Real Reason Why You Should Not Follow a Quran Reciter
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
- quranrevolution...
We are revolutionizing the way you READ, RECITE and UNDERSTAND Quran. There’s a deep-rooted myth that reciting Quran beautifully is for the elite, for the special among us.
Let’s fix that together.
The Answer to your Dua to Come Close to the QURAN. You wanted to change your relationship with the Quran right? This is your chance to recite with confidence. Build your Relationship with the Quran starting today.
i follow sheikh Mishari rashad alafasy . who is here follows afasy ?
Me too 🤓
Me too
I understand the meanings with my dad and understand the tajweed he does
He is a legend because of listening to him i have learned that quran has a certain rythm which makes my recitation a lot better.
Also I learned reciting listening to him. After learning the verses SubhanAllah. I learned the alphabet and letters and had it easy with reading the Quran. Ramadan mubarek brothers and sisters❤️👍
@Sayfullah Osmani can you tell me what is sufi mean?
I’ve been listening to Mishary Rashid for the last 5 years and during my Hifdh. My teachers have all complimented me on my makraj and tajweed and have said I have the best in my entire locality. And listening to Mishary while doing my sabaq etc has undoubtedly helped me memorize.
Same. Mishari *REALLY* helped.
Same here. I learn Surah Al-Baqara by listening to him for good 3 months.
IT has helped me too, listening to Mishary. Sometimes different people have different level of understanding. What may work for us may not work for other.
Same
You are totally right brother. Because I am also like you. I have learnt a lot by heart listening to sheikh Mishary Rashid
Easy fix : use only 1 earphone and lower the volume until your hear know your own voice
Or record yourself and compare
Why not first listen to it clearly then pause it and try it?
@@QuantumQuest931 That's exactly what I do
Edited title:
Don’t recite with him “if” it is your first time
If you don’t know which letters make up the words that are being recited*
Alfasy is who I like, he’s faster and is clear. Husary is very good with Tajweed and the gold standard. Abdul Basit is great at Tajweed but I love to listen to him when I want to focus and pounder over the Quran, he has the voice of gold
Follow Abdur Rahman Al Ossi. He is the best reciter.
I agreed. We have our own voice, our own tone, our own melody. But most importantly dont stop read quran and find your own sound.
True
I think if you know how to read Qur'an with proper Tajweed Rules reading with reciter isn't problem. The problem comes when you don't know how to read and you memorize it from the tape directly. I have seen people who memorized some Ayahs in a wrong way and when they tried to correct them it was very difficult to get rid of their mistakes.
This advice that they're are giving is to Tajweed learners. For people who don't have a problem with Tajweed and have fluent and perfect recitation then they can pick any Qari they like and do Taqleed. They can try to copy their variations and tune
I agree one hundred percent with you. This is what happened to me
The issue is beyond that. Memorising and Murajah with a reciter will make you lose the picture/visualization that you should have when you're reciting the Qur'an. You should be seeing the page in your mind, but instead, you'll be forced to follow the reciter in your mind. Instead of visualising the Mushaf, you'll imaginatively hear the reciter in your head. And that will make it hard for you to go back when you've made a mistake. You'll be molded in the voice of the reciter and many more disadvantages. Your memorization will totally depend on the reciter.
I'm speaking from experience. Right now, I'm trying to get back my old Murajah right now and it's a tough struggle. I'll advise you to not go down that path.
I learn appropriate pronunciation of arabic Alphabets from this channel (alhamdulillah)and know some basic rules of tajwed and i try to recite by watching and reciting along with quran reciters. May allah give me the guide to Quran. Amen
Ameen
Ameen
The title is kinda controversial
Actually, by following your 3x3 method, I discovered that not only did I learn faster quraan but I also enjoy it more ! I feel much more secure listening to my recitation because when I was trying to learn, I also learned to let my voice out. That’s so gratifying ! Before that, I always needed to hear the reciter then repeat after him, then without him so my voice was excluded from the formula. Now, by reading and doing tajweed while beautifying my voice I am involving 4 of my senses ! Hearing, seeing, speaking and touching the quraan ( by following the letters with my finger ) This is spectacular ! Thanks you so much you have changed my way of learning quraan and my relationship with it. BarakAllahou fikoum 😁
I’m trying to find my own sound right now
In Sha Allah
Allah help me with beautiful recitation ♥️♥️♥️♥️📿📿📿📿🌸🌸
And give us all Hidayat Ammeeeeeennnn ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
my husband was a very well know reciter when he was alive and he even said don't follow as many reciters will or can make mistakes and then if you stay with only one then you would never know of the mistakes best to take classes to learn correctly.
May Allah grant him the highest of Jannah 🌺
@@toxictwisst aamiin
The Caption of this video will misguide people. Please don't use confusing Headlines.
I have a friend who already momorized suratul yasen, al waqi'ah and ar- rahman without learning how to read the Quran in proper tajwed. Just like your video by listening qori on mp3 or youtube without having anyone to listen to her recitation. The moment she has a teacher, , become her most ackward moment..everything is similar but not the same:). So yeah thank you for this video Brother Wisam
Assalamu Alaikum Wa Rahmutullahi Wa Barakatuh. I know of someone who memorized the whole Quran without proper Tajweed and he forgot it later on, but he started learning Tajweed again and he is memorizing again.
I have memorized juzz amma
@hindoo Corona virus hindu corona...haha
I think you have to follow with a mashaf, not just only listening along. You following and reading the same time. Really works this way as alternative of live teacher.
I learnt all tajweed rules. Then i follow mishary in Quran hive to check out if i miss any rules
Hussary is excellent....
And his recital my heart ❤ feels it .. I actually feel so good after I hear his recital and then ponder on how does he get that tajweed ...
Suratul Maoon v3
Listen very carefully and hear how he joins the dawd with the aiyn ..hope you can hear what I hear ...
Please come back to me on this ...as I don't hear the same with your quraan app sheigh Wisam
Learn tajweed and arabic .. Learn reading the Quran first ..then memorize with your own tone .. Record yourself insha Allah and correct .. Later you can change your tone and recite like Huzaifi ... Definitely reciting Quran is to please Allah - not our ears and certainly not the ears of others.
Tajweed and rythm are different - bad habits in tajweed specially reciting like reciters MAY sticks with you for life .. I have seen people being corrected on surah IKHLAS after completing memorization of the Quran .. May Allah protect us and make the quran a light for our heart ..
I listen to a reciter while holding and reading the part where the reciter is reciting
This advice that they're are giving is to Tajweed learners. For people who don't have a problem with Tajweed and have fluent and perfect recitation then they can pick any Qari they like and do Taqleed. They can try to copy their variations and tune
Me too
@@kodahezekiah8158 guys its a scammer on alt account don't trust it wallah it's fake. He is commenting on other different videos. Saying this website worked or something.
@@mmcweight8827 any good head set I can buy to listen to Quran and memorize?
@@peace9265 which country are you from? I will find headphones based on where you live becuase if I just find them based on where I live they may not be available where you live
Here are some sunnah of the prophet(SAW)
#...When ever the prophet is mentioned say (sallallahu alaihi wasallam)
#...Dikir after every prayer/you can also add (wa bihamdi) and reciting *Alatul Kursi after every fard salah
*SubahanAllah 33 times
*AllahuAkbar 34 times
*Amhamdulillah 33time
#...While entering home syaing this supplication (Allahumma inni as'aluka khairal mawliji wa khairul makhraji bismillahi wajlana wa bismillahi kjarajna waaalla rabbina tawakkalna)
#... While going outside of home saying this supplication (Bismillah tawakkaltu aaalallah wala hawla wala quwwata illa billah)
#...When entering your home give salam even if there is no one give salam to your self
#...Entering the bathroom with left foot and exiting with right
*and covering the head and while relieving yourself sitting is wajib
*and when relieving yourself don't face the qibla or your back behind it
#...Entering the masjid with right foot and exiting with left and performing wudu at home
#...Every muslim you cross by give salam
#...Using meswak
#...Using fragrence
#...Reading Surah Khaf every Friday
#...Dusting the bed with an edge of an cloth or bromm
#...Eat with your right hand and share your food with the nearest person
#... if any food drops of the plate pick it up remove the dust and eat it
*after finish eating lick the plate with your fingers and lick your fingers
#...Before eating and drinking saying bismillah and after finishing eating and drinking saying Allhamdulillah
*if one forgots to say bismillah before eating or drinking say this (bismillahi fi awwalihi wa akhirihi)
#... After finish eating sya this supplication (Allhamdulillah hil ladhi at amani hadha wa razaqanihi min ghayri hawlin minnee wa la quwwatin)
#...Before staring any work or going to do something saying bismillah
#...After doing wudu saying (La illah illallah wadahu la sarikala)
#...While drinking or eating sitting is recommended and it is an sunnah
#...Sleeping on the right shoulder
#...Not sleeping on your stomach or chest
#...Before going to sleep
*sleep in the state of wudu
*Surah ikhlas 3 times
*Surah Nas 3 times
*Surah Falak 3 times
*Ayatul Kursi 3 times
*And saying (Lailahaillallah MuhammadaRrasulullah)
*And reciting Surah Mulk
#...When going to sleep saying this supplication
(Bismika rabbi wada tu janbi wa bika arfahu in amskata nafsi
fagfir laha wa in arsaltaha fahfazha bima tahfaz bihi ibadaka-s-salihin)or
(Allahuma bismika amutoo wa ahyaa)
#...After waking up saying this supplication (Allhamdulillah hil-lathee ahyana baaada ma amatana wa ilayhin nushoor)
#...After waking up doing wudu and put water inside the nose and blow it
#... when wering cloths syaing this supplication (Allhamdulillah hil lathee kasanee hatha aththawab warazaqaneehi min ghayri hawlin minnee wala quwwah)
*While wearing entire the right hand first and when taking of start with left hand same with the shoes
Reference
Sahih Al Bukhari: 12.28.153.168.183.216.217.245.568.3295.5010.5623.5628.5630.5631.
6293.6294.6295.6296.6311.6314.
6322.7393.7394
Sahih Muslim:
265.267(c).304.2018(a).2020.2024.
2025.2032.2034.2626
Jami Al Tirmidi:
14.1857.1858.1885.2048.2678.2689.
3426.3458
Abu Dawood:
2.30.51.4023.4141.5094.5095.5096. 5212
Ibn Majah:
303.307.3287.3288
An nasai:
259.
Credits goes to
Ismalic knowledge official
Ranga nature English
May Allah guide us and have patience and remember Your lord is not ONE EYED and to read surah kahf every friday
Plz pray for palistine
Lailahaillallah MuhammadaRrasulullah
@deenaddict6625 I think it's 34x after every prayer and before going to sleep, and Allah knows best.
I wouldn't say "some", rather a lot, a handful or many 👽🖤
I disagree. I'm learning and memorizing the Holy Qur'an from a reciter because I do not have anyone to teach me, so I listen to his recitation and then follow. Alhamdulillah I'm learning with tajweed and mahkarij because he is one of the best when it comes to tajweed and mahkarij and he takes his own time to read without rushing. His name is Sheikh Ali Abdul- Rahman Al- Huthaify. Following a reciter doesn't mean that you cannot have your own voice, I'm following him and I don't even know how to read with his voice, I have my own voice, so I only listen to him to get a proper recitation and a very good tajweed and mahkarij. The reciter voice that I imitate is Sheikh Abubakar Al- Shatri because I started imitating him before I started learning the Qur'an with tajweed and mahkarij, but I do not learn tajweed and mahkarij from him because I prefer Sheikh Huthaify when it comes to tajweed and mahkarij.
Mashallah you lads are brilliant.
Duas your way. 🤲😍
once you go sheikh noureen mohammad , you dont go anything else lol
I think the best way to practice is know how to read it. I had a tajweed teacher and even sometimes he missed my mistakes and i found out later a missed a very similar sounding letter by reading the quran.
I totally agreed with your steps in grasping the real tajweed.
The best for tajweed according to my knowledge is qari Aimen. go look him up. He is actually used as an example to learn tajweed. If you want to learn tajweed properly and level up listening to qaris isnt the way unless it is a qari who recites very slowly and incorporate the highest level of tajweed.
Lol, this is so clickbait
I totally disagree. You can recite a long the qira if you only know how to recite the Quran from the mashaf contrary if you can't recite the quran from the masaf than you can't recite along the qira cause you dont understand what the qira is reciting .
yes. first is to recite yourself an ayah with a proper tajweed then listen to the qari for the harakat and the tune.
the title got me in the first half, ngl
I'm sorry, you lost me at Malcolm Gladwell. Also, you're using a lexicon with which I'm unfamiliar -- '3x3" for example. What does that mean? Anyway, my first Tajweed teacher suggested that I listen to Sheikh Abdullah Basfar (because of his precision) and Ibrahim Akhdar for the same reason. I "follow" no one but the Rasulullah (saw) but I listen to the recitation of those who are said to be the most accurate. I've learned that beautiful voices are wonderful, but if they make mistakes-- they are only singing.
This is 3x3 here
ua-cam.com/video/-q46uBDwBEA/v-deo.html
This is the full process here:
ua-cam.com/video/M6fJvHAa7LU/v-deo.html
"I've learned that beautiful voices are wonderful, but if they make mistakes-- they are only singing." subhanallah. So, function over aesthetics. Better to recite and not make any mistakes than not to recite with making mistakes (*recite regardless, mistakes or not, but be sure to correct yourself if mistakes do happen. My point here is to make steps in preventing mistakes, if by beautifying adds mor mistakes in which you can't make changes for there not to be mistakes, you'd rather recite without beautfying it and Allah knows best) all because you're making it more aesthetic and Allah knows best I think we should beautify but not in the expense of making mistakes.
Your Quran recitation will never reach proficiency without a mentor who gives you feedback.
My teacher as a beginner hafidha and for better tajweed told me not to hear fast reciters and sheikh Hussary is the best .
Asalamalikum!
I am trying to fix my rhythm of recitation. I am studying Arabic at the moment and as the text is starting to come to live; that’s I am beginning to understand a little more of what I am reading without having to look at my word for word translation. I want to incorporate that in my recitation. Meaning I want to recite with punctuation marks and emotions taken into consideration instead of just reciting everything in a flat monotonous voice. But I am having very hard time try to do that and keep a rhythm of some sort. Any advice on how to find a rhythm and stick to it???
Jazak Allahu Khairan!
I recommend joining the quranrevolution.com program. Level 3 is about rhythm and they have instructors who listen to you and help you improve
@@WasifSikder does Quran revolution teach Maqamat?
But i follow Sheikh shuraim,
Can you please change the title of this video ? This is really really really misguiding. Please change this. You’re sending the wrong message.
What part is misleading?
Recite along when you are also reading the Quran, so that you know exactly which letters are being read and so that you don’t make mistakes, then you’ll know how long to hold and what tajweed rules will come next
Who is your Favourite Quran Reciter? My Favourite is Yasser Al Dosari etc... And Melodious Maqam Ajam🤤♥️
That's the only way I can read surat al Kahf. I can read some easy surats but I need help with big surats.
Happy with his explanation though.
Abdullah Basfar is my favorite reciter. I like listening to Nasr al Qatami but just for listening not to learn tajweed or for hifth.
Alhamdullilah 💖Jazakallahu Khayran
Have you done what you are advocating others to do?
Gotta do your part as a Talib and strive to learn Daad. I didn't choose to learn for some vanity reasons. Only to achieve paradise and converse with our prophet Sallallahu Aylah wasallam
Oh no hahaha 😆
I don't think I am a tenth of what the imam is when it comes to tajweed. So when I pray in congregation I don't have to pronounce the surah? Shouldn't we keep our tongues moist in remembrance of Allah? I heard that if you don't pronounce it it doesn't count.
brother I really have this big doubt ,,, pls pls explain me with it,,, I am memorizing surah with listening to qaris only now I am aimed to change that to my tone to my style but still ,,without listening to qari I can't memorize, It is confusing pls tell It is ok for me to keep like that or to change to my tone ,.... After memorizing it thoroughly I can able to recite my tone, consider it
An important distinction: don’t recite with the imam AT ALL during prayer. But if it’s out of prayer then it’s okay. Allah says in the Quran: “So, when the Quran is recited, listen to it, and be silent that you may receive mercy” [al-A‘raaf 7:204]
And our beloved messenger ﷺ said in this hadeeth:
Abu Dawood (823) narrated that ‘Ubaadah ibn as-Saamit (may Allah be pleased with him) said: We were behind the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) in Fajr prayer. The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) recited, and he found it difficult to recite (due to interference). When he finished praying he said: “Perhaps you were reciting behind your imam?” We said: Yes, O Messenger of Allah. He said: “Do not do that, apart from the Opening of the Book (al-Faatihah), because there is no prayer for the one who does not recite it.”
hello brothers and sisters, is there anyone who can introduce me to a female reciter for Quran because I really want to learn but there is no teacher for me here in the Netherlands so please let me know if anyone knows someone to do online learning, and i can read the qoran i really want to recite with a beautiful voice
Mishary sudais aund hussary best qari in the world
Ye dono logo ko time pass kar rahe hai😅
I wish Wisam had the chance to speak his mind without interruption.
Don't mix quran with singing first understand what verses mean to under the basic .it's God word s not a singing song so please respect
The meaning by is what considered never you singing other wise eh yh bother what will gain if you choose soundd. And leaving the meaning
Mashallah, this explanation is very beautiful May Allah swt reward these qaaris for teaching the holy Quran.
you should listen to the Quran in the proper way and listen to the pronunciation correctly, our brains are amazing at remembering how things sound and when you read it again you can recall how they said it. The Quran requires recitation and the Arabic language is complex. Even Allah tells his prophet to (Atlo 3alihim il koran) to recite his book to the people. When you are not a native Arab then how else would you know how to recite. I'm baffled by these words.
Wow. This makes sense. I have made many mistakes like this.
I follow sheikh Mansoor as salami
why not? i follow sheikh sudais who else?
How can i relax while reciting my hifdh coz i tend 2 be so anxious
As Salamu Alaikum. Maasha Allah.
The first verse of Al Fatihah is Bismillah, but we talk to ourself with the first verse. Therefore we say it silently.
Alhamdu Lillahi is the second verse and when we start talking to Allah SWT.
And the Book is in two parts as Allah SWT says:
And indeed, We have bestowed upon you seven of Al-Mathani (seven repeatedly recited Verses), (i.e. Surat Al-Fatihah) and the Grand Qur'an. 15: 87.
So we recite Al Fatihah with Imam in salah and with anyone reciting it but not the Quran as Allah SWT commands us not to:
So, when the Qur'an is recited, listen to it, and be silent that you may receive mercy. [i.e. during the compulsory congregational prayers when the Imam (of a mosque) is leading the prayer (except Surat Al-Fatihah), and also when he is delivering the Friday-prayer Khutbah].
(Tafsir At-Tabari).7: 204.
I follow sheikh yasser Al Dosari.
Me too
Same brother I really like the style especially jiharkah
Salaam so many people was help by shaikh hussary recital may Allah accept his endeavor .
I don't agree.... All of my memorization of the Quran has been from following alafasy, luhaidan and in the past few years, thr imams of kaaba if I hadn't followed them I wouldn't have any memorized quran as compared to the 40 odd surahs I do now
Do u also have his recition or u have ur own?
Mishari rashad alafasy
At first I thought the meaning of the tittle was diff lol
One should not FIT the tajweed as per TONE.......but set the tone as per tajweed means go on reciting as per tajweed with a bit of conciousness regarding tone and and you will get a beautiful recitation
Alafasy recites beautifully
But I always know the mistakes I make. Like I can hear them, I always know when I am saying it wrong.
Alhamdulillah.. great information
Thank you
.. jazakallah khoir
I have a funny story of when I was learning and how my first teacher checked me(Its very funny now😂.this was 15yrs ago. I had Basit tapes)! Insha Allah, tell you all some day!
Anyway he(May Allah have Mercy on him) told me the tapes are not gnna stop themselves and correct me if Im (was) wrong!
Oh Allah bless you.😁
@@mansoorhaque3306 Ameeen!
Would love to read it. Could use a laugh right now
@@habiba9311 سلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته!
Insha Allah! I will keep you posted. Sounds better if I tell with all of his sound effects and facial expressions than if I write it. But its a story about how I couldn't even pronounce Bismillah or Al Fatiha correctly and some Ayat of Surah Yasin! And I was young with an ego! 😂😂It was sooo embarrassing, but funny! He loved me so much.
He was a tiny man (4' 5"). Mufti from Bangladesh! Tough too!
Time fot Subh! سلام
Assalam I don't accept about elite or specialty I say learning must continue because it's not written in al Quran yes tajweed n tarteela good im in a multiracial. Country I speak 4 language n I read Quran am afana of Ab baset from childhood I study only in little class of madrassah but I came 3rd position in my country in aquiraat competition still am learning Alhamdolilah
WRONG ADVICE IS THIS GUY EVEN A QARI?
I can't hear you. Can you type in BIGGER ALL CAPS?
Ithink you should put the subtitle for better understanding
His facial expressions is so good LOL
Very enthusiastic, Allah huma barik.
his mouth is super big
Some reciters recite with zaad instead of thaad what is this?
there is a difference of opinion on how the letter dhwaad should be pronounced
@@DayDreamer1230-n1i Assalamu Alaikum Wa Rahmutullahi Wa Barakatuh. you have stated there is a difference of opinion. I just heard that from you by the way. May you please provide the sources for what you have stated.
@@DayDreamer1230-n1i that is ridiculous. د is a د.
ز -is pronounced like the letter z
@@oak1071 I think they're referring to ض
Arabic is the language of the letter ض as it’s unique to Arabic out of all the languages of the world. No other language has a ض sound. So you must get this right. This was one of my first lessons in Arabic Language
Can you tell where have you been
Will you answer upon quran preservation
Do you mean reciting at the same time while listening? I will listen and recite separately. Can you clarify which you are referring to?
brother I really have this big doubt ,,, pls pls explain me with it,,, I am memorizing surah with listening to qaris only now I am aimed to change that to my tone to my style but still ,,without listening to qari I can't memorize, It is confusing pls tell It is ok for me to keep like that or to change to my tone ,.... After memorizing it thoroughly I can able to recite my tone, consider it
Couple things to consider. First, is regarding tone: ua-cam.com/video/S2_opXCYz4Q/v-deo.html
Second has to do with process:
ua-cam.com/video/M6fJvHAa7LU/v-deo.html
jazakallahu khairan fi dunya wa al akhirah ya shaikh
Is there any problem regarding it,, may beafter sometime I will be able to change to my tune,... I watched all your vds regarding this ... I am asking If I was learning my quran under a teacher I ll be able to join him and recite like him or her,... U understood
Tell me pls .. Today I memorized without qari My ustadha sent me back that I was not fluent..
0:15 , why he is laughing ? What is funny about it ?
It's funny because folks were offended in the comments by the proposition. This is the original video for context. ua-cam.com/video/QMkqhkGdBHk/v-deo.html
Tum kuch bhi nahi
Mishary aur sudais aur hussary ke samne
"Tum" nahee. "Aap." Izzat say baat karo varna bud dua milaygi tuj ko, vo bhi, laylatul qadr key waqt.
mashallah tbark allah alhamudillah inshallah better astgfrallah
The clickbait is real 😂
Just read freestyle
6:31
Jazakallahu khayran
I don’t agree with you
which part you dont agree?
@@sillybeans929 an u have I don’t think so
@@sillybeans929 an plus that don’t got anything to do with listening to Quran recitation that how ik that u don’t know anything next time try to stay on topic
Quite confusing. If you're trying to say that a person should first learn Tajweed, like here in Pakistan, from understanding جمال القرآن or خلاصة التجويد or مقدمة الجزيرة، then copy an arab reciter, you're then just talking about common sense among memorizers (huffaaz) of the Quran in Pakistan. This video could've been shorter.
Except vast majority of folks watching this and those who are enrolled within Quran revolution are not from Pakistan, but from UK, USA, EU, and Canada. Their only real exposure or hifdh and tajweed is famous reciters.
btw - this is the original video in question: ua-cam.com/video/QMkqhkGdBHk/v-deo.html
@@khanceptbelal Ok, then it's understandable.
Al Afasy My Idol 💜
Bro.
Please remove this comment because That's shirk.
@@imranshaik5325 not really. In the context of his post, idol is a person or thing that is greatly admired, loved, or revered (not an object of worship) - ie "American Idol" - no one's talking about Worship in that context
@@khanceptbelal it is shirk , doesn't matter what hi means by that . Just say I like Al Afasy . But no, he chose that words , in the day of judgment he will be asked for that words. Thats why it is easy and better to ask forgiveness in this world .
@@khanceptbelal If he doesn't worship him it doesn't mean it is not shirk . Idol in this context is tagut
@@user-fj1je3qm1c how's it taghut - that's usually in reference to an earthly tyrant demanding submission who he's positioned themselves against Allah and His prophet