Thank You Bob Dylan For Writing This Masterpiece . Thank You For Letting Artists Like Patti Smith Cover them. Patti Puts So Much Of Herself Into These Covers.
I had the pleasure of seeing this live. Patti and Tom Verlaine stepped in at the last minute, the support band for Garbage having dropped out. An unbelievable bonus. When Garbage came on stage, Shirley Manson mentioned how humbled she felt having such a legend as support. Patti was my first gig ever in 1979 in Biarritz.
Many of the masters know humility and perform from the heart . Not ego. Miss Smith is a true gem. A master poet and musician. Well done Pattie and band! Have a listen to the full version of Pattie performing at Nobel ceremony doing another master’s A Hard Rains Gonna Fall for Dylan. Beyond priceless.
I love Dylan...a extreme few can actually sing a Dylan song...this is the best cover of a Dylan song I have ever heard...i am in awe....Patti, you did Mr. Zimmerman proud!!! And, you have a new fan!!
Apparently you've not heard Dylan singing the song he wrote. Patti Smith is a horrific no-talent who appeals to a generation trying to figure out how to proceed without "The Beatles" and Dylan. So they fall for horseshit becuase it is promoted as "awesome". So let's do a Dylan song, because we haven't anything of our own. Oh -- but "GLORIA!" -- that was written by Van morrison. What else is she known for, except being a suck up to the "Beatniks" who died out three generations before she was born. If we have no imagination, then let's plunder someone else's past.
@@jnagarya519 well Her husband Sonic Fred Smith of the great rock band MC5 wasn't too shabby. Tho I will agree w u a bit on the surge of youngsters who are "woke", hip and cool that "dig" Patti...and "Hey man, have you read ginsberg, kerouac?" They make me wanna puke (is that too harsh? 😀)
Parts of the phasing effective -- like she was digging the knife in, skewering her enemy. A heartless thing to do,, but somehow you don't hate her or Dylan when they sing it. I'll save this version, thanks;
quand j etais petit je t aimais deja Maman ma Nounou me disais ecoute maman et j aimais beaucoup ma Nounou je suis revenu au paye regarder les pierre qui roulent c etais beau tres beau enfin j etais chez moi et je sais je t aime merci Maman.
Albeit being above half century old, I had never heard about Patti Smith until I watched this video... Given the extremely derogatory comments I read, I'll have to research a bit about her...
i especially like Patti's singing. the band plays the chords, very well but without any real sparks or roughness. maybe they should have had some extra female backing vocals in the chorus.
rjkaneda - Supposedly nobody liked it but Dylan, but the delayed chording Al Kooper did on the organ is what makes Dylan’s studio version rock. It’s simple and primitive but it never sounded the same when Kooper left. Find a live version that doesn’t suck, and hang onto it. Patty’s versions are better than Dylan’s, but everybody’s live versions are better than Dylan’s. The man can’t do live performances unless he’s doing acoustic solos.
I think they're too awed by the song to really do it justice. That's kind of OK, though; there's no doubt that Patti Smith and Lenny Kaye are, at some level, just plain old rock and roll fans. (Kaye put together Nuggets, after all.)
"Now you don't talk so loud . . . " That must have been wishful thinking on somebody's part. Adversity has done nothing to silence me. I bitch non-stop about scrounging for my next (decent) meal and about selling my plasma for Internet access. "How does it feel?" Feels okay. I'm alright.
I listened, I kept an open mind, and I read all the posts. Finally, I have to agree with the guy who said it is rubbish. And if it''s not that, it's still pretty much at least pointless.
Everything in life gets better to the sound of Patti Smith.
Thank You Bob Dylan For Writing This Masterpiece .
Thank You For Letting Artists Like Patti Smith Cover them.
Patti Puts So Much Of Herself Into These Covers.
Patti has been a Rolling Stone and keeps it real here...
I had the pleasure of seeing this live. Patti and Tom Verlaine stepped in at the last minute, the support band for Garbage having dropped out. An unbelievable bonus. When Garbage came on stage, Shirley Manson mentioned how humbled she felt having such a legend as support. Patti was my first gig ever in 1979 in Biarritz.
Patti is a poet and what I love is that she sang this song like Dylan wrote it.
WHAT A BEAUTIFUL VOICE
Absolutely sublime!
OH MY GOD Patti does it again. Broke thru my cold heart to the tears
Many of the masters know humility and perform from the heart . Not ego. Miss Smith is a true gem. A master poet and musician. Well done Pattie and band!
Have a listen to the full version of Pattie performing at Nobel ceremony doing another master’s A Hard Rains Gonna Fall for Dylan. Beyond priceless.
Patti is one the greatest Rock'n Roll queen forever. We love you !
You are totally oblivious to history. Compared with which she is a gawd awful non-talent.
GRACE SLICK , JONI MITCHELL , CAROLE KING , JANIS JOPLIN ,JOAN BAEZ ?
@@claudioconti5593 O'Connor?
All my love and recognition to Lenny Kaye too, because he is so amazing and important, love this version ❤😊
I Love Bob Dylan!! This version is GREAT!!! THANK YOU!! PATTI SMITH is GREAT I LOVE IT!!
Awesome job by Lenny. Love him too.
What's not to like? It's great! Also, nice to to see and hear Tom Verlaine
Patti, you make me cry! Just great!!!
voice still holds up, be proud of that goddess of female rock!!!
Very Nice!!! we Love Patti Smith. Thanks good video
This beautiful, beautiful version too.
This beautiful, beautiful version too.
One of the best performance I've ever seen.
Cool! Courageous as always, both Patti and Tom Verlaine!
Great performance on a great song.
Patti is the QUEEN
sung in true Patti Smith way. i like it.
Bob Dylan and Patti Smith are the best
BEAUTIFUL
I love Dylan...a extreme few can actually sing a Dylan song...this is the best cover of a Dylan song I have ever heard...i am in awe....Patti, you did Mr. Zimmerman proud!!! And, you have a new fan!!
As we are all one, we all know how it feels to be on our own.
Very Nice!!! we Love Patti Smith. Thanks good video
Patti Smith is extraordinary.
Does this woman really exist?!
She's amazing.
NEVER enjoyed a version of this song as much as this one!!!!!
Apparently you've not heard Dylan singing the song he wrote. Patti Smith is a horrific no-talent who appeals to a generation trying to figure out how to proceed without "The Beatles" and Dylan. So they fall for horseshit becuase it is promoted as "awesome".
So let's do a Dylan song, because we haven't anything of our own. Oh -- but "GLORIA!" -- that was written by Van morrison. What else is she known for, except being a suck up to the "Beatniks" who died out three generations before she was born.
If we have no imagination, then let's plunder someone else's past.
@@jnagarya519 well Her husband Sonic Fred Smith of the great rock band MC5 wasn't too shabby. Tho I will agree w u a bit on the surge of youngsters who are "woke", hip and cool that "dig" Patti...and "Hey man, have you read ginsberg, kerouac?" They make me wanna puke (is that too harsh? 😀)
Wonderful!!
Così bella che mi commuove. Tk's Patti.
Patti sings just like Dylan. Great version
The one and only Patti Smith. Love her
Top des Tops 'Patti' , rendarte piaz , un grand merçi pour cette chanson
great version
+Boris Martinez Without any doubt,Patti's awesome! Bob Dylan would also agree with us!
Brilliant!
Thank you Patti...❤️
Excellent ❤
Love it and love her she is a fantastic woman
Pam
No había escuchado esta versión. I love pati
what's all the self important fuss. this is a perfectly fine and interesting cover.
any cover u do, you do brilliant, not seen this, one before, my favorite is u2 and bruce, iconic
This song gained a life of its own. Few songs are able to do that.
a very good version
So excellent!!!!!
Fabulosa.
me too i love I ove rolling stones and you patty a lot......
Patti prevails 🎤🎸
Me encantoooooooooooooooooooooooooo
que version bravisimo
I love it!
wery fine version
💜 Sublime
Nice rendition...great mix...Greg Boardman Band...
Parts of the phasing effective -- like she was digging the knife in, skewering her enemy. A heartless thing to do,, but somehow you don't hate her or Dylan when they sing it. I'll save this version, thanks;
Patti Smith maravilhosa canta muito
This song is that great that it's impossible to do a bad version of it even if you should forget some of the lyrics
I love what'Lenny is singing here!
VIVA DILAN
THE GOD'S MUSIC
Y PATTY SU REINA
Comment on arrive à créer une chanson comme ça, elle est vraiment magique !
The Song was Born . . within working class , U S A . . .
and is woven into the Fabric . . of . . Today .
( world wide )
Like the guitar's metallic RED! Oh cool, only ten years ago>????? Very awesome.
as always She does Dylan Justice
Lindo isso . obrigado .
An excellent version from Patti of Dylan's angry classic...
quand j etais petit je t aimais deja Maman ma Nounou me disais ecoute maman et j aimais beaucoup ma Nounou je suis revenu au paye regarder les pierre qui roulent c etais beau tres beau enfin j etais chez moi et je sais je t aime merci Maman.
Great
No Secrets. Patti never let anyone get her kicks for her . Ever
This sounds better by Patti than anyone else who has done this other than Dylan
gonna get used to Her doing Dylan Justice Like a Rolling Stone
Nobody does Dylan better
Like a Rolling Stone She's the Direction Home
Awwwwwwesome ♥
かっこ良い！
かっこ良い！
かっこ良い！
Next to Dylan's version, Patties version is fantastic.
Io ti voglio tanto bene Patti... BRA/ITA
Nobody does Dylan better than Patti
A few flubs on the lyrics, but I can never have enough of this song....
Albeit being above half century old, I had never heard about Patti Smith until I watched this video... Given the extremely derogatory comments I read, I'll have to research a bit about her...
The Best
Vengo hoy decepcionado un 1ero de Enero del 2021.
Patti Smith
i especially like Patti's singing. the band plays the chords, very well but without any real sparks or roughness. maybe they should have had some extra female backing vocals in the chorus.
They also needed a lead guitar throwing some electric riffs out every so often.
rjkaneda - Supposedly nobody liked it but Dylan, but the delayed chording Al Kooper did on the organ is what makes Dylan’s studio version rock. It’s simple and primitive but it never sounded the same when Kooper left. Find a live version that doesn’t suck, and hang onto it. Patty’s versions are better than Dylan’s, but everybody’s live versions are better than Dylan’s. The man can’t do live performances unless he’s doing acoustic solos.
Nice cover, originally a Bob Dylan song.
No, REALLY? Snark!
I always thought it was a menudo's song...
Nobody sings this song like Bob Dylan. I feel something very essential is missing if he's not the one performing this song. But maybe that's just me.
What about Jimi Hendrix's great performance at Monterey?
I think they're too awed by the song to really do it justice. That's kind of OK, though; there's no doubt that Patti Smith and Lenny Kaye are, at some level, just plain old rock and roll fans. (Kaye put together Nuggets, after all.)
my kind of Gal...
Goood
Anybody who doesn’t like this needs a slap
Fuck you. Patti Smith is one of the biggest phonies and no-talents of all time. Want to dig this song? -- go to Dylan's original.
@@jnagarya519 im sorry for your brain damage
Patti and Bobby sittin a tree....
We don't need a Dylan-imitator -- petending to be talented -- doing Dylan. We have Dylan.
"Now you don't talk so loud . . . " That must have been wishful thinking on somebody's part. Adversity has done nothing to silence me. I bitch non-stop about scrounging for my next (decent) meal and about selling my plasma for Internet access. "How does it feel?" Feels okay. I'm alright.
Mutter. Vielleicht mit Rohranschluss. Kapselmaschine.
how does it feel?????????????????
Threw the rums a dime? 😁
Do the rope a bime ?
Trying to figure out whether I like it or not... I agree with Protestfolk here below but the Rock is here... mixed feelings
I listened, I kept an open mind, and I read all the posts. Finally, I have to agree with the guy who said it is rubbish. And if it''s not that, it's still pretty much at least pointless.
seems like she's singing lyrics in too loveless/non-emphatic a way ( especially "now you don't talk so loud" phrasing), in my view.
e um pouco catherine um pouco anelise
+Fernanda Duarte praticamente um esperma fecudou o ovolo meu coracao e teu ser
Wow even lenny can sing better than dylan
não e linda e deusa
if you're gonna cover Dylan? Especially the "greatest rock and roll song of all time"? Learn the words. Just an idea.
ElGato7000 Don’t play dumb. Like a Rolling Stone is a rock song. This is not a controversial or debatable question, it’s just a statement of fact.