Everyone misses the “probably” bit. We “probably” made the best paints in the world. If you dig into our release content you can understand why we say that and how we measured that in the development. Thanks for the review of the new range. We hope that hobbyists get to try them and love them as much as we do. ❤
I also remember an entire video segment addressing the tension between "best paint in the world," and affordable prices. The idea was clearly: "our best possible paint without abandoning affordable prices."
I applaud you all on your business decision. You took an honest look at the current state of your product, came to the conclusion that it was substandard, scrapped it and drastically improved it. I purchased my Fanatic Complete set and am eagerly awaiting its delivery.
Not sure if you watched any of the promo videos before launch where Army Painter got pro painters to try out the Fanatic line. In the videos, the painters praised how much better they are and just repeatedly trashing how bad their old paints were, and Army Painter just sat there taking it. They know how bad their old paints were. I give Army Painter props for leaving in the trashing of their old paints. I think the biggest pro of this is that Army Painter is one of the most available paint lines out there and also often the lowest cost. This means a lot of new people to the hobby buy them. With the old paints, it probably turned a lot of people off the painting hobby because of how bad the paint jobs would come out and how hard to use they were. Having this new line is important to for that reason.
Exactly! And the fact they were brave enough to go see those painters shows what it means to them as a company. I love what they have done and enjoy the shit out of the new paints. Plus, it's easier to get a hold of than any other brand.
@@OldManRogersYou get more paint per pot for a lower price than Citadel paints (which is probably the most used brand out there) - and fanatic paints being usually thicker also means that you can (and possibly should) dilute the paint you have a bit more thus having even more mL worth of "paint" to actually paint with.
One thing that I respect about Army Painter is that they are good at taking and learning from criticism. They aren't the greatest hobby producer in the world, but they are solid and continually improving.
Could be their statement about being (probably) the best paints in the world, is just a fun jab at Carlsberg, that claims to be the best beer in the world (probably)? Both companies are from Denmark afterall :)
Im glad i can consider Army Painter as a viable brand of paint again, they are some of the most easilly accesible here in Scandinavia, but their old range was just a nope. Happy they've stepped up.
Same. I've been sticking to Citadel as they're easiest to get a hold of a wide range, and are used in a lot of tutorials. But this really opens my available options.
Hey Zumi, I just purchased an Army Painter mega set. I used to just buy my paints by color as needed, but I was recently in a motorcycle accident and shattered my leg, so I’m not very mobile right now. I needed a good set that wasn’t too many paints, but still had a good span of colors, which is why I went with this set. I was concerned though, about previous AP reviews. Even though you didn’t think AP is the ‘best in the world’, your review at least gave me confidence that I made a good purchase. Thank you! 🙂
When someone gives a bad review of a product, as a company when you make a revision, that person should be on the priority of people to send to. Because if that person gives a good review of the new thing, then you know you have a winner.
As a starter (and a bit colourblind) hobbyist, right now I'm more interested in their triad system rather than any other feature. If other brands implemented a clear system and maybe a consistent naming convention, well, that would be very interesting! Great video, as always!
As a non-colourblind painter I agree, because what the hell AK "grey blue" and "blue grey", I use one of these and I don't even remember which one it is
There are reviews of this set everywhere and they always say they got a complementary set from Army Painter. I appreciate you spending the money so could make an unbiased review of these. Well done!
The triad is genius. I'm a new painter and having a gradient of paints ready for me to learn and work through removes a whole lot of anxiety for me. I don't know why more companies don't do it.
I rode the hype train for the entire marketing campaign lol. I know you are pretty biased against them so I was really looking forward to seeing your review of the new line! The fact that you used to have them as "dog****" and now consider them around C to B tier. Thats a huge leap from a tough critic, and they can consider it a win lol. "Best" is better pronounced as "boast" and its not opinion or fact so much as advertising lol Solid review! very fair and thorough. I think my biggest takeaway wasn't about the quality of their product so much as the quality of their effort to elevate their product.
The triad system is relative to itself. That’s why underneath the graphic there is what triad it belongs to. I guess i don’t understand what the heck you’re talking about.
I see that you are fan of the Spanish acrylics. I also use Vallejo a lot. I still need to try more of AK, but I love their rust/verdigras/moss effect emanels.
New to the hobby (although I will be a historical vice fantasy/sci-f war gamer). I have been looking all over for paint comparisons but of course 95% of such content is fantasy focused. However, reviews of paint regardless of miniature is very helpful. I ran across your video and found something you said interesting. Folks from the UK and into Warhammer would naturally gravitate towards Citadel. The bit you mentioned about Warlord was a light bulb moment. In that historical space they chose Army Painter. So my question is if you were in my shoes as a newcomer who will focus mostly on 18-19 th century historical miniature painting, who would you go with. I am from the U.S. so no bias or history with any company at all. It seems on the surface that Vallejo model color is well suited to historical but then again I like the base/layer/highlight ease with Citadel.. again as a beginner. I very much welcome suggestions. Thanks!!
For 20 plus years I have been using Games Workshop paints mainly Citadel and loved them. However, I brought the new fanatic paints as I heard many good things about them, and I have to say I do love them. They are great to work with and you can get a fanatic thinner to help water down some of their paints, War Paint Stabilizer and Warpaints Retarder as well as a gloss Varnish and Matt Varnish. The fact that each pot comes with 2 (I think it is 2) ball bearings to help mix the paint when shaken is bloody brilliant. One of the best features is the flexible triad system, I find this for glazing works wonders, better than the Citadel paints. I have not used every paint they have (216 at present) and I only have about 112, yet the ones I have used are fantastic. They are as good as or even better than the Citadel paints, I have. The dropper bottle is so much better than the flip lids which causes citadels paints to dry quicker in the pots and more gets wasted. I do however confess, that the only other paint I have used is the ones you get for Airfix kits, I have no idea what the other paint rangers are like.
Have to agree, the old Army painter paints were awful, to say the least. I received my new complete Fanatic Paint set this week, and so far, after trying a few of the paints, I'm enjoying using them, and the slight satin finish to some paints actually helps me see any mistakes I've made, as I'm partially sighted, so the slight sheen helps me see where the primer or layer paints are showing through. I make my own washes/glazes, so haven't used the shades in the set yet. However, the inclusion of new brushes with set has had me jumping for joy, as they include a detail brush, a larger layering brush, and a dry-brush too. I'd never used the "Toblerone" handle style brushes before, after over 50 years of using just round handled brushes, and they are remarkably comfortable to hold/use, and so I may just make the leap and invest in a full set of these brushes now, as my painting hand doesn't ache as much after a heavy session after using this type 🙂 By the way, absolutely LOVE your sweater 😉 Where did you get it from, as I SO want one for myself now 😊
Was hesitant on picking up any army painter paint after a bad first experience with their original speed paint but keep hearing more about these and might keep an eye out for a few colors if I happen to see them now.
Good video, honest opinion and the same conclusion I have come to based on various reviews. Pick up some colors as you need them and, in my case, grab the new washes and a couple of the effects paints. Thanks for the video.
Ahoj, díky za super otestování nových barviček od AP. Měl bych jeden doplňující dotaz, nezkoušel jsi porovnávat stejnojmenné barvičky Warpaints proti Warpaints fanatic? V té sadě ve videu vidím třeba žlutou Daemonic Yellow, která se v barvách Warpaints jmenovala stejně. Zajímalo by mne, jestli je i tam taková změna. Díky za odpověď
Hope these make AP more available in stores. I have tended to use them over Vallejo and citadel, mainly due to price as my core colours, I like citadels technical paints, and really the only Vallejo product I buy is the plastic putty it's my favourite gap filler for minor gaps. But for paints unless I need a very specific shade like a military uniform, AP I feel once mixed up properly did the same job cheaper. I also like APs brushes for price to performance. Another brand that does well is SMS their acrylics are great too.
at 2:34... you have 3 "Cool Reds" paints...and add a "pinks" paint? but...why? they are not from the same line... there are 6 points in "cool reds" line, so, might be a better idea to use them.
Very similar to Juan Hidalgo's arguments, and probably correct. Note that yes, Vallejo and AK are super cheap and available in Spain, but in the US.... they aren't. My local store sells AK for $5 a bottle. We also get them with major delays: The Vallejo XpressPaint 2.0 arrived to US stores this week, while Spain had them in November.Even when the stores theoretically carries them, the most popular colors disappear quickly, and aren't restocked fast. In comparison, I can get Army Painter products in basically as many stores as I can get Citadel, and often deeply discounted. That crazy complete set of 216 paints is 645 dollars down the street: I am not buying such a monstrosity, but it's two dollars cheaper per bottle than AK. So as far as hobby equipment goes, pricing and availability varies so much, every visit to Spain includes a bag full of paint and brushes.
Yep.. I was looking for some specific AK colors and everywhere was sold out.. Except eBay where someone wanted double the price for each color. You'd think these companies would be working on their logistics...
Army painter is definitely cheaper than ak or vallejo here, but i love all 3 ranges. I ended up getting the complete fanatic range, and have no regrets. The "best paint in the world"was just marketing hype though lol
As someone with more money than sense, I picked up the complete speed paint 2.0 range. I realized pretty quickly what it wasn't good at and picked up the entire fanatic range. I'm a beginner. None of them were frustrating to use. I think what they do best is accessibility. The boxes come with instructions. The labeling makes sense. I never was frustrated or lost. For an ultra skilled UA-camr, maybe they aren't the best. For somebody who has no idea what they are doing, I feel like AP has done a good job of providing quality paints and made them approachable. Damn I should have posted on Reddit. This is way too long for YT.
Did you try out the new Game Color range by Vallejo? I loved them, but the more I used them the more I noticed a bubbling issue. Pretty sad, might switch to AK since I really love their pastels set
@@alternate3787 over here if you buy the army painter sets the stores here will give a discount, making AKI more expensive. AKI also sell their paint sets packaged very differently so the army painter sets gives you more mileage because they cover a wider spectrum of colours.
I think I'm going to stick with pro acryl for now too. I had thought maybe with how much hype these were getting they'd be the best on Earth. I might try out their metallic since they're doing a Vallejo metal flakes in the paint style thing
It's an interesting decision what they decided to include in the 50 paint kit, knowing theyve got the 200+ kit as well. You're right, 20% of the set being just blues and teals seems a bit extreme. They looke xcellent though tbf
the some paints satin, some paints matte, is an issue for most of the good paints. it's just down to the material used in these high pigment paints, and how they react with the solution
So a thought, this brings their paints in line with more modern lines, in my opinion they are better than GWs line. They have a vert wide selection of paints to build from. Most likely this will compliment your favorites not replace them. As far as price goes they are still cheaper than GW and scale 75 and whatnot, especially when nearly everything is is going to be thinned at least 1:1 paint and water and the bottles are bigger. Then it is hard to beat amazon availability, which none of the other ranges seem to do. One of the negatives is their really bright colors tend to break down more when thinning to glaze like levels and so you have to use their mediums instead of water and they are missing some depth of color choices in their very wide range. Overall though they are a solid paint line that should definitely supplement your existing paints and should not be avoided like the old line. Good video, though i think you are more critical than I in regards to the line.
I've bought the complete set and I am really happy so far. As you mentioned, some of the colours are a bit on the understaurated side but other than that I like them. The triads help me personally because i suck at mixing colors conistently and end with slightly different hues that just look weird. If I really need to push contrast or need a really colourfull I still use Kimera colors, but they are a pain to use IMO. Edit: My biggest critique is that you must shake them like hell (might be the problem with your satin black) otherwise they behave weird.
i really didnt like just how negative this was. it seemed your previous experience with army painter color your experience. They improved alot, Speedpaint and air paints are fantastic paints aswell. it seemed like you where reading for reasons to not like these.
@cblack04_92 it's to make the point that the triads are helpful for beginners but not advanced painters, having a preset value scale for a colour is very helpful for beginners but it's not something that'll be helpful for people who've been painting for years so know how to work with their colours.
The cross-triad thing seemed a bit left-field, but I don't see how anything he said isn't fair? Mirrors some of the comments some of other reviewers have mentioned to me. Things like the paints being pastel from added white/grey/whatever, that's something Juan Hidalgo pointed out as well. If you're not prepared for reviews of things you like to have negatives, maybe don't watch reviews.
I hate the new speed paints. It flakes off the model if you fart wrong. I was constantly doing touch ups. Worst buy ever. Now I don't trust their new acrylics.
I might have asked before, but what parchment paper are you using in your wet pallet, and what is the benefit of having extra paper between the parchment paper and the sponge?
So what does anybody think about just buying any acrylic paint for models? I'm new i have a some citadel paints but I was thinking hey maybe I should buy a bunch of these walmart paints and water them down and use them as washes or something idk. I just wonder what makes citadel and army paints so much better than any other acrylic?
You can buy artist brand acrylics and those will work, but cheap paints from stationary or walmart won't attach to the models properly - I even tested that in one of my videos
So refreshing! My experience so far - opaque over dark if glooped straight from the bottle. Thinned to a workable consistency, AK 3rd Gen perform much better.
Hmmm. I don't think that's what they meant by the color triad. Pretty sure triads are just meant to be used for a gradient within a single hue. P3 and other paints have done this in the past. I don't think it's anything new. But maybe I missed that pitch. Where I do think it helps is working with shadows that involve multiple hues.
My only problem with their new sets is that you don't have an entry level set with just 15-20 colors including metallics and washes. Instead you have to buy the monster set with 50 colours for 150+ bucks. EDIT: False information. They do have a starter set. Its just not on Amazon yet.
I just bought it, it's quite light (only 11 pots including a wash and no orange) but the price is decent, about 35€. I think I prefer their old "Pure red", it was redder lol. However the improvements of metallics, Plate mail notably, are impressive.
I have such a hard time articulating what the exact style of lighting/shading is - bright, kind of like a Spanish thing? I really need some help to get to that
From all the reviews and podcast I have listened to I get the impression that this is an update to compete with the new generation of hobby paint, not to surpass them. I'll try out a couple paints but it won't replace my collection of mostly Vallejo. All the buzz lately is mostly because Army Painter is readily available and apparently has good marketing. Meanwhile the new Vallejo Model Color range is about to drop in two weeks and I have yet to see anyone talk about it outside of the people involved.
Solid, fair review. Their lighter tones are good enough, but anything darker than a supposed "midtone" is far to desaturated. The Reds are either too orange or too pink. The darkest red in Warm Red triad is actually orange, and its quite annoying. EDIT: At the end of the day, I only kept 3 or 4 colors, the rest I'm getting rid of/selling off since they're barely used. Colors are way to pastel for my tastes, and I don't see myself going back to them, in comparison to Vallejo's updated model color line, Pro Acryl or Scale 75(sue me I love their paints). Even their new XL wet palette is "lacking." I think I'm done with Army Painter to be honest, too many misses for my tastes.
I've heard that from some opinions from what I've tested and painted so far you can get a good saturation after testing most of them, some dry with a punchy saturation kick after they dry I was surprised with some reds being whitish when applied but becoming really RED when dried so idk maybe it's more of the medium they use rather than white pigments ?
I'm not a big fan of the "effects" paints, would have loved for them to not be included in the set. I'd have loved to have the warm reds in the mega set. I think a "build your own mega-set" option would have been really nice.
Man, I'm entirely behind that idea of building your own set. Would probably be hell on their packaging department, but I bet a lot of people would pay more (but less than if they got them individually of course) for that sort of thing. Might even be worth sending them an email about
Myslím si, že je super, že na těch barvách makají a zlepšují je na základě zpětné vazby. Jestli budou dál pokračovat, jednou možná nejlepší budou. Pro mě je to momentálně přínosné hlavně v tom, že mají ty seřazené triády. Jako barvoslepý jsem si tohle u ostatních barev vždy musel dohledávat a psát na papír, jak barvy k sobě míchat a jak je navazovat v odstínech.
You are the only youtyber that pointed that these colors have always white in them, it’smsomething i noticed immediately from th first videos: AP did not make a miracle for coverage, they just made every color a pastel variant adding white. Also no one considers that this kind of “perfect coverage” while usefulmfor beginners and basecoating, iis a pain in th but when w alk about glazing and using the naturall transparency of th paints to our advantage to make gradients
Juan Hidalgo noticed the same thing, with them apparently having more white or other opaque pigments added in. As for the perfect coverage thing, just thin it more? IMO, a thicker base is much better, since you can turn a thick paint into a thin one, but the inverse isn't true (without dehydrating the paint and running the risk of ruining it - don't do this). And if I'm glazing with a super-thin paint, I often want to have an opaque version of the same colour on hand for the same project, so not having it cover poorly out of the bottle is valuable there. But YMMV.
le seul avantage que je vois à cette marque et plus particulièrement à cet étiquetage. c'est que pour moi qui suis daltonien le fait d'avoir 6 teintes différentes qui soient repérées sur la bouteille, cela me facilte le choix des couleurs. mais si effectivement c'est plus cher.... je continuerai avec mes peintures habituelles.
These really seem like a massive improvement to the old army painter paints (or more so, the older ones were just terrible). But I’ll just stick to AK and Pro Acryl
I just ordered Pro Acryl for the first time after almost enirely using army painter. I hope it's as good as everyone says! The army painter white is so rubbish
Always buy paints by the colours you need unless you're just starting out then get a set. Each brand has better and worse colours to others, or specific shades you use heaps so you dont need to mix them. Think i've got like 5-6 paint brands atm all have upsides and downsides
I mostly use AK and Vallejo, both model and game, but I look forward to trying Army Painter’s new cool reds, most reds seem to want to be warm so will be fun to try some cool reds :)
Same, I mainly bought a bunch of AK and a couple of Vellejo. The Vellejo need a bit more thinning but feel like they go a bit further. I was using "grimy grey" alot and then tried Citidel wraithbone.. its unbelievable how dogcrap it is compared to AK.
So what you're saying is Vallejo and AK are cheaper, a bit better, and I can actually buy vallejo locally and AK from hobby shops... I wonder how they compare to GSW though.
I never had a worst time with army painters reds… like Christ on a cracker….. I love painting red and this stuff just never mixed well or covered. I hope this stuff is better
The new paints are too thick for my purposes as I glaze a _LOT_ and thicker means I gotta put more work into my glazes. Imma stick to my ProAcryls. Thems good.
Yeah he said his point in a bad way basically he means that these are useless for experienced painters which I don't fully agree BCS it's always a nice to have rather than nothing like all the other brands but that's my opinion
I don't know what it is with black paint, but it seems that unless you apply a very thin, almost watery, final layer it won't look matte, regardless of brand. As for the 'best paint' part, there is no best range, it all depends on what you're doing. Best for the average painter? That might seem plausible. For youtubers and artists who have refined their techniques and want select properties from each of their colors? Less plausible. There are in my opinion best pots or bottles of paint out there. Citadel's Retributor Armor is practically renowned at this point.
My experience is they are not that much saturated because they prioritized the coverage so they added titanium white to most of the colors… so they of making darker color is by using other pot because they mix very bad with dark tones or black. (Edited: shit! You talked about it after I wrote the comment)
If you play around with the paint consistency, that will do the trick. For the thick layer, just apply it like a basecoat and when glazing, just use like 50/50 water and paint and drag the drop from the darker layer towards the lighter one, ideally leaving it on the transition. Good luck!
There's nothing wrong with the OG army painter set as long as you have a vortex mixer or similar. The OG ones have a lot of medium in the tops and if there not mixed well then yes they don't perform.
Join our community on Patreon! 👉www.patreon.com/zumikito
Everyone misses the “probably” bit. We “probably” made the best paints in the world. If you dig into our release content you can understand why we say that and how we measured that in the development. Thanks for the review of the new range. We hope that hobbyists get to try them and love them as much as we do. ❤
I also remember an entire video segment addressing the tension between "best paint in the world," and affordable prices. The idea was clearly: "our best possible paint without abandoning affordable prices."
Wow Backpedaling already 😅
I'm still ordering the box when I get my paycheck
I still give you guys mad props for making hand sanatizer during the pandemic. IDK if I'll buy your paints, but some of your other stuff for sure.
I applaud you all on your business decision. You took an honest look at the current state of your product, came to the conclusion that it was substandard, scrapped it and drastically improved it. I purchased my Fanatic Complete set and am eagerly awaiting its delivery.
I mean no one is gonna go out there and say “Yeah our new paint? Mid” lol
'It's okay, you don't need to buy it'
"We use Vallejo ourselves anyway"
The correct quote would be “our new paints are some of the best in the world.”
@@jameskillbot2867 I think when you were one of the worst in the world you probably want to go as far in the other direction as possible 😂
@@electo21You've killed me xD
Not sure if you watched any of the promo videos before launch where Army Painter got pro painters to try out the Fanatic line. In the videos, the painters praised how much better they are and just repeatedly trashing how bad their old paints were, and Army Painter just sat there taking it. They know how bad their old paints were. I give Army Painter props for leaving in the trashing of their old paints.
I think the biggest pro of this is that Army Painter is one of the most available paint lines out there and also often the lowest cost. This means a lot of new people to the hobby buy them. With the old paints, it probably turned a lot of people off the painting hobby because of how bad the paint jobs would come out and how hard to use they were. Having this new line is important to for that reason.
Exactly! And the fact they were brave enough to go see those painters shows what it means to them as a company. I love what they have done and enjoy the shit out of the new paints. Plus, it's easier to get a hold of than any other brand.
@sbip88 not convinced tbf, they had a lot enter their team... Making the 'review' part absolute bollocks
At least old AP were budget friendly, seems that these aren't
@@OldManRogersYou get more paint per pot for a lower price than Citadel paints (which is probably the most used brand out there) - and fanatic paints being usually thicker also means that you can (and possibly should) dilute the paint you have a bit more thus having even more mL worth of "paint" to actually paint with.
One thing that I respect about Army Painter is that they are good at taking and learning from criticism. They aren't the greatest hobby producer in the world, but they are solid and continually improving.
Could be their statement about being (probably) the best paints in the world, is just a fun jab at Carlsberg, that claims to be the best beer in the world (probably)?
Both companies are from Denmark afterall :)
Im glad i can consider Army Painter as a viable brand of paint again, they are some of the most easilly accesible here in Scandinavia, but their old range was just a nope. Happy they've stepped up.
Same. I've been sticking to Citadel as they're easiest to get a hold of a wide range, and are used in a lot of tutorials. But this really opens my available options.
Hey Zumi,
I just purchased an Army Painter mega set. I used to just buy my paints by color as needed, but I was recently in a motorcycle accident and shattered my leg, so I’m not very mobile right now. I needed a good set that wasn’t too many paints, but still had a good span of colors, which is why I went with this set. I was concerned though, about previous AP reviews. Even though you didn’t think AP is the ‘best in the world’, your review at least gave me confidence that I made a good purchase. Thank you! 🙂
Hope you recover well soon there mate
@@terrydactyl2077
TY. Every day is a little better than the last. 🏍️
Hope you're healing up well! How did the paints end up suiting you? @@rccarguy3696
That yellow actually looks really good. I'm really impressed with the coverage overall. The range as a whole seems pretty solid.
That sweater is the perfect talking point for any family function.
Its usually something I say to a girl on the first date at Applebee's
@@ShowerOnceYearly "And that kids is how I met your mother."
When someone gives a bad review of a product, as a company when you make a revision, that person should be on the priority of people to send to.
Because if that person gives a good review of the new thing, then you know you have a winner.
that little color triad gauge on the bottle is a great feature for colorblindness (except when theyre mislabelled, like the "magenta" and "pink")
Don't worry. They probably won't see the difference.
@@pawe6199It's me. I am they.
@@little_isalina joke's on You then, please don't kill me 😅
We can see it , we just can't identify it
As a starter (and a bit colourblind) hobbyist, right now I'm more interested in their triad system rather than any other feature. If other brands implemented a clear system and maybe a consistent naming convention, well, that would be very interesting! Great video, as always!
As a non-colourblind painter I agree, because what the hell AK "grey blue" and "blue grey", I use one of these and I don't even remember which one it is
There are reviews of this set everywhere and they always say they got a complementary set from Army Painter. I appreciate you spending the money so could make an unbiased review of these. Well done!
The triad is genius. I'm a new painter and having a gradient of paints ready for me to learn and work through removes a whole lot of anxiety for me. I don't know why more companies don't do it.
I rode the hype train for the entire marketing campaign lol. I know you are pretty biased against them so I was really looking forward to seeing your review of the new line! The fact that you used to have them as "dog****" and now consider them around C to B tier. Thats a huge leap from a tough critic, and they can consider it a win lol.
"Best" is better pronounced as "boast" and its not opinion or fact so much as advertising lol
Solid review! very fair and thorough. I think my biggest takeaway wasn't about the quality of their product so much as the quality of their effort to elevate their product.
The triad system is relative to itself. That’s why underneath the graphic there is what triad it belongs to. I guess i don’t understand what the heck you’re talking about.
I thought the same thing. I think he must not have understood how it works. Feels very intuitive to me.
In the US, AK and Vajello are either not available or the cost comes out to the same or more due to logistics.
Just ordered a Mega Set too and this is the most critical video I've seen about these. Thank you. I'm still excited for it to arrive 😊
they have a new kit coming out - the 22 kits which I am told have no overlapping colours. Its really nice to see that kind of thought like that.
I see that you are fan of the Spanish acrylics. I also use Vallejo a lot. I still need to try more of AK, but I love their rust/verdigras/moss effect emanels.
Exactly what i had in mind, also i need that ORANGE and yellow and a few grey-greens.
Excellent review! Thank you!!!
Zumikito merch is making me double check what kind of merch i browse with those slogans
You'll be put on lists!
I originally misread this as “Tasting the best paints in the World” and let just me say I’m still holding out hope
New to the hobby (although I will be a historical vice fantasy/sci-f war gamer). I have been looking all over for paint comparisons but of course 95% of such content is fantasy focused. However, reviews of paint regardless of miniature is very helpful. I ran across your video and found something you said interesting. Folks from the UK and into Warhammer would naturally gravitate towards Citadel. The bit you mentioned about Warlord was a light bulb moment. In that historical space they chose Army Painter. So my question is if you were in my shoes as a newcomer who will focus mostly on 18-19 th century historical miniature painting, who would you go with. I am from the U.S. so no bias or history with any company at all. It seems on the surface that Vallejo model color is well suited to historical but then again I like the base/layer/highlight ease with Citadel.. again as a beginner. I very much welcome suggestions. Thanks!!
For 20 plus years I have been using Games Workshop paints mainly Citadel and loved them. However, I brought the new fanatic paints as I heard many good things about them, and I have to say I do love them. They are great to work with and you can get a fanatic thinner to help water down some of their paints, War Paint Stabilizer and Warpaints Retarder as well as a gloss Varnish and Matt Varnish. The fact that each pot comes with 2 (I think it is 2) ball bearings to help mix the paint when shaken is bloody brilliant. One of the best features is the flexible triad system, I find this for glazing works wonders, better than the Citadel paints. I have not used every paint they have (216 at present) and I only have about 112, yet the ones I have used are fantastic. They are as good as or even better than the Citadel paints, I have. The dropper bottle is so much better than the flip lids which causes citadels paints to dry quicker in the pots and more gets wasted. I do however confess, that the only other paint I have used is the ones you get for Airfix kits, I have no idea what the other paint rangers are like.
Have to agree, the old Army painter paints were awful, to say the least.
I received my new complete Fanatic Paint set this week, and so far, after trying a few of the paints, I'm enjoying using them, and the slight satin finish to some paints actually helps me see any mistakes I've made, as I'm partially sighted, so the slight sheen helps me see where the primer or layer paints are showing through.
I make my own washes/glazes, so haven't used the shades in the set yet.
However, the inclusion of new brushes with set has had me jumping for joy, as they include a detail brush, a larger layering brush, and a dry-brush too.
I'd never used the "Toblerone" handle style brushes before, after over 50 years of using just round handled brushes, and they are remarkably comfortable to hold/use, and so I may just make the leap and invest in a full set of these brushes now, as my painting hand doesn't ache as much after a heavy session after using this type 🙂
By the way, absolutely LOVE your sweater 😉
Where did you get it from, as I SO want one for myself now 😊
I was using AK (75 paints) and got the new complete set. I must say that I'm super happy with the change.
I'm quite happy with the new set, though I've noticed they don't actually have warm dark reds in there, their darker reds go purple real fast instead.
@@kanadaj3275 yeah, the reds could be way better. This is the only megative I have to say. Hopefully they drop more colors later :)
That's surprising, AK 3rd gen is very good
@@HappyDuude 100%, but I like these more right now (except the reds). Might be more colours I would change for ak later who knows :)
I was thinking about getting some Acrylic gouache colors and try them on miniatures.
@@somerandomguy180 I use Golden SoFlat all the time! It's awesome.
Was hesitant on picking up any army painter paint after a bad first experience with their original speed paint but keep hearing more about these and might keep an eye out for a few colors if I happen to see them now.
Good video, honest opinion and the same conclusion I have come to based on various reviews. Pick up some colors as you need them and, in my case, grab the new washes and a couple of the effects paints. Thanks for the video.
Ahoj, díky za super otestování nových barviček od AP. Měl bych jeden doplňující dotaz, nezkoušel jsi porovnávat stejnojmenné barvičky Warpaints proti Warpaints fanatic? V té sadě ve videu vidím třeba žlutou Daemonic Yellow, která se v barvách Warpaints jmenovala stejně. Zajímalo by mne, jestli je i tam taková změna. Díky za odpověď
Hope these make AP more available in stores.
I have tended to use them over Vallejo and citadel, mainly due to price as my core colours, I like citadels technical paints, and really the only Vallejo product I buy is the plastic putty it's my favourite gap filler for minor gaps. But for paints unless I need a very specific shade like a military uniform, AP I feel once mixed up properly did the same job cheaper. I also like APs brushes for price to performance.
Another brand that does well is SMS their acrylics are great too.
at 2:34... you have 3 "Cool Reds" paints...and add a "pinks" paint? but...why? they are not from the same line... there are 6 points in "cool reds" line, so, might be a better idea to use them.
Very similar to Juan Hidalgo's arguments, and probably correct. Note that yes, Vallejo and AK are super cheap and available in Spain, but in the US.... they aren't. My local store sells AK for $5 a bottle. We also get them with major delays: The Vallejo XpressPaint 2.0 arrived to US stores this week, while Spain had them in November.Even when the stores theoretically carries them, the most popular colors disappear quickly, and aren't restocked fast. In comparison, I can get Army Painter products in basically as many stores as I can get Citadel, and often deeply discounted. That crazy complete set of 216 paints is 645 dollars down the street: I am not buying such a monstrosity, but it's two dollars cheaper per bottle than AK.
So as far as hobby equipment goes, pricing and availability varies so much, every visit to Spain includes a bag full of paint and brushes.
Yep.. I was looking for some specific AK colors and everywhere was sold out.. Except eBay where someone wanted double the price for each color. You'd think these companies would be working on their logistics...
I look forward to try it out. 🖌
Army painter is definitely cheaper than ak or vallejo here, but i love all 3 ranges. I ended up getting the complete fanatic range, and have no regrets. The "best paint in the world"was just marketing hype though lol
As someone with more money than sense, I picked up the complete speed paint 2.0 range. I realized pretty quickly what it wasn't good at and picked up the entire fanatic range. I'm a beginner. None of them were frustrating to use. I think what they do best is accessibility. The boxes come with instructions. The labeling makes sense. I never was frustrated or lost. For an ultra skilled UA-camr, maybe they aren't the best. For somebody who has no idea what they are doing, I feel like AP has done a good job of providing quality paints and made them approachable.
Damn I should have posted on Reddit. This is way too long for YT.
Agreed!
Did you try out the new Game Color range by Vallejo? I loved them, but the more I used them the more I noticed a bubbling issue. Pretty sad, might switch to AK since I really love their pastels set
I can’t believe he said AK Interactive was cheaper than Army Painter, nothing about AKI is cheap in the slightest
I dont know where you live but its around 2,75€ a bottle. Not cheap but cheaper than the new Fanatic paints
@@alternate3787 over here if you buy the army painter sets the stores here will give a discount, making AKI more expensive. AKI also sell their paint sets packaged very differently so the army painter sets gives you more mileage because they cover a wider spectrum of colours.
@alternate3787 it's hard to get in the US why I'm looking into army painter
I think I'm going to stick with pro acryl for now too. I had thought maybe with how much hype these were getting they'd be the best on Earth. I might try out their metallic since they're doing a Vallejo metal flakes in the paint style thing
It's an interesting decision what they decided to include in the 50 paint kit, knowing theyve got the 200+ kit as well. You're right, 20% of the set being just blues and teals seems a bit extreme. They looke xcellent though tbf
They know we all only paint space marines anyway /s
@@kanadaj3275 Cato Sicarius has many shades of blue ya know
I would really like to see green stuff world paint review from you!
the some paints satin, some paints matte, is an issue for most of the good paints. it's just down to the material used in these high pigment paints, and how they react with the solution
So a thought, this brings their paints in line with more modern lines, in my opinion they are better than GWs line. They have a vert wide selection of paints to build from. Most likely this will compliment your favorites not replace them. As far as price goes they are still cheaper than GW and scale 75 and whatnot, especially when nearly everything is is going to be thinned at least 1:1 paint and water and the bottles are bigger. Then it is hard to beat amazon availability, which none of the other ranges seem to do. One of the negatives is their really bright colors tend to break down more when thinning to glaze like levels and so you have to use their mediums instead of water and they are missing some depth of color choices in their very wide range. Overall though they are a solid paint line that should definitely supplement your existing paints and should not be avoided like the old line. Good video, though i think you are more critical than I in regards to the line.
What is this drop on the cap wizardry? 10:28 ? Is this a thing i should do too?
I do that to have see the actual sample of the paint.
I've bought the complete set and I am really happy so far. As you mentioned, some of the colours are a bit on the understaurated side but other than that I like them. The triads help me personally because i suck at mixing colors conistently and end with slightly different hues that just look weird. If I really need to push contrast or need a really colourfull I still use Kimera colors, but they are a pain to use IMO.
Edit: My biggest critique is that you must shake them like hell (might be the problem with your satin black) otherwise they behave weird.
Yeah I've found that even my vortex mixer can't actually do much to shake them up properly, not at this thickness.
i really didnt like just how negative this was. it seemed your previous experience with army painter color your experience. They improved alot, Speedpaint and air paints are fantastic paints aswell. it seemed like you where reading for reasons to not like these.
yeah the complaint about the triads not working between triads feels just illogical
@cblack04_92 it's to make the point that the triads are helpful for beginners but not advanced painters, having a preset value scale for a colour is very helpful for beginners but it's not something that'll be helpful for people who've been painting for years so know how to work with their colours.
The cross-triad thing seemed a bit left-field, but I don't see how anything he said isn't fair? Mirrors some of the comments some of other reviewers have mentioned to me. Things like the paints being pastel from added white/grey/whatever, that's something Juan Hidalgo pointed out as well.
If you're not prepared for reviews of things you like to have negatives, maybe don't watch reviews.
When you make claim that you're selling "the best product", you shouldn't complain about being held to high standard.
I hate the new speed paints. It flakes off the model if you fart wrong. I was constantly doing touch ups. Worst buy ever. Now I don't trust their new acrylics.
I might have asked before, but what parchment paper are you using in your wet pallet, and what is the benefit of having extra paper between the parchment paper and the sponge?
sponge + paper towel transports the moisture to the top better and the parchment paper is from Tesco
Ive seen elsewhere that glazing can be an issue, that needs to use their medium to get good results - not sure if you found that.
So what does anybody think about just buying any acrylic paint for models? I'm new i have a some citadel paints but I was thinking hey maybe I should buy a bunch of these walmart paints and water them down and use them as washes or something idk. I just wonder what makes citadel and army paints so much better than any other acrylic?
You can buy artist brand acrylics and those will work, but cheap paints from stationary or walmart won't attach to the models properly - I even tested that in one of my videos
@Zumikito ah gotcha. I won't bother then. Lol thanks for the tips I'll keep working my way through your videos. I just started about a week ago.
Hey I can’t remember have you reviewed proacryl?
I have talked about pro acryl in the video about other paint brands, yes :)
Did you apply them without thinning them ? Or did you thin it with water or medium?
So refreshing! My experience so far - opaque over dark if glooped straight from the bottle. Thinned to a workable consistency, AK 3rd Gen perform much better.
Hmmm. I don't think that's what they meant by the color triad. Pretty sure triads are just meant to be used for a gradient within a single hue. P3 and other paints have done this in the past. I don't think it's anything new. But maybe I missed that pitch. Where I do think it helps is working with shadows that involve multiple hues.
I just gotta tell ya...NO other content creator makes me laugh like this. Nearly choked to death on my coffee. 😂😂😂
Hi Zumikito - what paints would you recommend if you were to put together a set for Vallejo and AK interactive? :)
great video. subscribed. imagine an actual honest opinion! crazy. Love it.
I’m pretty pissed. $200 paint set with one red that is called pure red buts it’s a pink instead.
Have you already tried the new Vallejo model color?
My only problem with their new sets is that you don't have an entry level set with just 15-20 colors including metallics and washes. Instead you have to buy the monster set with 50 colours for 150+ bucks.
EDIT: False information. They do have a starter set. Its just not on Amazon yet.
I just bought it, it's quite light (only 11 pots including a wash and no orange) but the price is decent, about 35€. I think I prefer their old "Pure red", it was redder lol. However the improvements of metallics, Plate mail notably, are impressive.
I have such a hard time articulating what the exact style of lighting/shading is - bright, kind of like a Spanish thing? I really need some help to get to that
in terms of coverage this are better then vallejo? thank you mate
AK and Vallejo is almost impossible to get in my area. I’ll have to give army painter a try
From all the reviews and podcast I have listened to I get the impression that this is an update to compete with the new generation of hobby paint, not to surpass them. I'll try out a couple paints but it won't replace my collection of mostly Vallejo. All the buzz lately is mostly because Army Painter is readily available and apparently has good marketing. Meanwhile the new Vallejo Model Color range is about to drop in two weeks and I have yet to see anyone talk about it outside of the people involved.
Solid, fair review. Their lighter tones are good enough, but anything darker than a supposed "midtone" is far to desaturated. The Reds are either too orange or too pink. The darkest red in Warm Red triad is actually orange, and its quite annoying.
EDIT: At the end of the day, I only kept 3 or 4 colors, the rest I'm getting rid of/selling off since they're barely used. Colors are way to pastel for my tastes, and I don't see myself going back to them, in comparison to Vallejo's updated model color line, Pro Acryl or Scale 75(sue me I love their paints). Even their new XL wet palette is "lacking." I think I'm done with Army Painter to be honest, too many misses for my tastes.
Hey Zumiko thanks for all the great content.
All of the colours are slightly desaturated which I'm not a fan of. Good for base coating i guess.
I've heard that from some opinions from what I've tested and painted so far you can get a good saturation after testing most of them, some dry with a punchy saturation kick after they dry I was surprised with some reds being whitish when applied but becoming really RED when dried so idk maybe it's more of the medium they use rather than white pigments ?
Just bought a bunch of Vallejo. I always want to try out new products, but paints are too expensive! 😭
Honestly considered buying some of these, but Vallejo has never failed to work for me
I'm not a big fan of the "effects" paints, would have loved for them to not be included in the set. I'd have loved to have the warm reds in the mega set.
I think a "build your own mega-set" option would have been really nice.
Man, I'm entirely behind that idea of building your own set. Would probably be hell on their packaging department, but I bet a lot of people would pay more (but less than if they got them individually of course) for that sort of thing. Might even be worth sending them an email about
I searched for rimming but haven't seen any base painting for 5 days...
Hey Zumikito are you that dude from Safe and Sound song?
Myslím si, že je super, že na těch barvách makají a zlepšují je na základě zpětné vazby. Jestli budou dál pokračovat, jednou možná nejlepší budou. Pro mě je to momentálně přínosné hlavně v tom, že mají ty seřazené triády. Jako barvoslepý jsem si tohle u ostatních barev vždy musel dohledávat a psát na papír, jak barvy k sobě míchat a jak je navazovat v odstínech.
You are the only youtyber that pointed that these colors have always white in them, it’smsomething i noticed immediately from th first videos: AP did not make a miracle for coverage, they just made every color a pastel variant adding white. Also no one considers that this kind of “perfect coverage” while usefulmfor beginners and basecoating, iis a pain in th but when w alk about glazing and using the naturall transparency of th paints to our advantage to make gradients
Kimera havo no withe in It and are Just a single pigment. really love them!
@@pierluigimarchi8108 i know, i have them 😁
Juan Hidalgo noticed the same thing, with them apparently having more white or other opaque pigments added in.
As for the perfect coverage thing, just thin it more? IMO, a thicker base is much better, since you can turn a thick paint into a thin one, but the inverse isn't true (without dehydrating the paint and running the risk of ruining it - don't do this). And if I'm glazing with a super-thin paint, I often want to have an opaque version of the same colour on hand for the same project, so not having it cover poorly out of the bottle is valuable there. But YMMV.
@@nicholassinnett2958 Juan hidalgo’s video came out the day after i wrote this comment 😅
i use them only because, i hate citadels paint pots, and paints like vallejo, AK, pro acrly, two thin coats are hard to get in my country
le seul avantage que je vois à cette marque et plus particulièrement à cet étiquetage. c'est que pour moi qui suis daltonien le fait d'avoir 6 teintes différentes qui soient repérées sur la bouteille, cela me facilte le choix des couleurs. mais si effectivement c'est plus cher.... je continuerai avec mes peintures habituelles.
Better then Proacryl?
Outside of some colored metallic options, I've not been a fan of the army painter paints I've used.
These really seem like a massive improvement to the old army painter paints (or more so, the older ones were just terrible).
But I’ll just stick to AK and Pro Acryl
I just ordered Pro Acryl for the first time after almost enirely using army painter. I hope it's as good as everyone says! The army painter white is so rubbish
Are you talking about the new or old AP ?@@WafflePrince
As a beginner mini painter I have to say that I absolutely love these paints
Always buy paints by the colours you need unless you're just starting out then get a set. Each brand has better and worse colours to others, or specific shades you use heaps so you dont need to mix them. Think i've got like 5-6 paint brands atm all have upsides and downsides
I mostly use AK and Vallejo, both model and game, but I look forward to trying Army Painter’s new cool reds, most reds seem to want to be warm so will be fun to try some cool reds :)
Same, I mainly bought a bunch of AK and a couple of Vellejo. The Vellejo need a bit more thinning but feel like they go a bit further. I was using "grimy grey" alot and then tried Citidel wraithbone.. its unbelievable how dogcrap it is compared to AK.
The reds in the AP lineup have a real pink hue! Liquitex cadmium red is literally the only “red red” I’ve found.
@@BrettohI've got that colour in oil paint but yet to try, but yeh it is the highest quality Red pigment.
@@blakearius The heavy body acrylic takes some thinning but it’s gorgeous to work with once you get it!
Thanks for this review Zumi! Really great points and arguments related to the claims!
Liked and subscribed for the jumper because as it turns out i too also like rimming...
I mean if were going after advertising slogans, i would assume we would give the same trestment to Pro Acryls "Best paint period "
So what you're saying is Vallejo and AK are cheaper, a bit better, and I can actually buy vallejo locally and AK from hobby shops... I wonder how they compare to GSW though.
Great sweater!!!
I never had a worst time with army painters reds… like Christ on a cracker….. I love painting red and this stuff just never mixed well or covered. I hope this stuff is better
I just cannot wear a shirt that says "I love Rimming" on it lol
Ty for your honest review
The new paints are too thick for my purposes as I glaze a _LOT_ and thicker means I gotta put more work into my glazes.
Imma stick to my ProAcryls. Thems good.
That's not how the little chart on the bottle works. It's specific to the color family.
Yeah he said his point in a bad way basically he means that these are useless for experienced painters which I don't fully agree BCS it's always a nice to have rather than nothing like all the other brands but that's my opinion
I don't know what it is with black paint, but it seems that unless you apply a very thin, almost watery, final layer it won't look matte, regardless of brand.
As for the 'best paint' part, there is no best range, it all depends on what you're doing. Best for the average painter? That might seem plausible. For youtubers and artists who have refined their techniques and want select properties from each of their colors? Less plausible.
There are in my opinion best pots or bottles of paint out there. Citadel's Retributor Armor is practically renowned at this point.
Pro Acryl has that distinction imho. And ive tried most. So far Pro Acryl have been the best.
My experience is they are not that much saturated because they prioritized the coverage so they added titanium white to most of the colors… so they of making darker color is by using other pot because they mix very bad with dark tones or black. (Edited: shit! You talked about it after I wrote the comment)
I laugh in Pro Acryl! Soooo good.
Out of everything in this video I just want a start to finish video on how you did those space marine legs. Just shiteloads of glazing?
Thick layers and thin glazes to blend them
@@Zumikito thankyou so much!!!! I'll give it a try, looks so good with what (seems like) so little effort.
If you play around with the paint consistency, that will do the trick. For the thick layer, just apply it like a basecoat and when glazing, just use like 50/50 water and paint and drag the drop from the darker layer towards the lighter one, ideally leaving it on the transition. Good luck!
There's nothing wrong with the OG army painter set as long as you have a vortex mixer or similar. The OG ones have a lot of medium in the tops and if there not mixed well then yes they don't perform.
IDK if this was intentional but I got an Ad directly following "is called rimming" which made me laugh