you gotta remember how intense her training was to ultimately end up in blackpink, she has gone through the MOST intricate of scrutiny for everything, to be honest I personally think she seems super chill as a mentor compared to what she had to go through lol.
that’s true it reminds me of the netflix documentary when rosé said “everything that i did was wrong” when she talked about their trainee days and she was practically crying while saying it because she remember how hard it was 😭
They will insult you by saying “ you dance like a child” and stuff while you get evaluated. Lisa’s mentoring on YwY isn't even half of what YGE’s dance mentors probably did with her, like goddamn.
Well yeah, Lisa and other YG members have been trained strictly, the YG mentor's were really strict to them just so they can get the dance right, and have them practice the whole day without sleeping. And i think thats how Lisa got the attitude of them, Lisa isn't as strict as them though.
So if you check the dance mentors in Korean competitions you will see that they are very strict so it's kind of understandable why she a little bit tough, in other Chinese competitions the mentors are lenient that's why they were surprised by LISA :p but she is the best and very professional. Thank you for the video ;)
lmao if you actually watched the Chinese show LISA mentored in you'll realize that nothing about the competitions, mentors or otherwise, can be associated with leniency
There is actually a huge difference between rude and tough. What she did should undoubtedly be considered as rude. That is humiliation not professional or tough. I think that's why the speaker deliberately cut out a part where Lisa humiliates a trainee who did not smile.
I used to do ballet and the toughest teachers i’ve ever had were the ones i loved the most because if they’re harsh, you know the care. it’s when they don’t say anything to you when you should be worried.
You should meet my Thai TAs (I teach in Bangkok as a foreigner) and well, hitting children still happens in schools here. My school banned it last year but my TAs can still be very strict vocally
It's part of Lisa's job. But what makes us shocked is not about her being tough, but because we get to see the Lisa that we never see before. Some people called her out for being too tough. That's why in YWY S3 she changed her way in giving critique and encouraged them instead. Here we can see that the trainees are afraid. She's tough, but I think it's part of her job as a mentor. But what's surprising is..... we never really know this side of Lisa before (which is 180° to the crackhead and bubbly Lisa we usually know as the maknae of the group)
I am not a dancer so I cannot judge how tough as a mentor Lisa is but I can see is that she is very dedicated to her work. The trainees should be happy that she is watching them and their every little move like a hawk so that they can improve and show their full potential....
i like lisa as a teacher, this is the first i’ve actually seen of BP but i like the toughness, it’s more that she’s frustrated bc she knows the girls can do it
Lisa had just a few weeks to get the girls to perform a PERFECT choreo that would be broadcast in TV and voted on. That one girl that kept messing up was counting the movement wrong, she kept adding an extra beat. On the show Lisa didn't tell her what she was doing wrong at first, she was showing her the sequence to let her do it on her own and correct herself. She finally did show her where she was messing up. Also the last girl in the video who was super energetic is Esther Yu, she's a Chinese actress and singer who wanted to be on the show. She was one of the winners and is now a member of the group THE9. She's also an obsessed Lisa fan, she's on the current season with Lisa again, her job is to assist the mentors.
It was obvious the trainees were already taught and practiced the coreographer. Lisa was there to clean up, but the trainees did not really have the basic choreo down, since they are off beat, timing is off, and basic lines are not understood. so how to get a group of dancers to be ready for public performance? You can't make an omolette without breaking some eggs. this is not a dance exercise class for amateurs, this is choreo for trainees trying to debut as artists. I am surprised some of them were not sent home to set a minimum standard. people asking for a softer approach, are just asking for the trainee to be humiliated and end a career before it starts. welcome to pop music industry, second prize is your not debuting with the rest of the trainees.
I really enjoyed your insight. I've seen clips of Lisa multiple times, but your explanation of what the trainees were experiencing and the difficulties they were facing at the time, was very interesting. Thank you....Also...second!
There are still a lot of Lisa dance performances that you haven't reacted too, she has 3 performances in x-academy, 2 in youth wit you 2, 2 in youth with you 3 and her solo performances in their concert.
Kpop is just extremely competitive. Every year there are hundreds of groups debuting and it's already difficult staying together as a group after the first song. She is one of the few that made it and if they are not the best they stand no chance.
There’s a social difference in western and eastern culture, teachers in asia are strict and don’t tend to compliment you much when you make a little progress. This companies are strict, they want to squeeze your full potential out of you. Just look at all the succesful idols, they have been through such a tough a hell of a training process and some even don’t make it to debute. In my opinion she is just being how a instructor should be, disciplined to make motivate one to push beyond one’s limits.
Sometimes u have to be strict. Lisa and other k-pop idols have gone through worse. They have been evaluated very strictly and it's been very demotivating at times and yet she's Understanding and soft to others, that's her beautiful character
I think with someone like Lisa, who can watch a dance once and then do the dance to almost perfection, it frustrates her when others have such a hard time with simpler things. I've seen this and been frustrated myself, while training/teaching jobs to others.
that’s why you need to understand that it in their side as well. it frustrates them that they can’t get it right too. u have to slow down ur pace for them to catch up. lisa i think is too strict but in shows like this there’ll always be someone who’ll be taking that role. she’s a great dancer and I’m sure they’ve learned so much from her as well. it’s never easy to achieve ur dreams u need to work hard for it.
@@eminaislf3744 nope, it's a survival show that they would only have a few weeks or few days practice. Idols would usually have months of practice. That's why you have to get it as fast as u can. I understand that not everyone is just good in getting choreos but when u think about time in this competition, u need to step it more than usual
@@lovelessshin3 to each his own I guess. I have no problem with her, it’s just that as a teacher/mentor she’s too much for me. If I ever get her as a teacher I’d only be reminiscing about how much nerves I got when I had her to teach me. But considering her talent and all, I know most of them are really thankful for having her mentor them.
@@lovelessshin3 oh and I know it’s a survival show btw. With all the time constraints, anything can affect a person’s state of mind. the pressure and all but her teaching method is not for me. No disrespect for anyone out there especially blinks. I hope u don’t take this the wrong way.
@oOOOo I’m not even comparing her to the other mentors in that show. I’m not trying to disrespect her or anything. I’m just saying she’s too much for me. I’m not picking a fight alright. Why can’t you just accept that not everybody agrees with you. I’m just saying what I thought about it and I don’t hate Lisa or anything.
3:40 you're right, people usually say girl group choreographies are easy, but it's not easy to control your hands, fingers and arms so well, so it's not actually that easy
these girls were not training just to perform a dance. They were in a competition to make it as a pop idol... that stage presence is EVERYTHING, so when lisa tell you to smile... it's because you NEED TO SMILE hahah. I really enjoy your commentary on these videos. awesome
I think for me the way she is becoming tough is for their own good. Now just try to analyze it, for example she is not a tough mentor, obviously the trainees won't take it seriously nor will focus. And now the way she acts, look, the trainees are really focus on the dance, and working hard on it. Edit: Excuse my bad grammar. :)
i think their desire to impress their idol, is far stronger then any discipline or negative comments they hear. so, they want her to recognize their good performance, because if my idol was my mentor, I would be giving it my best every time.
Ame cuando estuvo en la temporada 2 y ahora en la 3 es lo. Más, no olvidaré cuando hubo gente inmadura que dijo que era mala, siendo que ella les enseñaba disciplina y fue una gran maestra, enserio amo que haya sido tan profecional, tremenda diosa que es
I am dance club member in our school and we don't have a practice room or even a mirror to practice with so we trust out teacher and just do what he taught to us. So when we have joint practice with another school and practice in their school, they have a freaking big mirror and we dance in front of it... it was really weird and distracting... so when we dance we close our eyes HAHHAHAH
I also think that what Lisa's doing is quite normal, we're just used to her being soft and sweet to her members and to Blinks ofc. She could be an actress tho. Haha I'm not into groups because of their dance choreos, I focused more into the vocals but I still love your reactions. Guess I'd be sticking around and gets excited for ur next updates whichever group it is but please do react to NAUGHTY by IRENE and SEULGI (Red Velvet) or their MONSTER (title track). Lovelovelove
Meet my professor before you say Lisa is harsh. She was a trainee for five years in YG. Y'all know how K-POP trainees work so hard in a strict environment. It's not easy in Korea... Let's appreciate our Lisa and all K-POP stars who have been working hard everyday. 💜
This to me just seems like how trainers are. Like I’m not a dancer but I’m in a sport that requires exact timing and line up so like Lisa here is just how my coaches were on a good day. It just kinda shocks me that people think that this is someone being too harsh or mean. No one here is holding back tears she’s not being mean
Love your reaction as you understand why they were trained like that. I had anxiety when they had those training classes with Lisa. My poor girls were trying so hard
Thanks again for a great review. I always get a much better idea of what is actually going on in the minds of the dancers and why Lisa is so focused on certain movements with your analysis. And you are SO right - the editing is hilarious! :)
The play over and over until you get right thing is the same in concert band. We would literally practice one note at the end of a whole song because the end was messy and not staccato enough.
A few years ago , it was an annual function so the choreographer was teaching us the choreography , but there was just this one move that I kept messing up!!! I preety innocent at that time so I was really asked and evertime I messed up that move the choreographer looked at me dead in the eye..I was hella scared
As you love Lisa’s dance, you should react to more of her dance practice videos!! Here are some: - Long Nights - Party Favors - Good Thing - I Like It - Faded - Señorita And also her Solo stage from the tour!!
Hi Radostina! I dont know if you saw, but Taemin released the dance practice for "IDEA" a few days after you did the MV reaction in November. As I didnt see the reaction, I dont know if you forgot to see. Nice reaction as always :))
Becoming an idol is a competition. A real competition to get all the glory or to fail and have nothing because to become one they take you out while you're still in high school If you're not in Korea. You have no plan b or anything to fall back on if you failed. It means you have to start over and that is not good. So when you're competing to be the next big group you got to work hard and you're going against your fellow trainees that you grew up with. They're also close friends because you're in a foreign country and the only people you hang out with is them(even if you live in the country). So it is a cut throat process. This show is different from when you're actually competing to become a staple groups that will stay for years instead of like produce 101 etc. So overall , Lisa is pretty chill! Cause just imagine you come and then they just tell you. You gotta go back home, you didnt make it. After months of training.
That part about the mirror is soooo true. You learn the move by the mirror, then add the attitude by the mirror, etc, and boom your coach makes u do it without a mirror and you just lose a sense which is vision, now you have to do it by feeling and it's really confusing the first time but then you catch and feel invincible
@@RadostinaPetrova And you're interacting with your subscribers very well too, that's so sweet of you 💛
3 роки тому
wooow I really enjoyed your video so muchhh!!! It is nice to listen to your experiences and your takes on what Lisa corrects them :O also... idk why but I felt so much nice vibes from you and your reactions uwu thank you for your content *^* really hoping to see more of your videos! Have a nice one! :)
i did ballet when i was like 12-13, i once had a teacher call out a student for something that happened outside of class like full on reprimand this girl for something her mother told the teacher about
I think anyone who has done performing arts before wouldn't think this is being tough. We have to expect a lot from ourselves and not be content with winging it.
How can you ever truly go beyond your limits if you're not pushed to them? Lisa's training ensured precision and even though it may have been harsh, it can benefit the trainee's in more ways than one. It will motivate them to do their best in order to NOT face such harsh judgment but it will also force them to pay closer attention because she's making it so obvious something is wrong forcing the dancer to almost overthink what's wrong because of her strong attitude. Some people believe being comfortable will help you learn better, but you're comfortable below your limit and that's where Lisa doesn't want her trainee's to be.
7:58 you're really right, because this has happened to me several times, in my dance training, My teacher asked me to smile, i thought i would smile and focus too, but it was harder than it seems, i tried to smile, but on the first try, i forgot about smiling and just focused on the steps, second time my only focus was to smile, and then i forgot the steps in between 😳
Not a blink but...that's how most asian teachers are. Some of them are way too strict (just check asian ballet teachers),some of them are strict but also understanding and nice,some of them are strict when they are in teacher mode but also have friendly/motherly/fatherly approach otherwise. I think it depends on what you're studying and in which field you wanna go. My teachers in hotel management are strict because of the cutthroat business.
Lisa was tough and forgot that students couldnt follow all of her instruction. Lisa means well to all trainees but I think she changes her strict and just tells them to practice more.
I dont know if you actually watched the entire show but Lisa often demonstrates the correct way of executing the moves. She's not that strict all the time as she compliments and praises the trainees from time to time. She even acknowledges some of the weaker trainees improvement in dancing. She just doesnt tell to practice but also often gives some simple tips for them to do the moves better. Please dont generalise her teaching based on a few minutes clips you see online if you havent watched the entire show.
sometimes the way she pays attention to detail is what a mentor should be. those little details like that should be critiqued the way she does. i think she is very stern when it is needed and she is a great dancer as well. she’s so love able and had immaculate talent.
I can totally relate to not smile, at practice. I'm a thinker, so when really focused on each move, I have my bitch face on. I only smile, if I focus on smiling. Of course easier to smile when you are confident in the choreo and your technique because les to think about. That's what hard about dancing in a way as you should focus and think about what you're doing, but it shouldn't show on your face during your performance.
I really miss the show, and I'm so happy that someone is still there. I'm a self taught dancer and when I do moves wrong I pretend that Lisa is there watching me and being strict. I know that most dance teachers and stuff are very strict 'cause it's like their job, but Lisa's face when she is mad is just - Idk.
LISA WAS A GREAT MENTOR. IN ORDER FOR ANY K-POP OR “STAR” TO SUCCEED DURING TRAINING YOU HAVE TO ACCEPT CRITICISM. IF A METOR DOES NOT GIVE! “STRICT” mind you if that’s the word. THEN THE PERSON IN TRAINING WILL NOT SUCCEED. LISA WANTS THEM TO SUCCEED, TO BE BIG STAR LIKE LISA. IF THE MENTOR LACKS THAT, THE PERSON IN TRAINING WILL SLACK AND NOT DO WELL, THEREFORE LISA WAS ABSOLUTELY AND 100% A GREAT MENTOR. SHE WAS NOT TRYING TO BE MEAN IN ANY WAY, SHE JUST WANTED THE GIRLS TO DO WELL/TO BE GREAT K-POP IDOLS. LISA MEANT WELL🙏🏻🫶🫶🫶
In Korea, the term "What's wrong with you" is not taken to as high offense as it is in western areas. It's a lot more commonly used in slang than in America. It's kind of like, "What are you doing?"
I think Lisa was a good mentor. The biggest problem i think is that she has to mentor in english, and even though she is fluent it isn't easy to speak very well in a language that isnt your mother tounge nor that you speak very often. It seems hard for her to find the right words to use to express what she really means. But i still think she did very well and its impressive concidering she is Thai and is mostly used to speaking Korean
9:53 I just did that on my dance less today TwT It’s not really difficult but we move a lot and we are 12 in the group so yeah. Also the studio is really small compared to the stage and we had to do the placing right. (My performance is this Saturday TwT)
I like lisa mentorship cause technically when u learning a dance routine you should understand the dance itself so you can dance it properly and convey an emotion to your audience tru your body!
That's how a mentor should be cause i myself when we wanna dance for some celebration when someone cannot catch up when i teach the second time my blood boils 🙃
If you think Lisa is a tough mentor that you can’t handle, wait till you hear about YG’s mentors and how they are teaching their trainees to be the best out of the best. Bacause I’ve watched one video where ex trainee of YGE confessed herself about how hard her trainee session with YGE until she had to give up or maybe failed. Because they must train how to sing, dance, acting, and many more.
For me,lisa is a good mentor like i think its normal to be that strict as a mentor.. I remember when i was in cheerleeding our mentor was strict and we understood it bcs if you dont act strict towards the dancers they will just not do there best .. But its based on my experience tho but i think all mentors should act like this :))
she being harsh for a reason.she is a trainee for 5 years and she knows very well what she need to do as a mentor. those girls are going to be an idol how you want to be an idol if you didnt even good at dancing nor singing.
I think Lisa is grate mentor she is just gud at it she went more when she was young if they want to be like Lisa they need to do it they came to see lisa there so no cap,
I love Lisa's attitude. Most of the comments of her being rude are based on when she speaks in english. But I lived in Asia and most of their "rude comments" aren't supposed to be that way, they just don't know any other way to say it. And that's something I don't see anybody talking about :c (Hope I made myself clear, English ain't my mother tongue either)
lisa's role there is to be a really strict mentor so i dont think shes harsh but when the season two of ywy she mentors the guys shes really nice because its her role to be strict but shes nice
In dance in high school we had to perform the dance one by one and I hated it. Just doing it alone made be so nervous I completely blanked out. And then I had to explain I know the dance and I really did practice I’m just nervous having everyone watch me 🤦🏽♀️
This isn't harsh at all, she wasn't abusive or over critical in any way, and she didn't belittle them. My dance teacher paused a song and singled me out once and said "are you an old lady?" When I said no he said "then why are you dancing like a grandma pushing a shopping cart?" 😭🤣 (Irish dance so arms were supposed to be by my sides)
🔥🔥🔥💖💖💖👑👑👑 Lisa 👑👑👑 💖💖💖 🔥🔥🔥 Is My Bias and My Queen , And The Best Mentor...!!! #RapperQueen #SwagQueen #DancingQueen #BarbieDollHuman #BLCKPNK
![SUPER STRICT | Lisa becomes a tough Mentor - Youth With You | The Duke [Reaction]](/img/n.gif)
you gotta remember how intense her training was to ultimately end up in blackpink, she has gone through the MOST intricate of scrutiny for everything, to be honest I personally think she seems super chill as a mentor compared to what she had to go through lol.
especially with the language barrier- she probably had a harder time since she would have a bit of trouble know what the trainers wanted
I agree
exactly
Me too
that’s true it reminds me of the netflix documentary when rosé said “everything that i did was wrong” when she talked about their trainee days and she was practically crying while saying it because she remember how hard it was 😭
All of mentor from YG very strict, they're so scary, Lisa got YG attitude
They will insult you by saying “ you dance like a child” and stuff while you get evaluated. Lisa’s mentoring on YwY isn't even half of what YGE’s dance mentors probably did with her, like goddamn.
@@ariboo13 I think Yg says that to make the members angry and they will dance there best to prove they best
@@devika7572 classic motivation tatic even if it’s cruel
@@devika7572 yeah its a great tactic to shape people up.
Well yeah, Lisa and other YG members have been trained strictly, the YG mentor's were really strict to them just so they can get the dance right, and have them practice the whole day without sleeping. And i think thats how Lisa got the attitude of them, Lisa isn't as strict as them though.
I think Lisa is how a mentor should be. I don't believe she was too harsh.
Exactly
Ikrrr
That's not harsh at all! That's soft enough.
Me too actually she was very cute and nice to them
Yeah i know a lot of harsh mentor ex the mentor in produce
So if you check the dance mentors in Korean competitions you will see that they are very strict so it's kind of understandable why she a little bit tough, in other Chinese competitions the mentors are lenient that's why they were surprised by LISA :p but she is the best and very professional.
Thank you for the video ;)
Oh that's interesting! And thank you 😊
i’m chinese and i assure you they are also very tough 😂
fun fact: korea's lock n lol actually was able to beat Royal Family of newzealand in HHI year 2015
lmao if you actually watched the Chinese show LISA mentored in you'll realize that nothing about the competitions, mentors or otherwise, can be associated with leniency
There is actually a huge difference between rude and tough. What she did should undoubtedly be considered as rude. That is humiliation not professional or tough. I think that's why the speaker deliberately cut out a part where Lisa humiliates a trainee who did not smile.
Conclusion: she's not a "tough" mentor, she's just a good one
i agree
I used to do ballet and the toughest teachers i’ve ever had were the ones i loved the most because if they’re harsh, you know the care. it’s when they don’t say anything to you when you should be worried.
Haha that's true!
If you guys think Lisa is too harsh, wait until you meet my mentor hahahaha
And my assamese teacher
You should meet my Thai TAs (I teach in Bangkok as a foreigner) and well, hitting children still happens in schools here.
My school banned it last year but my TAs can still be very strict vocally
It's part of Lisa's job. But what makes us shocked is not about her being tough, but because we get to see the Lisa that we never see before. Some people called her out for being too tough. That's why in YWY S3 she changed her way in giving critique and encouraged them instead. Here we can see that the trainees are afraid. She's tough, but I think it's part of her job as a mentor. But what's surprising is..... we never really know this side of Lisa before (which is 180° to the crackhead and bubbly Lisa we usually know as the maknae of the group)
ya that's why I liked Youth With You because we got to see this mature side of Lisa!
I think they’re afraid bc they don’t want to disappoint one of the biggest idols in the world
I am not a dancer so I cannot judge how tough as a mentor Lisa is but I can see is that she is very dedicated to her work. The trainees should be happy that she is watching them and their every little move like a hawk so that they can improve and show their full potential....
i like lisa as a teacher, this is the first i’ve actually seen of BP but i like the toughness, it’s more that she’s frustrated bc she knows the girls can do it
Lisa had just a few weeks to get the girls to perform a PERFECT choreo that would be broadcast in TV and voted on. That one girl that kept messing up was counting the movement wrong, she kept adding an extra beat. On the show Lisa didn't tell her what she was doing wrong at first, she was showing her the sequence to let her do it on her own and correct herself. She finally did show her where she was messing up. Also the last girl in the video who was super energetic is Esther Yu, she's a Chinese actress and singer who wanted to be on the show. She was one of the winners and is now a member of the group THE9. She's also an obsessed Lisa fan, she's on the current season with Lisa again, her job is to assist the mentors.
It was obvious the trainees were already taught and practiced the coreographer. Lisa was there to clean up, but the trainees did not really have the basic choreo down, since they are off beat, timing is off, and basic lines are not understood. so how to get a group of dancers to be ready for public performance? You can't make an omolette without breaking some eggs. this is not a dance exercise class for amateurs, this is choreo for trainees trying to debut as artists. I am surprised some of them were not sent home to set a minimum standard. people asking for a softer approach, are just asking for the trainee to be humiliated and end a career before it starts. welcome to pop music industry, second prize is your not debuting with the rest of the trainees.
I´m also a dancer and she is a normal mentor. I mean besides that she is the god Lisa. She do what a normal mentor would do
I really enjoyed your insight. I've seen clips of Lisa multiple times, but your explanation of what the trainees were experiencing and the difficulties they were facing at the time, was very interesting. Thank you....Also...second!
Aw thank you, really appreciate that 😊 Im glad it gave you some new insights!
React to Lisa lover and intentions dance on ywy3 and also check out her good things + seniorita live performance
up
There are still a lot of Lisa dance performances that you haven't reacted too, she has 3 performances in x-academy, 2 in youth wit you 2, 2 in youth with you 3 and her solo performances in their concert.
That's true, I need to get on that!
For me Lisa is a excellent mentor, is strict, fair and charismatic
When you mentor says "one more time" *NEVER* its just an one
Hahah true!
Kpop is just extremely competitive. Every year there are hundreds of groups debuting and it's already difficult staying together as a group after the first song. She is one of the few that made it and if they are not the best they stand no chance.
try 80,000 a year coming out of entertainment academies, most of them are not signed by the big three plus big hit.
There’s a social difference in western and eastern culture, teachers in asia are strict and don’t tend to compliment you much when you make a little progress. This companies are strict, they want to squeeze your full potential out of you. Just look at all the succesful idols, they have been through such a tough a hell of a training process and some even don’t make it to debute. In my opinion she is just being how a instructor should be, disciplined to make motivate one to push beyond one’s limits.
Idk what you mean by west, bcs here in Europe dance mentors are exactly like her
Sometimes u have to be strict. Lisa and other k-pop idols have gone through worse. They have been evaluated very strictly and it's been very demotivating at times and yet she's Understanding and soft to others, that's her beautiful character
Lisa is the real definition of a mentor. Thats why iqiyi invited her again to youth with you season 3
She is soo different from the YG mentor. She is more kind and help them a lot... for me she is a good mentor. She have experience 💗🖤
I think with someone like Lisa, who can watch a dance once and then do the dance to almost perfection, it frustrates her when others have such a hard time with simpler things. I've seen this and been frustrated myself, while training/teaching jobs to others.
that’s why you need to understand that it in their side as well. it frustrates them that they can’t get it right too. u have to slow down ur pace for them to catch up. lisa i think is too strict but in shows like this there’ll always be someone who’ll be taking that role. she’s a great dancer and I’m sure they’ve learned so much from her as well. it’s never easy to achieve ur dreams u need to work hard for it.
@@eminaislf3744 nope, it's a survival show that they would only have a few weeks or few days practice. Idols would usually have months of practice. That's why you have to get it as fast as u can. I understand that not everyone is just good in getting choreos but when u think about time in this competition, u need to step it more than usual
@@lovelessshin3 to each his own I guess. I have no problem with her, it’s just that as a teacher/mentor she’s too much for me. If I ever get her as a teacher I’d only be reminiscing about how much nerves I got when I had her to teach me. But considering her talent and all, I know most of them are really thankful for having her mentor them.
@@lovelessshin3 oh and I know it’s a survival show btw. With all the time constraints, anything can affect a person’s state of mind. the pressure and all but her teaching method is not for me. No disrespect for anyone out there especially blinks. I hope u don’t take this the wrong way.
@oOOOo I’m not even comparing her to the other mentors in that show. I’m not trying to disrespect her or anything. I’m just saying she’s too much for me. I’m not picking a fight alright. Why can’t you just accept that not everybody agrees with you. I’m just saying what I thought about it and I don’t hate Lisa or anything.
3:40 you're right, people usually say girl group choreographies are easy, but it's not easy to control your hands, fingers and arms so well, so it's not actually that easy
2:39-2:41 bruh you basically had the same thought when lisa reacted to the hands lol
I love the reactions to different kpop artist I think that she should do one of HyunA's dance or performance
Noted 😊
these girls were not training just to perform a dance. They were in a competition to make it as a pop idol... that stage presence is EVERYTHING, so when lisa tell you to smile... it's because you NEED TO SMILE hahah. I really enjoy your commentary on these videos. awesome
I think for me the way she is becoming tough is for their own good. Now just try to analyze it, for example she is not a tough mentor, obviously the trainees won't take it seriously nor will focus. And now the way she acts, look, the trainees are really focus on the dance, and working hard on it.
Edit: Excuse my bad grammar. :)
i think their desire to impress their idol, is far stronger then any discipline or negative comments they hear. so, they want her to recognize their good performance, because if my idol was my mentor, I would be giving it my best every time.
Whoever is the person of the utube channel named confusion, he/she must get an award for editing.
That’s why I’m not in Kpop group because everything has to be perfect and singing. Lisa is a great mentor and coach. I love you Lisa
Ame cuando estuvo en la temporada 2 y ahora en la 3 es lo. Más, no olvidaré cuando hubo gente inmadura que dijo que era mala, siendo que ella les enseñaba disciplina y fue una gran maestra, enserio amo que haya sido tan profecional, tremenda diosa que es
I am dance club member in our school and we don't have a practice room or even a mirror to practice with so we trust out teacher and just do what he taught to us. So when we have joint practice with another school and practice in their school, they have a freaking big mirror and we dance in front of it... it was really weird and distracting... so when we dance we close our eyes HAHHAHAH
Hahha thanks for sharing that! 😊
I literally love Lisa.. she’s the best
Me too she’s a queen
She just wants everyone to be perfect❤️
Watching this, I’m not surprised she can speak like four languages. You don’t get to that with a “close enough” mentality.
Lisa just wanted the members to dance well. If they join the competition, they should expect how harsh it is.
After watching Paris goebel and her dance troupe train… I found this mild.
Happy to see that you also share your experience on dancing so that I can more understand on what the trainees might thought.
Really glad it gave you a different insight 😊
I also think that what Lisa's doing is quite normal, we're just used to her being soft and sweet to her members and to Blinks ofc. She could be an actress tho. Haha
I'm not into groups because of their dance choreos, I focused more into the vocals but I still love your reactions. Guess I'd be sticking around and gets excited for ur next updates whichever group it is but please do react to NAUGHTY by IRENE and SEULGI (Red Velvet) or their MONSTER (title track).
Lovelovelove
Aw that's really nice to hear, thank you 😊 And welcome to the channel!
This girl is so pretty. Man my heart is sinking
Your videos makes my day just that little bit more joyful!
Im so happy to hear that 😊 And just so you know, your comment made my day more joyful 🥰
From morning I am watching your videos. You are so beautiful. I appreciate you dear! Keep going like that💜
Thank you! I really appreciate that 😊🙏🏻
Meet my professor before you say Lisa is harsh. She was a trainee for five years in YG. Y'all know how K-POP trainees work so hard in a strict environment. It's not easy in Korea... Let's appreciate our Lisa and all K-POP stars who have been working hard everyday. 💜
This to me just seems like how trainers are. Like I’m not a dancer but I’m in a sport that requires exact timing and line up so like Lisa here is just how my coaches were on a good day. It just kinda shocks me that people think that this is someone being too harsh or mean. No one here is holding back tears she’s not being mean
Love your reaction as you understand why they were trained like that.
I had anxiety when they had those training classes with Lisa. My poor girls were trying so hard
Thanks again for a great review. I always get a much better idea of what is actually going on in the minds of the dancers and why Lisa is so focused on certain movements with your analysis. And you are SO right - the editing is hilarious! :)
Hey there 😊 Thanks, really happy to hear that!
The play over and over until you get right thing is the same in concert band. We would literally practice one note at the end of a whole song because the end was messy and not staccato enough.
A few years ago , it was an annual function so the choreographer was teaching us the choreography , but there was just this one move that I kept messing up!!! I preety innocent at that time so I was really asked and evertime I messed up that move the choreographer looked at me dead in the eye..I was hella scared
As you love Lisa’s dance, you should react to more of her dance practice videos!! Here are some:
- Long Nights
- Party Favors
- Good Thing
- I Like It
- Faded
- Señorita
And also her Solo stage from the tour!!
Nobody:
Not even a soul:
Lisa: I don't have any comments AND what's wrong with you
Hi Radostina! I dont know if you saw, but Taemin released the dance practice for "IDEA" a few days after you did the MV reaction in November. As I didnt see the reaction, I dont know if you forgot to see.
Nice reaction as always :))
Hey there 😊 Yes, I did see there was a dance practice, I just never got around to filming that one to be honest 😅
Becoming an idol is a competition. A real competition to get all the glory or to fail and have nothing because to become one they take you out while you're still in high school If you're not in Korea. You have no plan b or anything to fall back on if you failed. It means you have to start over and that is not good. So when you're competing to be the next big group you got to work hard and you're going against your fellow trainees that you grew up with. They're also close friends because you're in a foreign country and the only people you hang out with is them(even if you live in the country). So it is a cut throat process. This show is different from when you're actually competing to become a staple groups that will stay for years instead of like produce 101 etc. So overall , Lisa is pretty chill! Cause just imagine you come and then they just tell you. You gotta go back home, you didnt make it. After months of training.
She says: don't know what to do
Me: LIKE THE SONG!!!
Lisa is so adorable 😍
“Whats wrong with you” Shookedt
That part about the mirror is soooo true. You learn the move by the mirror, then add the attitude by the mirror, etc, and boom your coach makes u do it without a mirror and you just lose a sense which is vision, now you have to do it by feeling and it's really confusing the first time but then you catch and feel invincible
Also I love your breakdowns I would like it so much if you could react to Rose - On the ground Dance performance !
Aaaack here you go again.. I love your "Lisa" reaction videos and YOU so much.
Thank you, I really appreciate that 😊🙏🏻
@@RadostinaPetrova And you're interacting with your subscribers very well too, that's so sweet of you 💛
wooow I really enjoyed your video so muchhh!!! It is nice to listen to your experiences and your takes on what Lisa corrects them :O also... idk why but I felt so much nice vibes from you and your reactions uwu thank you for your content *^* really hoping to see more of your videos! Have a nice one! :)
Hey 😊 Thank you for the lovely comment! I'll definitely make more videos!
lisa is angel compared to my old teacher so i don't think this is though at all
i did ballet when i was like 12-13, i once had a teacher call out a student for something that happened outside of class like full on reprimand this girl for something her mother told the teacher about
I think anyone who has done performing arts before wouldn't think this is being tough. We have to expect a lot from ourselves and not be content with winging it.
How can you ever truly go beyond your limits if you're not pushed to them? Lisa's training ensured precision and even though it may have been harsh, it can benefit the trainee's in more ways than one. It will motivate them to do their best in order to NOT face such harsh judgment but it will also force them to pay closer attention because she's making it so obvious something is wrong forcing the dancer to almost overthink what's wrong because of her strong attitude. Some people believe being comfortable will help you learn better, but you're comfortable below your limit and that's where Lisa doesn't want her trainee's to be.
Love your channel now
7:58 you're really right, because this has happened to me several times, in my dance training, My teacher asked me to smile, i thought i would smile and focus too, but it was harder than it seems, i tried to smile, but on the first try, i forgot about smiling and just focused on the steps, second time my only focus was to smile, and then i forgot the steps in between 😳
Love Lisa mentor
Not a blink but...that's how most asian teachers are. Some of them are way too strict (just check asian ballet teachers),some of them are strict but also understanding and nice,some of them are strict when they are in teacher mode but also have friendly/motherly/fatherly approach otherwise. I think it depends on what you're studying and in which field you wanna go.
My teachers in hotel management are strict because of the cutthroat business.
Lisa was tough and forgot that students couldnt follow all of her instruction. Lisa means well to all trainees but I think she changes her strict and just tells them to practice more.
I dont know if you actually watched the entire show but Lisa often demonstrates the correct way of executing the moves. She's not that strict all the time as she compliments and praises the trainees from time to time. She even acknowledges some of the weaker trainees improvement in dancing. She just doesnt tell to practice but also often gives some simple tips for them to do the moves better. Please dont generalise her teaching based on a few minutes clips you see online if you havent watched the entire show.
Thank you for reacting Lisa’s clips again, I’m very happy.
Im really happy to hear that 😊🙏🏻
The mirror yes omg hahahhahahahaha i had the experience too 🤣🤣🤣 it was like wait left right wait
sometimes the way she pays attention to detail is what a mentor should be. those little details like that should be critiqued the way she does. i think she is very stern when it is needed and she is a great dancer as well. she’s so love able and had immaculate talent.
I can totally relate to not smile, at practice. I'm a thinker, so when really focused on each move, I have my bitch face on. I only smile, if I focus on smiling. Of course easier to smile when you are confident in the choreo and your technique because les to think about. That's what hard about dancing in a way as you should focus and think about what you're doing, but it shouldn't show on your face during your performance.
You…should see ballet instructors… this is tame compared to every single day all types of dance teachers. Literally.
you're so pretty omg
Thank you 😊🙏🏻
@@RadostinaPetrova 😊😊
"One more time, One more time. That is the secret of success from Lisa!
I really miss the show, and I'm so happy that someone is still there. I'm a self taught dancer and when I do moves wrong I pretend that Lisa is there watching me and being strict.
I know that most dance teachers and stuff are very strict 'cause it's like their job, but Lisa's face when she is mad is just - Idk.
Love your reactions,pls keep it up😊
Thank you 😊🙏🏻
LISA WAS A GREAT MENTOR. IN ORDER FOR ANY K-POP OR “STAR” TO SUCCEED DURING TRAINING YOU HAVE TO ACCEPT CRITICISM. IF A METOR DOES NOT GIVE! “STRICT” mind you if that’s the word. THEN THE PERSON IN TRAINING WILL NOT SUCCEED. LISA WANTS THEM TO SUCCEED, TO BE BIG STAR LIKE LISA. IF THE MENTOR LACKS THAT, THE PERSON IN TRAINING WILL SLACK AND NOT DO WELL, THEREFORE LISA WAS ABSOLUTELY AND 100% A GREAT MENTOR. SHE WAS NOT TRYING TO BE MEAN IN ANY WAY, SHE JUST WANTED THE GIRLS TO DO WELL/TO BE GREAT K-POP IDOLS. LISA MEANT WELL🙏🏻🫶🫶🫶
In Korea, the term "What's wrong with you" is not taken to as high offense as it is in western areas. It's a lot more commonly used in slang than in America. It's kind of like, "What are you doing?"
I think Lisa was a good mentor. The biggest problem i think is that she has to mentor in english, and even though she is fluent it isn't easy to speak very well in a language that isnt your mother tounge nor that you speak very often. It seems hard for her to find the right words to use to express what she really means. But i still think she did very well and its impressive concidering she is Thai and is mostly used to speaking Korean
For context, in Lisa's company, they trained for about 5 years, 12 hours a day and only 1 day off every two weeks.
Lisa is jut teaching them what YG taught her and BlackPink many years ago up to now and her also teaching them what she learned and what she knows
9:53 I just did that on my dance less today TwT It’s not really difficult but we move a lot and we are 12 in the group so yeah. Also the studio is really small compared to the stage and we had to do the placing right. (My performance is this Saturday TwT)
I like lisa mentorship cause technically when u learning a dance routine you should understand the dance itself so you can dance it properly and convey an emotion to your audience tru your body!
omg this was so funny loved it
Glad to hear it 😊
wow you are really a dancer with great insight. i appreciate your comments
Thank you 😊🙏🏻
Lisa is a great dancer she wants every-trainee has a perfect move
That's how a mentor should be cause i myself when we wanna dance for some celebration when someone cannot catch up when i teach the second time my blood boils 🙃
If you think Lisa is a tough mentor that you can’t handle, wait till you hear about YG’s mentors and how they are teaching their trainees to be the best out of the best. Bacause I’ve watched one video where ex trainee of YGE confessed herself about how hard her trainee session with YGE until she had to give up or maybe failed. Because they must train how to sing, dance, acting, and many more.
For me,lisa is a good mentor like i think its normal to be that strict as a mentor.. I remember when i was in cheerleeding our mentor was strict and we understood it bcs if you dont act strict towards the dancers they will just not do there best .. But its based on my experience tho but i think all mentors should act like this :))
she being harsh for a reason.she is a trainee for 5 years and she knows very well what she need to do as a mentor. those girls are going to be an idol how you want to be an idol if you didnt even good at dancing nor singing.
I think Lisa is grate mentor she is just gud at it she went more when she was young if they want to be like Lisa they need to do it they came to see lisa there so no cap,
I love Lisa's attitude. Most of the comments of her being rude are based on when she speaks in english. But I lived in Asia and most of their "rude comments" aren't supposed to be that way, they just don't know any other way to say it. And that's something I don't see anybody talking about :c
(Hope I made myself clear, English ain't my mother tongue either)
legend has it abby lee visits lisa every night
lisa's role there is to be a really strict mentor so i dont think shes harsh but when the season two of ywy she mentors the guys shes really nice because its her role to be strict but shes nice
In dance in high school we had to perform the dance one by one and I hated it. Just doing it alone made be so nervous I completely blanked out. And then I had to explain I know the dance and I really did practice I’m just nervous having everyone watch me 🤦🏽♀️
love your commentaries 💖! you should check out the performance of Butterfly by loona
Thank you and noted 😊
This isn't harsh at all, she wasn't abusive or over critical in any way, and she didn't belittle them. My dance teacher paused a song and singled me out once and said "are you an old lady?" When I said no he said "then why are you dancing like a grandma pushing a shopping cart?" 😭🤣 (Irish dance so arms were supposed to be by my sides)
Hi im actually new to the channel. I just wanted to ask whats your name?
YG best choreographers in the kpop industry. moves are always good. Street women fighter looks fire also.
🔥🔥🔥💖💖💖👑👑👑 Lisa 👑👑👑 💖💖💖 🔥🔥🔥
Is My Bias and My Queen , And The Best Mentor...!!!
#RapperQueen #SwagQueen #DancingQueen #BarbieDollHuman #BLCKPNK