Bach Talk: Sarabande of Cello Suite No 1 - F or F# in bar/measure 13?

This video has first been published as part of my Bach Cello Suites Project - Talks, Lessons & Recordings on patreon: www.patreon.com/ , then go to Collection "Bach Cello Suites".
Content:
Sarabande G major from Suite No 1 -
0.03 min - Bar/measure 13, F or F#? - what the versions sound like
0.56 min - The Kellner manuscript
1.41 min - Anna Magdalena's manuscript
1.56 min - Editors to today rely on the readers taste
3.37 min - The manuscripts C and D
3.59 min - The Dotzauer print
4.50 min - Doerffel / Bach Gesellschaft / Bach society
6.27 min - Accidental indication within one bar/measure reliable?
7.13 min - Our today lukewarm compromise since Doerffel
7.45 min - Kellner / Dotzauer: the most likely true version
B.02 min - the original: not plain Classical but Baroque
8.35 min - The most likely Bach Sarabande original: Bar 13 to the end
Recording of Sarabande of Suite 1 - • Bach Cello Suite No 1 ...
For history & analysis of the Bach cello Suites see: www.georgcello....
* For My CELLO METHOD "Learning to play cello beautifully" visit: / georgcello - click "Shop" for sheet music / for the online cello lesson course - or Talks on the Bach Cello Suites - go to "Collections". Lesson No 1-10 are offered as a free trial, sheet music attached (ad free).
* Sheet music also available from my website - www.georgcello....
* or Sheet Music Plus - www.sheetmusic...
* For all my youtube playlists see: / @georgcello

[@BernardDauphinais]

Thanks for this discussion.

[@nedheadwyoming]

Very interesting

[@mettevunsjensen4094]

Indeed😊