It’s interesting that Yamada Sensei mentions that Hikitsuchi Sensei’s ability was below Saito Sensei and Tohei Sensei… Many students who spent time with Hikitsuchi Sensei swears that he was one of the best in the world… I’m sure Tohei Sensei and Saito Sensei’s students would say the same though…
Perhaps students are fans and not high enough experts and thus be qualified to properly judge otherwise they would be students or ever put down a teacher they love but the curriculum may be what is fantastic and survives even lower levels of expertise
O'Sensei insisted Tohei a 10th because of his mastery of ki and techniques and being the chief promoter of the art across the continents particularly Hawaii and US.
Politics in the martial arts is rampant and pervasive. Masters are literally a dime a dozen. Those who claim to be masters usually are not nearly proficient in what they say they are. A true master is usually humble enough to not say that he is.
“Don” is not the correct pronunciation of 段. “Dan” is correct. But one robot is saying “deehn” and another is saying “daaan” because they speak American rather than English.
The whole grade system is a modern invention to motivate students to continue training. It is a competetive system, a pat on the back, and is contrary to the budo spirit. Morihei himself and all the great masters never had any kyuu or dan, only later. Dans were given away not based on real skills but to incompetent aikidokas to make them look like a true master, so they could be send to teach overseas for example. OSensei made regularly fun of dan grades (it was new to him) and jokingly gave away dan grades like chocolate cookies to little kids. (interviews with students of Morihei who did understood he was joking and not accepted it.) Thats why Kisshomaru and the Aikikai do not recognize certain dan grades including the tendan grade of Hikitsuchi (a great master by the way...) Nowadays everybody is a Shihan LMAO everybody is a puffed up showboat thinking that any dan actually has value and make them better than lesser ranked aikidokas!
"Dans were given away not based on real skills but to incompetent aikidokas to make them look like a true master, so they could be send to teach overseas for example" - This is just plain stupid. Sure Ueshiba didn't care about the Dan/Kyu grading system but in reality all of the people who went overseas were highly skilled people.
Ueshiba sensei didn't care about ranks... seems a lot of silly people did though and thus Aikido has a problem today... self-promoted 10:th dan ranks... jeeez ! You might as well find it at the bottom of a cornflakes box...
Mach ado about nothing. ... O’Sensei did’nt care much about ranks and obviously liked to joke with those who gave them to much importance. The tenth dan of Koichi Tohei is an exception occured for spiritual reasons we have no means nor right to évaluate.
Interesting content on the topic. Thank you 🙏
It’s interesting that Yamada Sensei mentions that Hikitsuchi Sensei’s ability was below Saito Sensei and Tohei Sensei… Many students who spent time with Hikitsuchi Sensei swears that he was one of the best in the world… I’m sure Tohei Sensei and Saito Sensei’s students would say the same though…
Perhaps students are fans and not high enough experts and thus be qualified to properly judge otherwise they would be students or ever put down a teacher they love but the curriculum may be what is fantastic and survives even lower levels of expertise
O'Sensei insisted Tohei a 10th because of his mastery of ki and techniques and being the chief promoter of the art across the continents particularly Hawaii and US.
O-sensei was right: rank means very little.... but boy do we make a big deal out of nothing, don't we.
Seidokan Aikido 6th ☯️🥋
The way they hand out Dan grades nowadays, I’m not surprised that there aren’t thousands of Tenth Dans out there!!!!
Блез Паскаль
That's reserved for the Japanese only.
Politics in the martial arts is rampant and pervasive. Masters are literally a dime a dozen. Those who claim to be masters usually are not nearly proficient in what they say they are. A true master is usually humble enough to not say that he is.
O Sensei did not care about ranks!
Belt holds 👆👖😊☯️
MINORU MOCHIZUKI.
Get a robot that can say “don” (soft “a”) a level of black belt grading, instead of “Dan” (hard “a”), a common male first name.
“Don” is not the correct pronunciation of 段. “Dan” is correct. But one robot is saying “deehn” and another is saying “daaan” because they speak American rather than English.
Sorry, that should be “rather than Japanese.” Quite a few English speakers would get the vowel wrong.
à 9'21 çà devient grave,il faut faire quelque chose çà dérape!
The whole grade system is a modern invention to motivate students to continue training. It is a competetive system, a pat on the back, and is contrary to the budo spirit. Morihei himself and all the great masters never had any kyuu or dan, only later. Dans were given away not based on real skills but to incompetent aikidokas to make them look like a true master, so they could be send to teach overseas for example.
OSensei made regularly fun of dan grades (it was new to him) and jokingly gave away dan grades like chocolate cookies to little kids. (interviews with students of Morihei who did understood he was joking and not accepted it.)
Thats why Kisshomaru and the Aikikai do not recognize certain dan grades including the tendan grade of Hikitsuchi (a great master by the way...)
Nowadays everybody is a Shihan LMAO everybody is a puffed up showboat thinking that any dan actually has value and make them better than lesser ranked aikidokas!
"Dans were given away not based on real skills but to incompetent aikidokas to make them look like a true master, so they could be send to teach overseas for example" - This is just plain stupid. Sure Ueshiba didn't care about the Dan/Kyu grading system but in reality all of the people who went overseas were highly skilled people.
Ueshiba sensei didn't care about ranks... seems a lot of silly people did though and thus Aikido has a problem today... self-promoted 10:th dan ranks... jeeez !
You might as well find it at the bottom of a cornflakes box...
Don't use ai voices
Stuffed dogi's me thinks!! 😂
Mach ado about nothing. ... O’Sensei did’nt care much about ranks and obviously liked to joke with those who gave them to much importance. The tenth dan of Koichi Tohei is an exception occured for spiritual reasons we have no means nor right to évaluate.
Блез Паскаль
Блез Паскаль