A Quiet Place Part II - How to Ruin a Franchise in 7 Seconds | Anatomy Of A Failure
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 лип 2021
- Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today’s video! Get 20% OFF + Free International Shipping + 2 Free Gifts with promo code “FILMENTO20” at mnscpd.com/Filmento
A Quiet Place Part 2 directed by John Krasinski continues the story of 2018's A Quiet Place, starring Emily Blunt and Cillian Murphy, and not very well so. Writing wise, this monster horror movie sequel is on the level of the likes of the Nun and The Curse La Llorona, which originates from the fact that they moved on to make it without the original writers who created the whole thing. So in today's Anatomy of a Failure, let's see how A Quiet Place Part II drops the ball and ruins the original movie.
Support: / filmento
Follow: / filmento
#AQuetPlace #AnatomyOfAFailure
-
A Quiet Place Part II (2021)
Following the deadly events at home, the Abbott family (Emily Blunt, Millicent Simmonds, Noah Jupe) must now face the terrors of the outside world as they continue their fight for survival in silence. Forced to venture into the unknown, A Quiet Place - How to Ruin Fear in 7 Seconds A Pictures Curse of La Llorona - Making the Worst Horror Film of All Time everything wrong with a quiet place 2 a quiet place part 2 honest trailer watch a quiet place part 2 movie online 4k clip hd a quiet place 2 a quiet place 2 review a quiet place 2 ending explained rant port scene monster scene a quiet place part 2 kill count monster scene beartrap a quiet place 2 first 10 minutes how to beat a quiet place mosnter creature fallen angels explained a quiet place 2 full movie they quickly realize that the creatures that hunt by sound are not the only threats that lurk beyond the sand path. Directed by John Krasinski.
-
A Quiet Place (2018)
In this tense thriller set in the not-so-distant future a family must live in complete silence to avoid creatures that hunt through sound. The parents, played by (John Krasinski and Emily Blunt), must come up with ingenious ways to protect their children and outsmart the terrifying monsters as they attempt to go about their daily lives. Directed by John Krasinski.
-
The Curse of La Llorona (2019)
Director/co-writer Michael Chaves’s horror film draws supernatural inspiration from Mexican folklore. In 1970s Los Angeles, a social worker discovers that the children under her care are being pursued by the Weeping Woman: avengers endgame reaction curse of la llorona cinemasins everything wrong with the curse of la llorona reaction a female ghost who abducts living children because she lost her own child. She turns to a priest for assistance in warding off the terrifying maternal spectre. - Фільми й анімація
If I'm in trouble again... check out Manscaped with a special Filmento discount of 20% off plus 2 free gifts and free shipping, using code FILMENTO20: mnscpd.com/Filmento
@@Studio-yi2bm huh?
Indie movie about paying rent
I watched it in cinema, and its a 6/10
Meh.
Filmento you could make a review of city of god a Brazilian movie
I love the effort and passion you put into ALL of your videos! But please make some POSITIVE videos about movies that you LIKE, because most of them are about what movies do wrong. Your videos on The Pirates of The Caribbean series are some of my favorites because we all got to see the *FUN AND POSITIVE* side of you for a change
That actually is a good idea to kill the monsters. Buy a boat, live in the water and use sound to attract them so they can drown to death.
Poe Dameron: They fly now!?
Probably
if im not wrong they didn't attracted from the sound of waterfall in the first movie, i didn't watch the sequel
Wait how did the navy get destroyed
@@epicblue00 look up the USS Liberty incident
@@kahjethegreat8075 I did and what does that have to do with it
“The sequel to ‘A Quiet Place’ we bring you ‘A Slightly Louder Place’.”
the prequel should be called A Loud Place
A Quiet Place 2: Quiet Harder.
Don't you mean "A Less Quiet Place"?
A Quiet Place Part III: Crazy Noisy Bizarre Town
im using that.
When the first one ended, I just assumed in my Head Cannon, that they would hook up a speaker system on the farm constantly playing extremely high frequencies to deter any monsters nearby and immobilize them if they get too close. Seemed like a pretty obvious next step. You have the weakness, so everything you do now should be in favor of exploiting the weakness.
I did too.
How would they power that for constant use?
@@virginiapicker Hmm. I mean if they don't have to worry about the monsters much anymore I assume they could perhaps use those kinds of spinnable cranks to make electricity, take turns and save up a resevoir or just use the waterfall to spin said cranks
@@virginiapicker The issue wouldn't be power, they likely have ways to get enough power, and if they can kill them that now includes loud generators. The issue is ammo
@@LimblessAnt this film establishes that they can be beaten to death by a little girl and an aluminum pole. You don't even need ammo to kill them, they're basically jello on the inside apparently
Imagine if the beginning had them rely on the feedback method where they were killing a few with ease only to stumble upon a variant where that same weakness doesnt apply. That overconfidence killing one of them or causing a traumatic incident
Well, hope it knows how to swim too
I was thinking of a scene where they are using the feedback thing, and one monster escapes, and we later see a scene where it heals it’s head with like a harder shell or something
*I have to completely disagree with you on this one. I absolutely loved this movie 🎬 and can't wait for the third.*
Or, possibly, just accidently dropping the hearing aid and it breaks, and the movie is them finding another functional hearing aid. Those pieces of shit are expensive but they can break super easy. Or hell, they need batteries. Have them run out of batteries and they need to find something else to use or something, anything.
That could have been a good way to kill off the dad and also rise the steaks
It was just an alright movie that doesn't add enough or change much about the concept to justify a sequel. It feels like DLC to the first movie.
Oh my god,it does.
I personally was more than fine with a dlc of the first
Its not the Ringed City/Blood And Wine dlc tho
And that's saying a lot cuz the original was already kinda flawed, and mediocre to begin with.
It's not empire strike back but the last Jedi. Every characters lose iq points for plots
This reminds me of my problem with The Walking Dead, these things would never win over humanity. If some random family in the middle of nowhere can find and exploit their weaknesses so easily I think governments across the world would be able to also
For that reason I liked the novel "World War Z", in which humanity actually wins the zombie virus outbreak. Good spin on the genre and the "logistics" behind a zombie crisis.
Not really I mean in a situation where there possibly thousands of those thing across the globe and trying to kill them with standard gun won't work what else can they do and I mean they did find a weakness they can drown which the national guard exploited which is why that island had people in the first place
@@Gnabba Almost in every zombie movie humans win
@@RANDOM-pf1ve but do they end the zombie pandemic completely with states and military still intact?
In most cases the lone survivers win their struggle to survive in a lawless destroyed world, iIrc.
Honestly to me the only zombie like apocalypses that would mean the death for humanity is Resident Evil(not the movies,fuck those),Left for Dead, The Last of Us and Call of Duty Zombies which is surprising since all of those are from games which normally up the danger level as opposed to most movie zombie movies/franchises.
Its ironic to see the mother crying in front of somebody because she’s “sad” while in the previous movie, if you breathed too loudly, your organs would be turned inside-out in the next 10 seconds
That’s insane how the ones who created this masterpiece are the ones who didn’t get any talk show time, they didn’t get any love and they didn’t even get called back to make a part 2
If you like horror movies, they also did a pretty good film called Haunt.
Masterpiece? Even the first one was filled with plot holes
The sequel made me realize it would have made a better Series than a Movie.
Like the walking dead
@@skeegyskeegy355 yea but only like 2 seasons not 11
@@adog4398 I think three seasons, 20 episodes each would get the job done.
@@joshuaseraphin8712 nah i feel like after 2 seasons you would be milking it. Only saying this because it woulf just be a rinse and repeat like twd imo
@@adog4398 If you already have a plot already laid out it could work, just don't drag any story plots that don't need to be dragged.
Ik it's different from a show with real people but I think attack on titan does a great job of this, and there going to work on season 4 part 2.
Funny story: when the bear trap scene came up, I was horrified at first...and then I thought of that one Robot Chicken sketch with the gummy bear, at which point I accidentally burst out laughing in the theater.
i was scared when the kid was locked in the boiler with the baby
I'm so happy cus I'm a gummy bear gummy bear
I thought of that scene from Severance.
If you haven't seen the film, watch it. It's hysterical.
I just watched this and thought the same lmao 🤣🤣
Lmao!
Thank you 3 billion for sending me here: ua-cam.com/video/PIC9eFvKpfA/v-deo.html
First movie: "I promise the mother will lead the family."
Second movie: "Here is the new dad."
What's the problem? The father is the one who leads the family, it's just the mom when there's no father.
@@juregaumhidratado4785
THIS is the problem
@@MissMedeiros what's the problem? A man doing his duty or the presence of one?
@@juregaumhidratado4785 I mean, it kind of takes away the importance of the death of the father, because it immediately replaces him with another strong protector man, instead of, how it was said on the video, the family adapting to losing one of the members and making the mother or the girl take the lead. But no here's your "man doing his duty" in replacement of the father act like nothing has happened
What you on about dude.
The guy(Cillian Murphy) did not have nearly as prominent a role as John Krasinski had in the first film.
This film was about the kids.
The first film was about parents protecting their kids.
This film was about letting go of your kids so they can stand on their own.
Was it ever explained why a furnace wouldn't have oxygen going into it? You know, considering a healthy oxygen supply is required for making a furnace work efficiently.
Could the intake perhaps be sealed off with a systems of valves?
This movie was all sorts of cringe 😖 The main characters NEVER learn their lesson. They’re not forced into danger. They do stupid stuff to get themselves into it.
To put out the fires efficiently would you not have a valve to close off all oxygen to it so when you're done you can another it quickly and leave? Without making it wet so when you come back it's dry and easy to relight
I figured it was a fermentation chamber, which does have to be airtight, but I don’t remember if they said so.
@@jasperzatch610 The answer here is no. Extinguishing the flame with a lack of oxygen as opposed to letting it burn out leads to residue making it burn less efficiently and harder to relight. You really want all the fuel to clean burn.
would've been neat if the consequence of using its sound weakness and a gun shot, you'd attract a massive horde shooting a loud gun out in the open. It wouldn't have really contradicted with the first either.
I have to say that when I saw the movie, it seemed to me like that's exactly how it works?
It doesn’t really contradict the first one doe, after the first one they killed many that were in the area and traveled to a different area so there would be other alien things but less since they cleared an area of them already
Or just build a house by a waterfall. Jk jk. Kinda
Exactly why I think that Filmentos rant about the “worst 7 seconds” is IMO pointless. They attracted another monster, and possibly many others, creating a lot of tension when considering they have limited ammo.
i think that was the assumption of the movie, but indeed we never see hords of them only few at once...
indeed stupid
Reality as a bear trap is the most realistic thing I’ve ever seen.
He wouldnt be able to walk the whole film if it was realistic
Yeah really, @@IamMacias.
He would've survived if surgically amputated, idk how did he do that wouthoit
@@IamMacias No no he could walk, on a stump.
soy
A quiet place was genuinely never meant to have a sequel simple as that
Whilst shunning the original writers out of the crew and hiring new ones thinking they know the world any better
I recall reading that John Krasinski didn't want to be involved in the sequel but got talked into it eventually.
@@wildman2012 I could see it. I mean theres literally no room for a sequel, the whole concept was played out after one movie and they already figured out how to kill the creatures so the problem was solved
$ talks
Well, true but I think if done right it could have been good, exploring this world further and showing what happened when they first got here
A definite problem lately is how a lot of sequels aren't actual continuations of the story or further explorations into established worlds but instead are just franchise installments, whose main purpose are to ensure some sequels and/or spinoffs. It felt like a lot of this film's goal was to set up part three, which will probably be, "This time... WE FIGHT BACK! ...but quietly."
This was an actual continuation of the first film. The second film opens with a prologue showing the Audience the start of this apocalyptic nightmare. The main characters continue the narrative.
A franchise instalment would be more akin to 10 cloverfield lane. In that sequel there is no direct continuation in narrative nor are any of the original characters back in the sequel.
You need to understand the difference between sequels and franchise instalments.
@@master-of-mind5881 Studios are focusing way too much on creating franchises instead of just making the individual films. This is clearly the case with AQP 2 and that was my point.
@[L A Y L A]- Go To My ChanneI! L!VE NOW I get what you're saying, but AQP2 made the mistake of treating the aliens like the players instead of the humans. It might have been better if it had introduced stronger aliens who were impervious to the methods that were figured out in the first one, instead of inexplicably not being able to hear as well and not being able to swim. In keeping with your videogame comparison, it'd be like if the enemies became easier to defeat as the game progressed and that really doesn't work in games or movies. Maybe they'll change course with the next one, but I'm not really getting my hopes up for part three...
I know, right after I finished this movie with my mom I just said to her, "They're milking this series for all it's got." I really enjoyed the first movie with how clever it was and liked the second movie well enough but I feel like they are just ruining this franchise by furthering it. The main allure to the first movie was the mystery surrounding the creatures and the isolation that the family had to face due to them, they had to use their own wits to survive and this franchise just makes them seem dumber in the new movie.
The whole time I was actually waiting for the hearing aid's battery to die. (Which is an actual problem they're gonna have to eventually face). Maybe part 3?
Give it part 6
That would’ve been perfect for this sequel. For her hearing aid’s battery to die and then needing to either find another or a battery or some way to charge it because without that feedback, they can’t fight the monsters. Giving the monsters some of their fear back.
Terrible Movie. I was so bored.
@@dinomightstudios4119 seriously, their secret safety net is then gone and if they didn’t have a way to replace the battery, how would they go about explaining the tone to the rest of the world. Surely not everyone has the skills to make a machine to produce that sound, especially when people haven’t been collecting speakers or noisy electronics since people discovered that sound lured the monsters. Add in the fact other frequencies don’t work, and suddenly the family has a serious issue to solve
@@sambrandner You’re acting as if this is real life and not a movie… just write in a scene where they manage to find a new battery or is able to fully recharge it. Simple. It’s a movie, they’ll find what they’re looking for if that’s what the writers write.
Maybe they met some people along the way who they may have tried to help, the people realize the power of her hearing aid, and then steal it from her! Now the mom and her kids would have to fight to get her daughters hearing aid back, because they NEED it. It would eliminate that new male character they introduced, but he was random and not needed for this sequel anyway. It should’ve still focused on the mom and her kids.
There’s many different ways they could’ve written more a more structured storyline that presents the characters with real obstacles and challenges for this SEQUEL. That’s all we’re commenting about.
for being a movie called “A quiet place”, it was quite loud honestly honestly compared to the first
Bear trap Scene 🤣
This was exactly what I posted on Facebook lol....gotta love the irony
@@noelv1976 I watched it in theaters and it was loud as HELL. If it was transformers sure, but a quiet place? You can tell this wasnt made by the same creators of the first
@@JujuInFlames you slow asf
@@solol2909 Not really. Just you
It's been brought up a couple of times, so I thought I'd chime in. The whole medical kit scene does have a purpose if you pay attention to every shot. While walking up to the train, the camera tilts up reveling that Reagan is leaving bloody footprints as she walks along the railroad ties. The next morning when her and Emmett head out on their journey, she is seen with her feet bandaged up with gauge and tape. The benefit of going barefoot and walking on sand is no longer an option, shoes are the better choice, although they have their downsides in many ways. Emmett wears boots throughout the entire movie and it seems he never came up with the sand technique as the Abbott family did.
Also, Reagan leaving bloody footprints makes it very easy for Emmett to track her down, making the last second save on the train much more believable.
Right? I really thought this guy was more competent than that.
I watched this review and decided to go watch both films back to back simply out of boredom (and cuz i am a baby and dont care for horror but figured i knew enough about them that i could sit through them) and I have to say Im quite enjoying them, simply because they *dont* spell out the necessity for everything every second to the audience. As you said, paying attention to small details is just as important as when the film decides to zoom in on a piece of important info (i.e the nail or the mom's calendar in the first film). So far ive been emotionally invested in both films, the characters have clear motivations, they have an active hand in the plot versus the plot just happening around them, and they are multi-dimensional characters. Im not saying these films are peak cinema but they have a good concept and in my opinion, execute it well enough for me personally to enjoy and be immersed in it. Maybe others will dislike it based on this or that, I know my mom would be bored by this time of storytelling and lack of action for example, but I like em.
Id say my only big flaw with the first one was (potentially me missing a detail) on how the monster got in with the mom during the flooded basement scene (did Lee not cover the entrance? was it attracted by the water? I might have to rewatch it to catch it) and how they have to be kind of irresponsible parents in the beginning of the film to let the plot point of the son's death happen (Maybe it was just my parents or too much survival horror but my mom hardly ever had me, at that age, walking where she couldnt see if we were out in public, and i feel that parenting method would go double for a world like this one, and i personally felt that the parents should at least be capping the line of them walking home; dad at the front, mom at the back, for instance, instead of them just letting their kids wander behind them where they couldnt see)
Regardless of my small nitpicks for literally like, two scenes, everything else I've enjoyed far more than I thought I would especially based on some reviews ive watched on youtube.
I think if the audience had to put in all the head work, they'd doing that for better purposes in their general life. Your point about the first aid kit and the bloody prints are fair but that does not undermine, in the least bit, the fact that characters in the movie series (even in the first one) were dumb AF. Hey, so there's an apocalypse out there and I might die if I did something as normal and human as sneezing? Huh, seems like the perfect time for me to abandon my mum, brother, a baby brother with a total fucking stranger, take away their only saving grace, and go out and try to save the world that very well may not even exist for no fucking reason at all. Assuming that the people who know their genre and are watching the movie for more than just dumb monster horror fodder, will make peace with 90-minutes of this stupidity, is worse than expecting them to pay attention to the "small details". If I've to pay attention like I'm sitting in a quantum theory lecture, then I'd be doing the latter because the horror element is present there as well.
She didn’t leave with a stranger. She went by her self to get help for her family and show other people how to fight back. Also that ”stranger” was a family friend.
I've wondered why it took this one girl to be able to find the weakness, when there are millions of people using hearing aids just like hers. Then, I've wondered why people didn't create a perimeter of speakers with that feedback on a 24/7 loop, where they would be able to live normally while inside that perimeter.
Batteries lol
In regards to your first question: there is nothing that says she's the first. But whether or not she is, it seems she is the only one in this particular area who's either still alive and/or still has functioning aids. Also, if there is someone else who figured it out, communication isn't easy. Doubtful that they'd be able to spread the info.
@@Tijjain Honestly a major goverment probably managed to find that out eventually. Jet planes, ect. They'd just hole up in a bunker with a few of those things trapped. Sooner or later someone will think, "Hey these things seem to like sound, what if we try different sounds??". Cue people using tanks with giant speakers or something to make the monsters go away.
Because we're following this family's story, not others? in The Walking Dead, we had to see them evolve and figure out new things and later discovered that there are communities that were able to get way ahead of what they found so far and were more organized. I don't see how that's an issue in a world where it's near impossible to communicate with people.
true but it would take time, effort and silence to establish something like that. their attempt could them all killed because the aliens can hear almost everything
Imagine traveling through space with zero oxygen for years, and then drowning within seconds.
It's not about that. When they open their heads there are very sensitive ears inside. Imagine the confusion they would have if the ground suddenly disappeared under them and they would hear their own frantic splashing in the water that would get in their ears. Also they are described to have armor that is so bulletproof, it can stop a sniper rifle round (.50 cal). Go out and try to swim when you weight like half a ton and don't know how to mechanicaly move your limbs to stay above water
@@M3RS. ...... really?
@@M3RS. in The first movie they can swim
@@Genburthing
You mean in the basement where the water was just waste height and they could walk on the bottom?
That's different from swimming
@@M3RS. did you really just say .50mm
In a world where music/radio is practically death, why the hell would they put a message in music? At least send some sort of natural sound through the radio. Like emit birds chirping morse code so people can listen to it without having to worry about alerting monsters.
They don't target humans. Birds chirping is pretty abrasive, and these things are from another planet. They probably kill the birds, too.
@@seanm.3481 I think they killed a racoon in the first movie
@@seanm.3481 Yeah but bird sounds are so common, they probably see it as more of a background noise now. I mean they dont attack every single sound. Else they'd just go ham on a waterfall all day long.
@@manchmalpfosten8133 I like to think that they totally did attack waterfalls at first before learning that water doesn't die when slashed at.
Eh not everyone knows morse code and I doubt they'd be able to edit a sound bite together with the more than limited resources they have so the music thing was a better choice
Hold on, but at 12:00 she DID spread it to others by going to the radio that was playing. That was the entire plot device for the second film. For her to go to where the radio tower that was still playing music, and begin broadcasting the sounds so that others could fight back against the monsters.
And that's a different ending to the original.
I’m glad this guy didn’t seem to have a problem with the opening scene. That was the highlight of the movie for me and I thought it was great.
Only good thing
In the 1st, when the dad died and told the girl he loved her, it was a perfect emotional highpoint that drove everything home, which u really don't see in horror movies, today, anymore, plot-wise. It was the most impactful part of the story, for me. This 1 had nothing remotely close to that type of story telling & I just felt disappointed
True, nothing did hot as hard. But it built on a fascinating lore and Emmett was good. So many apocalypse films take cynicism as a good thing, so seeing a decent character do good things to help a family friend out was really nice to watch. Though there were moments where he had to be pulled.
I watched this with my brother in law and our friend, since it was her first time seeing it. When the dad died, she was bawling and went "this movie is stupid!" and kept crying even after the movie ended. It was quite funny, but well warranted since that scene really was impactful.
Sorry but his death was pretty generic. There were alot of contradictions(with basic logic) in that first movie that people don't want to admit. Namely how the little girl even figured out their weakness or the faulty sand trail logic to begin with. Try walking on sand or gravel it definitely doesn't make you quieter.
She and the other kid are taking the mantle and learn how to defeat the monsters and exploring the world. This movie is great. John added some new things.
I thought when the son finally stood up for himself and killed the monster at the end, while the daughter does the same on the island, both showing how much they take after their dad was the emotional highpoint, at least for me it was.
I honestly find it so hard to believe that the military couldn't handle this at all. I understand these things are virtually impossible to kill, but at the same time, it seems so illogical that the military isn't even around.
What the Navy doin
My thoughts exactly, I assume there would be a Navy out there. Once it found the monster’s weakness, it would become a shooting gallery.
@@ATankEnjoyer i refuse to believe the US 7th fleet died to these fuckers.
@@julienrooknizan5711 Me too, I believe they’re just out there waiting on someone to broadcast the knowledge of the weakness. Then they send helicopters in pairs, one with a massive speaker, and the other has a guy with a Barrett.
@@ATankEnjoyer Apocalypse now style
I enjoyed the movie, but the daughter going off by herself, when she’s at a huge disadvantage by being deaf, is very silly. Also, the mom decided to go off to get medical supplies, and only mentions it to the son as a sort of afterthought, as she’s going out the door. Then the son wandering around the factory by himself? 😂
But I still enjoyed it 👏 🍿🥤
I think he knew about it since she instructed him on how to take care of the baby, but followed her to try to stop her. Now why he wandered around the factory that's on him lol
i think he was just bored or he had gone up to the factory so he could have a height advantage and see where his mum is or if emmet and his sister are coming as well
You're kidding yourself if you think this franchise can't "recover". If there's a third film made, the casual viewers will absolutely eat it up no question and it'll be a massive success.
They mean quality not box office.
Whoever decided to put “why are you running? Why are you running?” in there needs a raise 😂😂
i know right hahaha
I was dying lmao reminded me of the Halloween episode of American dad lol
The sound editing of the entire video killed me everytime.
It’s distracting nonsense.
@Mia - Sᴇx Cʜᴀɴɴᴇʟ 18+🅥 they probably dont know that apes cant swim.
If video games has taught me anything about story telling, taking away optimal strategies from the player is one of the most effective ways to make them feel helpless... The best part is how it can apply to any genre.
The reason that the people on the island had to send a cryptic message through the radio station was because they didn't want the crazy cannibal people to come.
Why wouldn't they be able to encrypt the message?
@@EmyN Indeed. Seems a bit convenient that the cannibal people, having access to a load of boats, haven't yet decided to explore the island that isn't that far to travel to.
They could have had a huge abandoned ferry full of those monsters be slowly floating towards the island so there is a constant countdown and sense of dread for what’s gonna happen when it finally reaches them. Then at the end have the deaf girl put her hearing aid to the radio mic allowing the whole island to use it to defeat all The monsters when they land.
Hollywood give me money
I wasn't nearly as emotionally invested in this movie as I had been in the first one, but I couldn't quite figure out why, or put it into words, so thanks for doing that; in hindsight, the boy's appalling dumbness when leaving the bunker must have been what made me lose interest, or the guy's convenient last second save in the train wagon.
By that logic a last second save or characters idiocy pulls you right out of any movie.that literally in like 99 percent of movies
@@jjonahjameson8934 It depends. When I am watching some random action/horror flick, these things normally don't bother me, however, when I expect a movie to be "something else", like I did this one, such cliches become a real bummer.
@@jjonahjameson8934 last second saves are insulting to me...bah, Im too evolved for Hollywood, sucks that they wont even let me veg out on some movie because Im just too smart for it all.
@@cadu7698 the dad being dead was one thing that made me a bit less emotionally invested this time.
I loved this movie. I don’t watch movies for logic I watch movies for story. Tell me any fictional story with the best logistics….
There are none. A story is a beginning, middle and end that’s it. In the context of movies it’s how it makes you feel. Sure I questioned some moments that broke suspension of disbelief (creature casually riding the boat) but I was curious to know how the characters would survive the entire movie or how it would end.
The whole point of these two movies is to portray a family who are forced to survive the worst case scenario, they lose a lot but it’s a story or how to use your weaknesses into strengths. It’s intimate and tight. Not an overblown militarised action horror bonanza.
The film’s biggest strengths is its performances and directing. I was emotionally invested in these characters and the execution of the dark angels is solid. If a movie makes me feel scared, nervous, tense throughout then it’s done it’s Job simple.
They should have made it so the monsters learn how to close their ears when they hear the noise, it would close their existing weakness, and open up a new weakness for the characters to exploit, since the monsters wouldn’t be able to hear while the noise is going
They made it, it was a success, they're going to make a 3rd one so this guy can bitch on all day long.
@@SuperOmnicronsj44 honestly I agree
Honestly that would be really cool. If the monster survives it the first time, it adapts to it and loses the weakness while developing a new, albeit less lethal one. Could have been dope.
Well with a monster that only knows how to kill and can't swim you can't really say their smart
@@ChuckBoi8545 either way they made the monsters incredibly unthreatening
14:46 was gold, and even Djimon's expression after seems to reflect the alternative dialogue. I was also expecting the islanders to be harboring a deeper secret...that they were cannibals or something, luring newcomers to their place. (perhaps that would've been too much like Terminus in TWD). That would've made this a whole lot more interesting and amped up the threat. Alas....
I'm pretty sure that the reason they ran away after killing the first creature was because they don't exactly have infinite amounts of bullets. They have to limit how many times they use the bullets and if they rinsed and repeated they would eventually ran out and now have no bullets for an emergency case... I thought that was pretty obvious
I could be wrong, but didn't they killed a bunch of them without bullets in the first movie? Like ramping up the volume, I remember some of the aliens literally exploded.
@@blackest3314 no, they just killed one in the first movie.
@@blackest3314 nope, the noise only stunned them, which is when they used the shotgun to shoot it’s head when the inside was exposed
Thank you this reviewer has a lot of shit takes
Don’t leave the farm, have the mom take the corpse back under ground where they can make sound. Take the scales and build an armor for yourself…. Oh yeah baby.
Hey filmento. Can you do Dolittle? The Robert Downey Jr one.
@@jariel2568 link?
The guy who played Iron Man gets farted in the face by a dragon.
No
Ewww no
Anatomie of a Failure lol
I was really hoping that they showed more of the past and how the "invasion" spread throughout the world, even on how the military responded but we only got day one for a few minutes which was interesting at first but was not enough and therefore was disappointing. Another thing that was important to note and was missing in the movie was that they may have found out the weakness of the creatures but did not have to deal with large numbers of them in the movie which lost the factor of tension by not being displaced by the idea that they can be killed.
I was hoping for more stuff about the beginning of the invasion too. And all the parts we did see from day 1 were already shown in the trailer, so it kinda ruined any element of surprise
Yea honestly from watching the trailers I thought the whole movie was going to be a prequel and show the beginning of the invasion but it only showed day 1 and only a few minutes of it at that. Which was highly disappointing, but I still enjoyed it. The first one was far better though in my opinion. I might just be biased though since I love John Krasinski
@@blainejackson2857 Still trying to figure out, with how ruthlessly efficient they were in small town USA, that there were ANY functioning printing presses to make the magazines and newspapers wondering aloud about where the creatures came from that he collected in the basement...
I thought the whole movie would be a mix of both as google said it was a prequel and a sequel so the whole movie I was waiting for it to flash back to what I was interested in
I mean im just confuse on why sonic weapon werent use.
Playing Halo music while talking about someone new ruining it was truly poetry.
The reason why he spoke to the deaf girl was in hopes she could read his lips as the movie made it very clear that Killian was not proficient in sign language. Also as a whole the reason why they run from the monsters is because as a mother you would be concerned about your kid who just steped in a bear trap rather than trying to kill every alien in the area.
I think he knows why, it’s more the point of why write yourself into that corner to begin with. I was expecting the movie to take us on a journey with the original family too, they do come across as side characters in their own movie
Couldn't he have just mouthed the words to her instead though?
He doesn't actually have to be audible for her to understand
The sequel just exemplifies the question of “how the hell did it get this bad, there’s no way the monsters could’ve beaten every military and genius scientist around the world”
Right. Cause its like. Okay,fine. Bulletproof carapace. But they obviously have squishy insides that need to stay in tact to survive. The thing about high yield weaponry is that it doesnt matter if you stop the projectile. The kinetic energy still travels through and will fuck up any squishy bits on the inside. That's why its pointless to make/wear body armor that can stop 50BMG. Not only would the armor weigh to much to be functional. But it would still probably kill you even if you stopped the round. Because the force would be enough to fuck up your insides.
It's like a small car accident.
I mean, the Navy alone is effectively immune from attack. As is every island nation, for that matter. And anyone living near a waterfall or other noisy environment.
The future predator from Primeval is a *better* monster than this no need for armor for it is speedy… no need for a clever weakness cause it is powerful enough… and it also has numbers but they act more as a military unit… also echolocation these if ya don’t know are bats
@@berserkasaurusrex4233 other than the fact that after a certain period they'd just be stranded without supplies or fuel
The creatures were sent all over the world and most likely caused everyone to scramble due to how sudden and powerful their invasion was
At this point, Filmento is not doing AoaF's of a Quiet Place. He's building an Epic 7-Second Trilogy.
Perhaps we'll soon have a 7-Second Cinematic Universe.
When the third one comes out and its actually good and filmento makes "How to save a movie in 7 seconds"
The Good Ending
Great example showing Aliens as a horror (and that was also scifi) sequel done right.
You get to build off the things that makes the xenomorph terrifying (chest burst, great hunter, etc) and now have a whole hive full of them after destroying a colony.
I love how the movie starts off making you feel secure with a warship full of well armed marines then it all goes to shit soo quickly you find yourself in a survival situation.
Great horror movie done right example.
Omg the editing is what makes this video pure gold I love it
In Part 1, they were able to scare the audience off with a nail on the stairs. I wished the bear trap had the same feeling.
Exactly!
It shouldve been like when the mom was pregnant. The kid trying to hold in the scream but then eventually giving in to the pain and letting out a scream. damn this movie was disappointing
"Maybe have the family spreading that tool to fight the creatures to the world" Is this not exactly what they were doing with the radio tower
You can really tell that they weren't paying too much attention. This is literally the most significant scene in the movie. I can't tell if he just thinks the radio randomly started playing the monsters weakness or if he knows there was something behind it.
I also didn't get why they didn't understand why the girl needed the first aid kit. Her feet were bleeding all over the rail road tracks. They showed it several times lol
@@KaylaMarie_ True, but even without that injury, having something like that on hand is always smart. Better to have it when you don't need it than not have it when you do need it.
yeah i feel like a lot of the negatives ive heard people bring up just come from them literally not paying attention??
@@doclinny That seems to be the case for a lot of movies
While I love these videos for pinpointing why some movies feel so unsatisfying or simply provide interesting filmmaking discussions, it’s the hilarious editing like at 4:40 that keeps me coming back.
You said something about the first one being a completely new concept but I feel they were inspired by bird box. Inspired in the best way where they then created their own story.
Remember guys, there being an anatomy of a failure video on a movie doesn’t necessarily mean Filmento is saying it’s a failure. It’s just the name of the series where he analyzes how a movie can be improved.
he has the word "failure" in the thumbnail.
@@piercesimmons494 That’s just how the thumbnails for this series are formatted. He’s said multiple times that the name of the series doesn’t necessarily mean that the movie he’s talking about is good or bad.
WHO CARES WHAT HE SAYS
@@nestorperena8629 I care :))
he says its one of the worst horror sequels at the start of the video lmao
I think the reason why they couldn't just weaken and shoot every creature early in the film was; limited radius for the speaker feedback, and limited ammo of course. If like 10 creatures came I feel like they'd lose.
cant they just bludgeoned the creatures if they ran out of ammo
@@lominse body armor very dense.
I enjoyed the opening scene that takes place when the aliens/monsters arrived on earth. I also really liked some of the cinematography and camera work. And I love the way that the aliens/monsters move around. Other than those things I felt like the sequel was pretty bland.
That was probably the only good scene in the movie.
agree
your comments are spot on. The opening scene really was very well done. But then it petered out...
"-so desperate for money that needs to claim all filmento's internet videos"
lmao, that got me!
Lo mismo pensé, sobre todo con el lanzamiento de Paramount+ acá en México y sus comerciales piteros (I'm assuming you speak Spanish because your user name).
It felt like more of a survival movie than horror. Or in other case, with horror sprinkled in it.
You felt like it was; not that it was.
Maybe it uses both genres, usually they are correlated
I've always thought it was a survival movie
I feel like if someone went into the movie not being told a genre, they would enjoy it a lot as is, instead of having a certain expectation for something more horror
It PG-13 what did u except.
Your edits always kill me 😂
First thought that came to mind for me in terms of the feedback loop thing is a sort of..."Fight or Flight" type thing. Where, yes the feedback thing could cause them to pause and become vulnerable if you are lucky. But this one could also have the exact opposite response and book it straight towards you in a rage. So the weakness is still there but you also have to be careful whether you want to test your luck or no.
Can we handle this thing coming straight at us in a rage if it does not work how we want? Even if we can't do we have any other choice? Ect. Another one would be....well it IS a very loud noise so making it a "Yea you get a kill, but now every monster in a however big radius knows your location and is coming for you".
Movie was alright, one of the best scenes for me was when the boy (I forgot the name) got caught in the bear trap, the acting was super good! The raw emotion and pain you can hear in the scream after the adrenaline runs off was enough to make my spine chill.
I couldn't stop because of his scream plus he didn't scream like that in the first one if so I don't know how they survived with him
Marcus
When that happened, I was gasping and so shocked!!! It was an excellent scene.
@@raemmelparker9012 he didnt get his leg caught in a bear trap before
“Maybe the counter-argument for this is the baby”
I will turn a monster into a convertible
lesssgoo
3:53 I disagree because of 2 reasons, 1 the microphone and speakers have limited battery
2) the bullets are also limited so you can’t just stay there and hope to see if your bullets are enough to kill anything that comes.
Yes finally someone that agrees with me
I hope that a similar thing does not happen to Free Guy 2 and that they still keep the original writer.
I feel like the "Boldest, most innovative concept" is giving them a LOT of credit since many have seen how this movie basically just copied the homework of The Silence (novel), which is ironic cuz when THAT movie came out (whether good or not), everyone said it copied Quiet Place, when it was adapting the thing that Quiet Place copied. Weird how Hollywood gets away with those shenanigans.
Stupid people don't read, but they DO watch movies.
Similarly the book Battle Royale will probably never get a movie adaptation because everyone would think it's a Hunger Games ripoff, even though Hunger Games was written after it.
@@josephwodarczyk977 There is a Japanese movie literally called Battle Royale, based on a novel that the Japanese government tried to ban. They even made a sequel. Both made 2000 and 2003
@@josephwodarczyk977 battle Royale already has film adaptations.....
The Silence movie was bad imo because of the stupid decisions some characters made (ie a dude trying to mug the family by shooting a shotgun in the air as a threat, even though at this point it’s known that the creatures hunt by sound)
Monster: Swims in the first movie*
Paramount: "They can't swim."
It was more likely crawling on the floor for whatever reason
Is it really swimming though if they can still touch the bottom?
@@TheScarletSlayer It is not
@@Infinityendgame * sinks below the floor* of god their evolving!
The water in the house was no deeper than 1 meter and they are way longer, maybe the monster was crawling to get a clearer noise since it was pretty loud (or maybe I was too used to the silence)
I remember I went to the drive with my friends to watch this. I ended up watching more of Peter rabbit 2, which was playing next to us, by the end of it we all just ended up watching Peter rabbit 2.
I loved the first one, especially the bit where they bodied the kid. I was impressed the movie had the balls to murder a kid in cold blood IN THE INTRO. Absolutely brutal.
This is how the conjuring movies are, they don’t add really anything new and played it safe and they haven’t improved since the first Conjuring movie.
Conjuring 2 is better than the first IMO
@@meshachhitchen1475 Same here, I liked the second one even better than the first.
I did enjoy watching it.
But I definitely had to turn up the "Don't fking over think it, just enjoy it" part of my brain while watching it.
Which I did not have to do in the first movie.
Loving your work
Man I gotta say, great videos. im dead laughing at my desk at work.
I think we got lucky, it could have been so much worse. And I'm so happy it came out as good as it did, despite the flaws
At least it isn't Peninsula
it was ass bro i'm really sorry
Great, Paramount was rewarded for getting rid of scriptwriters and just making another shitty sequel. 👍
@@dighad3824 no it was definitely good. Imperfect yes but the performances, production value, score, tension building and direction were all masterfully done.
@@ollytherevenant1653, building and direction? The Scriptwriters weren’t even there and the movie doesn’t even follow the world’s logic. You might want to rethink your comment if you thought about it to begin with.
Filmento: *makes this video
*For future reference, Filmento didn’t kill himself*
@@user-lolman12390 what
@@leontriestomeme9712 what
What
@@kidflasher how
@@leontriestomeme9712 why?
If they called it “A Quieter Place” it would have been a perfect movie
Filmento's brand of sarcastic comedy never ceases to put me in the grave🤣😭😂😭🤣😭😂
The first movie used the silence to create tension because you know, even dropping a bottle can mean certain death
In the sequel, everyone is screaming and panicking, not even trying to maintain their composure like idiots who knows that the aliens have amazing hearing
Aslo what if they all stoped running aorund when it arrived and played a very intense game of red light green light without trying to make a sound instead of running aorund like a fox just got in the chicken coop
The saying should now be "like taking oxygen from a baby"
Hahahaha
You are so funny Filmento 😂 I came for the movie analysis, stayed for the humor lol
The oh colorful metaphor audio inserts. Are absolutely awesomely sublime. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
the original film was so incredible because it was founded upon character. This film seemed to forget that and focused instead on action. I enjoyed it but was really disappointed.
It felt like dumb action to me casue of the boy mainly and characters being dumb out of now where like they forgot thier world now needs to be slient. Instant at the first part was nice it could've been better if they didn't have the break with the old friend and the slow running away from the moster scene after the first monster being killed but instead had like 2 or 3 more show up real fast that forces them to run inside and take more immediate actions.
the weird monsters went from thanos to chitauris.
I love your editing and use of screams.
lol your editing is so funny
Ngl, I was kinda shocked and disappointed to see that this was an anatomy of a failure. But I'm sure you'll have some great points in the video, so I'm more than happy to watch.
We need more people like you in the world! I salute you, Sir.
You can accept different takes!!!??? That's impossible!!!!!
The Movie has a A- cinema score and broke box office records by becoming the first movie to make 100M Dollars at the US Box office in pandemic times
Meanwhile Filmento: ITS A FAILURE!
Like Bruhh
Pft, leave this planet you alien! LISTENING TO OTHERS OPINION IN THE INTERNET IS BLASPHEMY.
@@taskforceknight9336 Your the exact opposite of the OP
My biggest problem with the movie was the character development of the new father figure. And also how that little child at the dock magically put on a bell rope and tightened it so hard that a grown man could not untie it loose. But this is my opinion.
I think it's not so much that the rope was too tight for him, just that untying would make too much noise and he was trying to avoid that, he also knew that it was all a trap so untying it would only make things worse for him. Also I don't think it was tied since we don't see the girl tying anything, I think it was locked with something and that's why he doesn't try to untie anything, he just can't untie what isn't tied.
@@cuervoramos Mmmm no it was just tightened. And he had to cut it off with the knife he had. You could argue that it was a special knot that when a little girl ties it on quick no grown man can untie. Understandable.
My biggest problem was the *fucking SON.* Jesus Christ, Noah Jupe needs a better agent...
@@aidangordon2713 what was wrong with him?
@@extramile.5yago wouldn't cutting it cause the bell to jingle
7:40 the part where the monster slides onto the screen was so funny, I almost choked on a granola bar laughing.
What they should’ve done was shown a different type of monster that was immune to the sound interference but had a weak spot still just not the same one
"Franchise"
I'm just going to point out that bulletd are a limited resource, and they're on a sort of time crunch, as they need to get to safety before the son bleeds out.
Also they were sort of lucky that only one monster appeared. They probably wanted to get to safety instead of keep fighting since the gunshot would likely attract more, and fighting more than one at once might be risky. That´s my guess.
There's always more.
ok fair . But the movie never establishes that . For all we know they have tons of bullets but we just never see it . It doesn't even tell us actually . So it's filling up plotholes here by guessing here
If they're limited they still have other tools to kill the creatures; they literally killed the creature with the worse melee weapon possible!
@@dylana.9057 It's caleld fansplaining, or what I like to call apologetics., mental gymnastics, etc. If the movie is taking place in America then my question is, "what the fuck do you mean "limited bullets" I call bullshit.
Filmento: "They'll need an actual miracle for this franchise to recover"
God: 300 million dollar miracle coming up
These edits are hilarious!
Noticing a trend of 'part II' stories completely disregarding why the first part worked and missing key people who made said first part good. In all cases people enjoy them anyway (which is okay) so likely it will not be different anytime soon.
Yeah the fact I'm seeing so many people defending the movie without saying why is baffling.
@@soundrogue4472 I’ll do it. It’s got the vibe of the first one while intensifying the stakes and following up on the themes. The new main male character is extremely interesting to me, in his parallel to lee in the first movie. And the daughter becoming more like her father and the son becoming more like his mother. I loved it for many reasons but I really enjoyed this screenplay and the core concepts behind it
I agree
@@dope8878 it was incredible, i don’t see how people don’t like it, people don’t make sense anymore
Loved the continuation of the theme of the family. This was a smaller, contained film - even more so than the last one because the stakes were smaller. But thematically, it was a huge movie. I love how the mother was so powerful both despite and because of the husband. I love how it felt he was still always there through the presence of his children. The way the screenplay was written is so powerful when it brings all four character's arcs into two parallels of the two kids continuing his legacy. Family. Great thematic faithfulness and execution.
You just reminded me I was watching this, paused it and genuinely forgot all about it.
The next day I could barely tell the story man, it was so bad.
Best sequel ever!
I did the exact same thing. Maybe 30% left and I don't think I'll ever bother.
@@MarquezDaniel it isnt
to be fair its not like they have access to unlimited ammunition, yea they can exploit the death angels weakness but they cant keep shooting if more keeps coming and ammunition is low.
This editing, my god. . .it's hilarious LMAO
Idk. I was absolutely blown away when I watched this movie. And I could still feel a lot of tension. But I do see what you mean. Giving them a very exploitable weakness does remove a lot a stakes. But I still think they did a good job with what they did.
I actually liked this movie. But, you've presented your cases very well Filmento. Good video. 👍
The only thing I feel stupid about this movie is about the boy exploring the place with a broken leg.
@@cahidijoyoraharjo7833 and the australian goverment not doing anything since australia is basically a giant island continent
@@Iianator the aliens are no doubt also there
@@Iianator didn't you know, aliens only landed in USA
@@HM-wn2in Wow so every other place is fine. Did america not pay every other country debt so they dont mind the US dissapearing
This franchise never made sense since it underestimates humanity's ability to figure out how to kill stuff. Big ear monster? Obviously loud sound feedback. Even if that didn't work, someone would definitely try that day 1.
Also, yeah, they're bullet proof, but we discover that you can shoot into their face to kill them. Yeah no shit the military didn't try that
@@bruhkan457 Honestly a few tanks would have easily done the job those things would not have been able to take even a single HE shell.
@@Lunk42 the challenge is hitting something that moves fast. Let alone have multiple creatures.
If i remember right the movement when you aim tanks make significant sounds.
Pretty sure a helicopter gunship would make short work of them. Assuming the pilots weren't Hollywood stupid and flew low enough for the creatures to jump up and attack the chopper.
*I have to completely disagree with you on this one. I absolutely loved this movie 🎬 and can't wait for the third.*
Great video. You’re totally right!
Exactly. Went to see this film with my best friend and coming out we had this commentaries. It is a thrilling, enjoyable film, but as a sequel lacks. It doesn’t add anything to the first film, the finale is arguably the same as the first one, but now taking place in two different locations. Doesn’t expand on the nature of humanity in this post apocalyptic world as it glimpses at times, characters ignore the weakness they already know the monsters have. The danger the monsters present should escalate, or you should present a new danger, this being humans being crazy and they are even more dangerous than monsters (which they barely touched with the Dock’s folk)
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 Also convenient holes in the world building from the docks to the island. Why would this ravaged band hang out and pick out young girls? Why not go to the island? Are they picking off islanders who have to come back for supplies? Why doesn’t the island itself have a sentry or watch guard - for those kind of folk, if not the monsters themselves? Would’ve made saving folks much easier.
what? what's more crazy than the guys at the dock? you guys nitpick the wrong movies, for every thousand or so of really bad movies there's one that's actually good and you still like to shit on it. SMH
@@carlzune6626 glad I’ve come this comment later. It’s called constructive criticism CARL. Go to the back of the line or find a new thread for children.
Spot on as always, Filmento.
the editing on this channel is next level.
oh and... also the content XD :))
Even thought the first movie was superior in my opinion, I still enjoyed this one.
It just felt a bit “stranger thingy”, in the first movie, one creature was the ultimate danger, while in this one they fight dozens without any trouble.
Almost like they tried to pull an Aliens with this one. Aliens will forever be the kings of sequels and the most legendary sequel, these filmmakers of this "a quiet place" should shove off!
I loved this movie. I don’t watch movies for logic I watch movies for story. Tell me any fictional story with the best logistics….
There are none. A story is a beginning, middle and end that’s it. In the context of movies it’s how it makes you feel. Sure I questioned some moments that broke suspension of disbelief (creature casually riding the boat) but I was curious to know how the characters would survive the entire movie or how it would end.
The whole point of these two movies is to portray a family who are forced to survive the worst case scenario, they lose a lot but it’s a story or how to use your weaknesses into strengths. It’s intimate and tight. Not an overblown militarised action horror bonanza.
The film’s biggest strengths is its performances and directing. I was emotionally invested in these characters and the execution of the dark angels is solid. If a movie makes me feel scared, nervous, tense throughout then it’s done it’s Job simple.
@@master-of-mind5881 I can tell you of several movies that follow logic and people make the best decisions they can. and probably so could you.
you can enjoy a movie while recognizing it's flaws, you don't need to pretend every movie has the same issues as it.