Yamnaya Documentary CH 201

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 гру 2021
  • This video contains basic and historical knowledge about the up and rising Yamnaya Culture
    Zack Buck - zbuck@nevada.unr.edu
    Savannah Cedeno - Scedeno@nevada.unr.edu
    Stefan Anastassatos - Sanastassatos1@nevada.unr.edu

КОМЕНТАРІ • 46

  • @hellslounge6823
    @hellslounge6823 2 роки тому +9

    Scythian Steppe Brothers R1a and R1b. Join Now!

  • @micarol24
    @micarol24 2 місяці тому

    The sun wagon is found in Denmark and nobody has ever found a similar one and nobody knows which people used it. The people of Denmark has parts of Yamnaya dna, but no skeletons from the Yamnaya is found in Denmark. It's a mixed DNA which is found here.

  • @blaircolquhoun7780
    @blaircolquhoun7780 2 роки тому +1

    Tganks forr the video I never head if the Yamaya culture until I saw Dan Davis; videos on the Bronze Age.

  • @jeffmacdonald9863
    @jeffmacdonald9863 2 роки тому +6

    "DNA is just as powerful"?
    That doesn't even mean anything.

    • @shawnstorr10
      @shawnstorr10 10 місяців тому

      race supremacy reaching. These people did nothing major in human history. They are just a conquer and divide civilization.

  • @srivastavashivam949
    @srivastavashivam949 2 роки тому +3

    Stopped watching after I heard language like Sanskrit from Russia!!!?!?!?

    • @ArturBaidi
      @ArturBaidi Рік тому

      Probably the wastelands of Russia!😂 Sanskrit is probably from the Sintashta culture.

  • @alexalexsson4777
    @alexalexsson4777 2 роки тому +4

    Actually the 50 / 30% number is true... but abit misleading. For example a Norwegian and Swedish persons dna is more or less identical relative to a person from south asia for example. But you would still say a Norwegian had 0% swedish dna. But that becomes quite misleading in relation to a south asian or african since the norwegian and swedes dna are idenitcal compared to them.
    And in this regard, the yamnaya was a european ethnic makeup and not south asian at all. They had around 60-70% ancient european hunter gatherer dna while modern europeans have around 45-55%. A south asian has on average 2-5% of this dna.
    If they truly were 30% yamnaya then we would see european hunter gatherer dna in south asians numbering closer to north of 20% but it's nowhere near that level in their population. Alot of them have 0% even, on average it's 2-5% at most.
    What made the yamnaya unique was their lineage from european hunter gatherers and having 65-70% of this dna. While modern europeans have around 50% of it. That's 70% identical on that admixture.
    A south asian has 5%.

    • @michaeljosephjackson2364
      @michaeljosephjackson2364 2 роки тому +1

      Love your hate towards South asians
      Most Afghanistan, northern Pakistani and upper caste Indians have yamnaya dna 40 to 50 percent

    • @LOL-cv9it
      @LOL-cv9it 2 роки тому

      Yamanya is 50% EHG and 50%CHG(near eastern related),EHG isn’t totally European,they are some what 7-75% ANE which is a Siberian descended population who themselves migrated there from Middle East and other half of EHG came from WHG .Not to mention yamanya is 10-20% East Asian which itself also came from ANE. Yamanya paternal lineage is Siberian and middle eastern origin as R originated in Siberia and R1b is middle eastern and R1a is steppe or central Asian.
      Also neothelic Europeans didn’t had your identical blah blah bs. It can be seen as ANE DNA came to Europe after PIE’s invasion.Modern European got it from yamanya not other wise.
      South Asians have very little yamanya or steppe admixture after all,by the time steppe population arrived in South Asia.there European cline at beginning around 33% now reduced to >10%.while this steppe populations DNA is mostly western steep herders and other assimilated population of Central Asia

    • @michaeljosephjackson2364
      @michaeljosephjackson2364 2 роки тому

      @@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 where r1a originated from

    • @michaeljosephjackson2364
      @michaeljosephjackson2364 2 роки тому

      @@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 when u say bharat
      It includes Afghanistan,Pakistan,Sri Lanka,Cambodia

  • @fewthefearlessjat3938
    @fewthefearlessjat3938 2 роки тому +2

    R -M207 💪 , JAT - MASSGETAE ONLY JAT have R* 26 % HIGHEST IN SOUTH ASIA! ( R 26,Q15,L36)

  • @misterbanana9210
    @misterbanana9210 2 роки тому

    Interesting doco. Where do you getr the ifo from pls?

    • @1v1thousand
      @1v1thousand 2 роки тому

      This information is very faulty. David Anthony is a great source for proto indo European culture. The horse the wheel and language is a great work on the subject

  • @mrkps1986
    @mrkps1986 2 роки тому +1

    Make more videos

  • @jawiadream9491
    @jawiadream9491 2 роки тому +8

    So many mistakes, can't even point out all of them

  • @YamnayaSintash
    @YamnayaSintash Рік тому

    Slavs emerged from these people with that R1A dna and closer language relation.

  • @memyselfi0120
    @memyselfi0120 2 роки тому +4

    Ok except..South Asian men all belonged to Haplogroup R1a, meaning they can't possibly decend from the "Yamnaya", who belonged to R1b1a2a2... I also read an article published by a group of Russian scientists that apparently discredits the theory that "Yamnaya" are ancestral to Europeans. Apparently the subclade of R1b1a2a2 apparently found in "Yamnaya" bones branched off too early from that found in western Europe, r1b1a, like sum 9-11 thousand years ago or more... On top of that, they also state that the "Yamnaya" had significant admixture with Caucasian Hunter-gatherers, a genetic signature which doesn't show up in the modern European genome. It also doesn't explain where Haplogroup R1a comes from.

    • @farsa.658
      @farsa.658 2 роки тому +2

      R1a1 is in India, no?
      ua-cam.com/video/ZpCXiNL8F98/v-deo.html
      A 2-3 min clip on the Yamanaya and India connection.
      You may want to check out the work of Dr Niraj Rai...a seminal paper of his is expected very soon.
      The out-of-India (OIT) theory is gaining grounds because of recent studies and findings in several fields.
      Sangam Talks and Sattology channels have several talks around the ancient Vedic Hindu civilization and its connections with the rest of the world.
      The Vedic assertion "Vasudhaiva kutumbkum" (meaning roughly, for the Indians, 'the entire World is your family' ) therefore is not just some emotional slogan but a simple statement of a fact.
      Keep digging. 🙏

    • @blanketparty5259
      @blanketparty5259 2 роки тому +1

      @@farsa.658 lmao no. R1a is from Ukraine.

    • @blanketparty5259
      @blanketparty5259 Рік тому

      @@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 west Asia is a cope phrase. Thats literally Ukraine. Otherwise known as Europe

    • @blanketparty5259
      @blanketparty5259 Рік тому

      @Aryan Brahmin Tiger false , it has been proven wrong by davinski. And linguistics denies it as well

  • @selfinihalation
    @selfinihalation 2 роки тому +2

    So just curious. What characterizes an artifact as being Yamanaya? And why do you not display any in the video?

    • @blanketparty5259
      @blanketparty5259 2 роки тому +1

      Pots, and metal knives

    • @selfinihalation
      @selfinihalation 2 роки тому

      Are they "Yamanaya" Pots and Knives?

    • @blanketparty5259
      @blanketparty5259 2 роки тому +1

      @@selfinihalation yes

    • @selfinihalation
      @selfinihalation 2 роки тому

      @@blanketparty5259 How can you tell?

    • @blanketparty5259
      @blanketparty5259 2 роки тому +1

      @@selfinihalation the designs on the pots and the shape and material of the knives. Also if they were found in a kurgan. Thats a dead giveaway. Also red ochre on the skeletons with these other things indicates it even further.

  • @fightfannerd2078
    @fightfannerd2078 Рік тому

    it's not from the Yamnaya at all

  • @supercigar123
    @supercigar123 2 роки тому

    I THINK YOUR GOING A BIT FAR WITH THE 1ST THINKING

  • @TheSgrizli
    @TheSgrizli 2 роки тому

    Hahah I always laugh when an american tries to make a history video on Europe and somehow messes up half the countries

  • @jackwhitestripe7342
    @jackwhitestripe7342 2 роки тому

    Yamnaya people are ancestor of Kurdish people. They look same, blonde and tall people. They are intelligent and very brave. This is typical Kurdish.

    • @Michael_De_Santa-Unofficial
      @Michael_De_Santa-Unofficial 2 роки тому +2

      No shit.

    • @noahtylerpritchett2682
      @noahtylerpritchett2682 2 роки тому +5

      Kurds are swarthy. And Yamnaya are ancestor to all Indo-Europeans. And no Indo-European is similar to Yamnaya. We are all Yamnaya but the Yamnaya resemble non of us. We are its divergent offshoot

    • @jackwhitestripe7342
      @jackwhitestripe7342 2 роки тому

      @Xanan bint Somalia yes kurdish ppl is the first man in the world in Africa and most bravest

    • @Thekoryosmenstribepodcast
      @Thekoryosmenstribepodcast 11 місяців тому

      ​@@noahtylerpritchett2682Weird, cause i literally look just the yamnaya skull reanimation they found in ukraine. I have a shirt made with his face, cause he looks like he could be my grandfather.

    • @noahtylerpritchett2682
      @noahtylerpritchett2682 11 місяців тому

      @@Thekoryosmenstribepodcast when I made my statement I meant broad phenotypic features. Not outliner similarities