Stop Removing ALL Suckers! Try This Instead.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @GardeningInCanada
    @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому +9

    Just a heads up almost any variety can have a determinate growth pattern “version” Seems like there is some confusion on that. So for example beefsteak can be determinate as well if you get the right kind.
    You very well could have an SM that is indeterminate. Completely possible! Even a Roma can be indeterminate (see below)
    Below are some examples.
    www.trueleafmarket.com/products/tomato-san-marzano-determinate-seeds
    www.prairieseedshop.ca/product/romatomato/197
    www.reimerseeds.com/beefsteak-determinate-tomato-seeds.aspx

    • @myjewelry4u
      @myjewelry4u 6 місяців тому

      I bought a simple watering system from a well known website, have yet to set it up. Heat wave for the next week, so when my pup goes out in the morning, I water. Not everything
      Stuff up front is getting neglected a bit. I just want vegetables and flowers in backyard to flourish.
      Also, my backyard looks like crap, like no one has lived here in years. Weeds and trees, ugh!
      I’m older and with broken legs I just couldn’t keep up.
      So veggies it is!

    • @offgridwannabe
      @offgridwannabe 6 місяців тому +2

      👍🏽
      I was just coming here to mention that my package of San Marzanos says they're indeterminate.

    • @ienekevanhouten4559
      @ienekevanhouten4559 6 місяців тому +2

      That is what I thought! San Marzano is sort of the ultimate INdeterminate tomato in my experience. They just keep growing and growing.

    • @FloraM44
      @FloraM44 6 місяців тому +1

      I've been wondering about this! I've had seed packets say determinate and I've been like hmm.. as we all know, packet info isn't always reliable. I wish there was a way to tell!

    • @offgridwannabe
      @offgridwannabe 6 місяців тому

      Since writing my comment 2wks ago, I've noticed my SM tomatoes haven't really grown taller. (They're about 5 1/2ft or so) They all seem to be developing fruit but I haven't needed to readjust their ties 🤔
      I've only ever grown cherry tomatoes. Is this typical?

  • @sarabelden7092
    @sarabelden7092 6 місяців тому +14

    Long ago when where I lived had lots of space I would plant with a steak to support the main stock, trim off 6 to 8 inches of leaves off the bottom to keep everything off the ground. Then I'd keep an eye on things and push another stake or tree branch into the ground a couple feet away from the main stem when the additional stems started looking like they needed support. I'd end up with an almost canopy of tomatoes about 4 feet off the ground. My son loved playing under them. It was like his own miniature jungle. Perfect for his imagination to grow and for his toys to live they're best lives. 😂
    I had my best tomato harvests doing things that way. I miss having that kind of space.

  • @cmbooks2000
    @cmbooks2000 6 місяців тому +11

    I came looking for info on pruning and suckers and got hit with so much terminology. I threw some seeds into a bed and now I'm hearing about determinate indeterminate Florida weaving puppeteering topping flopping planting depth yada yada. Holy tomato!
    Thank you. Now Im going to dig a ditch in my garden , jump in it and take a nap.

    • @jeil5676
      @jeil5676 6 місяців тому +1

      Dont worry. You can get great results by not doing any pruning. You can make gardening as simple or as complicated as you want. You do however have to support or stake your vines, pretty much.

    • @salpine
      @salpine 6 місяців тому +3

      Right? One summer on a whim I decided to buy a few packs of seeds. Never gardened as an adult, only had a memory of cherry tomatoes in our backyard as a kid being the best ever. Boy did I open up a can of worms.

    • @helengabr5743
      @helengabr5743 6 місяців тому +4

      Thank you! I needed to hear that! 😂 I live in Egypt. They all think i am nuts because I grow them up instead of on the ground and even crazier because I prune them. I just try different things and see how the plants react and the results. So far so good😅

  • @edengardenlabs7773
    @edengardenlabs7773 6 місяців тому +50

    I believe it's best to accept the plant just how it is not change it to fit my needs lol last week one of my tomatoes told me he identify as an orange tree and I support him 100%😂😂

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому +11

      LMFAO dead 💀 mine always seem to change what they are 🙄 either that or my labels are subpar

    • @Well_I_am_just_saying
      @Well_I_am_just_saying 6 місяців тому +4

      It is fine to not prune an indeterminate tomato plant as long as you give it plenty of room and water and fertilizer and stake it up well and you are willing to accept a higher risk of disease from having lower leaves contact the ground and you don't mind digging through the jungle of leaves and branches to find ripening tomatoes. I did okay growing tomatoes that way for several years, but now I generally like to grow my plants very close together and prune off most or all of the suckers on my indeterminate tomato plants.
      I do like the idea of topping tomato plant seedlings to get 2 main stems instead of one main stem plus a sucker stem. The main advantage is that it is less likely that the stems will split from each other. You will just need to plan to start your plants a week or 2 earlier to account for the extra set back from topping seedlings.

    • @Wonderland_Homestead
      @Wonderland_Homestead 6 місяців тому +2

      Yes!!! Follow your heart and listen to the plant. Prune based on your spacing needs, prune overcrowded leaves, or don't prune at all (but I highly suggest it to keep them under control)
      I have one tomato plant that's squat and bushy, it's putting all it's energy into suckers. I'm letting it. That's what it wants. I'm predicting it's determinate.

    • @Well_I_am_just_saying
      @Well_I_am_just_saying 6 місяців тому

      @@Wonderland_Homestead
      Don't you know what variety it is? Therefore, you should already know whether it is determinant or indeterminate. I have 2 determinate varieties that I am growing this year and I will not remove any of the suckers.

  • @GardeningInCanada
    @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому +22

    What is your favourite way to prune? I won’t lie… I used to never prune not even indeterminate and I didn’t notice any MAJOR difference 😅.

    • @Aussie-des420
      @Aussie-des420 6 місяців тому +2

      My 85 year old mum you must take the suckers my dad did that my grandma on my dads side was no let nature do its thing me I don’t see the difference 🤷‍♂️ I just keep the peace and prune mums lol

    • @Aussie-des420
      @Aussie-des420 6 місяців тому +1

      I find some tomatoes are just nothing but big pest and disease problems at certain times of the year I find the Roma tomato the most problem free tomato to grow and also the small Eye call them a pair tomato the little tiny yellow ones find other varieties. just too much drama with pest and disease maybe it’s just my climate here in Queensland.

    • @andersjohansson6118
      @andersjohansson6118 6 місяців тому +1

      I learned from another channel Spring Hill Farms to use the 12 leaf method where you prune all the leaves below the top 12. They were growing in a greenhouse (in Canada) to sell at a market, so this improved airflow and access to pick the fruit.
      I grow mostly indeterminate varieties, but I do have the San Marzano, which I trellis, but only prune a few of the lower leaves for airflow.
      I have a limited area that gets sufficient sun, so pruning allows for a higher plant density.
      I like to grow the "marketable" tomatoes because having larger uniform product makes for more efficient processing. The amount of work to process smaller tomatoes vs larger ones is the same. The problem with smaller ones is you need a lot more time and quantity to acheive the same results with the larger ones.
      This year I am switching to the toma hook to do the lean method. I looked at the rollers, but apparently the rollers need replacing after about 3 years. I had fun showing off 14 foot tall tomatoes, but having to use a ladder to constantly prune and pick has gotten old.
      Since I start my plants from seed, I just double the tomato plants in a 7 gallon container and go with a single leader. This worked well last year with 5 gallon containers (I ran out of potting soil) growing Pompeii tomatoes on double leaders.
      I am in the Minneapolis Minnesota area, so the more aggressive indeterminate varieties are usually 10-14 feet long by season end.

    • @katharine5606
      @katharine5606 6 місяців тому +2

      I've had a skepticism about excessive indeterminate tomato plant pruning and just take the lower branches and suckers off (maybe up to 12 inches from ground level), as well as select ones above, to reduce disease and increase airflow. Otherwise I leave them. I use heavyweight square tomato cages that I stake into the ground and then zip tie on additional wire trellis vertically, if the tomato plant gets too high. Two years ago my tomato plants got to be 7 feet tall and I pulled in a good harvest. Last year we had the horrible drought which severely affected the outcome, so we'll see about this year. Things look pretty good so far, but I probably could prune a bit more on the indeterminates, as I know you don't want the plants to be too stressed and wonder if that plays a part in blossom drop... it's a balancing game I feel. I'll have to look and see if you've done a video on the blossom set spray because I tried it and am uncertain as to its helpfulness; I think I read a study saying that it was only effective on colder temperatures? Anyway... I have some tomatoes blushing now and am so excited! A GIC fan from Chicago/6A. 😊

    • @teac117
      @teac117 6 місяців тому

      I do V trellising. I'll prune like a greenhouse mainly for disease control. I can cluster tomatoes together like a mofo.

  • @tomfisher3117
    @tomfisher3117 6 місяців тому +5

    You are a sweet lady and a blessing to this community. God Bless you!

  • @Whistlewalk
    @Whistlewalk 6 місяців тому +2

    As a Coastal Cdn, I appreciate what you had to say. I've inadvertently tried both pruning and non-pruning depending on when camping trips were scheduled, and whether rain at home occurred. So have learned to keep the pruning urge under control until later in the season. Except for the growth at the bottom of the stem - you just do get more tomatoes and fewer munching critters I find if you keep the bottom of the plant tidy. However, I have also learned to top all the plants about mid-Sept to encourage the plant to finish off the season (1st wk of Oct-ish). Also, many determinant varieties seem to proceed to die off around the end of August. Annoying but it does spread out the canning nicely. I pushed the 'subscribe' button.

  • @aileenbell6750
    @aileenbell6750 6 місяців тому +6

    In AZ, in my garden, I have figured out that the best way to prune is…not at all. Pretty much. (I will prune sick branches or branches that are in the way). I used to prune heavily, and found my fruit getting sunburned, even with shadecloth. Now I leave the foliage and all of that foliage provides shade for the tomatoes underneath. It also should be noted that in my dry climate, I don’t deal with very much disease/fungus/etc. I have a thick layer of mulch and drip irrigation and don’t even worry about leaves on the ground. I will do a little bit of puppeteering, but I have found my lazy ways to be quite productive. ❤

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      Jeeze that sun must be intense!

    • @remrocket2885
      @remrocket2885 6 місяців тому +1

      I’m here in Az also and have found the same thing. Check out the Arizona worm farm. They prune theirs and have them climb a support string and their tomatoes are beautiful. They do shade cloth theirs which I’m doing for some of my plants this year. All are looking great though I have gotten quite a few sunburned tomatoes. Someday I’ll take this gardening thing seriously!

  • @shlejazz
    @shlejazz 6 місяців тому

    Thank you for demonstrating how to prune and trellis the indeterminate tomato. I usually prune all the suckers, but this year, I'm growing two main stems on one of my plants! Cheers! 🍅

  • @joman104
    @joman104 6 місяців тому +10

    Personally i only prune dying branches on my tomatos, and have a great result. I mostly grow indeterminites. Im in zone 6a. I also grow san marzano, but the variety i have say indeterminate on the packet(they grow like one too). I got over 100 tomatos off of one plant last year, on treack for 1000s this year.

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      That is fair! Some of the tomatoes in the back of my garden beds I can’t reach to even prune properly

  • @MelbelleRVA
    @MelbelleRVA 6 місяців тому +22

    “Watch imma forget to water these and they’re just gonna die” should be my tagline. 😂

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому +1

      😂 you’d be shocked how many times this happens to me 😅

  • @ASpinnerASpinner
    @ASpinnerASpinner 6 місяців тому +5

    I personally think that a grid trellis is probably the best way to grow indeterminates. It's easy, takes less faffing and you only really tie the plant once at the bottom when it's still too short to weave in the grid but tall enough to get knocked around in the wind. You're just weaving the plant through the grid as it grows, like once a week or so you just weave the top though. And it looks great, too.

    • @MissChievousRN
      @MissChievousRN 6 місяців тому

      Agree!! I use cattle panels because they are cheap, strong enough to handle ANY vine, nearly indestructible, and can be covered later for shade or high tunnel. (Put pipe insulation on edges to prevent tearing plastic)
      The grid gives you plenty of options to secure your vines with tapes, ties, or clips.
      I also put solar lights on mine because I work weird hours and can check on everything at night if needed.

  • @MiladaKaiser
    @MiladaKaiser 6 місяців тому +1

    My experience of best results in a long California summer with indeterminate is - 2 main stems, leave each sucker develop one bloom and then cut above it.
    Also - end of June I let root the sucker in the water and plant a new tomatoes plants.
    Some of my second crop ( mostly cherries) I can harvest even through the winter and next year.

  • @chrystalfromalaska
    @chrystalfromalaska 6 місяців тому +1

    Not Canadian but Alaskan. And this was very helpful since our climates are so similar and everyone down south has such long growing seasons! Their tips just aren't the same.

  • @digemsmacks5690
    @digemsmacks5690 3 місяці тому

    I live in Florida and still find your info very useful, much of it i just convert over to our shoukder seasons here and even winter gardening (Central FL so usually pots for the winter "crops"

  • @pascalxus
    @pascalxus 6 місяців тому

    i love the fact that you're looking at all these studies and finding truths to share with us!

  • @FloraM44
    @FloraM44 6 місяців тому +1

    One thing I've done before when I had several tomatoes that weren't ripe before we were about to get frost, was cutting the plant at the base, and hanging it upside down in a garage. The tomatoes took a while but they did ripen from what I remember!

  • @eklectiktoni
    @eklectiktoni 6 місяців тому +2

    12:48 This point makes me wonder if the timing of pruning would matter. Like should you allow the plant to grow unpruned until it begins to flower or just prune from the start? Great info. There's always so much to learn about growing tomatoes.
    EDIT: I'm in US zone 9a so temps/growing season isn't an issue. Obviously like you said, cold climate growers have different rules.

    • @natas12rm
      @natas12rm 6 місяців тому

      You’d prune a week before flower. Idk it works well with weed

  • @moirad6579
    @moirad6579 6 місяців тому +1

    Even in Canada 🇨🇦 it can be worthwhile growing suckers, at least for cherry tomatoes. Had a great crop of midnight snack cherry tomatoes from two sucker plants last year.

  • @Cen13-b8w
    @Cen13-b8w 6 місяців тому

    I did it 5 years ago. It was a last week of August and it's getting cold. All of my tomato fruits were still green. I cut off the top and the plant shoot lots of suckers, removed all suckers and after 2 weeks my tomatoes started to turn red. I have been doing the same procedure since then. 😊😊

  • @j.b.6855
    @j.b.6855 6 місяців тому +2

    Nice video and basically what I do when pruning tomatoes. Regardless of what I do below, the plant eventually has the lower 8-10 inches of leaves removed. I like double stemming indeterminates, except cherry tomatoes. Its a trade off between size of fruit and number of fruit. With double stemming you dont lose much size and get more tomatoes. Cherry tomatoes I start off double stemming removing all the suckers below the second stem (usually about a foot up), then let them go wild. Determinates are basically left to go wild in sturdy tomato cages.

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      Do you remove the bottoms for air flow

    • @j.b.6855
      @j.b.6855 6 місяців тому

      @@GardeningInCanada Yes and to prevent soil splashing up on the plant during watering to avoid issues.

  • @edengardenlabs7773
    @edengardenlabs7773 6 місяців тому +27

    I don't just remove suckers from plants I remove no good suckas from my life 😎😎😎

  • @ebradley2306
    @ebradley2306 6 місяців тому

    What about cherry tomatoes? They mature faster than the large varieties. I use them for everything. I grow them in SE Texas because our season is cut short by heat. Unlike the larger tomatoes, these guys just slow down flowering when it’s super hot and then fully recover when the temperature drops. ☺️

  • @Wonderland_Homestead
    @Wonderland_Homestead 6 місяців тому

    I topped the ones that got taller than the stakes they're weaved with this morning. Looking forward to seeing how they respond!!

  • @rrjesuslovesu
    @rrjesuslovesu 6 місяців тому

    So glad to have finally found someone in Canada. However, I hope you don’t mind if I make a suggestion. Near the end when you were showing us how to do the pruning, it was very difficult to see. If you could get a little closer, maybe it would be easier to figure out. Because honestly, right now I’m rather confused. But thank you so much, definitely, for doing this for us Canadians.

  • @skeletonfish110
    @skeletonfish110 6 місяців тому +1

    I weave and string (in Montreal, i think same zone as you) my family calls me the puppet master, I have strings on pretty much every branch. Plants are massive already

  • @ltlwlwl5057
    @ltlwlwl5057 6 місяців тому +8

    I think you're the reincarnation of a Garden Goddess. 😊

  • @MyBorealHomesteadLife-hn5lg
    @MyBorealHomesteadLife-hn5lg 6 місяців тому +2

    I grow my tomatoes on a page wire trellis. Other than pruning the lower leaves for air flow, I simply tie everything to the trellis - I kept track of varieties and weight harvested and the average size of tomato - I was happy. Another person read my information and commented that she prunes and although her average tomato size was larger, I had a higher yield per plant or it was similar. I am growing for yield and not size. Good video.

  • @chrisschultz1580
    @chrisschultz1580 6 місяців тому

    I experimented with topping seedlings this spring. It worked very well and set back growth about 3 weeks. Next year I will start a selection of seeds 3 weeks before normal and have some true double leader tomatoes ready at transplant time. I will then "single stem" prune each of the 2 leaders.

  • @gardeningtroutmaster
    @gardeningtroutmaster 6 місяців тому

    I like this advice i'm going to up my game on my San Marzano's ... and try some stuff I was so misinformed on some stuff. thx

  • @PlantObsessed
    @PlantObsessed 6 місяців тому +7

    Easy peasy. Lemon squeezy. 🎉🎉 My new love is dwarf tomatoes. If a tomato plant was a sheep dog. That's the vibe . Central Illinois ...no blite also no sun scald. They are tough mothers. Not the best harvest volume but basically bullet proof.

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому +1

      I have the red robins started this year. I am
      Pretty excited to see how they turn out. I want to grow these guys indoors

    • @remrocket2885
      @remrocket2885 6 місяців тому

      Let us know if you grow them and how they do!

  • @carmendoyle9786
    @carmendoyle9786 6 місяців тому

    Thank u for sharing all u know with us ! It means a lot ! ❤

  • @CWorgen5732
    @CWorgen5732 6 місяців тому

    Ooooh, thank you. I was pruning out the bottom few suckers and contemplating doing the rest of them, and it just felt wrong. This helps.

  • @kimmyseegmiller985
    @kimmyseegmiller985 6 місяців тому

    I have never pruned a single tomato in my life lol. I do mulch the roots heavy and keep them up off the ground. 800 pounds last year!

  • @memph7610
    @memph7610 6 місяців тому

    Southern Ontario tomato season can be fairly long. You can plant out mid-May if the forecast looks good, and the plants can keep going into October, sometimes even November in the warmest zones. Since the summers aren't that hot, typically in the mid-high 20s rather than 30-35C+, it means the plants get less stressed and less disease issues than in the southern US and as a result often last longer, so we can get 2-3 months of vine ripe harvesting, maybe even close to 4 months in Zone 6-7 for single-stemmed cherry tomatoes transplanted at 2ft tall. That means un-topped tomatoes can get quite big, I've had a beef steak tomato reach 10ft, and cherry tomatoes reach 13ft, despite leaving several suckers on the beefsteak, and dozens of suckers on the cherry tomato.
    That means even with puppeteering you'd have to lower the plants quite a lot, especially cherry tomatoes. I haven't tried that method yet, I might give it a go for beefsteak/slicer tomatoes, but for cherry tomatoes my preference remains growing them up, then sideways along a fence line or cattle panel arch.

  • @daniellebailey6802
    @daniellebailey6802 6 місяців тому +3

    James Prigioni uses a method where he lets suckers produce flowers and then he cuts the growth after the flowers off. I haven't tried it, but I thought it was interesting.

  • @zororosario
    @zororosario 6 місяців тому +1

    Good advice for a novice like me😊 Thanks Cheers

  • @lostpony4885
    @lostpony4885 6 місяців тому

    Every time someone pinches off a sucker i scream inside. I struggled for years with inadequate soil volume and nitrogen and moisture stability so incomplete sets etc BUT this year i have last years tomatoes planted into deeper soils with lots of rotting woods over stinky big fisheads set into sheltered positions uplight of shrubs and canna lillies etc so....even the Roma came right through winter and is producing big fruits in full sets. Roma in a cage the indeterminates on strings. Second year Romas are super fleshy.

  • @DaveSmith-pm2yq
    @DaveSmith-pm2yq 6 місяців тому +26

    Canada "you don't have to listen to anything I tell you todo"
    USA "If you want the highest yield this is the only way to get it"
    😅

    • @amyschmelzer6445
      @amyschmelzer6445 6 місяців тому +10

      But as an American I have to say “You can’t tell me what to do.” I have an unpopular opinion when it comes to pruning tomatoes. I leave the suckers because they’re gonna produce fruits. I prune the leaf branches that touch the ground.

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому +5

      I don’t even listen to myself most days

    • @yesterdayseyes
      @yesterdayseyes 6 місяців тому +3

      Americans do what we want regardless

    • @jacobclark89
      @jacobclark89 6 місяців тому

      Great video ! I leave the suckers cuz it helps to hide the tomatoes from the critters and protect from sun damage. I think I will try topping

  • @carolstuff
    @carolstuff 6 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for such good info Ashley!

  • @FloraM44
    @FloraM44 6 місяців тому +7

    I tried the puppeteer method after watching Charles Dowding do it a few years ago and several of my tomatoes broke. I didn't take into account that he was doing it in a greenhouse, and my area is super windy. Even though the plants were wrapped around the string, they'd unravel with the wind! The next year I invested in cattle panels and haven't looked back since lol

    • @Babs-Veterans-are-Family
      @Babs-Veterans-are-Family 6 місяців тому +1

      Have you tried using the clips with the puppeteer? I bought clips from Walmart made by Burpee. They look like a tiny clamp has a small nose like for the strip. I don't like the circle shaped ones they're only good for 1 year maybe 2. These seem like they'll hold up longer. I bought 1 plant from a nursery they used plastic tape like stapled the ends. I'm also going to try twine loosely tied that I can clip off if needed. It's very windy here haven't had any snap with the Burpee clips.

    • @FloraM44
      @FloraM44 6 місяців тому

      @@Babs-Veterans-are-Family I haven't tried the Burpee clips, not sure if I've seen them here in Canada. I have the circle clips and also tried foam wires. They didn't all break, but a few of them did, and the movement of the stem from pivoting in the wind seemed to weaken the others. I needed to really secure them somehow and I think I'm just an a place that needs a little extra sturdy support. We have gotten winds over 110 km/hr!

  • @strengthsuniversity
    @strengthsuniversity 6 місяців тому

    Question 🙋🏻 I need use grow bags (vary in size from 20-30 gallon) and the trellis method like in the video. In the past, I’d do one tomato per bag and let one or two suckers go. This year I thought I could jump start my harvest by just putting 2-3 plants per bag and doing a single stem. Do you think I could get away with two stems per plant if they’re that closely planted 🤔 Thanks 🙏🏼

  • @lexi-vx1pd
    @lexi-vx1pd 6 місяців тому

    Hey there, Ashley! Thanks for the info and ideas! This year I decided to experimentally grow mountain magic, sun gold cherry and super sweet 100 so we can compare. All indeterminate I believe so this should be fun 😊

  • @TheMash84
    @TheMash84 3 місяці тому

    I thought San Marzano was indeterminate type of tomato plant!
    I've been growing it this summer and guess what, I've been removing suckers, which I think impacted the yield as the plant was way less compact and the production of fruit was concentrated in terms of height!
    Especially in my case where I'm growing in the balcony and I don't have the chance to let the plant expand too much in height!

  • @Heather_At_The_Ridge
    @Heather_At_The_Ridge 6 місяців тому +1

    Thanks girl. Great info as always!

  • @CapitanFantasma1776
    @CapitanFantasma1776 6 місяців тому

    I didn't understand completely. Need to review it. Thanks!

  • @suzannestack7784
    @suzannestack7784 6 місяців тому

    The plant variety/height chart you showed at the beginning of the video. Would you mind sharing a link please.

  • @memph7610
    @memph7610 6 місяців тому

    Leaving suckers on means you require more space per plant though. Do you know if there's a difference in production per square space with closely spaced single stemmed vs widely spaced unpruned?

  • @shortseasongarden
    @shortseasongarden 6 місяців тому +1

    Very informative video as usual.
    However, several times in the video, you used San Marzano tomatoes as an example of determinate tomatoes. I realize that more than one variety of tomatoes is referred to as San Marzano, but any that I can find after a quick search are listed as indeterminate. I certainly hope that ones I planted in my new high tunnel are indeterminate because I have kept them pruned to one leader.
    I always enjoy your videos. Keep up the good work.

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      If your packaging is indeterminate it’s likely correct. Like that list I showed had beefsteak listed as determinate and that’s pretty rare imo

  • @southernyankeeprepper
    @southernyankeeprepper 6 місяців тому

    PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE HELP! do a video on pseudomanas corrugata and pith necrosis! Somehow my tomatoes caught it and I need help before I completely lose every single one of mine! Black rot and co hollowed out stems! I need some guidance on how to combat it or prevent it!

  • @timothyraymond7393
    @timothyraymond7393 6 місяців тому

    From Westfield NY. Just found your site.
    Love it!!!

  • @Babs-Veterans-are-Family
    @Babs-Veterans-are-Family 6 місяців тому

    Not sure if you meant San Marzono or if there's another variety called San Marizino? I couldn't find a Marizino. The Marzono variety are indeterminate tomatoes. I have a pack of seeds says right on the package as well as Google.

  • @jean-micheltanguay8664
    @jean-micheltanguay8664 6 місяців тому

    I like your content. Gardening is an ever growing science experiment ;)
    Do you have anything on electro culture ? I’d like to hear your tought and maybe observation about it.

  • @adamwisz
    @adamwisz 6 місяців тому

    From my research(wikipedia deep) San Marzano is indeterminate and Romas are the determinate hybrid derived from them!

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      You can get determinate and indeterminate yes. Beefstake is another one that has both for example

  • @axefairy7868
    @axefairy7868 6 місяців тому

    Just discovered your channel and learned loads, thank you so much!
    Do you have any experience with multifloral tomatoes? I’ve got some growing now and not been able to find a huge amount of information on them.

  • @Melly.K11
    @Melly.K11 6 місяців тому +1

    I have some determinate (Manitoba) tomatoes on my balcony. I didn't think they would survive (I didn't have the best lighting conditions when they were seedlings), but since I grew them from seed, I didn't want to toss them either. Now they are growing like weeds, and about 3+ feet tall, but only just getting flowers at the top of the plant. Will leaving all the suckers grow tomatoes further down on the plant? I've never had a tomato plant fail to put out flowers as it was growing like these ones. I haven't done any pruning, except the very bottom branches near the soil.

  • @GRPermie
    @GRPermie 6 місяців тому

    Would a plant that has more flowers hypothetically require more nutrient rich soil? Would plant density be a worry? (More spacing compared to an unprinted)

  • @jvin248
    @jvin248 6 місяців тому

    "We are the outcasts of the gardening community" ... Perfect! This is where the real answers hang out. Regenerative Agriculture? Lofthouse Landrace? Fukuoka One Straw Revolution? Let's see some more!

  • @dwwcoder5048
    @dwwcoder5048 6 місяців тому +1

    I have been almost daily pruning my plants. However, there are some I miss every day my Better Boys are hard to keep from branching out. I have plenty of them because I have been pruning but they growing out of control. How can I here in zone 6A slow them suckers down.

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      That’s a good problem to have lol. Do you use a fertilizer high in nitrogen?

    • @dwwcoder5048
      @dwwcoder5048 6 місяців тому

      I have miracle gro liquid fertilizer every week or two. But when I started to transplant them I used a microbe nutrient and Dolomites Lime at the bottom before covering them.

    • @dwwcoder5048
      @dwwcoder5048 6 місяців тому

      @@GardeningInCanada I used liquid fertilizer every other week depending on the weather and when transplanting I use a microbe booster and Dolomites lime at the bottom of the plant and bone meal around the top of the plant and work it into the soil. I did this on all my transplants.

  • @mary1973tx
    @mary1973tx 6 місяців тому +1

    awesome and great information like always
    thanks 🙂🌻

  • @JamieW-o7b
    @JamieW-o7b 6 місяців тому +1

    My O/S tomatoes only just started flowering, with only 5 weeks till winter should I prune them at the soil mark?? East of London!

    • @AustinandJax
      @AustinandJax 6 місяців тому

      5 weeks till winter? Is this a typo? Summer hasn’t even officially started?

    • @JamieW-o7b
      @JamieW-o7b 6 місяців тому

      @@AustinandJax Neither did spring start here!

  • @timbrickman8716
    @timbrickman8716 6 місяців тому +1

    Hey thanks for this

  • @inharmonywithearth9982
    @inharmonywithearth9982 10 днів тому

    If you have deer or dogs that chase rabbits the Florida weave is a disaster. They run through and drag away the whole garden in tangled mess. So much maintenance stringing them routinely.

  • @nicholasdemarest4254
    @nicholasdemarest4254 6 місяців тому

    I don't like bush so I prune suckers plus 10 plants in a 4x8 need pruning

  • @Saoirse.n.Murphy
    @Saoirse.n.Murphy 6 місяців тому +1

    Berkshires MA, thank you!

  • @kaleyjanenigh
    @kaleyjanenigh 6 місяців тому

    GIC new channel pic looking fire! 😊❤

  • @tyramasters-heinrichs921
    @tyramasters-heinrichs921 6 місяців тому

    Thank you.
    Okay, I didn't plant deep, they look good, but I put them in a new bed with 'filler' in the bottom and it sunk down...lol...so can I top up the soil or should I wait till the end of the growing season? Or wait till the end of July (I'm in Manitoba, zone 3)?
    Hi from the Manitoba Interlake !

  • @Zahra_95-Abd
    @Zahra_95-Abd 6 місяців тому +1

    Is there anything that you can recommend to use as trellising? (Other than cattle panels)
    Tight on budget

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому +1

      Bambo stakes I find to be inexpensive. That or puppeteering with 2x4s I have a video on that.

    • @gabriellakadar
      @gabriellakadar 6 місяців тому +1

      I use Peak 6-inch x 3.5 ft. x 7 ft. Galvanized Steel Wire Mesh (9-Gauge) from Home Depot. In Canada they cost $22.74 plus tax per unit.
      I have them attached to T posts vertically.

  • @joyceschmidt7372
    @joyceschmidt7372 6 місяців тому +1

    Why do my san marzano seeds say they are indeterminate on the packet 😭😭😭 they're already like four feet tall and ive pruned then to heck

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      It’s possible! If it says indeterminate I would take the package description.

  • @stayfree11
    @stayfree11 6 місяців тому

    I thought San marzano is indeterminate 🤔
    I’m loving you videos!! I love the great info!!!

    • @Tippler0611
      @Tippler0611 6 місяців тому

      Same! I got them specifically because I am more familiar with indeterminate trellising. Guess we'll find out!

  • @OceanFrontVilla3
    @OceanFrontVilla3 6 місяців тому

    San Marzano tomatoes... No "I"

  • @margaretmarshall3645
    @margaretmarshall3645 6 місяців тому

    I watched one UA-cam video that said cherry tomatoes, even indeterminate ones, should be left unpruned, except for low leaves and maybe late season topping. Is there any science supporting that, or anyone that’s tried it both ways?

  • @adventuresinlifemka1762
    @adventuresinlifemka1762 6 місяців тому

    I really don't prune my tomatoes. They grow on a cattle panel trellis. I'm in Norhern USA (Ohio).

  • @swampysanta5445
    @swampysanta5445 6 місяців тому

    topping never works for me always the sucker node next to the cut always takes dominance over the other sucker nodes.

  • @joeyturbo11
    @joeyturbo11 6 місяців тому +2

    My San marzano seed package says that they're indeterminate. I've been removing all suckers except for one. Should I be leaving them? I spaced my tomatoes only a foot apart, so I think I've kinda dug my own grave regardless.

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      I feel like sometimes the companies make mistakes. Try half unpruned half pruned

    • @joman104
      @joman104 6 місяців тому

      ​@GardeningInCanada mine also say that and from my experiences it holds true, I ended up with some huge viney 10 foot beasts last year

    • @joeyturbo11
      @joeyturbo11 6 місяців тому

      I'll see what I can do, thanks for the zippy response! Go figure I was out yesterday pruning... lol

    • @gabriellakadar
      @gabriellakadar 6 місяців тому

      @@joeyturbo11 San Marzano tomatoes are indeterminate. Feed them lots of organic hen manure and they will grow robust and produce well.

    • @andersjohansson6118
      @andersjohansson6118 6 місяців тому

      I grew them last year and I would call them a dwarf indeterminate. I live in the Minneapolis, Minnesota area and by years end they were close to 5 feet tall.
      I feed them a higher phosphorus and potassium fertilizer so they don't grow a lot of foliage. I do hit them up with some calcium nitrate on occasion as I grow everything in containers.
      The challenge is trellising them as they grow bushy like a determinate as I lightly prune suckers so there is airflow and so we can see when tomatoes are ready before the mice get to them.
      I also don't have all day full sun. I only get full sun between 9 am to about 4pm. So if I had full day sun, they probably would grow longer.

  • @myjewelry4u
    @myjewelry4u 6 місяців тому

    I gave up on pruning tomatoes except near soil.

    • @cynthiacollins2668
      @cynthiacollins2668 6 місяців тому +1

      That's the most important pruning anyway. 😉

  • @DebRoo11
    @DebRoo11 6 місяців тому +2

    Did you say san marzano is determinate? 🤔 My san marzano pkg says indeterminate

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      I would believe the seed company but I’ve mostly seen them as determinate. Maybe do 50/50 www.trueleafmarket.com/products/tomato-san-marzano-determinate-seeds

    • @mgguygardening
      @mgguygardening 6 місяців тому +2

      I noticed that too, I've grown them for years and the ones I grow are definiteley indeterminate. Maybe there's a variety out there that are determinate?

    • @gabriellakadar
      @gabriellakadar 6 місяців тому +1

      @@mgguygardening They are indeterminate. I grow them as well.

  • @rrbb36
    @rrbb36 6 місяців тому

    Fungus = singular = hard “g” sound.
    Fungi = plural = soft “g” sound = (same as the letter “j”)

  • @WPHWw-km1tk
    @WPHWw-km1tk 6 місяців тому

    What do you mean "top the tomato”?

  • @edbantam9559
    @edbantam9559 6 місяців тому

    HELP, celebrity plus is it simi inditerminate or simi derminate? I've read both.

  • @ebby0808
    @ebby0808 6 місяців тому +1

    ... gardening heretics.... outcasts... You are sweet talking us!💚

  • @sassyshawnzie
    @sassyshawnzie 6 місяців тому +4

    Seriously just take off the extra leaves that yellow and get dense towards the base 😅. Pruned.

  • @AmandaZuke
    @AmandaZuke 6 місяців тому +2

    Now I want a “garden heretic” t-shirt!

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      AHAHAH our entire wardrobe is going to be garden shirts 😅

  • @matthewkheyfets1309
    @matthewkheyfets1309 6 місяців тому +1

    My peunning method depends on the plant and nutritional program. For cherries, im more inclined to keep a lot more suckers. Usually with proper nutrient management, they can have way more suckers, like 5-8. The key imo is keeping the plant pruned so that the tops of these leaders have light because that keeps them growing and blooming and have energy. If you give them lots of P and K and tte micronutrients, then really they can keep producing.
    For larger tomatoes, i prefer to let a single stem Y out with a vigorous sucker and then keep it to two stems. Reason is with proper nutrients, rhe plants produce well, good size ideally, and the fruit quality isnt sacrificed. If you have truly large tomatoes, having 3-4 stems may reduce their size, delay ripening, quality, etc.

  • @rrbb36
    @rrbb36 6 місяців тому

    The key to pronouncing “determinate” correctly, lies in breaking the word down into its correct syllables.
    = De-ter-mi-nate There’s only one “N” 👍

  • @braptdl1483
    @braptdl1483 6 місяців тому +1

    ❤ this one lol

  • @kendravoracek3636
    @kendravoracek3636 6 місяців тому +1

    💚💚

  • @Miggeamakes
    @Miggeamakes 6 місяців тому +1

    Counterpoint, what if I'm the kind of dumbass who got confused and has no idea which plant is which type of tomato and is just flying by the seat of my pants while weaving them ALL up a trellis? 😎🍅🤦🏻‍♀️

    • @cynthiacollins2668
      @cynthiacollins2668 6 місяців тому +2

      Then, just prune off the lower branches & enough of the others to allow for good ventilation and a plant that's not so crazy you can't find the tomatoes! 🍅

    • @renah8081
      @renah8081 6 місяців тому +1

      I too only get so far along while keeping my labelling accurate lol

  • @Darknamja
    @Darknamja 6 місяців тому +1

    "The Geek Crew is smarter than me". It takes a village. 😉

    • @anne-9374
      @anne-9374 6 місяців тому +1

      And someone must be very smart to be ready to recognize the value of what others bring to the table and acknowledge when someone is doing it better!❤

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      Haha that is VERY accurate. You guys are so creative with your setups. I even use your tips.

  • @lolitabonita08
    @lolitabonita08 6 місяців тому

    yes, it is time to use the brain, that thing that helps u figure out things and it is inside ones head...

  • @Darknamja
    @Darknamja 6 місяців тому +1

    😉😉

  • @romazone101
    @romazone101 6 місяців тому

    San Marzano' tomato plants are indeterminate! Shocking mistake!

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      You can most definitely buy determinates www.trueleafmarket.com/products/tomato-san-marzano-determinate-seeds
      You can even get beefsteaks that are determinate. Always follow the package or the tag.

    • @romazone101
      @romazone101 6 місяців тому

      @@GardeningInCanada Almost 40 years of growing San Marzano and have never even heard of such a thing as a determinate S. Marzano. Learn something new everyday!

  • @DP-vm2dd
    @DP-vm2dd 6 місяців тому +1

    Why all professionals do prune they tomatoes? Are they all crazy? 😮

    • @DebRoo11
      @DebRoo11 6 місяців тому +1

      More uniform and tidy plants. An unpruned tomato plant can take up a lot of crazy space

    • @gabriellakadar
      @gabriellakadar 6 місяців тому

      @@DebRoo11 The greenhouse growers have them wound up wires and it makes it easier to pick. Farmers leave them to sprawl on the ground. It's only home gardeners that use supports because we have limited space and want to grow more than just tomatoes. Plus tomatoes near the ground get eaten by voles. Late in the season the squirrels get at them so I pick them green and pickle them. Not the squirrels, the tomatoes.

    • @DebRoo11
      @DebRoo11 6 місяців тому

      @@gabriellakadar mmm pickled squirrels 😂
      My brother in law and best friends parents had tomato greenhouses for market. They do train them up for sure. Also prune. They always had lota of maters on each. 🤜🏼 🐿 Those critters in the garden sure love feasting off someone else's hard work

  • @edengardenlabs7773
    @edengardenlabs7773 6 місяців тому +4

    Best way to extend your growing season ......MOVE AWAY FROM CANADA

    • @GardeningInCanada
      @GardeningInCanada  6 місяців тому

      I will not argue that

    • @edengardenlabs7773
      @edengardenlabs7773 6 місяців тому

      @@GardeningInCanada listen here gingersnaps this is called trolling it would please your viewing audience.... Well maybe just me ... if you'd be less agreeable and charming and troll me back 😂😂😂

    • @ebby0808
      @ebby0808 6 місяців тому

      Never!

  • @Inspiringsuccess2
    @Inspiringsuccess2 6 місяців тому

    SAN marzano are indeterminate

  • @SuperDranger
    @SuperDranger 6 місяців тому

    15 minutes of blah blah blah 10 seconds of actually showing the principle 😢