넘이쁘다
보고싶다… 단체사진 한번만이라도 꼭보고싶다
0:54 초 쯤에 설리 분위기 좀 봐.. 진짜 너무 아름답다
Sulli!!! So beautiful and natural beauty as always...... doesn't need a make up anymore...
vic umma is a good dancer!!! please we need more dances for vic!!!
Even without makeup and with sweat all over their faces, I think they still looked fresh and cute! And gosh, they looked so young, especially Vic, you can't tell that she's like 6 years apart from Amber, who is the oldest among the rest. WOW!
f(x) DAEBAK!!!
f(5) i'm crying cuz i'm seeing sulli and i'm hearing her voice
f(4) and sulli Fighting~
This really hurts now 😞😞😞
뉴진스 보니까이때 이감성 생각나서 달려왔네 ㅜ 그립다..
They were truly the queens
f(x) being so little and tired and sweaty in the beginning really hit me in the feels
Sulli, we miss you and we still love you. We will never forget you no matter what and no matter where you are, you will always be in our heart and mind. You did well Sulli, you can rest now. Rest in peace our beautiful innocent sweet angel giant baby Choi Jin Ri
OMG VICTORIA WITHOUT MAKE-UPS......THERES LITERALLY NO DIFFERENCE!! I LOVE YOU!
설리야 보고싶어 ㅠ
so sad F(x) doesn't have solo concert and official fandom yet! come on SM! they're all talented to be underrated.
아..저때로 시간돌려줘
진리야 진짜 보고싶다 웃는 모습이 이젠 슬픈데 그거조차 너한테 죄짓는 것 같아서 어떡해해야할지 모르겠어 그냥 많이 사랑한다고 말해줄래
My babies, they were so young and cute. They deserve more :( I'm still here girls, always for you and our angel♡
울 웅니들..ㅠㅠ 데뷔 해줘서 고마워요..정말로…
what's with this UA-cam recommending 10 years-old video again?
i'm not even hating it... but due to recent event it makes me sad😭😭
gosh, krystal looks the same from then to now
totally!
cause she's a vampire
100% you are right.. Even now in Police University when she worn school uniform.. Like the same when they used to perform with that costume..
Omg what a true beauty even without make up
*POOR SULLI :( YOU COULD TELL SHE FOUND TRAINING THE MOST DIFFICULT OUT OF ALL OF THEM AND NOW ITS POINTLESS CAUSE SHE HAD TO LEAVE FX :(*
and now she’s dead..
@@kangseulgiisseulgibear1593 can you not?
@@yestoday1073 ok
F(x)
Miss them. So so much
Luna looks so prettyy..
SM you will pay for what you did to these girls
이영상 유독 왤케 마음이 아프지 보고싶다 에프엑스 모두
SM best girl group concept ever.
I really miss this SM old youtube channel
This vibe 🔥❤ As a baby kpop stan nowadays lesserafim documentary and babymonster evolution taking this vibe videos ❤
데뷔초 에프엑스는 지금봐도 벅차네
너무 좋고... 내가 처음으로 사랑에 흠뻑 빠지게 한 그룹임..
They look prettier without makeup
언니들 너무 이쁘다... 10년전 영상인데 다들 너무 이쁘다...
the day when soo man daddy still the head leader.... and now when he left sm.. its horrible..... #weneedsooman
He still in SM. But now is not he the ""leader""
+Taeng Kim yeah he stepped down
yeah, bring back mr. soo man
lee soo man stepped down????
+Tharumi The BTS stylist noona-to-be he is still the founder but no longer the ceo
설리야...다섯 다 소중해 너무
마음이 너무 아프다 정말
어유ㅠㅠㅠ 빅토리아 진짜 너무 이쁘다..
My always-smiling-no-matter-what eye smile princess, sulli T-T Missing f(x) so muuuch
Wahh I love these girls
they all look so pretty and natural even in rehearsals
♥ amber!
다들 밝고 즐거워보여서 이 시점에서 보니까 참 씁쓸하네... ㅠㅠ 인생은 정말 한치 앞도 알 수가 없다. 데뷔한다고 얼마나 설렜을까? 생기 넘치는 모습들 보니까 참ㅠㅠ 굳이 연예인들 뿐만 아니라 일반 사람들도 다 똑같겠지? 다들 초심이 있고 설렘이 있던 시기 생기가 넘치고 의지와 희망이 있던 시기들이 있었을텐데ㅠㅠ 진리 씨 편안하게 쉬세요.
설리누나 예뻤다.. 하아 나쁜 악플러들!
보고싶다
Amber looks soooooo pretty from 1:45 to the end. i mean she does the whole thing but like she shines at the end.
fun to see the girls working hard. ^-^
Sulli. I really miss you.
Fly high ❤
MeU forever
Victoria: Flexible and great dancer
Krystal: Amazing voice
Sulli: The cutest of them all
Luna: So pretty and good voice
Amber: She's got style man!
=
F(x)
miss you all.
요즘 입덕한 팬들은 모르는 저 연습실... 추억이다
지금도 있긴있어요
연습생들만 쓰는 연습실인듯 엔씨티 데뷔전에 찍은거 있어요
Love f(x) so much always and forever.
5 talented star ever ☆☆☆☆☆
Before coming back, I can only watch these old videos😂😂😂
same
Hi I'm still waiting for f(x) cb in 2019 😭
whatever_ voyez yo same here
There is no coming back 💔
Same!
I miss my babies so much I'm crying
Why does UA-cam recommend this to me?
저렇게 밝았던 아이가.....
하늘에선 항상 행복하길
I love you Sulli 💜
The real fact The Legend Queen f(x) the best everything always and forever.
forever f(x). forever meU. i love these 5 girls forever and ever
와 크리스탈 개이뻐...
THE BEST GIRL GROUP FOREVER AND EVER. #MeU 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Omg! So young! 😥😥😥 sometimes I wonder if stanning these young idols is right thing for me to do. Looking back into the past (I've been a kpop fan for more than 10 years), I didn't notice that they were children put to work long hours just for the applause while their companies get richer and richer... after Sulli and Jonghyun's tragic lost, it feels like mere explotation. It doesn't matter if there's a troupe of fans loving them since the amount of wrong exposure and hate they receive is out of this world... Sure, idols get a lot from fame and popularity, but what's the value of it if they are miserable most of the time...
quiaan agree, i’ve been following kpop idols for 9 years, it’s kind of sad that we as a fan get to growing up happily listen their music but they are actually suffering all these years😭
I completely agree! Its insane to sign children as young as 10 then put them through so much excruciating training, combined with ridiculous rules that should absolutely be illegal, for anywhere between 4-10 years, then make them debut (if they’re lucky) and put them through 20+hour work days 7 days a week only to not pay them hardly anything!!
I’ve only been into kpop the last couple years and as someone from the west I’m used to celebrities, even teen celebs, being at _least_ upper-middle class wealthy, if not actually being quite rich.
So when I learned by watching so many idols struggle even ones who are very popular I was shoooooook. Its a complete scam!! Like just recently on the show queendom, there was a situation where hyejeong from aoa and Minnie from gidle was having trouble with a song and a producer said he could do it for $80, minnies face was reallyy sad and she was like “I don’t have any money”. It seemed a bit deeper than “I don’t have any money with me”.
On top of all that they have to deal with the public and media and fans it’s heartbreaking. They can’t even have fun at any kind of event with other idols, they can’t enjoy each others music, they can’t even date because they’re “already taken” by their insane fans who don’t give a fuck about the artists well being and happiness, they can’t even have fucking _cell phones_ or social media accounts_without *permission* from the company and even then they’re monitored like prisoners. It should be illegal for the companies to ban them from having phones.
I haven’t even gotten to the worst part which is the mental and physical abuse they have to endure during all this. Even the people who are supposed to help make it worse for them. Poor jonghyun went to his psychologist bc of his depression and was told that it’s his own fault because of the way he was. Poor Sulli was treated like a dart board for everyone to throw their hatred at for no fucking reason. Most of the time I fucking hate this world so much.
@@meowzy2439 you're right! This is a whole new level of slavery from which we're feeding of, that's why when we as fans are struck by tragic news about the idols we like or know, it's impossible to avoid some kind of accountability for being just a bystander.
I know right! 😢 I totally agree! I've been thinking the same thing since I realized how demanding and exploitative the kpop industry really is. Isn't it child labor? Sulli was 15 and Krystal 14 years old! The same happens with many other idols, with many other children, who start training from a very young age 😔
Yes!!! I've been following K-pop for about 10 years as well and I definitely didn't realize back then that they were kids as I'm the same age as Krystal. When F(x) debuted in 2009 I looked up to them and fantasized of becoming an idol myself. I guess that's why they choose children because they lack the wisdom to realize that they are being exploited for money. It's so disgusting they do these things and I wish their parents didn't sell off their kids to these greedy companies!
i love how everyone is wearing tights and amber is wearing sweats.
Miss u, Sulli!
1:02 is so precious like wtf why is it so short?!?!?!?! who edited this video?
IKR SO SHORT WTF
Right! I can't believe that I'm still angry about the amount of camera time Amber didn't get back then here in 2016 XD
와...대박 라차타때라니..진짜 신인일때네. 풋풋하다 ㅠㅠ 그리고 진짜 다들 어리구나..저때가 설리,수정언니 15살?? 미텼네
Sulli becomes an angel, looking down the world happily.
Wow they have grown so much since their debut. So proud of them :)
2020 anyone ?
YAAASSS!!! loving f(x) since 2011 when I started to like kpop
2021!
Please comeback f(x)
유튜브 사람 심란하게 하쥬
f(x) forever! Saranghaeyo! ♥ Fighting!
She was always smiling even if it was hard 😔
Victoria so pretty no.1 face
HAPPY 7 YEARS OF F(X)
파이팅,에프엑스~~~사랑해！！！
awh amber looks so cute with her pony tail and hot with the black outfit
1:18 maknaes
Sulli aa... I miss you so much, i hope we can meet again
why sm channel dont have fx`s dance practice? (sorry for my english)
+Aline Cruz same I'm a little mad about it
SM don't like dance practice?
Red Velvet also has very little videos.
Ikr not even nct limitless not even boA's camo 😭😭😭
We only had gangsta boy
For snsd also. Most of the dance practice are uploaded by fans or from vlive
Did anybody notice at 0:56 someone was translating for amber?
YES HAHA WAS JUST ABOUT TO COMMENT ABOUT THAT
Looks like Victoria too.
Shreya 사랑해 BTS whoaa
It's nice seeing them work hard for the debut ^_^
Can't wait till their full album comes out~!
Amber looked so girly when she did some photoshoots.
I really love how Sulli and Krystal put their hair down like that.
I MISS THEM SO MUCH