The Great Maulana AZAD رحمہ اللہ was a legendary SCHOLAR & Thinker of ISLAM. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect all MUSLIMS especially PALESTINE from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
kabhi balocho, kurdo, uyigar par bhi baat kar liya kar.kewal logo ko bhadka kar apne logo ko shoshan karna band karo. sirf dharm ka prachar karna chod bajaye logo ko rational bana. kabhi -- overpopulation, pollution, global warming, climate change, heat wave, biodiversity loss, animal cruelty, groundwater shrinking, natural disaster, toxic patriarchal society, gender discrimination, wealth discrimination par bhi baat kar liya kar.
Har baat mein Allah ko ghusana zarooree hay? 🙄 Kiya aqal se paidal log hein! Yeh namoonay Allah walay jab tak hon gay Musalmano aur Pakistanio ka kuch nahi banega. Allah ko public discourse se bhagao, sab kuch theek ho jayega.
My father was born in Lahore in 1910. Never wanted anything like this Pakistan. His prediction of it becoming an Intolerant Society has also come true in spades.
I met an old but strong Punjaban lady of 98 years old and she could still throw me out. Anyway, she said, we Punjabis and Pattans never voted for Pakistan. In fact, British forcefully created like they created Saudi, UAE, Israel +++. On the top of all Punjab and Bengal was divided based of Hindu Muslims but UP, MP, Bihar, Oressa ++ given to Hindustan rather should be splinted between both countries. Hyderabad, Junagarh were taken over by India and Pakistan did nothing. Jinnah was an honest lawyer but absolutely failed in politics. He wasn't politician. He should not poke his nose into this matter that change entire future of Islam and Muslims in that region. Basically because of division, Muslims and Islam was the loser. We were 700 Million Muslims in Powerful Hindustan and would have super power by now. But emotion took over brain and we lost.
As a person from Balochistan, I wish that happens soon. I lost my uncle (mamu) because of army brutality and forced kidnapping and we were never allowed to meet him again. I have seen my cousins blood cry just to meet him or to know whereabouts. Army is doing unspeakable oppression. I just wish to leave the country with family but unfortunately I don't have enough money to do that also.
I am from Punjab. I really empathise with you as pakistani. Army do not want middle class to rise and flourish. They want all the youth and educated class to leave the country and all the deaf and dumb illiterates behind.
@@AbrarAhmad-et9mo Don't call me Pakistani, it's an abuse. I don't relate to that term anymore. I just wish to see Balochistan liberation. Don't know when but if Allah is there, he will surely listen to screams of innocents that has been brutally massacred by Pakistani army. Ameen
Bro I am Hindustani and I want you preserve your culture your state or your country Balochistan Personally I am with you but I can't do anything so our representative means our government will support you indirectly but you have to do something in organised manner or something bigger than Pakistani establishment thinking Jai hinglaj mata Bharat mata ki jay
in the eyes of Pakistani establishment, only punjabi sunni lives matter, all other ethnic or racial groups are considered inferior and therefore, we have no rights to speak.
@@Adeeb377kyonki unhe pata tha ki indian Muslim hamesha victim card hi play krenge aur ha main bhi India ko secular country nahi manta kyonki secular country me sabhi ko saman adhikar hote hai pr yaha muslims ko bahut jyada adhikar hai jaise 4 shadi krna, 3 talak tha jo hata diya aur wakf board pr jabtak UCC lagu nhi hota tb tk India secular country nhi bn sakta
@@Adeeb377 did you not watch the video. Azad said this partition will create more divide in Hindi and Muslims. And there is no plight of Muslims in India. They have doubled in numbers and not one Muslim wants to go to Pakistan.
@@sanny47971 3 talak ka case was started by a muslim woman in 1990's. Her case against 3 talak was rejected cuz its muslim men right. She and many muslim women org fought for 3 talak ban. A poll was held all over India and over 83% muslim women voted for 3 tala ban. We didn't ban it by ourselves. It never concerned Indian government or hindus. It was muslim woman who started it and also she belived that we will bring justice to her. But the cass delayed sp much cuz muslim party and organisations opposed ir. Plus polygamy is very much allowed for muslims . And we are a secular state that's why shah rukh , salman etc are our fave we dont have sepretist ideology of muslims . Plus tata group is also owned by a parsi. A minority of 0.2% in india. Tata groups worth is more than pakistans. Our former ex president APJ abdul kalam was a president and a respectable scientist and a leader. We are a secular nationa and very liberal. I never saw a hindu or Christian leader in Pakistan or in army or in flim industry. Y'll are the most problematic. And love to play victim cards and love 2 shove the anti india propaganda. Just because Pakistan's foundation is about sepretism, islamic , narcissism dosent mean we india is same as u. Pakistan bana hoga islam aur 2 religion theiry pr but india kabhi is ideology pr nhi chala
When people are raised with the idea that they are superior because they are born in a certain religion then there's no scope for improvement or self reflection .
@@dr.ozyrak use castist slurs in India and you'll be sued big time . It isn't taught in school books like Pakistan who's foundation is based on supremacy of one religion over others
Jinnah couldn't foresee what Maulana Abul Kalam Azad clearly did and warned about the tragic consequences of partition which the Muslims of the sub continent are facing today. Excellent vlog.
It did not talk about Indian Muslims who have become second class citizens in India. There is hatred against them, their rights should be taken away, Muslims should be talked about, they too had to be talked about. 🙏🙏🙏
I wish U meet Azad soon.and tell him what is happening with Indian Muslims and other minorities in India. except 2 or 3 of his predictions rest are absolutely rubbish and you are trying to make false connections.
So can you tell me indians muslims how many muslims are there in India and how many CM's are there for Muslims in India. Because you always pretend you are happy there you never want Pakistan??? 😂😂
One interesting facts about abdul kalam azad that he is founder of indian institute of technology (IIT) And he set the rules of IIT which is still alive and there was no any change on his rules ❤❤❤
It reminded me of my late father. Who was always opposed by the Muslim league. His teacher and spiritual leader Maulana Obaidullah Sindhi was a great nationalist. Never accepted and believed in partition of India.
Because he instead wanted to Islamize the entirety of the Indian subcontinent in one go, not one piece at a time. If he didn't then he isn't a true Muslim.
So can you tell me indians muslims how many muslims are there in India and how many CM's are there for Muslims in India. Because you always pretend you are happy there you never want Pakistan??? 😂😂
😂 5 years before INDIAN president were Muslims😂 Dr APJ abdul kalam.and India has lot of MP's Even 😂 Abdul kalam azad were Minister in india and here 20 crore muslims are their. We have equal laws.
Mashallah what a brilliant bouquet of apt predictions by Abdul Kalam Azad ! From Abdul Kalam Azad as Education minister of India to Abdul Kalam - the father of Indian missile and space program ISRO and later as President of India have shown how vulnerable we as nation have become.
My Uncle worked in Abdul Kalam's Team on the PSLV. He said that Abdul Kalam wasn't that intelligent or a great scientist, but he was an excellent team player and team leader later.
Don't confuse between APJ Abdul Kalam - Missile Man of India With Abul Kalam Azad - 1st Education Minister of India. Btw Father of ISRO - Vikram Sarabhai.
Comparing missile man APJ Kalam with this Azad. Their intelligence, loyalty, brilliance run parallel. This guy is nowhere near Kalam . It is like comparing sour lemon with the most respected APJ Kalamji.
Muzzamil...you are a rockstar ....logical...with scientific temper... ability to reason out... ability to question...fearless to express your thoughts... ready to debate ...may God protect you and give you more power .. didn't know Azad's sad predictions about Pakistan...Azad opposed partition...he was angry with Nehru on this...& Yes blessed India by becoming 1st education minister 🙏
It did not talk about Indian Muslims who have become second class citizens in India. There is hatred against them, their rights should be taken away, Muslims should be talked about, they too had to be talked about. 🙏🙏🙏
I read Maulana Abul Kalam Azad's autobiography (India Wins Freedom) way back in 2004 as a teenager, borrowed from British Library in a small town called Ranchi. Now I live in Bangalore and understand how deep his understanding was, about the socio-political situation of the subcontinent. It amazes me how wise our first education minister was. I in fact read it at that time because the Urdu library in Ranchi was inaugurated by him in 1945 and I was intrigued.
At 4:03, Prediction number 2, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad discusses about converting non-Muslims to Muslims explains that he is also an Islamist but just pretending to be secular since they don't have enough numbers to establish an Islamic state. They are just waiting for their time since then and also now.
Just take the good part and throw the rest away. I love mangoes but I only like the tasty part. I throw away the skin and seed. All I suggest people is to read books, as many as possible, from right, left, centre - everything. I realised through my reading that I know nothing because there is so much knowledge in this world. Just immerse yourself in the quest for knowledge. So may be you are right or maybe you are wrong about him, but who cares. Just take the good part.
In 1946 election, 90% of Muslim Voters voted for the partition and 90% of Hindu Voters voted against the partition. But today ironically, most Hindus are happy with the partition, since the partition prevented the rise of Jihadi politics in India. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1946_Indian_provincial_elections
Oo...W. U. Degree holder first you have to checked ☑ what is the ratio between Muslim in Pakistan and India. At present the difference is only 4-6 crore. Then how 90% vote in favour is illogical and factless. What's App university data is not relevent. Be careful 😂😂
90 percent Muslims? And 90 percent Hindus? Dude we were not able to achieve 90 percent voting rates till like 1990s and you are talking about 90 percent people voting in 1947 What the fuck Also no normal civilians were after this Only the big leaders wanted it Most of the normal people be it hindu or Muslim didn’t wanted it Also the Muslim leader of Sindh Rajsthan Punjab and others also dint wanted partition It were just the rich and influential UP and Bengal muslim leaders
@@parthasarathykhiriya let me tell, UP muslim were brought as asset working population. The partition was proposed by muslim leaders hyderabadi nizams but favoured by all muslim due to kafir hatred. Syed muzamil is from same UP , his ancestors were brought as intellectual force to run Pakistan but in UP itself they were considered least educated. Edit: ironically none of the creator of Pakistan descendants lives in Pakistan but india be it owasi of Hyderabad or jinnah's grand son here
Abul Kalam Azad is revered by all in India. He was a scholar par excellence. I thank you for bringing him in focus. Thumbs up for your intellectual analysis and regards from India
It is amazing that this great man is remembered in Pakistan, Syed Muzammil Saheb. India itself has largely forgotten him because he was extremely critical of Jawaharlal Nehru. His autobiography, which was only published in a limited run, is extremely critical of Nehru whom he blames for the Partition. I am the grandson of Savitaben Kamdar and Gijulal Kamdar on my father's side, and the Maulana was a close friend of my grandparents. At my ancestral house on 24 Broadway (long demolished) in the hall, together with pictures of my grandparents, my father and three uncles and aunts, was the Maulana's portrait. I was unfortunately born more than a decade after his passing. He was a true patriot and one of the greatest sons of India. My father's family are Hindus and they were vastly more respectful to this great man and his memory than to many of the Hindu leaders of the time. The Congress Party tried to slime him by labeling him a drunkard. The fact is that he did not drink. He was a chain smoker, though, and that was what likely took his life. Few people fought for Indian unity harder than he did. India's educational strengths came into being because of people like Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, and at a lesser level on a local basis, Justice Basheer Ahmed Sayeed in Tamil Nadu, Dr Miss Ahmed Beevi (as she preferred being known) in Andhra, and C K Mohammed Koya in Kerala. I was fortunate in only meeting Ahmed Beevi - her brother's grandson Sikandar was a close friend of mine and the family owned a beedi factory in Nellore - the Stove Beedi Factory. When she lived, she was so highly respected that people would take their footwear off when they walked past her house. And Justice Basheer Ahmed Sayeed's daughter Dr Bader Sayeed became a Member of Parliament (I think) and remains a highly respected lady in India. Her father started the first college for women and he was the leader who together with Egypt's Gamal Abdul Nasser worked for the higher education of Muslim women. Thank you for bringing back some amazing memories. The world is a better place - and India owes a lot - to great patriots like the great Maulana.
Kamdar Saheb.....a good Narration with nuggets of firsthand history. Indeed, the role of Maulana Azad has always been underplayed in the Indian Post Independence Narrative.. Just like Netaji Subhas. It is quite obvious that neither Gandhi or Nehru or Patel or anyone......were Visionaries or Statesmen.......they unfortunately, did not rise from the level of Petty Egoic , Self Serving Politicians, Netas. Of course , all this is hindsight. Muzamil ,well done. Comment Fearlessly, since you have a Critical Eye
Tell me honestly, did he not corrupt indian history with mughal valor and reduce Hindus to warring tribes and caste problems? He has been on record to be against partition as Muslims would be less weak and rhe gazwa e hind will be incomplete.
Maulana Azad was education Minister of India until he died in 1958. In fact he played a very important role developing Indian education system. He advocated the idea of universalisation of the basic education system and proposed the idea of free and compulsory education until secondary level for both boys and girls. After becoming independent, Maulana Azad made primary education a free and compulsory citizen right for children up to 14 years of age.
Partition is one of the best Move by Britishers, we Hindus don't want to live with cancer..... If the partition had not happened, our country would have been burning today and civil war would have broken out in the country
Atleast we are proud to have sane young brains like Syed Muzamil who can filter out all the noise and bring the real meaningful dialogue for thought provoking analysis. Thank you Muzamil for your yet another brilliant vlog.
This is what gives me hope that Pakistan is changing & will change to better Insha Allah. When the world is becoming far extremist, Pakistan is calming because we're already reaping what our elders sowed.
Dear Muzzamil I place on record that you are the best blogger from India and Pakistan. My salutation . Pakistanis should use your intelligence and knowledge to improve pakistan.
It is a deliberate manipulation of history in Pakistan to create disdain and hatred against India - taught from kindergarten onwards - because as Azad said, if you found a country on hatred then you have to keep hating otherwise your country breaks apart.
@@shankarcg786 actually, even without the" entire Pakistan inside India", we now have a new breed of goondutva.rightwing extremos who will turn our beloved S E C U L A R India into a dharmic varmic kattarpanti/mazhabhi inteha pasandi Pakistan..........same daku mentality, same genetics?????
I am an Indian, and always knew that Azad was one of the most respected Indian statesmen from the Independence era, but I did no know how historically perceptive he was. Syed, thank you for this video.
CREATION OF PAKISTAN WAS A HUGE BLUNDER OF BRITISH AGENT JINNAH. PAKISTAN IS A CURSE AND SLAP ON THE FACE OF PAKISTSNI MUSLIMS. RULERS OF PSKISTAN ARE MOST DANGEROUS DICTATORS ON THIS PLANETS. POLITICIANS, LIKE ZARDARI-SHARIFF, ARE TOP RATED THIEVES IN THE WORKD. ARMY GENERALS AND POLITICIANS ARE READY TO SELL OUT PSKISTAN. It is harsh but factual truth.
"People plant trees, but not everyone sees the fruit. Maulana Abul Kalam Azad is a hero for people in subcontinent. He spent his life fighting for a united and free India. He wasn't just into politics; he was also a great writer and poet. Azad started the education system in India and was the President of All India Congress. What makes Azad special is his idea that religion can bring people together. This philosophy is something all Muslims, especially in places like Pakistan, should think about for progress."
If he truly believed Islam taught its followers to coexist with non-Muslims, then I am very inclined to believe that he had not understood Islamic teachings well. For instance , I wonder what his opinion was of Hadith 2922 cited in the Hamas Charter? By the way what were his educational qualifications?
It did not talk about Indian Muslims who have become second class citizens in India. There is hatred against them, their rights should be taken away, Muslims should be talked about, they too had to be talked about. 🙏🙏🙏
Hello brother, I am from India and I'm very happy to see that young people like you is critically analyzing the root causes which is responsible for persistent inconsistency and turmoil in Pakistan. Keep going, God bless you
Be aware of him. He does speak bitter truth of Pakistan, but he is equally poisonous about Bharat. He left no stone unturned to defame our PM Modi…. Watch his previous videos
@@manishainamdar6393 thanku for your concerns manisha ji, and yes you're right. Nonetheless we can only hope for best, otherwise 90,000 will change to 9 Cr. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@RealRandomVideos Maulana Abul Kalam Azad was the first education minister of India and he was the one responsible for the vision of iit/iim and other visionary educational schemes.
@@abhishekrajpoot5756 He was a jahil Mussalmaan. Don't buy this "secular" propaganda. Read what he wrote. He wanted to convert all of India to the death cult of Islam.
@@RealRandomVideos he was our first education minister and we admire his policies. We believe in ideology of WORK IS WORSHIP and we respect those who worship their work irrespective of their religion. Another example of this is, There is a cricket stadium and a College in Jammu city after his NAME too.
*Maulana Abul Kalam Azad on his speech on October 23rd, 1947 at Jama Masjid, Delhi* " It was not long ago when I warned you that the two-nation theory was death-knell to a meaningful, dignified life; forsake it. I told you that the pillars upon which you were leaning would inevitably crumble. To all this you turned a deaf ear. You did not realize that, my brothers! I have always attempted to keep politics apart from personalities, thus avoiding those thorny valleys. That is why some of my messages are often couched in allusions. The Partition of India was a fundamental mistake. The manner in which religious differences were incited, inevitably, led to the devastation that we have seen with our own eyes. Unfortunately, we are still seeing it at some places. There is no use recounting the events of the past seven years, nor will it serve any good. Yet, it must be state that the debacle of Indian Muslims is the result of the colossal blunders committed by the Muslim League’s misguided leadership. These consequences however, were no surprise to me; I had anticipated them from the very start.”
Abdul Kalam was a radical muslim who didn't want partition, only because he realised that if partition happened it will be very difficult to achieve gazwa e hind. Like all muslim leaders of those days he hated hindus and their ideology. He was supported by his closet muslim friend Nehru. 🎉
@@JJ-xo3bc I agree with the part that Nehru wanted to supress Hindu polity. I agree that Abdul Kalam was against Partition as it would have decreased the political power of Muslims in India. First the Muslim population in the subcontinent got divided once and again into three parts in 1971. 1947 is weakened Islamic political power in the Subcontinent and then again in 1971 Islamic political power weakened further. Abdul Kalam brainwashed the indian population with his education policy that he implemented as the first education minister of India. Only after social media and the emergence of alternate scholarship that was able to counter the mainstream that Abdul Kalam's sinister designs to brainwash India population to further his goals of maintain the powers of Muslim feudals in India has faced push-back. Without liberalization in 1991 it was not possible. In way a you could say India bankrupting itself in 1991 directly helped the resurgence of the Hindu culture into the mainstream.
I am from India. And I am still unable to digest that what was the need of creation of Pakistan if not the fulfillment of desires of few riches. I don't support Akhand Bharat etc(bcz I don't want highly radical time bombs in my country). But very sad that Pakistan is just on the path as told by Azad sahab.
BJP RSS has put us also on the same path that Azad warned..........cannot behave like Pakistan and want to be progressive developed like S E C U L A R democratic nations like US CDA AUS UK (Christian, but chose to be secular, instead of dharmic varmic like India.........mazhabi like Pakistan)
Mind blowing facts: - 90% Muslims voted for Pakistan, 90% Hindus against it. But today Hindus are happy with it and Muslims are divided! - An atheist (pork eater) Jinnah made a religious nation and a religious man Gandhi wanted a secular/undivided nation. - Two nation theory became Three nation theory. Muslims can live with Hindus (eg india). But can’t live with other Muslims! (Eg: Bangladesh). Partition had lot of ironies!
Maulana AZAD also warned the Muslims who were migrating to Pakistan not to go there ,because the four Tribal Provences ,Punjabis, Sindhis ,Balochis and Pathans will not accept you , and the same happened with Mohair's they were left alone.
Bull.... Just because Pakistan os going down today everyone including people of our own soil like muzammil shah are busy spanking the very ideology of this country. And for what? A few dollars more. @muzammil shame on you
So can you tell me indians muslims how many muslims are there in India and how many CM's are there for Muslims in India. Because you always pretend you are happy there you never want Pakistan??? 😂😂
You can still acknowledge your mistakes and reunite with Bharat. paXthan won't last for even 100 years. A country, who's one & only purpose is to hate it's origin, deny it's history and create terrorists to hurt it's neighbor, is not a real country.
@@Faqr-e-GhayoorHindu fanatics are a small minority in India. Muslim fanatics are a fanatical majority in Pakistan .. focus on your problems which are even bigger than trying ng to deflect
@@user-mk4vi5vq6g Very first converts were brutally tortured to an extent they had to leave their home town Makkah. Talk more about the personal gains here
Maulana Azad was also the first education minister of India. The very intersting fact is that , he never been to any school and college but still he has knowledge like scholars. 👏👏👏👏
@syed Muzammil Official, I am a Hindu from India, living in Canada, and been watching your video for quite a time, and really like your views and thoughts on various topic, especially on India and Pakistan shared history and position right now. So, thanks 🙏🏽
If Dogs got a Holy book which tells them to Bite Everyone who is not a dog I would be afriad of Every dog and the fact that some dogs dont bite wouldn't change my mind
Most important thing is that's he is first education minister of our country he gives IIT. International level engineering college and AIIMS international level medical college ........Im the starting jinna also a good politician and no doubt a good lawyer but jinnah ambitious and western culture influence person live nicely and well dressed after Gandhi bahut sare politicians ko laga ki yaar hamara naam nhi ho rha to wo congres switch kar gye jinnah England chala gya with 18 years old beautiful parsi girl at the age of 40 and some landlord approach and called india again'
If you just integrate in society nothing bad will happen I see so many indian moulvis who silently supports Pakistan it is only reaction of those things
Population usse jyada exchange hota to aadha india pakistan me chala jaata. Sardar patel ko pata tha, nhi to jyada muskil nhi tha population exchange karna. Pakistan me jitna land mass hai utne me pura muslim popuation nhi aati to aur india divide hota.
@@luciferzomer7479 aisa kuch nahi kyunki Bharat ke 90% Muslim Pakistan ke favour mein vote kiya tha toh har haal mein unko chale jana tha lekin begairat nahi gaye
@@luciferzomer7479 No. At the time of partition, Hindu population was 28 crores n muslim population around 3.5 crores. In fact, Dr. Ambedkar had asked Nehru to go for complete exchange of Hindus n muslims. But Nehru declined that. Had it happened, India would have been a much better place, today.
Those who didn’t have to be displaced or whose loved ones weren’t killed don’t get to have an opinion about how great partition was. Those who pride themselves on being Indian should see what happens to non-secular countries and stop dreaming of a non-secular India.
This amazing lecture should be part of the school curriculum. We have a lot to learn from the great Maulana .....................sadly, we refuse to learn from history & insist on repeating the same mistakes. Thanks you for researching this scholarly work & making us aware of a significant contribution by this great scholar, gentleman & human being.
A load of bull. If he truly was secular, and supposedly an islamic scholar, he should have started a movement to remove the usage of the word kaffir in Islam, and asked for establishment of temples in Mecca and medina just the way mosques exist in ayodhya , Kashi and mathura. He should have ensured that every symbol of Hindu humiliation like the Babri, gyanvyapi are treated as such, and asked for a seperate mosque rather than pray at those sites. He was a opportunist who modernized everyone else but lacked the will to do the same for his own, he ensured that a piece of the pie was retained for his community- minority status, minority institutions etc... All these originate from lightbulbs like this Maulana.
Dear Muzammil Sahib Assalamoalaikum. I have been a great admirer of you since I started following you. Your honest and truthful reviews unfolding the bitter realities of our country,s politicians, administrators and our nation especially our today's youth are commendable. It needs a lot of inner courage and strength. Please keep up the good work. May Allah Subhanatallah shower His blessings upon you.
Syed, this was known to all Indians of my previous generation, I e 2 generations before you. But it equally unbelievable that you are analyzing it! May Lord Almighty bless you. Stay safe.
بھائی مجھے پاکستان کی ریاست سے ہزار اختلاف ہیں لیکن پاکستان کا نظریہ ہمیشہ سے درست تھا اور فلسطین کا حال دیکھ کر اب میرا پاکستان پر یقین اور پختہ ہو گیا ہے۔ باقی جس کو غیروں کی غلامی کا کیڑا کاٹ رہا ہے وہ بخوشی افغانستان اور بھارت روانہ ہو سکتا ہے۔
Agree, i m from India. Many Indians r unhappy with partition. But my generation today lot of em realise it was very good decision. Probably with United hindu muslim India, India wud have been very poor with no growth even today. It wud have been a Hell hole with almost no science tech & modern education . Communities wud have been in constant fight with each other and regular riots. Hindus who have emerges to reform and modernise with time and still reforming wud have never happened. Hindus wud have been More fundamentalist like Moslems . Partition relieved Indian Hindus of Muslim threat and their Past. This ensured the left wing Congress rises and push reforms and make Hindus accept their Religion Problems. Also Rare conflicts has allowed peaceful atmosphere to Invite large Investment. Also the 15% muslims who have remained in India has Kept Hindus on their toes to remain united to a level. And keep accepting reforms specially in terms of caste. The ethnic and caste divide has been overcome by Showing these Muslims as others instead of creating othering within Hindus themselves . I know this is bad for 15% muslims but i m not going to lie.
Islam has one holy book, one prophet and essentially one belief system. In spite of this, Islam could not keep Pakistan and Bangladesh together and the country broke up. Hinduism has thousands of different belief systems, folk practices and beliefs and at least 9 well-developed schools of thought and people believe that despite these differences Hinduism will be enough to keep India together. Actually, it was never about Hinduism and Islam, but the fact that Pakistan was formed on exclusivism and hate as a basis of it's identity that led to its downfall. Once exclusivism was stressed as the basis of Pakistani identity, that identity started becoming more and more exclusive and its definitions narrower and narrower...pehle Pakistan is buniyaad pe banaa ke hum Musalman hain, hum Hinduon se alag hain or Musalman Hinduon ke saath nahi reh sakte, uski buniyaad positive identity par nahin balki nafrat par thi...ek baar Hindu aur Sikh khatam ho gaye nafrat uske baad bhi nafrat lekin waapas botal mein nahi gai....jin bewakoofon ko tumne izzat aur taakat de di thi, wo log nafrat ke oxygen pe palte the aur naye naye identity dhoondhte rahe nafrat ke liye...ahmedi, bangali, Muhajir, shia, Hazara etc etc....In contrast, India did not stress Hindu identity but secularism and acceptance as its core value and stayed together despite being (possibly) the most diverse country in the world..... For Indians, we need to learn from Pakistan's history...if we go down that same road, we will get the same results....don't forget it took them 30-40 years for the results to start showing in the everyday lives of citizens....aaj hum aage hain apne pichli 30-40 saal ki decisions ki wajaah se aur aaj jo kar rahein hain uska fal humein agle 30-40 saal mein milega.... For Pakistanis and muslims who say present day India shows you how valid two-nation theory is- you should consider that in every system different variables interact, react and influence each other....even among brothers - if one brother is consistently bullying, influences his own way and captures your property, sooner or later the other brother is not going to treat them well....iska matlab ye nahi hai ke aisa hona tayy tha....shayad agar doosra bhai theek se pesh aata, to dono bhai saath mein reh sakte the.... Before criticising the other, we both need to look in our own girebaan...There are so, so many things to talk about but I just want Indian viewers to think about this, as I know many Indians will come here to watch your video and gloat on our 'superiority'.
I will just add one more point (among many others I believe in)- Jinnah (post-Congress and retirement in England) and Savarkar (post- kaala pani) were british agents....to understand this, dont follow their speeches and words but follow their actions...ask how much time they spent in British jails after they started spouting religion based nationalism...look at who they supported when nationalist movement was at peak (like what was their attitude to movements such as Quit India movement or to supporting the British with Indian manpower and resources when the British desperately needed help during world war 2)....you will find a remarkable similarity in their actions and support/criticism....aur to aur, people who made their entire ideology about Hindus and Muslims not being able to live together, even shook hands and came together to share power when Congress provincial governments resigned ...and it was in one such mili-jhuli sarkar which had Hindu Mahasabha in government that the Pakistan bill was first passed....LOL, Gaddar the ye haraamkh0r.....aur jo inhe poojte hain wo awaal darje ke bewakoof....when people say ke Jinnah ne badi kurbaniyaan di.....ask them how much time he spent in jail since leading Muslim League, compare that to the years that were spent by Nehru, Gandhi, Azad, Patel and Badshah Khan and you will know who the British thought were their enemy and who their friend....
Quick reminder for any Pakistani who might think/comment here "Thank you Jinnah" on what they perceive is happening in India these days... When Muslims of minority provinces approached Jinnah and asked him what would happen of them this is what he had to say - Kanpur on March 30, 1941, "in order to liberate seven crores of Muslims where they were in a majority I am willing to perform the last ceremony of martyrdom, if necessary, and let two crores of Muslims be smashed". Pls don't come n preach what about Modi etc.... your "Qaid E Azam" and his fan boys CONDEMNED us (Indian Muslims) to death (SMASHED, his words) .. After condemning us to death you have NO RIGHT to preach anything..... Not only we survived but thrived and will continue to, thanks to our hindu brothers and sisters... Even today Modi government gives crores and crores rupees worth of support to the pasmanda Muslims of India... Treat your minorities with the respect and equality they deserve please. Your actions towards minorities gave rise to the popularity of right wing in India.. its a direct reaction.....
So your telling me Indian Hindus are so educated that what happens in another sovereign state was enough for them to not only turn their backs on but actually oppress their own countrymen? So much so that they are on the world genocide watch list, several academics and historians have warned of a potential genocide and to quote one of your own politicians Shashi Tharoor: “I never thought it would be safer in India to be a cow than a Muslim”.
@@SK-rt8yn I understand...just sick and tired of reading this nonsense "Thank you Jinnah" each time there is news of attacks on some muslims in India... Jinnah himself condemned ALL Indian Muslims to death... I had to type it coz most of these people comment the aforementioned rarely read books except the fables they are taught in school or Nasim Hijazi type fiction...
You will not understand how happy comments like these make me, an Indian Hindu. Live and let live, have a growth mindset, respect each others religion and focus on development for all!❤
Wonderfully explained the facts of Pakistan, hopefully the nation will get some ideas where they stand today and put some concrete efforts to set the right direction for coming generations - Thank you
I laugh whenever someone uses the word "muslim ummah", basically that means they heard their friday sermon from an illiterate man and believed it. Even in Sunni sect there is no unity, salafism, wahabism are cannibalising traditional Sunni muslims who held moderate views on politics, religion. From Turkey to Japan, only in India that minority sects of Islam not just live but prosper. Members of Borah community are not just richest Muslims but richest Indians. Go to bazaars of Mumbai and some of the richest Muslim businessmen belong to Shia and Bora community. Every other Muslim country represses their minorities even smaller sects of Islam, only difference is the degree to which they oppress them.
@@asfandyar5570 they are called pasmanda Muslims(lower caste Muslims) and they are below poverty line for a reason. Muslim leaders never encouraged education or critical thinking amongst Muslim society. They feared education will bring modernity amongst masses and thus reducing their power. So rich and powerful Muslims got their kids educated in best schools and sent them abroad for further studies meanwhile their community was never allowed to even pass 10th.
*Thats Because Maulana Abul Kalam Azad Sir Was A Prominent And Visionary Politician with Rational Mind .. Azad Sir Ne Kaafi Sare Muslim Leaders Ke Views Kafi Kareebi Se Jaane Including Jinnah And Other Muslim League Muslim Politicians which gave him quite clear view of Future Social and Political Vulnerability of Pakistan* .. 💯
I am impressed with your openness, fearlessness, and the way you have taken the bull by its horns. The very fact that I mention fearlessness as a virtue and strength for a vlogger is a sad commentary on the State of politics. Please know that we in India really wish you well; though we are being selfish because a prosperous and peace loving neighbour is a blessing for us. Too much time and resources have been lost in the last 75 years. Imagine the opportunities lost for both countries if from 1947 itself we would have just focused on development and growth alone instead of fighting. I have always maintained that it takes only one true and genuine leader to change the fortunes of a country. May your country be blessed with one such leader!
Amazing..my view of Muslims and Islam is changing. For me, the intricacies of Indian spirituality was first explained to be my friend Irfan Moosa. With so balanced commentators, the future is still bright
We have a concept called KARMA Forced conversations , breaking religious places like temple and churches are enough for the situation that this country is in One tip : protect the 1% minority left in this country they might as well save this country from KARMA
I'm a Hindu from Uttar Pradesh (United Provinces of British India) and I have many Muslim friends like Farhaz, Shadab and so many. I never felt that they are different from us. We all invite each other to our home. Marriage is not a very common thing between two communities but it happens on the understanding of two families. Riots between Hindu and Muslims happened in the past but it's not a thing anymore. There are hardliner hindu and Muslims but there are liberal Hindus and Muslims as well and that's why things get managed eventually.
Hinduism amd Islam have very different cultural ethos but people have one thing to live with each other that's mutual understanding. India is birth place of Sanatani philosophy , Buddhism, Jainism so as Muslims are emotionally connect with Mecca and Medina we are emotionally connect with vedas and Kashi, Somnath, Ram temple..
Sab mamla understanding he ...that is enough in common people but not in politicians , election jeetane ke liye kuchh bhi... Ram ji aaye hein ...29 mein Krishan ji aaynge ...33 min Shivji tandav karenge ...Agar Yamraj nahi aaye tab tak
@@ashfaqahmad6910that's not living together if I invades your country beats you convert you and then said we were living peacefully after that 💀 ese toh Palestinians or Israeli bhi peacefully hi reh rahe the kafi waqt se
@shamsherbahadur5570 ofcourse it will give political advantage to BJP. Unke manifesto me likha tha ki agar unki government bani toh wo Shree Ram mandir banwayene.
Partition was the best thing which happened for India. Otherwise, Jihadi politics would have hampered the development of India. Although, most Hindus opposed the partition in 1947, today most Hindus are happy that partition happened, which freed India from religious fanatism. 🙏🏽🇮🇳🙏🏽
A Hindu fanatic talking about Muslim fanatics is nothing but hypocrisy. I would have agreed if Hindus were a tolerant people. But looking at their extreme hatred towrds Muslims, I have to support the separation.
If Dogs got a Holy book which tells them to Bite Everyone who is not a dog I would be afriad of Every dog and the fact that some dogs dont bite wouldn't change my mind
There are doubts about whether Azad was religious. Some say he was agnostic. But he definitely could see through the hearts n souls of people he grew up around n knew that something was not right about them
Though i ageee with Azad predictions but how India has become intolerable society especially for muslims, the current Hinduvata movement compel progressive muslims to celebrate partition, sir thought on this ?
Maluana Abul Kalam Azad is one of the respectable figures in Indian independence history. We have a National Institute of Technology on his name since 50 years named as MANIT Bhopal, one of the premier engineering institutes of India. Unfortunately Pakistanis couldn’t see his predictions and finally all who moved to Pakistan are still suffering in one of the most unstable country of world named Pakistan. If they would have been stayed in India probably they could have become part of growth of India - 4th largest economy of the world.
I have studied from the Maulana Azad Medical College located on the Bahadur Shah Zafar Road in Delhi. It is one of the best medical colleges in India with 3 hospitals attached to it.
as a person from bharat i agree these poeple have habits of flexing their muscle or showing superiority towards Pakistan which is a failed or vassal state they have never compared with china which is mighty @ali19231
It will be blasphemy😂😂 in pakistan , he is one of the greatest Indian , they cannot have Dr BR Ambedkar their society cannot handle one. You get leaders you deserve
He was also the man who as the first education minister of Independent India shoved Mughal history down our throats as the only history worth learning about along with Congress’s tales of heroism for freedom. We should critique him for these terrible ideas too, if we give him props for many good deeds also done. We have a far longer and much richer civilisational history that was needed to be known by the masses.
Agreed to an extent. He did portray some Muslim rulers in a positive manner but he did portray many Muslim invaders in a negative manner. Further India followed federalism in education also. So respective State government can draft their own versions of regional histories. Basically he tried to built an overall harmonious history which do not promote Hate against muslims. Because he already saw that if you build a nation on the basis of Hate then what are the consequences. For example pakistan. So I would suggest that if he was not Right in doing so but he absolutely right to serve a stable political and economic future of India.
@@hemalbhatt4055It’s not a question of portraying the Mughals in a good or bad light. The fact remains why was it the majority chunk of indian history taught in schools. Didn’t we have a lot more important historical figures and events that we should have been taught? Why this bias? Is it because he associated with them and thought he was a descendant of theirs, whereas he most probably was a convert like most of the current indian subcontinent muslims are.
@@hemalbhatt4055We have the right to know the truth.Besides,if you are teaching all secular education,then why have madrassas.Pakistan was non muslim before islam.Muslims were humans.Now they think non believers have to be killed
Azad sir's Predictions, as far as Pakistan is concerned, was 100 percent correct, like what Nostradamus predicted, and of course Winston Churchill had said in his speech. Very nice compilation bro, superb. Thanks for an eye opener, if I may say so.
He was our first and probably the best education minister ever since. IIT and IIM are the brainchild of this great man, of course incited by JN. Today, his idea of centre of excellence makes Indians shine in the world.
The sad thing is atound 40 % did fall for it. I am Indian muslim, 3rd gen of Azad India. Since I started reading and gaining knowledge about partition incidents. I feel as if "It was a personal Hatred " of one person Jinnah that created Pakistan. When he was offered to be the first PM of India,, his sentence was some what ,, even if he became the first PM of India ,, in future he will loose because Muslims are not in majority. If his idea of creating a new country was because of religion. His reply would be " I don't want to be a pm,, I want a Islamic nation ".
@saddozaiproduction it's not a claim, it's a fact. Once you do some research on him , you can get to know him easily. He wanted a Islamic country that would be on Sharia law. Alhumdulillah very nice. But did he Drink Alcohol? Did he Ate pork? He did he prayed regularly? Once he got offended because in a party a British women gave his wife a shawl to cover herself because of her outfit. His Mother was a Kadiyani , father converted to Islam, wife a parsi, daughter a parsi. Forcefully removed from hindu viillage and Community because of fishing business and convention to Islam. That thing made a bad impact on his mind. He hated Hindus, but he was not a Sharia law abiding muslim. I am not questioning his muslim faith, but from history what I have known about him. I could say that such a person asking for a Islamic Sharia law country is totally opposite to what he himself was doing.
@bmniac A muslim cannot do migration from a majority Muslim country to a non-Muslim country. The intention of migration should be only dawah ( teach Islam in that country) . Rasool Allah SWA was in Macca , and very few accepted Islam ,,, did he migrated because everyone was Kafir? No. The migration was done to Madina, after few years , even though there were more Muslims in Macca than Madina. And when most of the muslims migrated to Madina, Islam was taught to the people of Madina. They accepted Islam. A muslim in Majority non muslim country can do migration to a non muslim country. But, someone who is already born in a non muslim country , Islam doesn't say he have to migrate to a muslim country.
We are greatful to almighty in whichever form who gave us Maulana Azad to our country. A true human being who respected being human first. We will do our best to carry his legacy forward
Thank you Muzammil. As always you bring eye opening content. Pakistan has a great future if it listens to you and allows intellectuals like you to flourish.
Proudly as an Indian I can say Maulana Azad is one of the best Indian statesmen ever produced! We own him and cherish his work regardless of Muslim or what ever the religion. We don’t care at the end of the day what matters is he is a patriotic Indian !
Muzzamil sir aap logo ko nhi pta hoga maulana Azad K baare me lekin hum Hindustanis ko unke baare me waise h padhaya jata hai jaise baaki deshbhakt K baare me padhaya jata hai 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
A real knowledgeable person like you. The way you argue the points of political scholars and great historians is amazing. I have never seen a more brave creator like u in pak. Thank you for all the times that made you like this.❤
“there will be muslims in pakistan but not islam” such a shameful dark truth. and i’m proud say that we have people like you to guiding our nation, providing light in the darkness.
We pushtoons even voted against Muslim league in 1947 and congress win the election but qaid e Azam by force invaded pushtoon Territories and Balochistan, Quaid Azam ordered army to kill pushtoons in congregation at babra😢
Bhai konsi sasti charas pi kar history parh li hy? Pushtoon ny kab Pakistan k against vote kiya tha. Jaisa sasta intellectual sunty ho waisi sasti opinion rakhty ho
😢😢😢yes.. I lost my ancestors! I'm pastooni but now live in 4th generation in srinagar kashmir india 🇮🇳and now sukoon hai! Pakistani army politics is so bad 😢
Hi Bhai, First of all big salute and appreciation for presenting the facts the way you do it, living in Pakistan and presenting like this need courage that I can see you are full with. My ancestors were from Sindh and moved to India after partition, my grand pa used to say they didn’t wanted to leave their mother land buy were forced to , anyhow , in the current state of Pakistan, I hope things get better soon from here , and I am sure they will, because even if 10% of people understand and follow what you are presenting, it will bring huge difference . I wish you all the best , let the two nations progress and prosper together .
You will not believe it but most Hindus and BJP are firm believers in the two nation theory today …Hindus and Muslims are like chalk and cheese , we don’t interdine , we don’t intermarry, we don’t live amongst each other ..our heroes are your villains and your heroes are our villains . Our civilisational paths are different . The greatest mystery for Hindus is as to why all Muslims did not leave for Pakistan in the first place in 1947. Today Muslims are unpopular with Hindus, Jews, Christians, Buddhists and even Chinese communists are having problems in Xinjiang
First of all, most Hindus are not BJP. After this election, at least that much must be clear. You didn't even convince half the Hindus. Most Hindus and even Vajpayee sahb looked at the Partition as a tragedy in which millions died. Most Hindus have no real problem with everyday Muslims. They work together, are friends with each other, play cricket together, and even marry each other. It is some fanatics on both sides who can't get along.
In 1946 election, 90% of Muslims voted for the partition and 90% of Hindus voted against the partition. But today ironically most Hindus are happy with the partition, since the partition prevented the rise of Jihadi politics in India.
The Great Maulana AZAD رحمہ اللہ was a legendary SCHOLAR & Thinker of ISLAM. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect all MUSLIMS especially PALESTINE from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
kabhi balocho, kurdo, uyigar par bhi baat kar liya kar.kewal logo ko bhadka kar apne logo ko shoshan karna band karo. sirf dharm ka prachar karna chod bajaye logo ko rational bana.
kabhi -- overpopulation, pollution, global warming, climate change, heat wave, biodiversity loss, animal cruelty, groundwater shrinking, natural disaster, toxic patriarchal society, gender discrimination, wealth discrimination par bhi baat kar liya kar.
❤❤❤❤
Bow Qaiser Ahmed Raja will cry about your comment 😆
@@BaDbOy-wj1ii Cancer Ahmed Raja 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Har baat mein Allah ko ghusana zarooree hay? 🙄 Kiya aqal se paidal log hein! Yeh namoonay Allah walay jab tak hon gay Musalmano aur Pakistanio ka kuch nahi banega. Allah ko public discourse se bhagao, sab kuch theek ho jayega.
Dr Ambedkar who was the father of our constitution also predicted the same thing in detailed way he wrote a book on partition of india and Pakistan.
Dr. Ambedkar had great insight about this cult of Islam as well, he saw through this cult way before.
Wo nahi padhega
He also said a very great thing regarding Hindu raj also
@@aliyanshah4592 tum six years ki ho 🤪
@@Escobar003 ap ki BAAT samj gaye hu
Ap ko views likes Sirf isi topic par milta ha
My father was born in Lahore in 1910. Never wanted anything like this Pakistan. His prediction of it becoming an Intolerant Society has also come true in spades.
Tu abhi 90 saal ka hoga kitna jhuth
@@LostinMango why do you have to show your real worth*? I was born when my father was 55. He died at age 95. We live long 👍👍😆😆
@@LostinMango wasn't he right about the intolerant society reading your "high IQ" comment 🤣
@@HappyKafir Ohh maaf kardoh muje
I met an old but strong Punjaban lady of 98 years old and she could still throw me out. Anyway, she said, we Punjabis and Pattans never voted for Pakistan.
In fact, British forcefully created like they created Saudi, UAE, Israel +++. On the top of all Punjab and Bengal was divided based of Hindu Muslims but UP, MP, Bihar, Oressa ++ given to Hindustan rather should be splinted between both countries. Hyderabad, Junagarh were taken over by India and Pakistan did nothing. Jinnah was an honest lawyer but absolutely failed in politics. He wasn't politician. He should not poke his nose into this matter that change entire future of Islam and Muslims in that region. Basically because of division, Muslims and Islam was the loser. We were 700 Million Muslims in Powerful Hindustan and would have super power by now. But emotion took over brain and we lost.
"There will be Muslims in Pakistan but No Islam" Sad reality and Golden words by Azad Sahab
in end there is almost no islam in his family.
Don’t worry they are doing everything islam preaches their aim is to become like Afghanistan.
@@Reena-od4ri and that's good thing otherwise he would have end up like any politician from Pakistan.
There will be Muslims but no Pakistan.
@@rahulraina9354 If that ever happens, it will be the beginning of the end for a country called Bharat.
As a person from Balochistan, I wish that happens soon. I lost my uncle (mamu) because of army brutality and forced kidnapping and we were never allowed to meet him again. I have seen my cousins blood cry just to meet him or to know whereabouts. Army is doing unspeakable oppression. I just wish to leave the country with family but unfortunately I don't have enough money to do that also.
I am from Punjab. I really empathise with you as pakistani.
Army do not want middle class to rise and flourish. They want all the youth and educated class to leave the country and all the deaf and dumb illiterates behind.
@@AbrarAhmad-et9mo Don't call me Pakistani, it's an abuse. I don't relate to that term anymore. I just wish to see Balochistan liberation. Don't know when but if Allah is there, he will surely listen to screams of innocents that has been brutally massacred by Pakistani army. Ameen
Bro I am Hindustani and I want you preserve your culture your state or your country Balochistan
Personally I am with you but I can't do anything so our representative means our government will support you indirectly but you have to do something in organised manner or something bigger than Pakistani establishment thinking
Jai hinglaj mata
Bharat mata ki jay
in the eyes of Pakistani establishment, only punjabi sunni lives matter, all other ethnic or racial groups are considered inferior and therefore, we have no rights to speak.
Pakistan Zindabad
Mr. Azad was way ahead of his time. Because everything he predicted came true!
If so, then why didn't he predict about the plight of Muslims in India and the future of secularism in India?
@@Adeeb377kyonki unhe pata tha ki indian Muslim hamesha victim card hi play krenge aur ha main bhi India ko secular country nahi manta kyonki secular country me sabhi ko saman adhikar hote hai pr yaha muslims ko bahut jyada adhikar hai jaise 4 shadi krna, 3 talak tha jo hata diya aur wakf board pr jabtak UCC lagu nhi hota tb tk India secular country nhi bn sakta
😢 true
@@Adeeb377 did you not watch the video. Azad said this partition will create more divide in Hindi and Muslims.
And there is no plight of Muslims in India. They have doubled in numbers and not one Muslim wants to go to Pakistan.
@@sanny47971 3 talak ka case was started by a muslim woman in 1990's. Her case against 3 talak was rejected cuz its muslim men right. She and many muslim women org fought for 3 talak ban. A poll was held all over India and over 83% muslim women voted for 3 tala ban. We didn't ban it by ourselves. It never concerned Indian government or hindus. It was muslim woman who started it and also she belived that we will bring justice to her. But the cass delayed sp much cuz muslim party and organisations opposed ir. Plus polygamy is very much allowed for muslims . And we are a secular state that's why shah rukh , salman etc are our fave we dont have sepretist ideology of muslims . Plus tata group is also owned by a parsi. A minority of 0.2% in india. Tata groups worth is more than pakistans.
Our former ex president APJ abdul kalam was a president and a respectable scientist and a leader. We are a secular nationa and very liberal.
I never saw a hindu or Christian leader in Pakistan or in army or in flim industry. Y'll are the most problematic. And love to play victim cards and love 2 shove the anti india propaganda.
Just because Pakistan's foundation is about sepretism, islamic , narcissism dosent mean we india is same as u. Pakistan bana hoga islam aur 2 religion theiry pr but india kabhi is ideology pr nhi chala
When people are raised with the idea that they are superior because they are born in a certain religion then there's no scope for improvement or self reflection .
Very true. When people of a certain caste r told that they are superior than the shudras it is absolutely abhorrent.
@@dr.ozyrak use castist slurs in India and you'll be sued big time .
It isn't taught in school books like Pakistan who's foundation is based on supremacy of one religion over others
@@dr.ozyrak beta jinna ne chutiyo ka moolk banaya naam hai...... 😅😅😅😅
@@dr.ozyrak in today bharat this social evil is not in practice anymore 😅😅😅😅
@@dr.ozyrak tu kis gattar se paida hua tere comment se samjh araha 😅😅😅😅
Jinnah couldn't foresee what Maulana Abul Kalam Azad clearly did and warned about the tragic consequences of partition which the Muslims of the sub continent are facing today.
Excellent vlog.
It did not talk about Indian Muslims who have become second class citizens in India. There is hatred against them, their rights should be taken away, Muslims should be talked about, they too had to be talked about. 🙏🙏🙏
I wish U meet Azad soon.and tell him what is happening with Indian Muslims and other minorities in India. except 2 or 3 of his predictions rest are absolutely rubbish and you are trying to make false connections.
allama Iqbal was the great philosopher he was right
So can you tell me indians muslims how many muslims are there in India and how many CM's are there for Muslims in India. Because you always pretend you are happy there you never want Pakistan??? 😂😂
One interesting facts about abdul kalam azad that he is founder of indian institute of technology (IIT)
And he set the rules of IIT which is still alive and there was no any change on his rules ❤❤❤
It reminded me of my late father. Who was always opposed by the Muslim league. His teacher and spiritual leader Maulana Obaidullah Sindhi was a great nationalist. Never accepted and believed in partition of India.
Because he instead wanted to Islamize the entirety of the Indian subcontinent in one go, not one piece at a time. If he didn't then he isn't a true Muslim.
So can you tell me indians muslims how many muslims are there in India and how many CM's are there for Muslims in India. Because you always pretend you are happy there you never want Pakistan??? 😂😂
@@salmanairport Fact is 90% of Muslim voters voted for the partition in 1946 election.
😂 5 years before INDIAN president were Muslims😂 Dr APJ abdul kalam.and India has lot of MP's Even 😂 Abdul kalam azad were Minister in india and here 20 crore muslims are their. We have equal laws.
If I am allowed to express myself in metaphysical way I will say Azad is like nostradamous or like baba vanga
Mashallah what a brilliant bouquet of apt predictions by Abdul Kalam Azad ! From Abdul Kalam Azad as Education minister of India to Abdul Kalam - the father of Indian missile and space program ISRO and later as President of India have shown how vulnerable we as nation have become.
My Uncle worked in Abdul Kalam's Team on the PSLV.
He said that Abdul Kalam wasn't that intelligent or a great scientist, but he was an excellent team player and team leader later.
Don't confuse between APJ Abdul Kalam - Missile Man of India
With
Abul Kalam Azad - 1st Education Minister of India.
Btw
Father of ISRO - Vikram Sarabhai.
As education minister he ruined India with wrong history with active support of Congress . Now all thisevwrongdvare being corrected.
Comparing missile man APJ Kalam with this Azad. Their intelligence, loyalty, brilliance run parallel. This guy is nowhere near Kalam . It is like comparing sour lemon with the most respected APJ Kalamji.
Father of space program of india isro
is
Vikram Sarabai
Muzzamil...you are a rockstar ....logical...with scientific temper... ability to reason out... ability to question...fearless to express your thoughts... ready to debate ...may God protect you and give you more power .. didn't know Azad's sad predictions about Pakistan...Azad opposed partition...he was angry with Nehru on this...& Yes blessed India by becoming 1st education minister 🙏
❤
It did not talk about Indian Muslims who have become second class citizens in India. There is hatred against them, their rights should be taken away, Muslims should be talked about, they too had to be talked about. 🙏🙏🙏
Maulana Azad was our first Education minister too.
Jai Hind
Very brave and honest journalism. Wish a better future of our neighbour overcoming all these problems.
There will be Muslims in Pakistan but No Islam" Sad reality and Golden words by Azad Sahab
Any Religion is Not Read To understand
It's The people who identify the country and the Religion
Hence you Call it Terrorist Country and People
happy reality
Islam is desease
This is true face of Islam....read Qur'an and Hadith. Available on the net
@@aol6419yes agree with you
I read Maulana Abul Kalam Azad's autobiography (India Wins Freedom) way back in 2004 as a teenager, borrowed from British Library in a small town called Ranchi. Now I live in Bangalore and understand how deep his understanding was, about the socio-political situation of the subcontinent. It amazes me how wise our first education minister was. I in fact read it at that time because the Urdu library in Ranchi was inaugurated by him in 1945 and I was intrigued.
He wasn't a saint either. He was a soft Islamist himself. Be very careful when you curve an image of anyone.
At 4:03, Prediction number 2, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad discusses about converting non-Muslims to Muslims explains that he is also an Islamist but just pretending to be secular since they don't have enough numbers to establish an Islamic state. They are just waiting for their time since then and also now.
Just take the good part and throw the rest away. I love mangoes but I only like the tasty part. I throw away the skin and seed. All I suggest people is to read books, as many as possible, from right, left, centre - everything. I realised through my reading that I know nothing because there is so much knowledge in this world. Just immerse yourself in the quest for knowledge. So may be you are right or maybe you are wrong about him, but who cares. Just take the good part.
@@sewaligoswami781of course nobody is perfect
Now he is father of 500 Pakistan's in India
In 1946 election, 90% of Muslim Voters voted for the partition and 90% of Hindu Voters voted against the partition. But today ironically, most Hindus are happy with the partition, since the partition prevented the rise of Jihadi politics in India.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1946_Indian_provincial_elections
For time being
Oo...W. U. Degree holder first you have to checked ☑ what is the ratio between Muslim in Pakistan and India.
At present the difference is only 4-6 crore.
Then how 90% vote in favour is illogical and factless.
What's App university data is not relevent.
Be careful 😂😂
90 percent Muslims?
And 90 percent Hindus?
Dude we were not able to achieve 90 percent voting rates till like 1990s and you are talking about 90 percent people voting in 1947
What the fuck
Also no normal civilians were after this
Only the big leaders wanted it
Most of the normal people be it hindu or Muslim didn’t wanted it
Also the Muslim leader of Sindh Rajsthan Punjab and others also dint wanted partition
It were just the rich and influential UP and Bengal muslim leaders
@@parthasarathykhiriya let me tell, UP muslim were brought as asset working population. The partition was proposed by muslim leaders hyderabadi nizams but favoured by all muslim due to kafir hatred.
Syed muzamil is from same UP , his ancestors were brought as intellectual force to run Pakistan but in UP itself they were considered least educated.
Edit: ironically none of the creator of Pakistan descendants lives in Pakistan but india be it owasi of Hyderabad or jinnah's grand son here
@@ABDULKADIR-tc2ljabe anpadh jinhone vote kiya agar vo 10 bhi the unme 9 hindu ne kiya tha aur usse 90 percent bolte hai bkl
You forgot ghaffar Khan. He predicted the same. Please try to read his book if you have not read yet.
Abul Kalam Azad is revered by all in India. He was a scholar par excellence. I thank you for bringing him in focus. Thumbs up for your intellectual analysis and regards from India
It is amazing that this great man is remembered in Pakistan, Syed Muzammil Saheb. India itself has largely forgotten him because he was extremely critical of Jawaharlal Nehru. His autobiography, which was only published in a limited run, is extremely critical of Nehru whom he blames for the Partition. I am the grandson of Savitaben Kamdar and Gijulal Kamdar on my father's side, and the Maulana was a close friend of my grandparents. At my ancestral house on 24 Broadway (long demolished) in the hall, together with pictures of my grandparents, my father and three uncles and aunts, was the Maulana's portrait. I was unfortunately born more than a decade after his passing. He was a true patriot and one of the greatest sons of India. My father's family are Hindus and they were vastly more respectful to this great man and his memory than to many of the Hindu leaders of the time. The Congress Party tried to slime him by labeling him a drunkard. The fact is that he did not drink. He was a chain smoker, though, and that was what likely took his life. Few people fought for Indian unity harder than he did.
India's educational strengths came into being because of people like Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, and at a lesser level on a local basis, Justice Basheer Ahmed Sayeed in Tamil Nadu, Dr Miss Ahmed Beevi (as she preferred being known) in Andhra, and C K Mohammed Koya in Kerala. I was fortunate in only meeting Ahmed Beevi - her brother's grandson Sikandar was a close friend of mine and the family owned a beedi factory in Nellore - the Stove Beedi Factory. When she lived, she was so highly respected that people would take their footwear off when they walked past her house. And Justice Basheer Ahmed Sayeed's daughter Dr Bader Sayeed became a Member of Parliament (I think) and remains a highly respected lady in India. Her father started the first college for women and he was the leader who together with Egypt's Gamal Abdul Nasser worked for the higher education of Muslim women.
Thank you for bringing back some amazing memories. The world is a better place - and India owes a lot - to great patriots like the great Maulana.
Right wing communal Hindus hate Maulana AZAD.
Kamdar Saheb.....a good Narration with nuggets of firsthand history.
Indeed, the role of Maulana Azad has always been underplayed in the Indian Post Independence Narrative..
Just like Netaji Subhas.
It is quite obvious that neither Gandhi or Nehru or Patel or anyone......were Visionaries or Statesmen.......they unfortunately, did not rise from the level of Petty Egoic , Self Serving Politicians, Netas.
Of course , all this is hindsight.
Muzamil ,well done. Comment Fearlessly, since you have a Critical Eye
Only by the scholars.... not by the Madressa taught mass or Mulle - Maulvis. 😊
Tell me honestly, did he not corrupt indian history with mughal valor and reduce Hindus to warring tribes and caste problems? He has been on record to be against partition as Muslims would be less weak and rhe gazwa e hind will be incomplete.
@@sreyanshuchaterjee3962 sir, why is it so hard to edgiest the truth, nothing but the truth.
Maulana Azad was education Minister of India until he died in 1958. In fact he played a very important role developing Indian education system.
He advocated the idea of universalisation of the basic education system and proposed the idea of free and compulsory education until secondary level for both boys and girls. After becoming independent, Maulana Azad made primary education a free and compulsory citizen right for children up to 14 years of age.
So he glorified mugals and others in education system
Ji aur ye hee log the jinhone mugals ko "MAHAN" banaya.
He was pro muslim only.
@@lonerid1234 kuch aur bi bato.... WhatsApp University 😂
@@anerkanttum batao sickular and Dhruv tatti university
@@mrshubham655bhai mughals ne 600 sal tak india me raj kia mughal ek empire tha tum kya cahte ho 600 sal ka history nhi padhaye??
Partition is one of the best Move by Britishers, we Hindus don't want to live with cancer.....
If the partition had not happened, our country would have been burning today and civil war would have broken out in the country
Exactly...just because pakistan is drowning they're being apologetic..generic trait of their quam to seek sympathy after attacking
Atleast we are proud to have sane young brains like Syed Muzamil who can filter out all the noise and bring the real meaningful dialogue for thought provoking analysis. Thank you Muzamil for your yet another brilliant vlog.
😂😂😂
This is what gives me hope that Pakistan is changing & will change to better Insha Allah. When the world is becoming far extremist, Pakistan is calming because we're already reaping what our elders sowed.
yes, but if they will let him do his job? We know how Paki army pick up any one and then guy disappear or toe their line.
Dear Muzzamil
I place on record that you are the best blogger from India and Pakistan. My salutation . Pakistanis should use your intelligence and knowledge to improve pakistan.
It’s amazing how little Pakistan is informed of great Muslim leaders of India. Thanks for doing this video
Punjaab is not Pkistan bro, KHutbaat e Azad is a common book in Karachi
It is a deliberate manipulation of history in Pakistan to create disdain and hatred against India - taught from kindergarten onwards - because as Azad said, if you found a country on hatred then you have to keep hating otherwise your country breaks apart.
Pakistan doesn't acknowledge muslims who talk of unity. They only love muslims who divide and want wars with other communities based on religion
@@smnabil Actually punjab is the pakistan. 😅
Stop saying, Muslim leader, he was an Indian leader, we don't say Muslim or Hindu in everything.
We Bangladeshi people still remember him with great solemnity and respect.
Bangali be grateful to Bharat for rescuing from pakis in 71
No you remember. To me Azad is a Gamdu Indian PorkJeet.
My Grandparents came from Village Badiana District Sialkot in 1947
My Grandfather met with Late Dr. Azad and he said to my Grandfather, I lost Mr. Mukherjee, I lost to keep India intact. 🇮🇳 ❤
We can't change the past, but we can change the present & the future ❤
Good 👍 that azad lost otherwise I cannot imagine entire Pakistan inside India 😅
@@shankarcg786 actually, even without the" entire Pakistan inside India", we now have a new breed of goondutva.rightwing extremos who will turn our beloved S E C U L A R India into a dharmic varmic kattarpanti/mazhabhi inteha pasandi Pakistan..........same daku mentality, same genetics?????
He wanted Muslim to stay United. Imagine those 40-45% would have made our lives hell in india.
In a way we won , still some of them are left behind..
I am an Indian, and always knew that Azad was one of the most respected Indian statesmen from the Independence era, but I did no know how historically perceptive he was. Syed, thank you for this video.
Lol. You know very little about the man. Dont rush to declare him a saint😂
@@theprovocateur24 I havent heard Bhakts providing any sort of prediction which tests the water let alone test the time.
@@rajeshbista2690 in prediction ki sources kya hai kuch bhi bachhodo pel do
In an interview in1946, he made the predictions....
CREATION OF PAKISTAN WAS A HUGE BLUNDER OF BRITISH AGENT JINNAH. PAKISTAN IS A CURSE AND SLAP ON THE FACE OF PAKISTSNI MUSLIMS. RULERS OF PSKISTAN ARE MOST DANGEROUS DICTATORS ON THIS PLANETS. POLITICIANS, LIKE ZARDARI-SHARIFF, ARE TOP RATED THIEVES IN THE WORKD. ARMY GENERALS AND POLITICIANS ARE READY TO SELL OUT PSKISTAN. It is harsh but factual truth.
"People plant trees, but not everyone sees the fruit.
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad is a hero for people in subcontinent. He spent his life fighting for a united and free India. He wasn't just into politics; he was also a great writer and poet. Azad started the education system in India and was the President of All India Congress.
What makes Azad special is his idea that religion can bring people together. This philosophy is something all Muslims, especially in places like Pakistan, should think about for progress."
He is responsible for the messy situation of muslims in india. Check the sachr committee report.
If he truly believed Islam taught its followers to coexist with non-Muslims, then I am very inclined to believe that he had not understood Islamic teachings well.
For instance , I wonder what his opinion was of Hadith 2922 cited in the Hamas Charter?
By the way what were his educational qualifications?
@@Faqr-e-Ghayoor Pakistan government should do something similar for hindus in pakistan.
"What makes Azad special is his idea that religion can bring people together"
i bet he will not gonna like the same from other religions on muslims.
Of course he hasn't seen the fruit, Gujrat riots, Ram mandir and his own family, these are the fruits.
Definitely a man way ahead of his time. A true gem.
It did not talk about Indian Muslims who have become second class citizens in India. There is hatred against them, their rights should be taken away, Muslims should be talked about, they too had to be talked about. 🙏🙏🙏
Hello brother,
I am from India and I'm very happy to see that young people like you is critically analyzing the root causes which is responsible for persistent inconsistency and turmoil in Pakistan.
Keep going, God bless you
Be aware of him. He does speak bitter truth of Pakistan, but he is equally poisonous about Bharat. He left no stone unturned to defame our PM Modi…. Watch his previous videos
@@manishainamdar6393 thanku for your concerns manisha ji, and yes you're right.
Nonetheless we can only hope for best, otherwise 90,000 will change to 9 Cr.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@@manishainamdar6393: Pakistanis are Pakistanis, no matter how good they are.
तू मुस्लिम बन जा
Have a heart plz...
We Indians celebrate his birthday(nov 11th)as National education day of India.🫡🫡
Birthday of a maulana celebrated as national education day? Scientist Abdul Kalam is understable but maulana azad’s birthday is education day?
@RealRandomVideos Maulana Abul Kalam Azad was the first education minister of India and he was the one responsible for the vision of iit/iim and other visionary educational schemes.
@@abhishekrajpoot5756 He was a jahil Mussalmaan. Don't buy this "secular" propaganda. Read what he wrote. He wanted to convert all of India to the death cult of Islam.
@@RealRandomVideos he was our first education minister and we admire his policies. We believe in ideology of WORK IS WORSHIP and we respect those who worship their work irrespective of their religion. Another example of this is, There is a cricket stadium and a College in Jammu city after his NAME too.
Proves that we Indians aren't less stupid
You have used the right word as "prophetic predictions"! K.Azaad was so accurate so precise and it's astonishing.
مزمل صاحب آپکی ولیگ خوشائند ھے اور معلوماتی ھے مولانا صاحب کے تمام پیشنگوئیاں درست آور ھم آپنی آنکھوں سے دیکھ رہے ہیں
*Maulana Abul Kalam Azad on his speech on October 23rd, 1947 at Jama Masjid, Delhi*
" It was not long ago when I warned you that the two-nation theory was death-knell to a meaningful, dignified life; forsake it. I told you that the pillars upon which you were leaning would inevitably crumble. To all this you turned a deaf ear. You did not realize that, my brothers! I have always attempted to keep politics apart from personalities, thus avoiding those thorny valleys. That is why some of my messages are often couched in allusions. The Partition of India was a fundamental mistake. The manner in which religious differences were incited, inevitably, led to the devastation that we have seen with our own eyes. Unfortunately, we are still seeing it at some places. There is no use recounting the events of the past seven years, nor will it serve any good. Yet, it must be state that the debacle of Indian Muslims is the result of the colossal blunders committed by the Muslim League’s misguided leadership. These consequences however, were no surprise to me; I had anticipated them from the very start.”
Abdul Kalam was a radical muslim who didn't want partition, only because he realised that if partition happened it will be very difficult to achieve gazwa e hind. Like all muslim leaders of those days he hated hindus and their ideology. He was supported by his closet muslim friend Nehru. 🎉
@@venkatganapathy3123 I think your high on drugs lol
Hmmmmmmm...... Hopeless
@@JJ-xo3bche is so right brother.
@@JJ-xo3bc I agree with the part that Nehru wanted to supress Hindu polity. I agree that Abdul Kalam was against Partition as it would have decreased the political power of Muslims in India. First the Muslim population in the subcontinent got divided once and again into three parts in 1971. 1947 is weakened Islamic political power in the Subcontinent and then again in 1971 Islamic political power weakened further. Abdul Kalam brainwashed the indian population with his education policy that he implemented as the first education minister of India. Only after social media and the emergence of alternate scholarship that was able to counter the mainstream that Abdul Kalam's sinister designs to brainwash India population to further his goals of maintain the powers of Muslim feudals in India has faced push-back. Without liberalization in 1991 it was not possible. In way a you could say India bankrupting itself in 1991 directly helped the resurgence of the Hindu culture into the mainstream.
I am from India. And I am still unable to digest that what was the need of creation of Pakistan if not the fulfillment of desires of few riches. I don't support Akhand Bharat etc(bcz I don't want highly radical time bombs in my country). But very sad that Pakistan is just on the path as told by Azad sahab.
BJP RSS has put us also on the same path that Azad warned..........cannot behave like Pakistan and want to be progressive developed like S E C U L A R democratic nations like US CDA AUS UK (Christian, but chose to be secular, instead of dharmic varmic like India.........mazhabi like Pakistan)
@@primordialarchetypes2927 lol...
Dear whatsapp university scholar do study hard to know the main theme of Akhand Bharat...stop following your godfather pappu gandhi...be real
It was a blessing in disguise. 😊
Islam cannot co-exist with a liberal society. Just look around. In any direction. West or East.
Mind blowing facts:
- 90% Muslims voted for Pakistan, 90% Hindus against it. But today Hindus are happy with it and Muslims are divided!
- An atheist (pork eater) Jinnah made a religious nation and a religious man Gandhi wanted a secular/undivided nation.
- Two nation theory became Three nation theory. Muslims can live with Hindus (eg india). But can’t live with other Muslims! (Eg: Bangladesh).
Partition had lot of ironies!
Asa ak hindu hi bol sakta h
Mr. Muzammil , you are a credit to your country.
Your level headed , logical, well researched, discussions are a pleasure to listen to.
Maulana AZAD also warned the Muslims who were migrating to Pakistan not to go there ,because the four Tribal Provences ,Punjabis, Sindhis ,Balochis and Pathans will not accept you , and the same happened with Mohair's they were left alone.
Azad was absolutely right about his prediction.
loru muhajirs are living peacfully in punjab & sindh, & there are no muhajirs in kpk & baloch because they wont accept them
Bull.... Just because Pakistan os going down today everyone including people of our own soil like muzammil shah are busy spanking the very ideology of this country. And for what? A few dollars more. @muzammil shame on you
So can you tell me indians muslims how many muslims are there in India and how many CM's are there for Muslims in India. Because you always pretend you are happy there you never want Pakistan??? 😂😂
@@imtiazfaruqui9729 Islam spread by bigotry and forcible conversion of other people. Pakistan is falling the same.
Being a Pakistani it is hard to digest the discourse.Perhaps it is what it was GENTLEMAN!
My foot
I am just amazed at the honest and forthright approach Muzammil sahab takes. Especially in a country like Pakistan.
Amazing. I learned so much here. Everything Maulana Azad said, points to Islam fanaticism. Islam used to get people’s support for their own benefits.
You can still acknowledge your mistakes and reunite with Bharat.
paXthan won't last for even 100 years. A country, who's one & only purpose is to hate it's origin, deny it's history and create terrorists to hurt it's neighbor, is not a real country.
That has been the case since its inception, very first converts also embraced it for their own personal gains.
Is moulana silent on Hindu fanatics?
@@Faqr-e-GhayoorHindu fanatics are a small minority in India. Muslim fanatics are a fanatical majority in Pakistan .. focus on your problems which are even bigger than trying ng to deflect
@@user-mk4vi5vq6g Very first converts were brutally tortured to an extent they had to leave their home town Makkah. Talk more about the personal gains here
Absolutely amazing - how far sighted and prescient was Maulana Azad.
But he also redicolis by mugal history
Maulana Azad was also the first education minister of India. The very intersting fact is that , he never been to any school and college but still he has knowledge like scholars. 👏👏👏👏
😂lol and you still believe he had knowledge 😂 he add mughals in indian education and remove hindu kings this tells how secular he was😂
also their main purpose to convert Hindus of india is directly or indirectly seen in prediction no. 2
@@GyanTvAmit Nahi bhai sari knowledge tumhe hai. Tumhe banade edication minister!!
@@GyanTvAmitwhat about you, are you secular. Please read again your comment. You are just andhbakht of mod'si card
True, knowledge like madrassa educated "scholars".
@syed Muzammil Official, I am a Hindu from India, living in Canada, and been watching your video for quite a time, and really like your views and thoughts on various topic, especially on India and Pakistan shared history and position right now.
So, thanks 🙏🏽
I am from India but I must appreciate your facts and unbiased opinions
If Dogs got a Holy book which tells them to Bite Everyone who is not a dog I would be afriad of Every dog and the fact that some dogs dont bite wouldn't change my mind
@@kaffir8216 kehna kya chahte ho?
His grandson actor Amir Khan weds his daughter with a hindo. This was his wisdom
I'm astonished. Azaad was a visionary person more than Jinnah. And his every prediction became true...
Jinnah - a visionary??
@@ravish05 He was a good lawyer and politician. But he didn't have a vision to lead Like Azaad sir.
@@shahbazali4982 agree.. he wanted to win his case and got Pakistan. He won but people of the subcontinent lost.
@@ravish05he didn’t win,he was planted and was given this role by British
Most important thing is that's he is first education minister of our country he gives IIT. International level engineering college and AIIMS international level medical college ........Im the starting jinna also a good politician and no doubt a good lawyer but jinnah ambitious and western culture influence person live nicely and well dressed after Gandhi bahut sare politicians ko laga ki yaar hamara naam nhi ho rha to wo congres switch kar gye jinnah England chala gya with 18 years old beautiful parsi girl at the age of 40 and some landlord approach and called india again'
What a co incident. I was searching for Kalam’s prediction of Pakistan for a few days and couldn’t find satisfactory answer and here you come..
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad & Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam both are different people FYI
I'm from India(buddhisht)🇮🇳.... Love all of you pakistani🇵🇰
You are doing very good work and give knowledgeble contant.।।
Keep it bro 🤜😎
Bhimta , maharashtra se hai kya?
Dr Ambedkar ne kaha tha kattar musalmano se bacho .
The difficulties we as Indian Muslims face is because of Pakistan.
Lol
True
If you just integrate in society nothing bad will happen I see so many indian moulvis who silently supports Pakistan it is only reaction of those things
Yes 💯....their every action against india impacts the indian muslims directly or indirectly.
The difficulties that you Indian muslims face is due to your devotion to Pakistan.
Thank God Partition happened we Indians are saved. Agar population exchange ho jata toh Bharat aur Zaldi tarakki kar leta.
Population usse jyada exchange hota to aadha india pakistan me chala jaata. Sardar patel ko pata tha, nhi to jyada muskil nhi tha population exchange karna. Pakistan me jitna land mass hai utne me pura muslim popuation nhi aati to aur india divide hota.
@@luciferzomer7479 aisa kuch nahi kyunki Bharat ke 90% Muslim Pakistan ke favour mein vote kiya tha toh har haal mein unko chale jana tha lekin begairat nahi gaye
@@luciferzomer7479
No. At the time of partition, Hindu population was 28 crores n muslim population around 3.5 crores. In fact, Dr. Ambedkar had asked Nehru to go for complete exchange of Hindus n muslims. But Nehru declined that. Had it happened, India would have been a much better place, today.
Sahi hai bhai hum बच gaye warna in janwaro ne hamare Hindustan ko bhi barbad kar dete...
Those who didn’t have to be displaced or whose loved ones weren’t killed don’t get to have an opinion about how great partition was. Those who pride themselves on being Indian should see what happens to non-secular countries and stop dreaming of a non-secular India.
Thanks for your efforts to help to find the truthness of last 75 years.
Best ever v.log.
Love you for that x.
ایک قابل لیڈر کے لیئے شرط ہے اس میں دور اندیشی ہو اس لیے مولانا ابوالکلام آزاد ہی سب سے قابلِ مسلمان لیڈر تھے اس وقت
Hundred percent correct, late Azad was a great personality knows everything what is happening.
This amazing lecture should be part of the school curriculum. We have a lot to learn from the great Maulana .....................sadly, we refuse to learn from history & insist on repeating the same mistakes.
Thanks you for researching this scholarly work & making us aware of a significant contribution by this great scholar, gentleman & human being.
True....
Really!!!
Worth listening this legend. Sanatani Buddhist Nepali residing in Canada 🙏🙏
A load of bull.
If he truly was secular, and supposedly an islamic scholar, he should have started a movement to remove the usage of the word kaffir in Islam, and asked for establishment of temples in Mecca and medina just the way mosques exist in ayodhya , Kashi and mathura.
He should have ensured that every symbol of Hindu humiliation like the Babri, gyanvyapi are treated as such, and asked for a seperate mosque rather than pray at those sites.
He was a opportunist who modernized everyone else but lacked the will to do the same for his own, he ensured that a piece of the pie was retained for his community- minority status, minority institutions etc...
All these originate from lightbulbs like this Maulana.
But these guys will never accept the real problem is Islam. The theology puts rascals in power😏🧐
Buddhist cannot be sanatani
@@rahulmranade kya re bhimte
Dear Muzammil Sahib
Assalamoalaikum.
I have been a great admirer of you since I started following you.
Your honest and truthful reviews unfolding the bitter realities of our country,s politicians, administrators and our nation especially our today's youth are commendable.
It needs a lot of inner courage and strength.
Please keep up the good work.
May Allah Subhanatallah shower His blessings upon you.
Syed, this was known to all Indians of my previous generation, I e 2 generations before you. But it equally unbelievable that you are analyzing it! May Lord Almighty bless you. Stay safe.
کچھ چیزیں تب ہی سمجھ آتی ہیں جب وہ ہو جاتی ہیں۔۔۔اگر ہم الگ نہ ہوئے ہوتے۔۔۔تو الگ ملک لینے کا کیڑا ابھی تک ہمیں تنگ کر رہا ہوتا۔
Now reunion movements should prevail. ❤
@@visualdropletsno need....
بھائی مجھے پاکستان کی ریاست سے ہزار اختلاف ہیں لیکن پاکستان کا نظریہ ہمیشہ سے درست تھا اور فلسطین کا حال دیکھ کر اب میرا پاکستان پر یقین اور پختہ ہو گیا ہے۔ باقی جس کو غیروں کی غلامی کا کیڑا کاٹ رہا ہے وہ بخوشی افغانستان اور بھارت روانہ ہو سکتا ہے۔
Bhai hamare yah bhe gutter hae
Agree, i m from India. Many Indians r unhappy with partition. But my generation today lot of em realise it was very good decision. Probably with United hindu muslim India, India wud have been very poor with no growth even today. It wud have been a Hell hole with almost no science tech & modern education . Communities wud have been in constant fight with each other and regular riots. Hindus who have emerges to reform and modernise with time and still reforming wud have never happened. Hindus wud have been More fundamentalist like Moslems . Partition relieved Indian Hindus of Muslim threat and their Past. This ensured the left wing Congress rises and push reforms and make Hindus accept their Religion Problems. Also Rare conflicts has allowed peaceful atmosphere to Invite large Investment.
Also the 15% muslims who have remained in India has Kept Hindus on their toes to remain united to a level. And keep accepting reforms specially in terms of caste. The ethnic and caste divide has been overcome by Showing these Muslims as others instead of creating othering within Hindus themselves . I know this is bad for 15% muslims but i m not going to lie.
Islam has one holy book, one prophet and essentially one belief system. In spite of this, Islam could not keep Pakistan and Bangladesh together and the country broke up. Hinduism has thousands of different belief systems, folk practices and beliefs and at least 9 well-developed schools of thought and people believe that despite these differences Hinduism will be enough to keep India together. Actually, it was never about Hinduism and Islam, but the fact that Pakistan was formed on exclusivism and hate as a basis of it's identity that led to its downfall. Once exclusivism was stressed as the basis of Pakistani identity, that identity started becoming more and more exclusive and its definitions narrower and narrower...pehle Pakistan is buniyaad pe banaa ke hum Musalman hain, hum Hinduon se alag hain or Musalman Hinduon ke saath nahi reh sakte, uski buniyaad positive identity par nahin balki nafrat par thi...ek baar Hindu aur Sikh khatam ho gaye nafrat uske baad bhi nafrat lekin waapas botal mein nahi gai....jin bewakoofon ko tumne izzat aur taakat de di thi, wo log nafrat ke oxygen pe palte the aur naye naye identity dhoondhte rahe nafrat ke liye...ahmedi, bangali, Muhajir, shia, Hazara etc etc....In contrast, India did not stress Hindu identity but secularism and acceptance as its core value and stayed together despite being (possibly) the most diverse country in the world.....
For Indians, we need to learn from Pakistan's history...if we go down that same road, we will get the same results....don't forget it took them 30-40 years for the results to start showing in the everyday lives of citizens....aaj hum aage hain apne pichli 30-40 saal ki decisions ki wajaah se aur aaj jo kar rahein hain uska fal humein agle 30-40 saal mein milega....
For Pakistanis and muslims who say present day India shows you how valid two-nation theory is- you should consider that in every system different variables interact, react and influence each other....even among brothers - if one brother is consistently bullying, influences his own way and captures your property, sooner or later the other brother is not going to treat them well....iska matlab ye nahi hai ke aisa hona tayy tha....shayad agar doosra bhai theek se pesh aata, to dono bhai saath mein reh sakte the....
Before criticising the other, we both need to look in our own girebaan...There are so, so many things to talk about but I just want Indian viewers to think about this, as I know many Indians will come here to watch your video and gloat on our 'superiority'.
I will just add one more point (among many others I believe in)- Jinnah (post-Congress and retirement in England) and Savarkar (post- kaala pani) were british agents....to understand this, dont follow their speeches and words but follow their actions...ask how much time they spent in British jails after they started spouting religion based nationalism...look at who they supported when nationalist movement was at peak (like what was their attitude to movements such as Quit India movement or to supporting the British with Indian manpower and resources when the British desperately needed help during world war 2)....you will find a remarkable similarity in their actions and support/criticism....aur to aur, people who made their entire ideology about Hindus and Muslims not being able to live together, even shook hands and came together to share power when Congress provincial governments resigned ...and it was in one such mili-jhuli sarkar which had Hindu Mahasabha in government that the Pakistan bill was first passed....LOL, Gaddar the ye haraamkh0r.....aur jo inhe poojte hain wo awaal darje ke bewakoof....when people say ke Jinnah ne badi kurbaniyaan di.....ask them how much time he spent in jail since leading Muslim League, compare that to the years that were spent by Nehru, Gandhi, Azad, Patel and Badshah Khan and you will know who the British thought were their enemy and who their friend....
First read what islam says about non believers.Don't think you're smarter than others if you don't broaden your perspective
Intelligent personality.
Love from India
Unbelievable🤨 Predictions, So Uncanny and Eerily True. Many thanks for doing this Sir from Canada!!
Quick reminder for any Pakistani who might think/comment here "Thank you Jinnah" on what they perceive is happening in India these days... When Muslims of minority provinces approached Jinnah and asked him what would happen of them this is what he had to say - Kanpur on March 30, 1941, "in order to liberate seven crores of Muslims where they were in a majority I am willing to perform the last ceremony of martyrdom, if necessary, and let two crores of Muslims be smashed". Pls don't come n preach what about Modi etc.... your "Qaid E Azam" and his fan boys CONDEMNED us (Indian Muslims) to death (SMASHED, his words) .. After condemning us to death you have NO RIGHT to preach anything..... Not only we survived but thrived and will continue to, thanks to our hindu brothers and sisters... Even today Modi government gives crores and crores rupees worth of support to the pasmanda Muslims of India... Treat your minorities with the respect and equality they deserve please. Your actions towards minorities gave rise to the popularity of right wing in India.. its a direct reaction.....
So your telling me Indian Hindus are so educated that what happens in another sovereign state was enough for them to not only turn their backs on but actually oppress their own countrymen? So much so that they are on the world genocide watch list, several academics and historians have warned of a potential genocide and to quote one of your own politicians Shashi Tharoor: “I never thought it would be safer in India to be a cow than a Muslim”.
@@SK-rt8yn I understand...just sick and tired of reading this nonsense "Thank you Jinnah" each time there is news of attacks on some muslims in India... Jinnah himself condemned ALL Indian Muslims to death... I had to type it coz most of these people comment the aforementioned rarely read books except the fables they are taught in school or Nasim Hijazi type fiction...
You will not understand how happy comments like these make me, an Indian Hindu. Live and let live, have a growth mindset, respect each others religion and focus on development for all!❤
Too long didn't read and Thank you Jinnah
Can you please give me the reference of Jinnah's speech?
Wonderfully explained the facts of Pakistan, hopefully the nation will get some ideas where they stand today and put some concrete efforts to set the right direction for coming generations - Thank you
I laugh whenever someone uses the word "muslim ummah", basically that means they heard their friday sermon from an illiterate man and believed it. Even in Sunni sect there is no unity, salafism, wahabism are cannibalising traditional Sunni muslims who held moderate views on politics, religion. From Turkey to Japan, only in India that minority sects of Islam not just live but prosper. Members of Borah community are not just richest Muslims but richest Indians. Go to bazaars of Mumbai and some of the richest Muslim businessmen belong to Shia and Bora community. Every other Muslim country represses their minorities even smaller sects of Islam, only difference is the degree to which they oppress them.
Absolutely true
Kya Sixer mara hai...bro...😅😅👍🏻
Itna sach bhi nhi bolna tha bhai, let them live in a Umma lala land .😂
Where did you learn this BS from? Majority of Muslims in India are below the poverty line.
@@asfandyar5570 they are called pasmanda Muslims(lower caste Muslims) and they are below poverty line for a reason. Muslim leaders never encouraged education or critical thinking amongst Muslim society. They feared education will bring modernity amongst masses and thus reducing their power. So rich and powerful Muslims got their kids educated in best schools and sent them abroad for further studies meanwhile their community was never allowed to even pass 10th.
*Thats Because Maulana Abul Kalam Azad Sir Was A Prominent And Visionary Politician with Rational Mind .. Azad Sir Ne Kaafi Sare Muslim Leaders Ke Views Kafi Kareebi Se Jaane Including Jinnah And Other Muslim League Muslim Politicians which gave him quite clear view of Future Social and Political Vulnerability of Pakistan* .. 💯
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad was a genius… He was first Education Minister of India He changes and brought many reforms in Indian Education System…
I am impressed with your openness, fearlessness, and the way you have taken the bull by its horns. The very fact that I mention fearlessness as a virtue and strength for a vlogger is a sad commentary on the State of politics. Please know that we in India really wish you well; though we are being selfish because a prosperous and peace loving neighbour is a blessing for us. Too much time and resources have been lost in the last 75 years. Imagine the opportunities lost for both countries if from 1947 itself we would have just focused on development and growth alone instead of fighting. I have always maintained that it takes only one true and genuine leader to change the fortunes of a country. May your country be blessed with one such leader!
Amazing..my view of Muslims and Islam is changing. For me, the intricacies of Indian spirituality was first explained to be my friend Irfan Moosa. With so balanced commentators, the future is still bright
Shit islam destroyed 100s of civilizations ,it's ones brutal idea to spread hatred in the name of peace😢😢😢
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad was 100% correct about Pakistan. Thanks to him for deciding to stay in India and founded IITs.
he was not responsible for starting IITs
Azad did not founded IIT. It was Mr.Roy who persuaded Nehru to form IIT. Azad only inaugurated IIT.
Please read more.
We have a concept called KARMA
Forced conversations , breaking religious places like temple and churches are enough for the situation that this country is in
One tip : protect the 1% minority left in this country they might as well save this country from KARMA
I'm a Hindu from Uttar Pradesh (United Provinces of British India) and I have many Muslim friends like Farhaz, Shadab and so many. I never felt that they are different from us. We all invite each other to our home. Marriage is not a very common thing between two communities but it happens on the understanding of two families. Riots between Hindu and Muslims happened in the past but it's not a thing anymore. There are hardliner hindu and Muslims but there are liberal Hindus and Muslims as well and that's why things get managed eventually.
Hinduism amd Islam have very different cultural ethos but people have one thing to live with each other that's mutual understanding. India is birth place of Sanatani philosophy , Buddhism, Jainism so as Muslims are emotionally connect with Mecca and Medina we are emotionally connect with vedas and Kashi, Somnath, Ram temple..
Sab mamla understanding he ...that is enough in common people but not in politicians , election jeetane ke liye kuchh bhi... Ram ji aaye hein ...29 mein Krishan ji aaynge ...33 min Shivji tandav karenge ...Agar Yamraj nahi aaye tab tak
Then why were they live together from 1000 year... And why they separated in 200 years 1757 to 1947
@@shamsherbahadur5570Hindutva is mainly reactionist to the extremist muslims and intolerant form of ISLAM..
@@ashfaqahmad6910that's not living together if I invades your country beats you convert you and then said we were living peacefully after that 💀 ese toh Palestinians or Israeli bhi peacefully hi reh rahe the kafi waqt se
@shamsherbahadur5570 ofcourse it will give political advantage to BJP. Unke manifesto me likha tha ki agar unki government bani toh wo Shree Ram mandir banwayene.
Partition was the best thing which happened for India. Otherwise, Jihadi politics would have hampered the development of India. Although, most Hindus opposed the partition in 1947, today most Hindus are happy that partition happened, which freed India from religious fanatism.
🙏🏽🇮🇳🙏🏽
A Hindu fanatic talking about Muslim fanatics is nothing but hypocrisy. I would have agreed if Hindus were a tolerant people. But looking at their extreme hatred towrds Muslims, I have to support the separation.
As an indian i can mock but save this man & listen & follow
Great video, Best of luck!
An enlightened discourse, as always. Thank you for your efforts Muzammil! 🙏🏻
If Dogs got a Holy book which tells them to Bite Everyone who is not a dog I would be afriad of Every dog and the fact that some dogs dont bite wouldn't change my mind
There are doubts about whether Azad was religious. Some say he was agnostic. But he definitely could see through the hearts n souls of people he grew up around n knew that something was not right about them
He was religious in personallife but was secular in political life
He was first education minister of independent India.
He was a Moulana for crying out loud. He didn't study in school, hence, Science & high school science wasn't part of his home schooling.
A bit ironic if that was the case, since he was born in Mecca.
@@FreddieMurphy746ex Muslims are usually those who study religion most deeply
Though i ageee with Azad predictions but how India has become intolerable society especially for muslims, the current Hinduvata movement compel progressive muslims to celebrate partition, sir thought on this ?
Then how muslim population in india exploded from 3 crore to 21 crore inspite of pakistan and Bangladesh
Maluana Abul Kalam Azad is one of the respectable figures in Indian independence history. We have a National Institute of Technology on his name since 50 years named as MANIT Bhopal, one of the premier engineering institutes of India. Unfortunately Pakistanis couldn’t see his predictions and finally all who moved to Pakistan are still suffering in one of the most unstable country of world named Pakistan. If they would have been stayed in India probably they could have become part of growth of India - 4th largest economy of the world.
If and only if Hindus had not been so cruel and unjust to Muslims at that time.....
@ali19231 Yep they compare themselves to other South Asian beggar countries and feel happy standards are too low here.
@@HMS_101😂😂😂😂😂 Hindus suffered a lots by Muslim , in Calcutta they started massacre of Hindus . Read how Jinnah fuelled it .
I have studied from the Maulana Azad Medical College located on the Bahadur Shah Zafar Road in Delhi. It is one of the best medical colleges in India with 3 hospitals attached to it.
as a person from bharat i agree these poeple have habits of flexing their muscle or showing superiority towards Pakistan which is a failed or vassal state they have never compared with china which is mighty @ali19231
Mr Muzamil, please read Dr BR Ambedkar's book on Pakistan 🙏🙏
It will be blasphemy😂😂 in pakistan , he is one of the greatest Indian , they cannot have Dr BR Ambedkar their society cannot handle one. You get leaders you deserve
He can't I guess , Pak's molvis and establishment would punish him.
Ya all are really obsessed with us. Get a fuckin life i guess 🫠
@@MuhammadMehdi-cx5is it is available for download for free online.
And create a video
He was also the man who as the first education minister of Independent India shoved Mughal history down our throats as the only history worth learning about along with Congress’s tales of heroism for freedom. We should critique him for these terrible ideas too, if we give him props for many good deeds also done. We have a far longer and much richer civilisational history that was needed to be known by the masses.
Agreed to an extent. He did portray some Muslim rulers in a positive manner but he did portray many Muslim invaders in a negative manner.
Further India followed federalism in education also. So respective State government can draft their own versions of regional histories.
Basically he tried to built an overall harmonious history which do not promote Hate against muslims. Because he already saw that if you build a nation on the basis of Hate then what are the consequences. For example pakistan.
So I would suggest that if he was not Right in doing so but he absolutely right to serve a stable political and economic future of India.
@@hemalbhatt4055It’s not a question of portraying the Mughals in a good or bad light. The fact remains why was it the majority chunk of indian history taught in schools. Didn’t we have a lot more important historical figures and events that we should have been taught? Why this bias? Is it because he associated with them and thought he was a descendant of theirs, whereas he most probably was a convert like most of the current indian subcontinent muslims are.
"Harmonious history"
This is what you call narrative building.
History should be put as it is !@@hemalbhatt4055
@@hemalbhatt4055We have the right to know the truth.Besides,if you are teaching all secular education,then why have madrassas.Pakistan was non muslim before islam.Muslims were humans.Now they think non believers have to be killed
Azad sir's Predictions, as far as Pakistan is concerned, was 100 percent correct, like what Nostradamus predicted, and of course Winston Churchill had said in his speech. Very nice compilation bro, superb. Thanks for an eye opener, if I may say so.
He was our first and probably the best education minister ever since. IIT and IIM are the brainchild of this great man, of course incited by JN. Today, his idea of centre of excellence makes Indians shine in the world.
The sad thing is atound 40 % did fall for it.
I am Indian muslim, 3rd gen of Azad India. Since I started reading and gaining knowledge about partition incidents. I feel as if "It was a personal Hatred " of one person Jinnah that created Pakistan. When he was offered to be the first PM of India,, his sentence was some what ,, even if he became the first PM of India ,, in future he will loose because Muslims are not in majority.
If his idea of creating a new country was because of religion. His reply would be " I don't want to be a pm,, I want a Islamic nation ".
Ridiculous claim. It is to say why Indians got independence from the British. Jinnah did good, his successors didn't. Simple
@saddozaiproduction it's not a claim, it's a fact. Once you do some research on him , you can get to know him easily.
He wanted a Islamic country that would be on Sharia law. Alhumdulillah very nice.
But did he Drink Alcohol? Did he Ate pork? He did he prayed regularly?
Once he got offended because in a party a British women gave his wife a shawl to cover herself because of her outfit.
His Mother was a Kadiyani , father converted to Islam, wife a parsi, daughter a parsi.
Forcefully removed from hindu viillage and Community because of fishing business and convention to Islam.
That thing made a bad impact on his mind. He hated Hindus, but he was not a Sharia law abiding muslim.
I am not questioning his muslim faith, but from history what I have known about him. I could say that such a person asking for a Islamic Sharia law country is totally opposite to what he himself was doing.
Incorrect. The claim that Muslims cannot live with kafirs goes back to the middle of 19th century. Please read history. Very few do.
@bmniac A muslim cannot do migration from a majority Muslim country to a non-Muslim country. The intention of migration should be only dawah ( teach Islam in that country) .
Rasool Allah SWA was in Macca , and very few accepted Islam ,,, did he migrated because everyone was Kafir?
No. The migration was done to Madina, after few years , even though there were more Muslims in Macca than Madina.
And when most of the muslims migrated to Madina, Islam was taught to the people of Madina. They accepted Islam.
A muslim in Majority non muslim country can do migration to a non muslim country. But, someone who is already born in a non muslim country , Islam doesn't say he have to migrate to a muslim country.
@@ikram11003 aapke naam me ram hai 😊❤
We are greatful to almighty in whichever form who gave us Maulana Azad to our country. A true human being who respected being human first. We will do our best to carry his legacy forward
I proud to be an Indian Muslim
No need to lie.We Indians know how 'proud' you are and where your loyalty lies
@@apurvabhide2860bro saying after demanding hindu rashtra 😅😅
اللہ تعالیٰ ہم سب کو ہدایت دے۔
Thank you Muzammil. As always you bring eye opening content. Pakistan has a great future if it listens to you and allows intellectuals like you to flourish.
Ñot possible it's a billion dollar enterprise
Excellent analysis, wonderful approach, Thank you so much.
More young men like you are required in Pakistan for it's survival
Proudly as an Indian I can say Maulana Azad is one of the best Indian statesmen ever produced!
We own him and cherish his work regardless of Muslim or what ever the religion. We don’t care at the end of the day what matters is he is a patriotic Indian !
Muzzamil sir aap logo ko nhi pta hoga maulana Azad K baare me lekin hum Hindustanis ko unke baare me waise h padhaya jata hai jaise baaki deshbhakt K baare me padhaya jata hai 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thank you so much
Your analysis is outstanding
A real knowledgeable person like you. The way you argue the points of political scholars and great historians is amazing. I have never seen a more brave creator like u in pak. Thank you for all the times that made you like this.❤
True that
The thing is Many brave people like Muzammil have been missing lately.....
“there will be muslims in pakistan but not islam” such a shameful dark truth.
and i’m proud say that we have people like you to guiding our nation, providing light in the darkness.
You are wrong. The Muslims in Pakistan practice true Islam.
We pushtoons even voted against Muslim league in 1947 and congress win the election but qaid e Azam by force invaded pushtoon Territories and Balochistan, Quaid Azam ordered army to kill pushtoons in congregation at babra😢
punjab also voted against partition
Bhai konsi sasti charas pi kar history parh li hy? Pushtoon ny kab Pakistan k against vote kiya tha. Jaisa sasta intellectual sunty ho waisi sasti opinion rakhty ho
😢😢😢yes.. I lost my ancestors! I'm pastooni but now live in 4th generation in srinagar kashmir india 🇮🇳and now sukoon hai! Pakistani army politics is so bad 😢
@@abdullahgull60921946 election ka result search karo pyaaray
Lol, look at the results of referendum.
Hi Bhai,
First of all big salute and appreciation for presenting the facts the way you do it, living in Pakistan and presenting like this need courage that I can see you are full with.
My ancestors were from Sindh and moved to India after partition, my grand pa used to say they didn’t wanted to leave their mother land buy were forced to , anyhow , in the current state of Pakistan, I hope things get better soon from here , and I am sure they will, because even if 10% of people understand and follow what you are presenting, it will bring huge difference .
I wish you all the best , let the two nations progress and prosper together .
You will not believe it but most Hindus and BJP are firm believers in the two nation theory today …Hindus and Muslims are like chalk and cheese , we don’t interdine , we don’t intermarry, we don’t live amongst each other ..our heroes are your villains and your heroes are our villains . Our civilisational paths are different . The greatest mystery for Hindus is as to why all Muslims did not leave for Pakistan in the first place in 1947. Today Muslims are unpopular with Hindus, Jews, Christians, Buddhists and even Chinese communists are having problems in Xinjiang
First of all, most Hindus are not BJP. After this election, at least that much must be clear. You didn't even convince half the Hindus. Most Hindus and even Vajpayee sahb looked at the Partition as a tragedy in which millions died. Most Hindus have no real problem with everyday Muslims. They work together, are friends with each other, play cricket together, and even marry each other. It is some fanatics on both sides who can't get along.
In 1946 election, 90% of Muslims voted for the partition and 90% of Hindus voted against the partition. But today ironically most Hindus are happy with the partition, since the partition prevented the rise of Jihadi politics in India.
Partition saved India from a civil war. The only problem is no complete population exchange took place.
No lying Muslim didn't Hindus by two leaders Petal & ShemaPrashad Mukherjee
Congress agreed Jinnah s plan but after one week they didn't accepted Muslim rights asper population.
Creation of Pakistan is historical blander in history of sub continent
Thank you for revealing the truth. At least there is someone who speaks the truth.
Right 👍👍👍