SM Lee Hsien Loong at the FutureChina Global Forum 2024
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 жов 2024
- Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong had a moderated fireside chat with SPH Media Chinese Media Group Editor-in-Chief Lee Huay Leng at the Business China FutureChina Global Forum on 18 October 2024.
0:58 On the Suzhou Industrial Park project
08:09 On the tensions between China and the West
15:05 Could China could explain itself better
17:33 On over-capacity in China
23:13 On China's economy
32:37 On the impact of more Chinese companies coming to Southeast Asia
34:24 On "Singapore-washing"
36:38 On attracting Chinese entrepreneurs to Singapore
39:24 On Chinese companies wanting to list on the Singapore Stock Exchange
42:15 On whether playing computer games can help students to learn Mandarin
48:28 On how the outcome of the US Presidential Election will affect US-China relations
Salute to our senior minister and ex-PM of Singapore. He is fluent in English and Mandarin. He is knowledgeable of economic, geopolitics, etc.
Singapore younger generation of Chinese must make an effort to study their mother tongue language, Mandarin, besides fluency in English. They would appreciate the Chinese culture and civilisation. To be able to communicate well in Mandarin and English, the Singaporeans would have a great future ahead to trade with China and the rest of the world.
Still want to say thank you MM LKY and SM LHL once and once again. extrodinary leaders, systems make extrodinary singapore
Lee Hsien Loong is Outstanding; approaching the style and perceptiveness of Mr Lee Kuang Yew (his father). I enjoyed the video very much.
Great speech and insights. Open, honest, and diplomatic. Proud to have you as Singapore Leader.
Yes she’s right
Indeed a very diplomatic senior minister..very wise replies!
LHL has a good understanding of US and China and their internal problems and difficulties and concerns.
Singapore has done well in reaping economic benefits trading with China and has steadfastly upheld and safeguarded its national sovereignty and security, positioning itself geopolitically as a force for good to defend and uphold rules-based international order, without being coerced by Chinese economic pie. Well done Singapore. 🇸🇬 👏💪👍
What "economic success"? Can U elaborate & give examples, especially in the light of the dire economic & political systems in PRC.
@@hengbin2974Do you prefer India’s political and economic systems?
What exactly does Singapore have to offer China? All China demands is that Singapore doesn’t choose sides and it is obliging.
India is NOT the issue here.......pls stick to PRC & SGP's involvement in SIP, which to me has been a FAILURE for reasons unforeseen by SGP, even though SGP had to give up control to PRC with SGP holding only 1/3 of the equity from 2/3...............that's just one eg of the propaganda LHL has been spewing about "LONG TERM",,,,,,,,,,,,the SIP experience CLEARLY shows the falsehood of SGP;s investments in PRC from which it cannot extract itself................so dun B/S about LHL incompetence.
@@davidlai399 , Obviously, he reads only The Financial Times, CNN, .. including Indian pod casts.
专注听李显龙的回答和理性分析他的解释，我无语但内心充满敬佩与自豪。 我自豪有这么睿智的国家领导人。 谢谢你，李资政，真的是劳苦功高。 祝福你身体健康，有个快乐的退休生活。 😀👍 麒芳 敬
Knowledgeable at such age, thank god he's still around!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mature RESPECT aid is the KEY!!!
The speech is very honest, yet diplomatic.
There is elephant in the room majority can't speak about openly.
Certain race leads the world for centuries, and form an opinion there can never be other race who has the same or even higher talent, dynamic, innovative and competitive thought. Some even thought it is just how the world must be, hence the "unwritten rules based order" comes about.
NEP's Rights® in the room specifically referring to Malaysia. Luckily Quota® didn't explode like in Bangladesh saw Sheikh Hasina on the run to India to take a refuge recently.
世界正常发展，唯有“止恶扬善”。❤
Great respect to Senior Minister LHL.
Very diplomatic remarks on some of those insidious municipal officials in Suzhou that gave us immerse problems. Mark of a great Statesman! Now the SM should have more time to help other countries who want to tap on his vast experience.
I have high admiration for Mr. Lee for his sound minded wisdom and vision.
The key is whi decides what is the International Order. Right now it is only the collective west of less than 20 countries decided for the rest of the 194 countries of the world.
Excellent 🇸🇬❤️✌️🙏👍💪🌞🌟🏅🪙
Huey Ling had asked very appropriate questions ... in a very amicable way ... esp in this political arena. Very good! Thank you. Dr Peter
Really well train.. salute to Mr Lee
Highly respected SM Lee 🫡
I agree with you 💯
@@1956Mariella Hello Marliella
@@1956Mariella Hello Marliella
I would recommend every person in the countryside to stay if they are happy. One may have less material wealth but can have more natural wealth. And one is close to food which can get scares from time to time as the older generations in China know too well.
Whether one is happy or not is NOT the issue............the ISSUE is why SGP's system has FAILED to prevent such unmitigated DISASTERS which affects everybody esp those over 65 which according to statista numbered 771.24 in 2023 & the relentless increased in COL.
You guys should know China lacks water. Climate change and extreme weather events exacerbated the lack of water in many countries and it will one day become a problem for China. So don’t think you can hide in some village and the problem will go away. The last time I heard the Chinese government made sure that the first tier cities like Shanghai secure their water resources while many small villages were left to fend for themselves with the dwindling water supply. That’s how water allocation will be like in bad times so I hope you will not be naive about thinking that staying in villages is the best option.
@@ditsygirl5409 A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.
@@Kaoniao earthly desires are enlightenments!
@@hengbin2974 , When you have had enjoyed the good times when you were active then you must continue to enjoy it even when you no longer contribute to the society?? This is the attitude of retirees who had their times which they want to continue, as if it is ordained from Heaven?
To be strong, accepted, respected and as an equal friend to others.
yes i agree with you nice comment
Singapore made a wise choice to retain LHL in the cabinet.
Shinkansen from Spore via JB to Laos maybe Longsighted vision esp for Johore Malaysia.
wow the lady mediator's english sounds very Singaporean
Sr. Min. Lee's responses and articulation of the realities is precise and accurate from my view point.
Salami slicing strategy has eroded trust.
IP theft has eroded trust
Intimidating smaller countries has eroded trust
One-way market access has eroded trust.
Other than that the CCP is doing the right things. The key word is 'restraint' something that CN's large western neighbour and equally large power-in-the making has demonstrated for generation even while being violated by brutish arab armies in pre-contemporary history making it a far more reslient society. Something that CN never had to face.
So, you still thought the PI theft is true notwithstanding the explanation by Prof. Richard Wolff? Or is your God Modi said so?
China needs to do adjustment, likewise, those so-called developed countries need to do adjustment. everyone needs to think that the way of the world runs is subject to some popular values or to the interest of some existed developed countries.
Aku uncle saya were greetings from the overseas peranakan Chinese merlion mighty 🙂🙏🐼 SO Peter 60 saya aku
Whatever former PM said does not mean he wished for. Not everything says it is what it will happen.
China Work force is 780 millions. What is the concern of reduction of population. China is more concerned of ensuring full employment.
事实上，劳动力的减少是有利的。未来是自动化的时代，根本没有办法创造更多的劳动密集型就业，加上ai的发展，无人出租，无人工厂，进一步冲击。别看印度现在人口这么多，他没有赶上二十年前的末班车，永远摆脱不了贫困国家
@@bingliu-china 我同意！但未來很少會直線發展..我們必須等待並觀察 :)
@@bingliu-china , I thought so, if the society is managed "correctly", as long a worker can "walk" to work, he could still be employed. In the West, automation is solely aimed at removing the employees at any level possible: lack of social responsibility.
USA is big.. Does USA take responsibility for their actions?? Doesnt look like US does with the US Exceptionism
the sad fact is that although U.S. is powerful, but it is quite far away. And due to the off-shore balance and the big China is so close to the southeastern Asian countries, in the long run, most of them may corporate with U.S. to counter-balance China. In another word, the U.S. exceptionism is based upon a big geopolitical sweet spot.
@@josephzhang1797 No.. Most of ASEAN dislike USA..
They will never be on the side of USA.. Except for dependent countries/states like Philippines, Taiwan, Japan and South Korea..
But ultimately.. They will still be closer to China..
USA dwells too much in War.. And Western culture is too freedom based..
East Asians don't like that..
The reason why East Asian countries dislike about China.. Is the same reason why they dislike themselves.. Their governments are likewise very Authoritarian.. Like China.. And a little bullying.. With looking down on weaker or poorer..
They dislike China because they dislike themselves as much.. They understand why China acts the way China does..
And 90% don't believe China is going to launch any Wars.. Contradictory to what West media like to portray..
The only reason of that fake counter balance is USA pressuring them..
Or else.. You think they don't want to buy cheaper Chinese military weapons???
@@josephzhang1797 @josephzhang1797 No.. Most of ASEAN dislike USA..
They will never be on the side of USA.. Except for dependent countries/states like Philippines, Taiwan, Japan and South Korea..
But ultimately.. They will still be closer to China..
USA dwells too much in War.. And Western culture is too freedom based..
East Asians don't like that..
The reason why East Asian countries dislike about China.. Is the same reason why they dislike themselves.. Their governments are likewise very Authoritarian.. Like China.. And a little bullying.. With looking down on weaker or poorer..
They dislike China because they dislike themselves as much.. They understand why China acts the way China does..
And 90% don't believe China is going to launch any Wars.. Contradictory to what West media like to portray..
The only reason of that fake counter balance is USA pressuring them..
Or else.. You think they don't want to buy cheaper Chinese military weapons???
@@josephzhang1797 @josephzhang1797 No.. Most of ASEAN dislike USA..
They will never be on the side of USA.. Except for dependent countries/states like Philippines, Taiwan, Japan and South Korea..
But ultimately.. They will still be closer to China..
USA dwells too much in War.. And Western culture is too freedom based..
East Asians don't like that..
The reason why East Asian countries dislike about China.. Is the same reason why they dislike themselves.. Their governments are likewise very Authoritarian.. Like China.. And a little bullying.. With looking down on weaker or poorer..
They dislike China because they dislike themselves as much.. They understand why China acts the way China does..
And 90% don't believe China is going to launch any Wars.. Contradictory to what West media like to portray..
The only reason of that fake counter balance is USA pressuring them..
Or else.. You think they don't want to buy cheaper Chinese military weapons???
@@josephzhang1797 What you say is not true.. But YT keeps censoring my replies
The former Premier of Singapore explains about some critical issues developed overtime globally. 15:25
He got grilled hard…
ตรงตามนั่นจริงๆค่ะ
First-world PAP.❤
Seems to be socialists democratic party?
"took inspiration" is a very politically correct phrase use, indeed a wise leader.
SM Lee just leaked there will be a Zhuge liang and Three Kingdoms game too
❤❤❤❤
Well said, SM Lee of Singapore 🇸🇬. He is another Mighty Dragon of China 🇨🇳. Long live to all Patriotic Dragons of Motherland China 🇨🇳 ❤❤❤.
Good evening sir
Ide karangan bunga di gantikan TV layar lebar bisa di pakai oleh negara anda juga
A lot of China’s issues are self inflicted because they prioritize security and national politics over economic and social growth and reform. While national security and politics are important, economic and social growth and reform remain 硬道理。 Without a strong economy and cohesive society (not through censoring speech and stiffening views, but sensible laws and unbias implementation), China can never become strong. I sincerely hope that China government can rethink and reprioritize their development path - be an inspiring global benevolent power
新加坡的外部环境能和中国一样吗 反华经费花在新加坡身上了 ？
But what choice has China got? Has the environment from the West be less aggressive, China would have double her basic infrastructure twice faster than today. It is obvious, China had no choice but to show that she is capable of defending herself if anyone think war is his option.
Hong kong so long time im share horse Racing.any county .
the west and usa very tolerant of Singapore's talks and behavior?
Benefits here and benefits there from the sino sg projects, have they made any monetary profits from them to SG? 志在揚名，不計成本！？
We have a very small window before AI takes over human reason and foresight.
中国跟美国的竞争会有最短十年的时间，中国人早就有了这种共识，所以一方面要强化国防，一方面要改善产业结构，一方面帮助非洲扩大市场。
GIC/TH hv been known to be UNABLE to extract themselves of their PRC investments for about 2 yrs.....,,,,surely it is because LHL/HC did not foresee such adverse implications of the deteriorating US-PRC relations.........In any case the said US-PRC relations is NOT the only issue........from what I've read it is more due to the Chinese President policies. In any case, what is GIC/TH & MOF doing in the next 10 yrs...............just increase the COL!!!
My thoughts are the encircling of China by the west rest on the issue of she being communist. Decades of geopolitical decisions which rested on the superiority of democratic versus authoritarian states would lose its credibility. Had China been a democratic state, she would face totally different sets of encircling like election interference etc.
日本当初发展成世界第二的国家，因为没有主权，也被美国给一脚踩到了地下
Being socialist is not the reason for US's behavior but being outcompeted by China's advances in practically all aspects of industrialization is the main cause especially just a century ago, China was available to be cowed less than a century ago! Did they all support Vietnam? The West could not handle China so they recruited Japan, South Korea and India to join the gang. By the look of the scenario, China does not seem to be bothered!
lee hsien loong is a gamer !! 😂 awesome
很喜欢听李光耀和李显龙对于中国的评价😊
Every year we give 30k citizenships to their kind. (1% of our population). 5 years that will be (5% of our population are new citizens) when election is held, who do you think these will vote for? True singaporeans need to wake up.
What is your objective? Open up your eyes. Singapore also has an influx of India Indians working here under the Ceca agreement with India. Also, many of them have permanent residency and became new citizens. Singapore also has a huge number of Malaysian working here as pmets. This also includes the Philippines, Myanmar, Indonesia, Blangah workers, and pmets. Singapore welcomes talents from all over the world.
It is not difficult to see what happened when your kind took over. Just look northward, he denounced his ancestors just to keep his family's interests safe. And their national problems which lingered on until today began with him.
Stupidly,EV has no over capacity issue.
Compare with the demand of global .
LHL practically the mouth of western countries
I find that his speech lets out the frustrations of China with USA, but kept the tone sharply down. Singapore has to be diplomatic with both China and USA as it is not in our interest or the interest of China or USA if we start bashing either.
Listening to LHL or George Yeo, you can tell this is the hallmark of high quality statesmen , unlike kishore mahbubani who talked nonsense who kept harping about Asian countries's humiliation that made them grow advantagesly, full of rubbish
I disagree with you. I prefer listening to Professor Kishore and Professor Yeo, when speak they don't need to be politically correct, they just speak their minds.
Also there is nothing wrong in speaking about the suffering of the Asian countries and their people at the hands of their Colonizers and Imperialists in the past.
History should be discussed about and remembered.
Yes, both LHL and George Yeo are great statemen.
& what exactly hv the 2 Prof speak their minds about? The FACT & realities of the unmitigated disasters hv been highlighted by me time & again.............why these so-called Prof dun care about the country's & sinkies well being.........is it just because they, being paid handsomely, dare not speak the truth about such unmitigated disasters?
@hengbin2974 -
What unmitigated disaster are you talking about? Singapore is doing well in every aspect and the people's living standards are among the best in the world.
Yeah, one thing I do see the difference is now there are lots of Indians that have taken up the jobs of the local-born Singaporeans.
Either U R in Total Denial or hv been living in Mars..............I've REPEATEDLY mentioned about the epic failures bt LHL and his wife Ho Ching in their epic mismanagement of the C-19 pandemic with negative results still counting & the tens if not hundreds of BILLIONs LOSSES. If these dun constitute "unmitigated disasters" which hv cost thousands of preventable DEATHS, undue sufferings/hardships and billions of waste........eg the USELESS TT-tokens which LHL/HC hv abandoned after wasting over 100 million $, & something I'd opposed from the very beginning,. Why dun U identify yourself & we can debate at a public inquiry into such "unmitigated disasters" which have resulted from LHL & HC's arrogance, incompetence etc?
Trade and reap economic benefits for Singapore by all means but never comprise our principle and value of upholding and defending a rules-based international order.
Agree with you. But who decides the international order? Who sets the rule? Is it still relevant? Who controls? And does those who set it up in the first place follows? Do we want to follow blindly?
@@ongdavid4896 Oh, so you’re wondering who gets to be the international referee, huh? It’s like having a football match where only the referee’s team gets to make the rules-yellow card, red card, and suddenly someone introduces handball just because they feel like it. Classic!
But let’s break it down. The “International Order” is like an unwritten set of house rules for global politics, where the players (countries) agree not to throw food at each other during dinner-unless someone’s being a real pain. Historically, yes, it’s been shaped by a handful of powerful Western countries because, well, they managed to grab the world’s remote control first. It’s like when your cousin has the PlayStation controller and refuses to let you change the game, even though you paid for the pizza.
Now, our friend here is raising a solid point: why do less than 20 countries get to decide the rules for the whole planet? With 194 countries, it’s a bit like having a family reunion where only your stingy uncle and chatty auntie decide the dinner menu. Where’s the input from the rest of the family? What about the vegetarian cousin or the aunt who loves spicy food?
In theory, the international order should be more inclusive, right? But as it stands, the countries holding the biggest economic, military, and political sway-kind of like the oldest kids on the playground-are the ones calling the shots. Yet, just like in every family, the smaller voices are getting louder, asking for their turn to speak up.
So, maybe it’s time for the international order to be a bit more like a buffet where everyone gets a say, and not just the people hogging the dessert station.
@@pgobserver254 Thanks for your great and detailed sharing. Much appreciated. That is preciously why I am asking the person who post the initial comments. To know his stand and point
@@pgobserver254When you have 194 countries setting the rules you will never have consensus. Let’s be realistic. A few countries, probably the more powerful with most resources, will have to lead and set the rules.
🇸🇬🇨🇳
听君一席话，胜读十年书。
Xi must go to see the doctor
Mr. LHL speaks like a representative of the US, and other Western countries.
People like him and some overseas Chinese, especially from Hong Kong and Singapore who still have the Colonial Mindsets seeped deep into their minds find it fair that we Chinese should always get the shorter end of the stick to please their Colonial masters.
When they are privately among the Chinese they will appear to be more vocal against the Westerners, but in public they will say just the opposite.
It is sad to say that people like them are the one who have held us back in advancing and competing with the Western Imperialists.
Look at how the CCP is handling the 9 dash line issue. That is just a glimpse of what a CCP world order would look like. When DXP came to Singapore to learn and went back to China to establish the SEZ, everyone was happy to see the progress. But now with the power and wealth, the CCP is trying to play punk with various territories. Only goes to show that if the CCP becomes too big it will become an oppressive neighbour. See Tibet and Xinjiang for example
One point to note is also the debt trap that the CCP has offered the 3rd world countries. Lending other poorer countries with huge amount of amount knowing they are unable to repay and also using their Chinese companies/workers to build the infrastructure, and eventually taking over the region or project cuz the other countries won’t be able to settle their debts
Huge amount of money*
@@bamboohat7 9 dash line(1949) supersedes 11-dash line(1947). It predates UNCLOS came into effect only in 1982(UNCLOS is late comer to enforce WPS(2012) to be placed on SCS as per👇🏼
😁Edinburgh Geographical Institute(uk) printed SCS on world map 1931. A credible publisher.
Has anyone with a right frame of mind to reject it(hotly disputable WPS) ?🤡
Занятно🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hello 👋
im not so clever person C4.just im share how to done the true must Leaning more deep ,just dont you wrong done or pick the number only this im telling frist before you done look the number must reading also the book must faster by 2,minit only
im need helping my Data today the Last day going to (0) im no job in 1,month no money to support my familly ,im hope they undertand me.maybe im nomore share in horse racing.is better let dame done himself.many time im show how to done by number in seletion want is give.sorry if me never care anymore
Given the FACT that almost all MNCs are packing up in the PRC, surely there must be more vacant factories in SIP after 30 yrs of SGP;s investment, what has been what I see as LOSSES SGP has suffered, NOT only in the SIP project but also other SGP-PRC projects? I see such videos as just another propaganda effort.
MNCs are not packing up in PRC; that is the narrative created by the West. Similarly, the US narrative that all the companies are packing up in Russia is also not reflective of the real situation in Russia.
Part of the 160 billion US funded campaign to smear China...
China has not been around for 5000 years. Someone may have mislead PM Lee. Egypt may have been around for 5000 years.
Legend just like his father
Blood is thicker than water.
The issue is not with China or US. Chinese people have been honest, industrious and hardworking… they are capable of great things. The problem is the CCP and their agenda.
Like what?
@@yashsawalkar646 like their 9 dash line shenanigans, like their constant threat of invading another sovereign nation. Like their annexation and assimilation of Tibet and Xinjiang. It was never the west that is holding Chinese progress, it’s the CCP.
The flood of goods into Europe/America would cause a backlash regardless of country.
Wuxi, one hour from Suzhou there is another one
In a nutshell, 韬光养晦
Wrong Promo Key SM LHL, too bad
HIGH UNEMPLOYMENT in China
Just IMPORT them To SG
Expect MORE OVERCROWDING n HIGHER PRICES
Are u joking ? Aren’t the singapore very expensive ?
Majority of Chinese aren’t interested to live expensively in singapore
Mr. LHL why don't you say in plain English that the West is jealous of China rise, hence the containment and the negative propaganda against China.
From your point of view on what China should do it seems like you still have colonial mindset.
又被共產黨早報主編套了！
SM Lee is wrong to be say that China will succeed because of its 5,000-year history. That is like saying that Italy will do well because of the Roman Empire’s glory in the distant past. => “New China” as labelled and ruled by the CCP is only 75 years old! The CCP will fall like the once might Soviet Union!
Lol just stay delusional
you are wrong, LHL is right
@@henryyip1 Time has to keep pace with history as both are inter related to move the country forward. History provides lessons to be learned from the past. Deng xiapeng triggered a change of destiny(1976) to open door policy. Singapore(early bird) stepped in earlier to catch the worms. The late LKY had a pair of eagle eyes👁️👁️ Unlike Malaysia Vision 2020(colour blind).
Lee Kuan Yew at age 5, invaded by Japan soldier, the soldier arrive and called all the kids nearby to board the Japanese soldier lorry, then he forgot to take something, go back to house, and lorry departed, those kids boarded on the lorry gone missing forever in Singapore. So, I wonder how LSL can exists here talking alive today.
That was history which was fateful to anyone who happens to be around at any fateful time.
Singapore should unite with China.Will make both more powerful❤❤❤🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳
But i thought they lean more to the west 🇺🇸
We lean towards the Singapore sunny side . Not any other country.
Its sad to see how LHL words are somehow resonating the west.
I find that his speech lets out the frustrations of China with USA, but kept the tone sharply down. Singapore has to be diplomatic with both China and USA as it is not in our interest or the interest of China or USA if we start bashing either.
LHL knows that the process of accommodation between USA and China will take many years before there is any breakthrough.
視野和認知差李光耀先生太遠了
disagree at all
I disagree too.
@@jiayinzhou293 😛
Sweeping statement.
放眼天下（20世紀中到如今），能有幾個人的遠見勝過李光耀？
非常的敬重！新加坡政府的治理政策！擁有東西的雙語能力和智慧！平衡和圓滑的在世界上處世之道！
he losing his sharpnesd or just being pro-US--does he not see the containment/targeting the US has done during the past few years? Thoses are not solvable by "talking" or "explaining"--believing the threats the US believes CN represents, is not a matter of explaining better. Disappointing and subpar.
Wow, who are you? Judgmental and Conclusive. Why not share your view on how to manage the US/China relation better? Any inputs?
I think you are wrong. SM Lee is very straightforward but in a very diplomatic and polite way, to say that China will lead the future!!
你键盘侠懂个pi
I find that his speech lets out the frustrations of China with USA, but kept the tone sharply down. Singapore has to be diplomatic with both China and USA as it is not in our interest or the interest of China or USA if we start bashing either.
LHL knows that the process of accommodation between USA and China will take many years before there is any breakthrough.
@@teckmenglee8060 China needs to reach technological, and military leadership, until the hypocritical West can accept the multipolarity, unfortunately!!
李光耀，李顯龍都是名副其實的華人之光！
Simply just talking on paper 🗞️
❤❤❤❤