Hello everyone. I'm Dilay. Thank you for watching the video and for your beautiful comments. Even reading the comments brings tears to my eyes. I just wanted to make a correction. I see that one of the information I gave in the video is incorrect. Rm and Suga wrote this song about friendship and lost friends. These theories apply to the MV of the song and as we know Bts has never confirmed these theories. I also see that there are some governmental problems related to this issue, but I will not go into detail here, because many Army have made very good and detailed explanations in the comments. In the end, no matter what, this beautiful song gives many people the strength to move on and remember their loved ones. That's why it's so valuable. Thank you again and condolences to those who have lost loved ones. 🙏🎗
I can’t tell you how much I enjoy your reactions…you are not fake and your courteousness is not something you see in humanity and for sure don’t see on social media….regarding this video I THINK they said BTS was the first to respond as far as Kpop groups go….they have to be very careful as they would get in trouble if they said anything about the government but BTS is very clever…not only in this video but also their other videos they are famously known for leaving clues in their videos we call Easter eggs and it depends on how far into the rabbit hole you are as to if you can spot what they are telling us…I’m always excited for the next video…I will be a subscriber for life💜💜💜💜
Merhaba Dilay bilirsin biz Armyler biraz çok heyecanlıyız bilgilerimizi aktarmak isteriz bazende idaliyizdir eğer seni üzdüysem(k) özür dilerim.Kendi adıma . Aslında hepimiz şunu aklımıza getirmemiz lazım biz nasıl başladık bizide yönlendiren kimse olmadı. Neden sizi bırakmıyoruz bu sizin yolculuğunuz ve siz sadece bu yolculukta seyirciyiz arada yol tarifi istiyorsunuz. Belki arada çıkmaz yanlış sokağa girsenizde sorarak okuyorak seyrederek yollunuzu bulacaksınız buna eminim.. daha ben İlkim ve Çağından Army şarkisi ve tabiki Spring Day performansı. Üçünüzü morluyorum sevgiyle kalın BTS le Kalın 💜
Thanx for this clarification. I thought I was losing my memory 🙃. Just wanted to let you know that I really love your reactions. Also I thought you might be interested in a programme that explains the BTS phenomenon (it's about an hour long) that's done by a South Korean lecturer who's an ARMY. I'm providing the link below and I hope you'll find it as informative as I did. There's also a segment about 'Spring Day' and what one ARMY did. It's truly very touching. I also hope you can react to it, if it's not too much 🙂 ua-cam.com/video/Uaj1X76h2mQ/v-deo.html
@@angie7777-7 *Italian* *Army* has the better explanation vid "what you still don't know about BTS spring day". I don't think Idols made any music about it. But Korean musicians - especially rappers - did already back in 2014. "Spring Day" is from 2017. Nevermind that the song was written about missing/loosing friends. I think that was about the time Namjoon (RM) called old friends who told him that they did not dare call him first because he was famous now and it would look bad if they did. So he vowed to call them more often himself. With Yoongi (Suga) I'm less sure about the timeline because I do not know when this happened or if at all: A friend of his got into drugs and that is an absolut no-no in the Korean entertainment scene and Yoongi may have broken the firendship over it. Mind you the song is an embodiment of the Korean emotion of "Han" and I see the stages of grief in it. MV and choreo are definetly about the desaster. And it is known how and why the ship sank. There are a at least one documentary about it and I think the articles on wikipedia have it, too. Italian Army also explains a bit. I think this vid overexplaines some small details - maybe even missexplains while overlooking other stuff - which is why some people dismiss it as "theory".
If you watch the Italian explanation, you’ll cry even more. There are real life scenes from that day if the parents waiting for someone to rescue their children… heartbreaking 💔
It needs to be seen to grasp the full blown murder of innocent children…but in light of recent years I’m realizing no one’s government is above corruption …it can happen anywhere and the average citizen is helpless
Little brother your tears are so precious and are a wonderful tribute to the lost and to BTS! They live on in our remembrance! Thank you for your precious gift!
Never ever apologise for crying, especially at Spring Day. I have heard it, and watched the MV dozens if times and always weep. It remains in the Korean charts ever since, and in Korea is known as 'the Queen'. The ferry sinking was worse than a tragedy, since it was avoidable from the start (caused by illegally overloading containers on deck) and ALL the loss of life was also avoidable ... they literally had hours to evacuate and not only did nothing but prevented others from rescuing passengers. Its incredible. The song was written about simply missing a close friend, but it's generally accepted that the MV is about the Sewol disaster. It is a masterpiece.
Thank you for talking about how the song still remains on the charts in South Korea... I think it is awe-inspiring and heartwarming to know people have continued to remember all that this song and video encompasses. Also, Dilay... You are an amazing ARMY... thank you for sharing this and the other music/videos/information with others. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Two days ago, I went to the Sewol Ferry memorial site on Jeju Island with my family. Ten years later, my daughter is now a second year in high school like them. The parents of the children who could not arrive in Jeju brought their children's photos to Jeju Island on their behalf. . Even after ten years, we must not forget it and monitor and change it so that a tragedy like this never happens anywhere again. In particular, we need to speak out to prevent accidents that are unreasonable or caused by man-made disasters.
Músicos que hablaron y/cantaron sobre el tema fueron hostigados al igual que reporteros honestos. BTS es una metáfora profunda habla del tema sin hablar y eso caló más profundo todavía. La canción desde su estreno no ha abandonado los rankings e incluso en Japón siempre está en tendencia obteniendo a fines de marzo el certificado de platino por llegar a 100 millones de reproducciones. La canción volvió a ser tendencia mundial cuando BTS comenzó a enlistarse.
💜🙏Thank you for sharing your heartfelt reaction to Spring Day.... i don't know if you can translate into Turkish but.... I want to share with you a comment to another reactor from a survivor of the Sewol disaster.. I would like you to hear from him just how BTS has healed him through this song and the messages they have: His name is Chilo Abellon - and this is his public comment in full - unedited - from 3 years ago.......... "I remembered when they rescuing us its so tragic when you see your classmates/friends stuck asking and hearing them scream for help, the screaming and voices of people asking for help while the ships is sinking the scream slowly vanished. When you can’t help them because the water got deeper and deeper while they rescue us slowly. The time that i got rescued only 3 of us survived, my two classmates and i in our and my other classmates stuck in the ships hoping they’re still alive but when the time i heard the news that they’re all gone. It slowly sinking in that all my friends and the other class are gone and will never comeback. I feel guilty when I survived, I’m thinking am i lucky? Or is it not right that i was alive and not them? Do i deserve to live?. Feeling depressed, having su!cidal thoughts, every night you can’t sleep because i keep hearing those scream a scream people needing a help but you can’t because your weak and got broken bones. Everything time I struggled to see what life is all about, thinking what if all of my friends survived and they with me survived. It would be dream to see that happening. I struggled to make a good life that i can be proud of because of that incident happened but when i found out about BTS my life changed me because of their music they changed my life the way that i can be proud of and I started loving myself by little by little and finally the day I realize life is so short and the incident happened 7years ago impacted my life to be a better person and all of our hardships are just a big task for us to make them done and the outcome will be 100times better the incident happened 7years ago thought me so many things. The biggest one is don’t forget they might be gone but don’t forget them put them on your heart and like life all of your hardship and your mistakes will not lose or fail you it’s always a win win situation because we always learn from them. Spring day is my number 1 fav song of BTS because I reminisce the things happened 7years ago while watching the mv and it always help me to keep going in life and do not give up on things that i want to achieve - My name is Chilo one of the survivors of the sewol ferry incident." I truly hope he does not mind me passing on his public comment - but this best shows the power of BTS message. The worst thing about the disaster - the captain and most of the crew fled the ship in the morning 9.35 - the ferry did not sink until the night - they left the warning to "not move and stay still" playing on a loop through the ship. Only the children that disobeyed the warning survived. The others drowned as they were so ingrained to listen to authority. The civilian boats that attempted to rescue people were stopped by the coast guard as people would discover the boat was illegally overloaded. Parents on the shore were receiving desperate calls and texts from their children begging for help. And the coastguard did nothing. The only rescue the coastguard made that day was the captain and crew... The people that got rescued were rescued by fishing vessels that got there first before they were stopped... 3 years the ferry lay at the bottom as the Govt would not raise it for fear of discovering the truth.... They found video footage taken on mobile phones that were recovered of children wishing their families goodbye. 3 crew members stayed behind to try and help the children, they all lost their lives, along with one of the rescue divers. Also, one of the civilian rescue divers later committed su!cide after having to recover so many childrens bodies, knowing that he could have saved them but was forcibly stopped. As a parent, I could not comprehend having to live through such a thing. Horrific that your own government would perpetrate and then cover up such an incident... jailing dissenters for protesting. It was proven that there were high officials with financial interests in the ferry. The president colluded with them to bury the truth and hamper investigations... 10000 people in the public eye (reporters, artists, etc) put on a Govt blacklist for speaking about it. BTS went and paid respects to the parents of the victims in 2014 when the tragedy occurred. No Cameras - No fanfair - just doing what was right...They also donated approx $100,000 (that year they only earnt $300,000 - they gave 1/3 of their earnings) to help the parents in their fight for justice.... We only found out about the donation years later as one of the parents was sick of all the hatred BTS was always getting and wanted others to know what decent and good people they are. The MV, The album cover, The choreography all relate back to the Sewol. But the song itself is about missing anyone you love and are separated from. They were singing Spring Day during the panademic as the world was longing for a spring day. Spring Day has never left the music charts. To this day, it is right that this song is still in the top 100 charts.... 7 years later, as this song still speaks to people everywhere. Sorry this is so long - but I really wanted to pass his comment and information to you relating to your Spring Day reaction video.... with posting your reaction you have helped keep the memory of Sewol alive and maybe others who do not know of it will learn of the tragedy. Thank you for sharing your journey, and helping to spread BTS message... Sending greetings and love from Australia.... BORAHAE💜 #WeNeverWalkAlone
Given the scandal that followed this tragedy revealing the corruption of many civil servants...the government tried to cover up the affair but faced with the tenacity of the victims' parents, all of Korea "rose up" Make a song on this tragedy was important for BTS who stood in solidarity with the families. RM and the boys were very young and did not hesitate to produce this magnificent tribute to the victims...we can emphasize the fact that Big Hit did not oppose this decision despite the risk of being perceived as an attack by the government....One more proof of the commitment of the boys to defend their ideas of social justice....This song did not have a commercial aim but rather to help the parents of the victims who also made it their anthem. ..Thank you for your very sincere reaction...You were already admiring of BTS...now you will perhaps understand better why there are millions of us who love them and above all respect them.Thank you
The Sewol sank in 2014. Spring Day dropped in 2017. 3 years later. The song was about a loss of friendship and "only" MV and choreo are about the desaster. I don't think they were on any lists. As far as I can tell they may be the only Idols that used the theme but plenty of other Korean musicians did, too. K-Army has put the song on their playlists when they stream new BTS songs. Details I don't know.
her dinlediğimde nefes almakta zorlanıyorum gerçekten. Feribotun batmak üzere olduğunu anlayınca bazı öğrenciler ailelerine mesaj atıp yardım istediler ve veda ettiler diye biliyorum. BTS gerçekten bir müzik grubundan daha fazlası bu şarkıda onların ne kadar güzel insanlar olduğunun ve gençlere ne kadar güzel örnek oldğunu kanıtlıyor.
Don't apologize for crying, for getting emotional. I cry every time I hear this song. Crying just says we have feelings and that's what makes us human.🇧🇷💜
Este 16 de abril se cumplirán 10 años de la lamentable tragedia, BTS con esta canción en base a símbolos nos hizo entender el sufrimiento tanto de los que ya no están como el de sus familiares y amigos, esta canción se ha transformado en un himno en Corea de Sur, un abrazo a ustedes y no lamenten llorar porque eso demuestra que la sensibilidad es lo escencial de la gente buena, hay muchas canciones de BTS que tienen una explicación, no solo es letra, musica, baile y canto, hay símbolos en todas ellas, por eso mucha gente de diferentes edades, países y culturas, quieren a estos chicos, yo tengo 60 años, soy de Chile de América del Sur y espero que estos chicos siempre estén bien, tengo a mi favorito es uno de los menores para mí el es Bebé Angel, saludos sigan adelante con sus reacciones están muy bien
fakat bir sorun vardır, öğrencilere yerlerinden ayrılmamaları söylenmiştir ve bu kadar can kaybının olmasının nedenlerinden biri de budur. ayrıca kaptan da feribotu, battığını anladığı ilk anlarda terk etmiştir. geriye öğrencilerin kıyafetleri, birer çift ayakkabıları kalır, gözü yaşlı aileleriyle birlikte. nuri bilge ceylan demiş ya hani ''birisi ölür üzülmezsiniz, sonra sandalyeye asılı hırkasını görürsünüz, o hırkanın duruşu kalbinize oturur'' diye, işte o ayakkabı koca bir ülkenin yüreğine dokunur.
The ferry started to sink in the morning and finally submerged that night. Whenever I think about the kids and the helpless parents watching the boat take their children, ever so slowly, fills me with rage and sadness
I think it was a bit faster than this. I remember a clip of the air gushing out from the balloon they tried to put into the ship to stop the farther sinking and it was still light. Mind you they had to already dive to try that - unfortunately a civilian diver that was forced to help them had pointed out that their equipment was unlikely to work right - his did I think - and as predicted the diver had to be recalled very soon. There is at least one documentary out there about it. I stopped watching somewhen in the middle because the footage was too much and they included all the messages that went over the chain of command explaining why everything was so slow and done so badly.
You didn't cried alone, this was a very emotional reaction and we appreciate that you watched the video. BTS goes beyond the stage and that's also why so many people loves them. Spring Day is so special for people in Korea. I remember the tragedy, watching the news and holding my 2 year old baby and thinking about those kids and their parents, it always brings me to tears but I like to watch reactions about it because I think it makes people realise the impact of the tragedy and BTS's big heart. Hold your kids or the people you love, tell them you love them everyday. Borahae 💜💜💜!
Please don't apologize for crying or not crying. We all express our emotions differently. I always cry when watching this video. Although the song was actually written in reference to a friendship when they did the music video it was done as a story about the Sewol Ferry incident and a tribute to those who lost their lives. The explanation video you watched is very good and the Italian one that people below mentioned is a little more in depth, very good and very emotional. I like your reaction videos very much and appreciate all your comments and observations. Thank you.
At first, they couldn't say it was about the tragedy, but after the condemnations, all the theories were confirmed. I cried like you, Dilay and Çagim, after watching the Italian Army explanation (more visual, sadder), I cried for a good time, sobbing. A stupid tragedy like that breaks any heart. Thanks for the reaction, I'm sorry if it was too sad, but, as always, BTS transformed bad experiences in art, a healing art. This song is called The Queen because it's always on top of the Korean charts.
The video made by an Italian army is also very good to watch because it is more detailed and has a lot of real videos of what really happened during that time.
I love your reactions. I don't know Turkish but it is a very beautiful language. I do enjoy learning new languages, and Turkish has now definitely been added to my constantly growing list of languages that I want to learn
And I absolutely loved this reaction. I was crying right along with you all. Although I've heard that song and seen the description vid. I still cry every time I hear that song. I'm a mother of 3 and just the thought of losing one of my babies is too much for me. So my thoughts and condolences are forever with those survivors as well as those who lost someone
I cried with you guys, sometimes this world feels so unfair, this reminds me of what’s happening in Gaza right now and how many lives were lost, this is the reason why I love bts they’re not just artists they feel like a family to us.
Spring day benim BTS'in en sevdiğim şarkısıdır. Büyük bir merakla bekledim bu videoyu ve izledim. Tepkileri gerçekten çok samimiydi. Çağın'ın ağlaması İlkim'in betimlemeleri çok içtendi. Kanalınızdaki tüm videoları izledim ve favori reaction videom kesinlikle bu diyebilirim. Aklımdan geçen tek şey bu şarkının reaction videosu olsa olsa bu olurdu. Böyle tepkiler verilebilirdi. Ayrıca Dilay'ın türkçe altyazı bulamayıp kendi eliyle emek verip çevirmesi çok güzel. Mvyi türkçe altyazılı izleyip ve dinleyip daha sonrasında hikayesini öğrenmeleri... Her şey harikaydı. Keşke 1 kere değilde daha çok like atabilseydim dedim 😅 tepkileriniz ve emekleriniz için teşekkür ederim ❤
bu şarkı gerçekten çok anlamlı, üstüne üstlük kore gibi baskıcı bir ülkede böyle bir şarkı yayınlayıp hükümeti de yapılanlar için eleştirmek herkesin yapabileceği bir şey değil. bts bu şarkıyı çıkarttığında 4. yıllarındalardı ve git gide daha da zirveye çıktıkları bir dönemdi. tüm bunları göze alarak şarkıyı yayınladılar. ayrıca yanlış hatırlamıyorsam bts yeni çıkış yaptıkları zaman bu olayla ilgili bir bağış kampanyasında(?) adları geçiyordu. bu yüzünden hükümet tarafından banlandılar gibi olaylar da olmuştu. yanlış hatırlıyor olabilirim eğer yanlışsam bu konuda beni düzeltin. kısacası, gerçekten bu şarkıyı yayınlamaları kesinlikle çok özel ve çok önemli. tepki verdiğiniz için de teşekkürler, çağın’ın ağlamaya başladığı yerde ben daha fazla duygulandım…
ve info geçeyim, şarkı hâlâ kore listelerinde yüksek sıralarda ve birçok rekora imza attı. en uzun süre melon ilk 100 listesinde kalan şarkı, melon platformunda en çok dinlenen şarkı gibi birçok rekoru var. bts her yeni şarkı çıkarttığında spring day mutlaka listelere girip kendi şarkılarıyla yarışır o derece
Daha çok live performance istiyoruz çünkü bts’in canlı performansları mükemmel yaa çok yaratıcı -Magic shop mesala var -MMA 2020 çok iyidi performanslar özelikle Dynamite ve yaptıkları dance break ağzım açık kaldı resmen…. -Film out var Japonca olan şarkılarından biri sesleri canlı çok iyi ✨🤩 -MMA2018 var oda çok iyi -PTD LA Black swan ve blue and gray performansı mükemmeldi ardındanda blood sweat and tears şarkısından bir küçük parça söylediler sonra hemen Fake love şarkısına girdiler 🔥 -Your eyes tell şarkısı canlı yayında var sesleri ayrı bir dünyaya götürür sizi -ON kinetik manifesto müzik videosu var ağzınız açık kalacak dansları çok iyi kamera açıları çok iyi -permission to dance var bakınca çok mutlu hissedersiniz kendinizi çok pozitif çok enerji dolu bir şarkı -butter grammy award show performansı resmen herkesi çıldırtı yaa kesin izlemelisiniz -proof live 2022 bir çok şarkı söylediler canlı -dear class 2020 var Ohhooo daha neler var neler 😂😂 * 💜umarım her izlediğiniz müzik video ile canlı yayınıda izlersiniz daha çok eğlenceli ve daha çok fark eder
Hi, FIRST ERA Reactors! 💜 Was carried by the manner you reacted to this video/ song/ Sewol ferry tragedy. My heart broke with you all. That is BTS, that is how i know them, how they wrote their songs…always meaningful. The lyrics are beautiful and the music/ melodies as well. When the song is sad it will truly, surely touch our hearts. Happy to see your true emotions…i could tell it watching you guys. We’re the same, i couldn’t control myself, too. Loved ones are loved ones, won’t be forgotten through the rest of our lives. Thank you for this, for your beautiful hearts. You are what you are beautiful outside and inside. BE MORE BLESSED. 💞❤️💜🥰
Oh no please keep doing the “bogoshipda” singing. Although this song is associated with this tragedy, I think it’s also taken on several meanings, both personal (for any listener) or BTS related. During the pandemic it’s a song that expressed the longing to see each other again, BTS and ARMY, and that Spring will come. They also sang this during their last concerts before enlistment and so again it’s a hopeful song that we will see each other again. I’ve come to cherish this bittersweet song and I hope the sweetness of it will surface more instead of the bitter for you soon. I always enjoy your reaction, thank you.
Beautiful reaction, I cried with you all :P I've seen this many times but still cry. BTS donated to the families of the victims back then, even though their company and themselves hadn't made any money from music yet. The government tried to really cover this event up and artists talking about it would get blacklisted. The references to the tragedy are incredibly subtle because BTS had to be subtle, it wasn't allowed to be talked about. Despite that, they still chose to address the issue in this way. There's many many many more references in the song/MV, it's a masterpiece. (For example the horn in the beginning isn't of a train, the spinning washing machines represent the windows of the ship, etc etc). But the overview you all watched was a good overview. BTS often use references to movies, art and books as you again see in this song.
"Bahar Günü" MÜZİK VİDEOSU Sewol Feribot Trajedisi hakkındadır, ancak RM ŞARKIYI bunu akılda tutarak yazmadı. RM aslında şarkının trajedi hakkında YAZILMADIĞINI doğruladı. Bunun Ilsan'daki memleketindeki arkadaşlarını özlemekle ilgili olduğunu söyledi. Yine de Sewol hakkında bir şarkı yazdı. Adı "Yanlış mıyım" ve Başkan Park'a ve onun yozlaşmış hükümetine doğrudan bir eleştiridir. Feribotun neden battığını biliyoruz. Yükle aşırı yüklenmişti; taşıması tasarlanan yükün neredeyse 3 katıydı. Başkan (başbakan değil) istifa etmedi. Azledildi, görevden alındı ve neredeyse 10 yıl hapis cezasına çarptırıldı. Müzik videosunu yöneten kişi trajediden ilham aldığını söyledi, yani bu sadece bir teori değil. Ancak videoda hangi sahnelerin ve öğelerin temsil edilmesi gerektiği konusunda çeşitli teoriler var.
😭😭ya me hicieron llorar Hola soy de República Dominicana 🇩🇴 amo a BTS por su sencillez humildad pero a ustedes también lo estoy amando encuentro que son igual de humanos y veo que tienen un corazón enorme verlo llorar así habla mucho de ustedes como ser humano Los amo cuídense mucho besos desde República Dominicana 🇩🇴🇩🇴
Really appreciated your considerations and sensitivity. Not many reactors take the time to understand and your tears made us all cry all over again. Thank you. I purple you. TRIVIA Spring Day has never left the charts since then
Hello gentlemen! Nice to be here!🤗💜🫡This song and its meaning I have watched too many times to count. Each time,I am brought to tears,especially with the Italian version with the students parents reacting in real time to the tragdey😢. But life goes on because you have to. Never,ever apologize for being human and sheding tears or being emotional. This makes the world go round. Thank you so very much for sharing with me. 😔💜🫡
Giving you all a big hug! Watching Spring Day and any of the explanation videos is a hard, emotional thing to do. This is why this song is so loved, not just in South Korea, but for people everywhere around the world who empathize with the families of the victims of this tragedy. Thank you for another heartfelt reaction. I cried along with you. 💜💜💜😭
Thank you for your reaction to this song and the explanation video. I didn't know much about the ferry sinking. Just remember clips of it in the news. When I first watched BTS' Spring Day video and the explanation video, it brought me to tears. Today, your reaction video brought me to tears again. I have seen a few of your BTS reactions, and I enjoy watching. BTW Your language is beautiful❤ I always love hearing different languages of the world. I'm Native American from the Diné (Navajo) tribe. Please continue your BTS reactions. Much love!💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🫶🫰
This should have never happened. As a parent, this breaks my heart. I cannot imagine what those parent went through knowing their children were drowning and there was nothing the parent could do. Shame on those who allowed this to happen and would not allow rescue of these young kids.
Fico muito feliz de ver como vocês reagem aos meus adoráveis membros BTS, sou uma Army apaixonada por eles, pois são inteligentes, carismáticos, encantadores ...... Obrigada pelo seus carinhos na ora dos comentários 💜💜💜🤙🇧🇷
Gracias a los tres por tener corazónes tan empaticos y sensibles, BTS hizo esta hermosa canción para recordar y no olvidar. Nosotros seguimos creciendo y viviendo mientras que aquellos muchachos se quedaron para siempre en ese tiempo y lugar. Gracias a esta canción nunca los olvidaremos.
Gracias por mostrar vuestra humanidad y sensibilidad, es un triste acontecimiento uy bien reflejado en una canción, y como bien decís es algo que no se debería olvidar.Me gustan mucho vuestras reacciones, un saludo de corazón para los tres, os sigo desde España Seguid reaccionando a BTS por favor, conozco todo de ellos pero me gusta ver como los vais descubriendo y apreciando
Thank you for your honest reaction. It does matter how often i watch the Spring Day video, it always makes me cry. Thank you for sharing your genuine emotions. We must all work together to make this world a better place for all people and always remember the victims of senseless tragedies.
I cry every time I watch it. I used their music video as inspiration for a presentation I did on the Sewol Ferry disaster for my Disaster Ethics class. It was hard to watch the live videos even more since I have a 7 year old daughter, so I cried a lot 😭❤️
It will soon be the 10th anniversary of the Sewol Ferry Disaster. At the time of the Sewol Ferry Disaster, President Park was the daughter of a president who had been dictatorial decades earlier and was supported by conservative forces. The generation that experienced rapid social development during the dictatorship and after the Korean War amid the sacrifices of many working class people. She missed President Park Chung-hee and believed that her daughter would do well, but after Park Geun-hye became president, she only cared about herself and did not care about the people and victims. At that time, celebrities who mentioned the Sewol Ferry were blacklisted and suffered disadvantages. BTS, who donated money to the bereaved families and made a music video for Spring Day, was also targeted. As a result of the disaster at that time, many Koreans suffered from depression and trauma for a long time. But they couldn't stay still because they were sad or angry. I took to the streets with my family for several cold winter months, raising my voice and shouting to reveal the truth about the tragedy. At the time, the president was not interested in saving the people from disaster. She used this politically, discussing and deciding national affairs with women with whom she was close, and she was only interested in pursuing personal interests. Critics of the regime were blacklisted and treated unequally. BTS was hated by the government at the time for comforting and donating to the families of the victims of the disaster. Afterwards, angry citizens held candlelight protests for months, and even during that cold winter, millions of citizens peacefully protested and impeached the president. I hope this never happens again anywhere else. Since then, the administration has changed for the second time, and the current administration is also politicians who followed the president who was impeached at the time. They did not reflect on anything after the disaster and have not even learned anything. Another tragedy called the Itaewon disaster plunged the people into sorrow, but even that They used it as a tool of political struggle and only used it for political purposes. The disaster could have been prevented even if they had not ignored the numerous signs warning of danger. Ironically, those who blacklisted BTS tried to use BTS' global influence politically. Even just before BTS enlisted, they visited their agency and pressured BTS's parents to give a free concert to promote the Busan Expo. As a result, the members began enlisting later than scheduled after the concert.
At this point i can say every country is under the rule of politicians (who actually not aware of their ppl needs) how come the politics never done anything good but targeted BTS who helped the ppl in need even though they are undergoing with hardships being a teen group under the bighit which is actually under going bankrupts, I remember k-government giving military exception for BTS and want them to give a free concert although they gave free concert for us, they never wanted to involve regarding political related stuff they didn't accept the special treatment offered by the government (isn't it obv gov try using bts for the political benefits only as they kn BTS are the main reason why korean economy is increasing rapidly) I love how they declined the gov offer and went to serve their country in military on their own wish we are proud you bangtan. thank you we aren't aware of the gov targeting bts in the spring day era thank you for letting us kn in clear way🤍( as ukn issues like this are exposed in rare)
@@just_wanna_behappier3369 damn thank you for telling us armys that werent through that spring day era. this whole situation is/was surely devastating. may the ones that lost their lives continue resting in peace and the survivors plus everyone affected find peace. 💜
@@rachenel252 welcome dear🤍. the only thing we can do is praying for them so from now on let's include them in our prayers. I hope the ppl who lost their children are doing well now it's really heartbreaking in that ship there was a couple they tied their hands so that they won't go far from each other in their last breath some student sent voice mails saying thank you to their parents and there was a guy who apologized to his father because he was angry on his father they fought he didn't talk with him from long(dkn how many days or months) so he said sorry and also said I'm happy for having father like you and love you mom and dad pls take care. And one of the guy sent text to his big brother saying take care of parents i love you i never said this as we always bicker abt everything but i do love you takecare... aishh now also i'm crying it's been soo long but still it shatters my heart 🥺.
Obrigada por essa reação. Assim como existem pessoas más nesse mundo, e que no se importam com a vida do outro, temos nós que criamos moatia e temos BTS que exalam amor e alegria! Não tem como não se emocionar.😢 Beijos do Brasil.
Ah, you sweet, sweet men. Lots of ARMY were crying with you. I had known about BTS since their debut but Sping Day was the song that made me an ARMY. I can listen to the song in a playlist and be okay, but after all these years, the MV still makes me cry. This song and MV are just one of many, many reasons BTS is so special.
Never apologize for being emotional, we all go through it, in our own ways. Some more outwardly, and others quietly and internally. But it’s one of those songs that makes you feel something. I usually go from rage at the injustice to sadness thinking of those who lost their loved ones, to a hope that it will never happen again as long as we are vigilant in not forgetting the mistakes of the past. That is BTS for you, one moment you are laughing hysterically at their funny antics, then bawling your eyes out at a deeply meaningful song. Sometimes I just listen to them and I don’t eleven know why I am crying so hard..then you realize that there is something in their lyrics that hits you, helps you bring it to light instead of buying it, and then gives you a bit of hope to overcome. That is the genius of them, is that no matter how dark, they will always put some positivity or hopefulness in their songs, to remind you that there is some ray of light to cling to. Great reaction, keep them coming!
Gerçekten ruhunuzun naifliği beni de ekran başında etkiledi. Herkes tepki kanalı açabilir ancak çok az kişi bu işe gereken değeri verir. Bu güzel tepki ve yorumlarınız için çok teşekkürler. 💖
Well this reaction broke me. I really have grown to love your channel. As a very protective army I look for genuine people to react to our members and you guys are doing a wonderful job. Thank you for your beautiful reaction. We all cry with you. 💜🫂
Patiently waiting for your next amazing reaction. I love all of you guys,Dilay is also so thoughtful for translating, Turkish is a beautiful language as well, its one of the languages I wish to learn. I'm glad you enjoyed spring day and the explanation as well, its touching. PS: I don't want to take away from this beautiful reaction, but I think it would be really great if you guys could react to the live version of Magic shop as well as how magic shop has helped many people (maybe reading a few stories on how it helped them)and even saved lives. I think it'll show you how not only are BTS such talented and humble guys but their music and words are a form of healing for others. DILAY should definitely be part of the video if you guys decide to react to Magic Shop. All the love from Cape Town,South Africa, your reaction is what I looked forward to today after college. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I have to say - maybe it's because I'm German, but those piles of clothes always remind me of the Holocaust. In IU's video for "Love wins all", they also used the Boltanski reference, but I have yet to find out, whether or not he himself was referencing Auschwitz with it. He had a jewish father as far as I know and in Auschwitz, they also piled up the clothes, the people wore upon their arrival there. I get so extremely choked up and emotional about this, it's horrible. And @Dilay: How precious are you to translate everything in handwriting for the boys? That's such a deep level of devotion, not only to BTS, their music and us viewers, but also to your boys. I hope you're being appreciated accordingly, it is not taken for granted. 💜 @Cagin: Never apologize for your tears. We all felt that. We got you, ARMY is a safe space.
It's not surprising the pile of clothes reminds you of the Holocaust. The French paper Le Figaro wrote this about Boltanski's installation 'Personnes' from 2010: "Sous la nef du Grand Palais, Christian Boltanski présente en 2010 une installation monumentale qui évoque la Shoah sans y faire directement allusion. La pince d'une grue prélève inlassablement des habits tirés d'une pile d'une quinzaine de mètres et les relâche au hasard. Au sol, 69 «carrés» recouverts de vêtements étalés comme autant de pierres tombales. Le son, très fort, anime l'atmosphère glaciale de battements cardiaques recueillis par l'artiste à travers le monde. Le visiteur, guidé par des médiateurs, est immergé dans l'œuvre gigantesque selon le souhait du plasticien. Il n'est plus un simple spectateur." Here's a video clip of the art installation: ua-cam.com/video/SXND1GZdBzM/v-deo.html
@@evacaspers4053 You're welcome. I had the same association when I first saw the music video (also, memories, like Çağin said). Although I had not been to the exhibition, I knew about Boltanski's art installation, so I looked it up. I think the exhibition video, also the beginning with the stacked metal boxes with numbers on them, shows a strong association with the Holocaust. The only reference I could find was in Le Figaro.
I'm only 8:41 seconds into your reaction but I can tell you are really thinking about and interpreting the meanings to the song lyrics as well as the contents of the video. You don't know it yet, but many of the concepts you've mentioned are very close to what many think the song means and because music is open to interpretation, you aren't wrong and what you're saying is definitely one way to interpret it. Many reaction channels don't even try to talk about what they think it means, so not only are your interpretations appreciated but it demonstrates your own artistic sides. It is exposure to art, poetry, music that informs how we interact with and interpret the world or other people's work. 💜
I have loved your reactions so far, and I look forward to watching your channel grow. I love your sincerity and your thoughtful discussions/reactions to the music. Many people don't understand the allure of BTS, but songs like this, their bravery, and their sincerity to their art and fans change the world and give people connections, which many are lacking in today's fast-paced world.
There is a heartbreaking video on UA-cam where it’s news videos of the actual disaster playing out and the families waiting around for news. It is set to this song. It will forever stay with you. 💜💜💜
The ferry had been 'converted' which was not within the legal weight regulations and so was extremely overweight. A lot of the footage from the news crews was heartbreaking, the volunteer divers were willing to get the students out but were stopped by the coast guard... I'm guessing the only reason for this is so the ferry would sink and cover up all the corruption of the government and authorities.... rescue boats from civilians were turned away whilst the parents and families remained on the wharf still being able to see their children alive in the windows of the ferry as the crew were saved. Korean children are very polite and stayed in place because they were told to by the captain and crew. I doubt western teenagers would have remained in their cabins and would mostly, I imagine , have survived.
Nope. It was because if someone rescued someone it needed to be the coastguard not civilians: it's a matter of "face"/station. which is why the messages that were send up the command chain held so many lies and orders were given on a perceived "resolved" situation instead of the real one. Holding on the "look good" even if it does not acomplish anything was important and as such overrode helping - which they couldn't do because they were not trained for that and had faulty equipment. I heard that an US ship wanting to help was also send away. I made it through about half a documentary were all these messages over the coast guard etc. was in before I couldn't do it anymore. We in Europe and NA simply do not think like that.
This was so wholesome, I cried with you. THANK YOU FOR BEING SO GENUINE.My favourite reaction channel by far, looking forward to many more💜💜💜💜💜 BORAHAE
again and again, i am always amazed how the boys and the production team always put in details their messages through their lyrics , their music videos and that's the proof BTS is in another level. I am so proud of them 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I have seen this video and the Italian video, which I also recommend, several times and have learned that I must be feeling a certain amount of emotional strength in order to watch these videos again. Right now I am experiencing some medical issues that weigh heavily on me, so I will not be watching your reactions. HOWEVER, knowing your great hearts and empathy, I AM sending you my warmest and most loving hugs as a measure of consolation. Thank you for watching this video! 🫶🫰🙏💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜 💜💜
It's ok to still sing Spring Day in your closing if you feel like it. The music video reminds us to never forget the victims of the tragedy, but the lyrics alone can be meaningful in any circumstance, I think. I do think about the tragedy when I hear Spring Day now, but I also think about those in my own life I miss, as well as being reminded to be thankful for my life & the lives of my family & friends who are still with me. It's a beautiful song we can sing along with as both a tribute & with gratitude. Perhaps sometimes with sadness, but also with happiness, depending on what we're going through at the time. Maybe it makes it more important to sing it than ever. Borahae. 💜
Thank you so much for your reaction. I felt your sincerity and kind hearts…tears are okay. Never apologize for them. You have empathy and that is something beautiful 💜 Would like to give a bit of an info that Spring Day was actually inspired by a falling leaf that Namjoon saw while sitting at a park one autumn day. He thought of friends he had lost touch with and the different lives they now have - him growing some distance from them because of his public life as an idol. The music video on the other hand, was made to honor the Sewol Ferry victims and survivors. It has never been confirmed up to this day. But many ARMYs, even K-ARMY attest that it was indeed a commemoration of BTS to show unity and sympathy for the families left behind, especially when they visited the families together with Bang PD. It was only revealed much later by a parent of one of the students who passed away. BTS never publicized it, the same way they keep their philanthropy low key, but this music video was their way of giving light to what happened and giving a voice to those who were silenced by the government (a lot of people were targeted by the government for speaking up) Them visiting the families in one of the memorial services was also a brave act and it just showed that even back then (in 2016-2017) even if they didn’t have the global phenomenon status they have now, they chose to use their influence in a positive way. BTS (and Bang PD) are genuinely kind, good human beings, and that is why they are so blessed with so much love from their fandom 💕💜
Spring Day is our Queen and we all love her very much. Most armys cry at the video no matter how many times we watch it so no worries for your tears little brother. I always enjoy your thoughtful reactions. Reacting to Spring Day and it's meaning is part of becoming an army. KDiamonds will never let her fall from the charts, ever. Because of this and other things many armys have promised the members of BTS to seek justice, fight racism, and activily try to make the world a better place, just like they make this world a better place for armys. When we say that BTS have meaningful lyrics....
Sending loads of hugs to our boys and you too Dilay 😢 beautiful reaction, so respectful and emotional. Thank you for your hard work of translating the video for them. 💜💜💜
Who would have thought as an English person I would watch a Turkish reactor, reacting to a Korean song. So many different language levels, but Spring Day is a masterpiece and while it breaks my heart every time it is also an exceptional piece of art, that moves us all intensely. Thank you for your openness and sensitivity.
and please, never ever apologize for what you're feeling, or how you express it. one of the things we love about bts is the transparency, even in regards to their emotions. whether you are sad, happy, angry... it's okay and very normal, human to feel and and not hide it
Está bien llorar no lo lamentes por eso, es una muestra muy sincera de su empatía 💜. Gracias Dilay por tomarte el trabajo de traducirles el video explicativo. Es un hecho que el cápitan del ferry actuó de manera egoísta y cruel. Vi videos muy tristes de como algunos estudiantes se despedian de sus familias en una llamada 😭. Muchos siguieron la orden de permanecer en su puesto y perdieron la vida por seguir las reglas.😢
Albüm reaksiyonları bekliyorum ya... Bence tüm klipleri 2şer 3er izleyip BTS'in kısa film olaylarına da girebilirsiniz. O teori oluşturma süreci çok zevkliydi wings dönemi ve öncesinde
Hello everyone. I'm Dilay.
Thank you for watching the video and for your beautiful comments.
Even reading the comments brings tears to my eyes.
I just wanted to make a correction. I see that one of the information I gave in the video is incorrect. Rm and Suga wrote this song about friendship and lost friends. These theories apply to the MV of the song and as we know Bts has never confirmed these theories. I also see that there are some governmental problems related to this issue, but I will not go into detail here, because many Army have made very good and detailed explanations in the comments.
In the end, no matter what, this beautiful song gives many people the strength to move on and remember their loved ones. That's why it's so valuable.
Thank you again and condolences to those who have lost loved ones. 🙏🎗
I really appreciate your efforts 👍😊😊
I can’t tell you how much I enjoy your reactions…you are not fake and your courteousness is not something you see in humanity and for sure don’t see on social media….regarding this video I THINK they said BTS was the first to respond as far as Kpop groups go….they have to be very careful as they would get in trouble if they said anything about the government but BTS is very clever…not only in this video but also their other videos they are famously known for leaving clues in their videos we call Easter eggs and it depends on how far into the rabbit hole you are as to if you can spot what they are telling us…I’m always excited for the next video…I will be a subscriber for life💜💜💜💜
Merhaba Dilay bilirsin biz Armyler biraz çok heyecanlıyız bilgilerimizi aktarmak isteriz bazende idaliyizdir eğer seni üzdüysem(k) özür dilerim.Kendi adıma .
Aslında hepimiz şunu aklımıza getirmemiz lazım biz nasıl başladık bizide yönlendiren kimse olmadı.
Neden sizi bırakmıyoruz bu sizin yolculuğunuz ve siz sadece bu yolculukta seyirciyiz arada yol tarifi istiyorsunuz.
Belki arada çıkmaz yanlış sokağa girsenizde sorarak okuyorak seyrederek yollunuzu bulacaksınız buna eminim..
daha ben İlkim ve Çağından Army şarkisi ve tabiki Spring Day performansı.
Üçünüzü morluyorum sevgiyle kalın BTS le Kalın 💜
Thanx for this clarification. I thought I was losing my memory 🙃. Just wanted to let you know that I really love your reactions. Also I thought you might be interested in a programme that explains the BTS phenomenon (it's about an hour long) that's done by a South Korean lecturer who's an ARMY. I'm providing the link below and I hope you'll find it as informative as I did. There's also a segment about 'Spring Day' and what one ARMY did. It's truly very touching. I also hope you can react to it, if it's not too much 🙂
ua-cam.com/video/Uaj1X76h2mQ/v-deo.html
@@angie7777-7
*Italian* *Army* has the better explanation vid "what you still don't know about BTS spring day".
I don't think Idols made any music about it. But Korean musicians - especially rappers - did already back in 2014. "Spring Day" is from 2017.
Nevermind that the song was written about missing/loosing friends.
I think that was about the time Namjoon (RM) called old friends who told him that they did not dare call him first because he was famous now and it would look bad if they did. So he vowed to call them more often himself.
With Yoongi (Suga) I'm less sure about the timeline because I do not know when this happened or if at all: A friend of his got into drugs and that is an absolut no-no in the Korean entertainment scene and Yoongi may have broken the firendship over it.
Mind you the song is an embodiment of the Korean emotion of "Han" and I see the stages of grief in it.
MV and choreo are definetly about the desaster.
And it is known how and why the ship sank. There are a at least one documentary about it and I think the articles on wikipedia have it, too. Italian Army also explains a bit.
I think this vid overexplaines some small details - maybe even missexplains while overlooking other stuff - which is why some people dismiss it as "theory".
If you watch the Italian explanation, you’ll cry even more. There are real life scenes from that day if the parents waiting for someone to rescue their children… heartbreaking 💔
Полностью согласна , итальянское видео это шедевр , очень подробно показано
Yes 🥺
I love hate the Italian army version too because the clips of the parents always make me cry
Yes🥹
It needs to be seen to grasp the full blown murder of innocent children…but in light of recent years I’m realizing no one’s government is above corruption …it can happen anywhere and the average citizen is helpless
이 영상을 보면서 진정성이 느껴지고 정말 수고하셨고 감사합니다😢
Little brother your tears are so precious and are a wonderful tribute to the lost and to BTS! They live on in our remembrance! Thank you for your precious gift!
He have soft heart❤
The Italian Army explains everything in much more detail. It’s heartbreaking but it makes you guys appreciate what BTS did even more 💜
Armies are always one "Bogo shipta" away from bursting into tears.
definitely
@@echinopsisarmy8231 💜
that's true 😢
For sure 😅
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP-
Never ever apologise for crying, especially at Spring Day. I have heard it, and watched the MV dozens if times and always weep. It remains in the Korean charts ever since, and in Korea is known as 'the Queen'. The ferry sinking was worse than a tragedy, since it was avoidable from the start (caused by illegally overloading containers on deck) and ALL the loss of life was also avoidable ... they literally had hours to evacuate and not only did nothing but prevented others from rescuing passengers. Its incredible. The song was written about simply missing a close friend, but it's generally accepted that the MV is about the Sewol disaster. It is a masterpiece.
Thank you for talking about how the song still remains on the charts in South Korea... I think it is awe-inspiring and heartwarming to know people have continued to remember all that this song and video encompasses.
Also, Dilay... You are an amazing ARMY... thank you for sharing this and the other music/videos/information with others.
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
i cried a lot aswell the moment i first watch it...even now ,watching it for many times i still became teary
My goodness, I can't even watch this reaction without crying... 😢
Agreed 😭🥺
Don’t you dare apologize for crying or showing your emotions. It is beautiful. You are beautiful. 💜
Two days ago, I went to the Sewol Ferry memorial site on Jeju Island with my family. Ten years later, my daughter is now a second year in high school like them. The parents of the children who could not arrive in Jeju brought their children's photos to Jeju Island on their behalf. . Even after ten years, we must not forget it and monitor and change it so that a tragedy like this never happens anywhere again. In particular, we need to speak out to prevent accidents that are unreasonable or caused by man-made disasters.
We will not forget it ..🎗️
Yesss exactly! Never forget. Wished I had the chance to visit the memorial site when I was there. Thanks for going 🙏🏽💜
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP-
다른 나라 사람들이 대한민국의 아픈 현실을 공감해주고 같이 아파하는 모습이 마음에 진실로 느껴져서 너무 감동이고 고맙게 느껴집니다 당신들의 채널을 응원합니다 💜
You sweet, tenderhearted souls, you are not alone. ARMY and BTS are here with you too. Hwaiting! Borahae 💜💜💜
Músicos que hablaron y/cantaron sobre el tema fueron hostigados al igual que reporteros honestos. BTS es una metáfora profunda habla del tema sin hablar y eso caló más profundo todavía. La canción desde su estreno no ha abandonado los rankings e incluso en Japón siempre está en tendencia obteniendo a fines de marzo el certificado de platino por llegar a 100 millones de reproducciones. La canción volvió a ser tendencia mundial cuando BTS comenzó a enlistarse.
💜🙏Thank you for sharing your heartfelt reaction to Spring Day.... i don't know if you can translate into Turkish but.... I want to share with you a comment to another reactor from a survivor of the Sewol disaster.. I would like you to hear from him just how BTS has healed him through this song and the messages they have: His name is Chilo Abellon - and this is his public comment in full - unedited - from 3 years ago..........
"I remembered when they rescuing us its so tragic when you see your classmates/friends stuck asking and hearing them scream for help, the screaming and voices of people asking for help while the ships is sinking the scream slowly vanished. When you can’t help them because the water got deeper and deeper while they rescue us slowly. The time that i got rescued only 3 of us survived, my two classmates and i in our and my other classmates stuck in the ships hoping they’re still alive but when the time i heard the news that they’re all gone. It slowly sinking in that all my friends and the other class are gone and will never comeback. I feel guilty when I survived, I’m thinking am i lucky? Or is it not right that i was alive and not them? Do i deserve to live?.
Feeling depressed, having su!cidal thoughts, every night you can’t sleep because i keep hearing those scream a scream people needing a help but you can’t because your weak and got broken bones. Everything time I struggled to see what life is all about, thinking what if all of my friends survived and they with me survived. It would be dream to see that happening. I struggled to make a good life that i can be proud of because of that incident happened but when i found out about BTS my life changed me because of their music they changed my life the way that i can be proud of and I started loving myself by little by little and finally the day I realize life is so short and the incident happened 7years ago impacted my life to be a better person and all of our hardships are just a big task for us to make them done and the outcome will be 100times better the incident happened 7years ago thought me so many things.
The biggest one is don’t forget they might be gone but don’t forget them put them on your heart and like life all of your hardship and your mistakes will not lose or fail you it’s always a win win situation because we always learn from them. Spring day is my number 1 fav song of BTS because I reminisce the things happened 7years ago while watching the mv and it always help me to keep going in life and do not give up on things that i want to achieve
- My name is Chilo one of the survivors of the sewol ferry incident."
I truly hope he does not mind me passing on his public comment - but this best shows the power of BTS message.
The worst thing about the disaster - the captain and most of the crew fled the ship in the morning 9.35 - the ferry did not sink until the night - they left the warning to "not move and stay still" playing on a loop through the ship. Only the children that disobeyed the warning survived. The others drowned as they were so ingrained to listen to authority.
The civilian boats that attempted to rescue people were stopped by the coast guard as people would discover the boat was illegally overloaded.
Parents on the shore were receiving desperate calls and texts from their children begging for help. And the coastguard did nothing. The only rescue the coastguard made that day was the captain and crew... The people that got rescued were rescued by fishing vessels that got there first before they were stopped...
3 years the ferry lay at the bottom as the Govt would not raise it for fear of discovering the truth.... They found video footage taken on mobile phones that were recovered of children wishing their families goodbye.
3 crew members stayed behind to try and help the children, they all lost their lives, along with one of the rescue divers. Also, one of the civilian rescue divers later committed su!cide after having to recover so many childrens bodies, knowing that he could have saved them but was forcibly stopped.
As a parent, I could not comprehend having to live through such a thing. Horrific that your own government would perpetrate and then cover up such an incident... jailing dissenters for protesting. It was proven that there were high officials with financial interests in the ferry. The president colluded with them to bury the truth and hamper investigations... 10000 people in the public eye (reporters, artists, etc) put on a Govt blacklist for speaking about it.
BTS went and paid respects to the parents of the victims in 2014 when the tragedy occurred. No Cameras - No fanfair - just doing what was right...They also donated approx $100,000 (that year they only earnt $300,000 - they gave 1/3 of their earnings) to help the parents in their fight for justice.... We only found out about the donation years later as one of the parents was sick of all the hatred BTS was always getting and wanted others to know what decent and good people they are.
The MV, The album cover, The choreography all relate back to the Sewol. But the song itself is about missing anyone you love and are separated from. They were singing Spring Day during the panademic as the world was longing for a spring day. Spring Day has never left the music charts. To this day, it is right that this song is still in the top 100 charts.... 7 years later, as this song still speaks to people everywhere.
Sorry this is so long - but I really wanted to pass his comment and information to you relating to your Spring Day reaction video.... with posting your reaction you have helped keep the memory of Sewol alive and maybe others who do not know of it will learn of the tragedy.
Thank you for sharing your journey, and helping to spread BTS message... Sending greetings and love from Australia.... BORAHAE💜 #WeNeverWalkAlone
😢😢😢I wish him all the love in the world and that good things always happen to him 💜🎗️💜
💜💜💜🫶🇸🇷
Borahae ARMY for writing and spreading this for those who don’t know💜
Thank You 🫂💜🪽
Thank you Army for explaining so new Armys understand!💜
Given the scandal that followed this tragedy revealing the corruption of many civil servants...the government tried to cover up the affair but faced with the tenacity of the victims' parents, all of Korea "rose up" Make a song on this tragedy was important for BTS who stood in solidarity with the families. RM and the boys were very young and did not hesitate to produce this magnificent tribute to the victims...we can emphasize the fact that Big Hit did not oppose this decision despite the risk of being perceived as an attack by the government....One more proof of the commitment of the boys to defend their ideas of social justice....This song did not have a commercial aim but rather to help the parents of the victims who also made it their anthem. ..Thank you for your very sincere reaction...You were already admiring of BTS...now you will perhaps understand better why there are millions of us who love them and above all respect them.Thank you
The Sewol sank in 2014.
Spring Day dropped in 2017. 3 years later.
The song was about a loss of friendship and "only" MV and choreo are about the desaster.
I don't think they were on any lists.
As far as I can tell they may be the only Idols that used the theme but plenty of other Korean musicians did, too.
K-Army has put the song on their playlists when they stream new BTS songs. Details I don't know.
her dinlediğimde nefes almakta zorlanıyorum gerçekten. Feribotun batmak üzere olduğunu anlayınca bazı öğrenciler ailelerine mesaj atıp yardım istediler ve veda ettiler diye biliyorum. BTS gerçekten bir müzik grubundan daha fazlası bu şarkıda onların ne kadar güzel insanlar olduğunun ve gençlere ne kadar güzel örnek oldğunu kanıtlıyor.
Don't apologize for crying, for getting emotional. I cry every time I hear this song. Crying just says we have feelings and that's what makes us human.🇧🇷💜
Este 16 de abril se cumplirán 10 años de la lamentable tragedia, BTS con esta canción en base a símbolos nos hizo entender el sufrimiento tanto de los que ya no están como el de sus familiares y amigos, esta canción se ha transformado en un himno en Corea de Sur, un abrazo a ustedes y no lamenten llorar porque eso demuestra que la sensibilidad es lo escencial de la gente buena, hay muchas canciones de BTS que tienen una explicación, no solo es letra, musica, baile y canto, hay símbolos en todas ellas, por eso mucha gente de diferentes edades, países y culturas, quieren a estos chicos, yo tengo 60 años, soy de Chile de América del Sur y espero que estos chicos siempre estén bien, tengo a mi favorito es uno de los menores para mí el es Bebé Angel, saludos sigan adelante con sus reacciones están muy bien
fakat bir sorun vardır, öğrencilere yerlerinden ayrılmamaları söylenmiştir ve bu kadar can kaybının olmasının nedenlerinden biri de budur. ayrıca kaptan da feribotu, battığını anladığı ilk anlarda terk etmiştir.
geriye öğrencilerin kıyafetleri, birer çift ayakkabıları kalır, gözü yaşlı aileleriyle birlikte. nuri bilge ceylan demiş ya hani ''birisi ölür üzülmezsiniz, sonra sandalyeye asılı hırkasını görürsünüz, o hırkanın duruşu kalbinize oturur'' diye, işte o ayakkabı koca bir ülkenin yüreğine dokunur.
The ferry started to sink in the morning and finally submerged that night. Whenever I think about the kids and the helpless parents watching the boat take their children, ever so slowly, fills me with rage and sadness
I think it was a bit faster than this.
I remember a clip of the air gushing out from the balloon they tried to put into the ship to stop the farther sinking and it was still light. Mind you they had to already dive to try that - unfortunately a civilian diver that was forced to help them had pointed out that their equipment was unlikely to work right - his did I think - and as predicted the diver had to be recalled very soon.
There is at least one documentary out there about it. I stopped watching somewhen in the middle because the footage was too much and they included all the messages that went over the chain of command explaining why everything was so slow and done so badly.
You didn't cried alone, this was a very emotional reaction and we appreciate that you watched the video. BTS goes beyond the stage and that's also why so many people loves them. Spring Day is so special for people in Korea. I remember the tragedy, watching the news and holding my 2 year old baby and thinking about those kids and their parents, it always brings me to tears but I like to watch reactions about it because I think it makes people realise the impact of the tragedy and BTS's big heart. Hold your kids or the people you love, tell them you love them everyday. Borahae 💜💜💜!
SPRING DAY is the Queen of songs for ARMY, that's why there is a before and after of it 🥲💜☺️
Please don't apologize for crying or not crying. We all express our emotions differently. I always cry when watching this video. Although the song was actually written in reference to a friendship when they did the music video it was done as a story about the Sewol Ferry incident and a tribute to those who lost their lives. The explanation video you watched is very good and the Italian one that people below mentioned is a little more in depth, very good and very emotional. I like your reaction videos very much and appreciate all your comments and observations. Thank you.
At first, they couldn't say it was about the tragedy, but after the condemnations, all the theories were confirmed. I cried like you, Dilay and Çagim, after watching the Italian Army explanation (more visual, sadder), I cried for a good time, sobbing. A stupid tragedy like that breaks any heart.
Thanks for the reaction, I'm sorry if it was too sad, but, as always, BTS transformed bad experiences in art, a healing art.
This song is called The Queen because it's always on top of the Korean charts.
The video made by an Italian army is also very good to watch because it is more detailed and has a lot of real videos of what really happened during that time.
Yes
Sensibilidad ,justicia , autoestima , factores que en cada tema de BTS brillan .Deberíamos tener un mundo más lleno de esa sensibilidad .
I love your reactions. I don't know Turkish but it is a very beautiful language. I do enjoy learning new languages, and Turkish has now definitely been added to my constantly growing list of languages that I want to learn
How about it?😊
so do I... nowadays, I'm learning Korean, Russian, and Turkish at the same time. I love to find similarities!
Myself as well. I'm learning Mandarin, Thai, and Korean atm.
And I absolutely loved this reaction. I was crying right along with you all. Although I've heard that song and seen the description vid. I still cry every time I hear that song. I'm a mother of 3 and just the thought of losing one of my babies is too much for me. So my thoughts and condolences are forever with those survivors as well as those who lost someone
I cried with you guys, sometimes this world feels so unfair, this reminds me of what’s happening in Gaza right now and how many lives were lost, this is the reason why I love bts they’re not just artists they feel like a family to us.
Spring day benim BTS'in en sevdiğim şarkısıdır. Büyük bir merakla bekledim bu videoyu ve izledim. Tepkileri gerçekten çok samimiydi. Çağın'ın ağlaması İlkim'in betimlemeleri çok içtendi. Kanalınızdaki tüm videoları izledim ve favori reaction videom kesinlikle bu diyebilirim. Aklımdan geçen tek şey bu şarkının reaction videosu olsa olsa bu olurdu. Böyle tepkiler verilebilirdi. Ayrıca Dilay'ın türkçe altyazı bulamayıp kendi eliyle emek verip çevirmesi çok güzel. Mvyi türkçe altyazılı izleyip ve dinleyip daha sonrasında hikayesini öğrenmeleri... Her şey harikaydı. Keşke 1 kere değilde daha çok like atabilseydim dedim 😅 tepkileriniz ve emekleriniz için teşekkür ederim ❤
Hikayeyi bilmeden bile hissettirebilen bir şarkı.çok derin
bu şarkı gerçekten çok anlamlı, üstüne üstlük kore gibi baskıcı bir ülkede böyle bir şarkı yayınlayıp hükümeti de yapılanlar için eleştirmek herkesin yapabileceği bir şey değil. bts bu şarkıyı çıkarttığında 4. yıllarındalardı ve git gide daha da zirveye çıktıkları bir dönemdi. tüm bunları göze alarak şarkıyı yayınladılar. ayrıca yanlış hatırlamıyorsam bts yeni çıkış yaptıkları zaman bu olayla ilgili bir bağış kampanyasında(?) adları geçiyordu. bu yüzünden hükümet tarafından banlandılar gibi olaylar da olmuştu. yanlış hatırlıyor olabilirim eğer yanlışsam bu konuda beni düzeltin. kısacası, gerçekten bu şarkıyı yayınlamaları kesinlikle çok özel ve çok önemli. tepki verdiğiniz için de teşekkürler, çağın’ın ağlamaya başladığı yerde ben daha fazla duygulandım…
ve info geçeyim, şarkı hâlâ kore listelerinde yüksek sıralarda ve birçok rekora imza attı. en uzun süre melon ilk 100 listesinde kalan şarkı, melon platformunda en çok dinlenen şarkı gibi birçok rekoru var. bts her yeni şarkı çıkarttığında spring day mutlaka listelere girip kendi şarkılarıyla yarışır o derece
Estos 7 jóvenes son valiosos como personas y cantantes. Su trabajo es maravilloso
This song always makes me cry when I hear it, it's so beautiful and emotional 🤧🤧💜
Daha çok live performance istiyoruz çünkü bts’in canlı performansları mükemmel yaa çok yaratıcı
-Magic shop mesala var
-MMA 2020 çok iyidi performanslar özelikle Dynamite ve yaptıkları dance break ağzım açık kaldı resmen….
-Film out var Japonca olan şarkılarından biri sesleri canlı çok iyi ✨🤩
-MMA2018 var oda çok iyi
-PTD LA Black swan ve blue and gray performansı mükemmeldi ardındanda blood sweat and tears şarkısından bir küçük parça söylediler sonra hemen Fake love şarkısına girdiler 🔥
-Your eyes tell şarkısı canlı yayında var sesleri ayrı bir dünyaya götürür sizi
-ON kinetik manifesto müzik videosu var ağzınız açık kalacak dansları çok iyi kamera açıları çok iyi
-permission to dance var bakınca çok mutlu hissedersiniz kendinizi çok pozitif çok enerji dolu bir şarkı
-butter grammy award show performansı resmen herkesi çıldırtı yaa kesin izlemelisiniz
-proof live 2022 bir çok şarkı söylediler canlı
-dear class 2020 var
Ohhooo daha neler var neler 😂😂
* 💜umarım her izlediğiniz müzik video ile canlı yayınıda izlersiniz daha çok eğlenceli ve daha çok fark eder
Hi, FIRST ERA Reactors! 💜
Was carried by the manner you reacted to this video/ song/ Sewol ferry tragedy. My heart broke with you all. That is BTS, that is how i know them, how they wrote their songs…always meaningful. The lyrics are beautiful and the music/ melodies as well. When the song is sad it will truly, surely touch our hearts.
Happy to see your true emotions…i could tell it watching you guys. We’re the same, i couldn’t control myself, too. Loved ones are loved ones, won’t be forgotten through the rest of our lives.
Thank you for this, for your beautiful hearts. You are what you are beautiful outside and inside. BE MORE BLESSED. 💞❤️💜🥰
Oh no please keep doing the “bogoshipda” singing. Although this song is associated with this tragedy, I think it’s also taken on several meanings, both personal (for any listener) or BTS related. During the pandemic it’s a song that expressed the longing to see each other again, BTS and ARMY, and that Spring will come. They also sang this during their last concerts before enlistment and so again it’s a hopeful song that we will see each other again. I’ve come to cherish this bittersweet song and I hope the sweetness of it will surface more instead of the bitter for you soon. I always enjoy your reaction, thank you.
friends, I cried with you. I love this song, it brings hope to my heart. Thank you Dilay for so diligently translating the video for the guys. 💜
I really respect this channel, you can react to a story with pure understanding from your heart...warm greetings from Indonesia..
Beautiful reaction, I cried with you all :P I've seen this many times but still cry.
BTS donated to the families of the victims back then, even though their company and themselves hadn't made any money from music yet. The government tried to really cover this event up and artists talking about it would get blacklisted. The references to the tragedy are incredibly subtle because BTS had to be subtle, it wasn't allowed to be talked about. Despite that, they still chose to address the issue in this way. There's many many many more references in the song/MV, it's a masterpiece. (For example the horn in the beginning isn't of a train, the spinning washing machines represent the windows of the ship, etc etc). But the overview you all watched was a good overview.
BTS often use references to movies, art and books as you again see in this song.
"Bahar Günü" MÜZİK VİDEOSU Sewol Feribot Trajedisi hakkındadır, ancak RM ŞARKIYI bunu akılda tutarak yazmadı. RM aslında şarkının trajedi hakkında YAZILMADIĞINI doğruladı.
Bunun Ilsan'daki memleketindeki arkadaşlarını özlemekle ilgili olduğunu söyledi. Yine de Sewol hakkında bir şarkı yazdı. Adı "Yanlış mıyım" ve Başkan Park'a ve onun yozlaşmış hükümetine doğrudan bir eleştiridir.
Feribotun neden battığını biliyoruz. Yükle aşırı yüklenmişti; taşıması tasarlanan yükün neredeyse 3 katıydı.
Başkan (başbakan değil) istifa etmedi. Azledildi, görevden alındı ve neredeyse 10 yıl hapis cezasına çarptırıldı.
Müzik videosunu yöneten kişi trajediden ilham aldığını söyledi, yani bu sadece bir teori değil. Ancak videoda hangi sahnelerin ve öğelerin temsil edilmesi gerektiği konusunda çeşitli teoriler var.
Cidden hepinizin kalbi çok güzel. Size hiçbir zaman kötülük uzanamaz umarım, çok tatlı insanlarsiniz cidden yiycem ya.
😭😭ya me hicieron llorar
Hola soy de República Dominicana 🇩🇴 amo a BTS por su sencillez humildad pero a ustedes también lo estoy amando encuentro que son igual de humanos y veo que tienen un corazón enorme verlo llorar así habla mucho de ustedes como ser humano
Los amo cuídense mucho besos desde República Dominicana 🇩🇴🇩🇴
Really appreciated your considerations and sensitivity. Not many reactors take the time to understand and your tears made us all cry all over again. Thank you. I purple you. TRIVIA Spring Day has never left the charts since then
I can only say that BTS are pure at heart 💜😢
Hello gentlemen! Nice to be here!🤗💜🫡This song and its meaning I have watched too many times to count. Each time,I am brought to tears,especially with the Italian version with the students parents reacting in real time to the tragdey😢. But life goes on because you have to. Never,ever apologize for being human and sheding tears or being emotional. This makes the world go round. Thank you so very much for sharing with me. 😔💜🫡
Giving you all a big hug! Watching Spring Day and any of the explanation videos is a hard, emotional thing to do. This is why this song is so loved, not just in South Korea, but for people everywhere around the world who empathize with the families of the victims of this tragedy.
Thank you for another heartfelt reaction. I cried along with you. 💜💜💜😭
Thank you for your reaction to this song and the explanation video. I didn't know much about the ferry sinking. Just remember clips of it in the news. When I first watched BTS' Spring Day video and the explanation video, it brought me to tears. Today, your reaction video brought me to tears again. I have seen a few of your BTS reactions, and I enjoy watching. BTW Your language is beautiful❤ I always love hearing different languages of the world. I'm Native American from the Diné (Navajo) tribe. Please continue your BTS reactions. Much love!💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🫶🫰
U guys should definitely react to the full explanation of the tragedy its very heart breaking
From pakistan , your reaction to BTS is incredible, keep up👍 you guys have such a beautiful soul
Spring Day, breaking people down on social media since 2014. Genius and beauty personified.
Except the song dropped in 2017.
This should have never happened. As a parent, this breaks my heart. I cannot imagine what those parent went through knowing their children were drowning and there was nothing the parent could do. Shame on those who allowed this to happen and would not allow rescue of these young kids.
Fico muito feliz de ver como vocês reagem aos meus adoráveis membros BTS, sou uma Army apaixonada por eles, pois são inteligentes, carismáticos, encantadores ...... Obrigada pelo seus carinhos na ora dos comentários 💜💜💜🤙🇧🇷
Gracias a los tres por tener corazónes tan empaticos y sensibles, BTS hizo esta hermosa canción para recordar y no olvidar. Nosotros seguimos creciendo y viviendo mientras que aquellos muchachos se quedaron para siempre en ese tiempo y lugar.
Gracias a esta canción nunca los olvidaremos.
Spring Day is loved across Korea. IU even recorded the song. It is performed with love... Spring day will come.
Çağın is me I would cry a river over anything emotional even if it’s a movie
Empathetic people have it hard
Fighting 💪🏻❤️
Gracias por mostrar vuestra humanidad y sensibilidad, es un triste acontecimiento uy bien reflejado en una canción, y como bien decís es algo que no se debería olvidar.Me gustan mucho vuestras reacciones, un saludo de corazón para los tres, os sigo desde España
Seguid reaccionando a BTS por favor, conozco todo de ellos pero me gusta ver como los vais descubriendo y apreciando
Thank you for your honest reaction. It does matter how often i watch the Spring Day video, it always makes me cry. Thank you for sharing your genuine emotions. We must all work together to make this world a better place for all people and always remember the victims of senseless tragedies.
I cry every time I watch it. I used their music video as inspiration for a presentation I did on the Sewol Ferry disaster for my Disaster Ethics class. It was hard to watch the live videos even more since I have a 7 year old daughter, so I cried a lot 😭❤️
It will soon be the 10th anniversary of the Sewol Ferry Disaster. At the time of the Sewol Ferry Disaster, President Park was the daughter of a president who had been dictatorial decades earlier and was supported by conservative forces. The generation that experienced rapid social development during the dictatorship and after the Korean War amid the sacrifices of many working class people. She missed President Park Chung-hee and believed that her daughter would do well, but after Park Geun-hye became president, she only cared about herself and did not care about the people and victims. At that time, celebrities who mentioned the Sewol Ferry were blacklisted and suffered disadvantages. BTS, who donated money to the bereaved families and made a music video for Spring Day, was also targeted.
As a result of the disaster at that time, many Koreans suffered from depression and trauma for a long time. But they couldn't stay still because they were sad or angry. I took to the streets with my family for several cold winter months, raising my voice and shouting to reveal the truth about the tragedy. At the time, the president was not interested in saving the people from disaster. She used this politically, discussing and deciding national affairs with women with whom she was close, and she was only interested in pursuing personal interests. Critics of the regime were blacklisted and treated unequally. BTS was hated by the government at the time for comforting and donating to the families of the victims of the disaster. Afterwards, angry citizens held candlelight protests for months, and even during that cold winter, millions of citizens peacefully protested and impeached the president. I hope this never happens again anywhere else.
Since then, the administration has changed for the second time, and the current administration is also politicians who followed the president who was impeached at the time. They did not reflect on anything after the disaster and have not even learned anything. Another tragedy called the Itaewon disaster plunged the people into sorrow, but even that They used it as a tool of political struggle and only used it for political purposes. The disaster could have been prevented even if they had not ignored the numerous signs warning of danger.
Ironically, those who blacklisted BTS tried to use BTS' global influence politically. Even just before BTS enlisted, they visited their agency and pressured BTS's parents to give a free concert to promote the Busan Expo. As a result, the members began enlisting later than scheduled after the concert.
At this point i can say every country is under the rule of politicians (who actually not aware of their ppl needs) how come the politics never done anything good but targeted BTS who helped the ppl in need even though they are undergoing with hardships being a teen group under the bighit which is actually under going bankrupts, I remember k-government giving military exception for BTS and want them to give a free concert although they gave free concert for us, they never wanted to involve regarding political related stuff they didn't accept the special treatment offered by the government (isn't it obv gov try using bts for the political benefits only as they kn BTS are the main reason why korean economy is increasing rapidly) I love how they declined the gov offer and went to serve their country in military on their own wish we are proud you bangtan.
thank you we aren't aware of the gov targeting bts in the spring day era thank you for letting us kn in clear way🤍( as ukn issues like this are exposed in rare)
@@just_wanna_behappier3369 damn thank you for telling us armys that werent through that spring day era. this whole situation is/was surely devastating. may the ones that lost their lives continue resting in peace and the survivors plus everyone affected find peace. 💜
@@rachenel252 welcome dear🤍. the only thing we can do is praying for them so from now on let's include them in our prayers. I hope the ppl who lost their children are doing well now it's really heartbreaking in that ship there was a couple they tied their hands so that they won't go far from each other in their last breath some student sent voice mails saying thank you to their parents and there was a guy who apologized to his father because he was angry on his father they fought he didn't talk with him from long(dkn how many days or months) so he said sorry and also said I'm happy for having father like you and love you mom and dad pls take care. And one of the guy sent text to his big brother saying take care of parents i love you i never said this as we always bicker abt everything but i do love you takecare... aishh now also i'm crying it's been soo long but still it shatters my heart 🥺.
Obrigada por essa reação. Assim como existem pessoas más nesse mundo, e que no se importam com a vida do outro, temos nós que criamos moatia e temos BTS que exalam amor e alegria!
Não tem como não se emocionar.😢
Beijos do Brasil.
Ah, you sweet, sweet men. Lots of ARMY were crying with you. I had known about BTS since their debut but Sping Day was the song that made me an ARMY. I can listen to the song in a playlist and be okay, but after all these years, the MV still makes me cry. This song and MV are just one of many, many reasons BTS is so special.
Never apologize for being emotional, we all go through it, in our own ways. Some more outwardly, and others quietly and internally. But it’s one of those songs that makes you feel something. I usually go from rage at the injustice to sadness thinking of those who lost their loved ones, to a hope that it will never happen again as long as we are vigilant in not forgetting the mistakes of the past. That is BTS for you, one moment you are laughing hysterically at their funny antics, then bawling your eyes out at a deeply meaningful song. Sometimes I just listen to them and I don’t eleven know why I am crying so hard..then you realize that there is something in their lyrics that hits you, helps you bring it to light instead of buying it, and then gives you a bit of hope to overcome. That is the genius of them, is that no matter how dark, they will always put some positivity or hopefulness in their songs, to remind you that there is some ray of light to cling to. Great reaction, keep them coming!
Gerçekten ruhunuzun naifliği beni de ekran başında etkiledi. Herkes tepki kanalı açabilir ancak çok az kişi bu işe gereken değeri verir. Bu güzel tepki ve yorumlarınız için çok teşekkürler. 💖
Well this reaction broke me. I really have grown to love your channel. As a very protective army I look for genuine people to react to our members and you guys are doing a wonderful job. Thank you for your beautiful reaction. We all cry with you. 💜🫂
Şarki ve şarkinin anlami🥺Spring day benim için çok özel.😢💜
This song was a very very risky move for the boys but they did it anyway. Thank you for reacting to this, took so much effort. I am grateful. 💜
No matter how many times I’ve watched those explanations, esp the one from Italian Army, I cry just as much😭
Both of you must be kind hearted, same BTS.. bless you all ❤
How a pure hearts y'all have so glad to the world there's a ppl like you 💜
Por favor reacciones a Like Crazy de Jimin presentación en vivo... asi podrás conocer su verdadera voz de angel
Patiently waiting for your next amazing reaction. I love all of you guys,Dilay is also so thoughtful for translating, Turkish is a beautiful language as well, its one of the languages I wish to learn. I'm glad you enjoyed spring day and the explanation as well, its touching.
PS: I don't want to take away from this beautiful reaction, but I think it would be really great if you guys could react to the live version of Magic shop as well as how magic shop has helped many people (maybe reading a few stories on how it helped them)and even saved lives. I think it'll show you how not only are BTS such talented and humble guys but their music and words are a form of healing for others. DILAY should definitely be part of the video if you guys decide to react to Magic Shop. All the love from Cape Town,South Africa, your reaction is what I looked forward to today after college.
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Este video lo he visto ya dos veces y lo volveré a repetir como ARMY sabemos lo que signifixo 😢❤ gracias chicos.
I have to say - maybe it's because I'm German, but those piles of clothes always remind me of the Holocaust. In IU's video for "Love wins all", they also used the Boltanski reference, but I have yet to find out, whether or not he himself was referencing Auschwitz with it. He had a jewish father as far as I know and in Auschwitz, they also piled up the clothes, the people wore upon their arrival there.
I get so extremely choked up and emotional about this, it's horrible.
And @Dilay: How precious are you to translate everything in handwriting for the boys? That's such a deep level of devotion, not only to BTS, their music and us viewers, but also to your boys. I hope you're being appreciated accordingly, it is not taken for granted. 💜
@Cagin: Never apologize for your tears. We all felt that. We got you, ARMY is a safe space.
It's not surprising the pile of clothes reminds you of the Holocaust. The French paper Le Figaro wrote this about Boltanski's installation 'Personnes' from 2010:
"Sous la nef du Grand Palais, Christian Boltanski présente en 2010 une installation monumentale qui évoque la Shoah sans y faire directement allusion. La pince d'une grue prélève inlassablement des habits tirés d'une pile d'une quinzaine de mètres et les relâche au hasard. Au sol, 69 «carrés» recouverts de vêtements étalés comme autant de pierres tombales. Le son, très fort, anime l'atmosphère glaciale de battements cardiaques recueillis par l'artiste à travers le monde. Le visiteur, guidé par des médiateurs, est immergé dans l'œuvre gigantesque selon le souhait du plasticien. Il n'est plus un simple spectateur."
Here's a video clip of the art installation: ua-cam.com/video/SXND1GZdBzM/v-deo.html
@@MakeMiniatures Merci pour l'explication. Je n'ai pas cherché dans les medias francaises.
@@evacaspers4053 You're welcome. I had the same association when I first saw the music video (also, memories, like Çağin said). Although I had not been to the exhibition, I knew about Boltanski's art installation, so I looked it up. I think the exhibition video, also the beginning with the stacked metal boxes with numbers on them, shows a strong association with the Holocaust. The only reference I could find was in Le Figaro.
I'm only 8:41 seconds into your reaction but I can tell you are really thinking about and interpreting the meanings to the song lyrics as well as the contents of the video. You don't know it yet, but many of the concepts you've mentioned are very close to what many think the song means and because music is open to interpretation, you aren't wrong and what you're saying is definitely one way to interpret it. Many reaction channels don't even try to talk about what they think it means, so not only are your interpretations appreciated but it demonstrates your own artistic sides. It is exposure to art, poetry, music that informs how we interact with and interpret the world or other people's work. 💜
I have loved your reactions so far, and I look forward to watching your channel grow. I love your sincerity and your thoughtful discussions/reactions to the music. Many people don't understand the allure of BTS, but songs like this, their bravery, and their sincerity to their art and fans change the world and give people connections, which many are lacking in today's fast-paced world.
There is a heartbreaking video on UA-cam where it’s news videos of the actual disaster playing out and the families waiting around for news. It is set to this song. It will forever stay with you. 💜💜💜
Thank you for supporting BTS and exploring their music...Army 💜
Me encanta ver su sensibilidad a flor de piel, cuídense 🍇💜
The ferry had been 'converted' which was not within the legal weight regulations and so was extremely overweight. A lot of the footage from the news crews was heartbreaking, the volunteer divers were willing to get the students out but were stopped by the coast guard... I'm guessing the only reason for this is so the ferry would sink and cover up all the corruption of the government and authorities.... rescue boats from civilians were turned away whilst the parents and families remained on the wharf still being able to see their children alive in the windows of the ferry as the crew were saved. Korean children are very polite and stayed in place because they were told to by the captain and crew. I doubt western teenagers would have remained in their cabins and would mostly, I imagine , have survived.
Nope.
It was because if someone rescued someone it needed to be the coastguard not civilians: it's a matter of "face"/station.
which is why the messages that were send up the command chain held so many lies and orders were given on a perceived "resolved" situation instead of the real one.
Holding on the "look good" even if it does not acomplish anything was important and as such overrode helping - which they couldn't do because they were not trained for that and had faulty equipment.
I heard that an US ship wanting to help was also send away.
I made it through about half a documentary were all these messages over the coast guard etc. was in before I couldn't do it anymore.
We in Europe and NA simply do not think like that.
This was so wholesome, I cried with you. THANK YOU FOR BEING SO GENUINE.My favourite reaction channel by far, looking forward to many more💜💜💜💜💜 BORAHAE
С уважением из России 🇷🇺, подписана на Вас и с удовольствием смотрю ваши видео и реакцию на прекрасных и талантливых мемберов BTS 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🫰❗❗❗
This make me cry every time 💜🇲🇽💜
Spring Day-this is the queen of all kpop songs. Thanks for the reaction. Greetings from St. Petersburg
감사합니다.
🙏🙏💜
Such a beautiful song the melody so respectful as to the story of this song so sad
Thank you for reacting to this… I know it was hard and I will always cry watching or learning more about this tragedy but I will never forget 🙏🏽💜
again and again, i am always amazed how the boys and the production team always put in details their messages through their lyrics , their music videos and that's the proof BTS is in another level. I am so proud of them 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I have seen this video and the Italian video, which I also recommend, several times and have learned that I must be feeling a certain amount of emotional strength in order to watch these videos again. Right now I am experiencing some medical issues that weigh heavily on me, so I will not be watching your reactions. HOWEVER, knowing your great hearts and empathy, I AM sending you my warmest and most loving hugs as a measure of consolation. Thank you for watching this video! 🫶🫰🙏💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜 💜💜
Bu şarkının her şeyi o kadar güzel ve anlamlıki sıkılmadan tüm gün dinleyebilirim anlamanı bilmeden dinlesen bile ayrı bir huzur veriyor
It's ok to still sing Spring Day in your closing if you feel like it. The music video reminds us to never forget the victims of the tragedy, but the lyrics alone can be meaningful in any circumstance, I think.
I do think about the tragedy when I hear Spring Day now, but I also think about those in my own life I miss, as well as being reminded to be thankful for my life & the lives of my family & friends who are still with me.
It's a beautiful song we can sing along with as both a tribute & with gratitude. Perhaps sometimes with sadness, but also with happiness, depending on what we're going through at the time. Maybe it makes it more important to sing it than ever. Borahae. 💜
Bu Mv'nin hikayesini tam anlamıyla ayrıntılı bilmiyordum :(
Gerçekten çok kötü hissettim . Teşekkür ederim bu konuyu açıkladığınız için ..
''BTS'' farkı güzellerimin, bir tane boş şarkısı yok!!
Thank you for taking the effort to write down and translate the text. Thank you for reaction.
Thank you so much for your reaction. I felt your sincerity and kind hearts…tears are okay. Never apologize for them. You have empathy and that is something beautiful 💜
Would like to give a bit of an info that Spring Day was actually inspired by a falling leaf that Namjoon saw while sitting at a park one autumn day. He thought of friends he had lost touch with and the different lives they now have - him growing some distance from them because of his public life as an idol. The music video on the other hand, was made to honor the Sewol Ferry victims and survivors. It has never been confirmed up to this day. But many ARMYs, even K-ARMY attest that it was indeed a commemoration of BTS to show unity and sympathy for the families left behind, especially when they visited the families together with Bang PD. It was only revealed much later by a parent of one of the students who passed away. BTS never publicized it, the same way they keep their philanthropy low key, but this music video was their way of giving light to what happened and giving a voice to those who were silenced by the government (a lot of people were targeted by the government for speaking up) Them visiting the families in one of the memorial services was also a brave act and it just showed that even back then (in 2016-2017) even if they didn’t have the global phenomenon status they have now, they chose to use their influence in a positive way. BTS (and Bang PD) are genuinely kind, good human beings, and that is why they are so blessed with so much love from their fandom 💕💜
자세하고 정확한 설명입니다. 그시기에 정부가 싫어하는 발언을 한 아티스트들은 블록리스트에 포함되어 아티스트활동에 대한 제한을 받았기에 공식적으로 세월호참사와 관련된 기부와 기타 활동들은 어쩌면 위험에 처할수도 있었습니다. 그럼에도 방탄과 그의 회사는 숨어있지않았습니다.
Spring Day is our Queen and we all love her very much. Most armys cry at the video no matter how many times we watch it so no worries for your tears little brother. I always enjoy your thoughtful reactions. Reacting to Spring Day and it's meaning is part of becoming an army. KDiamonds will never let her fall from the charts, ever. Because of this and other things many armys have promised the members of BTS to seek justice, fight racism, and activily try to make the world a better place, just like they make this world a better place for armys. When we say that BTS have meaningful lyrics....
Sending loads of hugs to our boys and you too Dilay 😢 beautiful reaction, so respectful and emotional. Thank you for your hard work of translating the video for them. 💜💜💜
Who would have thought as an English person I would watch a Turkish reactor, reacting to a Korean song. So many different language levels, but Spring Day is a masterpiece and while it breaks my heart every time it is also an exceptional piece of art, that moves us all intensely. Thank you for your openness and sensitivity.
and please, never ever apologize for what you're feeling, or how you express it. one of the things we love about bts is the transparency, even in regards to their emotions. whether you are sad, happy, angry... it's okay and very normal, human to feel and and not hide it
Está bien llorar no lo lamentes por eso, es una muestra muy sincera de su empatía 💜. Gracias Dilay por tomarte el trabajo de traducirles el video explicativo. Es un hecho que el cápitan del ferry actuó de manera egoísta y cruel. Vi videos muy tristes de como algunos estudiantes se despedian de sus familias en una llamada 😭. Muchos siguieron la orden de permanecer en su puesto y perdieron la vida por seguir las reglas.😢
Albüm reaksiyonları bekliyorum ya... Bence tüm klipleri 2şer 3er izleyip BTS'in kısa film olaylarına da girebilirsiniz. O teori oluşturma süreci çok zevkliydi wings dönemi ve öncesinde