This is why Birth Rates are Dropping

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @itsnesee
    @itsnesee Місяць тому +65

    Its too expensive to have kids. Theres your answer

    • @DeborahAnneWeber
      @DeborahAnneWeber Місяць тому

      It's this guy and his ilk to blame. If they didn't take so much from women & children, if they weren't so brutal & rotten, there would be more children. Evil men stop blaming women... and children.

    • @richbillionair
      @richbillionair Місяць тому +2

      Expensive in developed countries. Meanwhile in the developing world, the population increases.

    • @Scriptedviolince
      @Scriptedviolince Місяць тому

      The answer is probably some sort of UBI.
      But that's communism so it will never happen.

    • @xXBRgamesXx
      @xXBRgamesXx Місяць тому +1

      Depends

    • @nevereverlistens
      @nevereverlistens Місяць тому

      Governments are spending too much of our money

  • @montgomeryhill8175
    @montgomeryhill8175 Місяць тому +54

    The cost of delivering a baby, in a hospital where I live, runs a little above $900. It can be 10 times as much in other areas. The federal minimum wage in my country is below $8 an hour. The cost of taking care of an infant per month goes around or above $1K. God forbid the child is born with a medical condition or is sick in later months.
    The cost of living in this country has more to do with declining birth rates than women's rights.

    • @NeonVisual
      @NeonVisual Місяць тому +1

      In the UK our NHS is free, and we have the same issues. So no, it's not the act of having a child.
      We have imported over 8 million people since 2010.
      Women are freezing their eggs should they want to have a child later in life.
      The declining birth rate is due to the requirement of two full time salaries to live when just a few generations ago only one breadwinner was required.
      Declining birth rates are due to women having entered the workforce, wage suppression, and now women can't leave the workforce as they 3either can't afford rent, or can't afford the mortgage with a single breadwinner.
      Some women take part time jobs while their husbands work, or vice versa, so they have just about enough money to manage to survive with one child.
      It's no use flipping your toys out of the pram because you've heard sopmething which might sound sexist, it would be exactly the same issue if the husband gave up work and stayed at home while the women become the main breadwinner.
      The cost of childcare is astronomical, so in effect there is a 4 year period from birth to school where someone has to be with the child at all times, or pay someone to be with the child at all times.
      Only very rich people in well paid jobs can afford such luxuries as childcare and stay working, but then you are in effect paying someone else to raise your child, much like state education is paying someone else to educate your child.

    • @uioplkhj
      @uioplkhj Місяць тому +1

      ​@NeonVisual What you wrote sounds logical but is incorrect. When the UK had dire poverty, it had a soaring birthrate. Most third world countries that are extremely poor, have high birthrates. Watch what the guys says, he's right. Equality for women actually leads to a drop in children. I know plenty of wealthy people who won't be having kids. It's not about wealth.

    • @11ride4life
      @11ride4life Місяць тому

      OMG, if you are struggling with the $900 (I agree it shouldn’t be this much to be clear) you shouldn’t be having a kid anyway.
      It costs at least $1,000,000 to raise a kid from birth to 18 these days. (I am in my mid 30’s male without a kid for financial reasons)

    • @montgomeryhill8175
      @montgomeryhill8175 Місяць тому

      ​@@NeonVisualOkay, so the argument this person says which is an 'ironclad law' is that as folk get richer and women gain equal rights, they start having fewer children, which is why the birthrate is declining.
      My argument is that well over half of Americans live from paycheck to paycheck. Any sudden change to their daily routine can and will ruin them depending on the severity. Ignoring the delivering of the baby, doctor visits cost either out-of-pocket or comes out of your insurance. Then, there's the maternity wardrobe, the baby's clothes, furniture, baby-proofing the house, et cetera.
      It doesn't matter who's getting paid here, a child is a lifetime expense and to reduce the reason to a decline in population to increased wealth, equal rights, and even the cost of living is dismissive.
      There are many more reasons why people aren't having children, but those presented reasons the speaker made was nonsense to me.

    • @montgomeryhill8175
      @montgomeryhill8175 Місяць тому

      ​@11ride4life Not all pregnancies are intended and, in some places, you cannot get an abortion. In those same areas, there are abortion trafficking laws where people can sue you for getting one or helping someone else get one.
      What is someone to do with an unintended pregnancy and they cannot receive an abortion?
      Even if they forsake the child/children to an orphanage, not delivering in a hospital or receiving proper aftercare is potentially lethal to both parties.

  • @megladon3290
    @megladon3290 Місяць тому +5

    On a different note he looks like the mean boss in The Incredibles 😂

  • @Avery-wy1xh
    @Avery-wy1xh Місяць тому +3

    People haven't been able to afford children for a long time. What is this guy talking about.

    • @NeygarzruinedAmerica
      @NeygarzruinedAmerica Місяць тому

      Literally China India and Africa the poorest places had population explosion

  • @11ride4life
    @11ride4life Місяць тому +4

    I’ll help you out, if you live HERE already and are not wealthy, aka work for a living not off of investments -
    ITS A BAD THING!!!!
    If you are wealthy then it is a GREAT thing for your pocket but you will soon be needing better security because most of the people coming for a better life want it and you have it.

  • @johnwildwest1
    @johnwildwest1 Місяць тому +11

    The poor cannot afford a house they cannot afford children its a struggle to feed ourselves

  • @michaeltrousdale2510
    @michaeltrousdale2510 Місяць тому +20

    8 billion people on Earth and still can't feed everyone.

    • @stevec9972
      @stevec9972 Місяць тому

      Western countries have an obesity epidemic

    • @Theimperialone-o2g
      @Theimperialone-o2g Місяць тому

      It's all planned. Remember, poverty is man-made

  • @Pletonian
    @Pletonian Місяць тому +1

    If the money spent on importing people and taking care of them, was spent on the indigenous civilian population the result would be more indigenous population. People say its too expensive to have kids, because they don't know how much the states are expending on bringing and keeping immigrants, that's money that people could have going to creating their own children.

  • @marypylyp1636
    @marypylyp1636 Місяць тому +1

    You got it wrong! Too expensive!

  • @VictorSchelsinger
    @VictorSchelsinger Місяць тому +1

    Dude, where did you dredge up that "ironclad" bullshit from?

  • @danthelambboy
    @danthelambboy Місяць тому +3

    We don't need to maintain population levels at all, we just need less reserving of wealth by the rich. This is obvious if you look at the huge amount of people working in industries that do not need to exist instead of using their time in life to improve people's lives and they do this because there are many wealthy people paying for people to do things that serve no one but them, if they didn't chose this they wouldn't share their excess money without it being forcibly taken. The economy is available to serve population of people that are much smaller, there isn't an issue, we just need to motivate the wealthy to stop forcing the labour force into pointless work.

  • @1nitniuq
    @1nitniuq Місяць тому +1

    This is dumb more people = less resources = resources cost more

  • @fahhcue
    @fahhcue Місяць тому +8

    This world is already too crowded imo. So I definitely ain’t mad about it dropping honestly!.
    😏🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @TD-np6ze
      @TD-np6ze Місяць тому

      The world is overcrowded because (mostly speaking of the Unhealthy) OLD People being forced to be kept alive for the benefit of Medical/Legal & Religious GREED!!!
      If they're still healthy enough to enjoy continuing, then let them make up their own minds about it
      As an example, China has Over 300 Million people Over 60 - but young Chinese don't feel secure to even reproduce enough to sustain the next generation! Happens Everywhere!!!

    • @waltershumer4211
      @waltershumer4211 Місяць тому

      Nope... On the contrary there's a demographic collapse in every developed country

  • @Mhark127
    @Mhark127 Місяць тому +12

    Capitalism

    • @televishenimoniker5546
      @televishenimoniker5546 Місяць тому +2

      China has falling birth rates, too. The gov will pay you to have more kids! A total flip from prior years there.

    • @Scriptedviolince
      @Scriptedviolince Місяць тому

      ​@@televishenimoniker5546china had is own cyberpunk dystopia to contend with. But the workload and exploitation of women's time and Labor applies there too

    • @televishenimoniker5546
      @televishenimoniker5546 Місяць тому

      I interpreted the O.P. saying "capitalism" as a claim that it was to blame. But China, run by the Chinese communist party, has the same depopulation (of yutes) going on.

  • @jas.digitalnative
    @jas.digitalnative Місяць тому

    This guest is awesome

  • @dougjardine8545
    @dougjardine8545 Місяць тому +4

    I used to think that the correlation between women's opportunity and falling birthrates was a sign of increased welfare. Then, it occurred to me that birthrates fall as women are increasingly repaired to work full-time.

  • @NeygarzruinedAmerica
    @NeygarzruinedAmerica Місяць тому

    CHECK THIS GUYS EARLY LIFE

  • @NeonVisual
    @NeonVisual Місяць тому

    Ahh, so that's why I don't know anyone with kids.

  • @danielromerosol4158
    @danielromerosol4158 Місяць тому

    Migration? From where? The birth rate of most developing countries are as low as the United States

  • @brocklytodd5317
    @brocklytodd5317 Місяць тому

    hey what's this guys name? I remember he used to appear on that fox news show called Red Eye

  • @Frenzzii
    @Frenzzii Місяць тому

    Nope too expensive to have kids people an barely afford for themselves bringing kids into this world without having and financial stability is selfish

  • @OneCanisLupus
    @OneCanisLupus Місяць тому +4

    Kids are also a pain in the rear.

  • @sleekblackroadster
    @sleekblackroadster Місяць тому +1

    As the overall resources and the security of the resources of the future are dwindling away because all of our incentivization structures are based on narcissistic personality disorder

  • @bensanders5681
    @bensanders5681 Місяць тому

    SCORE!

  • @beonlife3283
    @beonlife3283 Місяць тому

    Yes it's the nature of things and yet nationalists are always looking for scapegoats...

  • @robmurphy9445
    @robmurphy9445 Місяць тому

    didn't have any so life much easier 4 me YaY ha, one love ❤️ hug

  • @pointlessgaming3989
    @pointlessgaming3989 Місяць тому

    Good

  • @TheSamjane4
    @TheSamjane4 Місяць тому

    It’s not because we dont want kids. It’s because we now have to work and it’s too hard raising them and doing all the housework as well as working because men haven’t caught up and still expect us to do it all while they just work.

  • @AngelEconomics
    @AngelEconomics Місяць тому

    The men our societies develop are not up to the standard either.