I saw them a few months ago. I have debated this same thing. It’s like shit was that the great band I have ever seen. 36 years of music tons of live shows…
This is the single best live recording of MO in my opinion. This whole show is insanely good. But this song in particular gives me chills every time. God bless, y’all.
I love this band!! Unlike so many other bands these days this band can play Live something fierce!! Thank goodness for my music app on my Xbox this is where I found this song. And I agree with a lot of others comments that either this band doesn't get a lot of exposure or their agents aren't pushing their agenda or they just flat-out don't want to be as well known as they could be?
This is incredible. Still nothing beats the show where Jesse Lacey came on and sang the chorus and bridge and then all of Brand New walked on with their instruments and did the final jam with them.
His "Goddddddddd" at 6:53 and onwards is worth the near 7 minutes to get to. (the rest of the song is amazing too don't get me wrong but this is eargasm city at the end)
The original........ is.... it's own version folks. It's cleaner, more refined......... more about the lyrics. These live versions are a successful attempt to encapsulate the moment. You cannot "fully" appreciate it live....... unless you have spent intimate time with the original alone.
The original........ is.... it's own version folks. It's cleaner, more refined......... more about the lyrics. These live versions are a successful attempt to encapsulate the moment. You cannot "fully" appreciate it live....... unless you have spent intimate time with the original alone.
When Andy transitions to the "God" section it illicits such an emotion reaction from me. It could be interpreted several ways but it makes me think where is the joy where is the "Creator" when I need him most are we here just to suffer?
this has to be their best performance in their career. I have probably watched this song alone 20k times, the whole show 100k! They absolutely destroy this song it gives me the chills to the core!
The best way to tell if a any good is if there music sounds good live compared meticulously recorded within a studio with a audio engineer etc. But somehow, the impossible happens with this band, almost all the music they play live sounds even better than those studio recordings. I hope I get to see then before my time is up. The first song I ever heard of them was in my second time in rehab. 3 days in coming off heroin and meth. Forced myself to go to a "class " they just so happen to b doing music therapy. After about ten mins of mostly rap music or that newer weird rap country crap almost walked out. Then a girl put in her request, and it was " the silence " I don't know what it was, just thr song being so amazing firstly, also while in that shitty withdrawal feelint still when your brain is like a bag of oatmeal, snd everythibf feeling ans nerve ending feels on fire, if I'd been by myself I'm sure I would have been crying like a baby. it had been awhile that I felt something that deep and cathartic. They have continually saved my life. It's in the top 5 best things about life. And I'm still surprised at jusf how unknown they really are. Honestly sad how fee people know of them. Yet uou see videos of there concerts ans they r sold out and packed. Everyone of my friends never heard of them. Hell 1 of my best buddies is in to alot of rap but played him a handful of my favorites and he got hooked too. Even to this day he asked me for a plaulist of my new manchester songs lol. At first he was really put off by Andy's voice. (NY buddy is q of those acts ljke a tough guy kind of guy) first he said the dude sounds girly. But I explained as best as I could that in fact it's him singing thru such emotion and that rawness of being truly humble amd unafraid of vulnerability. Like to me that makes andy even more of a Man, even tho I know that's just his singing voic. I dunno how to explain it better. Wish I had wrote down what somehow. Came off the top of my head when I explained it to my friend. Whatever I did say changed his mind lok
+Kid Cadaver Brand New yes, but I can't here Modest Mouse in Manchester Orchestra. Modest Mouse has got a dirtier sound than MO, but not in a more distorted way, but kinda emotional way. I don't know, it's hard to describe
I would of literally shit myself at 5:20 if I was there, So crunchy and finger licking jam out.. My God where have you been!!!!!!! This song is like dipping salty Wendys fries in a fat chocolate Frosty!! When I listen to it I need to put a Trojan Magnum over my head to keep my brains from blowing everywhere!
hands down one of the greatest performances of my 41 years.
I saw them a few months ago. I have debated this same thing. It’s like shit was that the great band I have ever seen. 36 years of music tons of live shows…
Yep as a musician andy gives with his words
Still listening to this song and live show 8 years later...best..band...ever
This is the single best live recording of MO in my opinion. This whole show is insanely good. But this song in particular gives me chills every time. God bless, y’all.
The whole show is awesome. I prefer watching it to listening to the studio versions of the songs. Even if I love them as well.
Best song I’ve ever seen sung live and always will be
This song will always be my most favourite one from them (:
+mystryaabbie and pride for me.....LOVEEEEEE THEM !!
Saw them perform this live when I was a kid seems so long ago they used to perform it with two drummers
How about now?
Wild ass performance.
That kind of dissonant sound when he says "I heard you're coming back to life just for the fourth".
That is the best way of describing this song.
They should release this gig as a live album.
They should should release everything as anything and let me get broke trying to get all of it.
I love this band!! Unlike so many other bands these days this band can play Live something fierce!! Thank goodness for my music app on my Xbox this is where I found this song. And I agree with a lot of others comments that either this band doesn't get a lot of exposure or their agents aren't pushing their agenda or they just flat-out don't want to be as well known as they could be?
I think they just don't care that much about fame. They're just passionate and talented guys who do their thing. They're awesome 💜
Underrated. Period.
this is absolutely perfect
This is incredible.
Still nothing beats the show where Jesse Lacey came on and sang the chorus and bridge and then all of Brand New walked on with their instruments and did the final jam with them.
Jesse Lacey ;) and yes, it was awesome. My two favorite bands together performing one of the best songs ever. What else could I ask for?
Preston Lacey 😂
@@nanocheneylol I don't know why I did that. I'm an idiot lmao
His "Goddddddddd" at 6:53 and onwards is worth the near 7 minutes to get to. (the rest of the song is amazing too don't get me wrong but this is eargasm city at the end)
Had no idea how little the studio recording does this song justice, Jesus CHRIST
dude i know fr
This song has evolved sooooooo much since it's original. Just an organic band doing what they do best. GROW!
Can't even listen to the album version anymore it's just so...boring? Compared to this monstrous jam, holy hell
The original........ is.... it's own version folks. It's cleaner, more refined......... more about the lyrics. These live versions are a successful attempt to encapsulate the moment. You cannot "fully" appreciate it live....... unless you have spent intimate time with the original
alone.
Literally every version I’ve ever heard is slightly different and all like visceral in their own way
Still one of the greatest live sets ever!!!!
Best underrated band on earth
This is amazing.
The original........ is.... it's own version folks. It's cleaner, more refined......... more about the lyrics. These live versions are a successful attempt to encapsulate the moment. You cannot "fully" appreciate it live....... unless you have spent intimate time with the original
alone.
I really reallllyyy needed this right now!
I REALLY LOVE THIS BAND, !!!!!! BOTH THIS ONE AND MEWITHOUTYOU ARE THE BEST !
I love you
GOD this version is sooooooo damn good!! LOVE YOU GUYS::)) i love listening to the album version in my headphones, so hauntingly beautiful!!::))
how does this only have 6,400 views... this is a brilliant performance!
A better question is why does this one have more. It's my favorite because they unLEASHED it.
ua-cam.com/video/FesjBQytz40/v-deo.html
This makes me happy
A hauntingly beautiful son. Oh my God , where is the one I'm thinking of.
This Band is just Perfect!
When Andy transitions to the "God" section it illicits such an emotion reaction from me. It could be interpreted several ways but it makes me think where is the joy where is the "Creator" when I need him most are we here just to suffer?
this has to be their best performance in their career. I have probably watched this song alone 20k times, the whole show 100k! They absolutely destroy this song it gives me the chills to the core!
The Silence, live at the Regency says "wait, hold my beer". I love these guys so damn much.
@@davidweaver1968 yes! I cannot stop watching/listening to that one.
Lol doesn't that mean you would have skipped this song 80k times each time you watched the whole show
Love this song, and love this version, has it really been 9 years? FML.. lol
Cause I can hardly see what's in front of me these days and those days too....these guys are Top Notch!
Freeman is such a beast on the keys
Really like this version, kinda wish they had played it when I saw them live!
same.
They didn't what the F
I love this band and song 👍
Saw them live in Leeds. Bloody awesome.
Wild.
That was fucking epic. Best band EVER.
Are you kidding me, wicked awesome, just spectacular
Perfection in its essence. Unbelievable performance.
First heard this band on Fender Musical back in January this year, and I can say they are a very great band live, as that is one way to jugde a band.
January 2018 and this song still rocks. #joy #WhereHaveYouBeen
Where have you been? Oh my God. Wow. Just wow.
AMAZING
Y’all are amazing
I need to learn this version.
For situational agony and enjoyment. Lovely.
Amazing performance
beautiful!
Can't wait to see them this summer!
I've said it once and I'll say it again, god damn Andy.
The best way to tell if a any good is if there music sounds good live compared meticulously recorded within a studio with a audio engineer etc. But somehow, the impossible happens with this band, almost all the music they play live sounds even better than those studio recordings. I hope I get to see then before my time is up. The first song I ever heard of them was in my second time in rehab. 3 days in coming off heroin and meth. Forced myself to go to a "class " they just so happen to b doing music therapy. After about ten mins of mostly rap music or that newer weird rap country crap almost walked out. Then a girl put in her request, and it was " the silence " I don't know what it was, just thr song being so amazing firstly, also while in that shitty withdrawal feelint still when your brain is like a bag of oatmeal, snd everythibf feeling ans nerve ending feels on fire, if I'd been by myself I'm sure I would have been crying like a baby. it had been awhile that I felt something that deep and cathartic. They have continually saved my life. It's in the top 5 best things about life. And I'm still surprised at jusf how unknown they really are. Honestly sad how fee people know of them. Yet uou see videos of there concerts ans they r sold out and packed. Everyone of my friends never heard of them. Hell 1 of my best buddies is in to alot of rap but played him a handful of my favorites and he got hooked too. Even to this day he asked me for a plaulist of my new manchester songs lol. At first he was really put off by Andy's voice. (NY buddy is q of those acts ljke a tough guy kind of guy) first he said the dude sounds girly. But I explained as best as I could that in fact it's him singing thru such emotion and that rawness of being truly humble amd unafraid of vulnerability. Like to me that makes andy even more of a Man, even tho I know that's just his singing voic. I dunno how to explain it better. Wish I had wrote down what somehow. Came off the top of my head when I explained it to my friend. Whatever I did say changed his mind lok
M.O. just so incredible live--always.
This will forever define the bucket of cold water in my belly when I first felt it at 15.
Best versión where have hoy been" Cover AGONEY HERNÁNDEZ OT, special, Strong voice, dancing all time. Must be appreciated. 👌👍
10 to you!!! Very welll!!👏♥️
that's a sick performance!!!
MY GOD
latvia still waiting MO live performance
So Mesmerizing!!!
Fire.
Brand new and modest mouse had a baby
Kid Cadaver I feel there is a Death Cab For Cutie twist in there too.
+Kid Cadaver True story
+Kid Cadaver also tame impala... a little bit
+Kid Cadaver Brand New yes, but I can't here Modest Mouse in Manchester Orchestra. Modest Mouse has got a dirtier sound than MO, but not in a more distorted way, but kinda emotional way. I don't know, it's hard to describe
+Dirty Jesus yes dude omg
I would of literally shit myself at 5:20 if I was there, So crunchy and finger licking jam out.. My God where have you been!!!!!!! This song is like dipping salty Wendys fries in a fat chocolate Frosty!! When I listen to it I need to put a Trojan Magnum over my head to keep my brains from blowing everywhere!
y does this only have 25k hits?
+andre chavez Because people don't understand true music these days.
Hell yes
Them feelz
4:02 that build up is great!
and love stays too
Coolest Christian rock band ever
If I don’t hear this song when I die then I’ve gotten my whole life wrong
Wow. Unbelievable.
Não se consegue abrir a pagina
GOD
Boom
All they do is put out gems.
So was like “9 years ago, fuck this song still bangs”. Then I see the COPE background and realize it’s a 17 YO song. My kid just turned 18.
Where have you been?
Imagine seeing mo in a festival and not getting an encore :( lol
Can someone tell me what he’s saying at @6:45?
Zachary Johns “joy, my god, my god, where have you been”
holyfuck
Wild. I forget I’m recording.
Yeow...
POWWWW
Corn? Where have you been?
Как же это охуенно
Anyone notice when he started to sing the lyrics to I can barely breathe near the end and tried to cover it? Lol 6:45
When?
When he started to sing Can?
@@BbyJLP 6:45
@@hodfranko8027 6:45
eloi, eloi, lama sabachthani...
My God, My God, why have you forsaken me? - Jesus Christ on the cross.
12 people are tasteless fools.
Zip
Shhhh
Wild.
GOD