That was a screeching disaster. Katie is very good but needs to learn when to make her voice sound "haunting" and when not to. With proper guidance, I think she would be amazing. She's got the voice.
Sarah won because she's 31 and Jessie felt like it's her last chance whereas Katie she said has more opportunities as she is much younger. But Katie should've won.
Sarah is good but her voice is too similar to every other female singers out there. Katie is also good and she brings something new into the mix. - I choose u Pikachu
I completely understand that Sarah was trying to show off her high note, but I think the note at 1:45 was a bit like she had something lodged in her throat. I would have chosen Katie purely cause she sang better. Also I don't get the song choice at all, it doesn't suit either of them and it's not something either of them would sing. I mean Katie sang Feeling Good at her audition and Sarah sang Ain't no mountain high enough at the knockouts
StuffForFun2 Sarah is a much better singer than Katie, I can see that Sarah's voice cracked, but all her other notes were so much better than Katie's, and not to forget, Sarah was already a professional singer before she came on the show :)
0:38 c'mon, Katie surely has one the most beautiful voice that I've ever heard... however, she's using it really BAD. Stop that vibrato, all these effects. Just sing NATURALLY. I have the feelings that she had learnt nothing with Jessie, when Jessie is a really good singer with one of the strongest voice. Of course, Sarah won it. Even though her voice is not as good as Katie's one.
Bastian Larsen im soo mad bc that crazy chicken voice of sarah ruined everything and jessie didnt hear that,she would win if she did. Shit my headphones died on this dying cat sarah
Negativo, sou professor de canto lírico e te digo que Kate não desafinou... Ela manteve o controle e mostrou sua verdadeira voz ... Uma voz totalmente diferente, ela foi até f5.
Honestly, I thought Sarah would completely smash this battle, but wtf Katie completely shocked me, she fought back so well this was a very good battle and both could've easily taken the win.
I have a big problem with their tone because is not very pleasant, unfortunately. Their tone should be more round so the notes are more pleasant to listen to. Vocally Kaite was best. Range Sarah, amazing range but too powerful
its been 8 years and i cant believe this is still on youtube. I have never heard a worse noise. The whole thing is horrendous and gets worse and worse as the screeching and whining goes on. This is the opposite of music. I cant believe it was ever aired. absolutely shocking. they nearly destroyed music in 2 mins! both should be eternally ashamed of how excruciatingly painful this is to sit through.
haters... Both of these girls are phenomenal . It a Battle for a reason, its not for the purposes of making music people will listen to, its. To how the vocal ability of each contestant, and that song did not allow either contestants to that to the best do their ability... If thats these girls at thee worst and restricted by song choice imagine them at their best.. Listen to some of the technique being shown in this performance, immense... You don't see many stars singing llive like that!
I cant believe some of the comments about Sarah .... She raised her game and as it was a battle i think she won by a mile and showed her vocal ability outclassing Katie.....The other judges did not steal Katie for a reason... and Jessie picked her for a reason ....I think she could be in with a great chance of winning the voice and seems so down to earth ... give her a chance i say
one thing i noticed.... obviously sarah has a clearer, more poppy voice. When she hits high notes, (1:44) she does it typically. she jumps straight to the note and just screams it. Katie, on the other hand, even though her voice isnt suited for screaming, glides into the note, (1:48-1:54) touching every one before it. theres something magical about katie's approach that just adds to her interpretation.
Vocally Sarah has it all but in this performance she was way off, she needs to control it, I think jessie probably done a great job coaching them but I think they ignored jessie and tried to out do each other...
O.K. people! Hold up! Katie had a different voice and it's very interesting, she's really fun to watch and listen to. But Sarah had a pretty amazing voice on her own. Give her some credit. Jessie made a desicion she thought was best at the moment, show some respect!
I agree Sarah screamed it...and you could hear her screaming it. Katie sang with much more control and then that note didn't feel strained. She sang with so much more passion too. Unbelievable Jessie...
Every battle is terrible. It's such an awful way to let someone through. They never sound good at all. Two complete strangers who have totally different style
Tom Jones: What the fuck was that?
Jessie: I don't know what's going on
Jessie shoudn't let Katie go, her voice is extraordinary. I've got goosebumps when she hit that high note on 1:49
Katie's voice is awesomeeeee
I said exactly the same 5 years ago... Katie should’ve win this battle.
Jessie like "I don't have a fucking idea what's happening right now"
Thank you to everyone who has been behind katie she was amazing and i am the proudest mummy ever right now
it's been 8 years and I still haven't gotten over katie having lost this battle
THE SAME HERE
Lol me tio
Still disappointed until now
TRUEEE
are y'all tone deaf or just delusional? cause she literally was off key throughout the entire performance lmao
katie won this battle 3747483992 times
I think they're both overdoing it.
its called a battle
I LOVE KATIE VOICE, SHE SHOULD HAVE AN ALBUM LIKE LANA DEL REY´S MUSIC ♥
don'T!
Yasdd
I would absolutely buy Katie Benbow album... It's a pity.
Katie should've won, just saying
Katie should've won...
I still watch this every now and then! And keep confirming that this is the only time I disagree with Jessie! COME ON KATIE WAS SO SO MUCH BETTER:)!
THAT SCREAM WAS NOT NECESSARY SARAH ! AND KATIE WAS BETTER !
FaHaD Oqlah my headphones died on that part🙄🙄
oh my sarah's 1:45 is PAINFUL compared to katie's gorgeous 1:48!
1:45 when you call the Pterodactylus
That was a screeching disaster. Katie is very good but needs to learn when to make her voice sound "haunting" and when not to. With proper guidance, I think she would be amazing. She's got the voice.
Sarah was screeching more than Katie especially at 1:45
Zubat! Use Screech! 1:45
2:09 zubat!use screech again....It was super effective I feel like my ears are bleeding
Sarah won because she's 31 and Jessie felt like it's her last chance whereas Katie she said has more opportunities as she is much younger. But Katie should've won.
2020 and I am still angry because Katie should have won ....
Play this video at 1:39 , 1:55, and 2:03.... that's how I feel about this!
That was horrible and seriously i had to take off my headphones at 1:44 and 2:09
Katie unique sarah ... Should be in a group her voice doesn't have enough versatility for solo shed get one or two songs then people would get bored
Katie sung way better here than her audition
Katie is awesome.
OMG KATIE SHOUND HAVE WON!!! AMAZING VOICE!!!!
2021, who's still watching this?
When Sarah sang her high notes I must say I got goose bombs, but the rest was just annoying... Katie's voice is so much better!
01:48 Katie.. i love it
Jesus Bravo jessie didn hear that bc of this chicken damn
Sarah sound like a screechy cat. Katie has such a beautifully haunting tone. It should have been a no brainer..
Katie was my favorite in the whole competition . Even from the first season . Her voice is so damn special . She is a class act
Sarah is good but her voice is too similar to every other female singers out there. Katie is also good and she brings something new into the mix. - I choose u Pikachu
Katie is a genius, Sarah's screams fucked up all.
the way Katie was even able to manipulate different tones at 2:01 on one word was gorgeous
RIGHT?! the way she sang the word "foreign" is perfect.
I completely understand that Sarah was trying to show off her high note, but I think the note at 1:45 was a bit like she had something lodged in her throat. I would have chosen Katie purely cause she sang better. Also I don't get the song choice at all, it doesn't suit either of them and it's not something either of them would sing. I mean Katie sang Feeling Good at her audition and Sarah sang Ain't no mountain high enough at the knockouts
I love Katie, but I still think this song was a bad choice for both of them. Jessie has a good voice, but made a terrible coach.
It was not a bad song choice and jessie j is not a terrible coach
Katie is better than Sarah!! :)
Ur opinion
sounds like goats dying :/
LMAO 😂😂😂
Kind of true
OMG I'M LAUGHING SO HARD !!! HELP ME ! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
10 years and I can’t believe Jessie J let Katie go!
That pterodactyl scream at 1:44 though
Underrated comment!
The most hysterical audition I've ever heard!
I love this so much. Katie was doing some weird shit in the beginning but overall incredible. :)
this entire performance is just painful oh god
It was just completely tragic
Sarah is my family 😙😚😙😚
katie was so much better than sarah.
I ALWAYS COME BACK TO THIS WHEN I WANNA LAUGH
Sarah's 1:44 compared to Katie's 1:48....
that's exactly what I was thinking.
yes i agree with you katie´s voice is better than sarah
StuffForFun2 Sarah is a much better singer than Katie, I can see that Sarah's voice cracked, but all her other notes were so much better than Katie's, and not to forget, Sarah was already a professional singer before she came on the show :)
Lasse Petersen With that in mind Sarah was so insanely bad, you just gave us another reason to favour Katie. Rofl
sarah was great that wasn't a crack that was planned
0:38 c'mon, Katie surely has one the most beautiful voice that I've ever heard... however, she's using it really BAD. Stop that vibrato, all these effects. Just sing NATURALLY. I have the feelings that she had learnt nothing with Jessie, when Jessie is a really good singer with one of the strongest voice. Of course, Sarah won it. Even though her voice is not as good as Katie's one.
1:48 Flawless. Pure talent.
I loved them both. Cant believe they had to battle each other
Katie's voice is phenomenal!!!!
2:03 i'm dead
1:48
2:02 Katie Benbow gives me goosebumps
Bastian Larsen im soo mad bc that crazy chicken voice of sarah ruined everything and jessie didnt hear that,she would win if she did. Shit my headphones died on this dying cat sarah
@@natalieiynemli6170 lmao 😂😂😂
This is the best battle on all the shows so far.
you guys dont know how hard it is to hit that note that sarah hit at the end! it wasnt off..it was brilliant
Negativo, sou professor de canto lírico e te digo que Kate não desafinou... Ela manteve o controle e mostrou sua verdadeira voz ... Uma voz totalmente diferente, ela foi até f5.
Honestly, I thought Sarah would completely smash this battle, but wtf Katie completely shocked me, she fought back so well this was a very good battle and both could've easily taken the win.
Tom looks scared, Jessie hopeless :) 1:53
One of the best bettle. Revised it many times already and still going to also look:)
I need to know what she was doing at @ 1:45
1:48 Katie do the right thing there
Katie is solo much better than Sarah I can't believe Sarah thought that rasp in that one part was good and that screech was so irritating
Sarah is like a Banshee screaming. Yuck
I have a big problem with their tone because is not very pleasant, unfortunately. Their tone should be more round so the notes are more pleasant to listen to.
Vocally Kaite was best.
Range Sarah, amazing range but too powerful
I loved Sarah’s “Let’s Stay Together” but this was a mess. 😟
its been 8 years and i cant believe this is still on youtube. I have never heard a worse noise. The whole thing is horrendous and gets worse and worse as the screeching and whining goes on. This is the opposite of music. I cant believe it was ever aired. absolutely shocking. they nearly destroyed music in 2 mins! both should be eternally ashamed of how excruciatingly painful this is to sit through.
What's wrong with you all ?!? They sing the song very well!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
My favorite battle of all the time of the voice!!!!
I still do not understand why Katie did not win. His voice is so great!
You mean hers dough
haters... Both of these girls are phenomenal . It a Battle for a reason, its not for the purposes of making music people will listen to, its. To how the vocal ability of each contestant, and that song did not allow either contestants to that to the best do their ability... If thats these girls at thee worst and restricted by song choice imagine them at their best.. Listen to some of the technique being shown in this performance, immense... You don't see many stars singing llive like that!
Sarah is amazing!! Totally deserves her place on The Voice!
Even with the note at 1:45 when she sounds like a dying cat
Should've picked Kate, DEFINITELY!!!
Sarah got lost in the moment here, but she's still amazing! Glad we get to see more of her.
i dont know what happended to Jessie for having choosen sarah when katie was better , katie ´s voice was more powerful that sarah´s
what the fuck was that.
Were I Can Find This Battle Full ?
Katie si the best!
I cant believe some of the comments about Sarah .... She raised her game and as it was a battle i think she won by a mile and showed her vocal ability outclassing Katie.....The other judges did not steal Katie for a reason... and Jessie picked her for a reason ....I think she could be in with a great chance of winning the voice and seems so down to earth ... give her a chance i say
I actually liked the screech lol
i love this version
1:45 its so amazing that somebody can sound that awful. Nails on a chalkboard...
Tone deaf....
one thing i noticed.... obviously sarah has a clearer, more poppy voice. When she hits high notes, (1:44) she does it typically. she jumps straight to the note and just screams it. Katie, on the other hand, even though her voice isnt suited for screaming, glides into the note, (1:48-1:54) touching every one before it. theres something magical about katie's approach that just adds to her interpretation.
Katie just looks unhappy.
Vocally Sarah has it all but in this performance she was way off, she needs to control it, I think jessie probably done a great job coaching them but I think they ignored jessie and tried to out do each other...
I'm sure both of their voices sound great but with that song they sound like two seals having a fight. Horrible!!
O.K. people! Hold up! Katie had a different voice and it's very interesting, she's really fun to watch and listen to. But Sarah had a pretty amazing voice on her own. Give her some credit. Jessie made a desicion she thought was best at the moment, show some respect!
Awful song choice...
I agree Sarah screamed it...and you could hear her screaming it. Katie sang with much more control and then that note didn't feel strained. She sang with so much more passion too. Unbelievable Jessie...
aaaah, i say this this battle was the worst of all
Every battle is terrible. It's such an awful way to let someone through. They never sound good at all. Two complete strangers who have totally different style
+Denny Kaleal the only good battle was last year Malik & Bryan. It was amazing.
Who thinks they saw Jade West/Liz Gillies’?
KATIE ♥
i dont think sarah was bad but they both have unique voices.............watch sarahs audition its amazing
katie
OMG, they would be an amazing duo!
I love Sarah C:
I keep listening to this, because of the band. Great back-up band to be fair.
Awful.
ummmm.... what the hell happened at 1:45 ? It scared the crap out of me
I like this version !
you won the internet today for me :D
1:44 oh my godness is someone freaking killing her
both are so good