I still haven't even opened mine up, almost a week since receiving it. Ever since watching all of the demos, I'm still in no rush. I love Hanna checkers, but this is just too much work. Great video.
I love Hanna Checkers too! But I agree with you... too much work. that being said, I will probably break it out if I have a tank reading zero nitrates to see if I can get a more accurate sense of what's going on. Once you use it, let me know what you think! Thanks for watching and commenting!
Same! I was so excited when Hanna finally came out with this test kit since I have all their other tests. Then when I watched videos knowing all along my nitrates are higher than 5, basically the box kit has been sitting there collecting dust. I will definitely use it just to have an exact number of what my nitrates are but as a few others have said, not in a rush. This was a great review and will come back for the step-by-step instructions when I have fresh water made up next time.
Just did this test for the first time and it wasn't bad. Thanks for the video because the others were horrible. I am starting a 110 gallon fowler tank so I wanted piece of mind that my measurements are accurate. One note. My kit did not come with a plastic cover for the needle so I was a tad confused at 5:29 but that plastic cover is not necessary. You can thread and unthread the needle without it. My nitrate read 2.05 and multiple by 10 since I diluted = 20.10 ppm
how do you like it so far? once a tank is cycled, I wouldnt imagine it would be something to test too often, probably test phosphates weekly or bi weekly more often?
@@xisotopex the parameters all test fine but unfortunately another large die off about 3.5-4 weeks into it. I dont know what I'm doing wrong. I just got an ammonia checker so I will be taking that reading tomorrow.
Thank you for the great instructions on this kit. I have all the other checkers and this is by far the most difficult to use. The absolute worst part is the instructions. They were obviously written by someone intimately familiar with the test kit. This is not how you write instructions that are meant to be used by the average consumer. What they shod do is get the secretary at the front desk. Hand her the kit and the instructions and observe and answer questions as needed. Once they successfully complete the test 3 times, have the secretary write the instructions and go with that. I am an actual chemist, and have 30 years lab experience. I've only rarely come by instructions this bad and this is right among the worst. I had to watch this video to even figure out how the test works. Whoever is in charge of writing these instructions needs to be put on bathroom cleaning detail for 2 months and never allowed to write instructions for anything again. Thanks to the poster for the video, your smarter than 3/4 of hanna instruments management team. A special note, if for some reason your tank is having major problems and you test and get the "5.00" error code (sample over range) you can fill the other vial with clean sea water and use it as a C1, then using the syringe and needle, remove exactly 5.0 ml of the purple solution from the cuvette and replace it with 5.0 ml of clean sea water. Use you clean water cuvette as a C1 blank, then use the now 20x diluted cuvette as a sample. This time just press the button and the new result appears. It may not be 100% accurate, but you will al least be able to tell if it's 53ppm as opposed to 103 ppm. And if like me you did this and got a calculated result of 55ppm, you probably don't need to test it again to be more accurate. Just do your water change.
Wow, thanks Jim! And that is some great advice at the end! Yeah, the instructions are not great for this product! I still do use this test kit from time to time, but I usually just don't need this level of accuracy for my reef tanks! Thanks for taking the time to leave such a detailed comment!
@@MyFirstFishTank I think the real benefit of this kit is when you get the level down low and are managing multiple parameters with a apex system with doser pumps, you need really accurate results to help with the overall assessment of your automated processes. That's the best application for this device. It is simply too complex and too time consuming a test to use as part of a regular testing regime.
I completely agree with you. The more steps there are, the great chance for user error, for sure! I mean the whole filtering aspect of it alone is quite confusing, and then having to dilute it is complicated as well. Thanks for watching. Are you going to get one?
Your video made this so much easier not mention fast. Reading the color cards was driving me nuts. One shade of light give me one reading, another gives me a different reading. Final, something that tells me just what is and more importantly consistently. I think I can live with the time as I only have two tanks, but I respect your reason for not using it. Again, thanks again for a great video.
Totally get that. It is a great test kit. Just as long as the Red Sea kit that’s for sure! Have you tried the Nyos nitrate test kit? I love it and find it super easy to read and it goes from 1ppm to 160ppm. Thanks for taking the time to comment! You are appreciated.
I was really looking forward to this checker too. I saw 3 other "first looks" and was bummed it took so long. Also a lot of materials that will need to be replaced over time. Thanks for being honest!
Me too! I was soooo stoked about this one! And then MD sent me one of their preview copies. Well, I usually don’t watch other videos, but as soon as I opened it up I was shocked how many pieces there were. And then there was the filter piece and I had no clue what that was for. It was so complicated that I started by watching the Hanna video on how to use it, and was sort of shocked. I do think it is a high quality test kit, but I’m not sure for who. I just don’t think its geared for the average hobbyist. So Remy, my question for you... are you going to get one?
I had already purchased the checker and could not figure out how to use it :) This video was great! Super clear on how to use and what to watch out for. Thanks!
Thank you for posting this. This checker is a royal pain in the *** and I don't think I would have successfully completed the test without seeing this.
Thank you so much for the honest review I have four younger children and they are always saying "Dad it takes you too long to check on the fish." I think they would thank you as well.
I have this and I found it not that bad. 1st: The gasket is obviously there for a reason. It was obvious to me. I didn't have any leaking issues my first time (only done a single test so far). 2nd: I don't think you need this if you know your nitrates are over 5... Just my opinion. If they're over 5, then use another kit and get them down. I got it because I knew my levels were close to 0 and wanted an exact number. 3rd: my other kit is red sea. That test takes a min of 11-12 minutes... You said you can get this process down to 15... We are talking about a 3 min difference now. It's obviously a personal choice, bit I will take accuracy over time any day. Good review though.
Thanks Chris. Great feedback and I can’t disagree with you. You are certainly right about the Red Sea kit. Although, Red Sea also makes a high range kit that comes with their marine care set that is much faster. I just haven’t found anything to beat Nyos. 7 minutes total, two reagents, and it reads from 1-160. But I totally get that if you want accuracy below 5ppm, then this is the kit!
You were spot on with this review but once you get used to the process it is very redundant that I finished checking my tank water in 12 mins with dilution etc.
Wanted to point out that during the dilution portion when you added the fresh sea water to the 10ml mark you did not add the proper amount which with these dilution steps will greatly skew your results. The bottom of the meniscus needs to be at the 10ml mark. Not the top of the water level.
Noted! Possibly another reason why this test kit may not be best for the average hobbyist? User error! Thanks for watching closely and correcting my method! Happy reefing!
@@MyFirstFishTank Sure. By the way, in your opinion what's the best Phosphate checker avail for reefers?? It happens that I have Red Sea P04 but since 2 years ago it always mark ZERO. I thought the chcker was expired or defective so I bought a new one, the results exactly the same. The only time the checker mark above ZERO was when I accidentally over dosed NeoPhos.
Like you I have seen two other videos and watching the time involved, I don’t think this test kit is for me. I have three tanks and I don’t want to spend that time to test all of my tanks. I have several Hanna test kits and they are the most accurate out there & save time over others. Thanks for the honest review Matthew.
You're welcome Darren! I was surprised just how complicated it was. Will that Mastertronic test for nitrate when it comes out? Because that might be the way to go!
Yeah, I've actually started using it a bit more lately. Although I've recently become addicted to the speed of the Salifert NO3 test kit. It takes me 4 total minutes!
new one every time. They give you enough, I think, for all the first round of tests, and I believe they would come in a reagent refill pack. At least I hope so!
Another comment I have about all hanna checker testers. Clean all your glassware and syringes, pipette tips,and mixing vials using tap water. Don't use soap. Rinse all plasticware with a final rodi water rinse. To clean the large mixing vial, A test tube brush is required, especially with this kit. The zinc powder is difficult to get out of the big mixing vial without a brush. I use a test tube brush while rinsing to get the majority out. Then I use a paper towel, twisted into a snake shape, then twist it into the big mixing vial to physically remove any remaining zinc powder. Now that's done, you need to rinse all of the glassware with rodi water. Rinse 3 times with a 20% full vial of rodi water, shake and dump. Then shake again to remove residual water. Once the vials have been rinsed, fill completely with rodi water and store the vials full. This will prevent buildup on the vials during storage. Don't forget to remove the used filter paper from the holder and carefully rinse the holder so you don't lose the silicone gasket. Leave the filter holder disassembled in the kit for it to dry.
Excellent video, thank you for taking the time to share your experience. I unfortunately had already made the purchase and it is a lot more than $50 in the UK :( Hanna kits just seem to be so hit and miss. I love the Alkalinity and Phosphate test kits but hate the Calcium test and this Nitrate test. Note the Calcium test is also very complex, time consuming and with a very small water sample size making it prone to error. One of the comments below summed it up well, the more complex the test, the more moving parts the higher the margin for error.
Thanks for watching and commenting Gary. Yeah, regarding the calcium test, my exact worry is how small the sample size is. I even consider the 1ml from the diluted nitrate to be too small, so the calcium one really worries me. I have a confession to make... I've started using the nitrate test kit! Not all the time, but I've been trying to really dial in the nitrates on my new clownfish harem tank, so I have found the accuracy to be super helpful. It takes forever, but I've finally memorized all of the steps, so it's a bit easier.
I use this test kit. I start this test then do other test while the test is going. Also I’m colorblind. Can’t tell the difference in all the other test you mentioned. I bought colorblind glasses. Yeah, they did nothing for me. So yes, it’s intense and time consuming, but the alternative is to ask my 6 year old what the color.
For sure! I have a confession though... I've started using this test kit on my clownfish harem tank. I just want super accurate readings for the anemones, so I've memorized the steps and use it. It is still a pain, but the digital read out it just so helpful!
I think the problem with this test is people have been begging Hanna to make a No3 tester for years. People have gotten used to Hanna checkers that take about 3 minutes or less to get a result. I dont mind the extra steps or time it takes for the accuracy this tester gives. This is the only test kit out there that will give you a dead on accurate result instead on fighting with the perfect ambient light to see what color the reagent it with every other test out there. Is this tester for everyone no, but personally reef tanks are a hobby that I enjoy every part of it not just looking at the tank. I own the Hanna no3 checker as well as all the others they offer, and was grateful when this one came out because i was sick of saying '' well yea this looks like the shade of purple... I think''.
Haha, I actually couldn't agree with you any more! I've started using this test a bit more since leaving this review. It's a good product for sure. My biggest complaint now is the filtration step. In order for mine not to leak i have to screw it on really hard. That makes it difficult for me to get off. I've also almost lost that clear rubber/plastic o-ring several times. If a future version of the checker could fix those two problems I'd definitely be happier. But it is a good product for sure!
Great video! Though just a heads up - check how to read a liquid meniscus in measuring vials. From your video it looks like you're doing it wrong ie. using the sides of the concave meniscus instead of the center. What frustates me about all the test kits I've used so far, is that none of them have an explanation as to how to properly read a liquid meniscus - which would seem crucial for an accurate test.
Bought it, used it, its no big deal. I do the KH and Phosphate while waiting for it to develop. Also the Red Sea Test kit if you follow the directions takes 11+ minutes in wait and mixing time.
So true! Although I think the Red Sea Nitrate test kit that comes as a part of their Master kit is a bit faster... Glad you like it. I've though about breaking it out again in the last few weeks since I ran out of my Nyos test kit, but I just switched back to API. Not nearly as good!
Unfortunally i bought this checker, wid out watch first a review. As soon as i opened it, ive seen the trouble that a reefer should go through jus to chek nitrate.. I decided to do not use it and resell asap! I wish i could hv seen this review before to buy :(. Thanx man u speek the truth ;)
Hey thanks! Yes, I love the Nyos test kit. My favorite by far! I use it everyday actually! I haven't used the Hanna test kit since making the video! It's more like a collectors item for me at this point! I'll look back fondly in 10 years remembering those times I used it... and shiver at the thought! Ha, ha, just kidding. It's a good test kit, just too many steps for me! Thanks for watching and liking Cristina!
At around the 2:50 mark you specify using the 5 Ml syringe with the large plastic extension. Assuming you filled to the 4 ml mark on the syringe (you didn't show it in the video). If you draw to the 4 ml line on the syringe, you actually have more than 4 ml. You need to account for the content in the extension tube. That extension tube accounts for a little over a ml of content\fluid.
Hey Bob, thanks for the comment. I used to think the same thing too! But even with the extension tube, it is still 4ml if you draw the syringe to line up at the 4ml line. If you take the syringe up until the liquid is at the 4ml line, then you would be correct. But if you take the syringe to the 4ml line, you'll notice that the liquid doesn't fill all the way. That is because of the extension tube. Does that make sense?
This looks like a very nice product . It looks like it may cost about 5 to 7 dollars to make this, but the Price you're charging is outrageous. that's taking advantage.
Yeah for sure. I really like the phosphate checker and the alkalinity checker, because they are easy! But this one is complicated even compared to the Calcium Checker, which is already complicated. What nitrate test kit do you use?
My First Fish Tank That’s funny you say that, the phosphate one is the only Hanna I use. I think the Red Sea Alk tester is quicker and little more cost effective than Hanna but not quite as accurate. Since I find myself testing my sps tank everyday, I am all about saving the money. For nitrate I just use the API, it’s terrible trying to figure out how yellow your test is, but I am super religious about my water changes and feed really lightly so it works for me knowing as long as I don’t turn orange I am good 😅 I have been curious about trying the nyos one out.
I bought a lot (as in auction lot) of Hanna checkers and this one was included. The text instructions for dilution are horrible. The official video is crap. Even though you were ranting against this checker, your instructions were perfect for the dilution step. Going to use it up and when the reagents are gone Ill mount it to my wall and wax fondly of the days I used this POS.
I purchased one as I tend to run on the low range for NO3 and the color change using carts is near impossible for me to read, that said this kit is.... annoying. lol
I was going to buy one, but the box says 0-5ppm and I would like to check up to 10+ ppm. After researching further and discovering the method to test up to 50ppm I went out and bought one....and who else will be using this checker? Perhaps people that are colourblind, and like me, people that don't trust the colour checkers because of the different results you get in different lights and even the angle the same light hits the vial!
It's a good checker, and I still use it occasionally. And if your colorblind, then shoot... why not right? You'll get faster and faster at it for sure!
I’m gutted really...Iv been waiting for this to come out for a long time. Hanna thinks we are all scientists! we are hobbyists and need something a lot faster and a tester that goes from 0-50 nitrate in two simple steps.
Yeah it's a tough call huh? I was really looking forward to this test kit as well. I didn't every imagine it could be more complicated than the calcium checker, but it is by a long shot. Maybe this product is aimed more at professional marine biologists in public aquarium settings. Not sure. So the question is... Are you still going to buy it?
Think many of those "SPS dominant" reef tank owners would be looking at the latest, or upcoming automated checkers. The Reefbot for example which has been out for some time. GHL has their ION director coming out this month for which I will look forward to reviews. Not sure of the accuracy of the Reefbot nitrate test but at least it should be consistent. I would guess you could tie it in with an ICP test as a baseline. There are other alternatives and I am sure Trident will come out with something sometime but when you are talking about potentially $1000's of coral, accuracy and regular testing would become important. Something which takes time and is complicated would mean it is less likely to be done as I am sure I am not the only one who is lazy.
Yeah, this is all important to consider. I would be curious to see how accurate this checker is compared to the reefbot or trident. I like your idea of pairing it with an ICP test to really see. I mean, I can be lazy, but I'm sure you're like me. We do what we need to for our tanks right? But a 17 minute nitrate test even pushes my patience! Will you be getting one of these? Thanks for watching and your insights!
@@MyFirstFishTank I'll admit I do not check nitrate as often now as I did when I first started when I was religious about it. It tends to be stable unlike a lot of other things I test for more regularly such as the core trio, Alk, Calcium and Magnesium which I have to dose. I'll stick to my basic nitrate test kit for now.
Great video I got this because I love Hanna checkers even though some are complicated. I enjoy the process. I’ve always liked the water testing process
Thanks! The truth of the matter is I still do use this from time to time, especially when I'm really trying to get my nitrates just right! It's a good tester. After a few months, I'd say I still wish the rubber o-ring was different, and I wish the filter was easier to unscrew! A good product that with a few tweaks could be great!
Wish I'd watched a few more review videos before buying one of these. Opened up the Phosphate checker and thought "Nice, that'll be convenient". Opened up the Nitrate checker and thought "WTF? Theres powders and liquids and a filter paper and that many steps? Dammit!!!" This is going on a shelf and I'll revert to the Sailfert test and only pull this out if I ever really need a precise reading. So... never?
Totally get it. But, Hanna has come out with a new, high range nitrate checker which is amazing! Only 1 reagent and perfect for aquariums! I would get rid of the low range checker and upgrade to this one! www.bulkreefsupply.com/nitrate-high-range-colorimeter-hi782-marine-water-hanna-instruments.html
Hey there. You can always actually just do the dilution test. Just multiply the results by 10. It's probably not quite as accurate as doing the standard test, but once you are certain your nitrates are low, then you can switch from the dilution version to the non-diluted version. Hope that answers your question!
Comparing to Red Sea, I think we have the same problems. Have to wait 9 minutes, and have the low range and high range. But watching the video, looks really painful doing the test. Specially the part that you have to prepare a new salt water
Yeah, it's quite similar to the red sea in terms of wait time. The additional filtration step with the Hanna checker is the most difficult part for me. And having to make a new batch of saltwater just to test? For some of us that's not a problem, but I don't think the average hobbyists keeps spare salt lying around!
This is crazy! Orgo labs in college were easier than this. Good presentation of the hassles. I will definitely pass. The syringe alone scared me, needles give me the creeps. I've been using the Salifert but I find it almost impossible to tell if my nitrates are 5 or closer to 50 PPM. Just got Red Sea nitrate test kit, have used once, didn't understand the result (NO3 and N-NO3 or something and didn't match Salifert for either) but we'll see, new test kits seem to take time to get used to.
Yeah I also find the salifert hard. I like the API for Nitrate actually. I can usually tell the measurement to within 0.1 ppm, which aint bad in my book! I'll be curious to hear how you like the Red Sea after a few uses. I just made an ammonia test kit video and my next video in that series will be Nitrate, so stay tuned to see which one you might want to buy next!
Glad you found it helpful. I will say that since this video I still do occasionally use it, when it's trending toward zero. But it just takes so much longer that I revert to other tests! Thanks for watching and commenting!
@@MyFirstFishTank I thought your videos were excellent. I use Red Sea and I do agree with you on the dKH that Red Sea offers a better product. Now the Hanna UTL Phosphate test is right on point. I'm going to subscribe to your channel, hope it helps.
I bought this because i have all the hannas and when i opened it, I said nope and put it away. The video they have isnt even detailed enough as yours. This test sucks so much!!! The vial isnt exactly 10 ml either so Idk how youre getting an accurate reading everytime.
No, it works just fine. It is. probably the most accurate test kit out there! But you will definitely want a different test kit for everyday use. My current two favorites are Salifert and Nyos.
Thank you so much for your advice & it’s funny I actually fall into your “who will need / use this kit” 1, my aquarium is going to be a SPS dominant aquarium & 2, I’ve already purchased 7 different Hanna test kits hahahaha But I truly appreciate this video & your advice
Awesome! You know, even though I said I wasn't going to use it, I find myself using from time to time because it's just so accurate! Glad you found the video helpful!
It took you 17 minutes because you preformed and over complicated the test drastically. The only difference with this test and all the others is you need to mix and filter part of your sample........ that’s it......... everything else is easy and straightforward..
I'm glad you found it easier than I did. I wonder what others think? If anybody else read this, leave a comment and let's hear your feedback! Thanks for watching and commenting Erick.
Dude! Great video. Man.... I HATE TESTING! It’s the one part of this hobby that I absolutely hate. lol This kit is definitely not for me. I want quick results simple as that.
It's kind of crazy huh? It would take an entire day! And you are right, it would be great if it read to 100. Because let's be real... a lot of our tanks have high nitrates! So I'm assuming you're not going to get one?
The only one I've used is the API kit. The only time I used this I had to raise the copper level to 2ppm, and I added the amount I was supposed to, and voila, the test kit read 2ppm. So it seems to have worked well for me! www.marinedepot.com/api-freshwater-saltwater-copper-test-kit-test-kit-of-90-tests
...and another thing. I’ve just attempted to do my first test (need accuracy at very low range, to determine nitrate dosing on a new setup into which I’m moving a mature reef - long story....) and guess what? I have no idea how I’m going to draw up “exactly 4ml of Reagent A” when the 5ml syringe HAS NO MARKINGS ON IT. Uh huh. Blank. Thought I would get the benefit of being careful by spending the $100 (Canadian) on the tester and a reagent refill. Nope. Hanna disappoints, not for the first time. @Hanna Instruments, Inc. I’m not afraid of complex tests, but it would be awesome to actually have the proper tools included in the not-so-cheap test kit. 🤬🤬🤬🤬
Frustrating eh? I've gotten used to the nitrate checker. I can't say I use it very often, but sometimes when I'm looking for low range accuracy I'll pull it out.
I have 2 tanks, one mixed sps/lps dominate tank with clams and delicate inverts. The other is a FOWLR tangs/triggerfish/wrasse tank. For the mixed tank, I cant second guess accuracy-so I got the NO3 Hanna unit. I can deal with the steps and time involved, BUT-I CANT DEAL WITH THE NEED TO DILUTE WITH FRESH UNUSED SALT WATER!!!!!! Who has that laying around????? Hanna should make available reference water!!!! WTF?????? Maybe Ill have to schedule my test around the weekly water change. IMO Hanna kinda screwed the pooch on this one. Thank god for my Nyos and Red Sea kits.
Ha! I just don't understand why they didn't consult hobbyists about this test. Maybe we are a tiny fraction of their market, but for the Checkers I feel like we are the largest segment of their market. It would have only taken a select handful of hobbyists to let them know that this test is too onerous!
I couldn't agree with this reviewer more. I have the red sea and api test kits, but I just had to have a digital display kit. After mucking up the first 3 attempts and after an hour later, I went back to api. Big waste of $50 and time out of like I can't get back. Way too many steps and too complicated for my needs servicing a 25 gal reef tank. Pass!!
Thanks Michael, it's always nice to hear I'm not alone in my opinions. I still think it is a good test, and in fact I've used it several times since. But I now just go for salifert or nyos because they are so much easier and faster! Thanks for taking time to leave a comment!
I hear you. I think it might be worth it for a very specific audience. But the vast majority of hobbyists just won't use it. To many points for user error and it takes soooo long! So I'm guessing you are not going to buy one?
I hear you! The filtration portion is the worst for me. I think if you did it a lot you would just get the hang of it! I assume you're not going to get one then?:-)
@@MyFirstFishTank your video was exactly what i wanted a fair unbiased review. And yes Sir i will not buy one i invested and just bought a phosphate ulr instead of the nitrate. The funny thing is i complained to hanna checker about red sea test because i need to add two reagent and wait for 8 minutes thinking Hanna will give me something like thier alk test but boy i was wrong.b
I was going to buy this. But I thought I best watch a review on it.. you probably guess what I'm going to do now.. I have 6 saltwater tanks. And I'm getting no younger.. thank you for your vid.. 👎👎👎👎👎
I still haven't even opened mine up, almost a week since receiving it. Ever since watching all of the demos, I'm still in no rush. I love Hanna checkers, but this is just too much work. Great video.
I love Hanna Checkers too! But I agree with you... too much work. that being said, I will probably break it out if I have a tank reading zero nitrates to see if I can get a more accurate sense of what's going on. Once you use it, let me know what you think! Thanks for watching and commenting!
Same! I was so excited when Hanna finally came out with this test kit since I have all their other tests. Then when I watched videos knowing all along my nitrates are higher than 5, basically the box kit has been sitting there collecting dust. I will definitely use it just to have an exact number of what my nitrates are but as a few others have said, not in a rush. This was a great review and will come back for the step-by-step instructions when I have fresh water made up next time.
Just did this test for the first time and it wasn't bad. Thanks for the video because the others were horrible. I am starting a 110 gallon fowler tank so I wanted piece of mind that my measurements are accurate.
One note. My kit did not come with a plastic cover for the needle so I was a tad confused at 5:29 but that plastic cover is not necessary. You can thread and unthread the needle without it.
My nitrate read 2.05 and multiple by 10 since I diluted = 20.10 ppm
how do you like it so far? once a tank is cycled, I wouldnt imagine it would be something to test too often, probably test phosphates weekly or bi weekly more often?
@@xisotopex the parameters all test fine but unfortunately another large die off about 3.5-4 weeks into it. I dont know what I'm doing wrong. I just got an ammonia checker so I will be taking that reading tomorrow.
if the tank is cycled there shouldnt be any ammonia but sometimes its quite mysterious...@@tas4092
Thank you for the great instructions on this kit. I have all the other checkers and this is by far the most difficult to use. The absolute worst part is the instructions. They were obviously written by someone intimately familiar with the test kit. This is not how you write instructions that are meant to be used by the average consumer. What they shod do is get the secretary at the front desk. Hand her the kit and the instructions and observe and answer questions as needed. Once they successfully complete the test 3 times, have the secretary write the instructions and go with that.
I am an actual chemist, and have 30 years lab experience. I've only rarely come by instructions this bad and this is right among the worst. I had to watch this video to even figure out how the test works. Whoever is in charge of writing these instructions needs to be put on bathroom cleaning detail for 2 months and never allowed to write instructions for anything again.
Thanks to the poster for the video, your smarter than 3/4 of hanna instruments management team.
A special note, if for some reason your tank is having major problems and you test and get the "5.00" error code (sample over range) you can fill the other vial with clean sea water and use it as a C1, then using the syringe and needle, remove exactly 5.0 ml of the purple solution from the cuvette and replace it with 5.0 ml of clean sea water. Use you clean water cuvette as a C1 blank, then use the now 20x diluted cuvette as a sample. This time just press the button and the new result appears. It may not be 100% accurate, but you will al least be able to tell if it's 53ppm as opposed to 103 ppm. And if like me you did this and got a calculated result of 55ppm, you probably don't need to test it again to be more accurate. Just do your water change.
Wow, thanks Jim! And that is some great advice at the end! Yeah, the instructions are not great for this product! I still do use this test kit from time to time, but I usually just don't need this level of accuracy for my reef tanks! Thanks for taking the time to leave such a detailed comment!
@@MyFirstFishTank I think the real benefit of this kit is when you get the level down low and are managing multiple parameters with a apex system with doser pumps, you need really accurate results to help with the overall assessment of your automated processes. That's the best application for this device.
It is simply too complex and too time consuming a test to use as part of a regular testing regime.
I would argue that it won’t be accurate. With that many steps, there is too much room for error.
I completely agree with you. The more steps there are, the great chance for user error, for sure! I mean the whole filtering aspect of it alone is quite confusing, and then having to dilute it is complicated as well. Thanks for watching. Are you going to get one?
Agreed
Your video made this so much easier not mention fast. Reading the color cards was driving me nuts. One shade of light give me one reading, another gives me a different reading. Final, something that tells me just what is and more importantly consistently. I think I can live with the time as I only have two tanks, but I respect your reason for not using it. Again, thanks again for a great video.
Totally get that. It is a great test kit. Just as long as the Red Sea kit that’s for sure! Have you tried the Nyos nitrate test kit? I love it and find it super easy to read and it goes from 1ppm to 160ppm. Thanks for taking the time to comment! You are appreciated.
I was really looking forward to this checker too. I saw 3 other "first looks" and was bummed it took so long. Also a lot of materials that will need to be replaced over time. Thanks for being honest!
Me too! I was soooo stoked about this one! And then MD sent me one of their preview copies. Well, I usually don’t watch other videos, but as soon as I opened it up I was shocked how many pieces there were. And then there was the filter piece and I had no clue what that was for. It was so complicated that I started by watching the Hanna video on how to use it, and was sort of shocked. I do think it is a high quality test kit, but I’m not sure for who. I just don’t think its geared for the average hobbyist. So Remy, my question for you... are you going to get one?
Never say never, but probably not.
I had already purchased the checker and could not figure out how to use it :) This video was great! Super clear on how to use and what to watch out for. Thanks!
Glad it was helpful! It's a great tester, just a bit confusing to learn and time consuming!
Thank you for posting this. This checker is a royal pain in the *** and I don't think I would have successfully completed the test without seeing this.
It is a pain right? But go ahead and buy the high range version. Only one reagent and soooo much easier!
Fortunately they also have a high range that use only 1 regent, it works exactly as the phosphate checker and it's fantastic
Thank you so much for the honest review I have four younger children and they are always saying "Dad it takes you too long to check on the fish." I think they would thank you as well.
Your welcome Timothy! So, I'm assuming you're not going to get one then? For the kids sake!
@@MyFirstFishTank That is correct. I feel that the Red Sea testing kit has been for my testing needs.
I have this and I found it not that bad.
1st: The gasket is obviously there for a reason. It was obvious to me. I didn't have any leaking issues my first time (only done a single test so far).
2nd: I don't think you need this if you know your nitrates are over 5... Just my opinion. If they're over 5, then use another kit and get them down. I got it because I knew my levels were close to 0 and wanted an exact number.
3rd: my other kit is red sea. That test takes a min of 11-12 minutes... You said you can get this process down to 15... We are talking about a 3 min difference now.
It's obviously a personal choice, bit I will take accuracy over time any day.
Good review though.
Thanks Chris. Great feedback and I can’t disagree with you. You are certainly right about the Red Sea kit. Although, Red Sea also makes a high range kit that comes with their marine care set that is much faster. I just haven’t found anything to beat Nyos. 7 minutes total, two reagents, and it reads from 1-160. But I totally get that if you want accuracy below 5ppm, then this is the kit!
You were spot on with this review but once you get used to the process it is very redundant that I finished checking my tank water in 12 mins with dilution etc.
Yeah for sure. I'm just excited that I already ordered pre-ordered Hanna's new high range NO3 test kit with only one reagent!!!!!
Wanted to point out that during the dilution portion when you added the fresh sea water to the 10ml mark you did not add the proper amount which with these dilution steps will greatly skew your results. The bottom of the meniscus needs to be at the 10ml mark. Not the top of the water level.
Noted! Possibly another reason why this test kit may not be best for the average hobbyist? User error! Thanks for watching closely and correcting my method! Happy reefing!
I almost buy this Hanna checker without watching reviews first.
I don't need that thing anymore. Thank you, you made me save money.
Glad I could help! It is a great product, but I'd only recommend it for people who have a need for accuracy.
@@MyFirstFishTank Sure. By the way, in your opinion what's the best Phosphate checker avail for reefers?? It happens that I have Red Sea P04 but since 2 years ago it always mark ZERO. I thought the chcker was expired or defective so I bought a new one, the results exactly the same. The only time the checker mark above ZERO was when I accidentally over dosed NeoPhos.
Like you I have seen two other videos and watching the time involved, I don’t think this test kit is for me. I have three tanks and I don’t want to spend that time to test all of my tanks. I have several Hanna test kits and they are the most accurate out there & save time over others. Thanks for the honest review Matthew.
You're welcome Darren! I was surprised just how complicated it was. Will that Mastertronic test for nitrate when it comes out? Because that might be the way to go!
I used this checker today and I thought it was cool. Use it when you’re doing other tests and it all works out.
Yeah, I've actually started using it a bit more lately. Although I've recently become addicted to the speed of the Salifert NO3 test kit. It takes me 4 total minutes!
@@MyFirstFishTank Quick question. Do you reuse those round filter pads or use a new one every time?
new one every time. They give you enough, I think, for all the first round of tests, and I believe they would come in a reagent refill pack. At least I hope so!
Another comment I have about all hanna checker testers. Clean all your glassware and syringes, pipette tips,and mixing vials using tap water. Don't use soap. Rinse all plasticware with a final rodi water rinse.
To clean the large mixing vial, A test tube brush is required, especially with this kit. The zinc powder is difficult to get out of the big mixing vial without a brush. I use a test tube brush while rinsing to get the majority out. Then I use a paper towel, twisted into a snake shape, then twist it into the big mixing vial to physically remove any remaining zinc powder.
Now that's done, you need to rinse all of the glassware with rodi water. Rinse 3 times with a 20% full vial of rodi water, shake and dump. Then shake again to remove residual water. Once the vials have been rinsed, fill completely with rodi water and store the vials full. This will prevent buildup on the vials during storage. Don't forget to remove the used filter paper from the holder and carefully rinse the holder so you don't lose the silicone gasket. Leave the filter holder disassembled in the kit for it to dry.
Excellent advice!
Excellent video, thank you for taking the time to share your experience. I unfortunately had already made the purchase and it is a lot more than $50 in the UK :(
Hanna kits just seem to be so hit and miss. I love the Alkalinity and Phosphate test kits but hate the Calcium test and this Nitrate test. Note the Calcium test is also very complex, time consuming and with a very small water sample size making it prone to error. One of the comments below summed it up well, the more complex the test, the more moving parts the higher the margin for error.
Thanks for watching and commenting Gary. Yeah, regarding the calcium test, my exact worry is how small the sample size is. I even consider the 1ml from the diluted nitrate to be too small, so the calcium one really worries me. I have a confession to make... I've started using the nitrate test kit! Not all the time, but I've been trying to really dial in the nitrates on my new clownfish harem tank, so I have found the accuracy to be super helpful. It takes forever, but I've finally memorized all of the steps, so it's a bit easier.
I use this test kit. I start this test then do other test while the test is going. Also I’m colorblind. Can’t tell the difference in all the other test you mentioned. I bought colorblind glasses. Yeah, they did nothing for me.
So yes, it’s intense and time consuming, but the alternative is to ask my 6 year old what the color.
Yeah that makes total sense, so for you, this is the test of choice, hands down! Thanks for commenting.
Just watching you do this stresses me out! Really good video though, thanks - you've saved me some cash! 🙂
For sure! I have a confession though... I've started using this test kit on my clownfish harem tank. I just want super accurate readings for the anemones, so I've memorized the steps and use it. It is still a pain, but the digital read out it just so helpful!
I think the problem with this test is people have been begging Hanna to make a No3 tester for years. People have gotten used to Hanna checkers that take about 3 minutes or less to get a result. I dont mind the extra steps or time it takes for the accuracy this tester gives. This is the only test kit out there that will give you a dead on accurate result instead on fighting with the perfect ambient light to see what color the reagent it with every other test out there. Is this tester for everyone no, but personally reef tanks are a hobby that I enjoy every part of it not just looking at the tank. I own the Hanna no3 checker as well as all the others they offer, and was grateful when this one came out because i was sick of saying '' well yea this looks like the shade of purple... I think''.
Haha, I actually couldn't agree with you any more! I've started using this test a bit more since leaving this review. It's a good product for sure. My biggest complaint now is the filtration step. In order for mine not to leak i have to screw it on really hard. That makes it difficult for me to get off. I've also almost lost that clear rubber/plastic o-ring several times. If a future version of the checker could fix those two problems I'd definitely be happier. But it is a good product for sure!
Great video!
Though just a heads up - check how to read a liquid meniscus in measuring vials.
From your video it looks like you're doing it wrong ie. using the sides of the concave meniscus instead of the center.
What frustates me about all the test kits I've used so far, is that none of them have an explanation as to how to properly read a liquid meniscus - which would seem crucial for an accurate test.
Bought it, used it, its no big deal. I do the KH and Phosphate while waiting for it to develop. Also the Red Sea Test kit if you follow the directions takes 11+ minutes in wait and mixing time.
So true! Although I think the Red Sea Nitrate test kit that comes as a part of their Master kit is a bit faster... Glad you like it. I've though about breaking it out again in the last few weeks since I ran out of my Nyos test kit, but I just switched back to API. Not nearly as good!
My husband is colour blind so literally can’t use any colour based test kits. This is great, despite the process.
I'm sure you've found the high range version by now! So much better!
Unfortunally i bought this checker, wid out watch first a review. As soon as i opened it, ive seen the trouble that a reefer should go through jus to chek nitrate.. I decided to do not use it and resell asap! I wish i could hv seen this review before to buy :(. Thanx man u speek the truth ;)
You are welcome! Sorry you saw this video too late though! Hope you find a buyer for it! It's a good test kit, just so complicated!!!
Was thinking to buy this test until i saw your video.i hate all this never ending steps🥴.will buy nyos instead.good video👍
Give you like👍
Hey thanks! Yes, I love the Nyos test kit. My favorite by far! I use it everyday actually! I haven't used the Hanna test kit since making the video! It's more like a collectors item for me at this point! I'll look back fondly in 10 years remembering those times I used it... and shiver at the thought! Ha, ha, just kidding. It's a good test kit, just too many steps for me! Thanks for watching and liking Cristina!
At around the 2:50 mark you specify using the 5 Ml syringe with the large plastic extension. Assuming you filled to the 4 ml mark on the syringe (you didn't show it in the video). If you draw to the 4 ml line on the syringe, you actually have more than 4 ml. You need to account for the content in the extension tube. That extension tube accounts for a little over a ml of content\fluid.
Hey Bob, thanks for the comment. I used to think the same thing too! But even with the extension tube, it is still 4ml if you draw the syringe to line up at the 4ml line. If you take the syringe up until the liquid is at the 4ml line, then you would be correct. But if you take the syringe to the 4ml line, you'll notice that the liquid doesn't fill all the way. That is because of the extension tube. Does that make sense?
@@MyFirstFishTank yes it does. I was testing the measurements taking the fluid to the 4 ml line. I did not account for the "air gap"
This looks like a very nice product . It looks like it may cost about 5 to 7 dollars to make this, but the Price you're charging is outrageous. that's taking advantage.
I watched many videos on the hanna nitrate checker this is the only video i would say best wow amazing 1 2 3 your done clearly explained thank you
Wow, thank you! Super kind thing to say! I'm glad it was helpful!
@@MyFirstFishTank when it's 5.00 and its flashing what is that mean, it's more then 50
Finally someone agrees with me that some of the Hanna checkers are way to much of a pain in the butt.
Yeah for sure. I really like the phosphate checker and the alkalinity checker, because they are easy! But this one is complicated even compared to the Calcium Checker, which is already complicated. What nitrate test kit do you use?
My First Fish Tank That’s funny you say that, the phosphate one is the only Hanna I use. I think the Red Sea Alk tester is quicker and little more cost effective than Hanna but not quite as accurate. Since I find myself testing my sps tank everyday, I am all about saving the money.
For nitrate I just use the API, it’s terrible trying to figure out how yellow your test is, but I am super religious about my water changes and feed really lightly so it works for me knowing as long as I don’t turn orange I am good 😅 I have been curious about trying the nyos one out.
I bought a lot (as in auction lot) of Hanna checkers and this one was included. The text instructions for dilution are horrible. The official video is crap. Even though you were ranting against this checker, your instructions were perfect for the dilution step. Going to use it up and when the reagents are gone Ill mount it to my wall and wax fondly of the days I used this POS.
I didn't understand were the tank water was added
I bought this not knowing all these steps and used it once and in garbage. I use API not as accurate but it's quick and cheap.
I purchased one as I tend to run on the low range for NO3 and the color change using carts is near impossible for me to read, that said this kit is.... annoying. lol
:-)
I was going to buy one, but the box says 0-5ppm and I would like to check up to 10+ ppm. After researching further and discovering the method to test up to 50ppm I went out and bought one....and who else will be using this checker? Perhaps people that are colourblind, and like me, people that don't trust the colour checkers because of the different results you get in different lights and even the angle the same light hits the vial!
It's a good checker, and I still use it occasionally. And if your colorblind, then shoot... why not right? You'll get faster and faster at it for sure!
I’m gutted really...Iv been waiting for this to come out for a long time.
Hanna thinks we are all scientists! we are hobbyists and need something a lot faster and a tester that goes from 0-50 nitrate in two simple steps.
Yeah it's a tough call huh? I was really looking forward to this test kit as well. I didn't every imagine it could be more complicated than the calcium checker, but it is by a long shot. Maybe this product is aimed more at professional marine biologists in public aquarium settings. Not sure. So the question is... Are you still going to buy it?
A big no
My First Fish Tank I have all the other Hanna testers, the calcium tester I think is great and a lot of people don’t like it.
I used to think the calcium checker was too difficult... but now I see it in a whole new light!! :-)
uhhhh... is there a better way to test than this? I dont need high resolution, I am fine with resolution to the tenth place....
Think many of those "SPS dominant" reef tank owners would be looking at the latest, or upcoming automated checkers. The Reefbot for example which has been out for some time. GHL has their ION director coming out this month for which I will look forward to reviews. Not sure of the accuracy of the Reefbot nitrate test but at least it should be consistent. I would guess you could tie it in with an ICP test as a baseline. There are other alternatives and I am sure Trident will come out with something sometime but when you are talking about potentially $1000's of coral, accuracy and regular testing would become important. Something which takes time and is complicated would mean it is less likely to be done as I am sure I am not the only one who is lazy.
Yeah, this is all important to consider. I would be curious to see how accurate this checker is compared to the reefbot or trident. I like your idea of pairing it with an ICP test to really see. I mean, I can be lazy, but I'm sure you're like me. We do what we need to for our tanks right? But a 17 minute nitrate test even pushes my patience! Will you be getting one of these? Thanks for watching and your insights!
@@MyFirstFishTank I'll admit I do not check nitrate as often now as I did when I first started when I was religious about it. It tends to be stable unlike a lot of other things I test for more regularly such as the core trio, Alk, Calcium and Magnesium which I have to dose. I'll stick to my basic nitrate test kit for now.
Great video I got this because I love Hanna checkers even though some are complicated. I enjoy the process. I’ve always liked the water testing process
Thanks! The truth of the matter is I still do use this from time to time, especially when I'm really trying to get my nitrates just right! It's a good tester. After a few months, I'd say I still wish the rubber o-ring was different, and I wish the filter was easier to unscrew! A good product that with a few tweaks could be great!
Wish I'd watched a few more review videos before buying one of these.
Opened up the Phosphate checker and thought "Nice, that'll be convenient".
Opened up the Nitrate checker and thought "WTF? Theres powders and liquids and a filter paper and that many steps? Dammit!!!"
This is going on a shelf and I'll revert to the Sailfert test and only pull this out if I ever really need a precise reading. So... never?
Totally get it. But, Hanna has come out with a new, high range nitrate checker which is amazing! Only 1 reagent and perfect for aquariums! I would get rid of the low range checker and upgrade to this one! www.bulkreefsupply.com/nitrate-high-range-colorimeter-hi782-marine-water-hanna-instruments.html
Hi if I am trying to get my nitrates down and its at 7 lets say 7 would I have to do two test...or can I do a dilution test to cover the below result
Hey there. You can always actually just do the dilution test. Just multiply the results by 10. It's probably not quite as accurate as doing the standard test, but once you are certain your nitrates are low, then you can switch from the dilution version to the non-diluted version. Hope that answers your question!
Comparing to Red Sea, I think we have the same problems. Have to wait 9 minutes, and have the low range and high range. But watching the video, looks really painful doing the test. Specially the part that you have to prepare a new salt water
Yeah, it's quite similar to the red sea in terms of wait time. The additional filtration step with the Hanna checker is the most difficult part for me. And having to make a new batch of saltwater just to test? For some of us that's not a problem, but I don't think the average hobbyists keeps spare salt lying around!
This is crazy! Orgo labs in college were easier than this. Good presentation of the hassles. I will definitely pass. The syringe alone scared me, needles give me the creeps. I've been using the Salifert but I find it almost impossible to tell if my nitrates are 5 or closer to 50 PPM. Just got Red Sea nitrate test kit, have used once, didn't understand the result (NO3 and N-NO3 or something and didn't match Salifert for either) but we'll see, new test kits seem to take time to get used to.
Yeah I also find the salifert hard. I like the API for Nitrate actually. I can usually tell the measurement to within 0.1 ppm, which aint bad in my book! I'll be curious to hear how you like the Red Sea after a few uses. I just made an ammonia test kit video and my next video in that series will be Nitrate, so stay tuned to see which one you might want to buy next!
@@MyFirstFishTank Are you going to review the Nyos? Is that API trustworthy? I associate API with inaccuracy... perhaps unfairly.
I am. I believe I'll be testing the following. Hanna, api, red sea, nyos, salifert, seachem, & aquaforest. Should be enlightening... for me at least!
Thanks for the heads up, definitely appreciate it.
Great video, I was going to buy one but you gave an honest review and I need to pass. Not a sps tank.
Glad you found it helpful. I will say that since this video I still do occasionally use it, when it's trending toward zero. But it just takes so much longer that I revert to other tests! Thanks for watching and commenting!
@@MyFirstFishTank I thought your videos were excellent.
I use Red Sea and I do agree with you on the dKH that Red Sea offers a better product.
Now the Hanna UTL Phosphate test is right on point.
I'm going to subscribe to your channel, hope it helps.
Thanks Ray, and yeah, I use the Hanna Phosphate checker every single day! Such a good test!
Thanks pal, its great to answered, not many do.... (Arrons aquarium...).... I am chasing numbers...
No worries, glad to answer! Thanks for commenting and watching!
WOW Great Video!!! I was looking at those... and I am glad you made this!
Are you going to get one? Do you think you would use it? Just curious!
My First Fish Tank After watching the struggle.... NAH, I’m a run and go type, the quicker the better....
Hi follow everything for the high range above 5 and it was 3.71 x 10 =37.1....is that correct...
Yep, you got that right! Definitely on the high side!
WHOAA. Should I quit my job?
4mL of reagent A measured how? Plunger or liquid level?
I dont remember! I haven't used this test in quite a while!
Great Video.... thank you.
Thanks John! Are you going to get one?
I bought this because i have all the hannas and when i opened it, I said nope and put it away. The video they have isnt even detailed enough as yours. This test sucks so much!!! The vial isnt exactly 10 ml either so Idk how youre getting an accurate reading everytime.
Nope! Thank you! I’m taking mine back to the LFS manana....
OMG I hate this checker and I haven't even started to use mine. So many steps shoot me now! But great video
So many steps right! Thanks for watching!
shouldi return this? whats the best nitrate test kit ?
No, it works just fine. It is. probably the most accurate test kit out there! But you will definitely want a different test kit for everyday use. My current two favorites are Salifert and Nyos.
Thank you so much for your advice & it’s funny I actually fall into your “who will need / use this kit”
1, my aquarium is going to be a SPS dominant aquarium & 2, I’ve already purchased 7 different Hanna test kits hahahaha
But I truly appreciate this video & your advice
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for taking time to leave a comment!
Great review! Thanks!
Thanks for watching!
Lol just got mine and your guide is the first I used, thanks for making it fun 👍
Awesome! You know, even though I said I wasn't going to use it, I find myself using from time to time because it's just so accurate! Glad you found the video helpful!
Api nitrate test kit has entered the chat
For sure! I really like the API nitrate test kit!
It took you 17 minutes because you preformed and over complicated the test drastically. The only difference with this test and all the others is you need to mix and filter part of your sample........ that’s it......... everything else is easy and straightforward..
I'm glad you found it easier than I did. I wonder what others think? If anybody else read this, leave a comment and let's hear your feedback! Thanks for watching and commenting Erick.
Dude! Great video. Man.... I HATE TESTING! It’s the one part of this hobby that I absolutely hate. lol This kit is definitely not for me. I want quick results simple as that.
I too hate testing! Some people love it though right? Thanks for watching Rob!
Damn, just ordered mine! And your videos suddenly appears.
i have failed first couple times, but it is alright since then
17 minute test for 7 tanks - waste a whole day testing. Not good. Should read from 0 to 100.
Nearly 2 hours to do all the testing?
It's kind of crazy huh? It would take an entire day! And you are right, it would be great if it read to 100. Because let's be real... a lot of our tanks have high nitrates! So I'm assuming you're not going to get one?
Hi Matthew which copper test kit accurate?
The only one I've used is the API kit. The only time I used this I had to raise the copper level to 2ppm, and I added the amount I was supposed to, and voila, the test kit read 2ppm. So it seems to have worked well for me! www.marinedepot.com/api-freshwater-saltwater-copper-test-kit-test-kit-of-90-tests
@@MyFirstFishTank Thank you for the suggestion..
...and another thing. I’ve just attempted to do my first test (need accuracy at very low range, to determine nitrate dosing on a new setup into which I’m moving a mature reef - long story....) and guess what? I have no idea how I’m going to draw up “exactly 4ml of Reagent A” when the 5ml syringe HAS NO MARKINGS ON IT. Uh huh. Blank. Thought I would get the benefit of being careful by spending the $100 (Canadian) on the tester and a reagent refill. Nope. Hanna disappoints, not for the first time. @Hanna Instruments, Inc. I’m not afraid of complex tests, but it would be awesome to actually have the proper tools included in the not-so-cheap test kit. 🤬🤬🤬🤬
Frustrating eh? I've gotten used to the nitrate checker. I can't say I use it very often, but sometimes when I'm looking for low range accuracy I'll pull it out.
I have 2 tanks, one mixed sps/lps dominate tank with clams and delicate inverts. The other is a FOWLR tangs/triggerfish/wrasse tank. For the mixed tank, I cant second guess accuracy-so I got the NO3 Hanna unit. I can deal with the steps and time involved, BUT-I CANT DEAL WITH THE NEED TO DILUTE WITH FRESH UNUSED SALT WATER!!!!!! Who has that laying around????? Hanna should make available reference water!!!! WTF?????? Maybe Ill have to schedule my test around the weekly water change. IMO Hanna kinda screwed the pooch on this one. Thank god for my Nyos and Red Sea kits.
Ha, totally understand! Thanks for sharing!
Wish I would have seen this before I bought it… you are dead on it’s kind of a pain to use by
I feel like Hanna realized it is 2020, decided to troll everyone and PRESTO! worst NO3 test ever. Brilliant!
Ha! I just don't understand why they didn't consult hobbyists about this test. Maybe we are a tiny fraction of their market, but for the Checkers I feel like we are the largest segment of their market. It would have only taken a select handful of hobbyists to let them know that this test is too onerous!
The Manhattan Project was less complicated.
Haha, this made me chuckle!
Another thing, you look suspiciously like the producer of Graveyard Carz. :)
Hmmm. I'm going to have to look up who that is! :)
You can make this test, and in 8 min of testing time do other test, but it seems to complicated for you 😂
I have hi range and it's reading o.o
New in box Hanna Nitrate test kit for sale.......
:-)
this is beyond bs for hanna to make this test. i rather buy a ghl ion director or as a last resort, an apex but that is as a last resort
I couldn't agree with this reviewer more. I have the red sea and api test kits, but I just had to have a digital display kit. After mucking up the first 3 attempts and after an hour later, I went back to api. Big waste of $50 and time out of like I can't get back. Way too many steps and too complicated for my needs servicing a 25 gal reef tank. Pass!!
Thanks Michael, it's always nice to hear I'm not alone in my opinions. I still think it is a good test, and in fact I've used it several times since. But I now just go for salifert or nyos because they are so much easier and faster! Thanks for taking time to leave a comment!
That test kit seems more like a pain in the butt and not even worth it
I hear you. I think it might be worth it for a very specific audience. But the vast majority of hobbyists just won't use it. To many points for user error and it takes soooo long! So I'm guessing you are not going to buy one?
@@MyFirstFishTank nope wen I first seen it I thought I might but after seeing that it's not a must have for me if it was easier I probably would
Makes sense to me!
Is this a joke,?!?! Are they even serious?!?
I hear you! The filtration portion is the worst for me. I think if you did it a lot you would just get the hang of it! I assume you're not going to get one then?:-)
@@MyFirstFishTank your video was exactly what i wanted a fair unbiased review. And yes Sir i will not buy one i invested and just bought a phosphate ulr instead of the nitrate. The funny thing is i complained to hanna checker about red sea test because i need to add two reagent and wait for 8 minutes thinking Hanna will give me something like thier alk test but boy i was wrong.b
So glad to hear it helped!
Making methamphetamine is easier than this😥
Wow - got not even half way though - won't be buying! Way too many steps. Good vid though!
Thanks Mark! Get their new High Range Checker! Only one step and I use it all the time!!
I was going to buy this. But I thought I best watch a review on it.. you probably guess what I'm going to do now.. I have 6 saltwater tanks. And I'm getting no younger.. thank you for your vid.. 👎👎👎👎👎
Glad you found it helpful. I do still use this test from time to time, but only when I want to know my nitrates with super high accuracy!
So wrong man
wow too many steps. thanks for sharing. Not for me.
Yeah, buy their new high range checker! one step!
@@MyFirstFishTank thanks