Those who are comparing them here are just fools. Both Maestros are showcasing different styles. They are distinctly amazing. We are lucky that we are getting to hear the different styles in one lehra. ❤️
এক কথায় শেষ - দুজনই মহান না হলে একসঙ্গে বাজাতে রাজি হতেন? দুজনই একসঙ্গে দেশে বিদেশে বাজিয়েছেন। আমি দুজনকেই লাইভ শুনেছি একাধিকবার ... দুজনই বিস্ময় প্রতিভা ও সাধনার মূর্তি !
What a style kumarji!! You are the most unique tabla player with the most unique bayan bols.. Your bayan talks.. You are the king of tabla!! Unparalleled.. ❤❤
I happened to listen Kumar Bose Ji's 1st appearance on stage with Usd Amjad Ali Khan at Modern School long back. On that very day it was evident to all listeners that a Tabla Maestro was born.....One bayan Ghe Ghe Ghe Ghe was timing and on dayan he was weaving exquisite patterns....after some days every table-player was imitating his style ....even Usd Zakir was seen doing the same.
Kya baat hai Anindoda.....perfection does belong to you....and Kumarda you are a composer...thanks very much for such a wonderful concert. Pronam roilo!
the level intricate detail kumar ji has shown blew my mind away , the bayan work is unmatchable .... maybe thats the reason he put extra effort on getting the sound right from the mic
Why do people have to criticize so much. People are saying Zakir Hussain is better and don’t get me wrong he an amazing tabla player but every tabla player has their own style of playing and different attitude of play. They are from two completely different Ghana’s with different styles of playing and they are here to display their art and talent to all of us and if people are just going to argue about who’s better, what is the point of the show. So just enjoy the show and enjoy the talent of Both of the Tabla players......
I often visit this just to watch Pt. Kumar Bose improvise and to see the reaction of Pt. Anindo Chattargee at a particular point... 14:29 Though it is a bit disturbing to see Pt. Kumar Bose struggle with the sound system, to improvise real-time, something like he did at 14:29 is quite impressive!
Dear Brothers, pls do not argue or abuse each other, we should be proud of the fact that both the stalwarts are of this land playing equally so well AT PAR. we can compare only if they belongs to same Gharana, but it differs. so just enjoy the essence of Gharanas ,
Wah kya baate hai is desh ke ye dono vidwanon tabla marstros hain jinki ulug alug rythmic play styles hai aur dono most appreciables aur most regarded marstros hain sir dono ko is bunde ka pranam aur hestty wishes to add more n more glories.... Dev pc. Knp
Kumar Bose ji and Anindo ji are both amazing tabla players. and no, kumar ji is not struggling, that's the way he plays. Even his guru Pt. Kishan Maharaj had simmilar style. Those people here saying Anindo ji is better than Kumar Bose, it's maybe just because you like the farukhabad style over the banaras style. That's possible. Both are very different styles. Saying one of them is better than other is disrespectful to both. Who are we to compare them, when Anindo ji himself says "this is not a competetion. it is improvisation" Both of them and Swapan Chaudhuri and Zakir Hussain are all legendary maestros.
Anindo ji comes from Lucknow Gharana, not Farukhabad. He received only basic training from there and then went to Ustad Afaque Husain Khan sahab of Lucknow
Abhilaksh Verma no. he is from Farukkhabad gharana, disciple of legendary Pt. Gyan Prakash Ghosh. He learnt from Lucknow ustaad from Ustaad Afaque Hussain Khan, and Ajrada kaidas from Ustaads of the gharana.Sorry, I don't remember the names. He has mastered those gharanas.But he is a gandha bandh shagird of Farukkhabad legend Pt. Gyan Prakash Ghosh who was a disciple of Ustaaf Masit Khan-father of the legend ustaad Keramatullah Khan saheb.
Dear all tabla lovers..I have attended several concerts starting from Ahmad Jan Thirakhava saheb to the current generation and recieved the joy of hearing. I think that each person has his own style of presentation depending on his physical strength and riyaz irrespective of an d addition to talim of Gharana. It's a vast ocean. We have to pick up the jewels. Be Happy .
Why not, both are good, but different and there's nothing wrong with that. One person may prefer vanilla icecream and another chocolate icecream, yet both are good, it's all about preferences
Both are great. Pt. Kumar Bose is a great composer like his father Pt.Biswanath Bose. Looking Kumar Bose performing from front is mind blowing. We experienced this as I was a student of Guruji Pt. Kumar Bose.
Incidentally I was acompanists on lahara for Shri. Narayan Joshi at Dombiwali concert on 14th August 1969. He was desciple of Ustad Ahamadjan Thirakhawa.
For fuck's sake, stop judging Kumar Ji. He's equally good as Anindo Ji here. That's why both of them gave an ecstatic performance. This is a once in lifetime performance, and so enjoy it. Best of Benaras and Farukhabad gharana!
some people are stupid, if not, they are trying to be one by comparing legends, by saying Kumar ji is struggling, by saying Anindyo ji is best, and, I found someone saying both of them are good , but Zakir is the best. please, stop. There is no one 'best' in the field of music. We should not compare and demean legends. They have definitely mastered the tabla and that is why they are here today. Apart from that, they have their own style too. So, let's learn from these video and stop comparing. Still you have doubt, watch other videos of those masters on UA-cam. You may have ur own point of view on who is better, but please do ur research more ( it will never going to be finished in this life though) and don't write down ur conclusion here, you will look like a kid from elementary school. Thanks.
+B Hazra...what do u mean by "If it was other round"..?? Also, have you all checked other videos of Pt. Kumar Bose ji and Pt. Anindo ji? The styles are completely different.."Bols are similar in all gharanas, to some extent even the nikaas is similar...but sound production and presentation is different...Khula baaj has a very rich sound texture..whereas farrukkhabad has more of a softer tone with complex kayadas"..It is difficult to produce such sound textures..and perform complex kayadas..
In music u cant say that he is better or he is better,if u have sense of music....u will understand....duet is not a competition...it is an improvisation
Dear friends: The Baz and the Nikas are the two ingredients which make Tabla play most interesting which was explained by Ustad Ahamad Jan Thirakhawa saheb and his disciple Mr. Narayanrao Joshi. The videos of both of them are available. Pl Visit them and get satisfied.
Their internal rivalry is visible. The fact is these masters have some prejudices about each other's gharana's. I've watched bith of these master's live interview with Arvind Parikh sahab. In first interview of Anindo where he criticized badly unconsciously about Banaras gharana style by making comment like Banaras people पिट के बजाते है। so, the particular piece in Tabla may not sound good. When Kumar Bose came he replied to Anindo's remark over Banaras style. May be this program happened before my instances. But their rivalry seems to be since old times.
tabla strength and variety.. guruji way better than anindo chatterjee. those who are judging, if u know tabla who plays better,.. dats his style of playing, look up any of his videos.. i sat beside him and learned from him directly . so i know.
Those who are comparing them here are just fools. Both Maestros are showcasing different styles. They are distinctly amazing. We are lucky that we are getting to hear the different styles in one lehra. ❤️
আপনারা আমাদের বাংগালির গর্ব! কী অসাধারণ!! 🙏🙏🙏
How fantastically they enjoyed each other!! Aha!!!
রবীন্দ্রনাথ থাকলে লিখতেন ঠিক “তুমি কেমন করে তাল বাঁধো হে গুণী;”শুধু শুনেই জীবন সার্থক।🙏🙏🙏
এক কথায় শেষ - দুজনই মহান না হলে একসঙ্গে বাজাতে রাজি হতেন? দুজনই একসঙ্গে দেশে বিদেশে বাজিয়েছেন। আমি দুজনকেই লাইভ শুনেছি একাধিকবার ... দুজনই বিস্ময় প্রতিভা ও সাধনার মূর্তি !
What a style kumarji!! You are the most unique tabla player with the most unique bayan bols.. Your bayan talks.. You are the king of tabla!! Unparalleled.. ❤❤
You want to learn tabla ?
I also play tabla. My guruji is pt Kumar Bose ji
I happened to listen Kumar Bose Ji's 1st appearance on stage with Usd Amjad Ali Khan at Modern School long back. On that very day it was evident to all listeners that a Tabla Maestro was born.....One bayan Ghe Ghe Ghe Ghe was timing and on dayan he was weaving exquisite patterns....after some days every table-player was imitating his style ....even Usd Zakir was seen doing the same.
मां सरस्वती की कृपा आप पर बनी रहे!
That's simply fantastic ! Two great maestros having fun on the richest percussion with the richest repertoire. Thumbs up !
Kya baat hai Anindoda.....perfection does belong to you....and Kumarda you are a composer...thanks very much for such a wonderful concert. Pronam roilo!
the level intricate detail kumar ji has shown blew my mind away , the bayan work is unmatchable .... maybe thats the reason he put extra effort on getting the sound right from the mic
Pranam to both the Legends. Aha - what a blessing🙏
Gems of bangal 😍😍
Why do people have to criticize so much. People are saying Zakir Hussain is better and don’t get me wrong he an amazing tabla player but every tabla player has their own style of playing and different attitude of play. They are from two completely different Ghana’s with different styles of playing and they are here to display their art and talent to all of us and if people are just going to argue about who’s better, what is the point of the show. So just enjoy the show and enjoy the talent of Both of the Tabla players......
I often visit this just to watch Pt. Kumar Bose improvise and to see the reaction of Pt. Anindo Chattargee at a particular point... 14:29
Though it is a bit disturbing to see Pt. Kumar Bose struggle with the sound system, to improvise real-time, something like he did at 14:29 is quite impressive!
Kumar Bose ji kya baat very good
Dear Brothers, pls do not argue or abuse each other, we should be proud of the fact that both the stalwarts are of this land playing equally so well AT PAR. we can compare only if they belongs to same Gharana, but it differs. so just enjoy the essence of Gharanas ,
Wah kya baate hai is desh ke ye dono vidwanon tabla marstros hain jinki ulug alug rythmic play styles hai aur dono most appreciables aur most regarded marstros hain sir dono ko is bunde ka pranam aur hestty wishes to add more n more glories.... Dev pc. Knp
Would love to see Pt Swapan Chaudhuri and Pt Anindo Chatterjee together. Dont know why hasnt this happened yet..
Mr. Kumar B lefthanded people r special humans ! You're a good tablaplayer.
Kumar Bose ji and Anindo ji are both amazing tabla players. and no, kumar ji is not struggling, that's the way he plays. Even his guru Pt. Kishan Maharaj had simmilar style.
Those people here saying Anindo ji is better than Kumar Bose, it's maybe just because you like the farukhabad style over the banaras style. That's possible. Both are very different styles.
Saying one of them is better than other is disrespectful to both. Who are we to compare them, when Anindo ji himself says "this is not a competetion. it is improvisation"
Both of them and Swapan Chaudhuri and Zakir Hussain are all legendary maestros.
Anindo ji comes from Lucknow Gharana, not Farukhabad. He received only basic training from there and then went to Ustad Afaque Husain Khan sahab of Lucknow
SIDDHARTH THATTE y always lol
SIDDHARTH THATTE
Don,t tell like this you are not the judge of both the ustad,s
Abhilaksh Verma no. he is from Farukkhabad gharana, disciple of legendary Pt. Gyan Prakash Ghosh. He learnt from Lucknow ustaad from Ustaad Afaque Hussain Khan, and Ajrada kaidas from Ustaads of the gharana.Sorry, I don't remember the names. He has mastered those gharanas.But he is a gandha bandh shagird of Farukkhabad legend Pt. Gyan Prakash Ghosh who was a disciple of Ustaaf Masit Khan-father of the legend ustaad Keramatullah Khan saheb.
Aha ..ishwar achen guruji apnar modhei achen..
lol, freakin cyber tabla warfare going on here.. so many cyber tabla guru`s
Dear all tabla lovers..I have attended several concerts starting from Ahmad Jan Thirakhava saheb to the current generation and recieved the joy of hearing. I think that each person has his own style of presentation depending on his physical strength and riyaz irrespective of an d addition to talim of Gharana. It's a vast ocean. We have to pick up the jewels. Be Happy .
Oh my God! Thirakhava Khan Saheb! What was that like?
both are great ...alag alag style hai👌👌 compare nhi krna chahiye
Why not, both are good, but different and there's nothing wrong with that. One person may prefer vanilla icecream and another chocolate icecream, yet both are good, it's all about preferences
Anindo is the Man ! When it's all said and done, he is the top of the Tabla pyramid cos his playing is so perfect.
dont judge both because both are lions of tabla ..........my guruji pt Anindo ji and kumar ji are kings of tabla.........rest all leave....
Kumar bose my favorite
both are equally amazing. ....stop comparing guys. ....they both are fabulous in their styles .....so we should not compare them 👌👌👌👌
KUMAR - it is a GOD!!!!!!
Anindo is the real Master. He's the guy you would want to aspire to. true Tabla perfection.
Both are great. Pt. Kumar Bose is a great composer like his father Pt.Biswanath Bose. Looking Kumar Bose performing from front is mind blowing. We experienced this as I was a student of Guruji Pt. Kumar Bose.
Bahot Tapasya ki dononey , Really Amazing. .
Incidentally I was acompanists on lahara for Shri. Narayan Joshi at Dombiwali concert on 14th August 1969. He was desciple of Ustad Ahamadjan Thirakhawa.
Awsm superb 👌👌👌
Sound oprater ko बिरयानी खिलायी की नही
Two Greatest Tabla Master Of Century 💜💛💚💙
@Joe Brooks spammer
My fevourite is kumar bose
बाकी इस कुमार अनिन्दो के व्हिडीओ में आकर झाकीर की प्रशंसा करनेवाले वही लोग है जो कपडे की दुकान में जाकर आटा मांगते है। 🤣
For fuck's sake, stop judging Kumar Ji. He's equally good as Anindo Ji here. That's why both of them gave an ecstatic performance. This is a once in lifetime performance, and so enjoy it. Best of Benaras and Farukhabad gharana!
Jagdish Singh you are right bro
Akdom sahi..
You are right
anindo sir best tabla player
Kisi ki koi aukaat nhi hai ki hum in legend ko judge kr shake 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Excellent duo!!! 😊🙏
are pahile unke jaise bajana sikho then u should compare💕💕😍👑
Wa g wa khan shab
just try to notice the crowd appreciation when kumarji plays the tabla....
Both have different styles of excellent nikas..oao amazing
Pt. Anindo Chatterjee great.
Just love kumar bose
Andindo chattergee sir looking very humble 👍
Anindoji and Kumarji both are our ideal. Pranam..
Its Amazing panditjiiiiii
pranams..💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
O my god kumar bose is very very best
2 legends....full stop...
Excellent amazing
Just enjoying the video🙏🙏🙏🙏 thank u god for this two legends ❤️❤️
they look like true master of the instruments. Masters - live long for the children of this world music family.
Sun always shine. Excellent performance.
Anindo Chatterjee is a good tabla vadak and a good tabla teacher
It's all about sound engineering .....
some people are stupid, if not, they are trying to be one by comparing legends, by saying Kumar ji is struggling, by saying Anindyo ji is best,
and, I found someone saying both of them are good , but Zakir is the best.
please, stop. There is no one 'best' in the field of music.
We should not compare and demean legends. They have definitely mastered the tabla and that is why they are here today. Apart from that, they have their own style too. So, let's learn from these video and stop comparing.
Still you have doubt, watch other videos of those masters on UA-cam.
You may have ur own point of view on who is better, but please do ur research more ( it will never going to be finished in this life though) and don't write down ur conclusion here, you will look like a kid from elementary school.
Thanks.
The ones who are comparing the 2 people in the video....pls make sure you are better than them b4 you ever try to judge!!
+B Hazra...what do u mean by "If it was other round"..??
Also, have you all checked other videos of Pt. Kumar Bose ji and Pt. Anindo ji? The styles are completely different.."Bols are similar in all gharanas, to some extent even the nikaas is similar...but sound production and presentation is different...Khula baaj has a very rich sound texture..whereas farrukkhabad has more of a softer tone with complex kayadas"..It is difficult to produce such sound textures..and perform complex kayadas..
Introducing the harmonium and Sarangi players on the stage was also necessary!
In music u cant say that he is better or he is better,if u have sense of music....u will understand....duet is not a competition...it is an improvisation
Amazing...mind blowing,...
best combo ,😻💞
Anindo ji nice.... but kumar ji playing like pandit kishan maharaj
Unke hi jo guru hai😊
Two totally Different schools and styles of Tabla playing . One should Learn to appreciate both
no need to say that Kumar is struggling both r playing equally
I dont think so - as other's have noted his body language betray's his inner state and hence his performance is inferior to that of ANINDO
Awesome performance by Kumarji and Anindoji.regards. 🙏
Subtle Ustad Sheikh Dawood tribute by Anindoji at 27:33! ( Hint : Tete Kata Gadhigene )
Sounds Wale ne wat laga di
Both are great tabal
aanando bhai subahnallah aap jsa daya baya to bohat mushkil he kece ka bole allah aap ko bohat ache sehat de
Which tirkit rela kumarji is playing can anyone tell?
wha Maza aay gaya
Anindo sir you are the best
Why are these always together? I'd like to see anindo and Hussain
Dear friends: The Baz and the Nikas are the two ingredients which make Tabla play most interesting which was explained by Ustad Ahamad Jan Thirakhawa saheb and his disciple Mr. Narayanrao Joshi. The videos of both of them are available. Pl
Visit them and get satisfied.
Very nice amazing performance
Superb
Their internal rivalry is visible. The fact is these masters have some prejudices about each other's gharana's. I've watched bith of these master's live interview with Arvind Parikh sahab. In first interview of Anindo where he criticized badly unconsciously about Banaras gharana style by making comment like Banaras people पिट के बजाते है। so, the particular piece in Tabla may not sound good. When Kumar Bose came he replied to Anindo's remark over Banaras style. May be this program happened before my instances. But their rivalry seems to be since old times.
Anindo! Any day! Farukhabad gharana en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anindo_Chatterjee
🙏🙏🙏
Super duper
🙏🙏🙏💐💐💐
🙏🙏
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Ki sadhana!!!
anindo and zakir Hussain both of them is geat butt anindo chattarji is old then the zakir Husain
himanshu nayak get some information before giving such info. Zakir Hussain is older than Anindo Chatterjee
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
super
Don't compare farukhabad with banaras style both are from different gharanas
anindo chatterji and zakir Husain both of them is geat butt anindo chattarji is old then the zakir Husain
himanshu nayak a
next program please dha tere kete dhe tete gene dha ti ghena Tina kena
supar
Anindo is Tabla perfection !
anindo and zakir Hussain Aoth of them is geat butt anindo chattarji is old then the zakir Hussain
+himanshu nayak zakir is older...
Kumar boss g ka sur ziada bolta hai Pt Anindo g sa
Very nice
tabla strength and variety.. guruji way better than anindo chatterjee. those who are judging, if u know tabla who plays better,.. dats his style of playing, look up any of his videos.. i sat beside him and learned from him directly . so i know.
Vedant singh you are wrong kumar bose brillent than zakir hussain
Hey Zakir Hussain is very
Pt. Anindo Chatterjee Is God Of Tabla