TEST: How much noise? Acoustic silent and digital pianos action/key/hammer noise issues - NO TALKING
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 сер 2024
- What are the pianos and digitals with noise action? Or else, what are the quieter digital and acoustic pianos?
Test of only action noise in acoustic silent and some DP (list below)
I hope that this my work is useful, then i was looking for a similar video i don't foundd anithing, then when i had the chance of try various pianos, I did it by myself
01:00 Yamaha U3 SH2
01:16 Yamaha C1x SH2
01:32 Seiler 122
01:42 Kawai K500
02:09 Kawai CA 99
02:20 Kawai novus NV10
02:36 Yamaha N1x
02:49 Kawai Novus NV5
03:01 Yamaha CLP 685
03:12 Roland GP 609
03:24 Kawai CA 98
03:35 Roland LX7
03:44 Roland LX 706 CH
03:55 Yamaha CLP 685 B
04:05 Yamaha N1x
04:18 Bluthner e-Klavier 1
04:27 Bluthner e-Klavier 3
#pianokeyboard #pianokeynoise
#pianist #piano #kawaii #top #technology #yamaha
Acoustic:
Yamaha U3 SH2, Yamaha C1x SH2 (C2x and C3x, same noise), Seiler 122 silent, Kawai K500 Aures
Digital or Hybrid:
Kawai CA99, Kawai NV10, Yamaha N1x, Kawai NV 5, Yamaha CLP 685, Roland GP 609, Kawai CA98, Roland LX 7, Roland LX 706, Yamaha N1x, Bluthner E-Klavier 1 and 3
Music made by Giko Gomez Pianist - / gikogomez
Composer of the background music
Please subscribe!
Yayd is the owner of this video
This clip is providing a very informative details most people did not aware. It gave me a confirmation that digital piano are quieter in general, and especially when they are new.
Even when they are aged, the key noise are not much worse than acoustic piano.
Thank you!
Thanks too, if u can share this video for help your friend, pls do it
Thanks for the video. I'm amazed by Kawai's, they're really quiet throughout the range. I have a few years old Kawai CN34, and my mother is disturbed by the key sound watching TV as both our piano and the TV is in the living room :) So, key noise is so important! I'm impressed by the new Kawai's, as I'm considering upgrading to CA79 or CA99.
Have you already upgraded you CA79? How about the CA99? Are you happy?
This is very informative! I rencently bought a KAWAI CN29 as a beginner. And I was shocked by that key noise and thought something went wrong. Thank you!
Im happy to help you!
@Darth Sidious The key sound from most digital pianos is massive compared to the key sounds from my organ and synthesizer. The manufacturers need to find a more quiet way to make weighted key mechanisms. Plastic versus wood is not the main problem. Acoustic pianos are quite noisy too.
Excellent. I always look for this info on you tube reviews, None seem to cover it. well done and thanks. The Rowland models seemed quietest to in your test. I am more interested in arranger keyboards, but this at least says that, even top end pianos have significant noise. Im sure all could be much quieter if manufacturers focussed on it instead if trying to make keyboards sound and feel the same as the traditional action on real pianos, with their old fashioned clunking noises. Theres Nothing worse than watching somebody clunking away on a modern keyboard in their headphones.
The same here, I have search for long time something similar, and I didnt found anything. Then, i decided to make it by myself! And i agree with your impression. In a silent piano, or in a digital with Real piano action, the noise is annoying for who, in the same room, is doing anything else. Something i read that also neighboor can hear the toc toc.
To all potential purchasers of any digital piano, over time the noise will become more audible, cheaper entry level keyboards are the worst, look for a digital piano with solid wooden keys, as being featured in this experiment
I agree
Thanks. Just had my new Kawai CA 701 today and thought it was faulty hearing the thudding keys as I've only ever played a synth 😊
Great!!!! Enjoy your new piano!!!
This is pretty useful. Thanks
Thank you so much, I could not find the Roland PH 50 noise anywhere and I can see now that it is really quiet
generally, roland are quiet pianos
This is so precious! Thanks a lot!
Thank you too for apreciate
Very nice video. There is a real sound difference between the digital non-hybrid pianos (sounds more.. plastic) and the rest. The Kawai and Yamaha hybrids sound very much like the silent pianos which I find a nice sound. Also the keys don't make a sound when released which happens with cheaper digital pianos like my old Hemingway piano which is quite annoying for other people in the room if you play with headphones. I ordered a NU1X three weeks ago, can't wait.
Yes also me i owned an clavinova CPL760 (i try to remember the model) that the top of the noise was not when i push the key, but when i released it! This is a very annoying issue because i think it is more resolvible than the noise on pushing
This actually makes for some good asmr lol
Very interesting! I live alone but recently the guy from the flat downstairs rings at my door at midnight.
The noise of my Yamaha P45 , played with headphone, was too strong for him!
Some neighboor complain even if hear a fly
@@YAYDChannel 😁
bless you! I thought I bought a bad digital piano but it's all good🤣
happy to hear it! what is your digital?
I also consoled myself that the keyboard is so knocking on all digital pianos, but I could not get used to the knocking, on a quiet sound it is just terrible. I passed my own piano (I decided to save money and buy a Chinese NUX WK-310, I was satisfied with the reviews), I will go to the store to try other ones. I'll look at the Roland FP-30X, maybe it's quieter. The sound of keys on my disk.yandex.by/client/published?idApp=client&dialog=slider&idDialog=%2Fdisk%2f sound%20klavish%20WK-310.3 gp
@@user-ch6gm2st2d i don't know that chinese piano, but sure i will go to hear it soon. I always say to anyone ask me an advice, to try also the piano with the power off
@@user-ch6gm2st2d sometime is bettrr hear a music bad played than the knock
@@YAYDChannel I'm looking at a Kurzweil piano (Kurzweil KA120, Kurzweil M70R, KURZWEIL MPS110). In the video ua-cam.com/video/5v1QQB21QeE/v-deo.html the FATAR keys look pretty quiet.
thank you so much.
Anyone has the key sound of a c bechstein a124 with vario..?
4:20
Something’s not right with this Bluthner e-klavier 1.
There seems missing dust felt stripe at the end of keys.
It’s there on the Bluthner e-klavier 3 right after this, in black color.
Yes, my thought was the same
Thanks for the video. Very informative... not easy to find this kind of reviews on pianos. Question: is there a way to eliminate (or at least reduce) this annoying thumping sound? I have a digital piano Yamaha P115, and when I play with the headphones on, the thump sound is heard downstairs from my neighbors. I don't want that. Maybe adding some think layer of soft material inside the key pockets0. I believe those are the source of the noise when hitting the plastic elements from the bottom case. Let me know what do you think about. Thanks!
Unfortunately, i am not a tech. I cannot suggest you to open your DP. Try to put a double carpet under the piano, first!
@@YAYDChannel Thank you, will do :)
@@alessandrosalaris6228 let me know if it work!!
What differences in feel did you notice between the CA98 and the CA99?
I see some unreplied comments sorry to all. The 2 pianos is same, but now you surely have bought one of them :)) But if your question is about sound, of course the 99 is superior
Which digital/hybrid piano is the quietest (not necessarily a model from your video)? Is there anything more silent than Kawai NV5S (with the same feel of wooden keys)? Thanks!
I think that Kawai is the most silent but not the ones with the same feel of wooden keys... We cannot have all... if you want a DP with the feel and real hammers well, iit will be more noising than a traditional DP, but surely less than an acoustic silent
The Kawai K500 was very silent to my ears. How did you perceive it in person?
I confirm, one of most silent acoustic pianos!
Yes, with a price of $ 11,000! Is it really so difficult for manufacturers to make normal inexpensive silent keys? People modify their pianos by adding lubricants or gluing additional material to reduce noise, but for some reason the manufacturers do not want to do this.
which was heavier between CA99 and CA98
same, sorry for late reply
Is it just my imagination or does the CA99 action sound a lot louder than the CA98 action?
Consider that all pianos was recordered at the same conditions. No normalization, no effects, no compression. If the difference is little, maybe I was not at the same distance between pianos, even if is matter of 3-4 centimeters of difference. If is big, then one is more loud.
It's hard to tell, since it's also affected by what you were playing and how hard you were pressing the keys. But the GrandFeel3 action in the CA99 does have "firmer" padding under the keys than the GrandFeel2 in the CA98, so it's possible there is a real difference in key noise. CA99 still seems quieter than a lot of the others...
@@droazen yes i confirm, with my ears, i felt CA99 very silent
When choosing an acoustic silent, havo to consider another thing, that someone - me included - don't think. While the upright acoustic have wires well hidden behind it, the grandpiano have wires well visible from the middle of the room to the plug.
This shows how higher quality digital pianos have less of the clicking problem than the sub 2k pianos. Welp..😭..life savings here I come. Time to buy an 8,000$ digital piano 🎹
oh i miss your comment, sorry very much! i disagree, the noise of keys NOT ALWAYS is related to the cost. Maybe mostrly of times, but not always
There is something wrong with that C1X, no silent piano should sound like that. Someone else who heard it thought the stop rail might be mis-positioned. I've played a silent C3X and is sounded nothing like that.
Thank you for your response, in that shop there was 1, 2, 3 , all silent and all the same noise. That i can say is that depends from phone mic quality. Don't concentrate on the quality of the noise, but on who make more. Phone is the same for all pianos, and as u see, also the distance. And finally, sorry for my english
I agree. C1X does sound "wrong."
Hi Chris! Just on a different note. How much does the silent feature effect the action in you C3X? I mean even if you play acoustic the let of is worse I have been told. Just curious if this is a dealbreaker for me when shopping for a new piano. :)
Ah der reisinger in wien. Hier in graz ist es echt übel mit klaviergeschäften... würde fast mal nach wien fahren für ne gscheite auswahl!!
Really, i want visit Graz and its piano shops.... yes Resigner is a good shop but i preffer Gasometer Klangfarbe. Talking about acoustic, surely Resigrer, Stingl and Forstl (sorry for late reply)
So, key noise on pianos are normal thing?
You mean acoustic? Yes is normal because of the hammer action. Maybe if the lid is closed the noise is less, but in the showroom i cannot do all i want...
what are acoustic silent pianos?
You dont know silent pianos?
Eine Güte, die Yamaha Tastaturen sind ja Hölle laut🥺😖
Yes I owned an yamaha piano that was really noising I think that when i play on headphones, the neighboor can listen the key noise