I don't comment usually but when I saw that the channel is relatively new, I knew this man behind the mic needs appreciation. Excellent research and unbiased piece. Keep it up whoever u are mate
I agree. Unless his performance improves, I doubt the Pakistan Cricket Board or the people of Pakistan will have the patience to allow him to continue as captain.
Yes, it’s up to him to prove his mettle with the bat and averaging about 30 in the last two series he has played isn’t going to be enough for a number 3 especially with talented players like Kamran Ghulam waiting in the wings.
@@TheCricketTapes what about Zak Crawley ( opener ) his average is 30 and Mitchell Marsh average is about 32 . But Crawley , Marsh , Shan strike rate is more than 70 . Iss mentality se nikal aao . Ravichandran ashwin ki tarha Shan ko support karo
Depends on the teams requirements. Marsh usually comes in at number 6, where he counter attacks and so his average makes more sense. Crawley is often under pressure for his position but he pulls off a big innings every now and then to release that such as the 189 in the Ashes last year. That’s exactly the kind of performance Shan needs to release the pressure. And SR is fine but you have to play according to the situation as well. With Abdullah Shafique out of form, and Pak not getting of to good starts, Shan can also find himself needing to bat longer coming in at 3 so the team doesn’t find themselves 2 down quickly.
@@TheCricketTapes I think kamran Ghulam should play in place of babar azam, no doubt he's one of our greatest batsman but he's going through a bad patch currently and is a liability to the Pakistan team and players like tayyab tahir and kamran ghulam should be given a chance in place of babar, meanwhile babar should train with the international coaches and improve his mistakes because he's a big asset to us.
Mansoor Masood khan was CEO of United Bank Limited UK . They shifted to kuwait for his father job then they again went back to karachi then his father , himself and his brother went UK for studies then again comeback Pakistan and played under 16. He is good player .
Fantastic video! Your research is truly exceptional. It's rare to see such an in-depth and unbiased analysis on Pakistani cricket, especially one backed by verifiable facts. Most channels don't dive this deep, but your effort stands out, providing us with an insightful perspective. Keep up the great work!
Great Analysis and great video overall! Really enjoyed it. The voiceover, the editing, the analysis depth, everything was perfect. You deserve much more support! Also, I believe he showed some promising signs of captaincy in the Australia tour. We as a nation and as a board need to give him some more time. But completely agree, he needs to be more consistent or have a defining innings 💯
The biggest problem with Shan Masood is his form…when it comes to Pakistan his form deserts him….finds so many soft way to get out…he looks ok for 15-20 runs and gets out …usually caught at slip with no feet movement….how difficult is this to resolve….having played cricket for 40 years batting at 3 i found you are always looking to correct weaknesses and develop strokes …it is always evolving…..not difficult ….WHY CANT HE RESILVE THIS WEAKNESS……UNTIL THIS IS RESOLVED YOU CANT LEAD A TEAM LIKE PAKISTAN …PITY AS I THINK HE HAS OTHER ATTRIBUTES
It's a misguided comparison to judge someone's competence in cricket based on their language skills. For example, instead of focusing on Inzamam's language abilities, one should consider his impressive stats. He was an outstanding player and later an excellent captain with a strong record. The focus should be on mindset and performance, not language proficiency. Shan may be an average player who could turn out to be a good captain, even with moderate stats, but comparing him to Inzi solely on the basis of language is unfair.
it's not the ability to speak english that is the issue, the issue is having at least somewhat educated people who can at least show professionalism even if they don't speak english
Bro I just started noticing you and I must say the content you have been producing is absolutely incredible and keeps the viewer engaged in what he or she is watching keep it up
Great video. I often say that sentence that a great player doesn't mean a great captain and a great captain doesn't mean a great player. I am happy to hear that from u. And yeah Shan will take this team to top with his captaincy. But he have to improve his batting a little
Great content, he is mentally strong, but technically pretty average. He needs to consult some big names and put more time and efforts to his batting. Bangladesh series was a great chance to improve his average and records, but he struggled a lot. There are many batsmen, who were not gifted but improved after coming in the team. Shan can do that.
Shan is 35 so time is not on his side but there are players who have beaten greater odds. A great example of a player who overcame his deficiencies is Australia’s Chris Roger’s. He came into the team at 36 and had physical disabilities that included being colour blind and short sighted. But in the 2 years he played he would hit 5 centuries and retire with an average of 42 with some iconic performances including in the Ashes. At this point Shan can only help himself and as you mentioned the Bangladesh tour was the perfect opportunity. It doesn’t get any easier from here.
Horror home season? Where we lost 4 tests against top sides like Aus and Eng. But apparently whitewash by Ban is lesser horror for you. Atleast babar won 10 test before losing 4 tests, Shan isn't even able to win against lower test teams
@honestreiewer2041 losing to Bangladesh is terrible but not winning a single test match out of 8 matches at home against teams which haven't toured Pak in 20 years is worse. At least Bangladesh have toured in 2020 and it's shan's first series at home only he can still be given one more series before getting sacked.
@@amaanzuberi6534 He won 2 tests against SA at home and we literally played with 5 debutants without any experienced bowler vs Eng and yet we lost close matches, don't think a captain can do any better than that when 4 debut bowlers are playing against a quality batting line up. It doesn't matter weather Ban has toured or not, Babar whitewashed them in ban where Aus/Nz/Eng couldn't whitewash them. Shan's captaincy is just overhyped, man couldn't win anything with Karachi kings, Yorkshire ranked 7 out of 8 in the county, yet to win a single match for Pakistan, career avg of 28. I don't what has shan done to get this reputation, Good English maybe
@honestreiewer2041 he shouldn't have been appointed captain in the first place but now that he has give him a proper run like babar was given otherwise it'll create more issues with revolving door of captains causing more uncertainty and dressing room disharmony. Also Yorkshire finished 2nd this season and pak came closer to win tests in aus last year than they have in a very long time.
@@amaanzuberi6534 Shan isn't Captaining Yorkshire this season, since he is busy with Pakistan team, I'm talking about last year, you're free to go check their standing. How were we close to winning? We lost one test by 360 runs, 1 by 8 wickets and 1 by 80 runs, none of them seems to be " close to winning" to me. Just because we had them at 16-4 doesn't means we were close to winning it, that's literally shameful that as a captain he bottled from that situation. Forget about that, we let ban won one sided from 26-6, imagine thinking this guy is a good captain. He's pathetic and sifarshi products can never be successful, no matter how much media overhypes your reputation, on field you need skills, which money can't buy you. Nothing is more shameful than losing to Ban one-sided, ban is literally the worst side in test cricket (If Shan led Pakistan hasn't replaced them yet)
Itni opportunities kisi ko nhi milti it’s unfair for domestic performers like Kamran Ghulam M Huraira Omair Yousuf Sahibzada Farhan what is their fault
Yes even though each time Shan has been dropped he has gone back and performed in domestic. But he has been unable to translate that in to international success. He needs to perform in the upcoming England series to justify his position in the team. KG and co are knocking on the door otherwise
Dude, your presentation and your analysis is top notch. I would love to hear your analysis on the over dependence of cricket on India or cricket becoming/has become a South Asian game.
It's not about Shan or Babar it is about the head of PCB being appointed by a politician who became pm of Pakistan.PCB is private organization head of PCB should never be appointed by Any Politician.When this is fixed your circket will be fixed
its not just a problem of having a captain in shaan, the entire team is faulty. you can't rely on babar to score a century every inning. other players need to step up and score those big hundreds and get those fifers.
Babar is unnecessarily criticized for Pakistan's usual tournament performances, we were never good in tournaments anyways, that's why we only won 3 trophies
Check out our video on the Babar Era. More than anything else we identify not developing a world class spinner as the biggest failure during his reign.
@@TheCricketTapes would've blamed Babar if he was the spin bowling coach of our team. Never knew a captain can make someone a world class spinner when the whole domestic circuit couldn't provide one.
Dude, don't remind me of 2022. Absolute horror. But bet you, babar will become captain again by 2026 and 2027 world cups. By that time, he will be more mature.
@@AntonAkhtar 2022 was a good year, the only shame was that whitewashed by England but that was a very inexperienced team and with a bowling attack of all debutants, it was inevitable However it was a good year for Babar and team, 2023 post Asia cup to 2024 Wt20 was actually the horror show
Why is this guy even a captain? Is he rich or what lol his performance is bad, i watched the bangladesh series, i almost cried. I'm not even pakistani. I grew up watching captains like inzy and misbah, thi guy is useless both as a player and a captain.
Why don’t you tubers make these kind of videos on Babar Azam? I feel Babar is highly overrated and a below average captain! Just look at his stats in last 3 years’ captaincy has affected his batting big time
@@balajzafarr pak was actually #1 in tests, do you even remember? I hate this joker, one performance means nothing to me. Again, again and effing again, let masood do it, then I'll probably be impressed.
Problem is Shan is good ….but needs to lead from the front and don’t fall to soft dismissals….sadly England will be tough for him…..but he is far better rep than anybody else ….others are so uneducated not worthy of leadership….Sarfaz …when he was captain….he was unshaven, rough looking and could not communicate ……in any language ……always yawning did not look a leader.
Dude, he won an icc trophy. What has education got to do with cricket, miandad was a better captain than imran, it's the knowledge of sport and street smarts that matters.
Without miandad, pak would've never won the 92 world cup. Educated imran took all the spotlight, same way without afridi pak would've never won the 09 t20 wc. Educated younis khan took all the credit. You don't need even school education to shine in cricket, great leaders in cricket mostly never went to college.
I don't comment usually but when I saw that the channel is relatively new, I knew this man behind the mic needs appreciation. Excellent research and unbiased piece. Keep it up whoever u are mate
Thank you for taking time off to write that. Appreciate it 🙌🏼
I thought it was a documentary from a big channel. The voice, editing everything is spot on.
I agree. Unless his performance improves, I doubt the Pakistan Cricket Board or the people of Pakistan will have the patience to allow him to continue as captain.
Yes, it’s up to him to prove his mettle with the bat and averaging about 30 in the last two series he has played isn’t going to be enough for a number 3 especially with talented players like Kamran Ghulam waiting in the wings.
@@TheCricketTapes what about Zak Crawley ( opener ) his average is 30 and Mitchell Marsh average is about 32 . But Crawley , Marsh , Shan strike rate is more than 70 . Iss mentality se nikal aao . Ravichandran ashwin ki tarha Shan ko support karo
Depends on the teams requirements. Marsh usually comes in at number 6, where he counter attacks and so his average makes more sense. Crawley is often under pressure for his position but he pulls off a big innings every now and then to release that such as the 189 in the Ashes last year. That’s exactly the kind of performance Shan needs to release the pressure. And SR is fine but you have to play according to the situation as well. With Abdullah Shafique out of form, and Pak not getting of to good starts, Shan can also find himself needing to bat longer coming in at 3 so the team doesn’t find themselves 2 down quickly.
@@TheCricketTapes I think kamran Ghulam should play in place of babar azam, no doubt he's one of our greatest batsman but he's going through a bad patch currently and is a liability to the Pakistan team and players like tayyab tahir and kamran ghulam should be given a chance in place of babar, meanwhile babar should train with the international coaches and improve his mistakes because he's a big asset to us.
Rizwan should be made the next all 3 format Captain
All he needs a good spinner and self improvement in batting, He's best Captain right now for Pakistan ❤
I think board and people of Pakistan should give him some time . Big nations give time to their players . I hope shan masood shines in test cricket
Mansoor Masood khan was CEO of United Bank Limited UK . They shifted to kuwait for his father job then they again went back to karachi then his father , himself and his brother went UK for studies then again comeback Pakistan and played under 16. He is good player .
The upcoming series is crucial for him, we hope he performs 🤞
Shan is the best example of "andhun m kana raja" we don't have any other sensible captain available.
Fantastic video! Your research is truly exceptional. It's rare to see such an in-depth and unbiased analysis on Pakistani cricket, especially one backed by verifiable facts. Most channels don't dive this deep, but your effort stands out, providing us with an insightful perspective. Keep up the great work!
Great Analysis and great video overall! Really enjoyed it.
The voiceover, the editing, the analysis depth, everything was perfect. You deserve much more support!
Also, I believe he showed some promising signs of captaincy in the Australia tour. We as a nation and as a board need to give him some more time. But completely agree, he needs to be more consistent or have a defining innings 💯
Thank you, really appreciate it 🙌🏼 and yes the BD matches were the perfect opportunity for that statement knock but all eyes on England now
The biggest problem with Shan Masood is his form…when it comes to Pakistan his form deserts him….finds so many soft way to get out…he looks ok for 15-20 runs and gets out …usually caught at slip with no feet movement….how difficult is this to resolve….having played cricket for 40 years batting at 3 i found you are always looking to correct weaknesses and develop strokes …it is always evolving…..not difficult ….WHY CANT HE RESILVE THIS WEAKNESS……UNTIL THIS IS RESOLVED YOU CANT LEAD A TEAM LIKE PAKISTAN …PITY AS I THINK HE HAS OTHER ATTRIBUTES
It's a misguided comparison to judge someone's competence in cricket based on their language skills. For example, instead of focusing on Inzamam's language abilities, one should consider his impressive stats. He was an outstanding player and later an excellent captain with a strong record. The focus should be on mindset and performance, not language proficiency. Shan may be an average player who could turn out to be a good captain, even with moderate stats, but comparing him to Inzi solely on the basis of language is unfair.
it's not the ability to speak english that is the issue, the issue is having at least somewhat educated people who can at least show professionalism even if they don't speak english
Content creation and editing is exceptional
Bro I just started noticing you and I must say the content you have been producing is absolutely incredible and keeps the viewer engaged in what he or she is watching keep it up
Great video.
I often say that sentence that a great player doesn't mean a great captain and a great captain doesn't mean a great player. I am happy to hear that from u.
And yeah Shan will take this team to top with his captaincy.
But he have to improve his batting a little
Finally someone with factss
Our motto is facts over feelings. Stay tuned for more 🙌🏼
Great Analysis Loved it
Great content, he is mentally strong, but technically pretty average.
He needs to consult some big names and put more time and efforts to his batting. Bangladesh series was a great chance to improve his average and records, but he struggled a lot.
There are many batsmen, who were not gifted but improved after coming in the team. Shan can do that.
Shan is 35 so time is not on his side but there are players who have beaten greater odds. A great example of a player who overcame his deficiencies is Australia’s Chris Roger’s. He came into the team at 36 and had physical disabilities that included being colour blind and short sighted. But in the 2 years he played he would hit 5 centuries and retire with an average of 42 with some iconic performances including in the Ashes.
At this point Shan can only help himself and as you mentioned the Bangladesh tour was the perfect opportunity. It doesn’t get any easier from here.
If Babar can stay on as test captain after the horror home season in 2022 then Shan can be given a few more series
Horror home season? Where we lost 4 tests against top sides like Aus and Eng. But apparently whitewash by Ban is lesser horror for you. Atleast babar won 10 test before losing 4 tests, Shan isn't even able to win against lower test teams
@honestreiewer2041 losing to Bangladesh is terrible but not winning a single test match out of 8 matches at home against teams which haven't toured Pak in 20 years is worse.
At least Bangladesh have toured in 2020 and it's shan's first series at home only he can still be given one more series before getting sacked.
@@amaanzuberi6534 He won 2 tests against SA at home and we literally played with 5 debutants without any experienced bowler vs Eng and yet we lost close matches, don't think a captain can do any better than that when 4 debut bowlers are playing against a quality batting line up. It doesn't matter weather Ban has toured or not, Babar whitewashed them in ban where Aus/Nz/Eng couldn't whitewash them. Shan's captaincy is just overhyped, man couldn't win anything with Karachi kings, Yorkshire ranked 7 out of 8 in the county, yet to win a single match for Pakistan, career avg of 28. I don't what has shan done to get this reputation, Good English maybe
@honestreiewer2041 he shouldn't have been appointed captain in the first place but now that he has give him a proper run like babar was given otherwise it'll create more issues with revolving door of captains causing more uncertainty and dressing room disharmony.
Also Yorkshire finished 2nd this season and pak came closer to win tests in aus last year than they have in a very long time.
@@amaanzuberi6534 Shan isn't Captaining Yorkshire this season, since he is busy with Pakistan team, I'm talking about last year, you're free to go check their standing. How were we close to winning? We lost one test by 360 runs, 1 by 8 wickets and 1 by 80 runs, none of them seems to be " close to winning" to me. Just because we had them at 16-4 doesn't means we were close to winning it, that's literally shameful that as a captain he bottled from that situation. Forget about that, we let ban won one sided from 26-6, imagine thinking this guy is a good captain. He's pathetic and sifarshi products can never be successful, no matter how much media overhypes your reputation, on field you need skills, which money can't buy you.
Nothing is more shameful than losing to Ban one-sided, ban is literally the worst side in test cricket (If Shan led Pakistan hasn't replaced them yet)
Itni opportunities kisi ko nhi milti it’s unfair for domestic performers like Kamran Ghulam M Huraira Omair Yousuf Sahibzada Farhan what is their fault
Yes even though each time Shan has been dropped he has gone back and performed in domestic. But he has been unable to translate that in to international success. He needs to perform in the upcoming England series to justify his position in the team. KG and co are knocking on the door otherwise
Excellent analysis. Very well spoken, high quality
W Video keep up the good work.
Great to see this kind of cricket content 👏 Keep Going
How are you planning to avoid copyright claims? and keeping the video monetized?
Dude, your presentation and your analysis is top notch. I would love to hear your analysis on the over dependence of cricket on India or cricket becoming/has become a South Asian game.
Thank you 🤝 we follow Indian cricket very closely and we would love to share our thoughts on that topic
Excellent analysis! 👌🏽😊
He's a good player with good technique and mindset. Just need to cross that finish line in the international matches
Can we please get a video on Rizwan. Its needed
10 Years only he played 63 internationals for PCB . Even if talent some time nepotism kills
Think he spent his childhood first in Kuwait, and then moved to California after the Gulf War, where he did most of his schooling.
Brother you should do more of these ❤
Coming soon 🙌🏼
aapki awaz shan masood jaisi hai. lag raha hai shan nay apnay par hi video bana li
Blkl alg awz h bhaiii
Superb content👍
Let him choose his own team for rest 3 -4 series without interrupting in between.
he will come back stronger inshallah
dont troll wasay iffi, they are only ones in Pakistan telling truth about this team for last 3 years
He literally avgs 28 in test idk how the hell is he in team
Babar is just likr ordinary ranji trophy player .. people like ramiz raja made him so big by words . He is just an ordinary lad.
He already have 32 century in International cricket and he is just 29. what are you talking about?
It's not about Shan or Babar it is about the head of PCB being appointed by a politician who became pm of Pakistan.PCB is private organization head of PCB should never be appointed by Any Politician.When this is fixed your circket will be fixed
We will definitely be exploring this issue soon!
Shan's challenge though is to keep his face down and walk back when he is given out.😅😅
bro up for a collab ur editing is masterpeice hope we work together ca help you with content ideas and other thing love to talk about it
its not just a problem of having a captain in shaan, the entire team is faulty. you can't rely on babar to score a century every inning. other players need to step up and score those big hundreds and get those fifers.
Agreed, our top three have one century between them in two years
Just a little advice rename dp to cons and cons
give some time to him .... but he should improve his batting & consistency
Where has this man come from 😂
Babar is unnecessarily criticized for Pakistan's usual tournament performances, we were never good in tournaments anyways, that's why we only won 3 trophies
Check out our video on the Babar Era. More than anything else we identify not developing a world class spinner as the biggest failure during his reign.
@@TheCricketTapes would've blamed Babar if he was the spin bowling coach of our team. Never knew a captain can make someone a world class spinner when the whole domestic circuit couldn't provide one.
Dude, don't remind me of 2022. Absolute horror. But bet you, babar will become captain again by 2026 and 2027 world cups. By that time, he will be more mature.
@@AntonAkhtar 2022 was a good year, the only shame was that whitewashed by England but that was a very inexperienced team and with a bowling attack of all debutants, it was inevitable
However it was a good year for Babar and team, 2023 post Asia cup to 2024 Wt20 was actually the horror show
Amazing work bro .. subscribed ✅
Thank you, we have lots more coming soon 🙌🏼 if there’s a particular topic you want covered, let us know 🤝
This video aged like milk
He needed a statement innings and he delivered! We are happy for him 🙌🏼
Shan can be a non playing captain... specialize at no.6 !! Kl Rahul has also m9ved there ...
Your thoughts on THE MAN SUPER RIZ❤
Coming soon 🙌🏼
@@TheCricketTapes insha Allah❤
Why is this guy even a captain? Is he rich or what lol his performance is bad, i watched the bangladesh series, i almost cried. I'm not even pakistani. I grew up watching captains like inzy and misbah, thi guy is useless both as a player and a captain.
Why don’t you tubers make these kind of videos on Babar Azam? I feel Babar is highly overrated and a below average captain! Just look at his stats in last 3 years’ captaincy has affected his batting big time
Check out our video on the Babar Azam Era for an honest analysis of his captaincy and batting
USE URDU/hindi LANGUAGE BECAUSE THERE IS VERY FEW english audiance
Munday ki awaz bari a one hai
He needs to score tons
Let him first score atleast two fifties per series.
@@AntonAkhtar scored 151
@@balajzafarr dude, I grew up watching misbah. Be honest, is he at that level?
@@balajzafarr pak was actually #1 in tests, do you even remember? I hate this joker, one performance means nothing to me. Again, again and effing again, let masood do it, then I'll probably be impressed.
Problem is Shan is good ….but needs to lead from the front and don’t fall to soft dismissals….sadly England will be tough for him…..but he is far better rep than anybody else ….others are so uneducated not worthy of leadership….Sarfaz …when he was captain….he was unshaven, rough looking and could not communicate ……in any language ……always yawning did not look a leader.
Dude, he won an icc trophy. What has education got to do with cricket, miandad was a better captain than imran, it's the knowledge of sport and street smarts that matters.
Without miandad, pak would've never won the 92 world cup. Educated imran took all the spotlight, same way without afridi pak would've never won the 09 t20 wc. Educated younis khan took all the credit. You don't need even school education to shine in cricket, great leaders in cricket mostly never went to college.
Honestly he is a mediocre batsman nothing special about him