Ethiopia in Development 1934

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024
  • Ethiopia in Development 1934

КОМЕНТАРІ • 120

  • @HabeshaTraveler
    @HabeshaTraveler 3 роки тому +6

    There 10000000 of channels on UA-cam yours is worth more than anything I can describe thank you brother / sister

  • @selamlehulum4373
    @selamlehulum4373 3 роки тому +25

    ፎቶው ብዙ ይናገራል!!!! አቤት ድምፅ ቢኖረው ደግሞ ልዩ ነበር!!!
    ለማንኛውም እናመሰግናለን!!! እንዲህ አይነት ታሪካዊ ቪዲዮዎች ይጨመርልን!!!

  • @tikuranbessa1963
    @tikuranbessa1963 3 роки тому +19

    As always, another brilliant upload.
    Wish it wasn't a silent one. None the less, very thankful.

  • @DagmawiAbate
    @DagmawiAbate 3 роки тому +2

    Ere yemechachu yezhe channel balebetoch. I wasn't expecting to see anything so damn beautiful! Tnks a lot.

  • @Drunk-Fly
    @Drunk-Fly 3 роки тому +17

    The Golden Era, when a King was a King 💯

  • @frehaile6298
    @frehaile6298 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks Mr Bani well done excellent job you sharing 💫

  • @agessaanbessa6026
    @agessaanbessa6026 2 роки тому +1

    Biniam Hirut Thank You

  • @hiruthseyoum5969
    @hiruthseyoum5969 3 роки тому +6

    Thank you for sharing
    🙏🙏💕from Ethiopia

  • @afroethiopia5667
    @afroethiopia5667 3 роки тому +12

    Beautiful Ethiopia 💚💛❤🦁

  • @meskeremsaunier4216
    @meskeremsaunier4216 2 місяці тому

    C'est un plaisir de partager avec vous ✨️🤩 merci BH👍💚💛❤️

  • @samuelyowhanes809
    @samuelyowhanes809 3 роки тому +2

    It was amazing and historical one thanks u for sharing this wonderful generation

  • @እምየኢትዮቤቴ
    @እምየኢትዮቤቴ 3 роки тому +6

    Wow, it's amazing, and thanks for sharing

  • @h.taf.220
    @h.taf.220 3 роки тому +2

    We love, love love your posts..Thank you!

  • @ድንቅነሽ-ቘ2መ
    @ድንቅነሽ-ቘ2መ 3 роки тому +2

    Thank you very much for sharing.

  • @ሁሉምያልፋል-ሸ7ቀ
    @ሁሉምያልፋል-ሸ7ቀ 3 роки тому +8

    Incredible Ethiopia

    • @tigrayfirst2261
      @tigrayfirst2261 3 роки тому

      You never went any further from 1934 until tplf took power. Now you got the power and the first thing you did was taking Ethiopia back to 1934... this is what amhara. Welcome to the amhara government.

    • @nanonano9940
      @nanonano9940 3 роки тому +1

      Now this historical mom Ethiopia are on the verg of disentegration by Unresponsible Oromo government😭😭😭😭

    • @nanonano9940
      @nanonano9940 3 роки тому +1

      Now this historical mom Ethiopia are on the verg of disentegration by Unresponsible Oromo government😭😭😭😭

  • @ethiopiannewendeavor8867
    @ethiopiannewendeavor8867 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks Biniam.

  • @nebtube9206
    @nebtube9206 3 роки тому +1

    Amazing Addis Ababa Old City

  • @tibebuderseh8235
    @tibebuderseh8235 2 роки тому

    What went wrong with the sound system? Could someone work on rehabilitating the sound?

  • @take12344
    @take12344 3 роки тому +2

    Amazing how life and history passed and going on....

  • @hope8944
    @hope8944 3 роки тому +10

    ዛሬ በሱፍና በከረቫት ነው የድሮ ያለባበስ ስታይላችን ቢመለስ

    • @artistsurafel
      @artistsurafel 3 роки тому +3

      የሚገርምህ ስታይሉ አሁንም አለ፣ ወደሰሜናዊው ገጠር ስትወርድ አለባበሱ እንዳለ ነው። በከተማ ደግሞ ቤተስኪያን ሳሚው ነጠላ የማያገለድም የለም። የሰርግ መልስና ቅልቅል ላይ ሙሽሮች የአሁንም ያገር ልብስ ይለብሳሉ። በየአመት በዓሉም ሕዝቡ ይለብሰዋል። ችግሩ፣ የኛ ልብስ ጥጥ ተፈትሎ ሸማኔ ተፈልጎ በእጅ በጥበብ በአድካሚ ጥረት የሚሠራ ስለሆነ ውድ ሆነ፣ በአንጻሩ የአውሮፓ ልብስ በማሽን በጅምላ ስለሚመረት ገበያውን አጥለቅልቆት ዛሬ ላይ የሀገር ባህል ልብስ እንደ ቅንጦት እየታየ ነው። ቻይኖቹ ግን በጅምላ አምርተው ሳያሳዩንና እንደህንዶቹ ወደየባሕላዊ አለባበሳችን ሳይመልሱን አይቀር ይሆናል።

  • @abyssiniaethiopia7667
    @abyssiniaethiopia7667 2 роки тому

    💚💛❤️gloire a l'Ethiopie !!!💚💛❤️gloire a l'Ethiopie !!!

  • @barockermias7464
    @barockermias7464 3 роки тому +2

    Thank you so much, very amazing footage. Anyone can tell me the name of the guys in minutes 3.43 to 3?

  • @derartutola2579
    @derartutola2579 3 роки тому +2

    የሚገርም ነው የየዋ ዘመን

  • @yestube1556
    @yestube1556 3 роки тому

    Thank you 🥰 😍

  • @NaniNani-kl2lg
    @NaniNani-kl2lg 3 роки тому +1

    Wereketuan (debedabewan) eko telatun yeyazew yemesel acheremametat 🤣ayy wendu Gobez, Jegena ♥️

  • @serkaddislevens2461
    @serkaddislevens2461 10 місяців тому

    Interesting, the behaviour doesn't change much.

  • @Lucy-km4zi
    @Lucy-km4zi 10 місяців тому

    ታሪክን በእውነተኛው መነፅር ስላሳያችሁን እጅግ አድርጌ አመሰግናለሁ።

  • @TADESDR3
    @TADESDR3 3 роки тому +1

    የድሮ ኢትዩጵያውያን ያላቸው ፀጋ ታይተው አይጠገቡም

  • @patiencevirtue3932
    @patiencevirtue3932 3 роки тому +9

    Thanks to the Emperor's visions and mission to develop his country and liberate the people of the land. He brought Ethiopis so many privileges. He was their savior/redeemer. But in the end his own people that he empowered turned against him. Same story of jesus being betrayed, crucified, and denied by his own people, after all the good he did for them. Emperor Haile Selassie 1 is Almighty God in flesh. His name, his titles, his birth sign his biography, enough proof of this claim.

    • @samsondawitagegnehu8913
      @samsondawitagegnehu8913 3 роки тому

      They could never turn against a great leader!!!

    • @justynthymetaylorcoleman2719
      @justynthymetaylorcoleman2719 3 роки тому +4

      Yes my brother and they did turn on a great leader history will show their judgment anybody who studies what highly Selassie did shows that he is a great leader we know there are people that will always spread propaganda about him he told us people living in Ethiopia are no exception members of the church are no exception and yes he was praised by the clergyman of his church who refer to him through scripture and prophecy and he commissioned the Ethiopian member of the church to paint a mural that remains inside of his Palace that depicts him in a scene from Revelation as the final judge

    • @XalaalSomalis
      @XalaalSomalis 3 роки тому

      It must be nostalgic for some to be enamored with these clips. Be objective, and ask yourself. Could he have done more in terms of ethnic and religious equity? Could he have been the reason why so many Amharas are haunted by his discriminatory policies towards those whom they considered less civil, less Ethiopian, and less noble members of the Ethiopian family? I feel, to a large extent, he was a failure, for if he succeeded, the country would have been very different. Much of what we continue to deal with is animosity towards each other rooted in the struggle of the significant difference in how his monarchy treated people. In the end, no one was left with an advantage. And by the way, I am not anti-Hile, but I liked the ending of Haile Selassie's feudal system, for that would have kept us 2nd class citizens. And on that front, I condemn the animosity that Amhara across our nation have been treated with for a perceived advantage they held over the rest of the Ethiopian family. If there was such a thing, others' envy didn’t let them enjoy it for themselves, just as the recent Tigarus haven’t either. And the centuries-old cycle seems to continue.

    • @patiencevirtue3932
      @patiencevirtue3932 3 роки тому +2

      @@XalaalSomalis the Good Emperor even struggled with his own noble family and the church to give up land to the poor. He gave all ethnic group a change to be a Representative in his monarch. But most of them fought him, because they didn't want to give up their old slavery and backward system. He abolished slavery in Ethiopia, he gave all Ethiopian equal priviledge as long as they were willing to make a change. The Good Emperor improved/developed Ethiopia's social and economic position tremendously. The world have record of what Ethiopia was like prior to his rule and what improvements was done once he sat up on the throne.
      DURING THE TIME OF KING DAVID, SOLOMON, TAHARKA, MOSES, ABRAHAM, JACOB, and especially JESUS CHRIST, despite their good heart and good intentions they were judged and hated by the enemies who sat upon oppression. You seem like an enemy of progress.
      When God brought the children out of Egypt and out of captivity and saved them from their common enemy, they turned around and disrespected him, and cursed him. And over the the period of time he turned his face from them and destruction took them, they couldn't save themselves. GOD CHASTISE THOSE WHO NEED TO BE CHASTISED, THEY WILL COMPLAIN BUT ITS OK. BECAUSE HE IS THE CREATOR AND THE AUTHOR. Not all people in Ethiopia are children of GOD, some of them are the SEED of the SERPENT. And the seeds of the serpent tongue is against God. EMPEROR HAILE SELASSIE IS ALMIGHTY GOD IN FLESH. REVELATION SAYS THAT IN THOSE DAYS (WHICH IS IN THE TIME OF REVELATION WHICH STARTED IN THE LATE 19TH CENTURY SINCE THE TIME OF EMPEROR MENELIK 2) All eyes shall see the face of the LORD all eyes shall see GOD (thanks to technology we saw him and his good deeds).

    • @XalaalSomalis
      @XalaalSomalis 3 роки тому

      @@patiencevirtue3932
      I realize the emperor has a completely different meaning for the two of us. But out of respect for what he means to you and knowing that anything I say won’t change much I will refrain from answering your justification of some Ethiopians to be “serpents” worthy of social injustice and oppression. Is it not Ironic that this is how the Whites have justified their slavery, racism and oppression towards you and your people? I guess dehumanization of people isn’t a new element for human beings to disregard the cruel and savagery lived experience of the oppressed.
      Since you hold him to be divine, pointing out his shortcomings won’t help. However, you can read about why his own people deposed him.

  • @artistsurafel
    @artistsurafel 3 роки тому +2

    ወይ አባ ጃንሆይ፣ ግርማ ሞገሳቸው እኮ ካውሮፓውያኑ ሊቃውንትና መኳንንት እንኳን እጅግ ይልቃል። 10:29 በፈገግታቸው ገልመጥ ሲያደርጉት እስቲ ፈረንጁ እንዴት እንዳደገደገ እዩትማ።

  • @akiya9931
    @akiya9931 3 роки тому

    it was ... one day we will back to ancient Ethiopia.

  • @reshidnuri5551
    @reshidnuri5551 2 роки тому

    እጅግ በጣም ደስ ይላል ምንም ይሁን ምንም ሀገራችን የት አንደነበረች ይናገራል አሁን ግን እንደ ካሮት የዘቅጠት ቁልቁሊት ወይኔ ያ ትውልድ !
    የዘሬ 50 እና 60 ዓመት ይህም ጊዜ ይሞገስ ይሀን ?
    ማን ያውቃል ?
    ደግሞ አይቀርም !

  • @mataralsuwaidi3463
    @mataralsuwaidi3463 3 місяці тому

    ❤❤

  • @dawitdenekew6650
    @dawitdenekew6650 3 роки тому

    you always surprise me

  • @Dior768
    @Dior768 3 роки тому +1

    WoW!!!!

  • @joewellajoe5377
    @joewellajoe5377 3 роки тому

    Thx too much ....

  • @hoodgeographic868
    @hoodgeographic868 2 роки тому

    Psalms 78

  • @bosenagashu1673
    @bosenagashu1673 3 роки тому

    😳😳😳😳🥰🥰🥰🥰
    አይ ሀገሬ

  • @ashemanall
    @ashemanall 3 роки тому

    why no sound ??

  • @Meiry756
    @Meiry756 4 місяці тому

    Ke3000 Amet Behuala ( Development ) Yemigerm’new Yenante ‘’’ inkulilish wey’demo Xiwixiway ‘’’ Tarik ...

  • @jonimiki8783
    @jonimiki8783 2 роки тому

    እኚ ንጉስ ግርማ ሞገሳቸው በጣም ይገርሙኛል።

  • @mathewosyohannes280
    @mathewosyohannes280 2 дні тому

    if it was not frater I wouldn't have been i. Hear displaced from.my 15 yrs.home with my five children .Alas Ethiopia ,Alaz Ethiopians.zzzzz!!!!!!

  • @ss-gu9ge
    @ss-gu9ge 3 роки тому

    አየ ጊዜ🙏🙏🙏

    • @Useh58rpbs
      @Useh58rpbs 3 роки тому

      ዛሬ ላይ አደረገን እኔጂ የውሻ ሚኒዜ

  • @henocklema3137
    @henocklema3137 3 роки тому

    💚💛❤

  • @addisabebapiazzaethiopia3658
    @addisabebapiazzaethiopia3658 3 роки тому +1

    🙏⛪️💚💛❤️💚💛❤️

  • @nabuteyimer1557
    @nabuteyimer1557 3 роки тому

    ባቡሩ እንደሚመስለኝ ወደኮሪያ የዘመቱትን ይሆን!

  • @luk-man7889
    @luk-man7889 3 роки тому +2

    በድህነቱ የሚመጻደቅና በመሃይነቱ የሚኮራ ከንቱ የሆነ ኋላቀር የ300 ዓመት የልመና ባህል ያለው ህዝብ ነው ሀበሻ ማለት።

    • @Only1God777
      @Only1God777 3 роки тому

      ምን ታደርገው ለሁሉም ጎዜ አለው እንቁላሉ ቀሰ በቀሰ በእግሮዎ ትሄዳለች።

    • @ካ.ደ.መ.Z
      @ካ.ደ.መ.Z 2 роки тому

      ፈረንጁ ቂቂቂቂ

  • @nanonano9940
    @nanonano9940 3 роки тому

    Now this historical mom Ethiopia are on the verg of disentegration by Unresponsible Oromo government😭😭😭😭

    • @user-fu1yt1rq7n
      @user-fu1yt1rq7n 3 роки тому

      nonsense

    • @nanonano9940
      @nanonano9940 3 роки тому

      @@user-fu1yt1rq7n i can improoved what i had written so that to make easy for you.:: the Galla who can not lead a country are making the country almost to the top of disentegration by slaughting civilian , displacing civilian mainly in oromia, Benishangul, South region , Tigray and now in Adis Ababa and Amhara region , Afar region

  • @nanonano9940
    @nanonano9940 3 роки тому +1

    Now this historical mom Ethiopia are on the verg of disentegration by Unresponsible Oromo government😭😭😭😭 the killer genocider Oromuma goverment, very sad is also invaded by the foriegn( the last weakest country Sudan) had invaded us, look in the early era even European dod not concored us. Abiy you will be rembered the the most bad Ethiopia goverment in the history.

  • @amanuelghedai7622
    @amanuelghedai7622 5 місяців тому

    HIM Haile Sellasie

  • @diribamazengiya5102
    @diribamazengiya5102 3 роки тому

    IS MY EYE OR GUDINA TUMSA?

  • @yosefetopia7711
    @yosefetopia7711 3 роки тому

    ድምፅ አልባ ነው።

  • @ethiopiatekdem7201
    @ethiopiatekdem7201 3 роки тому

    Ethiopia erson gela motech

  • @lili20009
    @lili20009 3 роки тому

    Catholic Cathedral church ohhhh

  • @samsondawitagegnehu8913
    @samsondawitagegnehu8913 3 роки тому +1

    I want to study this footage so much! I am famous 😂😅

  • @XalaalSomalis
    @XalaalSomalis 3 роки тому +1

    Historic, yes.....but It must be nostalgic for some to be enamored with these clips. Be objective, and ask yourself. Could he have done more in terms of ethnic and religious equity? Could he have been the reason why so many Amharas are haunted by his discriminatory policies towards those whom they considered less civil, less Ethiopian, and less noble members of the Ethiopian family? I feel, to a large extent, he was a failure, for if he succeeded, the country would have been very different. Much of what we continue to deal with is animosity towards each other rooted in the struggle of the significant difference in how his monarchy treated people. In the end, no one was left with an advantage. And by the way, I am not anti-Hile, but I liked the ending of Haile Selassie's feudal system, for that would have kept us 2nd class citizens. And on that front, I condemn the animosity that Amhara across our nation have been treated with for a perceived advantage they held over the rest of the Ethiopian family. If there was such a thing, others' envy didn’t let them enjoy it for themselves, just as the recent Tigarus haven’t either. And the centuries-old cycle seems to continue.

    • @onelove2817
      @onelove2817 3 роки тому +4

      You're regurgitateing unproven, flawed, false narratives propogated by TPLF, OLF, ELf, EPLF, EPRP, Derg, Meison, ESUNA, socialists, revolutionary democrats, and other narrow minded liberation fronts. Amharas are as poor as any ethnicity in Ethiopia. It was a lie then. It is a lie now.

    • @XalaalSomalis
      @XalaalSomalis 3 роки тому

      @@onelove2817,
      Do you know what all those organizations you mentioned represent? They all came about into existence due to grievances, and real ones, with the emperor’s regime. Of course, Amharas as a group were and are as poor as any other reflective of our country. You should have read my entire comment before going into your pre-existing defensive mode. Any neutral scholarly person will concede the facts that a disproportionate majority of the privileged under the emperor’s reign from education to government posts were Amharas and then other highland Christians; left out to be civilized first by those privileged core servants were the Muslims lowlands and other peripheral ethnicities who were also deemed not so Ethiopians. The emperor did some positive but that his education campaign policies were discriminatory in that they have separated Ethiopians into “a deserving group” and “not so deserving group.” From your defensive tone, it seems that you may need to examine your bias. Please respond to the entire gist of my comment without taking snippets to air an already formulated defensive position. And remember, every Ethiopian or, for that matter, any world citizens can either praise or criticize the late emperor based on his record during his reign. While he was a father figure to his largely Amhara and Christian constituents, he was absent in the lives of those who were deemed “others.” I can back this conclusion with facts and data. Lastly, the late Emperor was deposed and replaced by Derg, which sprung out of our Ethiopian Army for they recognized something needed done to attend to the grievances shared by almost all Ethiopians, except the an elites core. You can not re-write history by dismissing it as a propaganda.

    • @onelove2817
      @onelove2817 3 роки тому +3

      I primarily blame the fuedal system for the inequalities of the time. Landowning Amharas, Oromos, eritreans, Tigraians, and other ethnic Chiefs have control over the daily lives of the serfs and peasants . The uneducated Derg misled by the narrow minded tribal and ethnic alligned student movement destroyed the country. I am for land for tiller. Today land is taken from the poor Oromo, Beshangul, Gambela, Afar, Amhara is given to tribal Tigrayans in the name of investment. In Addis the farners were forcibly removed from their land by Tigraians in the name of development. The farmers end up being displaced and homeless. Despite resistance from conservative fuedal landlords and Orthodox Church Haile Selassie tried to bring the country to civilization. With limited resources he established modern education, aviation, rail, military, police, OAU, etc. When Derg took over Ethiopia"s economy was growing at faster rate.

    • @ካ.ደ.መ.Z
      @ካ.ደ.መ.Z 2 роки тому

      @@onelove2817 Well said sir! Couldn't have said it any better. except for the part about thec Dergue.

    • @BW-fz5kf
      @BW-fz5kf Рік тому +1

      Anybody could work in the government regardless of background during H.I.M Haile Selassie's era. All you had to do was work hard and be educated and you'd find a spot in the government. If you couldn't afford education the church would help you and the government would sponsor you if you were a promising student. Nowadays everyone want's to leave Ethiopia during H.I.M Haile Selassie's government Ethiopians living abroad would come back home after completing their educations to teach others and improve the state of their country. Now Habeshas are a people in exile. Secondly you call him a failure but if you compare 1930s Addis to 1970s Addis it's somewhat unrecognizable. Now look at Ethiopia today. Everything built on the legacy of H.I.M but the stripped his name so he gets no credit. Addis Ababa University was Haile Selassie I University. Bole Airport was Haile Selassie I University. Ethiopian Airlines was his idea and now it's one of the best airlines in the world and is part of the star alliance. He built the Holy Trinity Cathedral and made the ETOC independent of Cairo. There's many more contributions of H.I.M that are too much to mention. One can only hope that level heads prevail and people reinstate the monarchy.

  • @danityhayelom5011
    @danityhayelom5011 3 роки тому

    Eze qomeche tanqalye ka

  • @samsong2391
    @samsong2391 3 роки тому +2

    This were Amharas happy times. I wonder why🤔 ተረኛ ሲሉ ይገርመኛል.

    • @gerageru1388
      @gerageru1388 3 роки тому

      ሰው የማረድ ተረኛ ነው የተባልከው ይኸማ የፀሐዩ ጊዜ ይባላል አማራ ብቻ መች ሆነ ።

    • @samsong2391
      @samsong2391 3 роки тому +1

      @@gerageru1388 . you're state economy was based on human slavery ...what the hell are you talking about.

    • @Zeyede_Seyum
      @Zeyede_Seyum 3 роки тому +5

      @@samsong2391 show me one evidence slavery was practiced by the Ethiopian imperial government in 1934. You can't

    • @samsong2391
      @samsong2391 3 роки тому +2

      @@Zeyede_Seyum .our system of government was Feudalism 🙃 ...You know Mussolinis propaganda when they enter The Nation...they went around ethiopia and told the people..Why be slave? ...i will set you free.. Italy is here to bring freedom. መኖሩን ተወዉ ጭራሽ ፕሮፓጋንዳ ተጠቅመዉበታል ስልህ... Facts check history foreign or domestic.

    • @samsong2391
      @samsong2391 3 роки тому

      @@Zeyede_Seyum by the way evry tribe practiced it... But Amhara was in the position of power to abolish it...but they didn't..instead they made a deal with those they conquer...we won't mess with you but ትገብራለህ.

  • @sweetlava919
    @sweetlava919 3 роки тому

    Eko kit eyelasachu edget ema nebere eko befitim lik endahunu enga Tigrewoch gn alibeger bayoch nen! Wedefitim yiketilal

    • @ከታገሱትሁሉምያልፋል-ፀ8ኈ
      @ከታገሱትሁሉምያልፋል-ፀ8ኈ 3 роки тому +1

      ባንዳ የባንዳ ልጅ አታፍርም ቲንሽ ከናንተ በላይ አሽቋላጭ ሙልጭልጭ በልቶ ካጅ አቃጣሪ ወረተኛ ሌባ በምድር የለም ፡ የ ኤርትራዉያን ቂጥ አጣቢ የጣልያን እንቁላል ቀቃይ የእንግሊዝ ወሬ አመላላሽ የሱዳንና የግብፅ ተላላኪ ፡ እናንተ እኮ ጨርሶ አትታመኑም በወንድማማቾች መሀል ፀብን በመዝራት ከናንተ በላይ ማን አለ

    • @ambessashield9360
      @ambessashield9360 3 роки тому +2

      Kit? You mean like your doing now, dying for terrorist juntas?

    • @sweetlava919
      @sweetlava919 3 роки тому

      @@ከታገሱትሁሉምያልፋል-ፀ8ኈ yerasin tinegerengaleh adl min aynet keld yehone gize new bakachu

    • @sweetlava919
      @sweetlava919 3 роки тому

      @@ambessashield9360 junta is abiy not tegaru or hwhat

  • @danityhayelom5011
    @danityhayelom5011 3 роки тому

    Yeha qomeche yatenqulena aheya degmo

    • @onelove2817
      @onelove2817 3 роки тому

      You're angry person. You never had a full life. Loveless, deprived, cruel person.

    • @danityhayelom5011
      @danityhayelom5011 3 роки тому

      @@onelove2817 donky jast emiotonle ahaya we are more than you we are full fimely don't tinke like you damp and you jaje becouse that is amhara damp mind

    • @danityhayelom5011
      @danityhayelom5011 3 роки тому

      @@onelove2817 this min it is you we love god we don't love damp like you becoise yousless mind they did't mike senst what did you rigth becouse this is amhara donky mind