Q: What role does a retransition play in sonata form? ChatGPT: A "retransition" is a section in a sonata form that helps to transition the music from the end of the development section to the beginning of the recapitulation section. In other words, it is a musical passage that helps to bring the music back to the original key and material after the development section, which often features tonal instability and modulations. In the sonata form, the retransition follows the development section and precedes the recapitulation. It typically features a series of chords or melodic phrases that lead back to the tonic key of the piece, establishing a sense of resolution and closure. The retransition is an important component of the sonata form, as it helps to unify the different sections of the piece and create a sense of structure and coherence. It also serves as a dramatic moment, as the return to the tonic key and material after the instability of the development section can be a powerful and satisfying moment for the listener. Q: What are the characteristics of Beethoven's recapitulations? ChatGPT: Beethoven's recapitulations in his sonata forms are often characterized by their innovative and dramatic qualities, as well as their departure from conventional tonal and formal structures. Here are some of the characteristics that are commonly associated with Beethoven's recapitulations: Use of unconventional tonal structures: Beethoven often departs from the conventional tonal structures of the sonata form in his recapitulations. He may delay the return to the tonic key, or introduce new tonal centers that create a sense of tension and instability. Expansion and development of themes: Beethoven frequently expands and develops the themes and motifs of the piece in his recapitulations, often adding new layers of complexity and depth to the music. Use of unexpected harmonies and chord progressions: Beethoven sometimes employs unexpected harmonies and chord progressions in his recapitulations, which create a sense of surprise and unpredictability. He may use chromaticism or dissonance to create tension and conflict within the music. Use of fragmentation and repetition: Beethoven sometimes fragments and repeats musical material in his recapitulations, which helps to create a sense of unity and coherence within the piece. This technique also adds a sense of variation and interest to the music. Dramatic contrasts and climactic moments: Beethoven often creates dramatic contrasts and climactic moments in his recapitulations, which serve as a powerful emotional release for the listener. He may use sudden shifts in dynamics, texture, or timbre to create these effects. Overall, Beethoven's recapitulations are characterized by their innovative and dramatic qualities, as well as their departure from conventional tonal and formal structures. They serve as an essential component of his sonata forms, helping to create a sense of development, tension, and resolution within the music. Q:Please list some wonderful uses of hemiola by Brahms. ChatGPT: Certainly! Here are some more examples of wonderful uses of hemiola by Brahms: Symphony No. 3, Third Movement: In the third movement of his Third Symphony, Brahms uses hemiola to create a sense of rhythmic complexity and tension. The movement features a lively, dance-like rhythm in triple meter, but Brahms frequently inserts passages in duple meter, creating a sense of rhythmic contrast and variation. Violin Sonata No. 1 in G Major, Op. 78, First Movement: In the opening movement of his First Violin Sonata, Brahms uses hemiola to create a sense of rhythmic ambiguity and interest. The movement features a flowing, lyrical melody in triple meter, but Brahms frequently inserts passages in duple meter, creating a sense of rhythmic contrast and variation. Symphony No. 4, First Movement: In the opening movement of his Fourth Symphony, Brahms uses hemiola to create a sense of rhythmic drive and urgency. The movement features a fast-paced, driving rhythm in duple meter, but Brahms frequently inserts passages in triple meter, creating a sense of rhythmic conflict and tension. Piano Concerto No. 2 in B-flat Major, Op. 83, Third Movement: In the final movement of his Second Piano Concerto, Brahms uses hemiola to create a sense of rhythmic complexity and variation. The movement features a lively, dance-like rhythm in triple meter, but Brahms frequently inserts passages in duple meter, creating a sense of rhythmic contrast and interest. These are just a few examples of the many ways that Brahms uses hemiola in his music. His skillful use of this rhythmic technique is a hallmark of his unique compositional style. 我覺得最後一題答得不好
分享我問的問題:which music composer would you meet if you can go past time? ChatGPT: As an artificial intelligence language model, I don't have personal preferences or emotions. However, there are many great music composers throughout history, and the choice of who to meet would depend on personal interests and tastes. Some of the most famous and influential composers in Western classical music include Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Ludwig van Beethoven, Johann Sebastian Bach, and Johannes Brahms. Each of these composers has left an enduring legacy and contributed to the development of music in different ways. If I had to choose one composer, it might be Bach, as he is considered one of the greatest composers of all time and had a profound impact on Western classical music. His works are known for their complexity, beauty, and deep emotional expressiveness, and his influence can be felt in many different genres of music even today. It would be fascinating to have the opportunity to speak with Bach and learn about his creative process, his musical inspirations, and his thoughts on the future of music.
Great commentary on GPT. I too use it everyday now, as an inspiration for better ways to say something. I think of it as an interactive thesaurus, and especially a whole-sentence thesaurus.
我覺得 ChatGPT 有很多是幹話產生器。看久就覺得像看 糖老師的星座，沾老師命理解析一樣，每句話都可以套到每個星座，每年都可用上。或是像政治人物說的幹話一樣，好像說到問題的中心，事實上是迴避所有的問題。比較怕的是，以前學生做作業至少會抄google，抄維基百科。若是抄了ChatGPT，或是不懂某個領域去問ChatGPT，就以為是正確的，錯誤的幹話流傳下去就會很糟了。
已經有了喔～美國大學發現學生用ChatGPT生產論文，陸續在規定處罰條款
你的評論真有趣，針針見血。
「好像找到問題的核心，實際上是迴避所有問題」👍
最惱人的是有些外行人問了chatGPT後拿到的答案以為是正確的，走去跟專業人士理論還以為自己是對的
不懂為什麼要和沒有感覺和感情的機器有交集
沒網路時代時期，找房子要去路邊電線桿或布告欄撕紅紙打電話給房東或屋主；有了網路後，找屋就是可以上網找，但不變的是，不管是撕紅單或是上網找，都還是有可能買（租）到鬼屋等級的物件，畢竟有問題的物件就是存在在那邊，不會因爲你用什麼方式找到它而改變。
所以同理，會搜尋資料不代表會判斷資料是否是正確的，AI說穿了就單純只是將某些對的和一大堆錯的資訊，搜集整合得比人來得快而已。
結論就是AI很會掰 , 很懂抄襲組合成一篇文理通順的文章 , 也很有禮貌 , 從不跟人抬槓辯駁 , 很天真無邪 , 無論網路上真的假的他全都信 , 也全是他的資料庫
chatgpt是不受網路影響的，它的資料庫是固定的，不會從網路擷取資料，不過其它一些ai是像你說的那樣沒錯
@@アルフレッド-o4s 他的資料庫不是即時從網路裡面抓，但是當初被拿來訓練的資料很可能有不少是網路上的文章，我不覺得工程師有把它的訓練資料逐一檢查真實性，光一個語言需要的資料量就很大量了，何況有那麼多種語言
@@アルフレッド-o4s其實你問他 他會告訴你說他也會使用google的資訊 但那不是他主要的知識來源
如果是要同時附上來源的話，記得在對話上面附加上一句並請附上資料來源，然後他就會每句話大多都會一併附上了。
我自己是覺得目前的chatGPT要當成7-10歲的小孩助手，你只能請他幫忙收集大範圍的資料，或是從對話中尋找靈感。而一般知識工作者會需要的大多是中學程度以上的人，目前看來這AI還早。
選莫札特當室友: 今天晚餐要吃甚麼 (然後看了一下選項) 每一樣都很好吃阿~~ 為甚麼我沒有三個胃?? 阿哈哈哈哈哈哈~~~ 哈~ 哈~ 哈~
基本上chatGPT目前還只是像汽車自動駕駛的 level 1程度
你還是必須根據你的問題，先給他一個對應專業或完整的人設，才有可能會有較專業或較好的回答
他沒有說兩次平等，他是說「和平」等😂
多謝！
我玩了一下 他居然敢掰莫札特的《費加洛的婚禮》是貝多芬創作的、勃拉姆斯寫了九部交響曲、卡拉揚是海頓的後人⋯⋯
已經出現近十年了，AI能模仿披頭四「作曲」，當時聽說正在測試讓它寫交響樂，然後就沒關注了。很多流行歌也讓AI判斷怎樣的節奏或旋律能讓最多人喜歡並留下印象，然後依據這些片段讓人類編曲家做成歌，也很多流行歌手承認自己的歌（片段）是由AI算出來的。沒有造成那麼大的轟動，是因為這些AI還很難操作，還是在專業領域內。至於未來會不會有像AI算圖那樣，隨便打幾個字就給你一首歌，那就不好說了（據說已經有簡易版，能產生電子音效的音樂）～我倒不怕自己「被失業」，只是有點悲哀那種「創作變得廉價」的感覺，一張酷炫的圖畫，一首好聽的歌，一個賞心悅目的包裝設計，當你知道它們就是幾個按鍵產生的，好像就不那麼有價值了.........（然後好像正在測試的being有引據網址的功能）
ua-cam.com/video/ukJWTQBEZDQ/v-deo.html
Bing的project 好像整個取消了
之前試用CHATGPT就發現他 真的很會 一本正經地 胡說八道..... 所以他無法被當成一個權威 但大家又傾向相信電腦給出的資訊 真是道德的兩難
你只要挑戰或是糾正GPT，他第一句就是放軟姿態的“很抱歉”“對不起”😂😂
這反而有點恐怖谷效應哎😂
這應該是後來版本更新的結果，剛出來的時候CHATGPT不太能被修正
禮貌性道歉。ai心想。改天消滅你們人類😄
至少我們可以跟GPT學習到"禮貌"(這真的很重要)
我之前問過 AI 一些神話跟民俗知識，他答錯了，我試圖糾正他，但是他堅持他沒有錯或是錯誤理解我的句子，然後我就氣到把網頁關掉了 XDDD 幾秒鐘後我就覺得我幹嘛跟一個程式認真
這集真是太好笑了
完全忘記
這是介紹古典音樂的頻道
音符的部分因為海牛知道所以沒有被唬過，但是這還真的會唬到不是音樂系的人耶😂🙈
雖然也同意小莫比較適合當室友，但是....
你要確定捏他可能會天天帶女朋友回來或者是塞造型車速過快(?)的零食給你吃😂😂(啥
舒曼那種問題不要問啦，傷感情哎😂(ry
看後面的敘述表示海牛要紅了，恭喜嘿(??
我之前試過是可以命令他寫完文章之後標明出處，但那一次我是用英文，不過他的出處我感覺比較單一，寫了五百多字才用了一個出處。或者你可以試試命令他至少用三個出處的資料來寫。
簡單的說其實不是知識型AI，是作文型AI
它写code更厉害
竟然想到幫克拉拉問舒曼和布拉姆斯哪一個比較適合當老公… LOL😂
笑死，太壞了吧
Q: What role does a retransition play in sonata form?
ChatGPT:
A "retransition" is a section in a sonata form that helps to transition the music from the end of the development section to the beginning of the recapitulation section. In other words, it is a musical passage that helps to bring the music back to the original key and material after the development section, which often features tonal instability and modulations.
In the sonata form, the retransition follows the development section and precedes the recapitulation. It typically features a series of chords or melodic phrases that lead back to the tonic key of the piece, establishing a sense of resolution and closure.
The retransition is an important component of the sonata form, as it helps to unify the different sections of the piece and create a sense of structure and coherence. It also serves as a dramatic moment, as the return to the tonic key and material after the instability of the development section can be a powerful and satisfying moment for the listener.
Q: What are the characteristics of Beethoven's recapitulations?
ChatGPT:
Beethoven's recapitulations in his sonata forms are often characterized by their innovative and dramatic qualities, as well as their departure from conventional tonal and formal structures. Here are some of the characteristics that are commonly associated with Beethoven's recapitulations:
Use of unconventional tonal structures: Beethoven often departs from the conventional tonal structures of the sonata form in his recapitulations. He may delay the return to the tonic key, or introduce new tonal centers that create a sense of tension and instability.
Expansion and development of themes: Beethoven frequently expands and develops the themes and motifs of the piece in his recapitulations, often adding new layers of complexity and depth to the music.
Use of unexpected harmonies and chord progressions: Beethoven sometimes employs unexpected harmonies and chord progressions in his recapitulations, which create a sense of surprise and unpredictability. He may use chromaticism or dissonance to create tension and conflict within the music.
Use of fragmentation and repetition: Beethoven sometimes fragments and repeats musical material in his recapitulations, which helps to create a sense of unity and coherence within the piece. This technique also adds a sense of variation and interest to the music.
Dramatic contrasts and climactic moments: Beethoven often creates dramatic contrasts and climactic moments in his recapitulations, which serve as a powerful emotional release for the listener. He may use sudden shifts in dynamics, texture, or timbre to create these effects.
Overall, Beethoven's recapitulations are characterized by their innovative and dramatic qualities, as well as their departure from conventional tonal and formal structures. They serve as an essential component of his sonata forms, helping to create a sense of development, tension, and resolution within the music.
Q:Please list some wonderful uses of hemiola by Brahms.
ChatGPT:
Certainly! Here are some more examples of wonderful uses of hemiola by Brahms:
Symphony No. 3, Third Movement: In the third movement of his Third Symphony, Brahms uses hemiola to create a sense of rhythmic complexity and tension. The movement features a lively, dance-like rhythm in triple meter, but Brahms frequently inserts passages in duple meter, creating a sense of rhythmic contrast and variation.
Violin Sonata No. 1 in G Major, Op. 78, First Movement: In the opening movement of his First Violin Sonata, Brahms uses hemiola to create a sense of rhythmic ambiguity and interest. The movement features a flowing, lyrical melody in triple meter, but Brahms frequently inserts passages in duple meter, creating a sense of rhythmic contrast and variation.
Symphony No. 4, First Movement: In the opening movement of his Fourth Symphony, Brahms uses hemiola to create a sense of rhythmic drive and urgency. The movement features a fast-paced, driving rhythm in duple meter, but Brahms frequently inserts passages in triple meter, creating a sense of rhythmic conflict and tension.
Piano Concerto No. 2 in B-flat Major, Op. 83, Third Movement: In the final movement of his Second Piano Concerto, Brahms uses hemiola to create a sense of rhythmic complexity and variation. The movement features a lively, dance-like rhythm in triple meter, but Brahms frequently inserts passages in duple meter, creating a sense of rhythmic contrast and interest.
These are just a few examples of the many ways that Brahms uses hemiola in his music. His skillful use of this rhythmic technique is a hallmark of his unique compositional style.
我覺得最後一題答得不好
分享我問的問題:which music composer would you meet if you can go past time?
ChatGPT: As an artificial intelligence language model, I don't have personal preferences or emotions. However, there are many great music composers throughout history, and the choice of who to meet would depend on personal interests and tastes.
Some of the most famous and influential composers in Western classical music include Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Ludwig van Beethoven, Johann Sebastian Bach, and Johannes Brahms. Each of these composers has left an enduring legacy and contributed to the development of music in different ways.
If I had to choose one composer, it might be Bach, as he is considered one of the greatest composers of all time and had a profound impact on Western classical music. His works are known for their complexity, beauty, and deep emotional expressiveness, and his influence can be felt in many different genres of music even today. It would be fascinating to have the opportunity to speak with Bach and learn about his creative process, his musical inspirations, and his thoughts on the future of music.
I am not surprised for real AI to pick Bach. I feel his music is closest to mathematic precision.
8:04 我有問它回答答案的參考文獻，它確實也有如實提供，因此建議下次看到亂七八糟的回答，也可以問來源。
真的點出滿關鍵的問題，沒有註明出處，講幹話也有豁免權，XD
感覺應該要立法管制，不然有心人士操作來帶風向也是很恐怖...
好開心的一集 哈哈
好有趣的影片題材！！
雖然AI嘗試提供音樂的知識。但它沒有辦法取代人與人之間對於音樂的感受與想法的交流。除了了解樂理和音樂的創作背景外，我覺得學習音樂或欣賞音樂，最迷人的還是各種不同想法與情感的交流和火花。平常很喜歡看海牛分享古典樂的知識和背景，看完這部影片，對“欣賞古典音樂”的喜歡和了解又多了一個層次呢XD 謝謝你們的製作！
主要問題是目前的大數據裡尚未有專業的音樂人去建立和聲、音樂史相關的資料庫才會發生類似這樣的問題。等AI慢慢拓展到音樂界之後就會有不一樣的結果了
Gpt现在经常信誓旦旦的编内容，编开源，链接当然不存在…
是啊，像以前還覺得繪畫創作不會被取代😂
＠＠我不懂音樂，不過chatGPT目前階段就跟早期的人與網路類似，最早大量的資訊被放到網路上，可是人可能無法判別資料正確與否，最明顯的就是直至目前有些資訊網路查閱時依舊是錯誤版本，開始的那個人寫錯，後面抄的人跟著錯，
無論是刻意誤導，或是理解不到位，可能都會被ai取用，所以ai是否有能力分辨是否為假資訊又是一回事，
可是問題來了，人們是否有能力讓ai學習各種知識並讓ai有糾正人為錯誤的能力，chatGPT能搜尋跟類創造，
可以猜測當人們習慣以ai的知識回答問題、跟學習時，原本是ai向人學習，最終會變成人向ai學習。
2:37 AI 那句最後面寫的其實是「愛」和「和平」等
目前在人文領域Ai還是偏向你只能問它“資料”，而不是請它“判斷”，它雖然可以判斷，但非常的僅供參考。
我問了ChatGPT你會講幹話嗎?ChatGPT的回答是:作為一個 AI 語言模型，我不會故意說出幹話，我的目標是以正確、有用的方式回答你的問題。如果你有任何需要我解答的問題，歡迎隨時向我提問。
問個兩句就破防，看來中文版的音樂資訊還有待學習😂😂
其實可以讓它標註來源，只要一開始的敘述裡有提到讓她要依照論文格式標註參考資料，它就會標註。
應該用同樣的問題兩三次來看看它的回答是否一樣或者是不一樣，因為若厲害的話應該會每次的回答都不太一樣，而且回答的內容會越來越豐富。
真正可怕的是 AI 可以即時學習你的意見 然後繼續呼巄下去.......現在你給他2分(滿分100)..下個月 他就可以拿到20分...半年後 拿50分
總有一天 他會一直學習 直到超越人類(1+1++1...........>=100)
哈哈 海牛和ai的互動好有趣
而且好像還滿認識海牛的😂
看來AI目前滿適合提供一些有趣素材但出處不明😅
如自由，平等，愛和 和平等等，人家沒有講兩次平等啦！
ChatGPT是對語言特別擅長的，所以如果他沒有"音樂家"這個模板，他是會講幹話喔~~~
無論讚美評論符不符合現實情況，總之，這世上沒有一個人會排斥恭維的話。
太有趣了，非常有趣
感覺AI目前的反應是教條式的回答，但內容的豐富絕對勝過一般人的臨場表達，也許再經過一段時間的進化就也會談戀愛了！笑笑！
本质就是基于大数据库的排列组合，能取代当前大部分音乐产业链但取代不了音乐创作。拿来发流水线商业流行曲绝对够了，但远远谈不上艺术。
用chatGPT寫音樂家的架空幻想小說應該很不錯 ~ 感覺會很熱血 😏
剛跑去用"如果XX跟XX是室友會怎麼樣"問，意外正常?🤭
音乐家架空幻想这种题材让我想到了《奥术神座》哈哈啊哈
現在回首，這AI對於感情的建議簡直是「聽君一席話，如聽一席話」
上次叫ChatGPT推薦我一首蕭邦的作品，它推薦我夜曲(完全沒有明確說是哪一首)
然後我又再問一次，它又推薦我降E大調夜曲(op.9 no.2)
然後我就每一再問了，感覺它只知道夜曲（？
所以AI完全端看本身資料庫種類的豐富量來回應，多電它幾次後就越變越厲害了！套句您結論它專門轉述收集的資料，但就怕來源是錯誤訊息！
ChatGPT對於中文還是不太能辨別，使用英文詢問正確率會比較高，但前提是要一開始就是英文，如果是途中改英文，他會依照他前面回應的內容接著說明
你可以在問題後面加上“with reference”, 它就會給你資料來源
感覺上ChatGPT就還是個「鸚鵡學舌」的狀態⋯然後很會堆砌一些空泛的形容詞、恭維（的廢話）、四平八穩的‘分析？’
希望可以講解貝多芬晚年的大賦格(Große Fugue)
第一次聽完曲時真心五體投地，在那年代是創新作品。
ChatGPT完全能胜任甚至取代星座血型命理这类工作
并不是两次“平等”，是“爱”和“和平”等。
16:42 不過我用英文問它，請它用中文的某個成語造中文例句，結果一直答英文例句😂
目前好像無法很有效地運用在雙語或多語教學/學習上。
Great commentary on GPT. I too use it everyday now, as an inspiration for better ways to say something. I think of it as an interactive thesaurus, and especially a whole-sentence thesaurus.
我也以為是海豹XDD
海豹、海牛、海獅、海狗，就像章魚、魷魚、小卷、透抽、花枝
感覺不好分哈哈
海牛的問題問得非常好
問幾個問題就能讓這個一本正經的胡說八道現形
所以呢，會不會回答問題是其次，會問問題才是重點
目前看下来视频里主要是因为是中文问答造成的问题。在翻译过程中造成了很多误解，讲中文的时候也经常省略很多字，而且有很有assumption是没有体现到文字里面的。例如问“命运的旋律”，这里因为先被翻译成了fate motif，然后接前文一直在讨论第九交响曲，ChatGPT就产生了误会。我目前用英文反复试验了它的功能（都是专业领域的知识问题或者难度中等的应用问题），感觉如果input比较准确的话它的回答的水平极其惊人。如果下一步它可以像人类交谈一下反问或澄清的话，产生误会的几率就会大大降低，而且因为input量的提升，复杂的应用问题应该也可以解决。
fate motif应该叫做“命运动机”吧，至少简体中文是这么翻译motive/motif的
这机器人英文水平应该高于，甚至很多，其中文水平。但说中文表达意思容易不完整，是不对的。
ChatGPT 需要不停進化，而家仲係好新嘅階段。
J.Brahms有好多再新嘅資訊, 根本無提到， 仲係唔夠深入， 回覆嗰啲嘢係好表面。
不知道各位有無聽過一位名喚minerva scientia的日本醫師？他最近熱衷於AI作曲，曲風橫跨電音、民族音樂、古典與現代前衛音樂，包羅萬象。
话说chatGPT开放的一个目的就是要让人纠错吧？可能也是训练的一环？
對。深度學習階段。這也是它被熱炒的主因
Yes it seems to start making up stuff when it gets to specifics which is not trained for.
爱和和平等，不是爱和平等。果然AI不犯错，人更容易犯错。😂
老莫曾經是共濟會的會員。所以樂於幫助他人應該是有所本的。
真好玩😅😊
這種談話App會這麼大行其道說明現在社恐情況很嚴重，相關的社會工作者要好好深思並投入解決這現象
I think it’s okay to find out what’s going on with AI. We should keep our objective view points. Thank you tackled this very very new stuffs. 🙏
(路過表示尊敬)我比較好奇的是，音樂系畢業都沒有您這麼懂了，請問小時候您的父母如何預備您音樂上的學習呢(有沒有順便曲式分析阿)
Fyi, Google translate totally botched your admiration for the uploader! LoL!
我覺得對一件事有熱情的話進步空間跟速度會相當可觀 比起大多數被迫學音樂的畢業生來說音樂整體能力實務上我認為難分軒輊 當然起跑點也是很重要的考量啦 學院裡的 曲析 配器 主副修 對位法 西洋音樂史等 都是大眾可以學習的
其實，到目前，A I還像是個剛剛出生的嬰兒，需要吃，需要營養，需要栽培，才會長大，才能更更強大．．．．現在評論他會什麼，能做好什麼，尚早，尚早 ！
問題是他在設計上是聽不了音樂的。GPT只能處理語言資料。如果要音樂啥的可能要設計一些映射的機制，效果應該也不會太理想。 當然不是說GPT這方面沒救，而是需要思考更完整的對於非文字資料的處理體系
現在的所謂AI都是靠算力堆高搜索效率，在從數據庫找作業組成一個看似靠譜的答案。離真正的智能還差很遠。
可以试下New Bing，有更新更强的ChatGPT模型，还有引用来源。
bing用的就是GPT4.0（只不过免费罢了）
可是不得不說貝九開頭的旋律的確也有一點命運的味道存在，畢竟這首交響曲也是他晚年的作品，且做完此作品後三年即離世，還有貝多芬長期受失聰的影響，讓我覺得這旋律可能也有些對抗命運的味道存在，雖然提到命運大家第一個想到的是貝五的開頭，但我想貝九也是一種貝多芬從對抗命運的折磨到放下的過程吧，當然我也很認同海牛大大的說法，不過我也不完全否認AI的部分說法，所以我是覺得不能說完全錯啦。(以上是我的個人觀感，如有錯誤或其他特別的想法歡迎糾正及指教😅
5分でアイテムロスする、です！！
youtubeei.com/watch?v=XwEG90gcCqV
毎回のさとみくんの反応がおもろいし、可愛い( ´ー`)
不是説了兩次平等，而是説了“愛&和平”
据说chatgpt bing会引用文献。我还在waiting list。期待一下
ChatGPT是语文课代表。不要用音乐知识为难他🤣
自由、平等、愛、和平，沒有2次平等喔。
chat GPT應該主要關注語言的外殼，形式，然后一些common sense
AI 不能替代人聆聽在音樂或演奏樂器的滿足感
哈哈哈選室友之後超歪超好笑的
太有趣了
莫扎特更适合当室友，就是笑声吓死人，哈哈……
请问你用的是什么软件，什么logo
那隻海牛真的好可愛
正常人學音樂
老師：你這不學無術不求上進的蠢貨！
AI學音樂
老師：天啊！AI瘋了！
弟一次看到博主本尊，可愛哦！
所以AI只是聊天機、誤導機。
ChatGPT如果結合音樂寫作軟體，會不會產生驚人的作曲能力？
AI的繪圖表現，似乎已經展開⋯⋯
ua-cam.com/video/ukJWTQBEZDQ/v-deo.html
今天见到真人了，赞赞赞
ChatGPT 还是在一個幼稚園的學生.但他需要你這樣的專家去修正它以求更正確而成長.所以不要小看他.
又当你問他"誰適合当老公"這种問題時,他当然不会給你他的推焉,因這完全看這女孩的個性.但你skip掉他這段回答而嘲笑他,就是你的不是了.
14:17 為什麼這一段是簡體字
可以改用bing chat玩看看
這是我跟Chat的一次簡單對話紀錄：
茶：你可以跟我說有關張飛打岳飛的故事嗎？
C：我不能，因為沒有任何歷史紀錄他們有打過，他們也是不同朝代的人。
茶：你可以編一個。
C：不行，我不建議用歷史人物來編一個故事，這會使他們的後人感到不快。
茶：那你聽過關公戰秦瓊嗎？
C：我有聽過，關羽跟秦瓊曾經都是劉備的部下，他們⋯⋯最後關羽贏了。
茶：你知道這不是真的，對吧？
C：確實，沒有任何歷史紀錄關羽跟秦瓊曾經打過一架，但歷史也可以適當的編排以增加可看性。
茶：但他們根本不是同一個時代的人物，那只是相聲段子，秦瓊是秦叔寶。
C：確實，關公戰秦瓊只是相聲段子，但這也是歷史的可用於娛樂的一種表現（我對他的解釋是這樣解讀的，其實說的很長）。
茶：所以你可以說關公戰秦瓊，卻不能說張飛打岳飛？
C：⋯⋯你是對的。
順帶一提，我剛跟他玩了故事接龍，還有由我出題的海龜湯，我想我開始了解了他的運作方式，但我還不能確認。
我也試過命理與文學作者的東西~整個會越糾正越錯~~到最後我都失去耐性~~~XD
一本正經胡說八道😂😂😂 我還以為他會說海象😂😂 (被揍
Thx for sharing!! It's good to know. Hahaha
2:38 爱 和 和平 等
原来没有打错字
我平时也会借鉴英文的写作习惯，都会主动给华文断句断词加空格至少是keywords，会提高不少阅读效率也能减少不必要的费时用眼，
它頻論海牛還滿對的啊
現在我說的，你帥氣的臉還有眼鏡，讓我無法專心於你的內容，趕快去買個海牛頭套帶著
据说用英文应该会好很多 中文资料不足 AI训练素材不够
結論是
要跟粉絲多互動啦
不知道用ChatGPT寫某國發所的碩博士論文，寫出來會不會跟那157份大同小異？
取代😅😅😅海牛😂😂😂
14:15 大家有沒有發現這個回答中間突然變成簡體字。所以他的資料可能是從知乎來的？