Why should you read Dante’s “Divine Comedy”? - Sheila Marie Orfano

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,6 тис.

  • @Jack-zx1vq
    @Jack-zx1vq 5 років тому +5670

    In Italy, we spend three years studying this in high school. On third year we study the Inferno, on fourth the Purgatorio, and on last year the Paradiso. It’s so important for our language and culture. And I think the Purgatorio may be my favorite part.

    • @Nicks721
      @Nicks721 5 років тому +207

      Sorry my friend,may I ask if there are any significant differences between Dante's Italian and modern Italian. Are there many words that you don't use any more or differences in grammar or syntax? I want to learn Italian since I am Greek and all Greeks love you♥️♥️ and I love Dante,I know many of his lines in Italian ( not sure if I pronounce them always right 😅) so I wonder how close is the language of Dante to modern Italian. Thanks in advance!!!

    • @Jack-zx1vq
      @Jack-zx1vq 5 років тому +380

      @@Nicks721 well thanks! Greeks and Italians are like cousins, southern Europe squad! I loved visiting Greece!
      Anyway, yes there are many differences, because this is old Italian. But the first Italian (we call it volgare) comes from it, and so the language evolved in times, but a lot of italian words comes from Dantes. As they say in the video, the language of the rich people, the elite of the times, who studied, was Latin, and common people used to speak this ancient form of Italian, especially in Tuscany and Florence area (in the various parts of Italy, other people used to speak their dialects or different languages). So Italian comes from the Tuscany dialect, and Dante wrote the Comedy with this.
      Many words we use come from the Divine Comedy, he also invented many words we use today. But it's really difficult to read it. I'm Italian, but sometimes the reading can be very hard if you don't have notes or informations (in fact, the books where we study the Comedy, always have a lot of notes and informations at the bottom of the pages to help us understand). So I don't know, you could try read it, but if you don't know Italian it can be very hard!

    • @Nicks721
      @Nicks721 5 років тому +40

      @@Jack-zx1vq thank you very much for your answer!!

    • @MicheleGardini
      @MicheleGardini 5 років тому +132

      @@Nicks721 Giacomo Vicario is right, language sometimes is difficoult, words itself aren't much different from modern italian but construction is much more, and it's all written in verses, so Dante used many licences too. But that's not the only reason why the text needs a lot of comments and we spent 3 years on it, it's a matter of meanings too. Dante used a lot of metaphors, double or even triple meanings, references to history, science, theology or contemporary (by his time) events, and sometimes all this is so well hidden and overlying that you can't figure out without help. It's sometimes like to solve the greater puzzle you have ever found: really compelling, but so satisfying.

    • @Nicks721
      @Nicks721 5 років тому +23

      @@MicheleGardini thank you too! I love Dante and I know the complexity of his poetry with all those historical, biblical etc references, but I was referring to the language. I understand what you say about the liberties he took since he wrote in a very strict form ( terza rima) and it is natural that the structure of some phrases may look strange ( although many times the strange position of the words increases the emphasis and the beauty of the phrases). But I have an edition of the divine comedy in Italian and Greek translation and using my knowledge of English and a few Latin we did in school,I was able to follow the Italian text( not every time of course),I mean to understand the structure of the phrase and that the words I don't understand correspond to those words of the translation. So I imagine that Italian people will have no problem , putting aside the problems of the poetical use of language or the difficulties of the meaning. Thanks again for your answer.

  • @starcloak
    @starcloak 5 років тому +4064

    This channel actually makes me interested in history and literature, through videos like this.

    • @christiandahms8846
      @christiandahms8846 5 років тому +15

      That's really good that you do 😊 If you know your history, you can know just about anything. That's my quote 😉

    • @lalboimanlun1230
      @lalboimanlun1230 5 років тому +1

      Same here....
      And I'm glad for this.

    • @ThatReadingGuy28
      @ThatReadingGuy28 5 років тому +22

      Literature is amazing. Get off Instagram and read a classic book instead.

    • @donpula6349
      @donpula6349 5 років тому +3

      Me too I was fond on both subjects.

    • @thejoyofreading7661
      @thejoyofreading7661 5 років тому

      I talk about Dante on my channel if you're interested :)

  • @HarshVardhan-ps6fm
    @HarshVardhan-ps6fm 5 років тому +9555

    Pope: exiles Dante
    Dante: I'm about to end this man's whole career

  • @femboyv2006
    @femboyv2006 5 років тому +7139

    When you still don't read Divine comedy after watching this video
    " _he_ _who_ _desires_ _but_ _acts_ _not_ , _breeds_ _pestilence_ "

  • @KiddoLoLOfficial
    @KiddoLoLOfficial 5 років тому +1970

    The "Divina Commedia" is a poem about everything. In it you can discover history, mythology, philosophy, religion... It's an encyclopedia, a book about the knowledge of Dante's age. And Dante wanted to share this with everyone, so he used the common language, the "volgare", instead of the latin, the language of culture.
    The adjective "divina" (divine) was added by another important italian literaly man, Giovanni Boccaccio.
    The word "commedia" (comedy) indicates a story with a bad beginning and a good ending.
    We italians study the "Divina Commedia" in the middle and high school and it's unforgetable!

    • @ThatReadingGuy28
      @ThatReadingGuy28 5 років тому +46

      I wish I studied it in school

    • @alishbaali7223
      @alishbaali7223 5 років тому +30

      Boy, do I envy you

    • @mhm77887
      @mhm77887 5 років тому +13

      That's what I wanna study in literature, instead we read our national poems ENDLESSLY (I don't mind it, but there's no other option almost ever) and other not so interesting stuff. Analyzing legendary, ancient books, thats what I wanna do.

    • @KiddoLoLOfficial
      @KiddoLoLOfficial 5 років тому +47

      @@mhm77887 Well, we do the same things in Italy. I mean, we study the "Aeneid" (I know, it's Latin, but it was fundamental for Italian literature), the "Divina Commedia" (with other works/poems by Dante), the "Decameron" by Boccaccio, "I Promessi Sposi" by Manzoni and the Leopardi's poems. Obviously this is only the main core of the literature study, but it's only about Italian works. For example I study English literature (God saves Coleridge!) thanks to my English teacher. I think all the literature works are wonderful, it's the student/teacher's approch that make them interesting or not.

    • @Marco_Venieri
      @Marco_Venieri 5 років тому +32

      @@KiddoLoLOfficial all literature is beautiful. In Italy there's Dante, in Spain Cervantes, in Germany Goethe, in America Withman, in Britain Shakespeare, in Greece Homer

  • @Keriously
    @Keriously 5 років тому +3921

    The most succesful self insert ever written

    • @udayyysharma1501
      @udayyysharma1501 3 роки тому +29

      ahh yes

    • @void735
      @void735 3 роки тому +81

      Well important detail is he does not portray himself as better. Even tho he talks down to some of The sinners hes portrayed as being equal foolish by Virgilus

    • @ZephLodwick
      @ZephLodwick 3 роки тому +61

      He wrote a fan-fiction so popular that Tuscan became the lingua franca of the Italian peninsula.

    • @guskiraman
      @guskiraman 3 роки тому +59

      But a well made and honest self insert. Not like saying "oh yeah, this is the story of Dante, son of Jesus Christ" but literally just himself in a Fantasy scenario, detached from his ego

    • @Idonotseeafatherinyourcontacts
      @Idonotseeafatherinyourcontacts 2 роки тому +1

      @@udayyysharma1501 of

  • @francescol3
    @francescol3 5 років тому +3084

    First day in my Italian school. At the gates someone has just wrote: "Abandon all hope ye who enter here". Me: "It's not going to be that bad"... I WAS WRONG

    • @yuruyukii
      @yuruyukii 5 років тому +186

      BRO PEOPLE THINK ITALIANS SLACK, THEY JUST HAVE NEVER SEEN HSCHOOLS HERE

    • @christophermercaldi8616
      @christophermercaldi8616 5 років тому +8

      lol man sorry to hear that

    • @francescol3
      @francescol3 5 років тому +7

      @@yuruyukii lol

    • @silvasilvasilva
      @silvasilvasilva 5 років тому +78

      My local Italian school (founded by Italian migrants) is named after Dante Alighieri. Maybe they meant something else with that name... 🤔

    • @NICO_THE_PRO
      @NICO_THE_PRO 5 років тому +55

      Back when I was in middle school (Italy), 4 years ago, we and the teacher put up on our class door as a joke "Abandon all hope ye who enter here" in Italian. It was a fun year

  • @Old_Harry7
    @Old_Harry7 4 роки тому +1110

    The most fascinating thing about Dante's work is that EVERY (not even joking EVERY line) has a double or even triple secret meaning. (Both Masonic, mythical or alchemical.)
    People to this day are trying to figure out what he was secretly saying in some lines and it's very fascinating to me.
    Truly a genius.
    I'm so proud of being Italian.

    • @polimpiastro9857
      @polimpiastro9857 4 роки тому +79

      "Literal, moral, allegorical and anagogical"

    • @mariomaiorano1859
      @mariomaiorano1859 4 роки тому +9

      daje

    • @gabbysmith4208
      @gabbysmith4208 3 роки тому +39

      This was a very Italian way to end a comment

    • @matei3880
      @matei3880 3 роки тому +1

      Read Guenon

    • @jeremias-serus
      @jeremias-serus 3 роки тому +4

      @@polimpiastro9857 The use of allegorical here would not apply here as the device of having multiple meanings itself is allegory.

  • @dondean6402
    @dondean6402 5 років тому +770

    Guys, I’m italian and here we must study the Divine Comedy all through middle and high school. Everyone falls in love with it (especially the Inferno part.) The Divine Comedy is a masterpiece of creativity, love, hate, monstrosity and politics. Every sentence rhymes with the next one, we memorize certain parts since we are little kids, before we even know what they mean. Everyone one here, even the elders, the one who went to war and didn’t study at all, knows certain quotes and the general story. Everything is so well created, so meaningful and omniscient, it feels like something that goes behind time and place. Yeah, of course it’s about religion and christianity but there’s so much more than that. (I’m an atheist) It’s about the creation of the fictional world, the message and the characters who are all people that really existed in time, and how Dante Alighieri decides to portrait them. I wish more people around the world knew about the Divine Comedy because it is truly something

    • @ariannabinaghi5222
      @ariannabinaghi5222 3 роки тому +23

      Everyone kind of hates it eventually but yeah it's THE masterpiece

    • @darkahrenn1570
      @darkahrenn1570 3 роки тому +11

      Non so se odio sia una parola giusta per quel libro, se lo studio non fosse stato obbligatorio però mi dispiace ammettere che onestamente è un capola

    • @allegraalberoni
      @allegraalberoni 3 роки тому +20

      "Everyone falls in love with it" I burnt my books after my exam. No one falls in love with it thanks to italian school, they make it a burden to go through and a pain to revisit.

    • @mansuetitudinale
      @mansuetitudinale 3 роки тому +2

      Oh my God I tought It was terribile but now i'm studying It and i love It!! Im Just sad we dont read it (we did It fast) so Its a bit confusing.. but i bought the book sooo.. YAY!! Im probably doing the classical school so I'm studying It.. dante... Un capolavoro

    • @carolinegeorge13
      @carolinegeorge13 3 роки тому +5

      I'm Italian. I adore literature. But boy do I hate the Divine Comedy (though I agree that Inferno is the best part)

  • @DeliciousApricotCake
    @DeliciousApricotCake 5 років тому +1292

    "Lasciate ogni speranza o voi che entrate"
    The most iconic line for Italian students

    • @avimannuxbz3454
      @avimannuxbz3454 5 років тому +1

      What's that in English?

    • @vaibhavpandey7202
      @vaibhavpandey7202 5 років тому +112

      @@avimannuxbz3454 Abandon all hope, ye who enter here.

    • @DeliciousApricotCake
      @DeliciousApricotCake 5 років тому +31

      @@avimannuxbz3454 it's the Italian for "Abandon hope all ye who enter there"

    • @sleepingbackbone7581
      @sleepingbackbone7581 5 років тому +10

      @@avimannuxbz3454 google translate... ;)
      and it's not just for Italian students. can be said the same for more than few other countries.

    • @matteomunerati4674
      @matteomunerati4674 5 років тому +70

      Either that or "sempre Caro mi fu quest' ermo colle".

  • @我吃面
    @我吃面 5 років тому +511

    Love how in 2008, centuries after he died, Florence was like
    "Yo we should get Dante back here"

    • @lf-domino7876
      @lf-domino7876 4 роки тому +32

      Meanwhile he is still buried in Ravenna, where he actually died in 1321

    • @MrName-fo2td
      @MrName-fo2td 3 роки тому +9

      mfs took 706 years to get it right

  • @KevinFlores-ey8tz
    @KevinFlores-ey8tz 5 років тому +8872

    Dante's Divine Comedy = Dante's fanfic with Virgil senpai

    • @roentgenabe8294
      @roentgenabe8294 5 років тому +143

      exactly

    • @merrittanimation7721
      @merrittanimation7721 5 років тому +566

      “Virgil senpai I’m you’re biggest fan!”

    • @elessal
      @elessal 5 років тому +165

      in greta thunberg's voice: ''how dare you!''

    • @stanislawwitkowicz918
      @stanislawwitkowicz918 5 років тому +89

      And The Ninth Circle, as we all know, was originally designed as The Greeks Circle

    • @u13613to
      @u13613to 5 років тому +207

      ...and with his life crush: Beatrice Portinari

  • @merrittanimation7721
    @merrittanimation7721 5 років тому +581

    “Midway through the journey of our life
    I found myself in a dark forest”

    • @19SNARF66
      @19SNARF66 5 років тому +67

      Logan paul enters chat

    • @merrittanimation7721
      @merrittanimation7721 5 років тому +25

      Harvey Gleadell No that’s several cantos later

    • @luffydragneel5635
      @luffydragneel5635 5 років тому +10

      sounds like a midlife crisi

    • @Jack-zx1vq
      @Jack-zx1vq 5 років тому +25

      Nel mezzo di cammin di nostra vita
      Mi ritrovai per una selva oscura
      Che la dritta via era smarrita❤️

    • @Valerio_the_wandering_sprite
      @Valerio_the_wandering_sprite 5 років тому +9

      Where the clear path was lost.

  • @rinboyd5572
    @rinboyd5572 4 роки тому +338

    Imagine being a big Dante fan and reading his books as soon as they came out and thinking for a whole decade "dang I wonder when he's gonna drop the next one"

    • @anryx555
      @anryx555 2 роки тому +17

      He died before finish it... Sad... He does the "George R.R. Martin" before George R.R. Martin does it...
      For our luck, seems only a few lines lack at the end

    • @gianmattia13
      @gianmattia13 2 роки тому +42

      @@anryx555 Dante ended his work in time.
      He died after he wrote the full Paradise

    • @Tolstoy111
      @Tolstoy111 2 роки тому +18

      @@anryx555 The Divine Comedy is finished.

    • @mariaa.villalbareyes5488
      @mariaa.villalbareyes5488 2 роки тому +20

      @@gianmattia13 He did indeed finish it, but he didn't publish the trilogy himself. He died before doing so.

    • @gianmattia13
      @gianmattia13 2 роки тому +1

      @@mariaa.villalbareyes5488 Yeah, I know.

  • @safeersaadiq6385
    @safeersaadiq6385 5 років тому +332

    *Dante alighieri*
    _O human race, born to fly upward, wherefore at a little wind dost thou so fall?_

    • @animeshpathak3921
      @animeshpathak3921 5 років тому +6

      That wind you call little can be overwhelming . Everyone has some kind of drawback in them

    • @nicktroisi6347
      @nicktroisi6347 2 місяці тому

      I love this quote
      It’s so relatable. We have the potential to accomplish so much but if a little inconvenience comes along it’s like the world has ended. Something my generation knows all too well well

  • @lorefr7188
    @lorefr7188 5 років тому +1079

    Can I just praise the Italian pronunciation of the vocalist

    • @linaguida607
      @linaguida607 4 роки тому +57

      Are you serious it sucks especially when he attempted to say paradiso lmao

    • @URMOMJOWUAKAOASG
      @URMOMJOWUAKAOASG 4 роки тому +29

      lina Guinea better then when Italians try to say English words. You can’t expect perfection (yes I’m italian)

    • @lumbratile4174
      @lumbratile4174 4 роки тому +11

      I mean, /beatris/ is awful to me... Hire an Italian, do smth, idk, or just LEARN TO PRONUNCE IT! it's not difficult, Italian hasn't got crazy spelling like English! Beatrice is ∕beatrit͡ʃe∕

    • @bess00
      @bess00 4 роки тому +33

      @@linaguida607 I'm Italian my self, and I find his pronunciation understandable and good enough, you're just overreacting.

    • @Bottleofwater-n5y
      @Bottleofwater-n5y 4 роки тому +9

      @@bess00 well personally english people always laugh at italians for their pronounciation, begin very uneducated (im C1 level of speaking high class british accent, so i don't count)
      Soo... I don't really want to be patient with them when they speak my language wrong, unless they learn how to respect others and not act entitled

  • @MAXPAUERv
    @MAXPAUERv Рік тому +36

    Dante had sworn, on Beatrice's coffin that he would have wrote the biggest and best love poem ever written.. and he did it, i think nobody else has done a bigger effort in literature, putting that unbelievable volume of work and talent together...

  • @ashleightompkins3200
    @ashleightompkins3200 3 роки тому +201

    "The greatest love story ever told"? We talking Dante and Beatrice or Dante and Vergil?

  • @marcota9461
    @marcota9461 5 років тому +329

    La Divina Commedia has so much inside: religion, politics, scientific themes, horror, love, historical and mythological characters, fantasy, demons, numerological patterns...
    The allegory means there are alternative meanings in almost everythings he wrote.
    And, of course, it's all written in lines and rhymes

    • @animeshpathak3921
      @animeshpathak3921 5 років тому +1

      Reading oks

    • @jeffryhammel3035
      @jeffryhammel3035 3 роки тому +3

      Thanks for your comment. This and maybe Shakespeare or Dickens have exactly what you wrote.

  • @orionaugustwatson
    @orionaugustwatson 5 років тому +466

    This sounds so weird after listening to Overly Sarcastic Production's video

    • @youtubingjaguar5082
      @youtubingjaguar5082 5 років тому +43

      It *does* sound weird after watching Red's videos. But this still a good summation as to why people should read The Divine Comedy. ;)

    • @orionaugustwatson
      @orionaugustwatson 5 років тому +38

      @@youtubingjaguar5082 Absolutely
      Both presentations are excellent in their own way.
      Both make me wanna read it again.
      And of course nothing beats reading a good book.

    • @stanislawwitkowicz918
      @stanislawwitkowicz918 5 років тому +26

      These videos complete each other

    • @youtubingjaguar5082
      @youtubingjaguar5082 5 років тому +6

      @@stanislawwitkowicz918 Good point ;)

    • @orionaugustwatson
      @orionaugustwatson 5 років тому +5

      @@stanislawwitkowicz918 Couldn't have explained it any better

  • @camillachopinet3828
    @camillachopinet3828 5 років тому +156

    For three years we study it in Italian high schools. Three years.

    • @dantealighieri3750
      @dantealighieri3750 4 роки тому +2

      alessandro cocco bravo mio caro tu che riconosci queste umili scritte

    • @manasisnehal1572
      @manasisnehal1572 4 роки тому +2

      Lucky you. 🙃

    • @NeverSaySandwich1
      @NeverSaySandwich1 4 роки тому +4

      Spaghetti boy

    • @isakdahl7054
      @isakdahl7054 3 роки тому +13

      @@NeverSaySandwich1 This was so unexpected it was perfection. Gave a good chuckle.

    • @mansuetitudinale
      @mansuetitudinale 3 роки тому

      @alessandro cocco infatti.. noi lo studiamo velocemente.. :(

  • @AbdulrahmanVI
    @AbdulrahmanVI 5 років тому +117

    The animator who made this is very skilled

  • @Eis_.
    @Eis_. 3 місяці тому +23

    LAMENT! IF YOU WANTED ME TO SPEAK IF YOU WANTED ME TO THINK IF YOU WANTED ME TO CARRY ON OUR DREAMS🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥‼️‼️

    • @guuh5772
      @guuh5772 16 днів тому

      Emu otori dropping bars 🥶

  • @Mcelle100
    @Mcelle100 5 років тому +308

    I must say as an italian hearing/reading all these quotes in english is the weirdest thing

    • @mrrrokas
      @mrrrokas 5 років тому +5

      Do they pack a similar punch?

    • @Mcelle100
      @Mcelle100 5 років тому +29

      @@mrrrokas yes! Most definetely! Everybody knows all of them even if they don't want to, we study La Divina Commedia literally from birth lol (+ im from Florence)

    • @blueponypics2931
      @blueponypics2931 4 роки тому +2

      I can imagine, I feel obliged to apologize for the pleb contingent who insist upon broadcasting their ignorance @ wearing it as a badge of honour. I grew up with Lit.Language and The Divine Comedy was part of my piece of earth.🐎🐎🐎🦘🦘🦘🐨🐨🐨

    • @J040PL7
      @J040PL7 4 роки тому +3

      @@Mcelle100 so this is the Italian equivalent to "Romeo and Juliet" and "Oliver Twist" then xD

    • @lumbratile4174
      @lumbratile4174 4 роки тому

      aɡree lol

  • @carolinaalves239
    @carolinaalves239 5 років тому +36

    I always loved the Divine Comedy, last year, I presented to my class for portuguese and everyone loved it! It’s so cool how our generation is interested in things like this when well explained!

  • @giobronskij8249
    @giobronskij8249 4 роки тому +100

    In "If this is a man" Primo Levi recalls trying to teach Italian to a French prisoner through the Divine Comedy. He was not successful as he could not transpose the strength of Dante's verses in another language, but this anecdote goes to show what a universal and unmatched piece of literature the Comedy is.
    "ma misi me per l'alto mare aperto" almost brings tears to my eyes.

    • @thejoyofreading7661
      @thejoyofreading7661 4 роки тому +4

      I always remember that part from "this is a man" where he talked about Ulysses.

  • @sophiat7459
    @sophiat7459 4 роки тому +154

    So I read this and wrote a paper on it for school, and I ended up really liking it. The language is so descriptive and beautiful. I draw a lot, and drawing scenes from the Inferno is really fun, because Dante's descriptions allow you to almost see what is happening. I'm even thinking of learning Italian just to read the Divine Comedy in it's original language.

    • @lf-domino7876
      @lf-domino7876 4 роки тому +21

      It is very difficult to understand everything, even for an Italian (like me). My advice is to try to learn the correct pronunciation first and read it in Italian, just for the musicality of the verses. Then, if you want to study the language, thank you!

    • @sophiat7459
      @sophiat7459 4 роки тому +2

      @@lf-domino7876 Thanks for the advice!

    • @lf-domino7876
      @lf-domino7876 4 роки тому +2

      @@sophiat7459 You're welcome!

    • @syasyaishavingfun
      @syasyaishavingfun 2 роки тому +2

      Try reading the manga, the scenes there come from Gustave Dore

  • @jp4431
    @jp4431 5 років тому +890

    The greatest love story ever told
    Twilight fans: triggered

  • @manchro8672
    @manchro8672 5 років тому +92

    Truly divine . I'm studying italian just to read this in the original.

    • @MicheleGardini
      @MicheleGardini 5 років тому +1

      you're right, it worth it.

    • @cath4300
      @cath4300 4 роки тому

      Wow!!

    • @thenightcorevillain369
      @thenightcorevillain369 4 роки тому +1

      You’re a madman

    • @mallorygrace8190
      @mallorygrace8190 4 роки тому +23

      It's quite hard to understand it for us Italians too, you're brave 😂

    • @Joycejoker
      @Joycejoker 4 роки тому +3

      Completely worth the effort. It’s , personally, the universal masterpiece

  • @biancamaggiani8189
    @biancamaggiani8189 4 роки тому +58

    Why should I read it? Because I’m italian, it’s our culture and Dante is the most brilliant author of history. He’s just the best. The language, the setting, the fact that he uses “terzine dantesche”... it’s just something genial. “Divina Commedia” is the most amazing and best work man has ever made

    • @jeffryhammel3035
      @jeffryhammel3035 3 роки тому +1

      Hey, thanks. A great synopsis of the book and your own experience.

  • @ermonnezza74
    @ermonnezza74 4 роки тому +18

    what I find the most impressive is that he put in so many detailed and correct historical literary and religious references while being exiled, without much access to libraries, and no Wikipedia

    • @Dggb2345
      @Dggb2345 6 днів тому

      Great observation into the nature of genius

  • @giacomospada2491
    @giacomospada2491 3 роки тому +29

    I agree that the Divine Comedy is a "love story", but not in the normal sense: Beatrice is Dante's crush, that's true, but she is also the allegory for THEOLOGY, necessary for the journey through Paradise, in fact on the doorstep of this place Dante has to leave his first guide, Virgil, symbol of the REASON. However love has another meaning: in the very last line of the poem Dante says that "AMORE" is the force that moves everything in universe, referring to God's love.
    (I hope someone will read this comment and also to have used the right grammar)

  • @researcher3248
    @researcher3248 2 роки тому +11

    i read this book 12 years back... the light it shared cant be defined in words.. still i see people in these circles...

  • @angelotoledo
    @angelotoledo 5 років тому +397

    Pope: *exiles Dante*
    Dante: This party's getting crazy, let's rock!
    *writes a book*

  • @osse1n
    @osse1n 5 років тому +280

    My parent's never succeeded in encouraging book reading.
    Let's see if TED-Ed can.

    • @rupaligupta6338
      @rupaligupta6338 5 років тому +5

      Well u should read. U can start out with dan brown's 'inferno' which is a thriller based on the divine comedy

    • @lucasbelloni
      @lucasbelloni 5 років тому +24

      If you think is someone's else job to encouraging you to read, then you'll never achieve pleasure in reading.

    • @camillachopinet3828
      @camillachopinet3828 5 років тому +7

      Reading is great! Once you get sucked up into a story it's hard to go back just don't know if this one would be a good place to start
      It's a great piece of literature but pretty heavy on the language with lots of archaic words that translations I assume will mimic

    • @kennjt5015
      @kennjt5015 5 років тому

      Maybe give Fight Mediocrity channel a visit. Watch his early videos. That was the very influence that made me start buying books.

    • @暧昧-u8e
      @暧昧-u8e 5 років тому

      This is funny

  • @hutauruk_andika
    @hutauruk_andika 5 років тому +31

    Dante is also probably the best rapper ever.

  • @Daughterofminerva
    @Daughterofminerva 4 роки тому +104

    Has anyone ever thought that the Divine Comedy is one of the first examples of world-building? Before Tolkien, there was Dante ❤️❤️

    • @jeffryhammel3035
      @jeffryhammel3035 3 роки тому +9

      So agreed with you. Dante was a landmark. Shakespeare would never have followed without poetry like this.

    • @haiku_king
      @haiku_king 2 роки тому +9

      I think celtic mythology and greek probably outdate it, but it’s important nonetheless!

  • @oweznero
    @oweznero 5 років тому +501

    My friend : *refuses to read dante's divine comedy *
    Me : why did you refused to gain the power

    • @imsarah4245
      @imsarah4245 5 років тому +36

      OWEZ NERO vergil would be disappointed

    • @angelotoledo
      @angelotoledo 5 років тому +26

      The power of our father, Sparda.

    • @N0URii
      @N0URii 5 років тому +12

      father? huh i dont have a father, i just don't like you thats all

    • @oweznero
      @oweznero 5 років тому +6

      @@N0URii I had a feeling you'd say that

    • @oweznero
      @oweznero 5 років тому +8

      @Jiahao Zhang don't you dare say it

  • @violavalentino
    @violavalentino 5 років тому +21

    In high school we study it, it's so fascinating. Italian language and mind is really shaped as Dante Alighieri's

  • @brxnv_
    @brxnv_ 5 років тому +12

    this channel is a international treasure
    no lies

  • @dootboi4120
    @dootboi4120 3 роки тому +67

    Divine Comedy in a nutshell:
    Pope: You're exiled
    Dante: *laughs in terza rima*

  • @bondrewd3660
    @bondrewd3660 5 років тому +34

    Thank you 😊 Ted-Ed for finally covering Dante’s Divine comedy

  • @LuisRamirez-rn8yi
    @LuisRamirez-rn8yi 5 років тому +649

    Spoiler alert: Dante spends 90%of the book crying, just crying.

    • @idromelei529
      @idromelei529 5 років тому +148

      He passes out a lot too😂

    • @MicheleGardini
      @MicheleGardini 5 років тому +77

      Not really. In Inferno he cryes a lot, but only in the first half of descent, where He find the sinners for human weakness, cause He feels near to their sorrow and pain. But in last circles He doesn't cry so much, He scorn much more.

    • @williamthefloridano
      @williamthefloridano 5 років тому +19

      Luis Ramirez it’s kinda like a guy hasn’t traversed the inner circles of Eternal Damnation before. Dante, Fkn n00b.

    • @marianna6412
      @marianna6412 4 роки тому +4

      and fainting too

    • @ashmapathak
      @ashmapathak 4 роки тому +2

      I want beatrice.

  • @fedexos11
    @fedexos11 5 років тому +6

    I had the opportunity to learn italian and study the Divine Comedy in school, but I never appreciated it when I was a young kid. Later I decided to read it in the original language (with comments that could guide me to understand). It became my absolute favorite book and, in my opinion, the greatest, most beautiful and perfect book to be written by any person in history. This channel continues to give homage to works of literature that absolutely deserve it and for that, we are all grateful. Thank you Ted-ED!

    •  5 років тому +1

      i have never heared any argument other than "it's boring" on why it ISN'T the greatest book in history. It's almost a fact.

  • @rickblaine9670
    @rickblaine9670 3 місяці тому +3

    “You found me a servant, and you left me a free man. All that a person can possibly do to save another person, you did for me.”
    For me, the heart of the Comedy is all in these words. This is why you should read it. Dante‘s final declaration of love to Beatrice right before the end of the journey, right before meeting God. You have to remember that this whole poem, for all its richness and complexity, was written FOR HER. It was intended, first and foremost, as a love letter to Beatrice. Everything, every single word before that final couple of verses is Dante’s way of leading up to what he has truly wanted to say all along: “thank you for inspiring me, thank you for being the light of my life”. The Divine Comedy as a whole is a declaration of love, a celebration of how much one person, by simply existing, can positively impact the life of another person. Inferno, Purgatorio, Paradiso. It’s just one story, and it’s a love story. Perhaps the greatest humanity has ever told.

  • @TheyCallMeDio
    @TheyCallMeDio 5 років тому +23

    OMG THIS WAS MY FAVORITE POEM WHEN I WAS STILL STUDYING LITERATURE

  • @johnwisdomtv
    @johnwisdomtv 5 років тому +67

    FYI Dante called it Comedy. The "divine" has been added many years later -> 1555

    • @marcota9461
      @marcota9461 5 років тому +18

      By another important italian writer: Boccaccio (the author of the Decameron)

    • @cramerfloro5936
      @cramerfloro5936 5 років тому +7

      (And it was before 1555)

    • @johnwisdomtv
      @johnwisdomtv 5 років тому +3

      @@cramerfloro5936 Ma è nella prestigiosa edizione giolitina, a cura di Ludovico Dolce e stampata da Gabriele Giolito de' Ferrari nel 1555, che la Commedia di Dante viene per la prima volta intitolata come da allora fu sempre conosciuta, ovvero "La Divina Comedia".
      it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divina_Commedia

    • @cramerfloro5936
      @cramerfloro5936 5 років тому +3

      @@johnwisdomtv aaahhh, intendevi "intitolata", ok, scusa avevo capito male :)

    • @johnwisdomtv
      @johnwisdomtv 5 років тому +2

      @@cramerfloro5936 si intendevo intitolato, non che non fosse divina già prima :P mitico :D

  • @chaengyu992
    @chaengyu992 5 років тому +15

    As an Italian, after having analysed the work at school, I can say that reading it in its original language, gives a complete different effect, since the "volgare" used in it, it's a fundamental element in the actual and complete understanding of the work itself. Indeed, every single word needs to be analysed since there's always an accurate reason why the author used it, not to mention the different meaning a word might have and all the references to other events or concepts, that Dante might have implied within it

  • @_onlyrus3432
    @_onlyrus3432 5 років тому +13

    The divine comedy is a big allegory about everything. You can discover an entire world reading it, it gives a perfect portrait of the XIII-XIV Italy, but it's also so actual.
    Here in Italy is considered THE comedy, but the saddest thing is that the English translation is just an Italian->English translation, and originally the Divine is written in "Vulgar", a language used here during the middle ages, and is definitely more suggesting and interesting-
    so happy that not only Italian people loves this masterpiece-

  • @chaaaargh
    @chaaaargh 3 роки тому +6

    Crazy how no one here has commented on the impeccable animation in this video, and the music as well. The ambiance of this video is insane, completely convinced me to read it.

    • @lekal6247
      @lekal6247 3 роки тому

      i agree with this - the music is so good, i need it

  • @alecthomas7408
    @alecthomas7408 4 роки тому +10

    I Read this for leisure and coming from a person who reads religiously. Man this book was hard at times to grasp. The language is highly irregular, but I did really enjoy some of the hidden meaning and the challenge of deciphering them. It was an amazing book.

    • @thejoyofreading7661
      @thejoyofreading7661 4 роки тому +1

      If you're interested in the Comedy, I am doing a series about it on my youtube channel

  • @dulcealvarez6071
    @dulcealvarez6071 5 років тому +121

    Virgilio not mention even once
    also Virgilio: am i a joke to you?

    • @MellyP22
      @MellyP22 3 роки тому

      I know! Virgillio (or Virgil) was actually my favourite character.

  • @saintseptimuse3909
    @saintseptimuse3909 5 років тому +28

    “The heaven that rolls around cries aloud to you while it displays its eternal beauties, and yet your eyes are fixed upon the earth alone.”
    Dante Alighieri

    • @polreamonn
      @polreamonn Рік тому +2

      “The heaven that rolls around cries aloud to you while it displays its eternal beauties, and yet your eyes are fixed upon the screen alone.”
      Updated that one for the 21st century.

  • @BuddyL
    @BuddyL 5 років тому +24

    01:55: "Dante was *staunchly faithful to God* , but often *critical* of the *Roman Catholic Church ."
    📣Did everyone hear that in the back? The Church is not infallible. It is *your duty* as "good Christians" to scrutinise and evolve.

    • @marcobelli6856
      @marcobelli6856 5 місяців тому

      He lived at the time of the Pope vs Emperor controversy and he was in favour of the emperor so he is biased against the church

    • @BuddyL
      @BuddyL 5 місяців тому

      @@marcobelli6856 Speak up, ❄. Can't your dog-whistle whining attempt to defend the church after it has centuries of blood on its hands. Ta, troll.

  • @psycopirla1
    @psycopirla1 4 роки тому +35

    Can you imagine Dante publishing this piece of art in 2020? Thousands would get so offended he'd most likely go to jail.

    • @E-eb6ic
      @E-eb6ic Рік тому +11

      We literally read this book in school. A lot of offensive art gets published every year but you rarely hear about it bc unless it’s by a famous person the news doesn’t really care. I think art is safe

    • @Adrlly
      @Adrlly Рік тому +1

      LMFAOOOO he would get cancel cultured

  • @nachir10
    @nachir10 5 років тому +16

    I was waiting for this! I love this poem!

  • @yuh2800
    @yuh2800 5 років тому +11

    This art style and animation is LIIIIIFE

  • @stevied3400
    @stevied3400 5 років тому +7

    Inferno was not a critique of the Roman Catholic Church. It was a defense of the Church and a critique of those who violated Church teachings (hence why all those people are in hell).

    •  5 років тому +1

      In fact Dante wanted a world where the Empire would make everything work so smoothly no priest should ever even have the chance on getting into any form of politics. We almost did that with Mussolini, but it didn't last long... and there was too much of a tradeoff.

    • @prldh
      @prldh 5 років тому +1

      Ted-Ed say anything wrong. You are right, Dante defended catholic Church, but Dante did attack some popes and boshops and no one of his works was banned or he was exilied for this reason.
      Ted-Ed vision is one-sided and wrong.

    • @CarapaceClavicle
      @CarapaceClavicle Рік тому +1

      Exactly. It took me far too long to find this comment. Anyone familiar with a Catholic, metaphysical worldview knows that it’s a defense of it. The same goes for Tolkien’s works even though I consistently see people missing the point.

    • @dwaynekeenum1916
      @dwaynekeenum1916 8 місяців тому

      @@CarapaceClaviclemeg

    • @CarapaceClavicle
      @CarapaceClavicle 8 місяців тому

      ?@@dwaynekeenum1916

  • @MuffinMalafitusi
    @MuffinMalafitusi 4 роки тому +29

    "Vuolsi così colà dove si puote
    ciò che si vuole, e più non dimandare"

  • @DL-de7gy
    @DL-de7gy 4 роки тому +4

    Thank you for talking about Dante. Greatest artist ever.

  • @yuruyukii
    @yuruyukii 5 років тому +68

    In Italy in some highschools (wherr you study latin, ancient greek, phylosophy and stuff like this) you are required to read the Divine Commedy and study it as a subject for years. I wish morr countries would at least intriduce it in schools as it is one of the world's most important works of literature.

    • @andreatortato9134
      @andreatortato9134 5 років тому +21

      Actually, it's required in every Italian highschool trust me

    • @Giovanni-em7ny
      @Giovanni-em7ny 5 років тому +3

      @@andreatortato9134 Si in effetti anche io allo scientifico l'ho fatta al primo anno prima e al terzo e quarto poi, penso addirittura un paio di ore la settimana

    • @pillbobaggins2766
      @pillbobaggins2766 5 років тому

      I would have loved to study it in school but alas I went to a Catholic school

    • @pillbobaggins2766
      @pillbobaggins2766 5 років тому +1

      I think this and Tale of Genji should be required reading by the age of 18

    • @yuruyukii
      @yuruyukii 5 років тому

      @@pillbobaggins2766 why so? Both works are fine to read even under 18

  • @galaxymew5138
    @galaxymew5138 2 роки тому +3

    Dante's Purgatorio is definitely my favorite out of the 3, IT'S SO GOOD and I'd honestly LOVE to see this adapted in a way similar to the movie O Brother, Where Art Thou

  • @oweznero
    @oweznero 5 років тому +26

    " You are not worthy as my opponent "

  • @elijahmaxwell1059
    @elijahmaxwell1059 3 роки тому

    It is a journey in itself. A journey of what is human nature. A journey of comparison and companionship. A journey of true love. A journey of discovery. A journey of earth.
    This was the first book I bought by myself at 9 years old. I remember trying to decipher its meaning and overall virtue since then. I am 24 now, and still find it’s meaning though it’s extreme beginning, forgiving middle, and welcomed end. My favorite book of all time, for it is a reflection of ones stone between the mountain of life.

  • @s7nclair
    @s7nclair 5 років тому +16

    still my top favorite classic.

  • @Stills18
    @Stills18 5 років тому +16

    Let's not forget how Virgilius, a famous Latin writer guided Dante through the Inferno and the Purgatorio ( he couldn't go to the paradiso with him because he stays in the limbo, and thus can't see God's realm). He not only was a guide, but he treated Dante as if he was his beloved son. Beatrice instead keeps on laughing at the poor Dante whenever he asks "silly"(for her) questions about Paradiso smh.

    • @Doucas1349
      @Doucas1349 Рік тому +2

      In Italy we joke about the relation of Dante and Virgilius, the love or “the ship” couple

    • @giovannimoriggi5833
      @giovannimoriggi5833 Рік тому +1

      @@Doucas1349 The ship couple non l'avevo mai sentita. Si riferisce all'istinto di apprezzamento per la convivenza coatta di marinai uomini durante lunghi viaggi soli in mezzo all'acqua?

    • @Doucas1349
      @Doucas1349 Рік тому +1

      @@giovannimoriggi5833 no, con la ship noi intendiamo l’accoppiamento amoroso tra Dante e Virgilio, è un trend che esiste oramai da molto tempo. Però il tuo ragionamento ci azzecca oh

    • @giovannimoriggi5833
      @giovannimoriggi5833 Рік тому

      @@Doucas1349 ti ringrazio ma mi sembrava talmente banale… poi perché ship? In Inferno fanno pure dei giro in barca, ma piuttosto con Dante mi viene in mente “vorrei che io tu e Lapo…”

    • @Doucas1349
      @Doucas1349 Рік тому

      @@giovannimoriggi5833 non so dirti

  • @Manudyne
    @Manudyne 3 роки тому +10

    Dante couldn't do this without Vergil's help because he lacked MOTIVATION

  • @dayros2023
    @dayros2023 Рік тому +1

    “fatti non foste a viver come bruti ma per seguir virtute e conoscenza” should be the goal of every person.

  • @Ace-1525
    @Ace-1525 5 років тому +59

    Just reread "Paradise Lost." Might as well as reread this one, too. Thanks, Ted-Ed.

    •  5 років тому

      it has nothing to do with that in phylosophycal message and importance of characters

    • @zerstorer1269
      @zerstorer1269 4 роки тому +3

      @ But it criticizes Christianity too as well. Or better yet, destroys from the inside.

    •  4 роки тому

      @@zerstorer1269 It doesn't though. The story of Lucifer is just jewish folklore, and you can't "destroy" a religion, especially if it's the right religion

    • @zerstorer1269
      @zerstorer1269 4 роки тому +1

      @ Ok sei Italiano. Vedi, non so cosa intendi per "giusta religione", vorrei che approfondissi. Ciò che so è che quel libro mostra le contraddizioni del Cristianesimo e lo "distrugge" dall'interno in quel senso. Ce l'ho in libreria, devo ancora leggerlo e ciò che so me l'ha detto un conoscente, il quale é uno studioso serio.

    • @zerstorer1269
      @zerstorer1269 4 роки тому +1

      @ La mitologia è una cosa da contestualizzare a parte, ed è utile nella psicologia analitica. Comunque, ogni religione può avere "pro" e "contro" ma il presupposto principale parte sempre in modo errato, ovvero che esiste un dio, qualunque esso sia. Che vuol dire questo? Che ontologicamente non potrà mai esistere un super ente che ne genera altri. Si creerebbero paradossi ed errori ontologici. Qualsiasi cosa che si appoggia sulla fede è dogmatica e se lo é non gli si può attribuire valore di verità, dunque è non apofantico. E queste condizioni poi ovviamente non sono indagabili.

  • @biomechanicalintegration6137
    @biomechanicalintegration6137 5 років тому +2

    Ted ed thank you for encouraging your viewers to delve into the literary world🙏🏾

  • @YiSangmyYiSang
    @YiSangmyYiSang 10 місяців тому +13

    Hope Limbus Company's Dante and Vergillus becomes a combatable character in the game.😊

    • @Eis_.
      @Eis_. 2 місяці тому +2

      Yi sang can you see them together with ur mirror

    • @randomhomesapien9078
      @randomhomesapien9078 Місяць тому +1

      Pictured: Outism (colourized)

  • @explobgm2491
    @explobgm2491 3 роки тому +6

    Dante's Comedy isn't just a poem about love, redemption and politics; it's also an encyclopedia of sorts, in which Dante pours all of his scientific and literary knowledge.
    And to mention another author that was inspired by Dante, T.S. Eliot opened his Waste Land with the renowned (half-)line "il miglior fabbro" (="the best [word]smith"), which he dedicated to Ezra Pound.

  • @macmedia1000
    @macmedia1000 5 років тому +3

    You never fail to impress me Ted.

  • @theUnknled
    @theUnknled 3 роки тому +5

    I'm currently studying this on my own.. I find Dante's inferno very interesting and I love it.

  • @lf-domino7876
    @lf-domino7876 4 роки тому +10

    Let's just mention that he purposely wrote 100 Canti (34 for Inferno, 33 for Purgatorio and 33 for Paradiso), that every section ends with the word "stelle" (stars) and that the whole composition is written in rhymes and endecasillables!
    I'll leave you with two quotes from the original (in Italian) poem::
    "Lasciate ogni speranza, o voi che entrate" (Gates of Inferno)
    And my favourite one, the last of the poem: "L'amor che move il sole e le altre stelle" (The Love that moves the sun and all the other stars)

  • @enderghostit2320
    @enderghostit2320 5 років тому

    This channel teaches that:
    Considerate la vostra semenza/ fatti non foste a viver come bruti/ ma per seguir virtute e canoscenza.” (Inferno, XVI, 19-21)
    (Consider your origin/ you were not born to live like brutes/ but to follow virtue and knowledge)
    Thank you so much for doing this video :)

  • @inniagamboa9776
    @inniagamboa9776 4 роки тому +5

    Unrequited love is one of the seeds to a beautiful blooming book. So, if you get rejected or you can’t have someone, create a famous poem, sonnet, epic, or book like Petrarch and Dante. #Beingsinglemakesmemoney

  • @johnnyjacksted6528
    @johnnyjacksted6528 5 місяців тому +2

    It’s amazing how you can tell who the chronically online are in this comment section, based on how they interpret Divine Comedy

  • @theresak5906
    @theresak5906 3 роки тому +7

    Read it when I was taking a course on Italian literature. Honestly, it's one of the most ingenious literary works ever written. Though I admit it takes loads of preparation and preliminary reading to understand what Dante actually want to tell us

  • @void735
    @void735 3 роки тому +1

    I made a 3 hour review and analys on The divine comedy for my class. My class had fallen asleep and were bored out of their minds while my litteratur teacher absolutley loved it. As did I.

  • @doki965
    @doki965 5 років тому +5

    Yesss, I love thissss.. I first read this when I was in High school, I really enjoyed it even tho it's quiet long

  • @sudipchatterjee
    @sudipchatterjee 2 роки тому +1

    Wildly appreciate the animation here! It is as good as the narration!

  • @loods2215
    @loods2215 5 років тому +4

    As an Italian, I really appreciate this video

  • @joegurt1927
    @joegurt1927 3 роки тому +3

    arguably the greatest work of literature ever created

  • @mewsingsbynatk
    @mewsingsbynatk 5 років тому +5

    I was hoping you would cover the Divine Comedy! Grazie, Ted-Ed! ❤

  • @thintellect6103
    @thintellect6103 2 роки тому +1

    Haven’t read Divine Comedy but my band is playing Inferno, Purgatorio, ascension, and Paradiso, I’ve fell in love with all of these pieces and it feels as if I’m going through Dante’s Journey with him.

  • @burnburn2644
    @burnburn2644 5 років тому +96

    **glances at high pile of Ted-Ed book recommendations gathering dust at the corner**
    Me: Yeah, sure. Give me more books to read Ted-Ed. I love them!

  • @meothichhat1406
    @meothichhat1406 2 роки тому +2

    Divina Commedia di Dante Alighieri è un capolavoro bellissimo

  • @physicistapollo
    @physicistapollo 5 років тому +8

    you should read it cause it's the best book ever written

  • @benjaminjeffery6873
    @benjaminjeffery6873 3 роки тому

    The sound editing and animation is absolutely gorgeous

  • @christomi2431
    @christomi2431 5 років тому +23

    How many genres do you wan-
    Dante:yes

  • @TheAlps36
    @TheAlps36 5 років тому

    You've no idea how long I've waited for this one!!!

  • @JustADioWhosAHeroForFun
    @JustADioWhosAHeroForFun 5 років тому +9

    Featuring Dante from the Devil May Cry Series

  • @amber6422
    @amber6422 4 роки тому

    this is so relatable and amazing, making yourself as the protagonist journeying with the people you wanted to be with, and roasting the people you hated...just wOw

  • @CarapaceClavicle
    @CarapaceClavicle Рік тому +4

    People in these comments are completely missing the point. Dante was not criticizing the standard (Catholicism) he was criticizing those who didn’t follow the standard. This work drips with a Catholic metaphysical worldview, it isn’t against it.

    • @ANDROLOMA
      @ANDROLOMA Рік тому

      Especially with Popes he disliked, such as Boniface.

  • @magentuspriest
    @magentuspriest 3 роки тому +2

    I'm not gonna write a quote from this epic. But I will say it had a profound effect on my life.

  • @MarkArandjus
    @MarkArandjus 3 роки тому +4

    You should read it because it's metal 🤘
    Also Gustav Doré's illustrations of The Divine Comedy are some of the best illustrations of all time.

  • @erinahinata
    @erinahinata 5 років тому +1

    My favorite book series ever, a MUST read! Glad TedED covered it!

  • @giovanniparatore4450
    @giovanniparatore4450 3 роки тому +5

    Probably the greatest literature masterpiece in history. Nothing compares or even comes close to Divina Commedia.

    • @javierslytherin9898
      @javierslytherin9898 3 роки тому +1

      Lol, you wish

    • @serban8298
      @serban8298 3 роки тому

      I don't think one can say the greatest!It sure is amongst them, but not the greatest!

  • @mencken8
    @mencken8 3 роки тому

    We are now reduced to asking questions like this. If it has to be asked, the battle is already lost.