Nah, for real, if I worked on that ship, it's martial law at that point. Fuck my "job duties", I'm not policing drunk, angry, hungry and filthy passengers lmao. Just throw me over board.
@@laptopdroptop9457 Which is exactly why it's worse. If you're going to be in a terrible situation, do you want no obligations, or a whole list of obligations on top of every other complicated factor? Especially when, as someone pointed out, your pay is extremely minimal because they factor part of your "pay" as the food and living quarters, which were what were affected.
The fact that they apparently thought "people cannot use the bathrooms & are getting ornery" would be a good environment to offer an open bar is astonishing. At minimum, you're gonna need more bags.
It's a classic case of "Let them eat cake" ignorance, you've got 3k people crammed onto a ship, no A/C, no hot meals and worst no plumping for waste and then someone wants to add alcohol to the mix!? That's like seeing a house fire and instead of hand chucking water buckets they decided to douse it with jet fuel. :p
“We’re low on food” “They can drink their calories at the open bar!” “I don’t think we should give free alcohol to people on empty stomachs” “Nono it’s cool, that’s what the poop bags are for!”
I think it's the urine more than the poop. Urine contains pheremones. When men are around pheremones from unrelated men, it can be a factor increasing their aggression. But yeah, the poop too. 🤮 Plus the added dumb-ass factor when people drink.
Meh, when we were deployed we had snuck in alcohol and wouldn’t get too crazy. Did have to drink in shifts though. All those things for months unless out on a patrol in reference to confined areas.
@@idkjames Without knowing your conditions (which I imagine were probably hell if you were in combat), it sounds pretty organized (setting up drinking shifts), without all the feces and rage among people who had no one to take it out on. Thousands of people, all strangers, everybody full of outrage and constant disgust and a cruise director constantly announcing that everything was ok. I've never seen combat, but my imagination tells me one would have me terrified and bonding with my buddies while the other would have me furious and looking for someone to step up and ask for it. Sorry if I'm speaking out of turn, but that's where my brain goes. Again, it's my imagination. It's a dark, ugly place sometimes.
Yes, they should have just handed out bottled water instead!! There are, actually, worse scenarios! MY BET'S ARE WITH "ALL" COAST GUARD FORCES! COMPARE THIS TO " no survivors" air flights ? Well, you could VIEW " MENTOUR PILOT videos" , to see all of the malfunctions that can occur on air flights! When THEY go down, the whole plane goes down...I'm betting on a cruise advertised AND looking at the stats. (Rick Steves Tours?) EXCELLENT narrator; on a terribly difficult subject matter. RARE GREAT NARRATION ; thanks for not adding over sensationalized music tracks to enhance the tragedy being reported, too. (such as the Mickey Mouse Manipulated Media does!). WELL DONE....and they are definitely DARK "records!" "I Ain't no Middleman!" and "Riverboat Queen" Phil Bowen UK and LyndaFaye
As somebody who's worked in bars for 7 years, the absolute worst thing they could've done is NOT do an open bar when those traumatized who paid the original open bar ticket price are taking drinks all day for free and the other passengers with no drinks are trying not to jump overboard. A food fight from an open bar is probably the best case scenario. I could easily see people getting jumped for their open bar wristbands had they not done it.
@@darkwebgirl right because the extra urine, feces which is often much softer, and vomit that comes with excessive drinking would definitely have helped the situation. Yep.
It's weird though the fact that they're out in the ocean... You can always just pee off the edge and just put the poop in the ocean...it Will biodegrade.. not the best practice but if you have too...
I was just thinking.. imagine how many people had the bubble guts after that open bar and had to aim their diarrhea into those red bags, that cannot have gone well 😅🤢
My sister was on this cruise! She was compensated generously for all of this as she texted in the family group chat about the poop bags. It's definitely a memory she won't forget.
@@dominichowell961 Is it really that bad though? Yes it's warm, probably smells, you only have some cold food and need to poop in bags, but overall the passengers were never in any danger, nor did they run out of toilet paper and they even had an open bar the one day. Obviously it's not the trip you paid for but it was just a few days with some discomfort, nothing that should mentally scar you, especially since it was only for very few days and the passengers knew the main land was informed about their situation and ready to rescue passengers should there be the need (like f.e. with the dialysis woman). Were they stranded in the ocean, cut off or very far away from main land, then that's a situation that might mentally scar you.
@@corex6109 Unless you were on that ship, how would you truly know how they felt? You can project all you want, but no one truly knows how they would feel, what they would do, what they would say, etc., under certain dire circumstances unless they have experienced it firsthand themselves.
@@fjosephgonzales6870 Hahahahahaha! You're funny. Let me recap this for everyone else that might read it: First you say no amount of compensation could get you through that, then I ask if it's really that bad, bringing a few arguments to the table to which the only thing you can say is "how would you know how it was if you weren't on the ship". Did you even realize that with this sentence you're completely destroying every foundation for your previous comment? How would you be able to tell it would break you if you weren't present?
The staff doesn’t appertain to national laws so they basically are on the mercy of the company. It’s likely they didn’t get any compensation for the mistreatment. Cruise staff is straight up slave labor.
I agree, when I heard each customer received 500 dollars, a full refund, paid flight home, and another 4 day cruise credit. I thought, well maybe it wouldn't have been so bad to be there.
I can't imagine the smell on the ship with 4000+ people pooping and peeing and it all just spilling over onto carpets. And that too for multiple days without proper ventilation and light.
To my dismay I have to admit I laughed hard when they took the decision to open the bars. That's like looking a horror film when the victim makes a wrong decision and you know while wanting to scream "NOOOO!".
maybe, just maybe it was one big social experiment. lets do all this stuff to them....then in a bit we'll open the bars so they can drink and get drunk. how high of a degree of pandemonium will ensue?!
I'm sure their heart was in the right place, but plying enraged, exhausted, and vengeful passengers with all the alcohol they could drink is just asking for mayhem.
I'm surprised they had enough red bio-hazard bags for the thousands of passengers over several days. Given those bags are usually only used for blood soaked items, used medical equipment, PPE, etc, it's kind of suspicious they were that well prepared on the bag front
I heard somewhere that a lot of old people book cruises preparing to die or because they know they are dying soon. And that cruise ships have Disney park like security/med staff that can appear out of nowhere and quickly whisk you off to a private cell or med bay.
every life boat, first aid station, storage locker etc have them. I'm actually not that surprised because in terms of emergency gear, it's a pennies item that just gets included in everything.
I love how cheery the lady on the intercom was when she was telling people they'd have to poop in a bag, and pee in the shower. Almost makes it sound fun!
I can't imagine being one of the staff members having to take care of the passengers who are mostly very irritating people to begin with let alone in a situation like this.
Yep, and honestly, I have a lot of respect for the staff when it comes to these cruises. They’re needing a paycheck like anyone else, but instead of being able to go home and kick back, they have to be stuck with their customers on a boat out in the ocean even in their down time. Adding this fiasco on top of what they do … geez, they probably didn’t get paid anywhere near enough to be handling that shit - literally _and_ figuratively.
I can't imagine being one of the staff members having to take care of the poop bags! Best case scenario they're picking up waste baskets with neatly tied bags. I don't want to think about the worst case scenarios.
I went on a cruise a couple times. The staff is always pretty nice, and the females are easy to take back to your cabin (staff included.) Highly recommend cruises if you're single and wanna get laid.
It's bad but those people weren't really in great danger. They were more greatly inconvenienced. The real problem was logistics. If there was someone with a true medical emergency they would have got them off the boat immediately. I see these ladies holding a SOS sign and my eyes roll to the back of my head. "People do this in the movies right? Maybe they'll put us on the news like when we held that sign at the basketball game!"
It would have been less of a nightmare if the ladies had actually stopped using the toilets like they were told - but most of them kept using them despite the instructions. LOL....
@@danip2476 I thought the same thing as i was watching it! lol I would've burned it 😝 But I guess considering everything they gave back in refunds and compensation they figured it was more cost effective to salvage what they could and rebuild on it.
@-western froggy- Yes, tell me about it! They are racist!!! Very racist!!! Their Party has few minorities and the few tokens they have, they elevate them to deceive people into believing that they accept all. Like Trump at his rallies, they pick the ONLY few (lost) Black folk to be sitted right behind him for the television cameras. 😂 😂 They have one token in the Supreme Court that is so damn Corrupt he has ruined the credibility of the the Court, thanks Uncle Thomas!. I could go on and on with them, they are the Party of David Duke! They are also the Party of Timothy McVeigh and White Supremacists!!! You are right, buddy, these guys are racist to the core!!! But very cunning and crafty at covering their tracts and pretending that they aren't!
My moms friend was on that ship, she sadly passed because of Covid-19 in late 2021. However, I recall my moms friend saying that it was a terrible experience and one she would never forget. She loved to cruise and also said Carnival handled the compensation well. By that I mean she loved the fact that she was able to get another cruise free. Miss ya old friend
@@Jesuisderetour87 She was, she took care of me when I was younger. Thankfully I found an interest in cruise ships and I realized that this was what she referred to when she tried to make me and my mom start to go on cruise ships. Not a very good thing to mention lol
Man, do I feel bad for the menial staff who had little to no ability to help, who also had to deal with the situation Edit: yeah, in hindsight, menial was a poor choice of word.
Yes. The ship caught fire, is listing, drifting without power. Tow line keeps snapping. Could sink or drift into rocks and split in half. "The problem is the toilets don't work." -every passenger
As someone who has been a sailor before on a much smaller ferry than these beasts, the crew has my sympathies a hundred times more than the passengers. I never want to work on a "proper" cruise ship because I’ve heard and seen enough of the types of people who take their vacation on a ship.
I feel terrible for the staff and crew who, not only like the passengers were trapped on the ship, but had to quell things and keep some sort of order. That crowd is filled with entitled Karens.
@@catpax6075I can see why you say that, but it’s mainly just the people that make the experience not as delightful. But from what I’ve seen, it looks like one hell of a time to be on a cruise
My kid’s teacher was on this cruise. She said it could have been a lot worse. No water or food shortages. Just some discomfort and inconvenience. She said it brought out the best -and the worst- in many passengers. Humanity at work..
@@HowieHoward-ti3dx Give part of his multimillion dollar salary earnings back to customers he forced to stay on his shit island for a week. He should have been FIRED the day after this happened.
I was in High School when I first heard about this. One of our classmates in one of the rooms was supposed to be on vacation for a period of time, but they didn't come back on the day they said they'd return. Same for the next day and the day after. Eventually, we learned he and his family were on this cruise. He mentioned just how much shit there was everywhere and how bad it smelled after he finally got back.
of all the 'catastrophic" videos I AGREE; SUBSCRIBING TO THIS ONE. There are, actually, much worse scenarios! MY BET'S ARE WITH "ALL" COAST GUARD FORCES! COMPARE THIS TO " no survivors" air flights ? Well, you could VIEW " MENTOUR PILOT videos" , to see all of the malfunctions that can occur on air flights! When THEY go down, the whole plane goes down...I'm betting on a cruise advertised AND looking at the stats. (Rick Steves Tours?) EXCELLENT narrator; on a terribly difficult subject matter. RARE GREAT NARRATION ; thanks for not adding over sensationalized music tracks to enhance the tragedy being reported, too. (such as the Mickey Mouse Manipulated Media does!). WELL DONE....and they are definitely DARK "records!" "I Ain't no Middleman!" and "Riverboat Queen" Phil Bowen UK and LyndaFaye
I ended up being on this ship the week before this happened. Power went out for over an hour and I was briefly trapped in an elevator with a handful of other passengers. They chalked it up to an electrical fire, but I still wonder if something that day lead to these events. I remember seeing a page that covered it, too.
@@mashy712facts. Royal Caribbean is more like the Costco of cruises. Classier but still affordable for most within reason. I heard celebrity and Norwegian cruises are way nicer though.
We just got back off the ship and the engine broke down and we were stuck in the water for a few hours and ended up being late to port also due to engine issues.
All temptation to go on a cruise has left me. The chances of experiencing something like this may be statistically small, but I can prevent it from ever happening to me!
Go royal Caribbean, you are seriously missing out. It's like not going on a plane because bad stuff has happened in a plane, even worse, less duration but everyone had diarreah because an omelet ccok in Alaska. All plane covered in poop and vomit and such a closed space. In that event people ended in hospitals, someone suicided, laws changed.
That's a terrible cruise but I have to give carnival some credit. A refund on that cruise, a future free cruise, 500 bucks, and most ship board expenses paid. That's quite a lot.
You do not have to "give them some credit". They towed the ship all the way to Mobile because that's where the repair facility was. They could have let the passengers off earlier, but that was too expensive to pay the fees to dock at another port. So they let those people suffer for days in the stench of human waste to save money. To hell with corporations.
Honestly, apart from the amazingly stupid open bar idea, it seems like the crew and the cruise ship company handled it pretty well. Having 3000 shit covered, malnourished, sleep deprived, and spoiled guests stick on a boat for 5 days, with only 2 evacuations and a full compensation for everyone even though it wasnt legally required. That's a better ending then most of these stories.
Like the fact that it didn't sink even a little bit. There was that Italian ship that sank in shallow water and a bunch of people got trapped and drowned
@@snookstheoriginal they were referring to them before they got stuck. The common conception of cruise ship vacationers is that they are spoiled and lazy.
@snookstheoriginal Right. I love cruises, and I am thankful that my Carnival cruises have been very nice and never had any disasters. Everything worked properly. I hope that my next cruise doesn't end up a poop ship. 💩🤢🤮
@@The-Epic-clone-royal-flower i see channels that are way too energetic and are annoying to watch.. sure the topic is interesting but because of tik tok addicts every youtuber is trying to keep the attention of a 5 year old in a 26 year olds body. I personally favor a more straight forward style and will do whatever i can to keep my feed pure.. not an easy task.
As bad as this is, I was thinking it was a far worse situation. I was thinking it was a stomach virus issue. I've heard of them being rampant on cruise ships, so I thought it was a plumbing AND virus issue, trapped on a ship, which is probably my biggest nightmare to date.
I’d be afraid of a cholera outbreak in that situation. There was also much higher chances of a salmonella or botulism outbreak, or even deadly typhoid fever if there was a salmonella outbreak. Or how about some hepatitis A lol. The food was also going bad without refrigeration alongside the sanitation issues, but they were running out of food too; so maybe someone takes a bad risk serving something that’s gone bad and this doesn’t end as well. That environment was ripe for something bad to happen and in retrospect they are lucky there wasn’t a disease outbreak, especially if people weren’t washing their hands and handling bags of poop.
I find it a great experience. Other types of vacations generally require you to do a bunch of planning, scheduling, budgeting, rentals, and other bookwork. When cruising you simply have to show up to the ship, and afterwards you've got nothing to do but enjoy yourself. Unless of course the ship turns into a poop cruise.
@@headcrab4 honestly I would have never thought about it this way, but you're so right. I am terrified of the water, but this makes me want to do a cruise 😂
I love how it was mentioned they were running out of food. Eating would be the last thing on my mind if the entire ship reeked of feces, and it was seeping up through the floors! I would have been fasting for the duration of my time onboard.
Yeah cool comment and all but no you wouldn't. Sounds like you've never truly went through hunger pains. Research "The Donner Party". I knew a guy who deliberately set out to see how long he could fast. By the 4th day, he said he was so delirious that he wasn't seeing other human beings. He was looking at other humans as something he would eat if it came down to it. The human mind is wired to survive. Period.
You say that now, but I bet after a day or two without eating your hunger would overtake your sense of smell. Your standards go out the window when survival instinct kicks in.
@figment ofyourimagination fasting isn't something you can up and do........unless of course, you have a disciplined mind. If you up and fast out of no where (especially for 4 days), it's likely your body will wig out.
My family and I were on the Carnival Triumph cruise trip just prior to this one. It was a huge family vacation and we were all so grateful that it didn’t happen to us
it could happen anytime though. thats a risk yiu take on a ship out in the middle of the ocean with thousands of people. why wouldANYONE waste their vacation money on such a pretentious , environmentally toxic sh*t show? you could use that money to literally spend a week anywhere in the world and you choose to be stuck on a boat with a bunch of strangers? ill never understand. smh
You can hear it in her voice that it wasn't an announcement she ever expected to make... drew the short straw. I can imagine it... "soooo who tells the passengers?" Everyone stares at the floor awkwardly.
I can't imagine having to poop in a bag even. I mean Imagine you are on a cruise with some hot guy, new bf or something. You gotta walk out with your shit bag like a dog.
Haha...we went on this ship's first cruise after being cleaned up. It was SPOTLESS and there were Carnival executives on board to make sure nothing went wrong. I saw them all over the ship and at the bar getting drunk.
Yeah man, my fiance and I went, too. It's hard to comprehend how BIG that boat is. I remember watching the Packers beat the Lions on a Hail Mary in their sports bar, and the South African bartender putting a Packer helmet on and running around the bar haha
@@andrjsjan4231 I'll explain. The original comment says that they were the GLUE that held them together, and the repl is referring to the POOP, because..there was so much of it, and...yeah. Or maybe it isn't, i'm not sure.
Plus there has been cases of missing people and s3xu4l assaults happening on cruise ships. And the worst part is that because it's not on land it's hard to prosecute anybody.
Same here, I will never. I saw titanic too many times to trust /j I am genuinely afraid of cruises and larger boats that travel around the world, so much can go wrong and other factors of like SA… nope I’m good
For REAL. I fail to see any upside to cruises (pollution, worker exploitation, and operation negligence for starters) except that the passengers don't want to handle their own passport/travel plans. But the trade off is being locked in a floating hotel with thousands of strangers and their germs?? As an introvert that's my personal hell. If they do stop and get off the ship, they're ushered around expensive tourist traps and then ushered back on board. If travelers weren't lazy and unimaginative there'd be no market for cruises. I'd rather travel one state over to visit sights and experiences than travel across the sea on one of those hell rafts. This Poop Cruise was only one year after the Costa Concordia disaster.
Being a cruise ship Provision Master myself, I can not stress enough how crazy that maneuver is that Elation, Conquest and Legend pulled off. Big respect to the respective Provision teams and captains of those ships, that takes some huge balls from everyone involved.
May I ask though why passengers weren't transferred off of Triumph and onto the other three vessels as they came within sufficient proximity to use launches or deploy lifeboats? 🤔 I could understand loss of _amenity_ power on it's own is a mere inconvenience...But when you lose power to _sanitation_ systems to the effect passengers are having to be asked to use more „traditional“ 🇬🇧 methods, that's the point where any opportunity to transfer passengers to other ships ought to be taken. ⛵ Also: Removing 3140 passengers and 1050 staff would have lightened the ship by about 466 metric tons, which would have expedited its tow to Mobile AL and saved a lot of broken lines on the side. 👍
@@dieseldragon6756How should the people get to the other ships? The mentioned ships don't have capabilities to lift lifeboats from the water and you can't transfer people over towlines.
@@dieseldragon6756far far too dangerous and too much of a liability to transfer all of those people in the middle of the ocean. The ships just aren’t built for that purpose.
@@dieseldragon6756 The video went on to describe 35 knot winds and 6 foot (12ft total) high swells. Multiply that by 3000 guests and you have a recipe for disaster in the middle of the ocean.
@@dieseldragon6756 Huge winds, huge waves, and cruise ships that dont have an easy way to board on open water. Do you see how high the ships decks are? Cruise ships like that dont have the capability to lift life boats. The whole process wouldve been needlessly dangerous
even if everything goes smoothly, cruising is literally a floating prison. no escape, be it from bad food, bad entertainment, bad fellow passengers, bad weather, disease. rampaging madmen, sinking, or fire. name one other vacation option that has so much potential for disaster
Amen, i cannot think of another Vessel humans have made more horribly dumb than a cruise ship, it's hands down the laziest way to travel, and the most boring. if holidays were spicy, cruise ships would be milk or whatever is negative spicy.
Think about this, that cruise ship that tipped over in Italy killed 30 people. That boat didn’t even go completely underwater. Imagine that boat having the same problem in the middle of the ocean. It would’ve been the titanic all over again. Definitely the most vulnerable spot humans can put themselves in
i disagree, based on STATISTICS of SURVIVORS Sarah? Maybe "they" should offer a CRUISE TITLED " THE PIRATES' CRUISE" and offer a special price with a BYOB..bring your own bag ? They should have given out bottle water to everyone instead of free liquor! Of all the 'catastrophic" videos I AGREE; SUBSCRIBING TO THIS ONE. SINCE THE NARRATOR WAS EXTREMELY COMPETENT & ELOQUENT! There are, actually, much worse scenarios! MY BET'S ARE WITH "ALL" COAST GUARD FORCES! COMPARE THIS TO " no survivors" air flights ? Well, you could VIEW " MENTOUR PILOT videos" , to see all of the malfunctions that can occur on air flights! When THEY go down, the whole plane goes down...I'm betting on a cruise advertised AND looking at the stats. (Rick Steves Tours?) EXCELLENT narrator; on a terribly difficult subject matter. RARE GREAT NARRATION ; thanks for not adding over sensationalized music tracks to enhance the tragedy being reported, too. (such as the Mickey Mouse Manipulated Media does!). WELL DONE....and they are definitely DARK "records!" "I Ain't no Middleman!" and "Riverboat Queen" Phil Bowen UK and LyndaFaye
I can’t believe that I went on this same ship last October. Luckily it’s been completely renovated and called sunrise now. We at least had a great vacation.
It’s the staff I really Feel sorry for. I could only imagine that they were expected to carry out normal jobs still in that nightmare while suffering also!
I've never been on a cruise, but every time I think to myself "hey maybe it could be fun one day" one of these kinds of videos popps up in my home feed again and I remember "ah yes, perhaps it won't."
I remember south park had a very quick unnoticeable line when someone was watching the news: "passengers said the carnival cruise smelled like poop, but that was an improvement"
The crew handled everything as best they could. Also, great job from the CEO for getting everyone free flights home and their money back despite company policy saying he didn't have to.
The C.E.O had to offer goodwill to the passengers to salvage the reputation of Carnival cruises. Any negative publicity is bad publicity. He could not follow the company policy of no refunds without doing irreparable damage to the company’s image and reputation.
Bull Shil! My family and I were there, we KNOW what really happened and how Carnival and many cruise lines REALLY operate. Carnival made the best deal to come out of bad PR and pay the least amount of $$$$$. A refund, $500 and a free cruise will NEVER make up for the PTSD, nightmares and rash I still live with and experience almost daily. YOU try facing death at sea and the very real fear of watching your children drown then come back and tell me how much you appreciated the CEO and crew for how they "handled" the entire situation! It was a BAD experience that will HAUNT my life until the day I die. I'm a tough, old, 70 year-old broad but there are some things you can never forget or forgive. I have a deep suspicion that that fire may have been caused by neglect rather than an accident. Seems to me, if that could be proven then ALL contracts, including the tickets for that cruise, become null and void. Of course, you can't fight big money so no lawsuit could result in the truth. They DID owe the passengers regardless of what the contract said. I will NEVER forgive Carnival for what happened! And I will always try to tell others what REALLY happened on board the Triumph, 2013.
I remember the offical statments that Carnival was putting out during this ordeal. They kept saying that "things are under control." Anyone with experience at sea, things were definantly NOT under control. When the tugs are repeatedly breaking lines in relatively calm conditions, the margin for error was razor thin. Any sort of adverse weather, and that ship would have been dead in the water, adrift, limited food and water, no environmental controls, and over 3000 people on board. Loss of life in those conditions would be expected. Edited to correct the number of people on board.
Whenever people say "Things are under control" it seems to mean "things are emphatically NOT under control, and we are currently desperately trying to keep them from getting even more out of control.".
What amazes me is that the ship captain didn't call out Mayday and didn't evacuate the ship when it was clear that the condition is getting worse and passengers are suffering.
I don't know much about cruises, but I would guess there were just too many people to evacuate them. You'd have to interrupt/end another ship's cruise, and put everybody on an extremely crowded ship, or have like 3 or 4 other ships so you could distribute people evenly...and then they'd probably all have to be Carnival ships, and I doubt there were that many within the area. You could also maybe just get a few people at a time on a bunch of smaller boats but that would be extremely tedious. They were stuck right in the middle of the Gulf of Mexico. Hard to get to and from ports.
You only issue mayday calls if there is immediate, life threatening danger to the people on board or the vessel itself. Mayday calls are not treated lightly, this would at best be a pan pan call. Either way, rescuing that many people would be a massive undertaking, which doesnt make sense if people's lives arent endangered
I went on this cruise in 2019 and 3 things astounded me. 1- no one knew that this was the infamous Carnival poop cruise, and 2-it still smelled like poop and 3- the sewers still backed up into the rooms.
I truly doubt that the reason that it smelled like poop was because of this instance it was most likely due to the sewage overflow you mentioned. I'm taking a educated guess that those sewage problems were caused by a guest flushing something that shouldn't have gone down the toilet. Marine sewage systems are very sensitive beasts.
Exactly what i was thinking, if you took an early 1700s pirate operating out of the West Indies and put him on this cruise he would’ve found everything to be very hygienic and wonder why people were were freaking out bothering to take dumps in bags
ONLY ( write this down for future novels btw) PIRATES DIDN'T HAVE PLASTIC! They didn't destroy the fish populations either! They should have given out bottle water to everyone instead of free liquor! Of all the 'catastrophic" videos I AGREE; SUBSCRIBING TO THIS ONE. There are, actually, much worse scenarios! MY BET'S ARE WITH "ALL" COAST GUARD FORCES! COMPARE THIS TO " no survivors" air flights ? Well, you could VIEW " MENTOUR PILOT videos" , to see all of the malfunctions that can occur on air flights! When THEY go down, the whole plane goes down...I'm betting on a cruise advertised AND looking at the stats. (Rick Steves Tours?) EXCELLENT narrator; on a terribly difficult subject matter. RARE GREAT NARRATION ; thanks for not adding over sensationalized music tracks to enhance the tragedy being reported, too. (such as the Mickey Mouse Manipulated Media does!). WELL DONE....and they are definitely DARK "records!" "I Ain't no Middleman!" and "Riverboat Queen" Phil Bowen UK and LyndaFaye
@@ethanp7183They shat right into the sea and the deck was scrubbed daily. Yeah it wasn't great but not like that. Hard work though, they stuffed them with 7000 kcal and plenty of rum.
The crew deserve a huge bonus for continuing their work, while also going through the same challenges as the passengers. It was supposed to be a vacation, but turned to four-five days of suffering. At least it was only Sunday-Thursday. Some people go through ice storms that knock out power for weeks, cutting off the well pump, the heat, and the ability to travel out of the outage area. They get no refunds, and Mother Nature never apologizes.
In regions where such storms do happen, people have wood stoves as reserve heating at least. Also candles, stormlamps, sometimes electricity generators. Or, if it's a city, there is central heating, water and gas which comes in underground pipes. So what you really don't have in this case is light and smart devices - and that's it.
@@VermyScrubsi’ve never been on a cruise but have been thinking of it here and there. what specifically do you dislike about Carnival, what is it about them compared to the others that you wouldn’t ride Carnival again? genuine question
@@anaism.5821 To quote Bright Sun Films “Carnival is the Walmart of Cruise Lines”. They’re “often” the cheaper ones but does that cheapness reflect on their product. I went with the lowest type of cabin on Carnival and their biggest competition out of Miami, Royal Caribbean. RC’s product is better then Carnival on a lot of aspects. My cabin on Carnival had a lot of flaws and seemed a bit run down while RC’s felt slightly better. The food on Carnival was lackluster and was just average at best, RC’s despite being slightly more expensive was probably dealing with its lowest being an average. Activities onboard where completely different, Carnival was more of a family outing ship while RC despite opening up to the family still had that grown up experience from the previous century. I can’t really speak on that though since I did go on Carnival as a child while I went on RC when I’m basically an adult, but from what I heard from my parents The only thing that really suited them was a couple of bars and a casino on Carnival. I really can’t compare the staff because both of them were great (all though RC had one asshole). That’s really all I could think about them right now. I wouldn’t go out of my way to avoid Carnival, my comment is clearly hyperbole but it would be far from my first choice. I used to like Carnival deeply but ultimately that was when I was a child and my views have shifted.
@@anaism.5821 I'm british and I'd never ride carnival if I got the chance. I've never been on a cruise either and this may have put me off going on any cruise line but im not sure
I'm just glad nobody got sick there - with the sewage system going haywire and with people pooping on bags. The crew deserve medal. They did their best. Salute
To say that this was the poop cruise from hell insinuates that they may be a poop cruise from heaven, too, but I'm not sure if I'm willing to go down that rabbit hole.
the fact that the ship continued causing havoc even after the passengers had been freed from it, even resulting in someone's death like nah this ship is cursed
Man it must have SUCKED for those employees in particular. Having to go through the same shit, but with thousands of passengers probably still expecting them to take care of them. Tbh, in a situation like that, it should become a group effort. There are no employees and vacationers anymore. Everybody should pull whatever weight they can
Sure, in an ideal world. but the passengers paid for the trip, and the employees are getting paid, as shitty as the pay might be. And who knows what shitty jobs the passengers got paid for in order to buy the tickets for that trip. I'm sure a lot of them have pretty shitty jobs. Plus, it would be terrible pr for the company if they didn't do whatever they could to make it easier for the passengers
@@blueclover9918 there’s little reason why this couldn’t have been an “ideal world” scenario. There’s no point in keeping score when the situation is that dire and everyone is literally in the same boat. I personally don’t think I’d feel right having the staff take care of me knowing they’re going through the same horrible thing just because they’re getting paid $15 an hour. It’s a mutually traumatizing experience, all thoughts about who’s making what money and the company’s reputation are going out the window. And technically, although it was afterwards and they had no way of knowing at the time, the passengers did wind up receiving a decent amount of compensation.
@@shortking-vp9vv who paid and who is getting paid does make a difference. They paid for the privilege of having the trip - which wasn't even what they paid for. I mean I could totally understand if it were a life-and-death issue, but say what you might, it wasn't. If it were life-and-death, absolutely. But it wasn't at that point.
And it is still in Carnival's fleet today! Enjoy your time on the 'new' Carnival Sunrise! It's like a phoenix rising at dawn out of the ashes of it's old poo encrusted interior.
As someone who works hospitality, tossing free alcohol at already upset and annoying guests is ALWAYS a decision passed down from the executive or corporate 😂 no one with a brain would EVER make that decision.
Okay I bet if you added up all the pros and cons from the free drinks, it was a net positive lol They’re like “guests got too drunk and started throwing stuff over board” Sounds like they had a fun time and no one really got hurt 😂 (But ur right lol)
Imagine how frustrating it must have been to see all the other ships and helicopters coming and going for days and not being able to actually get on any of them. I get that transferring between vessels at sea is tricky but at some point you're just going to want to go anywhere else whatever it takes
It really comes down to the fact that transferring between vessels at sea is dangerous and done only in case of a full emergency. From the Captains perspective, his ship was afloat, stable, under tow, and no one was in danger of immediate harm. While crappy (hah!) and uncomfortable, keeping them aboard was less risky than an evacuation in open water.
Imagine a floundering cruise ship like the Oceanos when the crew abandoned ship and the entertainer (Moss Hills) took over to ensure everyone of the 100s of passengers were safely plucked off the ship by helicopter-rescue. 🛳💜
If you know anything by now, especially being an American, them telling you "its under control" for anything means it is not under control at all and things are going to get much much worse. It is used as a psychological clutch to control and subvert a mass panic scenario which would lead to a crush event or mass fatalities.
12:48 I’m quite sure the one person injured and one person dead isn’t due to Carnival Triumph crashing after it broke lose. They were in a guard shack on a nearby pier, which collapsed during the high winds, same event broke Triumph lose.
Not necessarily - there are minor incidents fairly often and they generally are under control in a very short time. Plus it's super important to listen to the crew, who have trained extensively for emergency situations. But people should definitely be vigilant and not blindly follow instruction that clearly puts them in danger.
@@Caroline-rv8wy I've heard the stories where the crew has told the passengers to remain in their cabin while the ship is sinking (that one Korean ferry) and they died. No way that's gonna be me. I wouldn't be sprinting down the hallway and jumping off the deck first sign of a fire alarm, but I would definitely have a plan to get out (probably something stupid like jumping out my window)
@@perrybb2 I know it's happened, I'm just saying generally speaking there are a lot of minor incidents on cruise ships that are easily handled. It's super important to pay attention to safety briefings and where your muster station is, but when you hear the initial announcements you just have to be vigilant and prepared to move if you need to, until you hopefully hear the stand down - I remember one where the Captain came on the loudspeaker afterward and said ''everything's fine now, some idiot put tennis shoes in the dryer.'' 😅 But like I said, you also need to use common sense and don't just follow blindly even if you're seeing something that goes directly against what you're being told.
@@Caroline-rv8wy better safe than sorry, that's my motto. There are a lot of ways to kick the bucket, and drowning's probably the worst (especially drowning in saltwater, which takes longer and is more painful than drowning in fresh water)
@@perrybb2 yes but panic is most likely to cause more issues... like a stampede, riot, etc. What's putting on a life jacket gonna get you? Where you going to go? The ship sinks then what? You float in freezing cold water for days?
I could only imagine being trapped on this boat with these people. These are not the kind of people you want to be going through this situation with. When it was said they opened the bar I spit out my drink laughing.
@@dionst.michael1482 Yeah but if you are stuck on a ship of pissed off people. opening the bar probably calmed a lot of them down. As long as they limit the amount per person. They probably also realized there are a lot of alcoholics who will have seizures or get real sick without alcohol. Then you have a bigger issue.
There are several nice, smaller luxury cruise lines. Carnival is definitely not one of them. And, I avoid the Caribbean cruises completely. Trashy, party crowd.
I went on a Disney cruise when I was thirteen with my (divorced) grandparents. We pretty much immediately wished that we'd just stayed at Disney World the entire time, instead of three days at the resort and four days on the cruise. Boo, I say. It wasn't terrible (first day seasickness aside), it just wasn't great either.
@@westhavenor9513yeah… I’ll never be doing another carnival or possibly Caribbean cruise. On top of all that it’s so fucking hot and humid, which I personally am not at all used to
To whoever thought having an open bar was a good idea when food and water are limited and the bathrooms don't function, my hat goes off to you. Not many would have dared to give a bunch of irate, hungry, dirty people unlimited booze, but hey, what better time to give the most realistic reenactment of the life of real pirates than being stranded at sea with nothing but old hard bread and booze. 😂
I love how this video makes it sound like the vacationers had it worse 😂😂, the crew is stuck on the same ship, but is getting all the blame and has to work while being able to do nothing about it
@@alien666-bs1ih "Which is exactly why it's worse. If you're going to be in a terrible situation, do you want no obligations, or a whole list of obligations on top of every other complicated factor? Especially when, as someone pointed out, your pay is extremely minimal because they factor part of your "pay" as the food and living quarters, which were what were affected." --Someone else who commented this to someone who said something similar.
@@41052 You're ignoring the money. Let's say you have to be in a situation of suffering, but you can choose: to pay 1000 to be there, or to earn 1000 to be there. What would you choose? The obligations are part of the work to earn money. You work and you get money in return. The crew was not getting obligations in return for nothing, but in return for money. Actually they had the option to quit the job and do nothing. The customers were not earning anything, they were spending and getting nothing in return, being in the same situation as the crew.
There was one last little slap in the face that was left out of this. One of the buses taking passengers to the airport broke down before it could leave the port.
An open bar on shop where there’s already an epidemic going on, nobody can use the toilet and everyone sleeping on the deck. Sounds like a perfect plan to create disaster
@@quintomalley1196not quite, the Poop deck was the top deck of the stern (rear of the ship). It’s an English translation of the French “La Poupe” meaning stern. Also, if a wave comes over the back of the ship (very dangerous) it’s called “being pooped”.
This kinda reminds me early on during the COVID thing there was a ship out at sea that suffered a COVID outbreak and they wouldn't allow the ship to dock anywhere or allow any passengers to disembark. This ship stayed out in the ocean for something like 3 weeks. This is barbaric and inhumane treatment of people.
I forget if they were delayed entry, but they were allowed to dock in Japan. It looks harsh, but given the totality of circumstances, primarily the limited idea as to what the hell exactly was going on, it wasn't the worst call. Not ideal but not overtly evil as well. Japan has far, far too much of a sense of honor to just scuttle the ship. (Something I would worry about certain southeast Asian nations doing)
If it was on the early stages of the virus pandemic wich there wasn't a cure i guess could have been a safety precaution to avoid spreading ? Im just guessing
To say it’s was a fire on a ferry 5 days from land, in the the engine room as well, and managed to control it and keep everyone alive with just 26 medical issues tells me they did something right
Carnival is absolutely great at dealing with disaster’s, I speak from experience when I was on the Carnival Pride last summer (it’s propulsion broke down in Germany)
6:03 "Offering free beer and wine after the fire" Ah yes, serving alcohol to people who are already stressed out due to an emergency situation. Absolutely brilliant idea. What could POSSIBLY go wrong?
This is the main reason I would never go on a cruise at least on land if the hotel sucks you could probably just find a nicer one but on a ship you are stuck .
Nah, there's just shy of a million reasons I'll never go willingly... I was dumb enough to sign up for the Navy out of high school... and I learned quite a lot (I didn't want to know) about ships and shipboard life... EVERYTHING is worse at sea. You're hundreds of miles from land, anything or anyone to help you, and stuck in a tin-can sharing air with God only knows who or from where... If you've even been to College or Summer Camp, you know what happens when you bring a bunch of people from thousands of miles apart together on the same ground, and those are with plenty of open spaces and air... Now, seal all that up with a half-assed ventilation system that was built by the LOWEST possible bidder. Saline is a solution used in medical facilities to keep humans alive, which is to say, it's NOT harmful to any life. It's the perfect medium for delivery of just about everything... just add whatever to a saline drip, and you can put it directly inside a body... no harm. Now, take into account that the salt water of the sea gets turned directly into mist to add to humidity... and you've got saline free-flowing everywhere and completely compatible with all living things, including algae, fungi, and all manners of microbes from bacteria to virus... ALL settling and swirling through the "ventilated tin-can" in the middle of nowhere squared. Yeah... THOSE are just some of the basic foundation of why I will never in hell willingly go on a cruise if I can possibly avoid it... AND I've BEEN both dry caving AND cave diving in my life. I have no problems with either of those "extreme activities"... I ride a motorcycle... I track down and wrangle reptiles, specializing in snakes mostly... I'm no stranger to "calculated risk assessment". People are WEIRD creatures. ;o)
Also you forget that cruise ships sail internationally in invalid waters and thus are immune to any legal or justice system. They have to police themselves (which they do not).
@@sentinelDJ707 C-Diff is a very infectious gut disease that spreads through spores and is hard to get rid of. Commonly, it is caused by anti-botics killing off the good bacteria and leaving c-diff to reign. If you have c-diff in the hospital, you are quatentined. And using disinfectant does not work! You need warm water and soap.
The staff had it worse then the customers. They had the same problems as the customers, except had to still serve the drunk and irritated customers
Nah, for real, if I worked on that ship, it's martial law at that point. Fuck my "job duties", I'm not policing drunk, angry, hungry and filthy passengers lmao. Just throw me over board.
Except one group is paying to vacation and the other is getting paid to work.
@@laptopdroptop9457 Personally I'll take a bad vacation day over bad workday every time.
@@laptopdroptop9457 cruise staff gets paid shockingly low wages
@@laptopdroptop9457 Which is exactly why it's worse. If you're going to be in a terrible situation, do you want no obligations, or a whole list of obligations on top of every other complicated factor? Especially when, as someone pointed out, your pay is extremely minimal because they factor part of your "pay" as the food and living quarters, which were what were affected.
The fact that they apparently thought "people cannot use the bathrooms & are getting ornery" would be a good environment to offer an open bar is astonishing. At minimum, you're gonna need more bags.
It's a classic case of "Let them eat cake" ignorance, you've got 3k people crammed onto a ship, no A/C, no hot meals and worst no plumping for waste and then someone wants to add alcohol to the mix!? That's like seeing a house fire and instead of hand chucking water buckets they decided to douse it with jet fuel. :p
@@mattmuch7536”give me five Jameson and ginger ales and an AK47 and I’ll solve all the problems right now.”
@@chosentwice1839 guns seem to be emotional support for Americans haha
@@anonymoust2877 just like booze and cannabis and Catholicism is comfort and emotional support for the Europeons.
Drinking makes me want to shit alot tbh
The kind of people that frequent cruises are not the kind of people you would want to spend extra time in a difficult time with.
I wouldn't know. Never been on a cruise, never would go. No thanks.
You think they would have more decorum from the multiple experiences, but no. Very snotty and trash.
@@_Shadoh_ cool sorry buddy
Dumbass comment of the year.
True, true.
Imagine having a stressful time at work and putting in for a vacation and you end up on this cruise.
At that point I think I’d just end it 😂😭 This cruise sounds like a literal hell.
You get the first hand experience of the Hunger Games.
I would look forward to work lol
American workers are lucky, they don't get to have vacations.
Imagine being stupid enough to go on a cruise.
My biggest surprise is that the open bar didn't end up worse. Something about confined spaces, anger, poop covered, and alcohol seem a little sketchy.
“We’re low on food”
“They can drink their calories at the open bar!”
“I don’t think we should give free alcohol to people on empty stomachs”
“Nono it’s cool, that’s what the poop bags are for!”
Just a normal night out in Camden Town
I think it's the urine more than the poop. Urine contains pheremones. When men are around pheremones from unrelated men, it can be a factor increasing their aggression. But yeah, the poop too. 🤮 Plus the added dumb-ass factor when people drink.
Meh, when we were deployed we had snuck in alcohol and wouldn’t get too crazy. Did have to drink in shifts though. All those things for months unless out on a patrol in reference to confined areas.
@@idkjames Without knowing your conditions (which I imagine were probably hell if you were in combat), it sounds pretty organized (setting up drinking shifts), without all the feces and rage among people who had no one to take it out on. Thousands of people, all strangers, everybody full of outrage and constant disgust and a cruise director constantly announcing that everything was ok. I've never seen combat, but my imagination tells me one would have me terrified and bonding with my buddies while the other would have me furious and looking for someone to step up and ask for it. Sorry if I'm speaking out of turn, but that's where my brain goes. Again, it's my imagination. It's a dark, ugly place sometimes.
A normal Poop Cruise is bad enough, but this one was straight from hell.
I laughed way more than I should've.
If the ship construction is made of eco friendly biodegradable poop that would be horrible
Name checks out
There are other poop cruises?
godly username
OMG as someone who has worked in multiple bars, the absolute WORST thing you can do when the toilets aren't working is get people drunk 😳
Yes, they should have just handed out bottled water instead!!
There are, actually, worse scenarios!
MY BET'S ARE WITH "ALL" COAST GUARD FORCES!
COMPARE THIS TO " no survivors" air flights ?
Well, you could VIEW " MENTOUR PILOT videos" , to see all of the malfunctions that can occur on air flights!
When THEY go down, the whole plane goes down...I'm betting on a cruise advertised AND looking at the stats.
(Rick Steves Tours?)
EXCELLENT narrator; on a terribly difficult subject matter. RARE GREAT NARRATION ; thanks for not adding over sensationalized music tracks to enhance the tragedy being reported, too. (such as the Mickey Mouse Manipulated Media does!).
WELL DONE....and they are definitely DARK "records!"
"I Ain't no Middleman!" and
"Riverboat Queen"
Phil Bowen UK and LyndaFaye
As somebody who's worked in bars for 7 years, the absolute worst thing they could've done is NOT do an open bar when those traumatized who paid the original open bar ticket price are taking drinks all day for free and the other passengers with no drinks are trying not to jump overboard. A food fight from an open bar is probably the best case scenario. I could easily see people getting jumped for their open bar wristbands had they not done it.
@@darkwebgirl right because the extra urine, feces which is often much softer, and vomit that comes with excessive drinking would definitely have helped the situation. Yep.
It's weird though the fact that they're out in the ocean... You can always just pee off the edge and just put the poop in the ocean...it Will biodegrade.. not the best practice but if you have too...
I was just thinking.. imagine how many people had the bubble guts after that open bar and had to aim their diarrhea into those red bags, that cannot have gone well 😅🤢
A moment of silence for the cleanup crew that had to deal with this.
A moment of silence for the balding Indian janitors
Yes I agree with you we need to show the cleaning crew some sympathy. 😢😢😢
🕯️
REALLL like they had the worst out of everyone
@@theflash691 imagine that day you were hitting on a hot chick and suddenly you see her 💩 in the hallways 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
My sister was on this cruise! She was compensated generously for all of this as she texted in the family group chat about the poop bags. It's definitely a memory she won't forget.
Honestly I don't think any amount of compensation could get me through that unless it was in the form of brainwashing or euthanasia
@@dominichowell961 Is it really that bad though? Yes it's warm, probably smells, you only have some cold food and need to poop in bags, but overall the passengers were never in any danger, nor did they run out of toilet paper and they even had an open bar the one day.
Obviously it's not the trip you paid for but it was just a few days with some discomfort, nothing that should mentally scar you, especially since it was only for very few days and the passengers knew the main land was informed about their situation and ready to rescue passengers should there be the need (like f.e. with the dialysis woman).
Were they stranded in the ocean, cut off or very far away from main land, then that's a situation that might mentally scar you.
@@corex6109 Unless you were on that ship, how would you truly know how they felt? You can project all you want, but no one truly knows how they would feel, what they would do, what they would say, etc., under certain dire circumstances unless they have experienced it firsthand themselves.
@@fjosephgonzales6870 Hahahahahaha! You're funny.
Let me recap this for everyone else that might read it:
First you say no amount of compensation could get you through that, then I ask if it's really that bad, bringing a few arguments to the table to which the only thing you can say is "how would you know how it was if you weren't on the ship".
Did you even realize that with this sentence you're completely destroying every foundation for your previous comment? How would you be able to tell it would break you if you weren't present?
@@corex6109 I only commented once (until now). When you said "first you say...," that was someone else.
My dad almost got on this cruise but had to reschedule. I remember what a sigh of relief that was
That's like missing your flight and finding out later it hit the Twin Towers.
@connorscanlan2166 definitely not THAT bad but a similar situation lol. that person’s dad is lucky.
Your dad is stupid
Your father must be fortunate. What's the odds of avoiding something like this?!?
Dodged a huge bullet right there
I appreciate how serious Carnival took refunds for the customers, I hope the staff got the royal treatment as well
They definitely should have received hazard pay & additional compensation similar to that of the passengers.
Yes, but no
They did not
The staff doesn’t appertain to national laws so they basically are on the mercy of the company. It’s likely they didn’t get any compensation for the mistreatment. Cruise staff is straight up slave labor.
I agree, when I heard each customer received 500 dollars, a full refund, paid flight home, and another 4 day cruise credit. I thought, well maybe it wouldn't have been so bad to be there.
@@NoNames-vw3bq not a chance. half of them were probably making a dollar a day. These are “technically” overseas workplaces after all.
I can't imagine the smell on the ship with 4000+ people pooping and peeing and it all just spilling over onto carpets. And that too for multiple days without proper ventilation and light.
I imagine so many people had pinkeye - accidentally touch the wall, eyes itches and you rub it … oops now you have fecal matter in your eyes.
Is there something wrong with your imagination?
@@PsychologicalApparitionno? Because that did really happen?
Especially if more than half of them are drunk.🤢
I'm sorry, but I'd take the easy way out 😭 I'd have to
To my dismay I have to admit I laughed hard when they took the decision to open the bars. That's like looking a horror film when the victim makes a wrong decision and you know while wanting to scream "NOOOO!".
"Gee, opening this creepy barn door can't possibly be a bad choice!"
"Gee, opening the alcohol bar freely can't possibly be a bad choice!"
Absolutely!!! My thoughts.
maybe, just maybe it was one big social experiment. lets do all this stuff to them....then in a bit we'll open the bars so they can drink and get drunk. how high of a degree of pandemonium will ensue?!
@@Gizziiusa You mean like how the Vaults were set up in the Fallout universe? I honestly would not be surprised.
😂😂😂😂 it gets funnier n funnier, sounds like a comedy movie
I'm sure their heart was in the right place, but plying enraged, exhausted, and vengeful passengers with all the alcohol they could drink is just asking for mayhem.
Right???
I would be serving xanax to costumers😂
WHen they mentioned free beer, I was was like " why? ... no... " LMAO 🤣🤣🤣they're asking for trouble with free alcohol .
@@pyromaniac709 😭😭😭
@@pyromaniac709 😊
Not only that, but serving free booze without having any working toilets...
I'm surprised they had enough red bio-hazard bags for the thousands of passengers over several days. Given those bags are usually only used for blood soaked items, used medical equipment, PPE, etc, it's kind of suspicious they were that well prepared on the bag front
Maybe more bags were dropped off by the tugging/passing boats.
It was a poor plan B
I heard somewhere that a lot of old people book cruises preparing to die or because they know they are dying soon. And that cruise ships have Disney park like security/med staff that can appear out of nowhere and quickly whisk you off to a private cell or med bay.
"PASSENGERS PLEASE RETURN TO YOUR COFFINS......ERR....I MEAN CABINS" 😳🤣
every life boat, first aid station, storage locker etc have them. I'm actually not that surprised because in terms of emergency gear, it's a pennies item that just gets included in everything.
I love how cheery the lady on the intercom was when she was telling people they'd have to poop in a bag, and pee in the shower. Almost makes it sound fun!
“A number one.. that’d be a wee..””
IKR like 'who ate more corn' bag counting contests n such ... carnival indeed!
Haha I thought the same.
I can't imagine being one of the staff members having to take care of the passengers who are mostly very irritating people to begin with let alone in a situation like this.
Yep, and honestly, I have a lot of respect for the staff when it comes to these cruises. They’re needing a paycheck like anyone else, but instead of being able to go home and kick back, they have to be stuck with their customers on a boat out in the ocean even in their down time.
Adding this fiasco on top of what they do … geez, they probably didn’t get paid anywhere near enough to be handling that shit - literally _and_ figuratively.
I can't imagine being one of the staff members having to take care of the poop bags! Best case scenario they're picking up waste baskets with neatly tied bags. I don't want to think about the worst case scenarios.
Can't imagine doing customer service with probably some of the most snotty ppl in a bad situation, I'm sure the bartender had a few drinks 😂
I went on a cruise a couple times. The staff is always pretty nice, and the females are easy to take back to your cabin (staff included.) Highly recommend cruises if you're single and wanna get laid.
@@hojocollider5276 Anddd you just proved everyone's point about people who regularly go on cruises lol.
I used to work as a musician for Carnival. I cannot imagine how horrifying this experience must have been for everyone on that ship. What a nightmare.
I had a student who was (and still is) a saxophonist on a cruise ship and he was the first person I thought of when I watched this video.
@@Kat-tr2ig It's a rite of passage for horn players. 😂
It's bad but those people weren't really in great danger. They were more greatly inconvenienced. The real problem was logistics. If there was someone with a true medical emergency they would have got them off the boat immediately. I see these ladies holding a SOS sign and my eyes roll to the back of my head. "People do this in the movies right? Maybe they'll put us on the news like when we held that sign at the basketball game!"
Was that a good gig? Id imagine it could be either awesome or horrible.
It would have been less of a nightmare if the ladies had actually stopped using the toilets like they were told - but most of them kept using them despite the instructions. LOL....
Oh man i feel for the people who had to clean and repair that ship, I hope they got compensated fairly.
Idk why I just assumed they would demolish it lol
@@danip2476
I thought the same thing as i was watching it! lol
I would've burned it 😝
But I guess considering everything they gave back in refunds and compensation they figured it was more cost effective to salvage what they could and rebuild on it.
@-western froggy- Yes, tell me about it! They are racist!!! Very racist!!! Their Party has few minorities and the few tokens they have, they elevate them to deceive people into believing that they accept all. Like Trump at his rallies, they pick the ONLY few (lost) Black folk to be sitted right behind him for the television cameras. 😂 😂
They have one token in the Supreme Court that is so damn Corrupt he has ruined the credibility of the the Court, thanks Uncle Thomas!. I could go on and on with them, they are the Party of David Duke! They are also the Party of Timothy McVeigh and White Supremacists!!!
You are right, buddy, these guys are racist to the core!!! But very cunning and crafty at covering their tracts and pretending that they aren't!
Contracted out to Haitians
I would just sink it
My moms friend was on that ship, she sadly passed because of Covid-19 in late 2021. However, I recall my moms friend saying that it was a terrible experience and one she would never forget. She loved to cruise and also said Carnival handled the compensation well. By that I mean she loved the fact that she was able to get another cruise free. Miss ya old friend
I hope that she is in heaven.❤
That actually made me sad to read. She sounds like such a sweet lady. ❤️❤️❤️
What?! She passed during? From Covid 19? This happened in 2013.
@@crupt1023 no,no during covid-19
@@Jesuisderetour87 She was, she took care of me when I was younger. Thankfully I found an interest in cruise ships and I realized that this was what she referred to when she tried to make me and my mom start to go on cruise ships. Not a very good thing to mention lol
Man, do I feel bad for the menial staff who had little to no ability to help, who also had to deal with the situation
Edit: yeah, in hindsight, menial was a poor choice of word.
I would have quit. There is not enough money in the world
Shituation
Yes. The ship caught fire, is listing, drifting without power. Tow line keeps snapping. Could sink or drift into rocks and split in half.
"The problem is the toilets don't work." -every passenger
@@cjb2749 You gonna quit and go home? I don't think the employees had much of an option. If you're stuck there, might as well keep getting paid.
@@cjb2749 where you gonna go? You're stuck there and can't leave.
As someone who has been a sailor before on a much smaller ferry than these beasts, the crew has my sympathies a hundred times more than the passengers. I never want to work on a "proper" cruise ship because I’ve heard and seen enough of the types of people who take their vacation on a ship.
I feel terrible for the staff and crew who, not only like the passengers were trapped on the ship, but had to quell things and keep some sort of order. That crowd is filled with entitled Karens.
Nothing worse than cargo that complains. I’ll stick to merchant vessels
@@MikeS309 Hear, hear.
Same, just the fact that they got rewarded all that and still tried to sue them. Crazy.
@@MikeS309Mike knows! 😁
Who else is amazed they had enough biohazard bags? I have no clue why they'd have so many, but thank god they did
For real, like who just has like 500lbs of red bags laying around?
@@skeetsmcgrew3282 probably for situations like this. its not a hard concept to understand
@@skydive7054 So bring poop bags but no extra canned food. Yeah real smart
@@skeetsmcgrew3282 the ship already has a large amount of food, so that's not needed.
to store thin plastic bags is a lot easier than enough canned food
The possibility of Being trapped in a cruise is the reason I would never go on one. You're in the middle of the ocean if something goes wrong
Not to mention that most people around you are entitled assholes
@@Simoxs7Been on 2 cruises, both times I've had someone throw their drink at me, and another call me racist over a chair.
So many reasons to not go on cruises 🚢 they’re incredibly overrated
Yea fuk all that
@@catpax6075I can see why you say that, but it’s mainly just the people that make the experience not as delightful. But from what I’ve seen, it looks like one hell of a time to be on a cruise
My kid’s teacher was on this cruise. She said it could have been a lot worse. No water or food shortages. Just some discomfort and inconvenience. She said it brought out the best -and the worst- in many passengers. Humanity at work..
But then the CEO took responsibility publicly - that's unheard of these days. Usually they deflect or blame others, but Cahill didn't.
@@BritGirlJay The compensation was fair enough, but honestly his apology felt really like a PR pre-written statement instead of a sincere apology
@@tommartenmark5786 He did what he had to do. What extra would you have done Mr. Smarty pants?
@@tommartenmark5786wasn’t really much he could do except apologize, he didn’t personally do anything wrong lol
@@HowieHoward-ti3dx Give part of his multimillion dollar salary earnings back to customers he forced to stay on his shit island for a week. He should have been FIRED the day after this happened.
I was in High School when I first heard about this. One of our classmates in one of the rooms was supposed to be on vacation for a period of time, but they didn't come back on the day they said they'd return. Same for the next day and the day after.
Eventually, we learned he and his family were on this cruise. He mentioned just how much shit there was everywhere and how bad it smelled after he finally got back.
I bet that really helped him to clear his thoughts and stress about school.
@@satina1169 He was surprisingly chill about it - mostly made a bunch of jokes at the expense of the ship itself!
Good thing he survived this hell
of all the 'catastrophic" videos I AGREE; SUBSCRIBING TO THIS ONE.
There are, actually, much worse scenarios!
MY BET'S ARE WITH "ALL" COAST GUARD FORCES!
COMPARE THIS TO " no survivors" air flights ?
Well, you could VIEW " MENTOUR PILOT videos" , to see all of the malfunctions that can occur on air flights!
When THEY go down, the whole plane goes down...I'm betting on a cruise advertised AND looking at the stats.
(Rick Steves Tours?)
EXCELLENT narrator; on a terribly difficult subject matter. RARE GREAT NARRATION ; thanks for not adding over sensationalized music tracks to enhance the tragedy being reported, too. (such as the Mickey Mouse Manipulated Media does!).
WELL DONE....and they are definitely DARK "records!"
"I Ain't no Middleman!" and
"Riverboat Queen"
Phil Bowen UK and LyndaFaye
I ended up being on this ship the week before this happened. Power went out for over an hour and I was briefly trapped in an elevator with a handful of other passengers. They chalked it up to an electrical fire, but I still wonder if something that day lead to these events. I remember seeing a page that covered it, too.
man you sure dodged a bullet
Carnival is the "Walmart" of cruises.
@@mashy712facts. Royal Caribbean is more like the Costco of cruises. Classier but still affordable for most within reason. I heard celebrity and Norwegian cruises are way nicer though.
Cap.
We just got back off the ship and the engine broke down and we were stuck in the water for a few hours and ended up being late to port also due to engine issues.
All temptation to go on a cruise has left me. The chances of experiencing something like this may be statistically small, but I can prevent it from ever happening to me!
then you shouldn’t even be outside because a raging car might hit you
I’m on a cruise. Never go on a lower-class cruise line. Carnival is the Walmart of cruise lines.
Go royal Caribbean, you are seriously missing out.
It's like not going on a plane because bad stuff has happened in a plane, even worse, less duration but everyone had diarreah because an omelet ccok in Alaska. All plane covered in poop and vomit and such a closed space. In that event people ended in hospitals, someone suicided, laws changed.
Carnival is the worst of them all. Go on another one and you'll be fine
@@Jesuisderetour87fr
That's a terrible cruise but I have to give carnival some credit. A refund on that cruise, a future free cruise, 500 bucks, and most ship board expenses paid. That's quite a lot.
You do not have to "give them some credit". They towed the ship all the way to Mobile because that's where the repair facility was. They could have let the passengers off earlier, but that was too expensive to pay the fees to dock at another port. So they let those people suffer for days in the stench of human waste to save money. To hell with corporations.
@@Heike-- Fair enough. I might but I can understand why you might not.
@@Heike-- i mean fair point
Yes, I thought that was quite generous as well. More than you get from airlines when they ruin your vacation anyway.
Boy, those were the days. My parents a were supposed to go on a 4 week cruise in March of 2020 and they had a hell of a time getting their money back.
Honestly, apart from the amazingly stupid open bar idea, it seems like the crew and the cruise ship company handled it pretty well. Having 3000 shit covered, malnourished, sleep deprived, and spoiled guests stick on a boat for 5 days, with only 2 evacuations and a full compensation for everyone even though it wasnt legally required. That's a better ending then most of these stories.
Like the fact that it didn't sink even a little bit. There was that Italian ship that sank in shallow water and a bunch of people got trapped and drowned
How is one "spoiled" if they ate covered in shut and malnourished?
@@snookstheoriginal they were referring to them before they got stuck. The common conception of cruise ship vacationers is that they are spoiled and lazy.
@snookstheoriginal Right. I love cruises, and I am thankful that my Carnival cruises have been very nice and never had any disasters. Everything worked properly. I hope that my next cruise doesn't end up a poop ship. 💩🤢🤮
They could have evacuated the vessel with the boats they have. But that would have made them pay more. This was the cheapest solution not the best one
This video's great. No filler, no "What if this was you??", no fictional narrative, no annoying background music, just straight to the point
Any channel or videos you don't like you can dislike and hit the prompt "not interested" you can create you own preferred feed
It was…..great!
@@grantfreeman5327also I think he doesn’t mean that….
@@grantfreeman5327 Sadly the dislike button is about as useful as me, I'll leave my sentence up to interpretation.
@@The-Epic-clone-royal-flower i see channels that are way too energetic and are annoying to watch.. sure the topic is interesting but because of tik tok addicts every youtuber is trying to keep the attention of a 5 year old in a 26 year olds body. I personally favor a more straight forward style and will do whatever i can to keep my feed pure.. not an easy task.
Most people are incapable of handling adversity. Hats off to the crew.
People handled ships basically like this for most of history, lol. We really do have a stunning amount of comfort nowadays
As bad as this is, I was thinking it was a far worse situation. I was thinking it was a stomach virus issue. I've heard of them being rampant on cruise ships, so I thought it was a plumbing AND virus issue, trapped on a ship, which is probably my biggest nightmare to date.
Triangle of sadness be like
I'm shocked this didn't result in a bunch of viral outbreaks.
I’d be afraid of a cholera outbreak in that situation. There was also much higher chances of a salmonella or botulism outbreak, or even deadly typhoid fever if there was a salmonella outbreak. Or how about some hepatitis A lol.
The food was also going bad without refrigeration alongside the sanitation issues, but they were running out of food too; so maybe someone takes a bad risk serving something that’s gone bad and this doesn’t end as well.
That environment was ripe for something bad to happen and in retrospect they are lucky there wasn’t a disease outbreak, especially if people weren’t washing their hands and handling bags of poop.
@@alexburke1899it isn’t the 1800s anymore, changes of cholera outbreak are pretty small
@@hangthed pretty small? I didn't know you hang out daily in rooms filled with sh*t.
will never understand why people would want to trap themselves in a ship with strangers for days in a middle of the ocean.
That’s what i always say, never been on a cruise in my 32 years…. Not likely gonna happen
@@heyikindalikeyou been once, never again.
I find it a great experience. Other types of vacations generally require you to do a bunch of planning, scheduling, budgeting, rentals, and other bookwork. When cruising you simply have to show up to the ship, and afterwards you've got nothing to do but enjoy yourself.
Unless of course the ship turns into a poop cruise.
@@headcrab4 honestly I would have never thought about it this way, but you're so right. I am terrified of the water, but this makes me want to do a cruise 😂
Thats what i told myself when i joined the Navy 🥲🤦🏻♀️💀
I love how it was mentioned they were running out of food. Eating would be the last thing on my mind if the entire ship reeked of feces, and it was seeping up through the floors! I would have been fasting for the duration of my time onboard.
Same. I can't imagine eating on a ship while the stench of human waste is wafting through.
Yeah cool comment and all but no you wouldn't. Sounds like you've never truly went through hunger pains. Research "The Donner Party". I knew a guy who deliberately set out to see how long he could fast. By the 4th day, he said he was so delirious that he wasn't seeing other human beings. He was looking at other humans as something he would eat if it came down to it. The human mind is wired to survive. Period.
You say that now, but I bet after a day or two without eating your hunger would overtake your sense of smell. Your standards go out the window when survival instinct kicks in.
Ya know.......
@figment ofyourimagination fasting isn't something you can up and do........unless of course, you have a disciplined mind. If you up and fast out of no where (especially for 4 days), it's likely your body will wig out.
The first 26 seconds of this video have me CRYING laughing. I just came from a morbid serial killer documentary and the tone shift was WILD 🤣
Im nosey, what documentary?
@@avampirenamedenzi it was a month ago so I'm not exactly sure, but I think it was either Ted Bundy or Jack the Ripper 💀
My family and I were on the Carnival Triumph cruise trip just prior to this one. It was a huge family vacation and we were all so grateful that it didn’t happen to us
Achievement Get: Side stepping a fucking nuke.
Your Lucky
Alexa? This isn't about you. Your shallowness leaks as crap did on this ill fated trip.
same thing here. went with my whole extended family. dodged a bullet
it could happen anytime though. thats a risk yiu take on a ship out in the middle of the ocean with thousands of people. why wouldANYONE waste their vacation money on such a pretentious , environmentally toxic sh*t show? you could use that money to literally spend a week anywhere in the world and you choose to be stuck on a boat with a bunch of strangers? ill never understand. smh
I cant imagine being the person that had to make the announcement asking people to poop in bags 😂
You can hear it in her voice that it wasn't an announcement she ever expected to make... drew the short straw.
I can imagine it... "soooo who tells the passengers?"
Everyone stares at the floor awkwardly.
@@221b-l3tI was about to say they drew straws
I can't imagine having to poop in a bag even. I mean Imagine you are on a cruise with some hot guy, new bf or something. You gotta walk out with your shit bag like a dog.
@@NumberOneCookieMuncher 🤣🤣🤣
@@NumberOneCookieMuncher Your dog carries his own shit bag?
Is this the ship where Mr. Krabs was head chef, famously known as S.S. Diarrhea?
Haha...we went on this ship's first cruise after being cleaned up. It was SPOTLESS and there were Carnival executives on board to make sure nothing went wrong. I saw them all over the ship and at the bar getting drunk.
They probably ripped out all the carpets 😂
Hahaha, same here. Booked a cruise on the ship after it was all cleaned up.
Yeah man, my fiance and I went, too. It's hard to comprehend how BIG that boat is. I remember watching the Packers beat the Lions on a Hail Mary in their sports bar, and the South African bartender putting a Packer helmet on and running around the bar haha
What are the executives going to do if something goes wrong? Hide in their cabins from the riots that’s what.
@@JordonTheo packers shouldn’t have even won that game, you celebrated a meaningless victory Green Bay shouldn’t have even won off a phantom call
Really gives the term 'poop deck' a whole new meaning...
I laughed way harder than I should've
Aah! Mother of Pearl! Fire on the poop deck!
Poop deck? Nah, just pick a spot wherever…
The poop deck ended up as the only part not covered in poop...
😂
Hand of applause to the crew cause you know they dealt with literal and physical shit! They were the glue that held it together!
more like the … you know….
@@elenacampbell5340 more like "you just know"
@@elenacampbell5340i didn’t get it?
I'm your 900th liker here & bye.
@@andrjsjan4231 I'll explain. The original comment says that they were the GLUE that held them together, and the repl is referring to the POOP, because..there was so much of it, and...yeah. Or maybe it isn't, i'm not sure.
'there is no reason to be waiting in the muster stations'
That is when you start launching the rafts
There’s nothing you can do to convince me to go on a cruise vacation.
Plus there has been cases of missing people and s3xu4l assaults happening on cruise ships. And the worst part is that because it's not on land it's hard to prosecute anybody.
My mom was talking about going on a cruise with our cousins next year. I don't plan on going.
Same here, I will never. I saw titanic too many times to trust /j I am genuinely afraid of cruises and larger boats that travel around the world, so much can go wrong and other factors of like SA… nope I’m good
@@Lockon_Stratos good for u
For REAL. I fail to see any upside to cruises (pollution, worker exploitation, and operation negligence for starters) except that the passengers don't want to handle their own passport/travel plans. But the trade off is being locked in a floating hotel with thousands of strangers and their germs?? As an introvert that's my personal hell. If they do stop and get off the ship, they're ushered around expensive tourist traps and then ushered back on board.
If travelers weren't lazy and unimaginative there'd be no market for cruises. I'd rather travel one state over to visit sights and experiences than travel across the sea on one of those hell rafts.
This Poop Cruise was only one year after the Costa Concordia disaster.
Being a cruise ship Provision Master myself, I can not stress enough how crazy that maneuver is that Elation, Conquest and Legend pulled off. Big respect to the respective Provision teams and captains of those ships, that takes some huge balls from everyone involved.
May I ask though why passengers weren't transferred off of Triumph and onto the other three vessels as they came within sufficient proximity to use launches or deploy lifeboats? 🤔
I could understand loss of _amenity_ power on it's own is a mere inconvenience...But when you lose power to _sanitation_ systems to the effect passengers are having to be asked to use more „traditional“ 🇬🇧 methods, that's the point where any opportunity to transfer passengers to other ships ought to be taken. ⛵
Also: Removing 3140 passengers and 1050 staff would have lightened the ship by about 466 metric tons, which would have expedited its tow to Mobile AL and saved a lot of broken lines on the side. 👍
@@dieseldragon6756How should the people get to the other ships? The mentioned ships don't have capabilities to lift lifeboats from the water and you can't transfer people over towlines.
@@dieseldragon6756far far too dangerous and too much of a liability to transfer all of those people in the middle of the ocean. The ships just aren’t built for that purpose.
@@dieseldragon6756 The video went on to describe 35 knot winds and 6 foot (12ft total) high swells. Multiply that by 3000 guests and you have a recipe for disaster in the middle of the ocean.
@@dieseldragon6756 Huge winds, huge waves, and cruise ships that dont have an easy way to board on open water. Do you see how high the ships decks are? Cruise ships like that dont have the capability to lift life boats. The whole process wouldve been needlessly dangerous
even if everything goes smoothly, cruising is literally a floating prison. no escape, be it from bad food, bad entertainment, bad fellow passengers, bad weather, disease. rampaging madmen, sinking, or fire.
name one other vacation option that has so much potential for disaster
Amen, i cannot think of another Vessel humans have made more horribly dumb than a cruise ship, it's hands down the laziest way to travel, and the most boring. if holidays were spicy, cruise ships would be milk or whatever is negative spicy.
Skull Island
florida
Think about this, that cruise ship that tipped over in Italy killed 30 people. That boat didn’t even go completely underwater. Imagine that boat having the same problem in the middle of the ocean. It would’ve been the titanic all over again. Definitely the most vulnerable spot humans can put themselves in
i disagree, based on STATISTICS of SURVIVORS Sarah?
Maybe "they" should offer a CRUISE TITLED " THE PIRATES' CRUISE" and offer a special price with a BYOB..bring your own bag ?
They should have given out bottle water to everyone instead of free liquor!
Of all the 'catastrophic" videos I AGREE; SUBSCRIBING TO THIS ONE. SINCE THE NARRATOR WAS EXTREMELY COMPETENT & ELOQUENT!
There are, actually, much worse scenarios!
MY BET'S ARE WITH "ALL" COAST GUARD FORCES!
COMPARE THIS TO " no survivors" air flights ?
Well, you could VIEW " MENTOUR PILOT videos" , to see all of the malfunctions that can occur on air flights!
When THEY go down, the whole plane goes down...I'm betting on a cruise advertised AND looking at the stats.
(Rick Steves Tours?)
EXCELLENT narrator; on a terribly difficult subject matter. RARE GREAT NARRATION ; thanks for not adding over sensationalized music tracks to enhance the tragedy being reported, too. (such as the Mickey Mouse Manipulated Media does!).
WELL DONE....and they are definitely DARK "records!"
"I Ain't no Middleman!" and
"Riverboat Queen"
Phil Bowen UK and LyndaFaye
I can’t believe that I went on this same ship last October. Luckily it’s been completely renovated and called sunrise now. We at least had a great vacation.
It’s the staff I really
Feel sorry for. I could only imagine that they were expected to carry out normal jobs still in that nightmare while suffering also!
Imagine being on the poop ship and watching another cruise liner with people having a blast deliver you food.😅
I'd jump ship to get on that boat somehow
@@critterwhisperer5821 except you're covered in shit so they would deny you entry
@@critterwhisperer5821they chuck you overboard
@@leeweesqueeQuite literally make you swap the poop deck
🥶
I've never been on a cruise, but every time I think to myself "hey maybe it could be fun one day" one of these kinds of videos popps up in my home feed again and I remember "ah yes, perhaps it won't."
Hey: looks like y'all will be saving a lot of money on the bright side 😂
Same!!! I always get rave reports about crosses and then consider it… but then i remember worst case scenarios lol
Just don’t do anything, don’t go anywhere, enjoy life from the comfort of your room
Don't feed into it.. Just go and have fun... start with 2 to 3 night cruise
It’s a good experience if the company knows what they’re doing
I remember south park had a very quick unnoticeable line when someone was watching the news: "passengers said the carnival cruise smelled like poop, but that was an improvement"
The crew handled everything as best they could. Also, great job from the CEO for getting everyone free flights home and their money back despite company policy saying he didn't have to.
Right? This situation was awful but honestly Carnival handled it as well as it could be handled!
The C.E.O had to offer goodwill to the passengers to salvage the reputation of Carnival cruises. Any negative publicity is bad publicity. He could not follow the company policy of no refunds without doing irreparable damage to the company’s image and reputation.
Bull Shil! My family and I were there, we KNOW what really happened and how Carnival and many cruise lines REALLY operate. Carnival made the best deal to come out of bad PR and pay the least amount of $$$$$. A refund, $500 and a free cruise will NEVER make up for the PTSD, nightmares and rash I still live with and experience almost daily. YOU try facing death at sea and the very real fear of watching your children drown then come back and tell me how much you appreciated the CEO and crew for how they "handled" the entire situation! It was a BAD experience that will HAUNT my life until the day I die. I'm a tough, old, 70 year-old broad but there are some things you can never forget or forgive. I have a deep suspicion that that fire may have been caused by neglect rather than an accident. Seems to me, if that could be proven then ALL contracts, including the tickets for that cruise, become null and void. Of course, you can't fight big money so no lawsuit could result in the truth. They DID owe the passengers regardless of what the contract said. I will NEVER forgive Carnival for what happened! And I will always try to tell others what REALLY happened on board the Triumph, 2013.
That’s the only positive thing
@@arnolddavies6734Exactly, he pretty much had to.
I remember the offical statments that Carnival was putting out during this ordeal. They kept saying that "things are under control." Anyone with experience at sea, things were definantly NOT under control. When the tugs are repeatedly breaking lines in relatively calm conditions, the margin for error was razor thin. Any sort of adverse weather, and that ship would have been dead in the water, adrift, limited food and water, no environmental controls, and over 3000 people on board. Loss of life in those conditions would be expected.
Edited to correct the number of people on board.
and the gulf is known for adverse weather conditions, geez, they were lucky
I will never understand why the USCG didn't evacuate that ship of all non-essential crew.
@@andrewyork3869 It's entirely likely they offered to do so on multiple occasions and were basically inches from forcing it.
@@dustycarrier4413 that makes magnitudes more sense.
Whenever people say "Things are under control" it seems to mean "things are emphatically NOT under control, and we are currently desperately trying to keep them from getting even more out of control.".
As a germophobe with crippling OCD this is my worst nightmare. I honestly would have thrown myself overboard. Super terrifying.
Sooooo, COVID isn't your worst nightmare 😂
You probably could have swam to shore faster than they got there
@@Rock-Bottem1982 You're saying a ship with hallways full of bags of poop isn't yours?
Into the Poop Soup by Fish
@@jakeryker546 it beats the
Titanic I guess …
What amazes me is that the ship captain didn't call out Mayday and didn't evacuate the ship when it was clear that the condition is getting worse and passengers are suffering.
I don't know much about cruises, but I would guess there were just too many people to evacuate them. You'd have to interrupt/end another ship's cruise, and put everybody on an extremely crowded ship, or have like 3 or 4 other ships so you could distribute people evenly...and then they'd probably all have to be Carnival ships, and I doubt there were that many within the area. You could also maybe just get a few people at a time on a bunch of smaller boats but that would be extremely tedious. They were stuck right in the middle of the Gulf of Mexico. Hard to get to and from ports.
Evacuating over 3,000 people in the middle of the gulf of Mexico would be a monumental task, and unnecessarily dangerous, and crazy expensive...
He wanted to see the hot chicks pooping in bags 😂😂😂😂
You only issue mayday calls if there is immediate, life threatening danger to the people on board or the vessel itself. Mayday calls are not treated lightly, this would at best be a pan pan call. Either way, rescuing that many people would be a massive undertaking, which doesnt make sense if people's lives arent endangered
Couldn't the ship have easily been evacuated to shore?
I went on this cruise in 2019 and 3 things astounded me. 1- no one knew that this was the infamous Carnival poop cruise, and 2-it still smelled like poop and 3- the sewers still backed up into the rooms.
wow lol
It all sounds so lovely.
I bet it’s a cheap ship now haha
I truly doubt that the reason that it smelled like poop was because of this instance it was most likely due to the sewage overflow you mentioned. I'm taking a educated guess that those sewage problems were caused by a guest flushing something that shouldn't have gone down the toilet. Marine sewage systems are very sensitive beasts.
@@spikefivefivefive 😂😂😂
So this basically went from a seemingly nice cruise to what it would’ve been like to be a sailor/pirate in the 17th to 18th century
Exactly what i was thinking, if you took an early 1700s pirate operating out of the West Indies and put him on this cruise he would’ve found everything to be very hygienic and wonder why people were were freaking out bothering to take dumps in bags
ONLY ( write this down for future novels btw) PIRATES DIDN'T HAVE PLASTIC!
They didn't destroy the fish populations either!
They should have given out bottle water to everyone instead of free liquor!
Of all the 'catastrophic" videos I AGREE; SUBSCRIBING TO THIS ONE.
There are, actually, much worse scenarios!
MY BET'S ARE WITH "ALL" COAST GUARD FORCES!
COMPARE THIS TO " no survivors" air flights ?
Well, you could VIEW " MENTOUR PILOT videos" , to see all of the malfunctions that can occur on air flights!
When THEY go down, the whole plane goes down...I'm betting on a cruise advertised AND looking at the stats.
(Rick Steves Tours?)
EXCELLENT narrator; on a terribly difficult subject matter. RARE GREAT NARRATION ; thanks for not adding over sensationalized music tracks to enhance the tragedy being reported, too. (such as the Mickey Mouse Manipulated Media does!).
WELL DONE....and they are definitely DARK "records!"
"I Ain't no Middleman!" and
"Riverboat Queen"
Phil Bowen UK and LyndaFaye
@@ethanp7183They shat right into the sea and the deck was scrubbed daily. Yeah it wasn't great but not like that. Hard work though, they stuffed them with 7000 kcal and plenty of rum.
Yeah it's what all our ancestors went through to come to America back in the day lol
The crew deserve a huge bonus for continuing their work, while also going through the same challenges as the passengers.
It was supposed to be a vacation, but turned to four-five days of suffering. At least it was only Sunday-Thursday.
Some people go through ice storms that knock out power for weeks, cutting off the well pump, the heat, and the ability to travel out of the outage area. They get no refunds, and Mother Nature never apologizes.
In regions where such storms do happen, people have wood stoves as reserve heating at least. Also candles, stormlamps, sometimes electricity generators.
Or, if it's a city, there is central heating, water and gas which comes in underground pipes. So what you really don't have in this case is light and smart devices - and that's it.
Also if it’s cold enough for ice storms it’s generally cold enough to put food outside for refrigeration
No one is suffering in there own shit every day by choice
Currently watching this sitting on Carnival Glory, looking right at Carnival Sunrise, which is the renamed Triumph.
boutta be on the magic, hope all goes well loll
Been on Glory, really nice ship and lovely staff. Wouldn’t want to sail on Carnival again however
@@VermyScrubsi’ve never been on a cruise but have been thinking of it here and there. what specifically do you dislike about Carnival, what is it about them compared to the others that you wouldn’t ride Carnival again? genuine question
@@anaism.5821 To quote Bright Sun Films “Carnival is the Walmart of Cruise Lines”. They’re “often” the cheaper ones but does that cheapness reflect on their product. I went with the lowest type of cabin on Carnival and their biggest competition out of Miami, Royal Caribbean. RC’s product is better then Carnival on a lot of aspects. My cabin on Carnival had a lot of flaws and seemed a bit run down while RC’s felt slightly better. The food on Carnival was lackluster and was just average at best, RC’s despite being slightly more expensive was probably dealing with its lowest being an average. Activities onboard where completely different, Carnival was more of a family outing ship while RC despite opening up to the family still had that grown up experience from the previous century. I can’t really speak on that though since I did go on Carnival as a child while I went on RC when I’m basically an adult, but from what I heard from my parents The only thing that really suited them was a couple of bars and a casino on Carnival. I really can’t compare the staff because both of them were great (all though RC had one asshole). That’s really all I could think about them right now. I wouldn’t go out of my way to avoid Carnival, my comment is clearly hyperbole but it would be far from my first choice. I used to like Carnival deeply but ultimately that was when I was a child and my views have shifted.
@@anaism.5821 I'm british and I'd never ride carnival if I got the chance. I've never been on a cruise either and this may have put me off going on any cruise line but im not sure
I'm just glad nobody got sick there - with the sewage system going haywire and with people pooping on bags. The crew deserve medal. They did their best. Salute
To say that this was the poop cruise from hell insinuates that they may be a poop cruise from heaven, too, but I'm not sure if I'm willing to go down that rabbit hole.
bruh 😆💀👍
😋
😂🤣🤣👏👏👏
Hell ya man!
Coprophiles would love a poop cruise.
You have to pay extra for that cruise 😂
the fact that the ship continued causing havoc even after the passengers had been freed from it, even resulting in someone's death like nah this ship is cursed
He covered that...
@@mattwolf7698 I know? I was commenting on it lol why are you pressed
@@inuyasha1014 Some people are just stoopid.
@@LeTangKichiro and you seem to be a shining example of that
@@mattwolf7698 Wow, you're such a scholar. STFU.
Man it must have SUCKED for those employees in particular. Having to go through the same shit, but with thousands of passengers probably still expecting them to take care of them. Tbh, in a situation like that, it should become a group effort. There are no employees and vacationers anymore. Everybody should pull whatever weight they can
Literally going through the same shit
Sure, in an ideal world. but the passengers paid for the trip, and the employees are getting paid, as shitty as the pay might be.
And who knows what shitty jobs the passengers got paid for in order to buy the tickets for that trip. I'm sure a lot of them have pretty shitty jobs.
Plus, it would be terrible pr for the company if they didn't do whatever they could to make it easier for the passengers
@@blueclover9918 there’s little reason why this couldn’t have been an “ideal world” scenario. There’s no point in keeping score when the situation is that dire and everyone is literally in the same boat. I personally don’t think I’d feel right having the staff take care of me knowing they’re going through the same horrible thing just because they’re getting paid $15 an hour. It’s a mutually traumatizing experience, all thoughts about who’s making what money and the company’s reputation are going out the window.
And technically, although it was afterwards and they had no way of knowing at the time, the passengers did wind up receiving a decent amount of compensation.
@@shortking-vp9vv who paid and who is getting paid does make a difference.
They paid for the privilege of having the trip - which wasn't even what they paid for. I mean I could totally understand if it were a life-and-death issue, but say what you might, it wasn't. If it were life-and-death, absolutely. But it wasn't at that point.
@@blueclover9918 "your money can't save you any more then it can save me" a line from Titanic......
And it is still in Carnival's fleet today! Enjoy your time on the 'new' Carnival Sunrise! It's like a phoenix rising at dawn out of the ashes of it's old poo encrusted interior.
A poonix, if you will
Just took a cruise on the Sunrise last month. Carnival did a great job of rebuilding the ship. Thankfully there were no issues 👍🏾
Like they were just going to sink it. In hindsight they handled the situation as best as they could after the fact.
You got one "It's" right, then the next "its" wrong. Good job.
@@jennacided6502 I will not, but I still got a good snicker out of it.
When they say “make your way back to your cabins”, it’s time to deploy the nearest lifeboat.
Freaking EXACTLY. Remember, ignoring a "shelter in place" order is how so many people from Morgan Stanley survived 9/11.
@@nerysghemor5781 also, "stay in your apartments" killed most people in burning Grenfell Tower.
My thoughts exactly!
@@Lili-xq9sn Yep, I was thinking of that one too.
Shelter in place: making it easier to find bodies since the late 1800s😅
You couldn't force me on a cruise ship at gun point.
i wasn't going to
As someone who works hospitality, tossing free alcohol at already upset and annoying guests is ALWAYS a decision passed down from the executive or corporate 😂 no one with a brain would EVER make that decision.
Okay I bet if you added up all the pros and cons from the free drinks, it was a net positive lol
They’re like “guests got too drunk and started throwing stuff over board”
Sounds like they had a fun time and no one really got hurt 😂
(But ur right lol)
“Floating Petrie dish” has stuck with me for 10 years.. thanks to this incident, I’ve never wanted to go on a cruise 😂
More like a floating septic tank.
Cruises suck went on one with Royal Caribbean lamest shit ever F that.
Did this coin the term? I know people who always call them that. I guess I know why now...
Imagine how frustrating it must have been to see all the other ships and helicopters coming and going for days and not being able to actually get on any of them. I get that transferring between vessels at sea is tricky but at some point you're just going to want to go anywhere else whatever it takes
It’s simple the other ships were already full
I think i woulda said fuck it and jumped off to catch the ladder/rope
It really comes down to the fact that transferring between vessels at sea is dangerous and done only in case of a full emergency. From the Captains perspective, his ship was afloat, stable, under tow, and no one was in danger of immediate harm. While crappy (hah!) and uncomfortable, keeping them aboard was less risky than an evacuation in open water.
Imagine a floundering cruise ship like the Oceanos when the crew abandoned ship and the entertainer (Moss Hills) took over to ensure everyone of the 100s of passengers were safely plucked off the ship by helicopter-rescue. 🛳💜
Just Call Some FisherBoat And Use A Rope To Get Down
five days of no electricity and pooping in bags in exchange for two free vacations and $500 sounds like a good deal to me
After the Sewol incident, I never trusted any ships staffs/annoucement that says "go back/stay at your cabins everything is under control".
If you know anything by now, especially being an American, them telling you "its under control" for anything means it is not under control at all and things are going to get much much worse. It is used as a psychological clutch to control and subvert a mass panic scenario which would lead to a crush event or mass fatalities.
And Costa concordia
One incident does not establish a pattern you can rely upon to predict future events
@@Syclone0044 there's multiple incidents though
After Titanic incident I never trusted any ships, and I wasn't even born yet 😂
12:48 I’m quite sure the one person injured and one person dead isn’t due to Carnival Triumph crashing after it broke lose. They were in a guard shack on a nearby pier, which collapsed during the high winds, same event broke Triumph lose.
Absolutely what I was gonna say
"the toilets aren't working, please help yourself to all the alcohol you want" 😳
With added panic, what could go wrong? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
😮no way that could backfire
That struck me, too. NOT a great idea.
all they had to do was make drink tickets to limit the drinks per hour and it would of went fine
i think i'll have another drinkypoo ( just 9 likes ? really ?) You people are sick.
Opening the bar was probably the dumbest decision they could possibly have made. Like seriously what were they thinking?
Whenever cruise liner staff tells you, that "everything is under control", grab your first-aid kit and pump up your life-vest.
Not necessarily - there are minor incidents fairly often and they generally are under control in a very short time. Plus it's super important to listen to the crew, who have trained extensively for emergency situations. But people should definitely be vigilant and not blindly follow instruction that clearly puts them in danger.
@@Caroline-rv8wy I've heard the stories where the crew has told the passengers to remain in their cabin while the ship is sinking (that one Korean ferry) and they died. No way that's gonna be me. I wouldn't be sprinting down the hallway and jumping off the deck first sign of a fire alarm, but I would definitely have a plan to get out (probably something stupid like jumping out my window)
@@perrybb2 I know it's happened, I'm just saying generally speaking there are a lot of minor incidents on cruise ships that are easily handled. It's super important to pay attention to safety briefings and where your muster station is, but when you hear the initial announcements you just have to be vigilant and prepared to move if you need to, until you hopefully hear the stand down - I remember one where the Captain came on the loudspeaker afterward and said ''everything's fine now, some idiot put tennis shoes in the dryer.'' 😅 But like I said, you also need to use common sense and don't just follow blindly even if you're seeing something that goes directly against what you're being told.
@@Caroline-rv8wy better safe than sorry, that's my motto. There are a lot of ways to kick the bucket, and drowning's probably the worst (especially drowning in saltwater, which takes longer and is more painful than drowning in fresh water)
@@perrybb2 yes but panic is most likely to cause more issues... like a stampede, riot, etc. What's putting on a life jacket gonna get you? Where you going to go? The ship sinks then what? You float in freezing cold water for days?
I could only imagine being trapped on this boat with these people. These are not the kind of people you want to be going through this situation with. When it was said they opened the bar I spit out my drink laughing.
Like honestly. Talk about one of the most ill advised decisions ever made…ever! 😂
@@dionst.michael1482 Yeah but if you are stuck on a ship of pissed off people. opening the bar probably calmed a lot of them down. As long as they limit the amount per person. They probably also realized there are a lot of alcoholics who will have seizures or get real sick without alcohol. Then you have a bigger issue.
Imagine the 1st class passengers on the Titanic. The entitlement in a real life or death situation must've been very real!
I've never wanted to go on a cruise, so thanks for reinforcing that conviction.
There are several nice, smaller luxury cruise lines. Carnival is definitely not one of them. And, I avoid the Caribbean cruises completely. Trashy, party crowd.
I went on a Disney cruise when I was thirteen with my (divorced) grandparents. We pretty much immediately wished that we'd just stayed at Disney World the entire time, instead of three days at the resort and four days on the cruise. Boo, I say. It wasn't terrible (first day seasickness aside), it just wasn't great either.
@@westhavenor9513yeah… I’ll never be doing another carnival or possibly Caribbean cruise. On top of all that it’s so fucking hot and humid, which I personally am not at all used to
Nah, you can never convince me to go on a cruise. Fuck that.
@@rottenapple_ what if your family was going and they offered you a ticket?
Let's be honest, this is the best story many of these people will ever have.
That’s so sad.
What the monotony of life does to a mf smh
They ride cruise ships, so that pretty much goes without saying.
haha
The most unusual, maybe. I'm 99% sure they would rather it never happened.
I was reluctant to go on a cruise but this has me sold
To whoever thought having an open bar was a good idea when food and water are limited and the bathrooms don't function, my hat goes off to you. Not many would have dared to give a bunch of irate, hungry, dirty people unlimited booze, but hey, what better time to give the most realistic reenactment of the life of real pirates than being stranded at sea with nothing but old hard bread and booze. 😂
Fellow alcoholics unite!
the pirates might actually be cleaner. they'd just take a wee or a dump on the side, straight to the great big blue.
Honstley in this situation I would want to drink lol eps the smell and soaked bathroom carpets yikes and the corn chunks
A ship full of drunken strangers is my idea of hell. Poop or no poop.💩
I wouldn't go on a cruise for free.
I love how this video makes it sound like the vacationers had it worse 😂😂, the crew is stuck on the same ship, but is getting all the blame and has to work while being able to do nothing about it
Yuppp
Except that the crew was being paid to be there. And the costumers were spending and getting poop in return (LOL).
Bro imagine how much of the staff probably quit I bet you a lot of them quit I would have too
@@alien666-bs1ih "Which is exactly why it's worse. If you're going to be in a terrible situation, do you want no obligations, or a whole list of obligations on top of every other complicated factor? Especially when, as someone pointed out, your pay is extremely minimal because they factor part of your "pay" as the food and living quarters, which were what were affected." --Someone else who commented this to someone who said something similar.
@@41052 You're ignoring the money. Let's say you have to be in a situation of suffering, but you can choose: to pay 1000 to be there, or to earn 1000 to be there. What would you choose?
The obligations are part of the work to earn money. You work and you get money in return. The crew was not getting obligations in return for nothing, but in return for money. Actually they had the option to quit the job and do nothing.
The customers were not earning anything, they were spending and getting nothing in return, being in the same situation as the crew.
We’re in a septic emergency. I know what will cheer people up! Booze! Absolutely nothing can go wrong!
“Please make your way back to your cabins.”
I’d be like, “hell NO! I’ve seen Titanic!” 😳
Darker, didn’t the announcements after the 1st plant hit the world trade building that it was fine to go back to their desks?
@@jenniferbond7073 the second plane: *Insert that rizz guy here*
Exactly, I will be staying at that muster station for hours until I’m absolutely sure I don’t have to be there
😆
Same, after the Costa Concordia.
4:31 The narrator starts laughing but tries not to! Saying “poop bags” really cracked him up.
There was one last little slap in the face that was left out of this. One of the buses taking passengers to the airport broke down before it could leave the port.
Well thats really bad luck xD
Like Planes Trains and Automobiles 😅
That's crazy bad luck 💀
An open bar on shop where there’s already an epidemic going on, nobody can use the toilet and everyone sleeping on the deck. Sounds like a perfect plan to create disaster
I can never get enough of the Poop Cruise
Whole new meaning to the poop deck 😂
And they certainly heard some swash buckling when they walked on them carpets.
😅
I'm your 100th liker because of this comment of yours. Goodbye.
Yeah🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yugioh reference?
Always thought the poop deck was a funny term, but WTF
It's a funny yet legit term. The poop deck is where they would dump the sewage off the ship in the times when ships didn't have sewage systems.
All the cringy passangers constantly making "poop deck" jokes is what would have driven me to jump off the ship.
@@quintomalley1196not quite, the Poop deck was the top deck of the stern (rear of the ship). It’s an English translation of the French “La Poupe” meaning stern. Also, if a wave comes over the back of the ship (very dangerous) it’s called “being pooped”.
@@jst7714 i was about to say this. I also corrected some people making some "dark age" jokes in The comment section 🥴 a lot of myths hanging around
Imagine being a member of cleaning staff entering the ship after docking... 😂 Wonderful job
This kinda reminds me early on during the COVID thing there was a ship out at sea that suffered a COVID outbreak and they wouldn't allow the ship to dock anywhere or allow any passengers to disembark. This ship stayed out in the ocean for something like 3 weeks. This is barbaric and inhumane treatment of people.
I forget if they were delayed entry, but they were allowed to dock in Japan. It looks harsh, but given the totality of circumstances, primarily the limited idea as to what the hell exactly was going on, it wasn't the worst call. Not ideal but not overtly evil as well. Japan has far, far too much of a sense of honor to just scuttle the ship. (Something I would worry about certain southeast Asian nations doing)
i heard about that, you'd think that we'd be civilized enough to not resort to archaic plague tactics
If it was on the early stages of the virus pandemic wich there wasn't a cure i guess could have been a safety precaution to avoid spreading ? Im just guessing
Diamond Princess. Quarantined in Yokohama harbor. Was happening in February, just before everything shut down in March.
@@TheWatchernator specially if it was during the time there wasn't any kind of cure to fight the covid
To say it’s was a fire on a ferry 5 days from land, in the the engine room as well, and managed to control it and keep everyone alive with just 26 medical issues tells me they did something right
Wow, that's a really good point, this could have been a true disaster.
Carnival is absolutely great at dealing with disaster’s, I speak from experience when I was on the Carnival Pride last summer (it’s propulsion broke down in Germany)
Thanks for letting us know that the ship’s new name is SUNRISE. Those sneaky devils.
its more like... sunsept
Toiletwater-rise
Maybe it was just a normal name change YEARS after
Holy shit really? I’ve been on the Sunrise! It was an alright cruise, nothing went wrong, but I never knew that.
6:03 "Offering free beer and wine after the fire"
Ah yes, serving alcohol to people who are already stressed out due to an emergency situation. Absolutely brilliant idea. What could POSSIBLY go wrong?
"How was your cruise?" "It was crappy!"
This is the main reason I would never go on a cruise at least on land if the hotel sucks you could probably just find a nicer one but on a ship you are stuck .
Nah, there's just shy of a million reasons I'll never go willingly... I was dumb enough to sign up for the Navy out of high school... and I learned quite a lot (I didn't want to know) about ships and shipboard life...
EVERYTHING is worse at sea. You're hundreds of miles from land, anything or anyone to help you, and stuck in a tin-can sharing air with God only knows who or from where... If you've even been to College or Summer Camp, you know what happens when you bring a bunch of people from thousands of miles apart together on the same ground, and those are with plenty of open spaces and air... Now, seal all that up with a half-assed ventilation system that was built by the LOWEST possible bidder.
Saline is a solution used in medical facilities to keep humans alive, which is to say, it's NOT harmful to any life. It's the perfect medium for delivery of just about everything... just add whatever to a saline drip, and you can put it directly inside a body... no harm.
Now, take into account that the salt water of the sea gets turned directly into mist to add to humidity... and you've got saline free-flowing everywhere and completely compatible with all living things, including algae, fungi, and all manners of microbes from bacteria to virus... ALL settling and swirling through the "ventilated tin-can" in the middle of nowhere squared.
Yeah... THOSE are just some of the basic foundation of why I will never in hell willingly go on a cruise if I can possibly avoid it... AND I've BEEN both dry caving AND cave diving in my life. I have no problems with either of those "extreme activities"... I ride a motorcycle... I track down and wrangle reptiles, specializing in snakes mostly... I'm no stranger to "calculated risk assessment".
People are WEIRD creatures. ;o)
And planes crash. What's your point?
@aguyandhiscomputer you're stuck on a plane for 6 hours not a week
Also you forget that cruise ships sail internationally in invalid waters and thus are immune to any legal or justice system. They have to police themselves (which they do not).
@@MrWolfSnack I know they is even a true crime series dedicated to it. It's shocking how many people vanish at sea
All it takes is one person with a infection that spreads through fecal matter or similar waste and that becomes a whole new nightmare. Lmao
Especially if that infection is norovirus.
I’ve had C Diff and if there was anyone on that ship that also had it it would have been a crisis. C Diff is no joke.
@@alloralou4722 what’s C-Diff?
@@sentinelDJ707 C-Diff is a very infectious gut disease that spreads through spores and is hard to get rid of. Commonly, it is caused by anti-botics killing off the good bacteria and leaving c-diff to reign.
If you have c-diff in the hospital, you are quatentined. And using disinfectant does not work! You need warm water and soap.
Hopefully this teaches cruise lines around the world a valuable lesson about looking over and testing for errors early on