MAKEUP by MARIO ETHEREAL EYESHADOW PALETTE | $68?! 😱 Review, Swatches, Comparisons
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 лип 2024
- ➡️ OVERVIEW
Hello friends! I have a HIGHLY requested review for you today. This is going to be an in-depth review of the new Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette. I am going to be doing swatches, TONS of comparisons, 2 looks and sharing all of my thoughts on whether or not I think this palette is worth the $68.
➡️ WHERE TO BUY
Buy at Sephora: howl.me/cis02XzIk8M
Buy at Makeup by Mario Website: go.shopmy.us/p-765393
Wayne Goss Smokey Quartz Palette go.magik.ly/ml/1m8ln/
Wayne Goss Pearl Palette go.magik.ly/ml/1e9de/
Hourglass Scattered Light Eyeshadows (Smoke) go.shopmy.us/p-765415
Patrick Ta Major Dimension Eyeshadow Palette go.shopmy.us/p-765417
Pat Mcgrath Moonlit Seduction go.shopmy.us/p-765419
Tom Ford Metal Lust (Discontinued)
Natasha Denona Glam Palette go.shopmy.us/p-758151
Colourpop Going Coconuts Palette go.shopmy.us/p-765423
Colourpop Bare Essentials Palette go.shopmy.us/p-765425
Colourpop Stone Cold Fox Palette go.shopmy.us/p-765429
Dior Soft Cashmere Quint go.shopmy.us/p-765431
Pat McGrath Celestial Nirvana Holiday 2022 (Bronze Bliss) go.shopmy.us/p-681257
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Quad go.shopmy.us/p-690122
Some of my links may be affiliate which means that I may earn a small commission from the brand at no cost to you. Please consider supporting my channel by shopping through my links
➡️ TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette Review
01:24 Product Details
03:14 Swatches
06:22 DEMO 1: Natural Look
09:49 DEMO 2: Glam Look
12:39 Comparisons
13:12 Wayne Goss Smokey Quartz vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
14:19 Wayne Goss Pearl vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
15:08 Hourglass Scattered Light vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
16:03 Patrick Ta Major Headlines vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
16:59 Pat McGrath Blitz Astral vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
17:36 Tom Ford Metal Lust vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
18:15 Natasha Denona Glam Palette vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
19:00 Colourpop Going Coconuts vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
19:55 Colourpop Bare Necessities & Stone Cold Fox vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
20:22 Dior Soft Cashmere vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
20:52 Pat McGrath Celestial Nirvana Bronze Bliss vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
21:10 Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Quad vs Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyeshadow Palette
21:55 Final Thoughts
❤️ UA-cam | PLEASE SUBSCRIBE! bit.ly/3HNgWUK
INSTAGRAM bit.ly/3HFeqjj
➡️ ON MY FACE
MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow Palette go.shopmy.us/p-762025
Lisa Eldridge Foundation www.lisaeldridge.com/collecti...
KVD BeautyGood Apple Lightweight Full-Coverage Concealer go.magik.ly/ml/1n0nf/
Tom Ford Soleil Glow Bronzer (Terra) go.magik.ly/ml/1n375/
RMS BEAUTY | "Re" Dimension Hydra Powder Blush (Maiden's Blush)
TOWER 28 | MakeWaves Lengthening + Curling Clean Mascara go.shopmy.us/p-696609
Tarte Maracuja Juicy Lip Plump (Honeysuckle) go.magik.ly/ml/1hbax/
➡️ WHAT I'M WEARING
Sweater: go.shopmy.us/p-726501
➡️ SHOP MY LINKS
Sephora: go.magik.ly/ml/1entx/
Ulta: go.magik.ly/ml/1enty/
Beautylish: go.magik.ly/ml/1entz/
Nordstrom: go.magik.ly/ml/1enu2/
Selfridges: go.magik.ly/ml/1enu5/
Harrods: go.magik.ly/ml/1enu7/
Saks: go.magik.ly/ml/1enu3/
Neiman Marcus: go.magik.ly/ml/1enu4/
Your eyeshadow palette reviews are hands down the best! So well done, very thorough. Love that you use natural light, love the comparisons for color and finish and formula, love the variety of looks you demonstrate. So much helpful content jam packed into each of your videos! Thank you! ❤
You are by far the most accurate beauty UA-camr! I bought the palette and couldn’t decide if I liked it or not as all my friends tell me Mario shadows are amazing. I loved the colour story for days when I don’t want to think about what to slap on my eyes. The mattes were so underwhelming! I can handle a lil kickback but playing with a palette where there’s ton of kickback in 7 pans?! 😬
Also, it lasted for 6 hours on my eyes yesterday then started to fade away. Felt like the mattes were patchy as well. I’m so sad I will be returning this cuz it’s a gorgeous palette.
Natasha Denona Glam palette + UD Space Cowboy and you pretty much have the essence of this one.
I love love love when you do the comparisons. That’s pretty much why I watch reviews and performance of course. So many beauty UA-camrs were giving this palette amazing reviews and here I thought I was going crazy. Thank you for being thorough and real. ✌🏻❤
Thank you so much Sara, I appreciate you sharing! 🤗 I think unfortunately a lot of folks on UA-cam rush the reviews to try and get their review up first and don't really get a chance to comment on longevity, fallout, eye irritation, or all of the shades. (or take the time to do the comparisons unfortunately)
If I kept a gratitude journal, this review would have its own entry. So super helpful, thorough and well thought out. Thank you!
Thanks for the in-depth review! Very helpful!
Thank you for the review! I think I really made the right choice getting it because I don’t have any of the palettes you compared it to and I love the blend of mattes, metallic and glitters. Loved both your looks too - will definitely try them out!
Nice!! This is a good staple for people that don't have a ton of palettes like me haha 😛
You have the best reviews! Thank you so much!!
Thank you Mary!! 🤗
I considered getting this palette during the sale, but I passed and now I’m glad I did. I do own a lot of the palettes in the comparisons already!
Nice Veronica!
I loved this very clear review dear Sofia, and so many comparisons, wow!!!!!!!!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩Think i have enough in this colourstory, thank you for all the work you put into this, amazing!!!!! Have a wonderful day!!!!😘😘😘😘
Thanks for watchingggg 💕
Sofia….you are amazing and I really love your reviews. I do not own any of the Mario palettes and I am super happy I bought this and I own all of the comparison palettes you showed, I like having different formulas. People need to just decide what is best for themselves. Again, I look forward to your next video….you are quickly becoming my favorite.
Hi Tammy! That is amazing, thank you for sharing your thoughts! I know what you mean -even if I have similar colors I like the experience of the different formulas and some people like one formula over another.
This is the best review I’ve seen 👏
Just thinking about it since I missed it last time but so glad I saw this video. I love your work and I will be spending my coins on another pallet.
Excelente review !! 👏🏽👏🏽
Thank you for this review and comparison! In 2022 to make a unique neutrals palette is an accomplishment. Patrick Ta and MBM are on trend, wearable and right up my alley. The palette shows up on medium/tan skin FWIW and I think it was intentional not to include a black, since as you state, it's meant to be "ethereal." Same for the ratio of toppers.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! Its definitely hard to make anything unique nowadays 😅
Thank you so much for your honest review. I see so many people rave about and I loved the glitter toppers (especially from previous reviews), however you show the real texture and the close up colors so it makes me think if I really need to add it to my collection (as far as we can call makeup a necessity anyways).
Thank you for your feedback! I am glad it was helpful 😊
Thank you for the review. I keep going back and forth about buying it or not. I think it's easy sometimes to get caught up in the hype and everyone saying it's so amazing. But realistically it's just a thing and not something that will change your life. I think you did a great job of talking about the pros and cons of the palette in a way that made me realize "it's just a thing, not something magical". It will be very expensive for me to buy since I live in Sweden and someone wrote in a comment on his instagram that the palette won't be coming to Europe. Unfortunately the shipping to Europe from his website is extremely expensive. What I like most about this palette is the tones of it and the sparkly toppers. But I will be trying to dupe this with my existing eyeshadows first before I decide whether to buy it or not. Thanks again for the review! 💜
Yes I completely forgot to make that point in the video. This palette is mad expensive if you live outside the US so it really needs to feel luxe for it to be worth it
Totally helpful! I think the palette is so beautiful but ultimately I have what I need in terms of shimmer from Pat McGrath!
I am glad it was helpful! Thank you for sharing your thoughts, Ava
WOW. You really went deep into this - thank you. Subscribed :)
Welcome Natalia!!
Thank you for the amazingly thorough review! Is it weird that after seeing your & GlamGirlChelsea's looks I went from not wanting this to considering it? You bring up a number of good points but as someone who only has 1 PMG palette and a cream shimmer, this just looks like such a beautiful, fun, and wearable palette for year round. It just looks very effortless on you.
Thank you Ivy! Chelsea did such pretty looks! That's why I try to show it as realistically as possible because that way you can get a feel for the product and decide for yourself 🙌
I knew it. This palette isn’t all that and tricky to use. I appreciate your review!
Glad it was helpful!
thank you for this! but glad i waited for your comparisons because i already have nd glam, soft cashmere and the hourglass scattered lights.
just saw lisa eldridge’s video and i am so much more excited for her eyeshadow palettes 😍
I'm excited for them too!
Thanks for reminding me I have the ND Glam Palette and at my (advanced) age I do not need another palette.
You’re welcome Julia 😅😁
the palette reminds me the dior 669, but with more variety! love it
oooo good comparison!
I'm wearing it today and all your points, both good and bad are valid. I'm glad I picked it up with the Rouge discount, because I don't know that it's worth it at full price. That said though, I really enjoy the looks I get with it and I find it a good, staple, "no brainer" pallette to grab for work.
Great points, Lee 💕 thank you for letting us know your thoughts!
I can’t believe that anyone thinks the price is too high. The palette sold out at Sephora in 2 days and EBay has price’s up to $150. Plus do we not think he has done any market analysis prior to launching it? Seriously ladies…
Hi
I really like your review to decide should I get item or no , plz keep your review honest . Like your videos a lot.
I’m so glad!
Thank you for the amazing comparisons. Literally no one needs this 😂
You're welcome!!
Hi Sophia- I’ve been on the fence about getting Wayne’s Smoky Quartz since it released - I love the look you created with it and others, too.. so I think in lieu of that, I will pick it up the next chance I get. This Mario palette is very pretty but I didn’t care for how dusty the mattes were either so I returned it.. was concerned about eye irritation as well❤ thanks as always!
Yes I think you will love Smokey Quartz from Wayne because the subtle purple undertones will be very pretty for your green eyes
Very long time ago, Sonia Kashuk at Target have these eyeshadow quad that are very similar to the glossy shimmers in the Mario palette. I loved them but they have long been discontinued. They were the best best glittery topper imo. A Sonia Kashuk quad was 10.99. I am very tempted to get the Mario palette just for the glossy shimmers...
Love you dear Sofia and truly appreciate all the work and love and energy you put into your work your reviews are so enjoyable and informative. Thank you my dear ❤❤❤
Thank youuuu 😘
Glad I passed...waiting impatiently for Lisa Eldridge to reveal her new palettes today. Forgot to mention, great in depth review as always. Truth! J.
I am with you Julienne! I am so excited for the LE release
I keep going back and forth on this palette. One minute I want it, the next I don’t. 😅 Whenever I see someone playing with it, I think how beautiful it is and how much I want to recreate the looks but then I remind myself that I have these shades and textures. Maybe if MUBM has a killer Black Friday, I’ll pick it up but for now, I’m okay saving myself $68. 💕
I know I felt the same way Talya! At first I wasn't going to get it and then I caved 😅
I got it
Lots of fallout
Still learning
Ty for your review
You’re welcome Debbie!
I clicked so fast when I saw your disappointed face on your thumbnail! 😃 Such great comparisons. I can dupe this palette 10x over with what I have already. I went in-store to swatch it, and the mattes were so powdery, it felt like talc, like you explained. And the glitter/topper shades had so much fall out, that I had a hard time removing it from my hands even with eye makeup remover. Yeh, no with the glitter fall out, and not for $68. The Limited Edition release seems like a marketing plow. Great review as always Sofia! Thank you!
Thank you so much for watching and sharing your thoughts! I wanted to make this video since there were so many other reviews that had a different perspective and not a ton of comparisons
It's the Mario grey shade that's hard to fine with the wet shimmers as well but the grey
Definitely would not pay full price for this! I’m glad I picked it up during the sale. It’s basically a 12 pan quad or quint, haha!, in that the looks will always be sort of the same but also hard to mess up.
I’ve played with mine once so far, and while I liked my look, I’m just now putting together that my eyes WERE irritated after, uh-oh! Gonna play with it again and see, Sephora does have a wonderful return policy.
You are always so nuanced and considered with your looks and comparisons.
Yes that's a good way of putting it. The colors are not differentiated enough so the experience is similar to a quad
I had my eye on this because it seems like something I'd really enjoy, but I have really sensitive eyes so thank you for bringing that to my attention!!!! Not spending a fortune on something I can't use...
It hasn't even launched in the UK yet as far as I'm aware so I wonder if it's going to be available at all lol
I heard it’s super expensive to get overseas 😬 not sure if it will launch at any UK retailers
I bought a couple of eyeshadow palettes during the sephora sale and this one is on the top of my returns list. I don't see myself during the glossy shimmers and the mattes are just like any other palette that I have. If this was half the price sure but it's too darn expensive to keep.
Interesting that you compared with the hourglass glitters, I prefer those!
Thanks for sharing your experience Sam! I am curious if it will come back in stock at Sephora since I keep hearing mixed reviews
As it has just been released for a final sale, then it will be gone, I have bought it from Mario's own website at the cost of £89 including expedited postage because it will never be released in the UK. I'm looking forward to trying it as it arrived today. It looked like a fairly ordinary neutral palette. At that price, it needs to perform well!
My update on this is that it does perform extremely well and I am glad I bought it.
Oof. This palette was such a let-down for me. His Master Mattes palette is such a workhorse staple in my collection, and I was really looking forward to this one. Sadly, I won't be keeping it. I'm actually glad it's limited edition...it gives me hope that he will reformulate and come out with something better. It's so interesting to see such polarizing views on this palette...it's the true definition of YMMV. Anyway, thanks for your thorough review and keeping it real, as always!
Haha yea in a way I kind of like the polarization cause at least it gives us something to debate and helps us highlight the pros and cons!
great review thank u so much!! im so glad you compared the wayne goss, bc i want to try one of his eye palettes. the pearl one is on my wishlist. i dont think black when thinking "ethereal". also thanks for the tip on the hourglass eye products.
P.S. my eyes are super sensitive so thanks for that advice.
I hope that the Pearl one comes back in stock 😩 seems like it's always OOS
Just watching bec I like your videos:) I’m a one and done kind of girl 😁
Hahaha hello Celeste!! 😜
@@SofiaSeesBeauty heyyyy chickie!
I love the mattes but I don’t love the toppers bc They are sheer. I’m gonna keep it bec it looks great on me. I don’t think it’s like soft cashmere on my eyes that’s cooler and taupier. So I like both. LIt does look similar to pillowtalk. But pillowtalk can’t be built up. I do think This is a great travel palette and I’m glad I got it.
Yes you are very right, the Pillow Talk palette doesn't have a lot of depth and this is for sure different enough from Soft Cashmere that you can have both!
I have purchased this palette and have been using it for 2 days now. Not sure if I feel good about this one. I can’t get that polished more expensive look from this palette. Matt’s are ok but glitters are not going on as smooth or lux and make my eyes look tired and old.
Will give it a few more days but possibly will return it. I hav all the other mentioned palettes, feel like they perform way better.
Thank you for another amazing review
Thank you Valentina for sharing your experience so far! Like you, I think I would have preferred a slightly more smooth metallic
i think Mario intentionally kept the color story lighter/ethereal based on his concept share. i also think artists tend to lean on eyeliner more to deepen or smoke out a look, but agree a darker shade would have added more options overall. not sure why it was ltd except that it sounded like a celebration/anniversary palette for him. of course if it does well he could always make it permanent. i suspect it being ltd ed and released during the sephora sale is why it sold out even faster. hoping the formula doesn’t irritate my eyes but tbd! i still don’t have a WG palette but have had my eye on pearl. i do think the tones of these neutral are exactly my preference. i also thought his shimmers were less impactful than WG which is why i guessed wrong, lucky for me 😂
Let me know what you think when you try it!!
I saw it at Sephora today and although it’s a beautiful neutral palette, I feel like I can definitely copy the color story with what I already have in my collection with my :
Too Faced: Neutral Nudes & Colourpop: Bare Necessities
& the shimmers with my: Fenty Diamond Bombs ( I have 4 ) & Glamshop: Totalt Blask Nudes ( all shimmer palette) & Glamshop : Single Shimmer Shades
So I feel content to not caving into the hype of this eyeshadow palette, because I have similar colors to it ! Or doesn’t take away how beautiful & stunning this palette is , even if it’s a neutral basic B.. palette, nevertheless!!!! ☺️✨
Yes very good points and thank you for sharing your alternatives!
I was thinking about buying this but your very thorough review convinced me that i just want a different experience and finish. I started to love the ysl mini cluth palettes and just hope they'll bring out other colour stories
Can I make a review/comparison request? I'm looking for a comparison between Haus Labs highlighter in Fire Opal and RMS blush in Mai Tai. Also Haus Rose Quartz and RMS French Rose. For being so viral and similar shifty gel powders, I'm surprised there are no comparisons.
I don't have any of those but I will check them out in Sephora next time I am there! Are they viral?? I haven't heard anyone I follow talk about them really but I am not on TikTok so a lot of times I am unaware
@@SofiaSeesBeauty Definitely check the Haus labs shade out when you are there next time!! It's striking. I think that one has some traction. RMS is online only.
Swatched the glitter shades in store, and were really disappointed that the have none of the said emollience, at all. And the matte shades are sadly too powdery. Please, Wayne Goss, bring back your OG Pearl and new OG Smokey palettes!
At Sephora Canada 92 $ canadian , totally INSANE
Thank you 😊😊😊 it’s a pass.. I don’t like powdery shadow.
I've been on the fence, but more and more, I think I'll pass on this palette. Not having a black isn't too bad (I use the single ND Blackest Black or VB Satin Kajal as my black, plus I have so many in palettes), but all those shimmers are so close. It's overkill to me. If one was a duo-chrome and the others were really different tones, that would be great. I might not mind the 'ethereal' and light textured mattes -- I've been into almost naked eye looks lately.
I don't know -- I'll see if he keeps it or comes out with something better...
Yes I know what you mean! I think Mario will keep coming out with more interesting launches
Yeah, I think I’ll pass. I’ve been wanting to get one of the Tom Ford quads for awhile now, so I think I’ll go with Nude Dip or Enchanted next. Probably Nude Dip. It is gorgeous and I can basically dress in whatever color of clothes and my makeup will still match my outfit. Enchanted is much more pinky, which I also love, but I’ll get that one next, after Nude Dip. (Nude Dip in December for Christmas and Enchanted in March for my birthday 🙃)
Thanks for the video! It’s a pretty palette though, but I already have enough eyeshadows… if I get this one I seriously won’t be able to justify buying Tom Ford quad 😉
Tom Ford nude dip is a must have! You will love it. I’m a March bday too 😜
@@SofiaSeesBeauty actually, it is impossible to get Enchanted in Slovenia. I’ve searched all websites but I can’t find Enchanted anywhere! So I ordered Nude Dip and I can’t wait to get it! 😃 We bring the spring!! 💪💖😉
@@samantarizzi248 I read Enchanted & got excited. I thought they bought it back since it's been gone for nearly a decade. TF Virgin Orchid is close, but the top 2 shades are less frosty, metallic, while the bottom 2 are the same.
@@kayade5305 yeah sadly we can’t get Enchanted anywhere 😭 Seductive Rose is next on my wishlist! 😉I had no idea when I was writing my comment…
wonderful review! i agree this should not be a LE piece, unless to your point it is expensive to make. it is a basic b**ch palette and no one should be rushed into buying it only during a sale or during a limited availability. to me if it's not this palette, there are many other, the ones you showed in comps and i bet there are many more out there similar to this in color story may be not the same formula. but who cares, once its on the eyes, i wonder who can tell the difference unless someone is standing 2 ft from me and knows about this palette.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts, RP! I am kind of hoping that he comes out with something that is permanent so that more people have the opportunity to enjoy 😁
@@SofiaSeesBeauty I hope so too. For now, I am going to enjoy the heck out of my ND glam eye shadow palette I got this year
Every luxury palette I buy has a black shadow I don’t think I need any more black shadows in a pallet
I totally get what you mean. For me, I am not going to dip into another palettes so I like the convenience of having a darker color in there
@@SofiaSeesBeauty but there are deeper colors in the palette, just not black. His palette is sold out at Sephora and EBay has it for $150 sooo… do we NOT think Mario has any business sense or does any market analysis before he prices and releases something???
@@susanbowman3865 James Charles, Kylie Jenner and even Shane Dawson of all people sold out too. It doesn't make them good colour curators, it means they are trendy and popular.
If I had known about the Lisa Eldridge releases I would never have picked this up. Just saying. Made the mistake of going into my Sephora during the sale instead of waiting for a delivery.
Yeah I am curious to see how the LE formula compares to this and other formulas!
I’m thinking it LE because those sell faster and more of them. He is friends with the queen’s of marketing 😂
Hahahaha great point Charli 😅
Hi Sofia ! Thank you for this review ! This palette is not for me ... Too much glitters and fall out
Have a good day ! 🥰
Have a great day Amira! Thank you for your input
Thanks for the thorough review and taking the time to swatch comparisons! This was sooo helpful. Wondering if you plan to review Lisa Eldridge’s new eye shadow palette launches? (Here is the link: ua-cam.com/video/F4p-8cvLnho/v-deo.html)
I am still making my way through her 45 minute video to be honest so I haven't decided just yet! I am sure I will pick up at least one but probably not all of them
I prefer Wayne goss over this one😊
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Parivash! 🤗
I'm still torn. On one hand, these are the formulas I love in terms of shimmers and colours of mattes. On the other hand, my hourglass scattered light shadows and Urban Decay moondust eyeshadows paired with any numbers of mattes scattered throughout my collection would recreate the effect. Having it all in one place is really the only reason left for me to grab it.
Yeah that is a good point. Sometimes I just like the convenience of having all of these things in one palette!
For us EU citizens it's total is 109$ (86$ price and 23$ shipping)... so not worth it.
I know it's SO expensive!
I’m sorry your eye look is basic and patchy looking. I appreciate your demo. Im so glad i didn’t give in to my FOMO.
My ee6 broke 🥲