Agree, and you should check ateez, they always have intense chreos and still sing live, their main vocalist jongho is the best among 4th gens and one of the best in the industry, they're known as performance kings
The blueprint for most kpop girl groups these days. Girl crush, pop electric sound with colorful, flashy outfits and set design. Nobody could ever replace Fx!
They had such loud fan chant already for debut performance because they were super anticipated! Especially coming from SM. They had a lot of hype going for them and I remember clearly how eager fans were for their debut! And they really delivered through this this debut performance! Stable vocals, STRONG dance! Such talented hard working ladies! And RIP to the beautiful Sulli 😞🤍
이거 아마 찐데뷔 무대였던거 같은데 이걸 본방으로 본 기억이 남 새록새록하네 글구 난 이걸보고 빅송에게 입덕해버려찌.. 송치엔언냐.. 내가 첨으로 사랑한 외국인이야 ㅜ 마오쩌뚱 다음으로 이름 기억한 중국인 ㅜㅜ 나 쿤토리아에도 진심이었다 ㅜ 실물 한번을 못보고 중국으로 보내버렸어 따흑
Where it all started, brb I need some tissues!😢😢😢😭😭😭😭 I'm so immensely proud of F(x) for coming so far in their career. Sure, these past years haven't been the best but they've still improved and have tried out different styles and have given us great music. They've grown up so well! :') I hope that we, as F(x) fandom, can continue to support our girls for more years to come. :') F(x) fighting!!!!!!
f (x) will always be 5 to me ♡ I will support these girls until the ends of time. Though to me Jinri will always be f (x), I look foward to Jinri the actress & of course f (x)'s future activities.
found myself listening to this more and more lately. It’s always good to remember how far Kpop has come because of the foundation that f(x) contributed to MASSIVELY. Thank you f(x) for paving the way! And thank you Sulli, you did great💙
2018..... it's been 9 years since this day this was filmed, it's been 4 years with the 5 of them on the same stage, it's been 3 years since the group's last release & every day it breaks MeUs hearts 💜
보고싶어 설리야.. 옛날에 이 무대를 처음 봤을땐 어른같고 멋있어보였는데 지금 보니 너무 어리고 아기같아서 짠하다.. 보고싶어 정말로
See that. Idols can sing live even with hard choreo. This is the reason why 2nd gen is the best. They pour passion in their performances
Agree, and you should check ateez, they always have intense chreos and still sing live, their main vocalist jongho is the best among 4th gens and one of the best in the industry, they're known as performance kings
Definitely agree and I was lucky enough to grow up in that era
지금아이돌에게는 없는 그 감성이있음.. .그룹마다 매력쩔엇는데ㅜ
에프엑스 감성은 이때도 없는 것 같음
풉
@@user-ve5wd5js3s 잼민이ㅎㅇ
그놈의 갬성타령 ㅋ ㅋ
이게 노래냐?? 딴따라지??
라떼는 서편제 별주부전 들었다
니들이 그 갬성을 아냐??
@성이름-n9g5l그쵸 유럽 걸그룹느낌
왜 이제 이거보면 슬프지............멤버들 이마에 맺힌 땀들이 슬프다
The blueprint for most kpop girl groups these days. Girl crush, pop electric sound with colorful, flashy outfits and set design. Nobody could ever replace Fx!
Dong forget about aesthetic mv
내기준 여돌 데뷔곡 탑3안에 든다... 진짜 그당시에 어찌나 좋아했던지... 지금 들어도 레전드..
ㅇㅈ
나머지 두곡은 뭔가요?
@@우춘남-h8k 다만세는 무조건ㅇ일 거 같습니다.
에프엑스 최애는 누에삐요 아닌가요
내기준 ㅋㄱ
@@우춘남-h8ksnsd - into the new world, 2ne1 - fire
그립다 에프엑스.... 실력과 재능..외모와 스타성,귀티,유니크함 어느것 하나 빠지는 것 하나 없는 그룹이었다... 항상 내 맘 속에 있어...에프엑스는 대체가 안됨.... 항상 신선하고 새롭고 예뻤어서......
다들 땀 흘리면서도 웃으면서 춤추는거 너무 예쁘다
이 노래 언제 질릴까 들을때마다 새롭다
At least amber can see us now.
@you tube aha, look at her bangs, it's totally cover her eyes
😂😂😂
LMFAOOO 💀
걍 존나 벅차서 찾아옴 민희진과 에프엑스는 전설이다
ㅇㅈ
Yes ped* min hee jin has tendency sticking to young girls 😊😊
wow.... they all grew up so much omg. Sulli and Krystal were like 14 here omg
Sulli was 15 and Krystal was 14 but was about to turn 15 on October.
they all were so young tho. Luna was 16 and Amber being the second oldest was only 17, Vic was the only who was over 20
신인때의 반짝거림이 너무 이쁘다..... 애들 진짜 어렸네ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
설리진짜귀엽다…..
So loud the fanchants used to be.. f(x) first perform..wooaaa u can't imagine how much tissues i used. Haters why did you made sulli leave
MEU haters did not make Sulli leave. She left to concentrate on her acting. She was a child actress in a Kdrama
Now the haters had made her leave for good 😭😭😭😭
god this comment hits worse after
우리애기 설리.. 진짜 애기야
victoria, so pretty...
Victoria song is pretty and beautiful and pretty ❤️
크리스탈이 제시카 동생이라고 했을때
친구들도 다 윤아가 아니라 제시카고?
하면서 엄청 놀랬는데ㅋㅋ
윤아랑 너무 똑띠 닮았는데
언니는 제시카래ㅋㅋㅋ
거짓말인줄ㅋ ㅋ 아무리봐도 윤아였는데ㅋ
유리도 닮았음 ㅋㅋ 유리,윤아 섞어놓은 느낌
라차타는 이 무대가 레전드
14주년 축하해 🎉❤❤❤❤❤
They had such loud fan chant already for debut performance because they were super anticipated! Especially coming from SM. They had a lot of hype going for them and I remember clearly how eager fans were for their debut! And they really delivered through this this debut performance! Stable vocals, STRONG dance! Such talented hard working ladies! And RIP to the beautiful Sulli 😞🤍
지금봐도 도입부 발차기 안무는 레전드...ㅋㅋ 빡세게하면서 합 맞는거봐 ㅎ
스타일도. 노래도 세련됨
설리다
첨에 뮤비보고 진짜 깜짝 놀랬는데
쌩신인의 쌩라이브 미쳤음....다들 너무 반짝이네ㅠㅠㅠ
Amber with that emo hair 😂
crescent loona ikr
lmaoo
이거 아마 찐데뷔 무대였던거 같은데 이걸 본방으로 본 기억이 남 새록새록하네 글구 난 이걸보고 빅송에게 입덕해버려찌.. 송치엔언냐.. 내가 첨으로 사랑한 외국인이야 ㅜ 마오쩌뚱 다음으로 이름 기억한 중국인 ㅜㅜ 나 쿤토리아에도 진심이었다 ㅜ 실물 한번을 못보고 중국으로 보내버렸어 따흑
다시는 볼수 없어 더욱 빛나 보일수도 있겠지만 그시절 반짝이던 아름다운 사람들.
의상도 좋고 라이브도 좋고 안무랑 노래도 좋고 그냥 매번 볼때마다 질리지가 않는다...
The best girl group debut performance, hands down. I miss F(x) 😢❤
설리 그리워서 찾아옴ㅠㅠ
who's watching this in 2016?
f(x) slayed me since 2009
I only discovered f (x) a year ago but I have been obsessed with them ever since.
me too, seven years
XD what I noticed was f(sweat) like dang girls XD
2018 and forever 💜
2018
rest in peace Sulli. We will never forget you. In the other world, hope you have a peaceful life and you can do whatever you like! Love Sulli
다들 반짝반짝 하다~~~ 에펙스 11주년 추카해 💜💜💜✨
10 years passed like a wind. Thank you for all, girls!
We miss you, Sulli!
난 라차타가 젤 좋더라
이방송보고 설리정말이뻤는데.. 그때 이뻤던게
아직도 생각나고 내가 생각한 연옌중에 너가 젤 이뻐서 계속 찾아오게되네
에프엑스 15주년 축하해
빅토리아 엠버 루나 설리 크리스탈
5명 모두 다 사랑해💜🎉
설리님 보고싶어요ㅠㅠㅠ
옛날에 이무대 올랐을 때 그립네요ㅠㅠ
지금도 보고싶어요ㅠㅠㅠ
2:23 배운거 땀흘리면서 보여주는거 보니까 왜이리슬프냐
This is called natural beauty!!
i love amber’s outfit in this and i wanna wear it
하튼 퓨어한 10대 감성 ㅈㄴ 잘살린다니까 어린애들 세련미
엠버 쩔어 이 노래 진짜 좋아했다 춤도
진짜 독보적이구만
It's their debut stage and their Vocals was stable. One of the best Girl Group ever Exist
루나가 노래가 아니라 춤으로 들어온게 맞네 ㅋㅋㅋ 1:58초 센터 잘춤 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Where it all started, brb I need some tissues!😢😢😢😭😭😭😭 I'm so immensely proud of F(x) for coming so far in their career. Sure, these past years haven't been the best but they've still improved and have tried out different styles and have given us great music. They've grown up so well! :') I hope that we, as F(x) fandom, can continue to support our girls for more years to come. :') F(x) fighting!!!!!!
I will miss you Sulli :c #ThankYouSulli
대한민국3세대아이돌
I love them all so much ! T.T
Victoria looks so good here 😍
-
I miss 2nd generation girl groups they were the best....
설리가 살아있었든 여행을 떠났든 더이상 완전체 fx로 환상적으로 매료되는 라차타 무대를 못본다는게 한이고 안타깝다..
어렸을때 나와서 지금 고1인 내가 이런데..
데뷔때부터 fx팬이었던 분들은 오죽할까...ㅜㅜ
2:10 Krystal's vocal so strong...😍
Victoria is so beautiful
Still hoping and waiting for the day when kpop can be like this again... 😢
Miss Sulli , Rest In Peace :(
다들 땀 엄청 흘리네 진짜 빛나고 이쁘다 저 때 내 시절도 생각나고,, 뭔가 기분 묘함
이런 환경에서도 최선을 다하는데 요즘은 진짜 배가 불렀나😮💨
The impeccable live vocals from a rookie group are incomparable!
설리.... 눈물난다...
크리스탈 의상 넘 이뻤는데 지금봐도 하나도 안촌스럽고 고급지다
그리운 애프엑스..
f (x) will always be 5 to me ♡ I will support these girls until the ends of time. Though to me Jinri will always be f (x), I look foward to Jinri the actress & of course f (x)'s future activities.
Vic post the image from this day. Ah the good memories. Rest well, Sulli. We love you, forever.
Wow. They are actually singing!
예전 에스엠 걸그룹은 지금 봐도 촌스러운 느낌이 없어
At least Sulli always smile, and live in our hearts ❤️🌸👸🏻. Ever-lasting queen, my bae 🌱
요즘 fx랑 느낌 비슷하고 설리랑 닮은 멤버보니 생각나서 보러왔는데 설리가 너무 반짝반짝해보이고 너무 예뻐. 저웃음 지켜줬어야 했는데..
May the soul of Sulli be in happiness and never ending peace. Much love to our angel Sulli❤️
this is their first debut and the fan chant extraordinary!!!!
Best Debut EVER 💜💜💜💜💜
설리 보고 싶다ㅠㅠ
이때가 좋았어 ㅠㅠ
The guy rapper with the brown leather jacket is so cool. Love this.
I hope you're trying to be funny
라차타 에프엑스 전설의 시작이었음 ㅠㅠ 보고싶다
너무 멋지고 예쁘다 설리
Will always comeback here my favorite girl group. 😭❤️
half of ambers face is covered half the time
15 year-old Sulli is so cute !! R.I.P …
라이브 진짜 쩐다...10년전 노래라니 여전히 너무 세련됐는데
셈법 다시 배우삼
빅토리아 진짜 미쳤댜 ㅋㅋ
Sulli looks so young and beautiful as always❤❤❤❤❤
천년돌 설리ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
found myself listening to this more and more lately. It’s always good to remember how far Kpop has come because of the foundation that f(x) contributed to MASSIVELY.
Thank you f(x) for paving the way!
And thank you Sulli, you did great💙
Happy 14th anniversary. Always coming back to watch these videos :)
아 진짜 애기다 ... ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
이게 무슨.. 데뷔곡이야... 진심 에프엑스 미쓰에이 투에니원 데뷔곡들 레전드임
they were so stable and it was just their debut stage what a legendary group
촌스럽지 않음
들을때마다 새로움😊
Their live singing is so chef's kiss
coming back here after Amber's interview in buzzfeed 💕
Gee me 😂😍
Krystal’s voice is so clear
마음이 아프다ㅠ
크리스탈은 똑같을 줄 알았는데 이제보니 애기티가 확 나는구나 이때는
The only group use stage name in english for all members.. 😭😭😭 miss them so much
Rest In Paradise Sulli ⚘
Gen2 keren selalu nyanyi live tanpa lipsing
fx is so perfect
Omg yes
2018..... it's been 9 years since this day this was filmed, it's been 4 years with the 5 of them on the same stage, it's been 3 years since the group's last release & every day it breaks MeUs hearts 💜
Iconic debut.