I am surprised she did not give an explanation on why pakistan rightfully and justifiably altered demographics and gifted Indian Land to China. Her fan Mr. H Saeed will be disappointed.
I am from Gilgit Baltistan. I want to tell the real ground situation in GB. Majority here wants their territory to be declared as a 5th province of Pakistan. But, what birkha is saying also correct.. GB has not been treated fairly by the successive Pakistani Govts since 1947. The State Subject rule was abolished by Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and that has brought radical demographic changes in the region over the years. Land grabbing at the hands of Govt is at full swing. People are being deprived of their ancestral lands without any compensation in the name of "khalsa sarkar". There is not even a single medical ,engineering or a technical college in the whole region. There is no concept of merit ; Govt jobs are given on the basis of loyalty to the govt. Unemployment is widespread as no private sector is allowed to invest in the region as they can challenge Army run institutions. This situation has lead to the marginalization of the local community from the mainstream and a sense of deprivation has been brewing for long. Anti Pakistan feelings are gaining roots. Having said that, we here also think that India is equally responsible for this situation as on one hand it has a claim over the region but on the other hand it doesn't want to talk to Pakistan over the matter. In all this it is the GBians who are suffering.. they are facing identity crisis. May sanity prevails on both side !!
Brother we pray for you people but the reality is India's stance is clear . Terror and talks cannot go hand in hand . India will take back POK but the thing is it will take time . If you want something you have to fight on your own .
Comparision Budget Indian #Kashmir : 80000 Cr. POK: 4500 Cr. Health Expenses Indian Kashmir: 3037 crores #POK : 29 Crores Airport Indian Kashmir: 4 PaOK: 2 College | University Indian Kashmir: 35 POKr: 6
*According to UNSC resolution 47 - Gilgit-Baltistan, Shaksam Valley and AJK should be occupied by Indian forces for security maintenance before Plebiscite. So, currently with Pakistan Army in these areas - Pakistan has violated UNSC resolution 47. Also, Pakistan violated the UNSC resolution with Operation Gibraltar in 1965.*
I'm from Gilgit Baltistan and a PROUD PAKISTANI, We have been given all the basic/human rights and we are thankful to Allah for being part of Pakistan. We the people of gilgit baltistan will defend our land and whole Pakistan along with our armed forces. 💪
Doesn’t matter if the people are happy or not - the issue is giving land which is part of Kashmir to another country. Unilaterally changing the status of Kashmir
Main gilgit baltistan se hon . Ur mujy pore gilgit baltistan ko fakhar hai ke un ko pakistani ki pehchan meli .. cuz we are all muslim . Hindo se koi b sacha muslim nhi mil skta .
Thanks for narrating the truth of other side with due importance. One more thing needs to be added is that---- Pakistan has changed the demography of not only Gilgit-Baltistan but also POK by Mirpuri n Pakistani Punjabis leaving behind sufi liberal ethos of Kashmiriyat. I'm a critic of yours n can explain the same more specific n scientifically. But, since you have the platform, you have done well. Thanks once again. Truth of any side shouldn't be hidden for grotesque political correctness...
Thats totally wrong wrong..ma kud GB k hun hamari 4th generation yahan rah rahi ha yahan shia and ismaili same % han since independance..vilance huay ha like other part of Pak no any demographic change..dear indian i specially invite u all and Barkhdutt com and see the ground situation not taking data from google
Bit the fact remains that Gilgit baltistan is the most peaceful area of the world. Unlike IOK, Pakistan don't have any forces in GB. Only small police consisting of locals is there. GB have very high literacy rate. They r more richer than ordinary Pakistani. They r more free than any Muslim in India.
Happy to see barkha dutt viewing something from India's perspective. Pushing the bigoted muslim appeasement agenda for 2 decades has left a long lasting impression that she is a pro pakistani though i dont believe an inch of that. She couldve conducted a more balanced narrative than being outright anti hindu in many issues.
Come to G.B. the name of G.B was given on the demands of local people. There was no strike there on this issue. Those people love Pakistan and very hospitable. You are welcome to come there and spend night at fairy meadows. You can interact with Shia and Ismaelis there v
The gilgite is speaking to you we want to be Pakistani and we are Pakistani it is not pak army here our ancestors kicked off the dogra raj ... Pakistan is not accepting us as a 5th province just because it will change kasmir status ... The clip in your faavour doesn't mean it is right.... We are Pakistani we will be Pakistani n we are proud of Pakistani.... it is your RAW and ur Papa CAI who wants to de stabilize this region but thank God we have pak army that's why there is peace in the region...
@@nawazuddin1237 Dogra raj thing is right, he was a bad ruler but how many airports are there in your Kashmir? we have 7. how many medical colleges you have ...none I guess.
@@zenith355 yes we k I know there is not a single medical college but the region has highest literacy rate compared to other province we have airport ... Gilgit is the most peaceful place.. you should be aware of things here 48 agencies are working to destabilize the region including your Raw Mosad Cai just to slow down pace of China economy but one ISI that's why pak army is here.... It is big game of economy in the world and the don't care about humanity...
@@nawazuddin1237 bro there were 89% Shia & Ismaili there at the time of partition , now around 50% , most of them dont even speak kashmiri over there ...mostly punjabi.
Answer a simple question. Why doesn't India allow UN human rights representatives to visit Kashmir? while as Pakistan always welcomed them. Both IOK and Azad Kashmir illegally occupied territories.
It's because we respect our sovereignty.. UN is already a joke and nobody really cares what that obsolete organisation says.. it's just for keeping appearances... they can fuck off!
Barkha ur speaking some truth now,, keep ur feet n urself on ground,, be a common person,, it's always good,, kashmir was and is indias part, Pakistan cancelled the right of pok and changed population demographic,, Pakistani people settled in pok n jammu kashmir, , but indians can't,, kashmiri can settle and buy land anywhere in India, but rest of indians can't,, now that's changed one India one people
Excellent video Barkha.. I'm so happy not living as a child like Voldemort (aka Pakistan) born out of sheer hate. But an optimistic and righteous Harry Potter (India).
Good exposé of Pakistan's furtive activities in Gilgit- Baltistan areas under its illegal occupation since 1948 including overt attempts to change its demographics. Soon India will rightfully get back its occupied territories and people will be freed from their clutches.
@@akhilreddy9953 there for rights not azadi aur tumhara affair tu Kashmir se hai tu Balochistan ki bbat kyu ker Rahe hu esse tu tumhare yaha formers protest hai India mein 😂😂
It is still Shia dominated place even today. I am not aware of what facts you are presenting but they are totally false and fabricated. When you talk of massacres, you must also talk about Indian Muslims in IOK being butchered by Indian status quo.
why you did not talk about this when you earlier and had influence at Ndtv.because you were more interested in Hindu bashing.Discrediting the RSS making Hindus villians
Politics & Tourism TV For referendum to take place you have to evict all the army settlements in PoK and gilgit baltistan and take your army out. Only then it’s possible.
So keeping it more simple first the people of that place have no problem, India doesn't care for it demographic change then whats the problem and there was no accord with Pakistan as Kashmir has with India and India plays the drum of most democratic country then is this the way to abograte the law? Why u compare Pakistan with India? And more importantly Pakistan is ready for Plebiscite but India is not...
@@parshuram321 Right Bro so it will be job of UN to do Plebiscite to find the actual residents of J and K like we have NRC in Assam, anything is possible once you want to do...
@@parshuram321 I am also from Jammu and Kashmir only and yes there was a grave mistake how Pandiths were treated like wise muslims were killed in 47 in Jammu but its not Tit for Tat...end of d day people of JK suffers...
@@parshuram321 I also condemn what happened to Pandiths and buddy read history once again JK had nothing to do with Partition..it was a separate state and accept Hindus killed muslims of Jammu n 47
@Akash First choose ur words wisely i know who is my father so only he has right to call me Son i am not like u that is not sure about his Father ad call anyone father or son and read History i guess u have just watched SIMBA so u r confused what i am discussing and what are u replying...
It is really pathetic to twist and present selective and distorted facts to distract people from the grave humanitarian situation in Kashmir...The lady has given an impression by sitting in front of books that she is a scholar....pity such scholars who justify violence on the basis of assumptions that since it is also happening on the other side of the boarder so we are justified to do it on this side....This is really shocking...and the irony of the IT development in India is that, Modi has transformed the majority of his followers into digital devices...devoid of reflection with which people when interacted mistakenly thinking that they are humans and they may have the ability to feel the suffering of people....They start playing the same recording, which Modi has saved on them....Modi and his accomplice have turned the whole Valley of Kashmir into the largest prison on earth about which you have no concern....Now coming to the issue of Gilgit-Baltistan, People have some issues about which they raise their demands, but honestly speaking there is not any separatist movement...on the contrary all the people here including myself are demanding to make GB as the 5th province of Pakistan...
Gilgit Baltistan people are not unhappy like Kashmiri people. Nor the area is heavily militarized. Do one thing. Watch Travel with Mi vlog by Mooro and you will find out.
Now after just watching this video I can tell you she knows nothing about Geography 😂 At one point she said because of law & order situation China is trying to get access through gilgit baltistan hey miss goof to reach Gawadar which is actually the main part of CPEC China has to go through Baluchistan there's no way to just cut pass it & reach Gawadar actually gawadar is part of Baluchtistan
People want to living in Pakistan so number didn't mater that. much in Kashmir people didn't want to live with India why are you closing your eyes to this big elephant in the room I know you can't say this openly because of RSS and you have to made a video too so keep working
We know the elephant, we will use elephant till it becomes tiger. If you look closely the modi cabinet, you will understand the cast equation, rss is only some of cast, Even BJP came out from rss, Last election.
anirban KANUNGOE yes that's what you are doing from 70 years when people didn't want to live with some no one can make them do so dear if indian can do this as Pakistan I will be very happy because the prob will be seteld by India record is bad in this regard 70 years is a lot of time
Anshuman Verma bro do not count people what mater is VIEW and BJP only view is RSS one check there doing in last 6 year the are doing each and every thing what RSS TEACH
Anshuman Verma by I have to say as pakistani my prb is Kashmir BJP and RSS apart from Kashmir is no of my prb nor have I got any right to discuss them yes I read about there history and everything to understand them batter that's all
The most important thing of a region is its people n people of GB don't consider themselves as Kashmiris but gilgitis even Kashmiri isn't a main lnguage of GB but balti, shina n some other languages. Majority is still gilgiti n shias. GB is one of the safest and most peaceful region of Pakistan and a biggest tourist destination of the country. Literacy rate is also high than other parts of the country. Still not a 5th province and people angry on that. So you can't compare it with Kashmir specially with IOK. Be honest.
Your data is misleading. Shia and Ismailia population was not 85% before Independence and is not 50% now. Diamer: 100% Sunni Astore: Sunni's 60%, Shias 40% Gilgit: Shia/Sunni 50/50 Nagar: 100% Shia Ghizer: Mostly Sunni and Ismailia and some Shia Ghanche: Noorbakhshi 90% and 10% others Shiger: Shia 75% and 25% others mostly Noorbakhsi SKARDU: 90% Shia and 10% others Kharmang: 96% Shia Hunza: Almost 100% Ismailia Total: Shia:39.85% Sunni:30.05% Ismaili24% Noorbakhshis:6.1% For you kind information we are all Muslims. Therefore there is no question of any religious demographic changes. In IOK Muslims are in majority but Hindus in flux from other states of India can change its demography.
thank u for presenting the true picture of Gilgit-Baltistan. As the Army has taken over control in Pakistan, but this time in a different manner. Uses a so-called puppet government to give a cosmetic touch of democracy, the same is the situation in GB, Force Commander of GB controls the overall affairs. Since Bhutto (motherfucker) lifted the state subject rule in1970s, the status of princely states of Gilgit, Hunza, Nager was waived, Sunnis from the downside of the country came in Gilgit and state agencies started the sectarian conflict so that people should remain in a persistent state of turmoil and darkness. GB has become a fertile land of some foolishly sentimental young blood to recruit in different forces. These foolishly sentimental people were used in Kargil war, and were disowned but non of army Generals were questioned for deceiving jawans of NLI, the foolish sentimental sons of Gilgit-Baltistan. The nationalist leaders and individuals from GB who take courage to talk about human rights are imprisoned through courts on false allegations. religious leaders are threatened and forced unwillingly to celebrate 14th Augst, Kashmir day etc. Gilgit has its own history of struggle against the British govt. it had got independence on Nov 1947. The whole region of south asia including Afganistan has never witnessed peace in the region since the inception of Pakistan. As far as the Army of Pakistan is not punished once for all India and Afganistan would never see peace. A simple solution is to hit the core commanders of Pakistan through a missile once they sit to analyse the secrity situation in the country.
Excellent barkha, I appreciate ur patriotic & real coverage of pok. God will forgive all ur previous sins if u speak the truth Hope u will speak & will join in favour of nation
This is surprising, what happened to you.lota of your friends are not going to like this report.it will be good if you make a video on Kashmiri pandit.
U forget to mention that in 1947 Jammu had a20% Muslim population that was reduced to 2% by massacring rest 18% ,was that to change demography ? Both countries had played for their interests and Kashmiris r paying the price !
@J R Rao Yar both countries had done and u should have guts to accept the reality!! I don't want to go in detail just for your reminder I will refresh your memory by some recent events!! 1984 .Anti Sikh riots in Delhi !! 3k + Sikhs butchered! 2002 .Gujrat massacre: more than 3k Muslims killed !! Power without blood stains is rare to find in today's world !!
Bilal kuch to sharam kero .1947 me pakistan me Hindu population 20 percent thi aur aaj uski kya position hai shayed 2 percent se bhi kam.kahan gayi baki ki 18 percent.Vo shikar hui tumhari Islami barbariyat aur forceful conversion ki.Kashmir pe to tum loge badi-badi baten milate ho,tumne Pakistan me base Hinduon ka kya haal kiya,ye sab jante hain. Hamare desh me to mussalmano ke saath aisa koi treatment nahi hua aur vo apne dharam ko maante hue badi aazadi ke saath rehte hain.
@@anilwanchoo3156 sharm to Tum ko krni chahiye ! 1947 m Pakistan Bangladesh mila ke tha ! Dekho glt ko Galt kehna sekho Bhai . Pakistan m agr ek bi Hindu mara gya ya Forcefully convert huwa I strongly condemn that !! Apka ye kehna ki India m ASA kuch na huwa !! Wikipedia, Google karo kuch topics deta hun . 1947 .Jammu Muslim massacre 1947 murder of Gandiji Murder of Indira Gandhi Murder of Rajiv Gandhi 1984 ,Anti Sikh riots 2002 Gujrat massacre Recently linching in India Ban on prayer on roads by up government ..Ye h Kya azzadi !!Bhai Sach Jano aur mano!! Andh bakti na kroo!!
@J R Rao Bhai world is badly in need of positive people that will think of future rather cursing one another for their past actions! Love is the only language that is understood by all and in present scenario we badly need it to make the world sustainable for our future generations! Spread love and stop hatred !! Nyce talking to you !!
She sometimes hugs Kashmiris for publicity and then stoopes in front of BJP. She is no more a journo. That is why in comments people are calling her name such as chamelion, alligator.
@subhadeep mandal Listen brother, you haven't understood my point what I mean is that whatever happened in past,all the communities suffered be it Muslims,hindus or sikhs. What matters is the present situation. People shouldn't suffer, they should be heared. They should be given complete rights without any conditions.
fictitious??? give me a break! I speak facts, do you want proof? And yes listen it's one's choice which religion he or she follows, no one can stop that.
Hari singh did this against our will we are 95 muslim majority why we would be worh india???now the way u caged kashmiris in Iok u want to do this with us as well???
I have lived in Gilgit Baltistan for many Years. But everyone is happy with Pakistan. Gilgit Baltistan people says they r not Kahsmiris. They are of a separate ethnicity. They even wanted to be a province of Pakistan as compared to Azad Kashmir. What Barkha is saying is totally useless n will never change Pakistani stance on IOk.
Hyderabad is a Urdu speaking Muslim occupation in a telugu land. But they are Indians now. We should move on. It is best muslims recognize the generosity of Hindus. If this was a Muslim land Hindus were invaders, I can tell you after the colonial power left, no Hindu would have been left unslaughtered, nor would he have received his rights. Hindus in own native land of sindh cannot build temples. Muslims ask too much and give too little.
Here, the point shouldn't be the what geographical position is. This time, the main issue is that how the people belonging to these areas are living? In Pakistan, they have never raised their voices for freedom and any forced action. But in #IOK living bodies are continuously demanding for their humanitarian rights and freedom since 1927. Though the movement of freedom was started before the actual struggle for claiming of independence of Pakistan. The #IOK have been victimized mentally and physically by govt. You are just making fool and trapping by words instead of raising voice to stop genocide. Nothing is above over humanity.
Totally wrong. 1. Kashmiri land within Azad Kashmir and in Pakistan is fully protected by law and even government cannot acquired. 2. Non Kashmiri cannot buy land in Kashmir but Kashmiris are free to buy land anywhere in AJK and Pakistan. 3. Kashmiri have free to any job/business in Pakistan but Pakistani are freely allowed to do business/job in Azad Kashmir. Indian viewpoint is bullshit.
Extremely poor and throw away analysis in comparison of two regions. Looks like it was done in your cozy bad without even paying a single visit to the areas you mentioned. Why not keep it simple and visit to see ground realities, I would love to be your host in GB
You can come to Gilgit Baltistan and meet the people there. You can talk to them freely and ask them about their ethnicity and affiliation. Its a cheap publicity stunt by you
I am surprised she did not give an explanation on why pakistan rightfully and justifiably altered demographics and gifted Indian Land to China.
Her fan Mr. H Saeed will be disappointed.
I am from Gilgit Baltistan. I want to tell the real ground situation in GB. Majority here wants their territory to be declared as a 5th province of Pakistan. But, what birkha is saying also correct.. GB has not been treated fairly by the successive Pakistani Govts since 1947. The State Subject rule was abolished by Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and that has brought radical demographic changes in the region over the years. Land grabbing at the hands of Govt is at full swing. People are being deprived of their ancestral lands without any compensation in the name of "khalsa sarkar". There is not even a single medical ,engineering or a technical college in the whole region.
There is no concept of merit ; Govt jobs are given on the basis of loyalty to the govt. Unemployment is widespread as no private sector is allowed to invest in the region as they can challenge Army run institutions. This situation has lead to the marginalization of the local community from the mainstream and a sense of deprivation has been brewing for long. Anti Pakistan feelings are gaining roots.
Having said that, we here also think that India is equally responsible for this situation as on one hand it has a claim over the region but on the other hand it doesn't want to talk to Pakistan over the matter. In all this it is the GBians who are suffering.. they are facing identity crisis.
May sanity prevails on both side !!
Brother we pray for you people but the reality is India's stance is clear . Terror and talks cannot go hand in hand . India will take back POK but the thing is it will take time .
If you want something you have to fight on your own .
Comparision
Budget Indian #Kashmir : 80000 Cr.
POK: 4500 Cr.
Health Expenses
Indian Kashmir: 3037 crores
#POK : 29 Crores
Airport
Indian Kashmir: 4
PaOK: 2
College | University
Indian Kashmir: 35
POKr: 6
Totally endorse what is said by Mr. Tasadduq.
Nice to hear something non Leftist from Barkha. Excellent coverage. Hope our Foreign Affairs Ministry takes notice.
*According to UNSC resolution 47 - Gilgit-Baltistan, Shaksam Valley and AJK should be occupied by Indian forces for security maintenance before Plebiscite. So, currently with Pakistan Army in these areas - Pakistan has violated UNSC resolution 47. Also, Pakistan violated the UNSC resolution with Operation Gibraltar in 1965.*
That's a pretty good job. No exaggeration at all and remained neutral. Beautiful summarization!
Good piece Barkha! Need more of these from you!
I'm from Gilgit Baltistan and a PROUD PAKISTANI, We have been given all the basic/human rights and we are thankful to Allah for being part of Pakistan. We the people of gilgit baltistan will defend our land and whole Pakistan along with our armed forces. 💪
Soon indian occupied Jammu and Kashmir will get freedom. 😍
Love u bro
Are you a Shia?
Show me your geographic coordinates with time tamp..then will talk.
Simply Liar
Very informative about Gilgit & Baltistan .
Doesn’t matter if the people are happy or not - the issue is giving land which is part of Kashmir to another country. Unilaterally changing the status of Kashmir
Barkha dutt is hypocrite. Don't trust her words. Double standards. I loath her
Main gilgit baltistan se hon . Ur mujy pore gilgit baltistan ko fakhar hai ke un ko pakistani ki pehchan meli .. cuz we are all muslim . Hindo se koi b sacha muslim nhi mil skta .
Thanks for narrating the truth of other side with due importance. One more thing needs to be added is that---- Pakistan has changed the demography of not only Gilgit-Baltistan but also POK by Mirpuri n Pakistani Punjabis leaving behind sufi liberal ethos of Kashmiriyat. I'm a critic of yours n can explain the same more specific n scientifically. But, since you have the platform, you have done well. Thanks once again. Truth of any side shouldn't be hidden for grotesque political correctness...
Unemployed, jobless woman struggling to survive.
Thats totally wrong wrong..ma kud GB k hun hamari 4th generation yahan rah rahi ha yahan shia and ismaili same % han since independance..vilance huay ha like other part of Pak no any demographic change..dear indian i specially invite u all and Barkhdutt com and see the ground situation not taking data from google
Bit the fact remains that Gilgit baltistan is the most peaceful area of the world.
Unlike IOK, Pakistan don't have any forces in GB. Only small police consisting of locals is there.
GB have very high literacy rate. They r more richer than ordinary Pakistani.
They r more free than any Muslim in India.
:D :D :D
Really. Pakistan army subjugation of media never let news out.
Happy to see barkha dutt viewing something from India's perspective. Pushing the bigoted muslim appeasement agenda for 2 decades has left a long lasting impression that she is a pro pakistani though i dont believe an inch of that. She couldve conducted a more balanced narrative than being outright anti hindu in many issues.
By the way....zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was a shia Muslim himself
piles of lies. No non local can still buy land in Gilgit baltistan. She is first Indian who is saying Kashmir is a issue.
Come to G.B. the name of G.B was given on the demands of local people. There was no strike there on this issue. Those people love Pakistan and very hospitable. You are welcome to come there and spend night at fairy meadows. You can interact with Shia and Ismaelis there v
The most competitive area for Pakistan Administrative Service Exam is G.B.
But I find difficulty to ask in Baluchistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
Change the camera position. Why is it kept so high?
I bet people who disliked did not even look at the video.
The gilgite is speaking to you we want to be Pakistani and we are Pakistani it is not pak army here our ancestors kicked off the dogra raj ... Pakistan is not accepting us as a 5th province just because it will change kasmir status ... The clip in your faavour doesn't mean it is right.... We are Pakistani we will be Pakistani n we are proud of Pakistani.... it is your RAW and ur Papa CAI who wants to de stabilize this region but thank God we have pak army that's why there is peace in the region...
@@nawazuddin1237 Dogra raj thing is right, he was a bad ruler but how many airports are there in your Kashmir? we have 7. how many medical colleges you have ...none I guess.
@@zenith355 yes we k I know there is not a single medical college but the region has highest literacy rate compared to other province we have airport ... Gilgit is the most peaceful place.. you should be aware of things here 48 agencies are working to destabilize the region including your Raw Mosad Cai just to slow down pace of China economy but one ISI that's why pak army is here.... It is big game of economy in the world and the don't care about humanity...
@@nawazuddin1237 bro there were 89% Shia & Ismaili there at the time of partition , now around 50% , most of them dont even speak kashmiri over there ...mostly punjabi.
@@nawazuddin1237 then why pakistan changed demography
the most absurd analogy one could draw, J&k has 8 lack army while POK has how much pak army there ..? ..... i think you get the answer ...
We have instument of accession........
U r illegally held gilgit baltistan
Illegals need to GTFO
Build a wall!
Excellent analysis . You are living encyclopaedia on Kashmir.
Answer a simple question. Why doesn't India allow UN human rights representatives to visit Kashmir?
while as Pakistan always welcomed them.
Both IOK and Azad Kashmir illegally occupied territories.
It's because we respect our sovereignty..
UN is already a joke and nobody really cares what that obsolete organisation says.. it's just for keeping appearances... they can fuck off!
Same way as why pak won't allow them to visit Baluchistan?
@@mayank1252 what sovereignty, tell me why there's United Nations Military Group in Kashmir?
@@akhilreddy9953 They do allow them. Only Indians don't because Indian government doesn't want to expose the human rights violation going in IOK.
@@mayank1252 when you people don't know a bit about Kashmir , better don't spit shit
At last, GOOD to see some enlightenment happening in Barkha!! All in good time as they say. There is hope 👍
*Sino-Pakistan Frontier Agreement of 1963 related to the Shaksgam Tract is also should be questioned as it gave part of Kashmir to China*
I m proud of you barkha, now its looks likes u r drifting and liking towards modi policies.
is it all because PRANAY RAY is getting arrested????😃😃😃😃
I'm from Gilgit,
We love Pakistan
We are Pakistani
Barkha ur speaking some truth now,, keep ur feet n urself on ground,, be a common person,, it's always good,, kashmir was and is indias part, Pakistan cancelled the right of pok and changed population demographic,, Pakistani people settled in pok n jammu kashmir, , but indians can't,, kashmiri can settle and buy land anywhere in India, but rest of indians can't,, now that's changed one India one people
Excellent explanation. Finally something good coming from Barkha.
Nice work dear Barkha. India needs more journalists like you.
Excellent video Barkha..
I'm so happy not living as a child like Voldemort (aka Pakistan) born out of sheer hate.
But an optimistic and righteous Harry Potter (India).
Good exposé of Pakistan's furtive activities in Gilgit- Baltistan areas under its illegal occupation since 1948 including overt attempts to change its demographics. Soon India will rightfully get back its occupied territories and people will be freed from their clutches.
Have you ever heard of a protest against Pak govt in kashmir or gilgit?
Compare it with mutiny in IOK
Ya I heard in Baluchistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
@@akhilreddy9953 there for rights not azadi aur tumhara affair tu Kashmir se hai tu Balochistan ki bbat kyu ker Rahe hu esse tu tumhare yaha formers protest hai India mein 😂😂
Thank you. This is quite informative
What happened to barkha ?
It is still Shia dominated place even today. I am not aware of what facts you are presenting but they are totally false and fabricated. When you talk of massacres, you must also talk about Indian Muslims in IOK being butchered by Indian status quo.
Entire region is living their best life. And Pakistan is protecting ITS ALL LEGAL PARTS INCLUDING GILGIT BALTISTAN
It was a move by zilfiqar ali bhutto....who did boundary agreement with China..he made China a permanent party in Kashmir dispute...
How many hindus and sikhs remaining in gilgit baltistan and so called azad kashmir?
why you did not talk about this when you earlier and had influence at Ndtv.because you were more interested in Hindu bashing.Discrediting the RSS making Hindus villians
At least Pak. doesn't have 700,000 trops in A J&K like in IoJ&K
Once demography is changed, there's no need for military
Why you not let have referendum from GB to across Kashmir inculding Ladakh... truth will prevail
Politics & Tourism TV For referendum to take place you have to evict all the army settlements in PoK and gilgit baltistan and take your army out. Only then it’s possible.
Do you think you will win, especially in jammu and ladakh???
So keeping it more simple first the people of that place have no problem, India doesn't care for it demographic change then whats the problem and there was no accord with Pakistan as Kashmir has with India and India plays the drum of most democratic country then is this the way to abograte the law? Why u compare Pakistan with India? And more importantly Pakistan is ready for Plebiscite but India is not...
@@parshuram321 Thats true but they are ready for Plebiscite as well..
@@parshuram321 Right Bro so it will be job of UN to do Plebiscite to find the actual residents of J and K like we have NRC in Assam, anything is possible once you want to do...
@@parshuram321 I am also from Jammu and Kashmir only and yes there was a grave mistake how Pandiths were treated like wise muslims were killed in 47 in Jammu but its not Tit for Tat...end of d day people of JK suffers...
@@parshuram321 I also condemn what happened to Pandiths and buddy read history once again JK had nothing to do with Partition..it was a separate state and accept Hindus killed muslims of Jammu n 47
@Akash First choose ur words wisely i know who is my father so only he has right to call me Son i am not like u that is not sure about his Father ad call anyone father or son and read History i guess u have just watched SIMBA so u r confused what i am discussing and what are u replying...
this is news that needs to be published.
So called leftist media, good job on this one!
Maybe, tweak the echo and reverb a bit .. ??
I think Indians want another cup of fantastic tea
It is really pathetic to twist and present selective and distorted facts to distract people from the grave humanitarian situation in Kashmir...The lady has given an impression by sitting in front of books that she is a scholar....pity such scholars who justify violence on the basis of assumptions that since it is also happening on the other side of the boarder so we are justified to do it on this side....This is really shocking...and the irony of the IT development in India is that, Modi has transformed the majority of his followers into digital devices...devoid of reflection with which people when interacted mistakenly thinking that they are humans and they may have the ability to feel the suffering of people....They start playing the same recording, which Modi has saved on them....Modi and his accomplice have turned the whole Valley of Kashmir into the largest prison on earth about which you have no concern....Now coming to the issue of Gilgit-Baltistan, People have some issues about which they raise their demands, but honestly speaking there is not any separatist movement...on the contrary all the people here including myself are demanding to make GB as the 5th province of Pakistan...
Violence by India? Did she said this in the end? 😡
Gilgit Baltistan people are not unhappy like Kashmiri people.
Nor the area is heavily militarized.
Do one thing. Watch Travel with Mi vlog by Mooro and you will find out.
Tiranga TV ka kya hua?
This is really informative Burkha...
I think this is second time after Kargill you done good job.
Kya ho gya,
News studio se you tube tak aane main waqt laga hai but don't you will stay here for a long time 😂😂😂
Now after just watching this video I can tell you she knows nothing about Geography 😂
At one point she said because of law & order situation China is trying to get access through gilgit baltistan hey miss goof to reach Gawadar which is actually the main part of CPEC China has to go through Baluchistan there's no way to just cut pass it & reach Gawadar actually gawadar is part of Baluchtistan
People want to living in Pakistan so number didn't mater that. much in Kashmir people didn't want to live with India why are you closing your eyes to this big elephant in the room I know you can't say this openly because of RSS and you have to made a video too so keep working
We know the elephant, we will use elephant till it becomes tiger.
If you look closely the modi cabinet, you will understand the cast equation, rss is only some of cast,
Even BJP came out from rss, Last election.
Don't worry. We will eliminate those people from Kashmir who don't want to live under the Indian dominion.
anirban KANUNGOE yes that's what you are doing from 70 years when people didn't want to live with some no one can make them do so dear if indian can do this as Pakistan I will be very happy because the prob will be seteld by India record is bad in this regard 70 years is a lot of time
Anshuman Verma bro do not count people what mater is VIEW and BJP only view is RSS one check there doing in last 6 year the are doing each and every thing what RSS TEACH
Anshuman Verma by I have to say as pakistani my prb is Kashmir BJP and RSS apart from Kashmir is no of my prb nor have I got any right to discuss them yes I read about there history and everything to understand them batter that's all
The most important thing of a region is its people n people of GB don't consider themselves as Kashmiris but gilgitis even Kashmiri isn't a main lnguage of GB but balti, shina n some other languages. Majority is still gilgiti n shias. GB is one of the safest and most peaceful region of Pakistan and a biggest tourist destination of the country. Literacy rate is also high than other parts of the country. Still not a 5th province and people angry on that. So you can't compare it with Kashmir specially with IOK. Be honest.
Your data is misleading. Shia and Ismailia population was not 85% before Independence and is not 50% now.
Diamer: 100% Sunni
Astore: Sunni's 60%, Shias 40%
Gilgit: Shia/Sunni 50/50
Nagar: 100% Shia
Ghizer: Mostly Sunni and Ismailia and some Shia
Ghanche: Noorbakhshi 90% and 10% others
Shiger: Shia 75% and 25% others mostly Noorbakhsi
SKARDU: 90% Shia and 10% others
Kharmang: 96% Shia
Hunza: Almost 100% Ismailia
Total:
Shia:39.85%
Sunni:30.05%
Ismaili24%
Noorbakhshis:6.1%
For you kind information we are all Muslims. Therefore there is no question of any religious demographic changes.
In IOK Muslims are in majority but Hindus in flux from other states of India can change its demography.
thank u for presenting the true picture of Gilgit-Baltistan. As the Army has taken over control in Pakistan, but this time in a different manner. Uses a so-called puppet government to give a cosmetic touch of democracy, the same is the situation in GB, Force Commander of GB controls the overall affairs. Since Bhutto (motherfucker) lifted the state subject rule in1970s, the status of princely states of Gilgit, Hunza, Nager was waived, Sunnis from the downside of the country came in Gilgit and state agencies started the sectarian conflict so that people should remain in a persistent state of turmoil and darkness. GB has become a fertile land of some foolishly sentimental young blood to recruit in different forces. These foolishly sentimental people were used in Kargil war, and were disowned but non of army Generals were questioned for deceiving jawans of NLI, the foolish sentimental sons of Gilgit-Baltistan. The nationalist leaders and individuals from GB who take courage to talk about human rights are imprisoned through courts on false allegations. religious leaders are threatened and forced unwillingly to celebrate 14th Augst, Kashmir day etc. Gilgit has its own history of struggle against the British govt. it had got independence on Nov 1947. The whole region of south asia including Afganistan has never witnessed peace in the region since the inception of Pakistan. As far as the Army of Pakistan is not punished once for all India and Afganistan would never see peace. A simple solution is to hit the core commanders of Pakistan through a missile once they sit to analyse the secrity situation in the country.
Excellent barkha, I appreciate ur patriotic & real coverage of pok. God will forgive all ur previous sins if u speak the truth Hope u will speak & will join in favour of nation
Actually it is copy & paste from any article. I hv read all these from an article 4 days ago 😂😂😂😂😂
Link to that article please 😊
@@partyrock6680 plz read it. It's totally copy paste 😂😂😂😂 m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/the-jammu-and-kashmir-pakistan-does-not-want-to-talk-about/amp_articleshow/70688492.cms#click=t.co/mJIXqs4ZMd
Pakistan at least don't guage the eyes of people in what you define Pakistan occupied Kashmir
Religious militias? Why can’t you say Islamic terrorists?
This is surprising, what happened to you.lota of your friends are not going to like this report.it will be good if you make a video on Kashmiri pandit.
U forget to mention that in 1947 Jammu had a20% Muslim population that was reduced to 2% by massacring rest 18% ,was that to change demography ? Both countries had played for their interests and Kashmiris r paying the price !
what happened to nearly 20% of Hindus in Pakisthan
@J R Rao Yar both countries had done and u should have guts to accept the reality!! I don't want to go in detail just for your reminder I will refresh your memory by some recent events!!
1984 .Anti Sikh riots in Delhi !! 3k + Sikhs butchered!
2002 .Gujrat massacre: more than 3k Muslims killed !!
Power without blood stains is rare to find in today's world !!
Bilal kuch to sharam kero .1947 me pakistan me Hindu population 20 percent thi aur aaj uski kya position hai shayed 2 percent se bhi kam.kahan gayi baki ki 18 percent.Vo shikar hui tumhari Islami barbariyat aur forceful conversion ki.Kashmir pe to tum loge badi-badi baten milate ho,tumne Pakistan me base Hinduon ka kya haal kiya,ye sab jante hain. Hamare desh me to mussalmano ke saath aisa koi treatment nahi hua aur vo apne dharam ko maante hue badi aazadi ke saath rehte hain.
@@anilwanchoo3156 sharm to Tum ko krni chahiye ! 1947 m Pakistan Bangladesh mila ke tha ! Dekho glt ko Galt kehna sekho Bhai . Pakistan m agr ek bi Hindu mara gya ya Forcefully convert huwa I strongly condemn that !! Apka ye kehna ki India m ASA kuch na huwa !! Wikipedia, Google karo kuch topics deta hun .
1947 .Jammu Muslim massacre
1947 murder of Gandiji
Murder of Indira Gandhi
Murder of Rajiv Gandhi
1984 ,Anti Sikh riots
2002 Gujrat massacre
Recently linching in India
Ban on prayer on roads by up government ..Ye h Kya azzadi !!Bhai Sach Jano aur mano!! Andh bakti na kroo!!
@J R Rao Bhai world is badly in need of positive people that will think of future rather cursing one another for their past actions! Love is the only language that is understood by all and in present scenario we badly need it to make the world sustainable for our future generations! Spread love and stop hatred !! Nyce talking to you !!
#Barkhadutt Do a story on Jammu Massacre. How long will you lie to your people.
She sometimes hugs Kashmiris for publicity and then stoopes in front of BJP. She is no more a journo. That is why in comments people are calling her name such as chamelion, alligator.
just trying to get into good books of indians.
Nobody dares to speak the truth. They have to choose between Truth and Life.She did the same
@subhadeep mandal Listen brother, you haven't understood my point what I mean is that whatever happened in past,all the communities suffered be it Muslims,hindus or sikhs.
What matters is the present situation. People shouldn't suffer, they should be heared. They should be given complete rights without any conditions.
fictitious??? give me a break! I speak facts, do you want proof? And yes listen it's one's choice which religion he or she follows, no one can stop that.
Well explained barkha nam.
Hari singh did this against our will we are 95 muslim majority why we would be worh india???now the way u caged kashmiris in Iok u want to do this with us as well???
Fatiiiii.... maza aa raha hai... kasam se. 🤣
Is any one living there ever said didn't do this ?
Zulfiaqar Bhutto was shia.
Come on Barkha we expect some mature commentary from the seniors like you
I have lived in Gilgit Baltistan for many Years. But everyone is happy with Pakistan. Gilgit Baltistan people says they r not Kahsmiris. They are of a separate ethnicity. They even wanted to be a province of Pakistan as compared to Azad Kashmir. What Barkha is saying is totally useless n will never change Pakistani stance on IOk.
What about hyderabad Deccan .
What about Telangana?
Hyderabad is a Urdu speaking Muslim occupation in a telugu land. But they are Indians now. We should move on. It is best muslims recognize the generosity of Hindus. If this was a Muslim land Hindus were invaders, I can tell you after the colonial power left, no Hindu would have been left unslaughtered, nor would he have received his rights. Hindus in own native land of sindh cannot build temples. Muslims ask too much and give too little.
Here, the point shouldn't be the what geographical position is. This time, the main issue is that how the people belonging to these areas are living? In Pakistan, they have never raised their voices for freedom and any forced action. But in #IOK living bodies are continuously demanding for their humanitarian rights and freedom since 1927. Though the movement of freedom was started before the actual struggle for claiming of independence of Pakistan. The #IOK have been victimized mentally and physically by govt. You are just making fool and trapping by words instead of raising voice to stop genocide. Nothing is above over humanity.
dude.... POWER is above humanity,it always was ,is and will be...
HISTORY is written by winners and not quitters
#freebalouchistan
Happy to see that Barkha Datt is talking sense!! Good coverage!!
Totally wrong.
1. Kashmiri land within Azad Kashmir and in Pakistan is fully protected by law and even government cannot acquired.
2. Non Kashmiri cannot buy land in Kashmir but Kashmiris are free to buy land anywhere in AJK and Pakistan.
3. Kashmiri have free to any job/business in Pakistan but Pakistani are freely allowed to do business/job in Azad Kashmir.
Indian viewpoint is bullshit.
I am from that place no not true
I am from Gilgit. It's true.
Extremely poor and throw away analysis in comparison of two regions. Looks like it was done in your cozy bad without even paying a single visit to the areas you mentioned. Why not keep it simple and visit to see ground realities, I would love to be your host in GB
Barka u first stop human rights violation in IOK then teach us
You can come to Gilgit Baltistan and meet the people there. You can talk to them freely and ask them about their ethnicity and affiliation. Its a cheap publicity stunt by you
Burkha right now I feel you were saying good but your mental approach toward leftist is not good.
They always said it's POK wish what they want, so If you have guts then Said same now India have illegally occupied Kashmir
burqa bitch ke kitte shohar gilgit Baltistan me?
Aj bi gilgit baltistan ma 90 percent shia muslim hai fuzol ma apna ap sa jhut mat bolo ma khud gilgit baltistan ka hu lol india
SHEROS Lady speaking 😁
Not true at all
Biased journalism
MOJO - MOSLIM JOURNALISM
Paapi pet sab kuch karwati hai.Pet pe laat parte reporting sahi ho gayi pagli ki
Congratulations.. Yeah kya Ho raha hai
It's due media threat so she balanced it by making this video aganist Pakistan.. Strategy
Sorry am not pakisatni so am not interested for this video🤣🤣🤣 and history
Dear Barkha
There is a very famous dialogue of Hindi film Deevar
"Dusroon kai paap gin nai sae apnae paap kam nani hotae"
She is a journalist. It's her job to report such things. 🤷🏻♂️
I'm big admire of your but now I feel you started working for BJP too like many others
What a jokes by Barkha Dutt through out the video
Ye kya rasta badal diya aapne... Barkha ji Sab kushal? Paristhiti badal gaya? Washington post mein kaam teek taak hain?
False figures and perceptions
Isko ho kya gaya hai ,itna sudhar kaise gayee hai
Tu aaj kisi true Indian k sath thi isliye tere bol badle badle lag rahe hai.