I think Chan feels even sadder because he knows how sad LeeKnow must be. Still pushing thru with the lives. I’m glad that the other members are doing their best to cheer him up.
Well Lee Know, Chan and the boys of Ateez did quiete a few Live Streams even if I am drawn to belive they're all still are in "processing-healing" time (as far as possible) so a) I was surprised how fast they trusted themselvs to "go back on the itnerwebs" whe like my aloghrhyhm is still filled with it. and b) Bang Chan seemingly having the guts already to bring it up himself and "tell the world." Not saying those who want to keep it private are cowards or so but I'm kinda "o.o that's tough talking bout that stuff with Fans after a few weeks, already again?" Just respectfully surprised, everyone should take his/her/their own time they need to "heal and grieve." Tottally would be ok if no one ever said anything bout it "bc it hurst to much" but if they bring it up ....
@@annasaddiction5129 everyone has their own way of grieving, and it's okay as long as it doesn't hurt anyone else. Some people like to go back to work as soon as possible to keep their heads busy, and others like to keep to themselves; we just process things differently and grief is a very unique and singular thing for everyone. Stay kind ❤
You can just tell how much the members mean to him. No matter how long it takes for that healing, I’m so glad he has stray kids, and that they have each other🥺
@@haiimleeknoww ofc he is sad about moonbins death but we never know.... I'm not saying that chan imagined that happening to one of his brothers, but the truth is that these thoughts can pop up in your mind when you care about people with all your heart. I'm sure you're aware of the massive amount of hate hyune gets for anything and everything and the others also get hated on for stupid reasons. We obviously don't know what chan was thinking at the time, but still, let's protect our stray kids so that we don't ever have to think about such things happening to one of the kids.
@@StanYeonjunNoonaYou're right you know, when I learned about the dark side of kpop I couldn't help but worry "what if this happened to one of them" like I can't even bear the thought of loosing any of them 💔. Like if you really love someone you're more scared of loosing them than yourself
I don't think he's feeling left out. He is just admiring the members or just tired. I hope he isn't tho if he is. I'm not in his mind. But yea this what I think :D
The last thing he talked about in Bubble was Moonbin. He also mentioned he hasn't been eating, but he's trying to. Even though he's going through so much right now, he told us if we ever needed to talk or needed anything to go to him and Stray Kids, that they would be there for us. He kept apologizing for missing his Live streams over the last couple weeks, he said he needed some time but would make it up to us. I cried. I couldn't stop crying. He has nothing to apologize for. He's more important to us than a live stream. I wish I could give him a big hug, like he always does for us. I wish we could help them too. I wish we could also comfort them when they are going through hard times. I'm so fond of Chan and the others, it hurts so much seeing him in pain and not being able to do anything to help him.
Hmm what if we would send him big hug the same way as he does for us? What about sending him hug thru tiktok or something 🤔🙂 I'm just thinking out loud 🙈 but maybe that woul make him happy at least a little bit
I cried too. I still tear up thinking about it. I instantly wrote that he should take as much time as he needs, and that we will be here when he is ready. I keep telling him how much we love him, and to eat and rest too 😅 He and the rest if SKZ are so precious to me, it hurts so much not being able to comfort them fully 😢
Beautiful Chan, it was difficult for them, they had all spent a lot of time with him and more because of the collaborations of LK and Hyunjin🥺🥺🥺Moonbin 😞😞😞such a beautiful soul I still can't believe he left and I'm heartbroken. His smile will only remain stored in memories 💔🥺
@@infiniteeva3569 yes they were close, Chan practically knows everyone in kpop, Moonbin was close to SKZ and Chan, so much so that in today's episode of Chan's room he commented on it, he also commented that he has not fully recovered, that he is not eating as well as it should but he's trying and that's also why there was no episode of Chan's room last week😔😔😔
So that's why all of you were like "You don't have to apologize for anything!" I was like "What was he apologizing for in the first place?" The thing if you only understand English and our billingual masters switch like a lightswitch between both you don't know what was said half a sentences ago.
Also artists, are defintily belonging to those who hear the "Fly cough on the wall" types of people often times...so expecting anyone in "Kpop" to be fine after a tragedy like this...in Bang Chan words "Manners please!"
I can feel the same chan it feels so sad to lose your precious friend I can see how sad and was quiet the whole time I can see him trying to control himself from crying we can feel the same thing as you are feeling channn be strong and you can to through it love u broo😥😢😭💜
I definitely felt so too. He was zoned out and quiet, and I really hope he doesn't feel pressured to come live. I don't mind and I hope others fans are understanding of him not doing Chan's Room, he needs time too. Edit: I'm not usually this person but 1.8K likes in 9 hours? Edit 2: 6.8K......imagine we made money from how many comment likes we got....I'd be fucking rich.
I don’t stan Astro but started crying when I found out, it felt like I lost someone I know and I felt and still feel so bad for all of his friends and family and all of the people that look up to him and see him as a role model❤️🕊️🌕
The way he looks at his boys and has taken responsibility for them is so beautiful. There are a lot of dads out there who could learn from him. 💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💐
I'm replying to my own comment because it needs to be said again. Chan looks like a proud father who loves his kids but is in pain and doesn't want them to see it. 💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💐
He mentioned on bubble how he was sorry for missing out on Channies room bc he was taking time to process and heal from the events. He still needs some time and we will always be there for him just as he is for us. 💙💙
I can bet 1M dollars that Chan doesn’t want that to happen to any of the group members, maybe even himself as well. He cares for them a lot, it seems like they’re a second family to him. I hope they all stay healthy. But most of all, rest in peace Moonbin🫶
As someone that also struggles with depression and low self-esteem his death really affected me. I hope chan gets to heal in a healthy way by being with the kids. I had to spend some time with my friends to kinda soak in the moment. When you see this happening knowing you also thought about it but you also see the pain it leaves behind you start to reconsider. I wish i could have been there to tell him that but sometimes the pain is just too much. I get it.
I feel like Chan having dealt with depression plays a big role in why he’s taking this so hard. I mean obviously losing a friend like that is the most difficult thing but they were the same age if I’m not mistaken. And I know he mentioned in a Chan’s room episode “who knows, without them [members] i might not even be here, might not even be on planet earth.” I just feel like all of it rolled into one has just made this loss extremely extremely difficult and I hate that for him so much. Also I hope that you’re getting to heal in a healthy way as well! Big hugs 🖤
"stuggles with depression" FYI, *people with depression are not aware that they are depressed* you'll realize that you have depression after you cope with it. Edit: I’m not talking about Chan
@@shreshtha7035 ? People get diagnosed, ofc they realise, you don't function normally, you feel like your a dead log, too tired to even breathe Unless I misunderstood ur comment
Chan has a beautiful soul. I don't understand why people can be so cruel to him, yet he still wants to help. When he said how he was feeling about Moonbins death a lot of people replied with stuff like he was just making it all about himself!! His FRIEND DIED and he only briefly said anything as obviously grieving. He's not allowed to live chats cause of these dispicable beings. We all adore him and want to give him a hug and tell him he's beyond amazing ❤
You can see how even when showing emotions they seem forced or even fake. Typical sings of depression. I’m seriously worried about him. Cus as someone who has been through depression for years, I can tell you it’s one of the worst things that can happen to you (in my opinion). You practically lose your ability to feel emotions. Things that used to bring you joy start feeling dull. The only time I saw a genuine reaction from Chan was when smiling or laughing with the members. I can imagine he has found a new appreciation for them, realizing that you never know what will happen. You have to appreciate what you have in the moment. Moonbin is still watching over us all. He is up in the night sky. Looking down at us and protecting us❤
just watching this made me tear up unconciously again, it reminded me of how i held up with the news 2 weeks ago, i saw the news few minutes before midnight and cried myself to sleep, but didn't really felt like i slept at all, woke up earlier than my alarm, cried again even on the shower, then it was all my co-kpop fan classmates and friends asked me in uni, but i still even got through exams that day, even my parents asked me about it, i was just crying every time i'm not occupied until monday last week, i got my appetite back and was able to properly eat a full meal after 4 days, but as bewildering as this may sound to some, the way i coped with the news was to listen to my most treasured astro song "Always You" on repeat and inever felt so hurt but comforted at the same time and i also binged watched some of astro's yt contents, specially their funny asmr guestings, i was crying but it reminded me of how much moonbin wanted everyone to be happy, and i just promised him to let me cry for a while before i could remember him in happiness only.
i honestly feel so bad for him and all of moonbins fans😭😭i loved moonbin myself and i was absolutely destroyed when i heard what happened so i can't even imagine the pain that bangchan felt😭😭😭i truly feel so bad for him and i know that he'll can remember moonbin and the little girl hiwa who was only a kid when she passed n his heart forever and ever🫶😭❤️
My Wolf Chan , it's OKAY not to be Okay all the time. We love you no matter what. 🥰🥰🥰 Hoping our Moonbin already found his happiness and peace now.🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼.
We love you Channie ❤ I’m sure it’s scary just to hear that someone your age has passed away, let alone a friend. I was born in 1997 and to hear that Moonbin died at 25 really scared me for a moment 😢
and me thinking of how many 1997 there are currently active makes me scared they're literally everywhere. But also Lee Know and Hyunjin too so I guess it's not only age group but also +/- 1-2 etc.
он выглядит таким подавленным, вся эта ситуация сильно повлияла на него, да и сам он говорил, что они были очень близки, мне больно смотреть на него в таком состоянии, я понимаю, это очень больно, когда человек так резко уходит из твоей жизни, но нужно быть сильным, надеюсь, он не чувствует себя виноватым❤
He had been so quiet and sad lately even in thier comeback everyone noticed han being sad but no one noticed that chan was going through so much and was so sad
i feel so bad for chan. it is such a sad thing that moonbin passed, so just imagine how many idols are affected by this but didn't say anything yet. 😭😭 rest in peace moonbin i hope you are in a better place now
seeing him sad is heartbreaking… our favorite therapist and father figure should not have to go through these things… everyone is struggling rest in peace moonbin.
I hope he knows we don't mind him missing chans room episodes so he can take time to heal.... as much as we love the comfort those episodes bring, his health and feelings are so much more important. we love you chan and moonbin ❤️
Pobresito, Chan, yo no soy su fan, pero se lo cercano que era con Bin, pobresito, me da mucho dolor, Moonbin era mi Bias y yo todavía lo lloro y de hecho este video me hizo llorar de nuevo....
i constantly say how much Bangchan makes me smile but it’s unfortunate that we can’t do the same. Moonbin’s death has really shook up the industry and may he rest in peace. I hope he’s grieving healthily and we get out jovial Bangchan again❤
i loved moonbin so much, and i respect bang chan for acting the way he did. i mean, it’s normal to feel down when someone you knew (i think) passed away, so im glad he’s trying to cheer up too, and im glad he has stray kids with him to help him
Its so sad i still watch moobin old videos bit whne i look at him it makes me cry honestly being a celebrity is not worth it its just killing them inside and wanting to die. I think bangchan was scared that what if one of the memebers of skz commit suicide and yeah its just really sad R. I. P moobin STAY FOR LIFE❤
Moonbin is in a better place now probably happier now so we hope he is better in the place he is now and I'm so sorry to bang chan for having to go through that pain and having to heal in very short time we love them so much
The members know the best way for Channie to heal is to be themselves and surround him with their love. That’s a true family. Hang in there Chris we are all here for you❤❤❤
I feel bad for these idols cause i want to just want to talk to them espescially chan cause he is so sweet and wants to care for everyone. I just want to hug them.
poor bangchan... dont worry all stays will protect and love you. throughout the whole live, it seemed like his smile was forced. he was so broken inside that time...
It hurts to know that he is most likely staring at his members/brothers like that because, he doesn’t want them to end up like Moonbin. Bin was always smiling but we failed to notice his inner pain. And I feel like Chris is hoping none of his members are going through that either.
I’m glad the kids seem to make him happier, I’m scared to think what state he would be in if it wasn’t for them keeping him company and cheering him up. He takes care of them as their leader, but they equally take care of him as well
Seeing Chan trying his best to give fake smiles genuinely makes me so sad🥺😞, he's such a bubbly and goofy guy🥰, hope he is trying his best to deal with everything in his life, more power to u channei❤
The way he feels sad. But at the same time heals with the happiness of his group, that in the same way is his family and his 7 kids. I hope he gets better, and they start being more aware of the self care.
The way that moonbin was best friends with lee know and friends with all of the members just breaks my heart. They probably miss him so much. RIP moonbin🤍🕊️
Yeah it’s sad that Chan is having a hard time but it’s also really really tragic that Moonbin died so young. It must be difficult to be an idol sometimes with cameras directed at a person nearly every day. Glad that even in the small ways SKZ supports each other by stepping up when a member needs it
![Shinee's Jonghyun's funeral and the goodbye (memories members) [Must watch]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DwSLPL8un3k/mqdefault.jpg)
Cr: skzshiper on TikTok
that username 💀
also this is fucked up. please don’t monetize someone’s grief.
Do you know the name of the song ?
@@Sosomovehotline Billie Eilish
Do you kno😅
Who she is
?
The way Chan is just healing by changbin's voice😭
QUIT ITS SO CUTE
AWW OMG
Tbh Changbin's loud voice made me laugh in some really hard times, thank God for this loud, extra, pig bunny, leo bundle of joy! 🤗
@@a_tiny_stay As a Changbin's stan since 2019, Your comment is so adorable! ^-^
when was this live done
It's so sad to see him sad. I'm happy stay and stray kids helped him to heal
you could tell he didnt feel up to it. he was so quiet the whole time. not his usual bubbly self. we should all show him some love
I was honestly staring at him the entire live :( I was so worried and concerned, but I was happy to see he atleast smiled from time to time
@@blanc__a it hurts, but i know he has the boys who will give him all the love and care he needs
Could I ask what this was? The video, I mean
@@luyandokalenga5761 it was from their most recent youtube live, they did a group live
Even his smile looks hurt….
I think Chan feels even sadder because he knows how sad LeeKnow must be. Still pushing thru with the lives. I’m glad that the other members are doing their best to cheer him up.
Well Lee Know, Chan and the boys of Ateez did quiete a few Live Streams even if I am drawn to belive they're all still are in "processing-healing" time (as far as possible) so a) I was surprised how fast they trusted themselvs to "go back on the itnerwebs" whe like my aloghrhyhm is still filled with it. and b) Bang Chan seemingly having the guts already to bring it up himself and "tell the world."
Not saying those who want to keep it private are cowards or so but I'm kinda "o.o that's tough talking bout that stuff with Fans after a few weeks, already again?" Just respectfully surprised, everyone should take his/her/their own time they need to "heal and grieve." Tottally would be ok if no one ever said anything bout it "bc it hurst to much" but if they bring it up ....
@@annasaddiction5129 everyone has their own way of grieving, and it's okay as long as it doesn't hurt anyone else. Some people like to go back to work as soon as possible to keep their heads busy, and others like to keep to themselves; we just process things differently and grief is a very unique and singular thing for everyone. Stay kind ❤
chan was bestfriends w moonbin. moonbin said so too back then. chan is sad bc he lost his friend not bc of lk wth
@@esme3761Moonbin's best friend for the past 8 years has been Seungkwan. Please don't make things up, it's not very nice.
@@ArohaStill a person can have more than one best friend you know?
You can just tell how much the members mean to him. No matter how long it takes for that healing, I’m so glad he has stray kids, and that they have each other🥺
yeah same (btw this is the first time i saw this emoji used by a Stay
Absolutely
wish I could I have that I only like three people that are there for me and we should show him love
@@Gnesiarr same
But if it wasn’t for skz bangcahn wouldn’t be aliv
"what if that's one of my kids one day..?"
I'm pretty sure he's not thinking about that he's probably actually said about Moonbin death bro
@@haiimleeknoww ofc he is sad about moonbins death but we never know....
I'm not saying that chan imagined that happening to one of his brothers, but the truth is that these thoughts can pop up in your mind when you care about people with all your heart.
I'm sure you're aware of the massive amount of hate hyune gets for anything and everything and the others also get hated on for stupid reasons.
We obviously don't know what chan was thinking at the time, but still, let's protect our stray kids so that we don't ever have to think about such things happening to one of the kids.
OKAY,NOW I'M CRYING
no we do not speack that swearinng sentence that is illeigal 4 stays k ?😶😶😶😭😭😭😭
@@StanYeonjunNoonaYou're right you know, when I learned about the dark side of kpop I couldn't help but worry "what if this happened to one of them" like I can't even bear the thought of loosing any of them 💔.
Like if you really love someone you're more scared of loosing them than yourself
Him being sad breaks my heart
Same 🥺
He is always wearing black
He is always wearing black
He is always wearing black
Bro this video literally made me cry
Only his children could make him happy in that moment
Poor channie he looks a bit down after hearing abt moon in
R.I.P Moonbin😭
Me everyday
@@JayJay-dd7yl your not alone🥹
I don't think he's feeling left out. He is just admiring the members or just tired. I hope he isn't tho if he is. I'm not in his mind. But yea this what I think :D
I thought it was because of Moonbin’s death. He’s processing still.
@@kiwiiiiiiiiiiiii829 maybe idk
I love how he just had to look at his boys and his smile came back...they are his world and I'm so thankful to God that he has them❤
The last thing he talked about in Bubble was Moonbin. He also mentioned he hasn't been eating, but he's trying to. Even though he's going through so much right now, he told us if we ever needed to talk or needed anything to go to him and Stray Kids, that they would be there for us. He kept apologizing for missing his Live streams over the last couple weeks, he said he needed some time but would make it up to us. I cried. I couldn't stop crying. He has nothing to apologize for. He's more important to us than a live stream. I wish I could give him a big hug, like he always does for us. I wish we could help them too. I wish we could also comfort them when they are going through hard times. I'm so fond of Chan and the others, it hurts so much seeing him in pain and not being able to do anything to help him.
Hmm what if we would send him big hug the same way as he does for us? What about sending him hug thru tiktok or something 🤔🙂 I'm just thinking out loud 🙈 but maybe that woul make him happy at least a little bit
@Simona Balážová That's actually such a good idea and I love it. 🩷🥺 I don't have tiktok though. How would we spread it to STAY?
I cried too. I still tear up thinking about it. I instantly wrote that he should take as much time as he needs, and that we will be here when he is ready. I keep telling him how much we love him, and to eat and rest too 😅 He and the rest if SKZ are so precious to me, it hurts so much not being able to comfort them fully 😢
@@simonabalazova2866I luv that idea❣️
@@simonabalazova2866 maybe on bubble STAY’s can send ‘virtual big hugs’ to Channie?
the fact that you can see his pain in his eyes hurts the most 💔
Beautiful Chan, it was difficult for them, they had all spent a lot of time with him and more because of the collaborations of LK and Hyunjin🥺🥺🥺Moonbin 😞😞😞such a beautiful soul I still can't believe he left and I'm heartbroken. His smile will only remain stored in memories 💔🥺
@@infiniteeva3569 yes they were close, Chan practically knows everyone in kpop, Moonbin was close to SKZ and Chan, so much so that in today's episode of Chan's room he commented on it, he also commented that he has not fully recovered, that he is not eating as well as it should but he's trying and that's also why there was no episode of Chan's room last week😔😔😔
So that's why all of you were like "You don't have to apologize for anything!"
I was like "What was he apologizing for in the first place?"
The thing if you only understand English and our billingual masters switch like a lightswitch between both you don't know what was said half a sentences ago.
He is doing he's best to keep all his members safe
We all know he would never forgive himself if something like that happens to one of his kids
Hes smiling thru the pain💔
Han and Changbin tried to make him laugh ❣
I felt that too - thank you for saying it
Also artists, are defintily belonging to those who hear the "Fly cough on the wall" types of people often times...so expecting anyone in "Kpop" to be fine after a tragedy like this...in Bang Chan words "Manners please!"
? did they all know moonbin?
id moonbin the one that helped lee know that day and gave him water
I can feel the same chan it feels so sad to lose your precious friend I can see how sad and was quiet the whole time I can see him trying to control himself from crying we can feel the same thing as you are feeling channn be strong and you can to through it love u broo😥😢😭💜
I definitely felt so too. He was zoned out and quiet, and I really hope he doesn't feel pressured to come live. I don't mind and I hope others fans are understanding of him not doing Chan's Room, he needs time too.
Edit: I'm not usually this person but 1.8K likes in 9 hours?
Edit 2: 6.8K......imagine we made money from how many comment likes we got....I'd be fucking rich.
He said on bubble he’s not doing a live this week cuz he’s trying to heal mentally
Same
we can wait 🥺 we just want him to be okay
That's the reason why he isn't doing chan's room? I feel like crying.
@@arinontop143 me too 😢
I noticed he was calmer, less talkative than usual. Take as much time as you need Channie. I'm sending you a big hug
Sensitive people felt the pain most,even you are not related with the person or know nothing about it.
I'm one of those 😢, I felt this loss so much and unexpectedly so...
This is so true.i knew him from moment of eighteen and had no idea that he was in astro until recently but i cried so much
I don’t stan Astro but started crying when I found out, it felt like I lost someone I know and I felt and still feel so bad for all of his friends and family and all of the people that look up to him and see him as a role model❤️🕊️🌕
Chan is close with him :(
Me as well. I cried so much that i could only imagine the pain his family must be feeling
The way he looks at his boys and has taken responsibility for them is so beautiful. There are a lot of dads out there who could learn from him. 💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💐
I'm replying to my own comment because it needs to be said again. Chan looks like a proud father who loves his kids but is in pain and doesn't want them to see it. 💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💐
He mentioned on bubble how he was sorry for missing out on Channies room bc he was taking time to process and heal from the events. He still needs some time and we will always be there for him just as he is for us. 💙💙
And yet he was on live just today couple hours ago?
@@annasaddiction5129 in case you missed it he said he missed 2 weeks of lives.
@@annasaddiction5129 I also posted this 2 days ago. Obviously no one knew he was gonna go live today
“Here’re my kids.. I need to be stronger for them.. just smile”
It's ok Chan.
take your time and care about your mental health. We'll be here for you always ❤🖤
I can bet 1M dollars that Chan doesn’t want that to happen to any of the group members, maybe even himself as well. He cares for them a lot, it seems like they’re a second family to him. I hope they all stay healthy. But most of all, rest in peace Moonbin🫶
As someone that also struggles with depression and low self-esteem his death really affected me. I hope chan gets to heal in a healthy way by being with the kids. I had to spend some time with my friends to kinda soak in the moment. When you see this happening knowing you also thought about it but you also see the pain it leaves behind you start to reconsider. I wish i could have been there to tell him that but sometimes the pain is just too much. I get it.
I feel like Chan having dealt with depression plays a big role in why he’s taking this so hard. I mean obviously losing a friend like that is the most difficult thing but they were the same age if I’m not mistaken. And I know he mentioned in a Chan’s room episode “who knows, without them [members] i might not even be here, might not even be on planet earth.”
I just feel like all of it rolled into one has just made this loss extremely extremely difficult and I hate that for him so much.
Also I hope that you’re getting to heal in a healthy way as well! Big hugs 🖤
Take care kath1366, hope everything works out well for you in life. You got this :)
"stuggles with depression"
FYI, *people with depression are not aware that they are depressed*
you'll realize that you have depression after you cope with it.
Edit: I’m not talking about Chan
@@ceebs_97 has he struggled with sh in the past too?
@@shreshtha7035 ? People get diagnosed, ofc they realise, you don't function normally, you feel like your a dead log, too tired to even breathe
Unless I misunderstood ur comment
They knew what Chan needed to help him through the initial shock and having to perform for the camera.
He chose wisely when he chose each member
I hope all of Moonbin's family, friends and fans find peace. This is hard on us all. From Aroha.
@Astro-Lun8-Exo. Pois é, não está fácil não!
Chan has a beautiful soul. I don't understand why people can be so cruel to him, yet he still wants to help. When he said how he was feeling about Moonbins death a lot of people replied with stuff like he was just making it all about himself!! His FRIEND DIED and he only briefly said anything as obviously grieving. He's not allowed to live chats cause of these dispicable beings. We all adore him and want to give him a hug and tell him he's beyond amazing ❤
Now Chan needs a big hug 😕🫂
😞🫂❤️❤️🥰🫶🏿🫶🏿🫶🫶Love you Chan
R.i.p Moonbin 😥😭😣🤧😿
i really wish we could go and give him one as a group. just yesterday i cried because of the loss of Moonbin😭🕊️
I really wish I can give him one😢 R.I.P to moonbin 🕊️
i can see the pain thorugh his eyes, this delicate man need to get better
You’re not alone Chan… Stays are here for you. Take your time, it’s okay ! Love you soooo much ❤️
R.I.P Moonbin, we will never forget you 🌙
You can see how even when showing emotions they seem forced or even fake. Typical sings of depression. I’m seriously worried about him.
Cus as someone who has been through depression for years, I can tell you it’s one of the worst things that can happen to you (in my opinion).
You practically lose your ability to feel emotions. Things that used to bring you joy start feeling dull.
The only time I saw a genuine reaction from Chan was when smiling or laughing with the members.
I can imagine he has found a new appreciation for them, realizing that you never know what will happen.
You have to appreciate what you have in the moment.
Moonbin is still watching over us all. He is up in the night sky. Looking down at us and protecting us❤
just watching this made me tear up unconciously again, it reminded me of how i held up with the news 2 weeks ago, i saw the news few minutes before midnight and cried myself to sleep, but didn't really felt like i slept at all, woke up earlier than my alarm, cried again even on the shower, then it was all my co-kpop fan classmates and friends asked me in uni, but i still even got through exams that day, even my parents asked me about it, i was just crying every time i'm not occupied until monday last week, i got my appetite back and was able to properly eat a full meal after 4 days, but as bewildering as this may sound to some, the way i coped with the news was to listen to my most treasured astro song "Always You" on repeat and inever felt so hurt but comforted at the same time and i also binged watched some of astro's yt contents, specially their funny asmr guestings, i was crying but it reminded me of how much moonbin wanted everyone to be happy, and i just promised him to let me cry for a while before i could remember him in happiness only.
The fact he wanted to reasure stays that he was fine by covering up with a smile hes totally deserves the world honestly 😭
Channie just fonding over the kids:')) you can tell that just being around them heals him. That man has such a pure soul.
It's fine chan...
I cried for hours in my bed i even made a tiktok about it take ur time to heal remember how good of a leader u are
i honestly feel so bad for him and all of moonbins fans😭😭i loved moonbin myself and i was absolutely destroyed when i heard what happened so i can't even imagine the pain that bangchan felt😭😭😭i truly feel so bad for him and i know that he'll can remember moonbin and the little girl hiwa who was only a kid when she passed n his heart forever and ever🫶😭❤️
My Wolf Chan , it's OKAY not to be Okay all the time. We love you no matter what. 🥰🥰🥰 Hoping our Moonbin already found his happiness and peace now.🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼.
Chan loves and cares for his members and stays, stays care for chan and his members members care about chan and stays, We love eachother ♥️
We love you Channie ❤ I’m sure it’s scary just to hear that someone your age has passed away, let alone a friend. I was born in 1997 and to hear that Moonbin died at 25 really scared me for a moment 😢
and me thinking of how many 1997 there are currently active makes me scared they're literally everywhere. But also Lee Know and Hyunjin too so I guess it's not only age group but also +/- 1-2 etc.
Чани такой солнышко,как же не хочется видеть его тихим,молчаливым и грустным....Я очень надеюсь,что с ним будет всё хорошо❤
он выглядит таким подавленным, вся эта ситуация сильно повлияла на него, да и сам он говорил, что они были очень близки, мне больно смотреть на него в таком состоянии, я понимаю, это очень больно, когда человек так резко уходит из твоей жизни, но нужно быть сильным, надеюсь, он не чувствует себя виноватым❤
Вы про мунбин?
Я просто не понимаю
@@milk_7.773 да
А что случилось то? Не понимаю просто..
@@miSaikola мунбин умер 🕊️
Honestly this was so sad to see him look down in the weather, i feel so bad for Chris 😢
He had been so quiet and sad lately even in thier comeback everyone noticed han being sad but no one noticed that chan was going through so much and was so sad
Same with me i think. I dont show it, but the grief is locked up inside.
i feel so bad for chan. it is such a sad thing that moonbin passed, so just imagine how many idols are affected by this but didn't say anything yet. 😭😭 rest in peace moonbin i hope you are in a better place now
When the problem child is the solution😢❤
He was so quiet in that live :( I really hope he's alright :( bless him he deserves everything
I cant stop crying bc of bang chan😭
We need to protect them.
Happy birthday moonbin❤
seeing him sad is heartbreaking… our favorite therapist and father figure should not have to go through these things… everyone is struggling rest in peace moonbin.
The fact that when changbin started talking (well more like shouting but yk 💀) chan started to smile amd seemed a bit more happy 🤍
I hope he knows we don't mind him missing chans room episodes so he can take time to heal.... as much as we love the comfort those episodes bring, his health and feelings are so much more important. we love you chan and moonbin ❤️
Beautifully said! ❤
The best leader😢❤
Pobresito, Chan, yo no soy su fan, pero se lo cercano que era con Bin, pobresito, me da mucho dolor, Moonbin era mi Bias y yo todavía lo lloro y de hecho este video me hizo llorar de nuevo....
i constantly say how much Bangchan makes me smile but it’s unfortunate that we can’t do the same. Moonbin’s death has really shook up the industry and may he rest in peace. I hope he’s grieving healthily and we get out jovial Bangchan again❤
they're the reason he's alive, they know it.
he's trying so hard but he smiles at the sound of changbins voice makes me happy but also makes me want to cry I feel so bad..❤️
Rest in peace moonbin you will be missed forever😢✊😿
Love how the members tried everything to make Chan hyung happy without him noticing 🥹 they are so kind ❤
Fly high Moonbin 🕊️
The fact this vid was 2month ago and thats the time when moonbin died
And everyone forgot abt someone😢❤
i loved moonbin so much, and i respect bang chan for acting the way he did. i mean, it’s normal to feel down when someone you knew (i think) passed away, so im glad he’s trying to cheer up too, and im glad he has stray kids with him to help him
Cuanto se les quiere a estos hermosos chicos, son tan adorables cada uno en su registro, como me encanta verlos felices SKZ FOREVER🤟🏻😍💖
Protect skz pls I don’t know what I will ever do without them they are my only source of happiness
But he is hiding his pain and showing a beautiful 😍 smile 😃 😢 😭 😿 😢 😭
Rest in peace out beloved moobin I miss him 😢 💔
Chan...... always so observant, always so caring. Someone also watches and cares for him.🤍🧡
Moonbin's death was hard for everybody i didnt even know him that well and im still sad even my mom heard about it R.I.P🕊
Its so sad i still watch moobin old videos bit whne i look at him it makes me cry honestly being a celebrity is not worth it its just killing them inside and wanting to die. I think bangchan was scared that what if one of the memebers of skz commit suicide and yeah its just really sad
R. I. P moobin
STAY FOR LIFE❤
Love you Channie, take the time you need. Stay will live up to their name and beyond ❤
Moonbin is in a better place now probably happier now so we hope he is better in the place he is now and I'm so sorry to bang chan for having to go through that pain and having to heal in very short time we love them so much
Everyone loved moonbin 😢😭❤
The members know the best way for Channie to heal is to be themselves and surround him with their love. That’s a true family. Hang in there Chris we are all here for you❤❤❤
i’m literally gonna cry all over again, it’s so heartbreaking 💔
He’s never that quiet
Even if he's hurting inside he still smiles it makes me wanna cry so bad🥺
Он присматривает за своими детьми. Настоящий отец ❤❤
Poor baby, he doesn't look like himself.
Moonbin's death affected all idols and all fandoms. Makes you rethink life values.
I feel bad for these idols cause i want to just want to talk to them espescially chan cause he is so sweet and wants to care for everyone. I just want to hug them.
poor bangchan... dont worry all stays will protect and love you. throughout the whole live, it seemed like his smile was forced. he was so broken inside that time...
The day one of the members dies will be the worst day in my existence I feel absolutely horrible for all those who have lost someone they love
This was me when I heard about his death R.I.P Moonbin you will be missed by lots of
I feel like chan is worried the same could happen to his members and he is worried for them
Bang chan with his members is like: a dad trying to be happy with their kids but they are actually sad😢💔
It hurts to know that he is most likely staring at his members/brothers like that because, he doesn’t want them to end up like Moonbin.
Bin was always smiling but we failed to notice his inner pain. And I feel like Chris is hoping none of his members are going through that either.
I’m glad the kids seem to make him happier, I’m scared to think what state he would be in if it wasn’t for them keeping him company and cheering him up. He takes care of them as their leader, but they equally take care of him as well
He's still trying to heal from the passing of moonbin. I feel bad for Chan, but his kids are helping him smile again.
Seeing Chan trying his best to give fake smiles genuinely makes me so sad🥺😞, he's such a bubbly and goofy guy🥰, hope he is trying his best to deal with everything in his life, more power to u channei❤
Чану еще тяжелее чем нам, после ухода Мунбина...
I love Chan very much because he cares about his members and takes care of them like he is their father. I love him so much
Вы не представляете как я его люблю ….
я заплакала
Bang chan was not really well, hope he get better now. Han too was not that’s happy. Keep protect them and making them happy. Please stay 🫶🏻❤️🩹
The person who helped us when we were sad needs help 😔💔
The way he feels sad. But at the same time heals with the happiness of his group, that in the same way is his family and his 7 kids. I hope he gets better, and they start being more aware of the self care.
Oooo...so thats why he was so quiet"(((
The way that moonbin was best friends with lee know and friends with all of the members just breaks my heart. They probably miss him so much. RIP moonbin🤍🕊️
Pobrecito chan tiene que poner su mejor cara pero en el fondo sufre en silencio la muerte de su colega moonbin 😭😭😭💖💖💖
😔🤝
I could see that it really shocked the whole kpop community. I didn't even knew who he was, but I was just as shocked.
Yeah it’s sad that Chan is having a hard time but it’s also really really tragic that Moonbin died so young. It must be difficult to be an idol sometimes with cameras directed at a person nearly every day.
Glad that even in the small ways SKZ supports each other by stepping up when a member needs it