She is not guilty. Obviously her husband was a violent person.. breaking down walls, punching holes into family home that daughter testified to, and also shooting inside the house , hole in the ceiling that daughter testified to.
She is not guilty. Obviously her husband was a violent person.. breaking down walls, punching holes into family home that daughter testified to, and also shooting inside the house , hole in the ceiling that daughter testified to.
The men in these comments are completely devoid of a clue when it comes to DV cases. I guess that's kinda a good thing bc it means you've never been in an abusive relationship to spot the signs or discern the truth. To those of us who know, we see clearly that Ashley is a complete narcissistic lying sociopath. She has now been found guilty of manslaughter, but it should have been 2nd degree. Bye Ashley, have fun in prison! RIP Doug
What a strong young women!!!! She has fight in her to see the justice her father deserves I can’t wait to hear her testimony in court….It will very very powerful and helpful in this case
her father was a violent person.. breaking down walls, punching holes into family home that daughter testified to, and also shooting inside the house , hole in the ceiling that daughter testified to.
What a beautiful, generous, intelligent, humble, strong and courageous girl....I wish nothing but the best for her...She s gonna make a change in people's lives!!
Eva I lost my parent 8 days apart so I know how it feel to to be alone. I am sure I’m one of thousands who are really proud of you and admire your strength. Your parents are so proud of you as they are looking down over you. You are an Amazing young woman. Stay strong. I know there are many of us who can see how narcissistic and manipulative Ashley was and we are hoping she gets the maximum punishment.
Smart girl. My ex shot a gun at me in one of her raging fits. I should've called the cops. She's still a teacher... Scary, you never know who's teaching your kids in the classroom...😮
That Eva is one impressive human being. I watched an interview with her several months ago - she is a top notch person and daughter. I hope the court sees through that nut case Ashley…she needs to pay for what she has done. That woman is very dangerous.
It's really fucked up when someone tries to sympathize with your about something only to turn around and do it to you. Poor girl. You can tell how strong she is though
@@jmgood2870Wow, I always thought how she didn’t understand Eva’s grief since she had lost a parent too. She has been saying she was abandoned. So one more way she mimics real victims. She makes a disservice to people that really go through traumatic experiences.
Rooting for justice right along with you. Btw, you're doing a great time verbalizing your feelings. Rest in peace to your Dad. Extra angels of comfort your way.
Ashley now has NO custody, but now is in custody! How ironic, and so sad. He choices damaged so many lives, even her own. I hope Ashlry can eventually learn what she did was terrible. Her indifference is astounding. Shock😮
This young lady is wise beyond her years and unfortunately I'm sure most of it is because she's had to grow up a lot quicker than she should have. I feel so bad for her. I hope that woman rots. Her father would be proud of the woman she has become. This has changed her life and shaped her and I hope she's able to live a full, happy healthy life and if making a difference and taking a stand against dv is what she wants to do to honor her father, I wish her all the best success ❤
Your parents would be so very proud as proud as your grandfather shows in court holding you, bless him and yourself....I am a survivor as well from DV and proud it was years ago....❤
Always have been rooting for you Eva your dad deserves justice for this unlawful killing. You do your dad proud your a exceptional beautiful well rounded young lady and your parents would be proud of you. I hope AB gets a lot of years in prison and rots there for her crime.
I feel for this girl, losing both parents so close together. She is so poised and kind and smart. I wish her all the best and hope that she stays as great as she is today and doesn't choose to go down any bad paths because of her situation and lack of parents.
I believe this young woman is doing the right thing to help her father, She is talking and telling the truth abt a really bad step mother. God bless her and the rest of the family. I know ,its not easy but keep on so she will stay in jail. I had a really bad step mother also. It was rough growing up but my father believed in taking his vows and not getting a divorce. I know he was happy for the last 3 years he got to live a life. I think abt him all the time. Bless all the father's that are so good with their children..
Very beautiful and genuine young lady, I wish her the very best in life. I believe she will do great things. God bless You Eva, I pray you find peace and comfort moving forward. Your a strong lady. Your Dad is so proud of you.
Deconstructing a gift someone gives you to send them a message is cruel and wanting someone to ve punished for not taking well to behavior like that is childish. I believe Eva knows her dad had tendency to become enraged or to be violent...but i think she believed her dad had the right to behave that way. This is going to mess her up worse than the murder itself... knowing that Ashley was most likely defending herself and testifying in court against her anyways is going to cause so mamy problems emotionally for thia girl. I hope she doesnt seek out violent people to feed her subconscious which must be so divided. How sad
Yeah I feel with you your story is like my story also my step mom she killed my parents although she killed my two olders brothers I hope your good and fine Ava 😢😢
Don't worry Eva, I looked through this woman and I am sure so will most every one. I hope you get through this ok and you don't lose your outlook on a positive life.
Wow you are so incredibly strong and beautiful! So sorry this happened ☀️🌻❤ your dad misses you I’m sure. I hope for justice as well. It’s so obvious Ashley has seriously mental health issues.
I’m sorry you’re going through this ! As a daughter your Father was your great thing in life ! I can’t imagine the pain you have experienced! We pray your dad flys with Angels & you his daughter will be able to rid the anger and hate because you don’t deserve to carry that upon your shoulders nor should you! We pray your heart heals ! 🙏🧎➡️🧎🏼♀️➡️🙏
This girl seems to just love the limelight doesn’t she. And she is in total denial about her father even though there are messages from her own mother detailing the abuse she also suffered. Just because this girl didn’t see it doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. What kind of father doesn’t tell his grieving teenage daughter he got married? This girl is also a victim of her father and the sad thing is she has no clue!
What kind of person abuses a grieving teenager for trying to remember her mom? What kind of person is jealous of a dead woman? What kind of person uses her own child in a trial like this to manipulate people out of court? What kind of person doesn’t request a physical exam after her toddler was allegedly SAed? What kind of person keeps multiple pew pew loaded around the house with a toddler? What kind of victim asks the other person to cancel their divorce when she is almost free? What kind of person that is in so much fear dares to introduce a fiancee to their perpetrator? A story with more holes than the moon. A story that hurts true DV survivors. But you think trashing the actual victim is cool. Hope that makes you feel great as a person.
I believe this woman is innocent of murder...and i think it is going to mess this little girl up as age develops knowing that her dad had a capacity for violence and witnessing him throw guns and shoot holes in the ceiling but still missing him so much she believes that this woman deserves to be punished for defending herself. I would not ve surprised if she found herself a violent partner to continue the cycle
They proved it was true. His words and actions with his ex and now the ballerina. He seemed like a complete wack job. Nice try. Sorry young lady, I wish things were so much better for you but we heard his words. They actually read them. His words.
Don't forget that he was talking about on Whatsapp he said that he is in a murderous mood, testosterone rage, wants to kill all the bad people, and even told Ashley you don't want to see the warrior side of me and never want to.😮
It's pretty horrifying that she has custody of that poor little child. Did Doug have parents? Because the child shouldn't be with her parents. A lot of times I notice in murder trials they often try to send the children to the murderers family which is absolutely ludicrous and despicable. So let's hope that little girl is placed in a better atmosphere
I wish condolences to this amazing lady. But i have a few words. Has you dog ever beaten and thrown down the stairs? Have you ever indirectly been threatened wih karate and talking about killing people around you ? Have you ever read the scary messages between your ex and his dead wife? Have you ever been stalked with cars and hit with boxes? Are u aware that nobody denied the aggresiveness of doug? If it was a murder , ashley would have planned in details but as u see in court , she doesnt know how to react.
#BlackSwanMurderTrial MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/trending/fl-v-ashley-benefield-black-swan-murder-case/?
So proud of you, Princess ❤
She is not guilty. Obviously her husband was a violent person.. breaking down walls, punching holes into family home that daughter testified to, and also shooting inside the house , hole in the ceiling that daughter testified to.
@@georgewashington3555 theirs also photos of the bullet hole and fist sized holes in the walls
Oh god. My heart goes out to her ❤️ I hope Eva can find peace and someone she can talk to 💞
What a beautiful daughter. So well spoken and humble. It’s a testament to how great of a father she had and will always have in her heart. ❤
She is not guilty. Obviously her husband was a violent person.. breaking down walls, punching holes into family home that daughter testified to, and also shooting inside the house , hole in the ceiling that daughter testified to.
@@georgewashington3555she’s not shy she has an online channel were she’s very upbeat.
I hope she wasn't in the court when we found
out about how he abused her birth mother
He seemed really violent……. I don’t think he’s that innocent but rip man, he probably was a victim in life too
The men in these comments are completely devoid of a clue when it comes to DV cases. I guess that's kinda a good thing bc it means you've never been in an abusive relationship to spot the signs or discern the truth. To those of us who know, we see clearly that Ashley is a complete narcissistic lying sociopath. She has now been found guilty of manslaughter, but it should have been 2nd degree. Bye Ashley, have fun in prison!
RIP Doug
How well put together is this young lady, she is doing her dad proud. God bless them both☺
What a strong young women!!!! She has fight in her to see the justice her father deserves I can’t wait to hear her testimony in court….It will very very powerful and helpful in this case
Eva is a strong young lady. Justice for your Dad!
her father was a violent person.. breaking down walls, punching holes into family home that daughter testified to, and also shooting inside the house , hole in the ceiling that daughter testified to.
she is con like her dad. JUSTICE for Renee and Emerson and Ashley.
@@MissisChannelhope she goes to jail. She is so guilty.
@@aileenbasri8814 hope you get put in same situation she was in at that moment so you know what is what
@@aileenbasri8814 JUSTICE FOR RENEE, EMERSON AND ASHLEY!
Your parents are looking down with pride. I hope justice is served.
What a sophisticated young lady! Her dad must be beaming down so proud of her
Oh Eva, you do your dad proud. You do yourself proud 💪🏼
This is a remarkable young woman, she will do good things in the future!
yeah lots of tik tok
I hadn't heard about this tragedy, this young woman is so poised and well spoken. My heart breaks for her. I'll be looking into this case further.
Eva is such a brave girl. After all she has lost she's made a life for herself. God bless her.❤
She is very articulate. Im impressed. My heart goes out to her.
Very mature, grown up, and articulate. She is determine to speak for her father, Doug Benefield who can't speak for himself. Bravo!
Yeah defending him when he poisoned her mother
You are a very strong young lady ❤ Im sending you love and strength from Australia ❤
He deserves justice!!! Give Ashley in prison for her natural life for her murdering this young lady s dad. ❤🕊️😢🙏🏻✝️🙌😭🕯️🛐💔
Beautiful young lady. I just listened to this case and pray for justice for her father.
So poised, mature, articulate
Good interview. I follow her on TT. She’s very open and was left nothing. She’s the hardest working woman I’ve seen.
You’re an amazing young woman. You’re dad will always be inside your heart and mind. My sincere condolences 💐
So very well-spoken young lady.
Beautiful young woman hoping she gets justice for her father ❤
What an absolute resilient young woman this is. Remarkable to witness, her parents would be so proud ❤
What a beautiful, generous, intelligent, humble, strong and courageous girl....I wish nothing but the best for her...She s gonna make a change in people's lives!!
Wow, she’s very put together and mature
Eva I lost my parent 8 days apart so I know how it feel to to be alone. I am sure I’m one of thousands who are really proud of you and admire your strength. Your parents are so proud of you as they are looking down over you. You are an Amazing young woman. Stay strong. I know there are many of us who can see how narcissistic and manipulative Ashley was and we are hoping she gets the maximum punishment.
Stand strong Eva, huge hugs from Canada.❤
What a phenomenal interview. I have the highest regard and compassion for Ashley. Her mom and dad would be so proud of her. I wish her the best.
Her name is Eva lol
Ashley is the one on trial for the murder.
My mistake, yes Eva thank you
Ashley? Eva makes her parents proud.
???
What a nice girl
Truth will prevail 🙏🏼 Lock her up and throw away the key
God Bless her! She’s been through so much pain
Rooting for you and your journey to healing and peace. I hope you and your dad get justice!
Praying for her. (The daughter)
Wow❤️ She’s a great 👍🏽.
What a strong woman🩷🩷💜💜
i wish her the best, she is so strong for all she went and is going through
What a strong young woman!
Getting suckered by a psychopath. It happens way too much.
Doug was the psychopath
How sad :( this young lady has gone thru so much. So sad . How dare this lady take her father from her 😢
Wow what an amazing young lady. Your dad would be so proud of you. All the best. 🙏🙏🙏
Very well put together young lady
This ballerina chic is crazy. She premeditated his murder. Sick woman - needs to be kept away from the little girl.
Ashleys deranged mother is taking care of the little girl. 😟
Her dad would be so proud of her! She seems like a really good person…❤
Prayers for you Eva! You’ve got this!! Get this justice for your Dad!!!
Smart girl. My ex shot a gun at me in one of her raging fits. I should've called the cops. She's still a teacher... Scary, you never know who's teaching your kids in the classroom...😮
Isn't that what Doug did? And also threw a loaded gun at Ashley
this girl is awesome
Love you Ava ❤❤❤❤❤ from Cape Town South Africa 🇿🇦💜💜💜💜💜💜
What a strong, articulate and intelligent young woman. A reflection of her upbringing I would say .... Best of luck to her for her future ❤
That Eva is one impressive human being. I watched an interview with her several months ago - she is a top notch person and daughter. I hope the court sees through that nut case Ashley…she needs to pay for what she has done. That woman is very dangerous.
Ashley is a wackadoodle. If it’s true she had her young daughter outside the court with a sign saying free my mom? Not healthy.
Ms. Benefield is well spoken and poignant, I'm glad she said bluntly, Ashley is a murderer.
It's really fucked up when someone tries to sympathize with your about something only to turn around and do it to you. Poor girl. You can tell how strong she is though
Especially when Ashleys father was in her life even after her mother and father divorced. So again, another lie from Ashley. (We know them)
@@jmgood2870Wow, I always thought how she didn’t understand Eva’s grief since she had lost a parent too. She has been saying she was abandoned. So one more way she mimics real victims. She makes a disservice to people that really go through traumatic experiences.
She sounds very fair, mature and intelligent for her age. She is making her parents proud for sure. Best wishes to you young lady.
Rooting for justice right along with you. Btw, you're doing a great time verbalizing your feelings. Rest in peace to your Dad. Extra angels of comfort your way.
Ashley now has NO custody, but now is in custody! How ironic, and so sad. He choices damaged so many lives, even her own. I hope Ashlry can eventually learn what she did was terrible. Her indifference is astounding. Shock😮
But Doug admitted to most of the allegations and was talking about killing people on text messages but somehow Ashley's the bad person
@@tyreseforren6721 This is interesting. Thank you. I write to prisoners. I will write to her if you like.
Poor girl. Sending prayers. I hope Ashley goes to Jail for life and you can get a relationship with your sister. 🫶🏻
This young lady is wise beyond her years and unfortunately I'm sure most of it is because she's had to grow up a lot quicker than she should have. I feel so bad for her. I hope that woman rots. Her father would be proud of the woman she has become. This has changed her life and shaped her and I hope she's able to live a full, happy healthy life and if making a difference and taking a stand against dv is what she wants to do to honor her father, I wish her all the best success ❤
🙏🏻for you and your family
God bless and keep Eva
Keep your head up girl
Blessings to her through her healing journey!!!
What a difference in character! The victim's daughter verses Ashley. I really pray for the family. It has been a terrible ordeal for all of them. 😢
Doug was a psychopath
@@tyreseforren6721Did Ashley get screwed then? Probably a combo. If both. I don't know. I write to prisoners. Should I write to Ashley too?
@@tyreseforren6721 Thank you for insight.
Your parents would be so very proud as proud as your grandfather shows in court holding you, bless him and yourself....I am a survivor as well from DV and proud it was years ago....❤
Always have been rooting for you Eva your dad deserves justice for this unlawful killing. You do your dad proud your a exceptional beautiful well rounded young lady and your parents would be proud of you. I hope AB gets a lot of years in prison and rots there for her crime.
Such a brave young lady
Ashley reminds me of Amber Heard.
I was thinking the same thing!
Und an Leticia Stauch
I feel for this girl, losing both parents so close together. She is so poised and kind and smart. I wish her all the best and hope that she stays as great as she is today and doesn't choose to go down any bad paths because of her situation and lack of parents.
I believe this young woman is doing the right thing to help her father, She is talking and telling the truth abt a really bad step mother. God bless her and the rest of the family. I know ,its not easy but keep on so she will stay in jail. I had a really bad step mother also. It was rough growing up but my father believed in taking his vows and not getting a divorce. I know he was happy for the last 3 years he got to live a life. I think abt him all the time. Bless all the father's that are so good with their children..
What a lovely young lady. Mom and Dad would be so proud. ..
That daughter is cold blooded
When someone lies to you and do anything that's not normal, get away from them. No chances is my policy.
Yeah exactly and that's what Doug did to Eva
Very beautiful and genuine young lady, I wish her the very best in life. I believe she will do great things. God bless You Eva, I pray you find peace and comfort moving forward. Your a strong lady. Your Dad is so proud of you.
Deconstructing a gift someone gives you to send them a message is cruel and wanting someone to ve punished for not taking well to behavior like that is childish. I believe Eva knows her dad had tendency to become enraged or to be violent...but i think she believed her dad had the right to behave that way. This is going to mess her up worse than the murder itself... knowing that Ashley was most likely defending herself and testifying in court against her anyways is going to cause so mamy problems emotionally for thia girl. I hope she doesnt seek out violent people to feed her subconscious which must be so divided. How sad
She is showing what a psychopath Ashley really is!
Yeah I feel with you your story is like my story also my step mom she killed my parents although she killed my two olders brothers I hope your good and fine Ava 😢😢
Oh, dear! Daughter of her father. Whom she had to lose because of that monstrous Ashley.
Doug said on text messages that he wants to murder people
Poor girl omg 😢
I'm glad Eva got her wish! ❤
A very strong articulate young woman. I bet dad would be proud!
Don't worry Eva, I looked through this woman and I am sure so will most every one. I hope you get through this ok and you don't lose your outlook on a positive life.
Well spoken and from her heart, no making up. Hope her uncle and cousins are supportive.
Great content I love court Tv
I’m so sorry that you have had to go through this. You are a darling young woman. I hope the best for you and your future.
Wow you are so incredibly strong and beautiful!
So sorry this happened ☀️🌻❤ your dad misses you I’m sure. I hope for justice as well. It’s so obvious Ashley has seriously mental health issues.
Such a beautiful daughter ❤
Brave, strong and intelligent girl 👍❤
How are you doing? Everyone is worried about how you are. My heart goes out to you.
Bless her. What a good person.
Her opinion on this is really all I care about personally. If she thinks the stepmonster did it with malicious intent, I believe her.
I hope justice for you ....I believe you
I’m sorry you’re going through this ! As a daughter your Father was your great thing in life ! I can’t imagine the pain you have experienced! We pray your dad flys with Angels & you his daughter will be able to rid the anger and hate because you don’t deserve to carry that upon your shoulders nor should you! We pray your heart heals ! 🙏🧎➡️🧎🏼♀️➡️🙏
I happened on to this trial. I knew she did it when testifyng
This girl seems to just love the limelight doesn’t she. And she is in total denial about her father even though there are messages from her own mother detailing the abuse she also suffered. Just because this girl didn’t see it doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. What kind of father doesn’t tell his grieving teenage daughter he got married? This girl is also a victim of her father and the sad thing is she has no clue!
Absolutely!!
What kind of person abuses a grieving teenager for trying to remember her mom? What kind of person is jealous of a dead woman? What kind of person uses her own child in a trial like this to manipulate people out of court? What kind of person doesn’t request a physical exam after her toddler was allegedly SAed? What kind of person keeps multiple pew pew loaded around the house with a toddler? What kind of victim asks the other person to cancel their divorce when she is almost free? What kind of person that is in so much fear dares to introduce a fiancee to their perpetrator? A story with more holes than the moon. A story that hurts true DV survivors. But you think trashing the actual victim is cool. Hope that makes you feel great as a person.
@@lhr8833 what you mean Doug admitted to most of the allegations theirs evidence of that but was just kept out of trial
I feel this young lady is hurting and in denial. I feel Ashley was abused by her father and of course this daughter can't see it. Just my opinion.
Exactly. It’s all she knew, so to her it’s normal.
I believe this woman is innocent of murder...and i think it is going to mess this little girl up as age develops knowing that her dad had a capacity for violence and witnessing him throw guns and shoot holes in the ceiling but still missing him so much she believes that this woman deserves to be punished for defending herself. I would not ve surprised if she found herself a violent partner to continue the cycle
They proved it was true. His words and actions with his ex and now the ballerina. He seemed like a complete wack job. Nice try. Sorry young lady, I wish things were so much better for you but we heard his words. They actually read them. His words.
Don't forget that he was talking about on Whatsapp he said that he is in a murderous mood, testosterone rage, wants to kill all the bad people, and even told Ashley you don't want to see the warrior side of me and never want to.😮
My heart breaks for her. Her step mom is a murderer.
Ashley is guilty life in prison
I don't think this should have been allowed. The jurors will see this!
This was over a year ago. The jurors are instructed to not view any outside information regarding the victim, defendant, and in general the case.
It's pretty horrifying that she has custody of that poor little child. Did Doug have parents? Because the child shouldn't be with her parents. A lot of times I notice in murder trials they often try to send the children to the murderers family which is absolutely ludicrous and despicable. So let's hope that little girl is placed in a better atmosphere
How did her mom die ? I am curious we to know .
💔
I wish condolences to this amazing lady. But i have a few words. Has you dog ever beaten and thrown down the stairs? Have you ever indirectly been threatened wih karate and talking about killing people around you ? Have you ever read the scary messages between your ex and his dead wife? Have you ever been stalked with cars and hit with boxes? Are u aware that nobody denied the aggresiveness of doug? If it was a murder , ashley would have planned in details but as u see in court , she doesnt know how to react.