Alan Bell question period

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 19

  • @truckerfromreno
    @truckerfromreno 3 роки тому +1

    The Falkland Islands - Forever British.

  • @seumasnatuaighe
    @seumasnatuaighe 5 років тому +1

    We had a goals down, plans up system where the team made the plan. Every member's input was listened to and when we received new info, we added it to our planning cycle. These methods are now used in the business world with success, especially in R&D and engineering.

    • @phmwu7368
      @phmwu7368 2 роки тому

      Even the best plans don't survive First Contact so a military leader needs to adapt quickly and efficiently ...

    • @seumasnatuaighe
      @seumasnatuaighe 2 роки тому

      @@phmwu7368 Totally agree. That's why our 5 point orders starts out with the Mission.

  • @jamjam472
    @jamjam472 4 роки тому +1

    What about his final comment: the 6-main mission to shoot down/up 3x C-130's with Arg Paras? Arg 4th Abn Bgd were earmarked to reinforce the FI's, so it makes sense. No book has ever mentioned this op before. Wish it wasn't the last q of the night!

  • @brianjones1151
    @brianjones1151 5 років тому +7

    Margaret Thatcher did not make the decision to through foreign invading forces off British sovereign territory because of political reasons !! (That is just a stupid and ignorant statement by a woman in the audience )!!
    Margaret Thatcher was a Great lady and i guarantee you she had many a sleepless night thinking about the lives that were lost on both sides of the conflict .

    • @themccarthyplan2020
      @themccarthyplan2020 5 років тому

      Who made the decision and why? I was there as a young Para. I'd like to know more.

  • @FHIPrincePeter
    @FHIPrincePeter 5 років тому

    Why did Alan move from the Marines to the SAS, the normal route would have been to SBS?

    • @peterbrittain6501
      @peterbrittain6501 5 років тому +1

      he was in sbs.. left for sas ... says that at the start if the vidio , or the one before ..

    • @dickensdickens3025
      @dickensdickens3025 4 роки тому +3

      peter brittain
      @ peter brittain
      Dinger did selection in 1979 and did summer selection that year. He was a ex RM (pvr) not SBS . ( despite his assertion to the contrary these days). I ve known him 42 years ... right from Day 1

  • @smootherbymaple3701
    @smootherbymaple3701 8 років тому +2

    Sounds like one big finger pointing exercise by Mr Bell aimed at everyone except themselves.

    • @richardvernon317
      @richardvernon317 7 років тому +5

      Partly, though in the grand scheme of things inter-service co-operation back then was non existent, An RAF Pilot on the Harrier GR3 force which was deployed to the Hermes later wrote a book which had a number of chapters entitled 'Navy C""k Up(s), with the general view that most Naval Commanders in that war treated anything deployed from their ship as an expendable weapon and didn't listen to the actual people doing the task who knew the limitations of their equipment and were prepared to do the task at a time were those limitations could be minimized to gain the greatest operational effect.