He's saying this so comfortably and calmly as if it's a line in a kdrama series😂. If he's really that sad, what happened to moonbin then? Why isn't anyone saying what really happened to him. What or who killed him?
@@aprildamian Idk what about a person clearly trying not to cry and taking careful pauses between their words seemed comfortable to you lmao? He may not even know the details, or if he does then he has no obligation to tell us thats private info anyways.
Hello……..👋 I appreciate you my beloved lady for your Likes and comments on my official page, I hope you will not stop supporting me I’m very pleased that all of you have been Around all this years of my career I appreciate your support and warm Comments I want to say thank you very much 🙏 I appreciate you all God bless you How are you? And where’re you from?
It's hard for those who are close, nobody expected it at all. Eunwoo probably feels partially responsible as someone who is close like "What went wrong?" "Was I not reliable for you to come for help?" It wasn't his fault but as someone who witness others losing their loved ones suddenly, they can't help but feel guilty that they weren't enough help to stop them from the unimaginable. Separation is hard and it was sad that Moonbin left in such a lonely and painful way. I hope Eunwoo can move on slowly and peacefully.
@@vanillafoodie non si sa niente di cosa sia successo a Bin. Non date per scontate cose che non sono sicure. Bin non avrebbe mai fatto un gesto volontario. In un video di Cjha Eunw Woo mentre canta si tocca la vena del collo e gli manda un bacio. Bin si toccava sempre la vena del collo e quando la vedi che batte forte non è un buon segno. E' il segnale che Bin era malato.
He has survivor's remorse. He feels guilty he could not see what the struggle was, that it ran so deep enough he could not see the hope anymore and became lost. He feels he let his friend down by not saving him. He someday needs to forgive himself. He had not been through this before, and had no idea about the signs or what to do. Now, with each celebrity dying the same way, it keeps taking him back to the tragedy, over and over again. He thinks Moonbin is forgotten because lives did not stop, but for the most part his did. Poor guy. Wish we could hug him and console him. Life is a journey. As we walk our paths of life, other's paths will cross ours as well. Some briefly, but other's will entwine with us, and we walk together, sharing each other's thoughts, desires, and love. Sometimes, all too quickly, we are split from each other's paths. Some move on their journey to meet other's, while some end their paths all too soon. But we have to cherish the time we spent together, remember the most special moments they left us, the footprints on our hearts and in our minds. These memories will keep them alive as we continue their legacy, never forgotten, never far from our sides. Sharing their influences is what keeps their legacy alive.
@nana8631 never seen such a news perhaps fake news but according to his family they expressed physical asthma with lung 🫁 infection just like when the (video) blue flame he was supposed to be the main performer instead the other astro members especially Cha eunwoo if you recall his Absence Moon wasn't there for over several months to promote the song...he was ill very ill...
@@userbunny I appreciate your response my beloved lady, And thank you for your love care and support 🤍🩵🤍. How are you? Where are you from? And how long have you been my fan?.
Moonbin will be remembered for a very long time. Still devastating to think he's gone, I think so much of his family and Astro members who have been so brave, kept going even if it has been so hard...
As a shawol I will never forget moonbin like I do with Jonghyun. The pain of loss never goes but at least we have happy memories and we’re lucky enough to of known them. I hope Eunwoo and the rest of Astro and AROHA are doing ok. Its ok to miss him. He will never be forgotten ❤
basta fare il confronto don Jonghyun. Questo ragazzo aveva lasciato una lettera di addio. Di Bin non sappiamo niente, non scrivete cose di cui non siete certi. Per rispetto di Bin che amava il suo lavoro ed aveva così tanto amore e rispetto per i suoi fan .
@ISABEL-k7h8n honestly some people will find anything to take a dig at 🙄 i never said anything against him. Im sorry you never got answers but it’s not a competition. Both were tragic circumstances. I understand your angry but please don’t take it out on people trying to be supportive and kind. Im not a Aroha but I respect Moonbin and saw how kind and talented he was. Its tragic. And I wish you the best and hope Moonbin rest in peace … the same to “that guy” Jonghyun who I miss and love.
Honestly, that feeling of thinking its unfiar if you eat or sleep after someone passes away, is one of the worst feelings ever! I've felt it too and its really hard to overcome :/
I'm so so sorry, Eunwoo. I'm so, so sorry, your heartaches. Your heartaches because you love so much. Your best friend had the honor and privilege to have you in his life. He loved you. We will always remember those who are not here, and it will hurt for a long time. Just know this, You are a beautiful, wonderful, kind human being who loved his best friend, and that's why your friend loved you so much.Think of this when you think of him... Our heart aches for you, and we wish we could take the pain away...
you will never forget the wonderful soul named Moonbin, he lives in all of our hearts forever .. his spirit lives on thru the music and our memories ..
this was rlly hard to watch... i cry just thinking about him bc it doesnt feel real and i think it never will, even more so to the ppl who were actually close to him.. that man had the ability to cheer me up everytime i saw a clip of him and im sure im not the only one who feels that way, i just wish i had enjoyed more of his presence when he was still here yk... thats my biggest regret as a fan and eunwoo theres not a single day moonbin will not be missed I AM SURE of that. ❤️🩹
It's so sad to hear when people talk about their close ones. You can really hear how broken hearted Eun woo is. So many people are crying and feeling guilty for their lost ones, and all we can really say is we love you and take care of yourself.
I can relate to your loss. Three years ago, I lost my oldest sone, ten days later I lost my only grandson. The hardest part of losing someone is getting back that part of you that went with them. Moonbin would want you to be strong and give it your all, so don't disappoint him. My thoughts, prayer, love and respect from my heart to your and Moonbins heart. Neve, ever give up!!
It is quite difficult to move on from grief. It will take awhile so just let the healing take its place. No rush. Cry if you need to. Be angry if you feel like it. Be sad if that’s how you’re feeling. Just express your emotions. You’re human just like everyone else. People should understand that. Just do what’s best for you. Your friend would want you to be happy too that’s for sure.
Moonbin will never be forgotten. Although I found him late he is forever in my heart. Eun Woo, Bonnie is watching over you, so make sure you take care of yourself and live a happy life. 😢🥰🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️
@@Gracy-ChanelZENGNGUEMA I appreciate your response my beloved lady, And thank you for your love care and support 🩵🌹🤍. How are you? Where are you from?, And how long have you been my fan?.
The most heartfelt, authentic thoughts of anyone who has lost someone dear and integral to their life. You are never truly ok. You do not want others to be concerned or worried. The pain is always fresh and new - no matter how long it has been. In moments like these, the heart and soul truly does not heal. You can place a bandaid over the wound, but thoughts and talking about it makes the wound fresh and new, never truly healing. My heart hurts and I literally cry when I see videos and photos of Moonbin and my heart breaks every time I see the fake smile Eunwoo puts on when he is not alone. I always keep Cha Eunwoo in my sincerest thoughts and prayers because of his loss.....just like Min-ho, Onew, Key and Taemin about Jonghyun *(SHINee). It's never easy and will never get better....but know that you are not alone
Eun woo my heart still aches for you it just hurts me a lot because just me imagining you going through all of this pain and grief makes me cry my eyes out ,i know how much it hurts and knowing your going through this pain makes me sad and cry, i hope you get better day by day i know your still healing but i want you to know that we will never forget binah and will always be in our thoughts and hearts love you always my dongmin my eun woo ❤️🩹 🌟🫶🏻✨
Like so many on here...I know of your pain. My best friend of 27 years, passed away this same time in 2022, alongwith my grandmother and cousin. The void can never be closed. But I pray that you find solace and peace in knowing him and being a brother to you in the group.
There isn't a single day that goes by without missing him. I used to watch moonbin's dramas in 2021 and eventually fell for his bright smile and warm personality. I can still remember the moment I got to know about him passing away, and never have i ever cried so hard for anyone. The fact that he wasn't there with us was hard for me to accept for a long time. I still tear up whenever his face flashes in my mind. I hope wherever he is now, he is happy. I hope he knows that he is loved and remembered by many. We love and miss you very much, moonbin, and i hope the warmth of our love always surrounds you🩵
Deepest line eunwoo said "lets meet again" actually touches my heart and i am crying actually But anyways we love you moonbin forever But the difference is just like that you shine as a star in sky not on stage❤
I just started crying I won’t ever forget moonbin 🥺 and what he meant to the world . Words will never be enough to comfort Eun Woos pain but I hope it gets easier to handle with time , never forgotten and always remembered ❤
Yes people forget but i'll never forget about him .moonbin we all miss you so so so so so so so much i wish u were here but fate decided atherwise you will always remain in our heart's
I believe he comes to you one because of his love for you and the other one o let you know he is alright and he wants you to not worry and for you to live a good life and when you get ow old and it’s time for you to leave this world you will definitely meet again much love ❤ to you
Why can't we live forever? Why do we have to be left behind? Why can't we be with the ones we love forever? No one, no one should have to experience the pain of losing someone. 💔
I´m crying. This makes me so sad. It´s not true that we forgot so quickly... Everytime I look at the moon it reminds me of Moonbin. And I´m pretty sure lots of other people feel like this too. I´m so happy that the members of Astro spend so much time together, even with Moonbin´s sister Sua. I´ve been a fan of Astro since early 2018 and even had the chance to see them at a festival in 2019, which was my very first concert. I will never ever forget a member of Astro because they are all just too precious and special to me 💜💜💜💜💜💜
Moonbin will always be in the sky watching us but sadly not everyone knows Eunwoo included. Eunwoo shouldn’t feel guilty about his death. I think in those dreams he’s trying to tell you, Eunwoo, that he’s not truly gone
I’m actually glad he didn’t stop his life like the way others wanted him to be to “mourn”. Everyone knows he is sad about it, he also supports Sua and has close ties with Moonbin’s family… it’s just that maybe like during the time with Shinee they said something about how being busy is how they cope with the loss. I thought of that way with Eunwoo too because no one should dictate how to mourn since everyone is different. I hope he works hard and continue to keep Moonbin in his heart like now. Eunwoo is very loyal and I like that about him. Btw he really looks so handsome
It's i think the part that will be hard for us kpop stans, our idols leaving us suddenly. But when i think of it they're also humans. We all humans, who will leave this world.
I remembered the first time i got to watched a group video of astro and i remembered saying that they'll be the chaotic male group i have ever known. Time really flew so fast.
We believe if we see someone in our dream they need our prayers and they want us to live for them and for us, they want us to give more like charities and ♡ around and help. Be kind and live a better life so when we meet again they’ll be happy too in Hannah idk
Awww I’m so sorry. Please know Binnie will always be watching us in the sky. It is time to move on but it’s ok to cry about it or whatever. It’s ok to still mourn for him. But if u feel this pain forever it will only get worse.
Be happy Dongmin.. Be happy ASTRO members JinJin, MJ, Cha eun woo, and Sanha.. Rest in peace Moonbin Best wishes to you Rocky Lots nd lots of love and good wishes from INDIA/BHARAT
It's been awhile like it's happen last yr and this yr the yr ganna ends again means it turning 2 yrs nxt yr April 19 but untill now bin case is still unclose its so hard and hurts for him to move on I think imagine why his special friend gone without any clue or any reason theirs a fact that might moonbin is not really commit suicide but there is something really happen reason why moon bin still coming to his dreams .... Why gone to young 😢😢😢
We need to be more aware of taking care of our mental health and not be ashamed to ask for professional help. Now should we discount these emotions and feelings as just "you're just tired."
I can never forget him ❤, tbh i didn't know him much cuz of Astro but through his n Sua's cover of my ear candy cover,my mermaid prince ,him n members funny moments especially those dirty minded ones😂 ,still find them funny cuz of him , it's just that I don't want to remember him as someone i lose but the one who's with us always ❤
The thing I've noticed about people who take their own lives is that those around them no matter how close never or rarely see it coming. Those people are very good at hiding what they're feeling until it eventually overwhelms them. I pray God comforts your heart Eunwoo until you see Moonbin again one day.
Please, tell him, that if you wanted to cry - just cry. Don't hold your feelings inside you. It's very important to show your own inner feelings. And we still remember Moonbin and Jonghyun, and Sulli, and everyone whose left a mark in our hearts.
Non mi piace il tuo commento. Giuisto ricordare quei ragazzi, ma perchè fai di ognoi erba un fascio? Bin non sai cosa gli sia successo. Gli altri ragazzi hanno detto addio prima di farlo. Basta scrivere cavolate.
I’m actually glad he didn’t stop his life like the way others wanted him to be to “mourn”. Everyone knows he is sad about it, he also supports Sua and has close ties with Moonbin’s family… it’s just that maybe like during the time with Shinee they said something about how being busy is how they cope with the loss. I thought of that way with Eunwoo too because no one should dictate how to mourn since everyone is different. I hope he works hard and continue to keep Moonbin in his heart like now. Eunwoo is very loyal and I like that about him.
I don't know Astro very well or Eunwoo, but the only kdrama I've ever watched is True beauty, which was a few months ago, it had so much more meaning to it, he didn't just lose his best friend in fiction, but in reality too.
The afterlife is just a state beyond living. Loved ones are amongst us, when we're receptive enough to help them make their presence realised. Talk to the ones you think you miss and give them enough opportunities to answer. I gave the Sholjas the Victory 'V' shape, like the international Peace sign ✌️ and they use it all the time. It is said that the "Little Mischiefs" are the spirits that are content to have their presence witnessed. They understand verbal dialogue and they are very receptive to thought and emotions. They are protective and they have a sense of humour. Engage your sense of belief, as though your best friend was feeling miserable and you were trying to cheer them up. One day, hopefully so many decades from now, you'll have eternity to share all the news of all the amazing things you did with your life and your time. Make those achievements worth describing. Eternity is longer than life. 😘✌️👄🙋♀️☯️
Not an Astro fan but I still cried a lot after hearing the news! As an army I’m also sad thinking about my idols. We don’t even know if they are hiding some pain behind their smiles. But Astro fans stay strong and pray for Moonbin.
@@bazlaumer1359 Thank you for your reply so far, I really appreciate your care and concern my best friend . What’s your name ? Where are you chatting from ?
OMG I’m sorry he left you instead of talking about it Eunwoo. As a 5u1c1de survivor, I wish he had shared his problems instead of bottling them up. But I can honestly say that when you reach that point you genuinely feel that everyone is better off without you so you don’t want to burden anyone with your problems 🖤🖤
He did not ascend into nothingness nowhere he dust in the boat week farmers field. He waits in grand soul for you on a daily basis. He says that you parallel to him in the universe. The one thing that you have that no one have of you is yourself. Your voice your story. Be true to yourself. At times, you may feel as if the universe is conspiring against you when reality is protecting you. He told me that you are the one person that he would deconstruct himself in order to put you back together again. He lays his head on the pillow next to yours nightly in place is a warm kiss on your cheek to wipe away the tears. He has known you for lifetime, but loved you even longer. He will never leave your side. Call me crazy or even delusional, but I would rather live in my delusions and daydreams to close my eyes nightmares.
I feel eunwoo pain 😢 nawalan din ako ng kapatid at sobrang sakit nun hanggang ngayon d mawawala yung bigat sa dibdib ko.. napanood ko to umiyak n nmn ako 😭😢
He didn’t commit self harm. He had an underlying health condition that caused his death. He loved everything about what he did, he had told the agency that he had health problems. If someone had been with him it still would not change the fact that he passed in his sleep. I wish people would read what the agency and family release for the fans. The agency and his family both said because of a health condition he had it caused his death if it had been a suicide do you think he would have said anything to his fans or family. All the idols in the past said goodbye and did a live for fans then left letters to their loved ones. Moon Bin did none of these things. He was going on tour that weekend and he had other projects he was working on. Please stop assuming that he took his own life and read the reports that his family and agency put out. He knew he was loved his sister Moon Sua of Billie is an idol only because her brother is an idol. Look up their music support her like you support Astro. Moon Bin is greatly missed and will always be missed by his fans. His smile was contagious.
Then what type of health condition would cause his death? Like seriously, I still don't understand or believe any of that. Like if someone was so sick, you shouldn't even be moving about recklessly. Or he would tell someone. Nah, it doesn't make sense to me. Especially how Cha eun woo and the others say it so calmly. Talking but not explaining what exactly it is. It's bound to have suspicions.
@@aprildamian he died of a stroke or something akin to it. It’s kind of like epilepsy. You can have a health condition and not show outward signs from it. Also the public doesn’t need to know everything about how a person died but the family and agency told the public. It is on you if you believe the family or not, but it is public information.
It's so hard for those left behind. Moonbin must've thought he had no other option but Eunwoo is suffering so much without him. It's so very very sad. Eunwoo shouldn't feel guilty at all. He gave him all the support he could.
He's saying this so comfortably and calmly as if it's a line in a kdrama series😂. If he's really that sad, what happened to moonbin then? Why isn't anyone saying what really happened to him. What or who killed him?
![[C.C] Key and Taeyeon think of the beautiful memory with Jonghyun #SHINEE #KEY](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vad27IQEVYo/mqdefault.jpg)
i just wish moonbin couldve seen how missed he is, and how much we all loved him.
i think moonbin knows it, he is still watching over his members, his family and the fans
Money loving companies killing these talented young artists.
He's saying this so comfortably and calmly as if it's a line in a kdrama series😂.
If he's really that sad, what happened to moonbin then? Why isn't anyone saying what really happened to him. What or who killed him?
As someone going to commit suicide soon I can’t relate people do not care and for everybody that’s is the real truth
@@aprildamian Idk what about a person clearly trying not to cry and taking careful pauses between their words seemed comfortable to you lmao? He may not even know the details, or if he does then he has no obligation to tell us thats private info anyways.
It’s good that he can speak so openly about it. I’m so sorry for his loss, it must be so hard 😭.
Hello……..👋
I appreciate you my beloved lady for your
Likes and comments on my official page,
I hope you will not stop supporting me
I’m very pleased that all of you have been
Around all this years of my career
I appreciate your support and warm
Comments
I want to say thank you very much 🙏
I appreciate you all
God bless you
How are you? And where’re you from?
He was a great big brother to Moonbin. He shouldn’t feel guilty at all!
There is no should in grief. Just existing can feel wrong when in grief. It is hard
It's hard for those who are close, nobody expected it at all. Eunwoo probably feels partially responsible as someone who is close like "What went wrong?" "Was I not reliable for you to come for help?" It wasn't his fault but as someone who witness others losing their loved ones suddenly, they can't help but feel guilty that they weren't enough help to stop them from the unimaginable. Separation is hard and it was sad that Moonbin left in such a lonely and painful way. I hope Eunwoo can move on slowly and peacefully.
@@vanillafoodieyou said it all
@@vanillafoodie non si sa niente di cosa sia successo a Bin. Non date per scontate cose che non sono sicure. Bin non avrebbe mai fatto un gesto volontario. In un video di Cjha Eunw Woo mentre canta si tocca la vena del collo e gli manda un bacio. Bin si toccava sempre la vena del collo e quando la vedi che batte forte non è un buon segno. E' il segnale che Bin era malato.
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
He has survivor's remorse. He feels guilty he could not see what the struggle was, that it ran so deep enough he could not see the hope anymore and became lost. He feels he let his friend down by not saving him. He someday needs to forgive himself. He had not been through this before, and had no idea about the signs or what to do. Now, with each celebrity dying the same way, it keeps taking him back to the tragedy, over and over again. He thinks Moonbin is forgotten because lives did not stop, but for the most part his did. Poor guy. Wish we could hug him and console him.
Life is a journey. As we walk our paths of life, other's paths will cross ours as well. Some briefly, but other's will entwine with us, and we walk together, sharing each other's thoughts, desires, and love. Sometimes, all too quickly, we are split from each other's paths. Some move on their journey to meet other's, while some end their paths all too soon. But we have to cherish the time we spent together, remember the most special moments they left us, the footprints on our hearts and in our minds. These memories will keep them alive as we continue their legacy, never forgotten, never far from our sides. Sharing their influences is what keeps their legacy alive.
He didn't take his life Moon was ill physically
@@sonnymedina7182if you look it up on how moonbin passed away it says he took his own life 😭
@nana8631 never seen such a news perhaps fake news but according to his family they expressed physical asthma with lung 🫁 infection just like when the (video) blue flame he was supposed to be the main performer instead the other astro members especially Cha eunwoo if you recall his Absence Moon wasn't there for over several months to promote the song...he was ill very ill...
Beautiful sentiments ❤
@@whatbringsmepeace🙏💙🌹🇰🇷
I believe when you see someone in a dream it's their way of saying "I'm ok" and to help those left behind to live
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
And if i See people i dont want to see? People that are still alive.
@@userbunny I appreciate your response my beloved lady, And thank you for your love care and support 🤍🩵🤍.
How are you? Where are you from? And how long have you been my fan?.
Moonbin will be remembered for a very long time. Still devastating to think he's gone, I think so much of his family and Astro members who have been so brave, kept going even if it has been so hard...
He’s gone on earth but he’s in the sky now
This will never not create an overflow in the old tear ducts. Just like how Shinee never forget........Nether will Astro forget. Or fans.
🤍🤍
As a shawol I will never forget moonbin like I do with Jonghyun. The pain of loss never goes but at least we have happy memories and we’re lucky enough to of known them. I hope Eunwoo and the rest of Astro and AROHA are doing ok. Its ok to miss him. He will never be forgotten ❤
Yeah and I wasn’t even a kpop fan when JongHyun died so I found out about his death late. I’m sure they’ve met in heaven by now
My first kpop death was YoHan from TST but because it happened during Covid I don’t consider it to be my first real one
🤍🫂
basta fare il confronto don Jonghyun. Questo ragazzo aveva lasciato una lettera di addio. Di Bin non sappiamo niente, non scrivete cose di cui non siete certi. Per rispetto di Bin che amava il suo lavoro ed aveva così tanto amore e rispetto per i suoi fan .
@ISABEL-k7h8n honestly some people will find anything to take a dig at 🙄 i never said anything against him. Im sorry you never got answers but it’s not a competition. Both were tragic circumstances. I understand your angry but please don’t take it out on people trying to be supportive and kind. Im not a Aroha but I respect Moonbin and saw how kind and talented he was. Its tragic. And I wish you the best and hope Moonbin rest in peace … the same to “that guy” Jonghyun who I miss and love.
He had to live it in true beauty, and now he’s actually living it 😢
Honestly, that feeling of thinking its unfiar if you eat or sleep after someone passes away, is one of the worst feelings ever! I've felt it too and its really hard to overcome :/
I'm so so sorry, Eunwoo. I'm so, so sorry, your heartaches. Your heartaches because you love so much. Your best friend had the honor and privilege to have you in his life. He loved you. We will always remember those who are not here, and it will hurt for a long time. Just know this, You are a beautiful, wonderful, kind human being who loved his best friend, and that's why your friend loved you so much.Think of this when you think of him... Our heart aches for you, and we wish we could take the pain away...
Yeah I wish he knew moonbin was watching him from the sky
He was so strong holding all this pain together, I could never
seeing him cry makes me cry 😭I am so sorry Moonbin, I hope you are in a better place 🙏
you will never forget the wonderful soul named Moonbin, he lives in all of our hearts forever .. his spirit lives on thru the music and our memories ..
this was rlly hard to watch... i cry just thinking about him bc it doesnt feel real and i think it never will, even more so to the ppl who were actually close to him..
that man had the ability to cheer me up everytime i saw a clip of him and im sure im not the only one who feels that way, i just wish i had enjoyed more of his presence when he was still here yk... thats my biggest regret as a fan
and eunwoo theres not a single day moonbin will not be missed I AM SURE of that. ❤️🩹
That was so heartbreaking I miss Bin also very much he is not forgotten...
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
It's so sad to hear when people talk about their close ones. You can really hear how broken hearted Eun woo is. So many people are crying and feeling guilty for their lost ones, and all we can really say is we love you and take care of yourself.
It’s been over a year yet feels like yesterday! But his legacy lives on! 🙏🏽
Thanks for your lovely like and comments on my official page, it’s great to know I have such a devoted fan.
Much love💜
I can relate to your loss. Three years ago, I lost my oldest sone, ten days later I lost my only grandson. The hardest part of losing someone is getting back that part of you that went with them. Moonbin would want you to be strong and give it your all, so don't disappoint him. My thoughts, prayer, love and respect from my heart to your and Moonbins heart. Neve, ever give up!!
Wow so sorry to hear about your losses how awful it must have been. May you and your family find peace again.
@@siskatan642 Thank you for you very kind words.
It is quite difficult to move on from grief. It will take awhile so just let the healing take its place. No rush. Cry if you need to. Be angry if you feel like it. Be sad if that’s how you’re feeling. Just express your emotions. You’re human just like everyone else. People should understand that. Just do what’s best for you. Your friend would want you to be happy too that’s for sure.
Yeah and plus he’s not really gone he’s in the sky now watching us he’s just not on earth
Moonbin will never be forgotten. Although I found him late he is forever in my heart. Eun Woo, Bonnie is watching over you, so make sure you take care of yourself and live a happy life. 😢🥰🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️
💛💚💛🇰🇷
Eunwoo ya don’t say that !! We didn’t forget him 😢❤❤❤ I think about him very deeply 😊❤
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
@ ❤️
@@Gracy-ChanelZENGNGUEMA I appreciate your response my beloved lady, And thank you for your love care and support 🩵🌹🤍.
How are you? Where are you from?, And how long have you been my fan?.
Chae eun woo 😢🥹 makes me cry so much 😭 I feel him from his words 😭🥹😭
I haven’t forgotten. I’m still praying for his soul 🙏🏻😔
Cha Eun Woo is just the nicest and kindest person!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️
The most heartfelt, authentic thoughts of anyone who has lost someone dear and integral to their life. You are never truly ok. You do not want others to be concerned or worried. The pain is always fresh and new - no matter how long it has been. In moments like these, the heart and soul truly does not heal. You can place a bandaid over the wound, but thoughts and talking about it makes the wound fresh and new, never truly healing.
My heart hurts and I literally cry when I see videos and photos of Moonbin and my heart breaks every time I see the fake smile Eunwoo puts on when he is not alone.
I always keep Cha Eunwoo in my sincerest thoughts and prayers because of his loss.....just like Min-ho, Onew, Key and Taemin about Jonghyun *(SHINee). It's never easy and will never get better....but know that you are not alone
Eun woo my heart still aches for you it just hurts me a lot because just me imagining you going through all of this pain and grief makes me cry my eyes out ,i know how much it hurts and knowing your going through this pain makes me sad and cry, i hope you get better day by day i know your still healing but i want you to know that we will never forget binah and will always be in our thoughts and hearts love you always my dongmin my eun woo ❤️🩹 🌟🫶🏻✨
Plus Bin will always be in the sky watching us
I am sure Moon Bin can hear everything you say about him. He is dearly missed. He brought so much joy to people with his beautiful smile.;)
Yeah he’s watching us from the sky I wish EunWoo knew that
So heart-breaking. 😢
I miss him so much, but I know it doesn't even come close to how much his brothers do.
Like so many on here...I know of your pain. My best friend of 27 years, passed away this same time in 2022, alongwith my grandmother and cousin. The void can never be closed. But I pray that you find solace and peace in knowing him and being a brother to you in the group.
Stay strong SuperStar and remember the good times you and Moonbin spent together. Hold onto those good memories that you will have forever🙋🤗😇🙂🙏🙏
There isn't a single day that goes by without missing him. I used to watch moonbin's dramas in 2021 and eventually fell for his bright smile and warm personality. I can still remember the moment I got to know about him passing away, and never have i ever cried so hard for anyone. The fact that he wasn't there with us was hard for me to accept for a long time. I still tear up whenever his face flashes in my mind. I hope wherever he is now, he is happy. I hope he knows that he is loved and remembered by many. We love and miss you very much, moonbin, and i hope the warmth of our love always surrounds you🩵
He’s still here with us just spiritually not physically. He’s in the sky now
@@gwenmloveskpopandmore yea. But knowing he isn't physically with us hurts, yk?
@ yeah it does hurt but we have to know he wouldnt want us to hurt
@ the majority of us have never met him irl but we all felt as if we did
@@gwenmloveskpopandmore so true
It’s hard losing someone close to you but their presence will always remain in our memories ❤
And they’ll always be watching us from the sky
Deepest line eunwoo said "lets meet again" actually touches my heart and i am crying actually
But anyways we love you moonbin forever
But the difference is just like that you shine as a star in sky not on stage❤
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
I just started crying I won’t ever forget moonbin 🥺 and what he meant to the world . Words will never be enough to comfort Eun Woos pain but I hope it gets easier to handle with time , never forgotten and always remembered ❤
Yes and plus he’s watching us from the sky I wish Eunwoo knew
Yes people forget but i'll never forget about him .moonbin we all miss you so so so so so so so much i wish u were here but fate decided atherwise you will always remain in our heart's
I love Dongmin's natural voice. He is sincere here.
I believe he comes to you one because of his love for you and the other one o let you know he is alright and he wants you to not worry and for you to live a good life and when you get ow old and it’s time for you to leave this world you will definitely meet again much love ❤ to you
Plus Binnie is in the sky watching us
Why can't we live forever? Why do we have to be left behind? Why can't we be with the ones we love forever? No one, no one should have to experience the pain of losing someone. 💔
Same reason anything happens, it just does by pure coincidence/chance. Its quite bizarre actually, but well C'est la vie I suppose. ❤
"coincidence". But yeah, I'm not trying to start an argument here. Just said what i think. @@liagamer4265
We can live forever in the sky. Binnie is alive in the sky now I wish everyone knew that 💔
So sad. They really loved each other. It doesnt come often.
I´m crying. This makes me so sad. It´s not true that we forgot so quickly... Everytime I look at the moon it reminds me of Moonbin. And I´m pretty sure lots of other people feel like this too. I´m so happy that the members of Astro spend so much time together, even with Moonbin´s sister Sua. I´ve been a fan of Astro since early 2018 and even had the chance to see them at a festival in 2019, which was my very first concert. I will never ever forget a member of Astro because they are all just too precious and special to me 💜💜💜💜💜💜
It made me tear up ...
Hope your doing well wherever you are🕊❤
Moonbin will always be in the sky watching us but sadly not everyone knows Eunwoo included. Eunwoo shouldn’t feel guilty about his death. I think in those dreams he’s trying to tell you, Eunwoo, that he’s not truly gone
RIP Moonbin🕊
I’m actually glad he didn’t stop his life like the way others wanted him to be to “mourn”. Everyone knows he is sad about it, he also supports Sua and has close ties with Moonbin’s family… it’s just that maybe like during the time with Shinee they said something about how being busy is how they cope with the loss. I thought of that way with Eunwoo too because no one should dictate how to mourn since everyone is different. I hope he works hard and continue to keep Moonbin in his heart like now. Eunwoo is very loyal and I like that about him.
Btw he really looks so handsome
I miss moonbin so much hes always goin to be a part of the group astro you are missed and loved always 💜 ⭐ i started crying when I click this
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
Omgg.. it hurts soo much for him. Please stay safe my dear. Keep your Bin close to your heart nd live happily🙏🙏🙏
Как и ожидалось, мне не удалось сдержать слёзы. Это очень грустно
Crying first thing in the morning 😢 Rest Peacefully Moon Bin 🙏🕊
It's i think the part that will be hard for us kpop stans, our idols leaving us suddenly. But when i think of it they're also humans. We all humans, who will leave this world.
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
I remembered the first time i got to watched a group video of astro and i remembered saying that they'll be the chaotic male group i have ever known. Time really flew so fast.
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
Its actually very sad may moobin soul rest in peace
We believe if we see someone in our dream they need our prayers and they want us to live for them and for us, they want us to give more like charities and ♡ around and help. Be kind and live a better life so when we meet again they’ll be happy too in Hannah idk
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
I cried through this whole video. Still not over it and can’t get through paper cuts without crying also because I think of Binnie
Awww I’m so sorry. Please know Binnie will always be watching us in the sky. It is time to move on but it’s ok to cry about it or whatever. It’s ok to still mourn for him. But if u feel this pain forever it will only get worse.
Be happy Dongmin.. Be happy ASTRO members JinJin, MJ, Cha eun woo, and Sanha..
Rest in peace Moonbin
Best wishes to you Rocky
Lots nd lots of love and good wishes from INDIA/BHARAT
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
It's been awhile like it's happen last yr and this yr the yr ganna ends again means it turning 2 yrs nxt yr April 19 but untill now bin case is still unclose its so hard and hurts for him to move on I think imagine why his special friend gone without any clue or any reason theirs a fact that might moonbin is not really commit suicide but there is something really happen reason why moon bin still coming to his dreams .... Why gone to young 😢😢😢
Yeah and plus Binnie is watching him from the sky I wish He knew
We need to be more aware of taking care of our mental health and not be ashamed to ask for professional help. Now should we discount these emotions and feelings as just "you're just tired."
I can never forget him ❤, tbh i didn't know him much cuz of Astro but through his n Sua's cover of my ear candy cover,my mermaid prince ,him n members funny moments especially those dirty minded ones😂 ,still find them funny cuz of him , it's just that I don't want to remember him as someone i lose but the one who's with us always ❤
The thing I've noticed about people who take their own lives is that those around them no matter how close never or rarely see it coming. Those people are very good at hiding what they're feeling until it eventually overwhelms them. I pray God comforts your heart Eunwoo until you see Moonbin again one day.
Ma chi ve lo ha detto che si è suicidato? Ma fattela finita di scrivere stronzate se non avete la certezza di quello che scrivete.
He is missed and he is always in my heart❤
🙏💙🌹🇰🇷
Te queremos hermoso y lindo de alma habrán más aidol que bailen más pero no todo tienen una alma pura y sana como tú cuídate ❤❤❤
my heart breaks for all the people who loved him
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
Please, tell him, that if you wanted to cry - just cry. Don't hold your feelings inside you. It's very important to show your own inner feelings.
And we still remember Moonbin and Jonghyun, and Sulli, and everyone whose left a mark in our hearts.
Yes and I wish everyone knew they’re watching us from the sky
@@gwenmloveskpopandmore💜🌹💜🇰🇷
Non mi piace il tuo commento. Giuisto ricordare quei ragazzi, ma perchè fai di ognoi erba un fascio? Bin non sai cosa gli sia successo. Gli altri ragazzi hanno detto addio prima di farlo. Basta scrivere cavolate.
@@ISABEL-k7h8n 💜🌹💜🇰🇷
I’m actually glad he didn’t stop his life like the way others wanted him to be to “mourn”. Everyone knows he is sad about it, he also supports Sua and has close ties with Moonbin’s family… it’s just that maybe like during the time with Shinee they said something about how being busy is how they cope with the loss. I thought of that way with Eunwoo too because no one should dictate how to mourn since everyone is different. I hope he works hard and continue to keep Moonbin in his heart like now. Eunwoo is very loyal and I like that about him.
Yes and I hope they know Binnie is watching them from the sky
Wow wow moments 😒😔😥😢💞💕💕💞💕💞💕💞💕💞💕💞💕💞
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
heartbreaking!!!!.... poor kids 💔
I don't know Astro very well or Eunwoo, but the only kdrama I've ever watched is True beauty, which was a few months ago, it had so much more meaning to it, he didn't just lose his best friend in fiction, but in reality too.
You should check them out they’re amazing
im just glad that he is openly talking about it.
didn't realize how TOXIC kpop can be until he left.
The afterlife is just a state beyond living. Loved ones are amongst us, when we're receptive enough to help them make their presence realised. Talk to the ones you think you miss and give them enough opportunities to answer.
I gave the Sholjas the Victory 'V' shape, like the international Peace sign ✌️ and they use it all the time. It is said that the "Little Mischiefs" are the spirits that are content to have their presence witnessed. They understand verbal dialogue and they are very receptive to thought and emotions. They are protective and they have a sense of humour. Engage your sense of belief, as though your best friend was feeling miserable and you were trying to cheer them up. One day, hopefully so many decades from now, you'll have eternity to share all the news of all the amazing things you did with your life and your time. Make those achievements worth describing. Eternity is longer than life. 😘✌️👄🙋♀️☯️
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
Not an Astro fan but I still cried a lot after hearing the news! As an army I’m also sad thinking about my idols. We don’t even know if they are hiding some pain behind their smiles. But Astro fans stay strong and pray for Moonbin.
Yeah Binnie is in the sky now. His health became worse which is one of the reasons he died
thank you share English subtitle and okay I'm know chaeunwoo he cry sing a song where I am he is deeply feeling tthus song 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 RIP moonbin
Thanks for your lovely like and comments on my official page, it’s great to know I have such a devoted fan.
Much love💜
@Chaeunwoo998 😉😉😉😉😉
@@bazlaumer1359 Thank you for your reply so far, I really appreciate your care and concern my best friend .
What’s your name ?
Where are you chatting from ?
OMG I’m sorry he left you instead of talking about it Eunwoo. As a 5u1c1de survivor, I wish he had shared his problems instead of bottling them up. But I can honestly say that when you reach that point you genuinely feel that everyone is better off without you so you don’t want to burden anyone with your problems 🖤🖤
I’m so proud of you for saving urself
He did not ascend into nothingness nowhere he dust in the boat week farmers field. He waits in grand soul for you on a daily basis. He says that you parallel to him in the universe. The one thing that you have that no one have of you is yourself. Your voice your story. Be true to yourself. At times, you may feel as if the universe is conspiring against you when reality is protecting you. He told me that you are the one person that he would deconstruct himself in order to put you back together again. He lays his head on the pillow next to yours nightly in place is a warm kiss on your cheek to wipe away the tears. He has known you for lifetime, but loved you even longer. He will never leave your side. Call me crazy or even delusional, but I would rather live in my delusions and daydreams to close my eyes nightmares.
Super ❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉 lowe ❤🔥❤❤❤️☀️ lowe cha 💓 eun 💓 wo lowe 💓💓🌹💓🌈🔥🌈🔥🌈🔥🌈 that's Perfect 🌈🌈🔥🔥🔥🌟🌟🌟💞 that's Perfect cha 💓 eun 💓 wo lowe 💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓
I still cant believe it.
I feel eunwoo pain 😢 nawalan din ako ng kapatid at sobrang sakit nun hanggang ngayon d mawawala yung bigat sa dibdib ko.. napanood ko to umiyak n nmn ako 😭😢
He didn’t commit self harm. He had an underlying health condition that caused his death. He loved everything about what he did, he had told the agency that he had health problems. If someone had been with him it still would not change the fact that he passed in his sleep. I wish people would read what the agency and family release for the fans. The agency and his family both said because of a health condition he had it caused his death if it had been a suicide do you think he would have said anything to his fans or family. All the idols in the past said goodbye and did a live for fans then left letters to their loved ones. Moon Bin did none of these things. He was going on tour that weekend and he had other projects he was working on. Please stop assuming that he took his own life and read the reports that his family and agency put out. He knew he was loved his sister Moon Sua of Billie is an idol only because her brother is an idol. Look up their music support her like you support Astro. Moon Bin is greatly missed and will always be missed by his fans. His smile was contagious.
Then what type of health condition would cause his death? Like seriously, I still don't understand or believe any of that. Like if someone was so sick, you shouldn't even be moving about recklessly. Or he would tell someone.
Nah, it doesn't make sense to me. Especially how Cha eun woo and the others say it so calmly. Talking but not explaining what exactly it is. It's bound to have suspicions.
@@aprildamian he died of a stroke or something akin to it. It’s kind of like epilepsy. You can have a health condition and not show outward signs from it. Also the public doesn’t need to know everything about how a person died but the family and agency told the public. It is on you if you believe the family or not, but it is public information.
Correct he didn’t his health worsened
😢🥺 , RIP our mounbin
This makes me so sad 😭
My eyes 😭
😔 témoignage bouleversant 🙏🙏
My throat hurts so much watching this 😢
I know it hurts but we have to be strong too. Binnie will always be in the sky watching us
this marks as the first time the member talks about him in a show ever since his passing right? :(
🤍🇰🇷🤍🇰🇷🤍
We didn't move on or forget quickly we didn't want to bother.
I moved on but at the same I didn’t. Moonbin will always be in the sky watching us but sadly not everyone knows
ຜູ້ເຂົ້າຜູ້ເຂົ້າຊົມທັງໝົດສຳລັບລາວແລະຫວຽດນາມຈະໄດ້😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
😥😥😥😥❤
It's so hard for those left behind. Moonbin must've thought he had no other option but Eunwoo is suffering so much without him. It's so very very sad. Eunwoo shouldn't feel guilty at all. He gave him all the support he could.
Yeah plus Moonbin will always be in the sky watching us but sadly not everyone knows Eunwoo included
🫂
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
😭😭
💔
They do not have right way to talk about
Or feel
What?
He's saying this so comfortably and calmly as if it's a line in a kdrama series😂.
If he's really that sad, what happened to moonbin then? Why isn't anyone saying what really happened to him. What or who killed him?
It is said that he had some health issues
Don't you think it's rude to use a "😂" emoji on a post about a passed person? At least learn to be a little civilized online fuckupp
🤍
😭😭😭