Harry hated that people sacrificed themselves for him and the cause. However he knew that without them fighting along side him, they would never have won. If Dobby didn't save Harry, then Harry would have died in Malfoy manor. Story over. Voldemort wins and the world turns to darkness.
I read somewhere the portraits weren't actually the people who died, merely moving pictures the Headmasters could teach to behave like them. Not sure where I read it though.
@j-bob_oreo Fred didn’t move out.. he had a tragic death in the battle of Hogwarts.. George (his twin) was never able to cast a patronus after his death.. nobody wanted fred to die. So yeah,
Dobby had no choice. Harry was his only friend. He still referred to Ron as master Weasley clearly he did not consider Ron a friend, and he said he came back to save Harry Potter and his friends. This grammatically shows the ownership of the friends as being Harry potter's, notice not Dobbys. And in his death scene in film he tells Harry Potter is a good place to be with friends looking over at the group, and then he says he is glad to be there with Harry Potter, again denoting his only friend.
The one with Molly sounds so plausible. I could, also, see George telling to to keep the setting there if she ever tried to stop or clear it away . One of the insights I saw about Molly was when she was trying to get rid of the Boggart and it kept showing all her family members dead, it showed both twins dead. Because in Molly Weasley's worst fears and nightmares she could never imagine the twins being separated.
It doesn't sound plausible. Every night the woman passes out and sets a plate for her lost son? How is that even possible? I know magic is a thing in that world, but an unconscious body isn't setting the table.
@@Saimerenno but muscle memory is a thing and setting the table is such a common daily task that Molly would likely do it on autopilot and since she isn't really thinking about her actions would accidental set out an extra plate simply out of habit
@@Angelwitch99The comment was about the fact that he used the word unconscious, not subconscious. As in "Molly would pass out in the kitchen and then her limp unconscious body would set a plate for her son." Not "She would SUBCONSCIOUSLY set a place for her son.
Dobby’s death was so profound for several reasons… He was one of the few truly, purely good characters in the story. There is no doubt that if Dobby knew that going to save those people, whom he dearly loved, was going to cost him his life, he would have gone anyway. Such was his goodness and his love for them. Such was his bravery. Dobby was powerful enough that if Harry had asked him to help fight the Death Eaters, he would have done so, and would likely have defeated them, even Bellatrix LeStrange. He has halted Lucius Malfoy’s attack on Harry, years before, as if it were nothing. But Harry had asked for a rescue mission. And Dobby obliged. Headcannon: Bill and Fleur owned Shell Cottage as long as they lived and it stayed in the family in perpetuity. The little plot of soil where Harry had buried Dobby was constantly covered in the most vibrant wildflowers. They were there year round. Nobody planted them, Fleur has asked everyone. But they continue to grow there. Bill would occasionally see garden gnomes in the yard, but they never disturbed anything they grew out there. In fact, he had once told Ginny that the only thing he’d ever seen the garden gnomes do…was clean Dobby’s headstone.
Personal Headcannon: Harry had memorized the names of every single person who died at the Battle Of Hogwarts and each year he thanks them for their sacrifice.
In the Harry Potter universe you have a choice when you die. Either remain as a ghost and wander the Earth forever or move on and see what's waiting on the other side. Being a ghost in the Harry Potter universe is kind of like being in a limbo but when you choose it you can't change your mind.
@@callanightshade8079 I think thr only one who would possibly remain would be Snape. My head-cannon on that would be because he couldn't bear to face Lily in the afterlife. And have to answer to her why he treated her son like he did.
I mean technically that hogwarts awakened game tells us what happens after the books are done and it’s pretty good Really cool seeing people like Neville working in herbology class as a teacher
I seem to remember a family dinner that included Charlie and Bill long after they moved out, so why exactly would she have not been setting a place for them if Fred hadn’t died?
Yeah but Dobby was under instructions from Dumbledore when he got hired, and that leadership was passed to Aberforth when Albus died. Dobby is such an underrated hero and did what he wanted to do the whole time, save Harry and defeat Voldemort
If you think about it, in a way, Voldemort won. Voldemort managed to hurt and kill so many people that he traumatized the wizarding world possibly for generations. I can see that the wizarding world will have trust issues with Slytherins even more now, maybe Albus Potter would be bullied for becoming a Slytherin. Slytherins would be seen as the equivalent of the “Yatzis” and probably anyone who wants to be a Slytherin would be seen as a possible Voldemort supporter or fanatic and they would be rejected by the wizarding world. There would be no unity in this wizarding world which is EXACTLY what Voldemort wanted
Yeah since Hedwig was just a dumb owl her death means Jack crap to Harry his friends and the person that makes these damn videos! I hate that Joan Rollins killed her off in the book series and that they killed her off in the movie! She was the one who was there for Harry the most and the longest and she had to suffer worse than him and she got nothing good to show for it!😠😡😚🤬👿👺
Not to be insulting, but McGonagle attacking Snape, he had it coming for mentally and physically abusing students and allowing mentally and physical abuse from his Slytherin
Harry hated that people sacrificed themselves for him and the cause. However he knew that without them fighting along side him, they would never have won. If Dobby didn't save Harry, then Harry would have died in Malfoy manor. Story over. Voldemort wins and the world turns to darkness.
Voldy needs kill harry twice in malfoy manor because of horcrux inside harry
@@krisztiandavid9984Good job. You watched the movies, or read the books.
I don't see how that has anything to do with my comment.
@@Saimerenget butt hurt much lol? Jeez bro chill out
The one about Snape and McGonagle is so sad I love both of them so much
Me too ❤️
@@mugglemagic_hp but she can talk with his portrait.
@@MsSoplaThe portraits have limits. They aren't a good substitute.
@@alexharkness586 harry could talk with Dumbledore portrait so i don't know where you heard about this limits.
I read somewhere the portraits weren't actually the people who died, merely moving pictures the Headmasters could teach to behave like them. Not sure where I read it though.
The one about Snape and McGonagall and the one about Fred are so sad 😢
Agree 🥹🤝
why is she setting places for someone who moved out years before ?
@j-bob_oreo
Fred didn’t move out.. he had a tragic death in the battle of Hogwarts.. George (his twin) was never able to cast a patronus after his death.. nobody wanted fred to die. So yeah,
@@ruchivats3383 Actually, Fred and George moved out in the sixth book to open a joke shop
@@emma_excellsr u autistic then Fred died?
With The dobby one, if anyone else got hit with the knife, Dobby would most likely beat himself everyday for letting someone die.
Anyone else could probably have survived it :/ Making his death even sadder honestly
Fred and dobby were definitely the saddest deaths. Dobby was so innocent, and Fred was so young
Of ALL the characters, besides his parent's, Dobby cared more for Harry than Anyone else
What abt Rons parents
Dobby did what he thought was right by harry after all the chosen one did find a loophole for dobbys freedom
The McGonagall and snape one hits me so hard
Yoda is looking a bit pale.
It was so hard to create him🙈🫣
Dobby had no choice. Harry was his only friend.
He still referred to Ron as master Weasley clearly he did not consider Ron a friend, and he said he came back to save Harry Potter and his friends. This grammatically shows the ownership of the friends as being Harry potter's, notice not Dobbys.
And in his death scene in film he tells Harry Potter is a good place to be with friends looking over at the group, and then he says he is glad to be there with Harry Potter, again denoting his only friend.
This made me cry man i loooove harry potter
Seamus never did firemagic, it was just a running joke in the movies that he commonly made this mistake
I get what you mean tho
Had Dobby not saved Harry that final time, Harry, Ron and Hermoine would’ve died
Yep!
I actually cried on the one about Fred.... 😢
Sorry 🥺❤️
What kind of friend will Dobby be , if he keep that ridiculous promise .
The one with Molly sounds so plausible. I could, also, see George telling to to keep the setting there if she ever tried to stop or clear it away .
One of the insights I saw about Molly was when she was trying to get rid of the Boggart and it kept showing all her family members dead, it showed both twins dead. Because in Molly Weasley's worst fears and nightmares she could never imagine the twins being separated.
thats so sad😢
It doesn't sound plausible. Every night the woman passes out and sets a plate for her lost son? How is that even possible? I know magic is a thing in that world, but an unconscious body isn't setting the table.
@@Saimerenno but muscle memory is a thing and setting the table is such a common daily task that Molly would likely do it on autopilot and since she isn't really thinking about her actions would accidental set out an extra plate simply out of habit
@@Angelwitch99The comment was about the fact that he used the word unconscious, not subconscious.
As in "Molly would pass out in the kitchen and then her limp unconscious body would set a plate for her son."
Not "She would SUBCONSCIOUSLY set a place for her son.
@@Saimeren unconscious and subconscious are often used interchangeably in this context there is literally nothing wrong with how he spoke
Dobby’s death was so profound for several reasons…
He was one of the few truly, purely good characters in the story.
There is no doubt that if Dobby knew that going to save those people, whom he dearly loved, was going to cost him his life, he would have gone anyway. Such was his goodness and his love for them. Such was his bravery.
Dobby was powerful enough that if Harry had asked him to help fight the Death Eaters, he would have done so, and would likely have defeated them, even Bellatrix LeStrange. He has halted Lucius Malfoy’s attack on Harry, years before, as if it were nothing. But Harry had asked for a rescue mission.
And Dobby obliged.
Headcannon:
Bill and Fleur owned Shell Cottage as long as they lived and it stayed in the family in perpetuity.
The little plot of soil where Harry had buried Dobby was constantly covered in the most vibrant wildflowers. They were there year round. Nobody planted them, Fleur has asked everyone. But they continue to grow there. Bill would occasionally see garden gnomes in the yard, but they never disturbed anything they grew out there. In fact, he had once told Ginny that the only thing he’d ever seen the garden gnomes do…was clean Dobby’s headstone.
"Dobby will always come for Harry Potter"
When Dobby got to the after life he found hedwig waiting. Dobby said "Dobby is happy to have a new friend."
Personal Headcannon: Harry had memorized the names of every single person who died at the Battle Of Hogwarts and each year he thanks them for their sacrifice.
This is so sad
I agree🤝
Dobby loved Harry unconditionally
This made me cry....
😮💨
You broke my heart❤😢 but lol i am here watching ur vidios instead of studying for ny exam
Thank you ❤️
The thing that hurts more is that even though Harry tried to get Dobby to promise him that, Dobby never did agree. 😢
That is so sad! All of those head cannons are so sad! Now i'm being mentally tormented.
Sorry, good thats only hesdcanons 😇❤️
I'm crying right now 😢
Sorry 🥹❤️
Wait what happens to Fred's clockhand? I just thought about this now
It fell off ang george wore it asa necklace
i cried watching this 😭😭
The one about Fred made me cry😢
Dobby is my favorite carektor 😭❤️❤️
I had a crush on Fred❤
❤️❤️
Literally 😭😭😭😭
I'm sad that dobby died he was my favorite Dowsett elf. I miss him. I can’t live without him.
I agree 🤝
Bro I’m crying just hearing about this😢😢😢
That’s so sad 😞.
Make it make sense for everyone that died in the battle of Hogwarts wouldn’t they? Ghost remain in Hogwarts just like the other ghost
99% percent of people who die choose not to return as ghosts. Otherwise the school would be way overpopulated with them.
In the Harry Potter universe you have a choice when you die. Either remain as a ghost and wander the Earth forever or move on and see what's waiting on the other side.
Being a ghost in the Harry Potter universe is kind of like being in a limbo but when you choose it you can't change your mind.
@@callanightshade8079 I think thr only one who would possibly remain would be Snape. My head-cannon on that would be because he couldn't bear to face Lily in the afterlife. And have to answer to her why he treated her son like he did.
since fred died at Hogwarts, wouldn't that mean his ghost now inhabits the halls of that school?
How do you know this head cannot see head canons are not even in the book
Fan Theory 😇🤝
Thats what head-cannons are lol
I mean technically that hogwarts awakened game tells us what happens after the books are done and it’s pretty good
Really cool seeing people like Neville working in herbology class as a teacher
Actually most people who lost their lives in the wizard world was because of trying to save or protect Harry.
Damn. Talk about depressing stories.
Fred and George had already moved out, she wouldn't be setting a place for either of them.
I seem to remember a family dinner that included Charlie and Bill long after they moved out, so why exactly would she have not been setting a place for them if Fred hadn’t died?
She would goerge came to live back atvthe burrow
Why you gotta do this to me! 😢
Sorry 🥹❤️
The one with Dobby kills me. He shouldn’t have died. ❤
…Umbridge should’ve died instead 😈
Yeah but Dobby was under instructions from Dumbledore when he got hired, and that leadership was passed to Aberforth when Albus died. Dobby is such an underrated hero and did what he wanted to do the whole time, save Harry and defeat Voldemort
But actually in the book, JK Rowling didn't write about Dobby promising Harry not to save him
Then Harry Ron an Hermione would be dead if dobby listened to Harry an that would be the end
😢😢😢😢😢😢 sigh
Snape became a portrait so actually the McGonagoll one isn’t true
Where do you get this infos from?
Internet but i search very Long for all 🤯
yeah but Harry would then be dead and Voldemort would be killing and torturing others indiscriminately. Dobby gladly gave his life for his friend
If you think about it, in a way, Voldemort won. Voldemort managed to hurt and kill so many people that he traumatized the wizarding world possibly for generations. I can see that the wizarding world will have trust issues with Slytherins even more now, maybe Albus Potter would be bullied for becoming a Slytherin. Slytherins would be seen as the equivalent of the “Yatzis” and probably anyone who wants to be a Slytherin would be seen as a possible Voldemort supporter or fanatic and they would be rejected by the wizarding world. There would be no unity in this wizarding world which is EXACTLY what Voldemort wanted
Wait Seamus had friends besides Neville
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
🙈❤️
Is this Canon? I whant to know the source for read it😊
No, they’re headcanons
Source?
I hate Dobby 😂😂
Ik a bunch of ppl are gonna come at me for this but it’s just my opinion 💚💚
Fallen professors is only 3 really
Are these real?
Unconsciously or subconsciously?
Because those are two very different things.
Nope.
Doby is still here. He changed his name to Alina Haba and works for Donald Trump.
Haha nice 🤣
Where is this said? Is this made up because JK didnt make a book for these head cannons. Unless it’s in Deathly Hallows.
"Head canons" does mean made up. Edit: it's in fans heads, hence the name. :)
they didnt hire new professors ? whybis she setting places for someone who moved out years ago ... this is crap
Yeah since Hedwig was just a dumb owl her death means Jack crap to Harry his friends and the person that makes these damn videos! I hate that Joan Rollins killed her off in the book series and that they killed her off in the movie! She was the one who was there for Harry the most and the longest and she had to suffer worse than him and she got nothing good to show for it!😠😡😚🤬👿👺
You wrong not based on evidence
Not to be insulting, but McGonagle attacking Snape, he had it coming for mentally and physically abusing students and allowing mentally and physical abuse from his Slytherin
Useless
sick of this voice in videos