I have watched Navtej Sarna as a young dashing diplomat handling the press briefing. India has by far got the best seasoned diplomats in its external affairs ministry. This is deep talent.
This Sardar ji gave me nostalgia, In my childhood, whenever we watched news on Doordarshan, he will be giving press conferences with ministry of external affairs written in his background. He was a good speaker.
True...Very True...Also he had a great IFS career in which he served as Ambassador to Israel and USA as well as High Commissioner of India to United Kingdom.
Yes to all the points! In fact it is regrouping quickly, has already got a new leader (happened in less than 48 hrs but the news not announced until later), started launching new missions and has already had its ground engagement with the IDF at the border. Two more things to think of: 1) Firstly, is leveling up to 7 tower blocks, killing hundreds of civilians ever justified? 2) Does the killing of Sayyid Nasrallah give any advantage (strategic, long-term or political, esp. at the global level) to Israel? The short answer to both is a resounding no. Those who say that Hezbollah uses human shields need to know that it's a resistance movement like others, and comes from the native people, mostly from the South yes, but still they are all Lebanese. Also Nasrallah was NOT a military commander but a civilian - once a theology, philosophy student in Iran's top centres of learning. As a general secretary of the party whose candidates were elected to the Lebanese government, he had many political duties, plus duties of running civilian organizations that maintain schools, hospitals, clinics etc. Therefore he had to be in Beirut or any other major city and not in some bunker, say, in the Bekkka valley. Effectively, he and his party, Hezbollah, ended up having to do things that was the job of the government, i.e. run clinics, hospitals, schools and social services etc etc all over the South. The country is not rich, has many corrupt people in the government and other areas, so somebody / some organization had to take responsibility. You have to be in a city to do all this and not in some isolated, secure place in a remote part. So, killing him where he was, and knowing that it'll involve massive civilian deaths is a war crime. Many international experts who are open minded and unbiased say this: This is a war crime but will never be punished as Israel through US backing enjoys impunity. Actually, the US is complicit in all the war crimes Israel is committing, but will never be brought to book! As the gentleman here says and implies this killing will not give Israel any real advantage. Certainly more serious than the pager / electronic goods attack recently (terrorism even according to Leon Panetta, former CIA head - just Google search) on the civilian population, killing Sayyid Nasrallah will backfire. There is already a dispute in the Israeli cabinet about this. Is killing people who are politicians and with whom you would want to talk to and negotiate a wise thing? We all know the answer. But Netanyahu, and many around him, are not thinking straight, but going around like a bull in a china shop. Doing a genocide of the Palestinians and now launching a war against Lebanon bodes ill for the long term future of the country. interestingly, his popularity has been shooting up and up, indicating that the well-educated Israeli public is also unaware of the blunders of its seemingly inept, and blatantly careless, if not obviously supremacist, politicians. The academic, Nurit Peled, Prof. of Education, University of Tel Aviv, has a lot to say about the very racist nature of the Israeli education system that's leading the country to a very biased and stunningly stupid view of not only the Palestinians, but Arabs in general. She has repeatedly called for a thorough reform of the education system leading to a better understanding of those in and around Israel. Otherwise she sees a bleak future since this cannot go on. Israel is very much dependent on the West, esp. the US from which it gets huge donations regularly. But this will not last for ever and a priority needs to be recognized: Solve the Palestinian issue, which will also solve the problems with Israel's neighbours and lead to trade and diplomatic relations. Its Israel, not the US, that has to live in that neighbourhood!
How is that logical? If he goes into Israel Hamas war, he is supposed to face threat.. if he is equivalent to functioning state, his army has failed .. after provoking his defence cannot be giraneteed
@@Zarghaam12 u know everything except the timing of Israel's strike.now that hezbollah has regrouped with a new leader predict the time and place of israeli strike on him.all other info.is useless.
The former Ambassador needs to be corrected on his labelling of Hezbollah and Hamas as terrorists. Who is the one committing genocide, conducting terror campaigns, torture and rape on civilians?
@@Sam-l5c5r most people overlook or are not aware of the fact that all western intelligence agencies (not only 5 eyes) are working closely day and night to defeat the resistance forces fighting against Israeli occupation forces.
Karan Thappad is so sad … Navtej ji analysis is correct … issues will not be solved because it is like this since 1500 years these issues will never resolve until only some one from heaven comes down again and explain sense to all
However reassuring the words of sarna may be for Thapar (that Hezbollah will regroup) the problem between Israel and Rest of the Islamic gang in the region can never be solved . Same between India and Pakistan. It is about incompatibility. It is a clash of civilizations.
Support for civilians are only genuine when its not based on religion. Unfortunately majority of people see religion above everything, humans are nothing for them again religion.
Every Palestinian couple has 6 children on an average and Hamas hides amongst civilians. It's but obvious that major casualty will be of woman and kids. Because every family has just 1 man, 1 woman and 6 kids.
What happened in Karbala dude? It was a Muslim Army fighting against another Muslim group. Similar stories are there in the Indian subcontinent as well. Guru Gobind Singh ji's sons have given the supreme sacrifice fighting against the foreign King's atrocities. Shivaji Maharaj's son and his companions too made similar supreme sacrifices for the sake of their people
Kab tk ek karbala ki Jung Ko leke hero bne rahoge iske baad jo history btao Siya Sunni desh hmesa aapas me ladte rahe h Isreal Iran m bina ghuse waha k president ko guest of honor raisi ko Ab lebnan m bina ghuse narsalla ko khatam kar diya Muslims kyu nhi Netanyahu ko maar pate bolo
Why is any of this shocking. The IDF runs roughshod in Gaza and the West Bank. The settlers dispossess Palestinians of their homes. It is to be expected.
karan , Have you or anybody in the world questioned the firing of 9000+missiles and rockets to Israel by hisbulla from 8th of October 2023 towards the people of Israel.If that projectiles are not destroyed by the Israelis what would have been the damage to the people and the state of Israel.If one rocket make a single death minimum 8000 may have been dead..Has Israel attacked Hisbulla first.The number of deaths in Gaza and Lebanon is because the terrorists use civilians as human shield.If your home is fully equipped with ballistic missiles and rockets you will be a military target. So the number of deaths in an urban warfare collateral damage will be far more than this.
Karan haokip plz bring tha video that two meitei were abducted by kuki militants. Why u can't make a video against kuki militants. If it was done by meitei it will be exposed to all the news. Huh kuki paid channel
This is not a war. It is a cowardly act. It was obvious Israel is militarily more superior to Hamas and hezbulla . If Islam wants to fight it has to come down and fight one on one and not bomb from the sky. Secondly, it is not only Israel fighting or committing the genocide and war crime alone.. It is supported by world powers that look like it.. So this isn't a equal war but an act of cowardice.
New leader has already replaced him yesterday. Sayed safiddin. This is how Nasrallahh took the charge at the young age when his predecessor died. Izrel will never be able to live there peacefully in someone else's occupiedd lands. Achievements of ressistence: There's 50% reduction in the influx of illegall settlerrs - Izrel after one year is yet to free hostagges - entire north izrel is empty thanks to hzblah. New settlerrs will think thousand times before occupying lands now.
Calculetively I favour you Paji ! But Izrael is saving it's Illegal OCCUPATION and wants capture further land more over supported by Imperialist Entity
It’s over a year and they have not taken down Hamas. That should have been a walk in the park, given that Israel is supported by the USA and Europe not just with weapons but also intelligence. The honorable ambassador seems to have little understanding of how badly Israel is actually performing. It’s a very very long way to take down Hezbollah. Israel has to watch out for Iran and Turkey joining the fight directly.
What a fascinating discussion among liberals! They highlight the civilian casualties caused by Netanyahu while labeling Hassan Nasrallah as a terrorist. It's remarkable how history repeats itself; just as Shaheed Bhagat Singh was imprisoned and executed for speaking out against British terrorism, today we see similar dynamics playing out in the discourse surrounding conflict and resistance.
Sir ji if Israel had not hit Lebanon, with iniveitale civil damage, they would have killed 1000 Israel. What would you do if you were head of nation. Armchair analysis is ok. Were civilians unaware what is at basement?
Mr Sarna's take on Gaza killing ratio is shallow at best, is he relying on Hamas's figures? They lie left, right and center! This is what IDF have to say about their pre-operation strike, “We use leaflets, we use millions of text messages, phone calls. We actually call the people, give up the benefit of surprise, tell them: ‘Get out of the way. Get out of the war zone so that we can accomplish our military objectives while you’re in a safe place,'” said Netanyahu Every strike gets legally documented. No army on the face of the earth does this, generous and kind. Don't forget almost all Gazans were celebrating on 7th October. Civilians who get killed are guilty of suicide!!
Ask Mr Ghandhi what had happened when he was fighting British. Today you favour enemies it seems you have forgotten what your encenssors have gone through. You should feel ashamed of yourselves. By supporting enemies
I have watched Navtej Sarna as a young dashing diplomat handling the press briefing. India has by far got the best seasoned diplomats in its external affairs ministry. This is deep talent.
This Sardar ji gave me nostalgia, In my childhood, whenever we watched news on Doordarshan, he will be giving press conferences with ministry of external affairs written in his background. He was a good speaker.
True...Very True...Also he had a great IFS career in which he served as Ambassador to Israel and USA as well as High Commissioner of India to United Kingdom.
Yes to all the points! In fact it is regrouping quickly, has already got a new leader (happened in less than 48 hrs but the news not announced until later), started launching new missions and has already had its ground engagement with the IDF at the border. Two more things to think of: 1) Firstly, is leveling up to 7 tower blocks, killing hundreds of civilians ever justified? 2) Does the killing of Sayyid Nasrallah give any advantage (strategic, long-term or political, esp. at the global level) to Israel? The short answer to both is a resounding no. Those who say that Hezbollah uses human shields need to know that it's a resistance movement like others, and comes from the native people, mostly from the South yes, but still they are all Lebanese. Also Nasrallah was NOT a military commander but a civilian - once a theology, philosophy student in Iran's top centres of learning. As a general secretary of the party whose candidates were elected to the Lebanese government, he had many political duties, plus duties of running civilian organizations that maintain schools, hospitals, clinics etc. Therefore he had to be in Beirut or any other major city and not in some bunker, say, in the Bekkka valley. Effectively, he and his party, Hezbollah, ended up having to do things that was the job of the government, i.e. run clinics, hospitals, schools and social services etc etc all over the South. The country is not rich, has many corrupt people in the government and other areas, so somebody / some organization had to take responsibility. You have to be in a city to do all this and not in some isolated, secure place in a remote part. So, killing him where he was, and knowing that it'll involve massive civilian deaths is a war crime. Many international experts who are open minded and unbiased say this: This is a war crime but will never be punished as Israel through US backing enjoys impunity. Actually, the US is complicit in all the war crimes Israel is committing, but will never be brought to book!
As the gentleman here says and implies this killing will not give Israel any real advantage. Certainly more serious than the pager / electronic goods attack recently (terrorism even according to Leon Panetta, former CIA head - just Google search) on the civilian population, killing Sayyid Nasrallah will backfire. There is already a dispute in the Israeli cabinet about this. Is killing people who are politicians and with whom you would want to talk to and negotiate a wise thing? We all know the answer. But Netanyahu, and many around him, are not thinking straight, but going around like a bull in a china shop. Doing a genocide of the Palestinians and now launching a war against Lebanon bodes ill for the long term future of the country. interestingly, his popularity has been shooting up and up, indicating that the well-educated Israeli public is also unaware of the blunders of its seemingly inept, and blatantly careless, if not obviously supremacist, politicians.
The academic, Nurit Peled, Prof. of Education, University of Tel Aviv, has a lot to say about the very racist nature of the Israeli education system that's leading the country to a very biased and stunningly stupid view of not only the Palestinians, but Arabs in general. She has repeatedly called for a thorough reform of the education system leading to a better understanding of those in and around Israel. Otherwise she sees a bleak future since this cannot go on. Israel is very much dependent on the West, esp. the US from which it gets huge donations regularly. But this will not last for ever and a priority needs to be recognized: Solve the Palestinian issue, which will also solve the problems with Israel's neighbours and lead to trade and diplomatic relations. Its Israel, not the US, that has to live in that neighbourhood!
Muito bom ..estou de acordo !
Eu se fosse os libaneses teria preferido Nasrallah vivo ..
Eles vão precisar de defesa..
Afrontar Israel ..!!
How is that logical? If he goes into Israel Hamas war, he is supposed to face threat.. if he is equivalent to functioning state, his army has failed .. after provoking his defence cannot be giraneteed
Hopes masquerading as Analysis😂😂
@Zarghaam.Brilliant Analysis
@@Zarghaam12 u know everything except the timing of Israel's strike.now that hezbollah has regrouped with a new leader predict the time and place of israeli strike on him.all other info.is useless.
Remarkable clarity of thought on Mr. Sarna's part; emanating from a deep understanding of which only the truly wise are capable.
The former Ambassador needs to be corrected on his labelling of Hezbollah and Hamas as terrorists. Who is the one committing genocide, conducting terror campaigns, torture and rape on civilians?
It is the hamas,if there is any confusion in your frugal brain
Incentive caused bias
Frustrted islamist
Good analysis by Mr. Sarna.
A pretty concise analysis. Wish we could see such frankness in western media.
It was great to listen to a very fine and nuanced analysis of a very very complex situation by Ambassador Navtej Sarna.
The sad face in karan Thapar face makes billions of people across world 🎉
Thank you for the excellent interview with a very humane gentleman
I think we underestimate how US intelligence and the 5 👀 playing a role in Lebanon and gaza
@@Sam-l5c5r most people overlook or are not aware of the fact that all western intelligence agencies (not only 5 eyes) are working closely day and night to defeat the resistance forces fighting against Israeli occupation forces.
Condolences to karan thapar😂
Cry for Bangladesh...
Karan Thappad is so sad … Navtej ji analysis is correct … issues will not be solved because it is like this since 1500 years these issues will never resolve until only some one from heaven comes down again and explain sense to all
He is able to repeat each and every word whatever he says. Impressed by your memory sardarji ❤
Israel is desperate !
Over 3 million people already left, and all the investments stopped.
Condolences to karan thapar
😂😂😂
Get well soon
So funny...do you do stand up?
@@gobindsingh3027 khalistan is not happening 😆😆🫵🏽
@@thetroll1887 it’s already done, you live under rock. Water talks are on.
However reassuring the words of sarna may be for Thapar (that Hezbollah will regroup) the problem between Israel and Rest of the Islamic gang in the region can never be solved . Same between India and Pakistan. It is about incompatibility. It is a clash of civilizations.
Israel is occupier land of Palestine people.
Study the Bible and you know whose Land it is. quran islam begins only 400 AD only.
This statement has become redundant now
Wrong!
victim card activated when you start loosing😅😅😅😂
Wrong
Brilliant and insightful interview. Very unlike for a former bureaucrat who normally tend to waffle and use wordplay
Support for civilians are only genuine when its not based on religion. Unfortunately majority of people see religion above everything, humans are nothing for them again religion.
12:58 October 7 was Israel's PULWAMA.& 26 November Mumbai ATTACK .Normal Public will never know How,Why,such Security lapses can take Place..😮
These lapses happen by the will and wish political bosses of respective State to get support from their people to be in power
@@sahilahmed8571 you want to support congress party you can do but don't such a brain washed man
Pajji is on conventional western line..but understanding Iran it requires different approach under the light of shia islamic theology
Everyone has a right to defend themself... but...
An eye for an eye will make the whole World Blind
#WorldPeace
Every Palestinian couple has 6 children on an average and Hamas hides amongst civilians. It's but obvious that major casualty will be of woman and kids. Because every family has just 1 man, 1 woman and 6 kids.
Exactly paaji and they are also not talking about hamas using its civilian as a human shield
Thank you gentlemen.
This is true! But also proves that there is no cure for stupidity.
Thank u for the valuable insights
Sardar Ji we are the Children of Karbala. Read the history of Karbala before you come to these calculations.
What happened in Karbala dude? It was a Muslim Army fighting against another Muslim group. Similar stories are there in the Indian subcontinent as well. Guru Gobind Singh ji's sons have given the supreme sacrifice fighting against the foreign King's atrocities. Shivaji Maharaj's son and his companions too made similar supreme sacrifices for the sake of their people
Children of Karbala living in 57 countries don't have the guts to act against Israel. They are merely paying lip service.
OK ch4m44r
Kab tk ek karbala ki Jung Ko leke hero bne rahoge iske baad jo history btao Siya Sunni desh hmesa aapas me ladte rahe h Isreal Iran m bina ghuse waha k president ko guest of honor raisi ko Ab lebnan m bina ghuse narsalla ko khatam kar diya Muslims kyu nhi Netanyahu ko maar pate bolo
@@FreddieMurphy746they always fighting with each other 😂😂
You don't mention that also Sinwar does not want it to end now
Navtej Sarnaji seems like a mouth piece of Western Imperialism. CNN, BBC.
Great discussion
@thewire please explain 'hasbara' in a separate video as it is important for many people to understand the extent of narrative building of Israel.
Always a pleasure to hear the very articulate Navtej Sarna as compared to the clowns we witness nowadays
Why is any of this shocking. The IDF runs roughshod in Gaza and the West Bank. The settlers dispossess Palestinians of their homes. It is to be expected.
karan , Have you or anybody in the world questioned the firing of 9000+missiles and rockets to Israel by hisbulla from 8th of October 2023 towards the people of Israel.If that projectiles are not destroyed by the Israelis what would have been the damage to the people and the state of Israel.If one rocket make a single death minimum 8000 may have been dead..Has Israel attacked Hisbulla first.The number of deaths in Gaza and Lebanon is because the terrorists use civilians as human shield.If your home is fully equipped with ballistic missiles and rockets you will be a military target. So the number of deaths in an urban warfare collateral damage will be far more than this.
Karan ko pitru paksh/shradh paksh main uske ek aur gair kanuni baap ke marne ki khabar mili jo uske chehre per aanath hone ki gavahi deti hai,
Is KT in mourning also??
@@cv7314 he certainly was not mourning when Kashmiri Pandits were killed
Karan Thapar is wrongly wired
About sardarji ??
That MBS quote is fake. It was a rage bait by times of Israel.
True
Karan haokip plz bring tha video that two meitei were abducted by kuki militants. Why u can't make a video against kuki militants. If it was done by meitei it will be exposed to all the news. Huh kuki paid channel
That will take another two decades and a woken up Israel also has two decades to grow stronger and keep degrading their rabble rousing adversary 😅
This is not a war. It is a cowardly act. It was obvious Israel is militarily more superior to Hamas and hezbulla . If Islam wants to fight it has to come down and fight one on one and not bomb from the sky.
Secondly, it is not only Israel fighting or committing the genocide and war crime alone.. It is supported by world powers that look like it.. So this isn't a equal war but an act of cowardice.
Wrong!
They have done strike who is hiding underground 😂.. who has his own army.. instead of firing ground missile..
New leader has already replaced him yesterday. Sayed safiddin.
This is how Nasrallahh took the charge at the young age when his predecessor died.
Izrel will never be able to live there peacefully in someone else's occupiedd lands.
Achievements of ressistence:
There's 50% reduction in the influx of illegall settlerrs
- Izrel after one year is yet to free hostagges
- entire north izrel is empty thanks to hzblah.
New settlerrs will think thousand times before occupying lands now.
☪️ancer
That new leader is dead too😅
Karan babbar the sold out turncoat.
Mr. SARDAR, it's better to educate Indians about British genocide millions of Indians
Everyone's knows about it
We all know what british did
@@zainaljaberi7940 and what's with the sub continent muslims gatekeeping the middle eastern discussions🥴🤣... what's with the weird ownership
Both-sides-ism equates those fighting oppression with the oppressors. Unfollowed.
Satanyahu lost his mind.
World mein Kahin bhi Kisi Desh mein , WAR Tatkal Band Hona Chahiye.---- AJAM, Buxar, Bihar.
*"If you recite the Quran, you are Muslim!*
*If you understand the Quran, you are Ex-Muslim!"*
I read the Quran and l am still a very proud muslim . At least l believe in one God, not 100.
@@nejlababali7901 he is not helping
Harsh but true 😅
@@nejlababali7901yeah you read it not understood it 😅
Calculetively I favour you Paji ! But Izrael is saving it's Illegal OCCUPATION and wants capture further land more over supported by Imperialist Entity
You don't even know the spelling of Israel and writing crap here 😂
@@Anonymous-w9m that's how the name of that crappy little state ought to be spelt 🤣🤣🤣
Jab UN ne batwara kiya 1947 me tab nahi mane. Ab mar kha ke bilbila rahe hai.
Lato ke bhut bato se nahi mante.
Apologist Indian..
Is it just me, or does this Karan guy sound fruity?
Mahindra and majindra via wadia
Hindi m interview kr view 1 million cross ho jayge
Poor show mr KP
Karma of 4000 years
🙏🫡👍👌👏👋💯✅️
Iran Iran Iran ❤️
I know you-ran 😅
Pa ji check the protest taking place in ISRAEL
And all your articulate smooth talk falls apart
Protest even happened in kashmir after his killing ,but ghanta farak nahi padta..
It’s over a year and they have not taken down Hamas. That should have been a walk in the park, given that Israel is supported by the USA and Europe not just with weapons but also intelligence. The honorable ambassador seems to have little understanding of how badly Israel is actually performing. It’s a very very long way to take down Hezbollah. Israel has to watch out for Iran and Turkey joining the fight directly.
What a fascinating discussion among liberals! They highlight the civilian casualties caused by Netanyahu while labeling Hassan Nasrallah as a terrorist. It's remarkable how history repeats itself; just as Shaheed Bhagat Singh was imprisoned and executed for speaking out against British terrorism, today we see similar dynamics playing out in the discourse surrounding conflict and resistance.
You guys need to reboot this act. Show is slow, utterly boring, old school and lacking in what works on UA-cam.
Sir ji if Israel had not hit Lebanon, with iniveitale civil damage, they would have killed 1000 Israel. What would you do if you were head of nation. Armchair analysis is ok. Were civilians unaware what is at basement?
FY
Sardar ji ko kaha se dund nikala. 😂
Oh, you talk as if you have insider info, be wary of IDF at least.
The US is powerful country.
Mr Sarna's take on Gaza killing ratio is shallow at best, is he relying on Hamas's figures? They lie left, right and center!
This is what IDF have to say about their pre-operation strike,
“We use leaflets, we use millions of text messages, phone calls. We actually call the people, give up the benefit of surprise, tell them: ‘Get out of the way. Get out of the war zone so that we can accomplish our military objectives while you’re in a safe place,'” said Netanyahu
Every strike gets legally documented.
No army on the face of the earth does this, generous and kind. Don't forget almost all Gazans were celebrating on 7th October.
Civilians who get killed are guilty of suicide!!
STANDARD WHO'S HAS STANDARDS IN THIS WAR ?
They will regroup and lose again.
Who Andhbhakt? 😂😂
Ever Heard of Vietnam ??
India to na ghar ka na ghaat ka.
Ask Mr Ghandhi what had happened when he was fighting British. Today you favour enemies it seems you have forgotten what your encenssors have gone through. You should feel ashamed of yourselves. By supporting enemies
🤔🤌