6.8 Western vs 7mm Remington Magnum! Not even close!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 109

  • @bustabass9025
    @bustabass9025 4 місяці тому +9

    6.8 Western, a modern version of the .270 cartridge. Some old dogs refuse to accept new tricks. Forget those guys.

  • @rtpickett
    @rtpickett 4 місяці тому +5

    I love my 6.8 western. I have found it performs extremely well.

  • @buddysumner4022
    @buddysumner4022 4 місяці тому +7

    I like the 6.8 western,, it’s a shame there’s not much of a ammo selection for it,, I’d pick the 6.8 western over the 7 prc, but that me people like what they like

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      The ammo that's out there will certainly do the job. Thanks for watching!

    • @buddysumner4022
      @buddysumner4022 4 місяці тому +1

      @@montanamusings oh yes ,, i just can’t understand why federal Remington and all the other bigger ammo manufacturers don’t make it,, it’s like they are protecting hornadys 7 prc , it’s like they all made a deal not to make ammo for the 6.8 western because of the 7 prc because they won’t the 7 prc to make it and not the 6.8 western,,

    • @ronbeckybeasley3566
      @ronbeckybeasley3566 4 місяці тому

      @@buddysumner4022 the 175 browning long range hunter are lights out. The 6.8 is the ultimate.277 bullets.

    • @buddysumner4022
      @buddysumner4022 4 місяці тому

      @@ronbeckybeasley3566 yes, I really really like it,, I’ve wanted one the first time I ever watched a video of how good it is,, I think it’s the ultimate hunting cartridge made, but I like to be able to buy ammo off the shelf for my guns,, I no I can reload but I like to be able to walk in a store and have a few different choices two buy,, I guess it’s just piece of mind,, but I’m still wanting one so dam bad,, I’ll probably buy one anyway and just load my on ammo

    • @jameswilson5562
      @jameswilson5562 4 місяці тому +1

      The only thing with 7 mag it's way water down it can get 3100 fps with a 175 easily if the ammunition factory would actually load it.but it's not the only one there are several caliber out there that are way under loaded

  • @davesnodgrass2074
    @davesnodgrass2074 Місяць тому

    The 6.8 Western is a great cartridge in superior to the 7 in the accuracy department and it kick nowhere near the 7 mm I like to help people realize how good a cartridge the 6.8western is

  • @HitSTXLax
    @HitSTXLax 2 місяці тому

    Love my 6.8 Western as well. Phenomenal “do-all” cartridge

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  2 місяці тому

      It's the real deal! Thanks for watching!

  • @rizi2187
    @rizi2187 4 місяці тому +1

    Looks like the 6.8 kick the heck out of the 7mm mag, nice to know. Thanks Steve

  • @chrisbatson3096
    @chrisbatson3096 4 місяці тому +8

    I'm not sure what barrel lengths everyone is using, but I know out of my 26 inch 7 rem mag I am getting over 3000 fps shooting 168 Berger vlds. DO NOT trust the velocity printed on the box of factory ammo. It can vary significantly depending on several factors.

    • @jimedick9496
      @jimedick9496 4 місяці тому

      If I remember correctly, those numbers are from a 24” barrel for both the 7 mag and the 6.8 Western….. I own both, and I love both of these cartridges.
      Given the same barrel length, the Western is slightly faster than the 7 Mag.
      Fact is, both are proven big game cartridges. For those longer shots on game or target, the Western does hold the advantage, but most hunters will never shoot past 300 yards anyways.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      @jimedick9496 Where I hunt my son got his Elk at 300 yards. That was the farthest he's had to shoot. I'm sure my 20" barrel will be plenty. Thanks for watching!

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +2

      The box numbers were from a 24" barrel. Both cartridges are proven. I'm just amazed at how well the 6.8 Western stacks up. Thanks for watching!

    • @jimedick9496
      @jimedick9496 4 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings
      The 6.8 Western does this while using less powder and with a short action vs long. Another advantage is that rifles are lighter in short action.
      So if someone wants 7 mag power, in a short action, lightweight rifle for those mountain hunts, the 6.8 Western is tough to beat.

    • @jimedick9496
      @jimedick9496 4 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings
      My 20” 6.8 Western is only 80’/sec slower than my buddies 24” 6.8 Western. I just ordered a Seekins in a 6.8 Western with a 24” barrel. Looking forward to its arrival.

  • @davidw835
    @davidw835 4 місяці тому

    Trigger Bar sent me, subscribed and excited for your channel!

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      Thank you so much! Trigger-Bar is a great guy. I appreciate you guys!

  • @rexking3698
    @rexking3698 4 місяці тому +2

    I think it's a good cartridge and would definitely pick it over a 7prc. I've been told factory 7 mag is a little weak so the the cartridge can do much better with handloads. You'd be surprised at what I get out of my 338 federal. It not a long range gun but the muzzle energy is more than the 7 mag and 6.8. With my hand loads of course.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      The 338 is gonna have some punch! Thanks for watching!

  • @Dalesarty
    @Dalesarty 3 місяці тому +2

    7 mag is severely under loaded in factory ammo. It would be great to see the factory load it to its full potential or at least 95%

    • @horsemany
      @horsemany 16 днів тому

      This is very true. Back in the day the 7RM was loaded much hotter than it is now. Handloading can show huge gains in 7RM. More so than any other cartridge I've loaded.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  16 днів тому

      @horsemany It's too bad they don't load everything to It's potential. Thanks for watching!

  • @GuyGooding-q9o
    @GuyGooding-q9o 4 місяці тому +1

    Factory 7 rem mag ammo is loaded to less than 62,000 psi 6.8western is 65,000psi . My 7mm rm handloads easily gets 2900fps with 175s & Retumbo or imr8133 . I like the 6.8western , but just like car engines " there's no replacement for displacement " & the 7mm rem mag has a bigger case/ engine. Enjoy your 6.8 , out to 500yrds the deer won't know the difference . Cheers man

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      Thank you! It's a lot more fun to shoot than my 7 mag was. Have a good one!

  • @melodyy0129
    @melodyy0129 4 місяці тому

    Let's not forget that the 6.8 Western is a short action rifle. As a person who hikes and brush hunt, I'll take the shorter rifle any day as it's easier to maneuver and is lighter 👍

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      Exactly! Thanks for watching!

    • @MatthewKyle-sg5uo
      @MatthewKyle-sg5uo 4 місяці тому

      @melodyy0129 literally a half inch difference. Short action, long action. Doesn't really effect anything at all. An ounce and maybe a 1/2 inch. If an ounce or two breaks you, get your frail ass to the gym lol

  • @TODinWY
    @TODinWY 4 місяці тому +1

    MY Nosler #7 manual shows 2970 fps with a 175-grain Partition for the 7 Mag. out of a 24" barrel. My 25" barrel breaks 3K. 7 Mag. WINS hands down. Nothing wrong with the 6.8, but what is, is.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      I was comparing factory ammo. Handloading, I'm sure it does. Thanks for watching!

    • @TODinWY
      @TODinWY 4 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings Factory ammo is almost always under-loaded.

    • @curtstephens9482
      @curtstephens9482 3 місяці тому

      @@montanamusingsThis is correct. In factory ammunition they are almost identical. However, if you handload you can safely load the 7 mag above the Sammi pressure and embarrass the 6.8. Having said that, I don't handload so I'd choose the 6.8 all day.

  • @ronlowney4700
    @ronlowney4700 4 місяці тому +1

    🕵‍♂️ The "Other" Dirty Little Secret of The 7mm Remington Magnum is That For People At Lower Elevations, They Needed a Barrel With a Faster Than Standard 1 in 9 Twist Rate To Stabalize Bullets Over 162 Grains! Additionally, They Also Need a 26" Barrel To Get The Most Out of That Cartridge! But, You and I Don't Have The "Same Problems" With Our Choices, Especially at The Elevations We Hunt At! 😂 Who Wants To Pack Around a Heavier Gun, With a 26" Barrel, and Endure More Recoil For No Improvements in Performance? 🙃 NOT ME! 😜

  • @BigTimberLodge
    @BigTimberLodge 4 місяці тому

    96 subs to go to 1k! 🎉 you're killing it!

  • @scottcimfl77
    @scottcimfl77 4 місяці тому

    I think if you want to do a comparison compare to like components. Look up the nolser ammo for the 7mm with the 168 ablr. Its a lot closer

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      I thought the 175 grain comparison was as close as I could get.😂

  • @ronlowney4700
    @ronlowney4700 3 місяці тому

    🤠 FYI: HORNEDAY Has Just Released The 25 Creedmore and a 138 grain Bullet For It! 🥳

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  3 місяці тому +1

      Of course they did! Could be a good one.

  • @elkhuntr2816
    @elkhuntr2816 4 місяці тому

    175 grain bullets are over heavy for the 7mm rem mag. For the best ballistics, use the hornady precision hunter162 grain eldx which should outperform the 6.8 western. They are pretty similar balistically.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      My son shoots the 155 gn Terminal Assents out of his 7 mag. It smokes them. Both calibers are awesome. 6.8 is more efficient. Thanks for watching!

    • @elkhuntr2816
      @elkhuntr2816 4 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings The 6.8 western should theoretically be more accurate out of a factory gun compared to the 7mm rem mag. Thats a test I would love to see. My browning abolt 7mm mag averages 1.5-2.0 MOA with factory ammo. Not really good enough for long range. I am considering going with a 6.5 PRC to get more accuracy, but it would give up some down range energy.

  • @ronlowney4700
    @ronlowney4700 4 місяці тому

    😂 Yes, Your Not Wrong! 7mm Factory Ammunition Has Always Been Loaded Well Under The Cartridges Potential and Compared To My 270 Winchester Handloads, Offers NO ADVANTAGES in The Heavier Bullets For The 7mm Owners Who Only Use Factory Ammunition (Which is Most People)! 🤭 It's a "Dirty Little Secret" That Has Been Overlooked Until The 7mm prc "Controversary" Caused Alot of People To Look a Little Closer at "The Facts"! If You Want a "True Magnum", The Big 30's Will Bury Any 7mm Cartridge! But, Since I Don't Need One (Though I've Owned Several Big 30's), My 270 Winchester and 30-06 Have Taken Home The Game For a 1/2 Century! 🦌

  • @tonydrain8527
    @tonydrain8527 4 місяці тому +1

    Crazy I know that 7 mag load is anemic I'm getting 2910 with a 175 LRX in the ancient 30-06

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      The good old 30-06. They all do a great job. It's just personal preference. Thanks for watching!

  • @COREYDEER
    @COREYDEER 4 місяці тому

    Factory 7 mag is weak loaded in lots of brands. Also the 6.8 only had one distributor and it’s their cartridge so they are going to get all they can out of it to make it look good. Marketing. The 7 mag can get better numbers.
    Also 7 mags really should have at least a 26” barrel to take advantage of the powder capacity which most factory guns are only 24-24.5 including mine. 175gr bullet for 270 seems excessively big for me though.

  • @MatthewKyle-sg5uo
    @MatthewKyle-sg5uo 4 місяці тому

    How fast does a 6.8 western shooting a 180 or 195 berger?

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      I haven't seen a listing for that. Probably 3100 fps, just because it's so awesome!

    • @MatthewKyle-sg5uo
      @MatthewKyle-sg5uo 4 місяці тому

      @montanamusings they don't make them. That's my point. 6.8 is more limited. Not that I would shoot 195s out of a rem mag or prc, but you can.

  • @ronbeckybeasley3566
    @ronbeckybeasley3566 4 місяці тому

    The .277 bullets are hands down superior to all other bullets

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      I like the way you think!😁

    • @ronbeckybeasley3566
      @ronbeckybeasley3566 4 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings I bought a Winchester Model 70 Super Grade in Maple. It’s amazing to say the least. It doesn’t like the 165s. But the 175s are .75 group at 200 yards

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      @ronbeckybeasley3566, I'm saving for one right now. Beautiful!

    • @ronbeckybeasley3566
      @ronbeckybeasley3566 4 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings pictures and videos don’t do it justice. In person it is absolutely beautiful. I’m waiting on my model 70 Super grade French Walnut to arrive. The model 70 in my opinion is the best looking and best quality rifle ever made

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      My FFL has one, so I made the mistake of having him let me handle it! Oh well, it's only money, right?

  • @mikesauer7775
    @mikesauer7775 4 місяці тому

    I'm not confident to make 1st one count past 200yds with out a bag and range finder while hunting

  • @todd0695
    @todd0695 4 місяці тому +2

    I loaded Berger 190-grain target bullets to 2,950 fps in a Remington Long Range in 7mm Rem Mag. Norma brass, 73.8 grains of N568 powder, COAL about 3.6", which still gives a full shank in the neck of the brass. That rifle has a 1:8" twist 26" barrel. That rifle, with that load, carries 1,800 ft-lbs of retained kinetic energy well past 1,000 yards. No way a 6.8 Western can compete with that. You just need to compare apples to apples when it comes to barrel length and twist rate, and you need to develop the best possible load for each rifle before comparing loads. If you want more performance than a 7 Rem Mag in a 7mm caliber, you have a few alternatives, and they're all barrel burners: STW, Weatherby, RUM, Nosler 28. The Western can't compete with a modernized, properly loaded 7 Rem Mag.
    Spend some time with QuickLoad, and consider non-SAAMI twist rates on the older cartridges, before being so quick to dismiss them. Slow-burning modern powders mean the calibers based on the 300 Win Mag brass can make the most of their case capacity. Load 'em right and they'll make good use of every grain. More "modern" cartridges with less case capacity simply won't keep up.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      Thanks for the info and your perspective. I simply was comparing factory loads.

  • @triplehelper6944
    @triplehelper6944 4 місяці тому

    I would like to see ur comparisons in real life shooting. U have a lot of 6.8 vids and not much else. I’m not knocking the 6.8 but let’s see how you shoot a 7mag and 7prc and 270 win in a fast twist

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      My son has a 7 mag, so I could do that if I had the time. I'm not likely to be able to compare the other two. I do really like my 6.5 PRC as well. I'll be doing some shooting with my 6ARC, getting ready for a match. Thanks for watching!

  • @montanastranger
    @montanastranger 2 місяці тому +1

    Need a private message with u. Aero precision 308 ar-10 with leupold vx6 HD. Wanna test it Steve?

    • @montanastranger
      @montanastranger 2 місяці тому

      I'm the talll guy used 2 work 4 beaver.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  2 місяці тому

      If we could get together sometime, that would be awesome! Email me at montanamusings6.8@gmail.com

  • @travise8008
    @travise8008 Місяць тому

    That federal fusion is a horrible bullet to use as a comparison it’s BC is terrible.
    Look up the hornady 175 gr eldx.
    The problem is there’s no factory options for a long aerodynamic high BC ammo for a 7mm rem mag.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  Місяць тому

      Hornady shows it is going 3000 fps. I don't trust their numbers. Besides, I can't find it anywhere. Choice Ammo loads it at 2889 and Copper Creek at 2840 fps. That's not enough difference for me, considering the 6.8 Western has less recoil in a short action. #savethe6.8western! Thanks for watching!

  • @ronlowney4700
    @ronlowney4700 4 місяці тому

    🤔 So, Again, Their Are Several Reasons Why The 7mm Remington Magnum Factory Ammunition Loads Are "Slow"! 1.) The Maximum SAMMI Cartridge Pressure is 61,000 psi, Where The 6.8 Western, 270 WSM, and 270 Winchester Are Specked To 65,000 psi! 2.) The 7mm Factory Loads Are Loaded To Even Lower Pressures Than That 61,000 psi Max Design Pressure 3.) The 7mm Remington Magnum is Not The Most Efficient Case Design! 🤷‍♂️

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      You are a very well educated man. I like your answers. Of course because of the poor case design, 6.8 Western CRUSHES 7 Mag.😜

  • @WildBushGrit
    @WildBushGrit 4 місяці тому

    Good video!
    Being slightly smaller diameter, the 6.8 has the advantage when it comes to BC for the same weight bullet. Smaller diameter but longer. What's even more amazing, is you get that in a short action. I don't understand why there is so few of us enamored with the 6.8 wst. It should have been a landslide if Winchester had the proper marketing machine. I'm going moose hunting tomorrow, with mine, zeroed at 200y my MPBR goes up to 325 yards, with a 10 MOA drop at 600 yards. I rebuilt the Winchester Copper Impact to my standard :) I made a video here if you are interested. ua-cam.com/video/KHr2VqYHpok/v-deo.html

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      Hey Thanks, my two favorite hunting rifles are the 6.5 PRC and the 6.8 Western. The short action, 60 degree throw and lack of recoil make them fun to shoot. I'll definitely check out your video! Have a good one!

  • @Accuracy1st
    @Accuracy1st 4 місяці тому

    I saw some Fed fusion tipped 6.5CM at Academy

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      They have to be a good bullet. They performed well in Mason Outdoors testing.

  • @BornAgain2019
    @BornAgain2019 3 місяці тому

    Unless your verifying actual velocities out of your barrel vs another with a cronograph this whole argument is mute. If we learned anything you cant go by numbers off the box.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  3 місяці тому

      I did run my 6.8 Western through the chronograph. It averaged 4 fps less than the box. I doubt the 7 mag is going to pick up 100 fps or more out of a 24" barrel. I don't think it's a bad comparison. Thanks for watching!

    • @BornAgain2019
      @BornAgain2019 3 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings Lee at Mason outdoors gives box specs then tells you what barrel he is shooting it out of then shows the chronograph results and penetration. His 24" Tikka 7mm Rem Mag usually runs slower than box specs.

  • @ronlowney4700
    @ronlowney4700 4 місяці тому

    🧐 So, Here is Another Widely "Unknown Fact"! The More Space in a Case, The More The Powder is Unevenly Distributed When It is Layed on It's Side, Which Causes Uneven Pressure To Be Applied To The Bullet and Effects Accuracy! So, Let's Compare "Cartridge Efficiency" and Case Capacity of the 7mm Remington Magnum Verses The 270 WSM, Using The Nosler Manual and a 160 grain Bullet! 🕵‍♂️

    • @ronlowney4700
      @ronlowney4700 4 місяці тому

      NOSLER Says It Takes 72 Grains of Magpro (The Powder Listed as The One Producing The Fastest Velocity For the 7mm RM) for the 7mm Rem. Mag. To Get a Velocity of 3,072 ft/s and at 92% Load Capacity! Meanwhile, The 270 wsm needs only 67.5 grains of the same powder to get 3,082 ft/s at a 95% case capacity! 😮

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      💯💯💯

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      That's why slightly crushed loads are not a bad thing as long as it's not overpreasured.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      EFFICIENCY!

    • @ronlowney4700
      @ronlowney4700 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@montanamusings So, Let Look at The Next Fastest "Common Powder" For Both Cartridges! The 7mm RM Takes 63 grains of Reloader 22 To Produce a Velocity of 3,058 ft/s and a Maxium Case Capacity of 85% (Which Isn't Good For Accuracy)! Meanwhile, The 270 wsm Uses 61.0 grains of the same powder to Get 3,088 ft/s and at a Case Capacity of 92%! Simply Put, The 270 WSM is More Efficient, as Is The 6.8 Western When Compared to the 7mm RM Using Heavier Bullets! 😃

  • @MatthewKyle-sg5uo
    @MatthewKyle-sg5uo 4 місяці тому

    Cherry picking data to prove a non existent point. Check out what they get handholding the 7mag. The 6.8 would shit itself.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      Cherry picking is for folks living in Washington State. 😂 Once again, factory ammo comparison. Handloads are a different story.

    • @MatthewKyle-sg5uo
      @MatthewKyle-sg5uo 4 місяці тому

      @montanamusings choice ammunition has 7 rem mag eld x 175 going at an advertised 2886. That would be a more fair comparison then junk remington core... your taking a bullet not designed for long range, non boat tail, and comparing it the an optimized long range bullet. So yeah cherry picking data.

    • @MatthewKyle-sg5uo
      @MatthewKyle-sg5uo 4 місяці тому

      @montanamusings don't get me wrong I probably will get one at some point. Not because it outperforms my 7 prc with hand loads, but because it gets close, and that's pretty cool.

  • @tandtoutdoors5154
    @tandtoutdoors5154 4 місяці тому +1

    This is why hornady won't get behind 6.8 western as it out performs many cartridges. I use a 160gr copper bullets, the 170 gr berger and the 165 gr nosler.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      I picked up some 155 grain LRX's to reload. I hope they shoot good. Thanks for watching!

  • @MatthewKyle-sg5uo
    @MatthewKyle-sg5uo 4 місяці тому

    Lmao no it doesn't. Stop being silly.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      36 yard zero aiming at 100 yards is 2.1 inches high. For real!😂

    • @MatthewKyle-sg5uo
      @MatthewKyle-sg5uo 4 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings also equals guessing. I'm into precision. Bullseye at 100. Each their own.

  • @BZE_Fishin
    @BZE_Fishin 4 місяці тому

    Ummm…you may want to rethink your position…the 7 REM Mag will exceed both the 6.8 and the 7 PRC especially now that the 7 REM Mag is offered in a 1:8 twist barrel
    Don’t take my word for it…head on over to Little Crow Gun Works…to date, he has 10 episodes worth of knowledge and proof.
    You can thank me later.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому +1

      I have watched some of the series. Great information. Most people don't own custom rifles with 1-8 twist barrels. I'm putting out information that is readily available to the average hunter who buys a couple boxes of ammo per year.

    • @BZE_Fishin
      @BZE_Fishin 4 місяці тому

      @@montanamusings…both Browning and Remington have 1:8 offerings in 7 REM Mag. This will soon result in 175 Gr ABLR offerings🤞🏼

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      @BZE_Fishin, Nice!

  • @SpudOutdoors
    @SpudOutdoors 4 місяці тому

    Any real shooters handload. Factory means nothing. 7 mag destroys most cartridges. Let me know when you can produce 1600lbs or more at 1000 yards.

    • @montanamusings
      @montanamusings  4 місяці тому

      I'll see what I can do. Thanks for watching!