Judge says Ohtani is the best ball player, so do most other players in MLB. Ohtani is an elite athlete at the highest level. You don't understand him enough.
The question that kills this debate: if shohei wanted to could he do what judge does or to a similar level, Than reverse it could judge do what shohei does or to a similar level. That question is what kills this debate and on top of that judge literally said Ohtani is the #1 best player in the world lol so yea
Ohtani is a better MVP than Judge, not just because of going 50-50 but the Dodgers had the most injuries on a team and Shohei carried the Dodgers to the best record in baseball. As individual hitter Judge was better with the War number, but ESPN showed a graph if people want to see a player's contribution to a teams win success look at WPA (Win Probability Added) is a baseball statistic that measures how much a player's value and actions contribute to a team's success of winning. WPA can help identify the key moments and major contributors in a game. It also shows which players had the biggest value, impact on a game and winning through the season. In 2024 Ohtani WPA=7.1 and cWPA= 5.6% Judge WPA= 6.1 and cWPA= 4.3% The ESPN panel all agreed Judge was a better hitter but Ohtani was a better MVP especially with all the injuries on the team and Ohtani carried the Dodgers all season and to the best record in baseball.
Ohtani is the hands down choice for mlb and if you play in a league with daily moves then Ohtani is the number one player in fantasy as well. I would love to see him close.
Judge is the better hitter. Ohtani is the better overall complete player. It's like comparing prime Muhammad Ali vs. prime George Foreman. Foreman was a bigger power puncher, but Ali was the better overall boxer.
As a New Yorker and a Yankee fan for over 50 years, its not even close. If I can only have 1 on the team I would take Otani.
Judge says Ohtani is the best ball player, so do most other players in MLB. Ohtani is an elite athlete at the highest level. You don't understand him enough.
The guy who is better is the one that shows up, the one who has the ring
Then Freddie freeman?
I'm taking Ohtani number one if i can
It is as simple as you think, Ohtani.
The question that kills this debate: if shohei wanted to could he do what judge does or to a similar level, Than reverse it could judge do what shohei does or to a similar level. That question is what kills this debate and on top of that judge literally said Ohtani is the #1 best player in the world lol so yea
Until I see Judge strikeout 12 batters in a game he already has 2 homers in it is Ohtani.
Ohtani is a better MVP than Judge, not just because of going 50-50 but the Dodgers had the most injuries on a team and Shohei carried the Dodgers to the best record in baseball. As individual hitter Judge was better with the War number, but ESPN showed a graph if people want to see a player's contribution to a teams win success look at WPA (Win Probability Added) is a baseball statistic that measures how much a player's value and actions contribute to a team's success of winning. WPA can help identify the key moments and major contributors in a game. It also shows which players had the biggest value, impact on a game and winning through the season. In 2024 Ohtani WPA=7.1 and cWPA= 5.6% Judge WPA= 6.1 and cWPA= 4.3% The ESPN panel all agreed Judge was a better hitter but Ohtani was a better MVP especially with all the injuries on the team and Ohtani carried the Dodgers all season and to the best record in baseball.
Ohtani is the hands down choice for mlb and if you play in a league with daily moves then Ohtani is the number one player in fantasy as well. I would love to see him close.
Judge is the better hitter. Ohtani is the better overall complete player. It's like comparing prime Muhammad Ali vs. prime George Foreman. Foreman was a bigger power puncher, but Ali was the better overall boxer.
Ohtani for sure as he brings speed and elite pitching. More well rounded and 90% the HR power of Judge
In terms of power Shohei hits farther homerubs
Not close, the GOAT, Shohei. 🎉🎉
I'm glad the Dodgers destroyed both NY teams. It laid to rest who the MVP of the best team was.
The Playoffs-Not Judge👀. Ohtani is the best player in the sport.
He slowed down because of injury
Definitely want pick closer to the turn & grab 2 great players
Everybody here is better than Aaron Judge
Soto
lmao
According to Soto only😂
I cannot stop laughing.
765 Millions