All Attack on Titan Endings That Were CANCELLED By Isayama (REACTION)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 лис 2023
- GAMERSUPPS PARTNER🔥 gamersupps.gg/LIGHT 🔥 for 10% off use code: LIGHT
🔴 LIVE STREAMING EVERY DAY @ 11am EST ON TWITCH ➩ / nicholaslighttv
❗ FULL UNCUT ANIME REACTIONS: / nicholaslighttv
❗ SUB TO MY MAIN CHANNEL: / nicholaslighttv
❗ JOIN THE DISCORD: / discord
⭐ ALL BUSINESS INQUIRIES: NicholasLightTV@gmail.com
My Socials:
✔️ / nicholaslighttv
✔️ / nicholaslig. .
*VIDEO IM REACTING TO*
• Video
“His editor told him to make humanity vs titans into a fully serialized manga” eren yeager is that you?
Thanks to his editor
Eren kruger🤨
Isayama what are you doing ?
Aren’t you the person who started this story?
For my sake ? The fans sake? The pieces of shit who mocked you in the internet cafe?
I show you glory if you keep moving forward
Actually he recently did an interview where he explained the meaning behind the line ( thank u for being a mass murderer for our sake ) , apparently armin said that to lift the guilt that eren felt and take responsibility with him by saying ( i will not let your sacrifice be meaningless) but nobody understood that , so he made it much clearer in the anime by making armin say "i'm responsable too so we will go to hell together" and by saying so he will lift the guilt by sharing it with him
Who actually doesn't get this? Either way, that scene/line is terrible.
@@powerofberzerker9487basically everyone who read it in the overseas
I think Isayama had a hard time figuring out how to word it. I don't know if this is true, but apparently it was poorly localized so it kinda got lost in translation. The anime definitely fixed that moment with Armin thanking Eren for showing him the world and taking on the sins Eren had committed.
I am pretty sure that for a writer like isayama
Or for any basic writer this is a line too terrible
You are not writing the story for yourself you have to make it so people understand it
Armin is shown to lie to manipulate people. In this case it was him trying to make Eren feel a little better about what he had done. It was better in the anime, because Armin really was a mass murderer, same as Eren, just at not quite the same scale.
@edgar80lol Armin blew up the Liberio port and the civilian area next to it.
@@grugnotice7746 Yep and since he's a pacifist in his soul that's why he was depressed the whole season. Armin was the less Armin when he exploded Liberio.
It is true that Armin has been shown to lie and manipulate people in the past. In the scene you are referring to, he does lie to Eren in order to make him feel better about what he has done. However, it is important to note that Armin's motives for doing so are complex.
On the one hand, Armin does want to make Eren feel better. He cares about Eren deeply, and he knows that Eren is struggling to cope with the guilt of what he has done. Armin believes that by telling Eren that he is a good person, he can help Eren to start to heal.
On the other hand, it is also possible that Armin is trying to manipulate Eren in order to achieve his own goals. Armin knows that Eren is a powerful person, and he wants to use Eren's power to help the world. By telling Eren that he is a good person, Armin may be hoping that Eren will be more willing to cooperate with him in the future.
Ultimately, it is up to the individual reader to decide whether or not they believe that Armin is lying to Eren in this scene. There is evidence to support both sides of the argument.
Personally, I believe that Armin is both lying to Eren and trying to help him at the same time. Armin is a complex character with complex motives. He is capable of both good and bad, and he is not always honest with himself or with others.
I think that this scene is a good example of Armin's complexity. He is a character who is willing to do whatever it takes to achieve his goals, even if it means lying or manipulating others. However, he is also a character who cares deeply about his friends and who wants to make the world a better place.
100% true@@SOLDAT_MENDES
@@SOLDAT_MENDES When hearing this though it seems like Armin is not as good as he is. Armin genuienly is a pacifist. He is like the Jesus of AoT, along with Sasha's father. I don't see him as being bad at all. He does manipulate, but like is that enough to make someone evil? Like especially if you manipulate to achieve a greater good?
I am Japanese and I have read both the Japanese and English versions of Attack on Titan. Eren's conversation in episode 139 was very difficult to translate and the meaning was a little different from what it meant in Japanese. We all need to understand that and discuss it.
What was the line in Japanese?
Thank you for pointing that out. People forget about everything not being able to be translated perfectly from one language to another.
@@justincain2702 I mean, "thank you" in japanese doesn't always mean fully appreciation.
@@justincain2702 here's an interview of isayama about the panel. sry for my poor english so i'll just use translation straight out.
My honest opinion is that everything is correct as far as people are willing to take it. I think the way it was drawn, it could be taken as an affirmation of the slaughter by Armin. I was immature in the way I drew it. Armin did not approve of the worst means Eren used, but he benefited from the massacre regardless of his own will. Armin wanted to be as close to Eren as possible by saying a final goodbye to Eren, whom he could never understand, and telling him that he was also an accomplice with the strong words, "Thank you for being a mass murderer". I realized that the last part of the story was a particularly difficult theme that I could not come close to drawing, and I really regret that I could not express these things in the manga. 11 and a half years I had been working on it, and when I finished the last draft, I really thought that everyone would be happy with it, but I think I was overconfident. I am sorry to those who have supported me and let me down in the end.
glad isayama gets to rephrase it in his own words again in the anime.
Oh, I'm wondering, is this because Armin used the verb conjugation of ーてくれてありがとう when thanking Eren? I could see how that would be taken the wrong way, since it's thanking someone because of how what they did impacted you in a beneficial way and has nothing to do with your opinion of the morality of what the other person did.
I always took Armin's line in the manga meaning more like "Thank you for going through all this pain for our sake". Armin and Eren were still best friends. Armin is trying to be close to Eren in their final moments. He knows Eren is doing this so his friends can live long and happy lives. So he is thanking Eren for giving his life and going through all this pain so Armin and Mikasa can live, even when he thinks what Eren is doing is evil and wants to stop him.
This is something I see a lot in general, that people who dislike the ending misunderstand or misinterpret something. Now that can be a problem of the reader or the writer. I can definitely see how people can take Armin's line too literal maybe, even though it doesn't really make sense for Armin's character to literally be thanking Eren for committing global genocide. I also had my difficulties with the manga ending at first, but came to love it after a while after I thought about it more. When you think about all the controversial or confusing scenes in the right way and really think what Isayama was trying to convey, everything makes close to perfect sense and it's a very fitting and beautiful ending.
That would be still fine but Armin didn't even react properly to 80% of Humanity being killed off, he just made one surprised face and moved on with the convo. In the anime, Armin falls to his knees and then holds Eren by the collar and yells at him to fix it. So when I originally read the manga, I was like not only did he react to Eren's genocide INSTEAD he thanks him for being a mass murderer. I hated the ending with a burning passion but the anime really fixed it for me. I like it now.
@@poemirtiza wow, is that what really happened in the manga. If anything the anime ending is better tbh for me .
15:51
"Even if these words are translated, they cannot convey the true meaning"
Part of the Akumanoko lyrics
In an interview with Isayama, he said.
"The way I drew it, it could have been taken as an affirmation of the massacre by Armin.
The way I drew it was immature. Armin did not approve of the worst means that Eren used, but he was able to benefit from the massacre regardless of his own will, which Armin could never understand. "I wanted to tell Armin that he himself was an accomplice in order to be close to Eren. I realized that it was a difficult theme that I could not come close to portraying, and I really regret that I could not express these things clearly in the manga."
He said.
The important part is that Armin receives the "benefit" (freedom) of the massacre that Eren caused, regardless of his will. I thought that was an important point of view. Even if you think you are not on the perpetrator's side, you are actually benefiting from his carnage. I thought this happens in any number of ways in this world. Even if it is morally wrong, killing the murderer will save myself, but then I will be treated and punished as a murderer. But having someone who is willing to take responsibility for that saves me from having to kill someone with my own hands. This is a very difficult expression in Japanese. Unlike other languages, it is sometimes easier to convey a message in a roundabout way than in a superficial way. It is so difficult that even some Japanese misunderstand it.
isayama doesn’t realize how amazing his work is man, never met somebody who doesn’t like aot and i don’t know if i ever will
I’ve met a shit ton and they all haven’t gotten past season 1 and 2. The show hadn’t even started during those two seasons.
They are out there
Sup! Finished the manga last year and i dont like it! Glad to have helped
@@EnzoPietro10U didn't like the whole manga or just the ending?
@@EnzoPietro10 built different ig💀
The ending we got >>>>>
Fr
ironically, the ending of AOT might be inspired by GOT.... but I definitelly feel like GOT in turn was inspired by another anime that came out in 2006.
For spoiler reason, I cant say, but this OTHER anime is even more closely similar to AOT than GOT did. From ending, to cast, to minute details such as hair color and whatnot being similar.
Dear Nick
This is a special program on Japan's NHK that aired the other day. This is a reprint. Although you may not be able to use it as a reaction, please take a look at the video recorded for the final episode. You can see that the director, sound director, and voice actors are working hard to create the anime while considering the author's thoughts on the story.
ua-cam.com/video/lTYUcvLKdJ4/v-deo.htmlsi=6Scj-L_L4qESDHXH
Write on UA-cam theories about Attack on Titan...and you will be amazed at the details that fans discovered between the anime and the manga...and we were all convinced that the ending was changed because of these details.
@@tanvu2728 are you a kid or something the ending wasn't inspired by that (GOT) there are more anime or stories similar to the ending we have .
Did you ever do a research in your whole life for somthing?
I think the whole "thank you for being a mass murderer" line was supposed to be something like "Thank you for being the villain for us", something to that extent, and not somehow glorifying mass murder. :D
The crazy part is how the story, in many chapters, as well as the ending, tell the audience that mass murder is wrong, and somehow there's this one line that isn't translated well and people lose their shit.
This entire story was poetic and the ending was equally poetic. The whole theme of this story has been relatable and realistic to our reality. The future shots showing that war will always exist. Our people that we followed for peace eventually, but conflict kicked back up. I love it and I will stick by it.
As an opinion from the Japanese, "thank you for becoming a mass killer for us" is a translation. Aluminum has not affirmed mass murder. Absolutely. The meaning of what we said at that time was to say, "thank you for protecting us. I write this sentence in translation software because I am Japanese, so I hope that it is correct English
I also feel that my sentences written above have been translated into translation software very much. In other words, he said, "thank you for being a villain in order to protect us, but we cannot accept the mass murder."
@@YURI-92 Thank you for this information ! I hope angry manga readers will see it. :)
Nick, some of what this guy says about all these other endings being canceled by Isayama should be taken with a grain of salt because in the most recent interview Isayama gave after the anime ended he said even though there were some differences here and there, the ending he gave in the manga and now in the anime is what he had originally had in mind when he started the story. This comes from Isayama himself, not some UA-camr talking about what he thinks Isayama did or didn't 😅
I’m pretty sure endings 3 and 4 are the same, it’s just that Isayama decided to push that panel of Gisha holding Eren to earlier in the chapter. I doubt there were many changes to the overall plot.
We gotta get this guy to watch that huge infamous Invaderzz Eren character break down video. He has knowledge now and the mindset to really come away appreciating that video a lot.
and yeah for some reason that guy saintitchief keeps harassing him, each time he keeps making a aot video talking about the ending and the characters
@popjack-ir2zi speaking of sanitchief, while normally I wouldn't pyscho analyze; allow me to indulge for a moment.
I don't actually think he's as far gone into the delusional ending hate as he lets on. From qhat I've seem of him in recent times he seems intelligent and aware enough to know that all the "Eren was always intended to be the father, Isseyama just character assassinated him and changed his original plans last second to appease the fans, etc" he knows that's bolony. He's accepted the hard truth that his feelings towards the ending arc are just genuine ideological disagreement about the plot beats and the themes they convey ; not this narrative intentional PR move by the mangaka.
Despite this all however it's still apparent thst he's fine either grifting off the ending hate for now, likely cause he can read the room and can tell he's already made his bed in thst side of the Fandom. So he might as well ride it out that sinking ship till the end.
Es que mucha gente que leyo el manga y no les gusto el final le falto lo de "compresion lectora", por eso esperaban un final como los de disney donde todo esta bien y viven felices para siempre, cuando deberian entender que si creces en medio de una guerrar nada va a terminar bien, las personas mueren en medio de ellas y no hay bandos a los cual escoger.
@edgar80lol Happy ending... Yes and no. Bittersweet at best. Mikasa lost the love of her life. Armin lost his best friend and has to fight for the sake of Eldia. Levi is handicaped for life... It's happy, for sure, better than everyone dying. But let's not forget "It's a cruel world but it's also beautiful". The ending was a reflection of this idea. With hatred, comes love. With pain, comes happiness.
me parece que el que no tiene comprensión lectora es otro. Literal nadie de los que no les gustó el manga quiere un final de Disney, porque el final que obtuvimos ya es un final de Disney, todos sobreviven la última batalla y consiguen estar con sus familias, a pesar de que el 80% de la humanidad murió, de alguna manera ellos lograron estar con sus familias. Joder, no
Hey nich, pretty sure that these 3 alternative endings this guy on the video u reacted is talking are fake. I read an article other day that, when Isayama started Attack on Titan he was already sure about the final, he written it thinking about the eren's no choice but to kill every1 cause "he saw the future" the more power he had less he could be really free cause had to follow that path he already saw
Yep there's a lot of misinformation in the video, a good chunk of it is pure speculation. I don't like how the essayist doesn't clearly distinguish between what is fact and what isn't.
The real problem is that it isn't fake, idk what Isayama is on, but it's stated by himself earlier those were the endings (the mist one where everyone dies). Ending 3 is just speculation because of a tease he made about the final panel, but didn't use it as the last panel of the manga, which makes us think it was another ending scrapped.
"I love the ending..haha... Does it bother you? Does it hurt you?"
No. It makes me happy.
Same, brother
same same! ^_^
Proves he only likes it to piss people off lmao dudes so cringe probably doesn’t even remember the worm
Funny how isayama doesn't want aot to be a love story . But in the end , that's basically the whole plot of aot . It's just a tragic love story. Ymir not being able to have her own will to go against king fritz until she finally found someone (mikasa) who was willing enough to kill eren and finally set ymir free from king fritz command for 2000 years as shown in the final scene where king fritz was stabbed with a spear and ymir was reuniting with her child.
cannot agree more. Planning is so important. Disney can learn so much from those guys lmao
While the manga ending had some wtf kinda cringe lines, and the art didnt portray a long period of peace before Elidia is destroyed im still mind blown how so many fans of Attack on Titan could turn on the series just cause of that. You realize if AOT was as bad as the Game of Thrones ending then Zeke would die from a ceiling falling on him, Gabi would be queen of Eldia, and Connie would have to kill Eren cause well Mikasa doing it is too obvious.
Exactly, it's nowhere near bad as GoT ending at all.
Some people just makes comparison to make it look like garbage ending.
A lot of this video is biased and is just blatant lies. Isayama has stated in multiple interviews that he had planned out the core story of the main trio, with Eren becoming a perpetrator and being killed by Mikasa. What the video describes as Ending 1 was simply a fail safe, as Isayama believed his manga would be dropped suddenly. Ending 3 is pure speculation, with people using a panel to justify the AnR theory, and in retrospect it is clearly Grisha.
There was one other confirmed change that the video didn’t bring up. Eren was intended to be more evil and hateful in the original plan, but upon hearing Yuki Kaji’s performance as Eren, he realized he was a real human with complex emotions, not just a monster.
Finally, he said the Guardians of the Galaxy inspired part of his ending. While it may seem unclear, I think it’s likely the source for Armin’s final message, the idea that a group of people who hated each other ended up coming together for peace.
13:40 i like to think that Nick forgot mangas are backwards so he open the 1sts pages not knowing it was at the end
I would love a video of you comparing the manga and anime ending one by one, so you can see the significant changes made for yourself. Armin and Erens conversation plays out a lot differently. Not thanking his best friend for becoming a mass murderer as Armins last words to Eren was just one change lol
Lmaoo WHAT!? Isayama was never planned that ErenxHistoria thing at all! That is some fake information, Nick. Even Isayama's first character he created for Attack on Titan was Mikasa
that's why the 5th ending was called a theory
that's actually not confirmed in the slightest lol
3:41 "what's the opposite of genocide?" "Oda? I guess, yeah" lmao
And the ending songs we got like the end of akuma no ko and see you later is afterlife of aot
I would love it if you reacted to the manga chapter lmao.
I couldn't sworn i saw this notification before
im so fucking happy they went with the manga one
God.. listening and trying to understand what he's saying as a non-native English speaker was a TORTURE
Levi chilling with annie after she crushed petra is kinda wild ngl
well, Mikasa killing Eren whom she loved to save the people IS similar to Jon killing Daenery for the same reason, so that GoT reference stayed :D
Nick you need to search ANR theory for attack on Titan!
Common Nick W
Theres a subreddit called titanfolk where they post shitpost memes and crackpot theory for the lols. It was a funny place to check out whenever a new chapter dropped with fresh memes.
But when the ending came about it became a circlejerk hate train(aaron yoghurt and tatakaw) and they started coming up with their own ending of eren killing his friends in the final fight. Its still a circlejerk when the anime ending concluded. Pretty sure they were the loudest vocal minority in expressing their hatred for the ending on every social media.
Left the sub awhile back.
Oh god, and they're making videos now to convince people that Isayama planned to make Eren Hisu's child's father lol. Ending number 3 never existed actually. Yes, everyone was supposed to die and there was a plan to have one survivor that's Armin. If you go back to season one the second op you'll see Armin covered in blood and the song says "Even if I'm the only survivor" sth like that. This was Isayama's original plan. I don't remember which interview but he even once said (wouldn't it be cool if all humanity perished and there were only two survivors like Adam and Eve) but I can't find it anywhere so I'm not sure anymore.
Man.. I´ve watched your SNK finale finale reaction.. and I´m 100% with you.. It was really awesome, those who didn´t like it, don´t know what a metaphore or character development is.
New subs. Didn´t subscribed at the video I´ve watched because I was on bed watching the YT playlist. So here I am, subscribing. Keep up the good work.
Hahahah i can see the sweat coming down on the Once Piece fans Forehead because fear for the ending :D
I think the bad CG in the Eren vs Warhammer titan is caused by the video being upscaled to 60 fps. They made it look passable at 30, but at 60 you get these awkwardly smooth shifts in movement that just look terrible. We need to stop converting work that was done at 30 fps into 60 fps. It looks terrible every time.
Yeah, that’s one of the reasons I couldn’t dig the Colossal Titan CG in seasons 2 & 3. The smooth movement made the fact they did it for budget reasons more obvious. The reduced frame rate in the final season improved the look more.
Bro loveocide made me spit out my drink 😂😂😂
When is the 3 hour AOT reaction compilation coming out?
It's out
Would be very interesting if you react to AoE theories and give us your view!
The be fair the manga first ending leave to much in the air and was not good, but the extra pages fixed that for me, and now the anime fixed even more the ending and I can say that now is good
I see Nick i click
I'm sorry, but the answer to any ending or relationship connection between Eren and Mikasa can be summed up through a paraphrase in a "siblings" video by Gigguk and Sydsnap, "Mikasa isn't a sibling. She's more like his butler."
I can't imagine this series ending any differently. Like even if you take away the ending of season 3 and change the plot twist to something else and keep the story in paradise, it would get really stale if it stayed as people vs titans.. Like we hit that climax in season 3.. Like perhaps its just me but ever since season 4 I had that feeling that Mikasa was going to have to kill him.. But I just imagined the classic kiss then stab him in the heart scenario. Like if Eren just crushes the entire world, its such an awful way to end the series.. It would have no replayability.
Why people have a problem with that Disney ending???
Maybe because suddenly everything turn into an Eremika romance story.
Maybe because Eren as a character got butchered to make him an incel for Mikasa. The Mikasa who he has never has a 2 minutes conversation with. The Mikasa who was adopted into his family as his adoptive sister.
Maybe because the "Ymir love Fritz" is asspull and we know Isayama was just shoving it in to make Mikasa relevant.
Also it's pointless trying to explain to you the valid reasons why people hate the ending. You seems like you're bias, an EM shipper abd someone who watch AoT in your 5 minutes spared time
- AOT has always showed hints at Eren loving Mikasa, way back from S1 and S2. Sorry if you missed it.
- Eren never got butchered. If you compare Eren's behavior in S1 and Eren's behavior in the scene with Armin, you'll realize that it's the same person.
- Adoptive sister, sure, but that does not mean that he can't have feelings for her. Mikasa has always had feelings for him and yet, no one said anything. But when it's Eren, it's "bad because she's family".
- Right from Ymir's flashback from S4, you can see Ymir staring at a couple getting married. Also, the headaches took place right from the beginning of AOT. Saying that Isayama did the whole love thing for King Fritz a last minute decision is just... delusional. What other reason would Ymir stay all alone for 2000 years making titans for a king that long died ? Other than love ?
I'm asking you for real.
@@Nessa1.995that’s what I’m talking about🎉
@@Nessa1.995
- there were no hints in S1, S2 was again a one sided "love" scene
- Eren's development got butchered in the final chapter. I dont mind how he was that much, but that was not the same character that went through everything in S1 - S4
- Isayama has literally stated that Mikasa loves him as a brother, because he is the only family she has left.
- her headaches always occurred when someone close to her was dying/died. They had nothing to do with Ymir, it was most likely just supposed to be PTSD
- Because she had no free will, she was the ultimate slave. Why else should she be so angry and crying when Eren came to her and was the first person to give her a choice, telling her she was free?
@@sinesjoe
- again, trust me, there were hints in the story, in the songs, in the openings and even in the OVA. Even in some Drama CDs from 2015. I mean, the ending song of S4 Part 2 is literally "The world is cruel but I still love you" and it's Eren saying it to Mikasa... How can you say that there was no hint. The same in S1. The same in S2.
- No, he wasn't butchered, I strongly disagree with you. As a major, major fan of SNK and Eren, I can tell you for sure that I was expecting that kind of character development and was never really annoyed or angry. It was what I had envisionned, again, as a major Eren fan. Maybe you are not a fan of his and so, never really paid attention to his character until the beginning of S4. But it was already too late to understand his character. You should (again) go back to S1 until the finale to understand everything.
- Because he wouldn't spoil the ending, duh... I mean, we all know, from S1 that she never loved him JUST as family. It has always been more than just family. From S1, a soldier calls Eren "your boyfriend" or "your lover" and she blushes and says "no, he's family" it was pretty obvious that he wasn't just a brother and way more from S1 until the finale.
- You've been fooled by Isayama, haha. That's what you are supposed to thing until the last twist. She never got headaches when her family died in front of her. It was actually after meeting Eren that those headaches happened. Why? Because meeting Eren was the key to the story and to Ymir's link to Mikasa.
- Wow, did you read the manga ? Or watch the finale ? I don't say it in a mean way but it really feels like you haven't understood the show at all... Have even watched it ? Mikasa always had free will, the whole Ackermann/master thing was a lie. Zieg says it way back in S4. Mikasa was like Ymir, it was her love controlling her. But then, in the end, she breaks free and kills Eren, while still loving him, showing Ymir that love is a bond but not meant to enslave people. The ultimate slave was Eren and Ymir. Not Mikasa, that why Mikasa is the one ending the story and the titan powers.
I get that it's a very complicated work of art, so I would suggest that you take your time to go back to the story, to the songs from S1 (the lyrics to every song in S1 were foreshadowing the ending, with Eren being a slave and so on), listen to the drama CDs that are available and even study Japanese because some lines from the manga were poorly translated (itterashai for instance does not mean "see you later"). Then, you'll understand the characters' or at least what Isayama tried to do with the characters.
Now I'm not saying it wasn't rushed in the manga, it surely was, but when watching the anime, you can actually see some relevant differences that improve what Isayama tried to convey in his story.
Again, please don't be offended by my comment, I don't mean it in bad way.
Can anyone confirm information in this video? I thought that Isayama from day 1 thought about Eren as a final vilain
none of it is true, it’s all just fan theories, wishes, or deliberate misrepresentation of the panels lol.
Yep there's a lot of misinformation in the video, a good chunk of it is pure speculation. I don't like how the essayist doesn't clearly distinguish between what is fact and what isn't.
Isayama said (once again) 2 days ago in an interview that it was always his idea for Eren. I mean chapter 1 starts with him crying and Mikasa saying « see you later ». It was always his plan. The video is full of bs
@@BeeG-ii3ro No Misinformation, those were real alternate endings with some added speculation from this guy. There are interviews with Isayama saying he wanted a The Mist kind of ending for both the first season of the anime and the manga when he thought he might not be a sucessful writer
@@Visethelegend There's plenty of misinformation, as well as his personal interpretation. that's not that he said lol. The interview did mention something like the mist ending, but there are multiple ways that can be interpreted. he never said it was correlated with his success as a writer either. he's said repeatedly this is the ending he was going for. but at the end of the day this is just a cartoon and i'm done arguing about it, it's pointless and these misinformed videos changes nothing at the end of the day!
I'm tired of teenage kids thinking they have a better ending. The ending was perfect, there's always conflict, Erwin said that human will never stop fighting until there is only one persob or less.
The ending is far from perfect. This statement is just as valid as calling teenage kids other people who wanted a better ending
This is more of a fan theory video. Isayama said in the most recent interview, not long after part 2 came to close, that the ending was already decided. In between the beginning and the ending a lot had changed. The most infamous change was that Sasha was supposed to be killed off a lot early in the story. S2:E2 to be exact. A lot of the "Cancelled Endings" were from Reddit posts or twitter which are not a reliable source of information anyways. These "Alternate Endings" started dropping like candy the moment the Manga ended. Not surprising due to all the hate the ending had received and the hate mail sent to Isayama, including death threats. There was a crap load of fan art dropped also before and after the manga's ending that was supposedly "Official Licensed Art" by Isayama/Kodansha.
he literally said he changed the ending. There is an abundance of evidence for what that ending could have entailes. Just look it up please
Can you watch "So i watched Redo of Healer" or "To Your Eternity: A journey of pain, sadness, and sorrow" by Cj Dachamp? 😭💔
19:20 no there is literal evidence in the show that hinted to an anime original ending
Akatsuki no requiem
I don't mind the ending of aot tbh, I think it's fitting. I just felt sad for Mikasa
Plz stream on 10 am. For your indian and Asian audience plz
... Bro I need your reaction on AOTnr fanfiction 😂
Apparently George Lucas had a clear plan for the sequel trilogy but for some reason signed everything over to Disney now the next trilogy will involve Rey doing what Luke should have done and bring back the Jedi Order.
He needs to make an entire new book for every ending
Fun Fact: In a new interview with the NYT, Isayama confirmed the ending we got was always the one he had envisioned. He merely changed the execution/approach to those ideas. The video you’re reacting to is a little misleading and it’s a common misconception nowadays unfortunately
Also Eren being the father of Historia’s child and doing a 100% rumbling is just a Reddit theory. Isayama nor his editor have ever talked about that and the “everyone dies” ending was planned way back when the series was first being conceptualized and a lot of the main characters didn’t even exist at the time (The Attack on Titan Zero manga even shows some of that)
Actually he wanted to include "See you Later" and "You are Free" in his ending. If you read carefully about his interview, most of the answers on characters motivation and reason of other plot devices, he said "I don't know", " I had no idea"
Also he stated that he had freedom to change the ending and he intended to do so, but an ending was still in his mind since childhood.
@@jaipandey7142Isayama did say that while certain things changed along the way, the ending remained unchanged
It reads:
Isayama touched on the story’s tragic ending and why he could not have changed it even if he wanted. “That is something I had in mind right from the get-go,” he said. “Along the way, certain aspects of the story didn’t go as expected, and I adapted and fleshed out certain aspects. But I would say the ending of the story didn’t change much.”
He said he felt chained to that ending and felt limited as a writer because making manga is supposed to be a freeing experience, that’s what he means by saying he might’ve wanted things to change, not necessarily that he had another ending in mind all this time.
he has also said his vision of the ending has changed many times, his interviews have always been a lil iffy , but we all knew it was going to end like muvluv unlimited , also the thing with the theory is based on muvluv alternative/anr , main reason because aot follows the same patterns of muvluv and the anr theory is due to mv creator being fed info clues to be a hint to an "ending" , and linked horizon making songs based off deceased characters and the song being based on mikasa and mikasa being the butterfly in lost girls and represented by , and in many ops , eds, mvs, it showed butterflies dead , so it was just a fun theory based on things that have been consistent
@@toxin4609 As I already said the part of the ending "See you later" and "You are Free" was in his mind. Just see, he wanted to end it like "The Mist", which is completely different from what we got now. And even those ending part I said could easily fit in that type of grim ending.
@@Requiem0139 Yeah you are right
Write on UA-cam theories about Attack on Titan...and you will be amazed at the details that fans discovered between the anime and the manga...and we were all convinced that the ending was changed because of these details.
Anyone who thinks the father of a Historia's child is Eren should doubt their own reading comprehension.
To be honest, it's a disgusting way of thinking.🤮
In addition, the official fanbook states that the father of a Historia's child is her childhood friend.
It is not disgusting it does make sense
But in a hypothesis
A
Farmer being the child is more bullshit
@@adityannair8951bro can't accept the facts 💀💀
@@me_me4998 well i accept facts more than u ever could
@@adityannair8951
No, it doesn't make sense.
I can't believe some people still have such delusions when it is officially stated that Eren is not father.
Those who say these hypotheses have too little respect for this work.
Don't let that ugly hypothesis ruin this masterpiece.
@@user-yr7qb8ro3g it will does if u use some damn brain of our but
It is just a hypothesis but there is a high chance it may happen
Why the hell historia would marry a random farmer without a fucking face
Hey can you read manga of SNK
Worst possible ending I could think of:
Instead of an army of Colossal Titans, it was an army of Rod Reiss Titans, and they were carrying Zachary's "special" chair on top, about to make everyone pay...
Who am I kidding, Paradis didn't need the Rumbling, they just needed Zachary's cursed contraption to get the world to back off
There's barely a difference they just didn't have bro hug
I started the rumor 😁😁😁
What's bigger than a collosal titan? One Piece
Nick, people may see u simple minded BUT you think deep... You understand what's a good story telling
🤢
Pretty sure this video was outright debunked by Isayama in an interview last week.
Also, the ending is just as great in the Manga, with minor differences.
Isayama said in previous interviews years ago he did think of the mist type of ending, and an ending which wanted to really hurt his readers, which marked them.
Fans who didn't like the manga they wanted more characters to die...
The hatred for this anime was different than other shows... Fans wanted a tragic ed
It makes since for them to die. But the reason people wanted them to die had nothing to do with just pure hatred of the characters, you can simply ask a ending hater and they will tell you why they wanted the alliance dead.
Don't decide for other people what they wanted, lol.
@@neonthehedgehog12 yup,, that's the difference man... I enjoyed the manga ed but when i came to know about the AOE i appreciated it... And still I don't hate manga ed but AOE is most likely a top of the cherry to me
I love the ending.
I don’t think there is an ending that would be as PERFECT as this one to this masterpiece, thanks Nick for pointing that out I’ve been pissed off by the jerks who don’t even understand basic scenes in the last episode, explain it wrongly, and then talking shit about the end because THEY GOT EVERYTHING ABOUT IT WRONG !!
Bro, you lost your shit after hearing "SAKE" and later "Billy Jean"
they are not cancelled, one of them is coming back
sure buddy lmao
Haters of the anime ending can suck it. Best ending.
Ok let's put it like this everyone with an iq above 85 will like ending. Now it's easy to know the rest don't like it.
漫画を読んでください。
そうすれば全部分かります。
Now you know why WE hated the Manga 😂
One pieces ending was decided long ago
Ending 3 is in Ending 4
I am going to the store, you know, for Japanese sake.
Thank you for being a mass murderer for our sake is the craziest line I’ve ever read.
You know the real main story and main character is Levi's. Best character in the series hands down.
Damn, ngl after researching Requiem fan theory just now, I like Isayama's ending WAY more than I already did. The idea that Eren kills all of humanity outside the walls and all of his friends and then gets to live the rest of his life with Historia and his child, like. That is straight up psychopath shit. These people need to be locked up.
Now i am truly interested in that outcome
It's not about liking or hating an ending. it's about finding an ending that is consistent to the story. The reason why you like Isayama's ending more is because it's more happy. AOT has always been about brutality and death before 135. What did you expect? Eren was pushed to do this, he had no choice.
I mean that ending also made sense. In season 2 they really emphasized so much on the parallels between eren and historia. And imo historia impacted eren and helped him mentally even more than mikasa and armin before s4. Even hange kept teasing eren for caring for historia so much so i don't blame the fans for theorising this. Its not really a ship war but the parallels and the emphasis they put for these two was really good. So for historia to all of a sudden having a kid with a guy who loves teasing her as a kid was so out of nowhere. Even isayama said in an interview or guidebook that for mikasa to develop as a character she needs to seperate from eren. And yet in the real ending, till the end mikasa is stuck with eren in her head. Her development was only when she needs to kill eren. What's most confusing in the real ending was the whole mikasa ymir connection cuz there's barely an explanation bout it in the manga and the anime.
Imo combining both of these endings could be the perfect outcome. Eren had a child with historia so that she won't be sacrificed, mikasa moves on from eren as a lover so her development can start earlier rather than near the finale of the season/arc. She still cares for him so in the end she still deals the killing blow.
@@adityannair8951there's a fan fic called aot no requiem. Currently there's only 3 parts. They're working on part 4 and said it should be ending at part 6/7
@@megatbasyarullah4859 what i have heard but isn't that a video of 1 minute so what is the point of watching
If I am current
They are the one who recently released the berserk trailer
the thing with the hatred cycle repeating, the anime kinda saved its ass , in the manga at most 100 years passed so it really makes it out to be the alliance failed , paradis failed to maintain power and floch was right in the end
im actually wondering if you have ADHD or something like that because you werent even able to understand what they tell you in this video?
jesus christ.. the 3rd ending literally is the ending where eren destroys the outside world and he says its a happy ending.
I love how he is milking the hell out of aot but we can t get bored from that please keep milking aot
Nick act like a fool and dumb but actually he is really smart and sensible ✨🙌
After the Rumbling was stopped and Mikasa realizing he gives her direct information how to kill him. They could have conviced those to kill the alien and live peacefully. All of them killed people and live happily.
1. Possibilty, Ymir saw the resolve of Mikasa and as a thanks for Eren lets him survive by stopping her the last split second before slizing through
2. Mikasa hugs Eren and convices him to help them and fake his death by living outside together.
and that would make a reaaaally bad ending, with all the respect. After all the murder, deaths, dark stories we see in the anime it ends all peacefully? with the mass genocide marrying the woman he loves and everyone forgiving him? Nah, thats shounen style, and eventough AOT was serialized in a shounen magazine it's definitly a Seinen in his aspects.
@@Fabianort97 His death was not needed. The Rumbling was stopped. Shounen Style is a very weak argument.
Shounen Style is everyone gathers against a big world destroying enemy whom dies and everyone else have saved the world. That happened here again and in tons of anime. The MC dies so often the more evil he seems to be as he kills people. All 3 cases, I have in mind the mc was killed of without a heroic need and pure stupidity in writing. The author want to punish their own characters is so dumb.
What about the titans ? With your idea, Ymir would not have been freed, would have continued making titans and the hatred for Eldians would have continued. That's not what Eren wanted. Ever.
@@Nessa1.995 If you change the plot a bit, it is possible. Make Ymir happy with the attempt of Mikasa to kill him and stop it by giving her headache and talking to her maybe. I found out that you cannot change Ackermann Memories but she can maybe convince her or stop her after she saw her resolve.
Then she is freed and saves Eren as a thanks. She remains in the coordinate could be right, but you can say the "living being" dies off as it is too long ago not paired with the Founding Titan. As the living being dies they all lose their Founding Titan.
If you wants to show how the Tree regrows, he could show Eren getting old and dying while Mikasa sits there and then do the extra chapters.
Isayama had 5 romances all end up with one loser getting no redemption man. Reiner - Historia, Eren - Mikasa, Keidh Shadis - Carla, Berthold - Annie, Dina - Grisha
@@thedragonruffy4023 so that would be it ? The solution was just an "attempt"? That'd be... lame, to be honest. Also, Ymir has always been "selfish" and doesn't care about the Eldians, so Ymir stopping Mikasa before killing Eren would not match her character. She literally wanted to kill everyone. Never cared about Eldians, but about King Fritz. Resolve means nothing without action. Mikasa needed to do it and then, kiss Eren's head to prove Ymir what real love is. That's what I think, anyway. When she saw Mikasa killing Eren, that's when the bond was severed, literally and metaphorically. She never cared about Eren in the first place, she was waiting for Mikasa all along... With love, comes sacrifice. Mikasa sacrificed Eren.
I mean, I would have loved for Eren to live (he's my favorite character of the show and I love him so much, trust me when I say that I've been sad and "depressed" for the past week) but... There was no other way... Except maybe if that was all a dream...
(spoil code geass careful )
I don't watched AOT last 10 episode because of the manga didn't like the final part , the all end not just the ending , it was a 10/10 before to come up to this party, whose who watched Code geass can make a comparaison between Lelouch and Eren and i think it's not how it's end but the way it's ending who is not good for me cause code geass have a great ending
No nick😂 aliens in war of the world's died because they were not resistant to bacteria and virus that humans have gotten used to.
Eren turned into chuntaro...
jojo??
AOT Requiem part 4 releases on Nov 12. Read the whole thing
Man isiyama inspired from game of thrones ending thats why ending is like that 😂😂 nice👍
Damn nick your take is pretty weak ill be honest. It seems youre too excited, as usual
I don't like it and I don't mind it being the ending... it's like marvels end game.
7:04 dude wtf is that book... It says Donald Trump near the bottom 🤣
Those authors who don't plan what they would write, how would they start their story, how would they conclude it. They have to face controversy in their work for sure. It could be Star Wars, Game of Thrones, and now Attack on Titan
I wish we got ending 3.
Nerd core reactions pls
The guy talking is indian, his accent is obvious.