One of the most bizarre scenes in one of the most bizarre TV shows of all time lol, it literally came out of nowhere and made no sense. I nearly spat my tea out when I heard his voice too ☕
This is legitimately one of the best scenes ever. I think about it all the time. I watched it with my parents and wanted to jump out of a window. So good.
For me I just love how turbo soap opera this show can be sometimes because it seems to me the only intention of the director here is to convey the teenage confusion of seeing his ex-girlfriend's dead ringer in the moment and forgetting about his current girlfriend right next to her. And she notices. Because it's so ridiculously melodramatic, it's how the director conveys the power of the emotion. It's SUPER corny, and his voice is well... it is what it is. But I LOVE how this show just ramped every emotion to 11. Either you can flow with it, and feel it with the characters, or it breaks immersion. No right answer, but this song is such an earworm and those looks are straight up Sergio Leone in execution. It's just teenage soapy drama though. Really low stakes, but the way it's done you get the idea that really it's the only thing that matters to all involved in the moment. Truly "Just You and I". LOL. Oh and also Donna. Poor Donna. lol
In a media world awash with Rambo and Arnold victims, fully automatic Uzis and Robocop splattering acid victims, this show introduced the body for a murder mystery and then dedicated the next HALF HOUR to the grief stricken family and friends. Lynch might be a weirdo, but this show was aces.
@kikaku2501 If your takeaway from RoboCop was the violence, I don't know what to say. It's got the tonal diversity of Twin Peaks and then some. Yes, it's got the over-the-top violence, but there's so much more to it. Pitch black comedy, social commentary on capitalism and the American media, and the heart-wrenching story of Murphy's self-discovery. It's definitely miles ahead of the rest of the action schlock put out in the '80s.
Almost every scene in Twin Peaks has me rolling. Like the set up is so clean, they are just waiting to start. Then the scene is so weird and pointless sometimes. This one is no exception, I really love Twin Peaks for how much it makes me laugh due to how quirky it is.
This scene is far from pointless. Also, funny? Sad, depressing, touching, sure. Twin Peaks contains a lot of humour but I don't really think that was what they were going for here.
This particular scene isn't pointless, for the record. It's when James starts to see Laura in Maddy and becomes attracted to her. When Donna also sees it, it drives a wedge between them and pushes her towards Harold. People seeing Maddy as Laura is also a recurring element - she hates it, and it ultimately leads to her death.
@@sourdough3533 Sheryl Lee became Laura in this moment. I remember being startled when I first saw it. So clever, to make us see what James was seeing.
I don't think David Lynch has ever done anything that's not quirky, that's what makes his stuff so fun to watch. And he doesn't apologize for it. And for those that hated it, he decided to troll them again, and bring it back, which was even more hysterical and brilliant. Lynch does not apologize to anyone. Not fans, critics, networks, no one.
If you listen to David Lynch's musical work, he clearly enjoys the sound of high pitched vocals, even if they sound uncomfortable. I can't explain why, but there does seem to be a pattern.
James has always been the worst twin peaks character, there’s literally not a single redeeming quality about his retarded personality and decision making. The actor didn’t help much with his monotone portrayal either
Nah low-key I like it. I like the song for sure. I'd probably tweak the vocals to snap it on key at all times, but I'm not turned off by how corny it is.
I really love this song and this scene unironically. I find it genuinely beautiful. I only realised from the comment section that people saw it as a meme
I am on this episode (finally watching the series). I'm laughing at all the comments here, because yeah I found this scene really weird, mostly his voice! Totally unexpected. The first note out of his mouth... I was so thrown off. "what?!" lol. Then I thought. No this has to be on purpose. This is a joke, right? Lynch is pulling our legs. Then I was thinking maybe it was the voice of the woman singing at the club in the first season.... and he was intentionally being weird, using a female voice just to fit the vibe, but not that the characters in the moment actually heard it like that. As I was trying to figure this out, I inevitably got drawn into the hypnotic musical vibe. And then I was just enjoying the love triangle aspect.... the romantic over the top staring between him and Donna. And then him inevitably looking at Laura's cousin and not being able to look away. And Donna noticing, and her jealousy. LOL. I loved it. I love how David Lynch visualizes those emotions, amplifies the eye contact, unspoken things. So yeah, this scene confused me but then drew me in and now I'm here on youtube watching it over again. Oh David Lynch
@@Stellarheim It was a spontaneous séance. Laura had taken over Maddy almost entirely at this point, the whole thing was ethereal and out of their time... Where do you think all the other instrumentation came from?
I never laughed or cringed to this or the Laura's burial scene, never understood what is so funny about them, these scenes were beautiful to me but I guess I'm weird or something
I gotta say…. This really drew into question the so-called genius of David lynch. I always figured that he was operating on a plane higher than my own, and that maybe I was missing something due to my own shortcomings. But now…..
Interesting how different people react to this scene. I laughed like hell. It's so cheesy but I enjoyed it and wouldn't like to see it omitted. Others have cringed at it and some have even loved it.
Divorce the song from the visuals - it's a perfect early '60s LA-style group harmony song (in its full length) a la The Innocents or The Fleetwoods. And now back to our regularly scheduled weirdness....
It was Lara Flynn Boyle, she was such a bad actress and made Donna so unlikable. So it was easy to not like James either, since he fell in love with her. And she was by far the worst thing about Twin Peaks. His scenes non-Donna, even then, weren't that bad. James was kinda naive at times, so he was an easy target, but hey, he's a kid... Kids can be pretty naive and stupid. And then post Donna, in season 2, they gave him an awful storyline with Evelyn, that just sucked... So it really made it easy to never warm up to James Hurley. But even in the movie, his screen time with Laura (Sherlyn Lee), was miles better than it ever was with Lara Flynn Boyle/Donna. And could see his character had a lot of potential. They never really gave the James Hurley's character much to work with in the first two seasons.
What was even the point of this?? What were they doing?? The Return implies people know about this song bc he plays it at The Roadhouse so did he make it as a musician?
I actuaoly love this scene tbh but when it first stsrted playing I was so confused lmao. They never mention wanting to sing together or James playing guitar or even show them setting up first. They just cut to it lmao with the strange vocals? I actually find it quite sweet and comforting tbh, though the ending exoanding the love hectogon was so odd lol. How many women does James need to f*ck haha cannot he not just pick one? Or just two even haha?
Things are well, go on and get boring, and then hey, there's something amiss; that's interesting enough. Let's go with it. Now Cooper's barfing into a radio. Repeat.
![Twin Peaks (1990 vs 2023) Cast: Then and Now [33 Years After]](/img/n.gif)
The echo. The sharp vocals. The cringe. The whatever the fuck is going on at the end. I love it.
Hahaha, for a while I thought that it was bad youtube compression. 😜
L Y N C H E D
If you play The Everly Brothers "All I Have To Do Is Dream" at the same time this is playing, you will have the ultimate creeeeepy David Lynch video.
It was amazing that no matter how much hate this song got, Lynch brought it back in the Return. 😂
The wrong key
Shelly: James was always cool.
James:
This is cool as hell it's soulful haha
This is insanely cool
One looks like James and one has to have a picture of Patrick to hide his facial shame
The guy that gets all the girls Absolutely swooning over him because he's oozing James Dean esque vibes...yup!
This was the only scene in twin peaks that actually made me uncomfortable.
Voch miayn qez, axpers! (Not only you, mate)
😬
This is the one scene that I’ll never forget and always love
oh...try 13th...
@@adriansvarela what about scene with Cooper and Annie?
I want this song to be played at my funeral as they lower my body into the ground. I think it’d be hilariously unsettling.
Unsettling because it's a romantic song?
LMAO everyone would be uncomfortably glancing around not knowing what to do
Lmao I might jump on your casket if you do that haha
If this song plays at my funeral I am rising from the grave
@@HaydenRisingYou can ride the casket up and down like Leland.
i couldn’t help but laugh everytime the backing track played later on in the show 😂
Exactly 😂😂
How these actors made it through some of these scenes without laughing hysterically will always be a mystery to me.
One of the most bizarre scenes in one of the most bizarre TV shows of all time lol, it literally came out of nowhere and made no sense. I nearly spat my tea out when I heard his voice too ☕
no sense, are you serious? This is highsschool drama, typical from 90s and Lynch know it
Exactly
making it out the lodge with this one🔥🔥
This is definitely one of the scenes of all time
Yes it is
One of the scenes that made me more intensely feel "are they for real?"
if you survived after watching Twin peaks you will survive anything.
James just couldn't control himself with around any attractive woman, period... Too funny.
This was the only scene in twin peaks that actually made me feel comfortable
This is legitimately one of the best scenes ever. I think about it all the time. I watched it with my parents and wanted to jump out of a window. So good.
For me I just love how turbo soap opera this show can be sometimes because it seems to me the only intention of the director here is to convey the teenage confusion of seeing his ex-girlfriend's dead ringer in the moment and forgetting about his current girlfriend right next to her. And she notices. Because it's so ridiculously melodramatic, it's how the director conveys the power of the emotion. It's SUPER corny, and his voice is well... it is what it is. But I LOVE how this show just ramped every emotion to 11. Either you can flow with it, and feel it with the characters, or it breaks immersion. No right answer, but this song is such an earworm and those looks are straight up Sergio Leone in execution. It's just teenage soapy drama though. Really low stakes, but the way it's done you get the idea that really it's the only thing that matters to all involved in the moment. Truly "Just You and I". LOL. Oh and also Donna. Poor Donna. lol
In a media world awash with Rambo and Arnold victims, fully automatic Uzis and Robocop splattering acid victims, this show introduced the body for a murder mystery and then dedicated the next HALF HOUR to the grief stricken family and friends. Lynch might be a weirdo, but this show was aces.
@kikaku2501 If your takeaway from RoboCop was the violence, I don't know what to say. It's got the tonal diversity of Twin Peaks and then some. Yes, it's got the over-the-top violence, but there's so much more to it. Pitch black comedy, social commentary on capitalism and the American media, and the heart-wrenching story of Murphy's self-discovery. It's definitely miles ahead of the rest of the action schlock put out in the '80s.
Turbo Soap Opera is a wonderful description which I will now use on multiple occasions. Thank you.
Donna's best girl 100%
❤
Obvious that Bob's playing the bass, but who's playing the drums? 😳
Mike on the bongos̶
The Arm, he rocks
@@joenappi8459 "The drummer from Def Leppard's only got one arm!"
Its just you, and I
@@negate5391 he saw the face of god.
Almost every scene in Twin Peaks has me rolling. Like the set up is so clean, they are just waiting to start. Then the scene is so weird and pointless sometimes. This one is no exception, I really love Twin Peaks for how much it makes me laugh due to how quirky it is.
This scene is far from pointless. Also, funny? Sad, depressing, touching, sure. Twin Peaks contains a lot of humour but I don't really think that was what they were going for here.
This particular scene isn't pointless, for the record. It's when James starts to see Laura in Maddy and becomes attracted to her. When Donna also sees it, it drives a wedge between them and pushes her towards Harold. People seeing Maddy as Laura is also a recurring element - she hates it, and it ultimately leads to her death.
@@sourdough3533 Sheryl Lee became Laura in this moment. I remember being startled when I first saw it. So clever, to make us see what James was seeing.
I don't think David Lynch has ever done anything that's not quirky, that's what makes his stuff so fun to watch. And he doesn't apologize for it. And for those that hated it, he decided to troll them again, and bring it back, which was even more hysterical and brilliant.
Lynch does not apologize to anyone. Not fans, critics, networks, no one.
This is your life bro :)
This is the most terrifying video I've seen this year🥺
woah binaural space profile picture 😳
You must be young... lol.....
You must be young, then :D
Despite its romantic lyrics it's so malencholic. And damn, Donna's stare is ice cold
thanks for creeping me out at the end
😂😂😂 me too!
Same 🤣😢
She become Bob or something?
This song is so good how james pitched up vocals and the one time delay just give it this psychedelic and eerie feeling just with the vocals so good
this is going in the roman empire playlist
It's so corny, I like it 11/10!
Is the corn creamed?
@@DillonExner😂😂😂
Coming here after the return and feeling the void open up beneath my feet
James was always this
If you listen to David Lynch's musical work, he clearly enjoys the sound of high pitched vocals, even if they sound uncomfortable. I can't explain why, but there does seem to be a pattern.
The mix of emotions when i first saw this. I wanted to laugh out loud, but I also lowkey love the song.
Lowkey you're autistic
I watched this the other day. His voice weirded me out to be honest.
so beautiful
@@mikescott4195 aww :3
he's altogether a thoroughly unsettling character
Just got to this scene. Loving the series
Me too
Always brilliantly weird, the best.
Song even sounds very early 60s. Loving the ending there. 😂❤
James sings this song about Laura and sees Laura in Maddy. But this makes his current girlfriend Donna upset. Such as sad scene 😥
It's actually funny, and sums up James. He couldn't keep it in his pants, literally, ever.
Well, mostly everybody cheated on each other in this show...
I love it, so classic old style, but the setting of the scene is what makes it great..
James was always cool, and will be forever on.
James has always been the worst twin peaks character, there’s literally not a single redeeming quality about his retarded personality and decision making. The actor didn’t help much with his monotone portrayal either
Love this song 🖤🖤🖤
i can’t be the only one who genuinely love this song and the way he sings it, come on…
No… I think you might be… David Lynch filmed this to torment us for bastardizing his creation.
Nah low-key I like it. I like the song for sure. I'd probably tweak the vocals to snap it on key at all times, but I'm not turned off by how corny it is.
I don't think it's corny at all, I find it beautiful
@@the3ambreeze same!
I really love this song and this scene unironically. I find it genuinely beautiful. I only realised from the comment section that people saw it as a meme
Beautiful ❤
Wonderful ❤.
love music forever !
This legally makes them a Hanna Barbera mystery-solving team now, right?
Dude what the hell is that ending
I love the edit you made at the end. Absolutely genius, somehow it would fit if this is how the scene was presented in the original run.
Was it on purpose ? So creepy
@@methebee Maddy reminds him of Laura.
I think it's an error with the renderer or something.
unintentional data mosh
why'd you do that to me at the end???? ........... can you make a creepier one?
I really really like this scene
Genuinely the scene that made me realize that David Lynch is a genius
im begging for you to elaborate
@@stoopkid58008 No
It's actually a really nice song idk why everyone hates on it.
@@glennhengist3977 aw man.. ok
@@stoopkid58008 this kind of explains it ua-cam.com/video/jjoMEw2RYlA/v-deo.html
Nossa, essa cena é memorável. Sentimento puro, ótima interpretação, ótima música, ótima letra
the next satellite that heads out into the void of space this track needs to be on the sd card to show da aliens how we do things on earth.
Realest shit ever
this is my favorite musical scene of all time
end of the video maddy is turning to hulk
Twilight saw how long James was staring in this song and decided yes, lets steal that
I am on this episode (finally watching the series). I'm laughing at all the comments here, because yeah I found this scene really weird, mostly his voice! Totally unexpected. The first note out of his mouth... I was so thrown off. "what?!" lol. Then I thought. No this has to be on purpose. This is a joke, right? Lynch is pulling our legs. Then I was thinking maybe it was the voice of the woman singing at the club in the first season.... and he was intentionally being weird, using a female voice just to fit the vibe, but not that the characters in the moment actually heard it like that. As I was trying to figure this out, I inevitably got drawn into the hypnotic musical vibe. And then I was just enjoying the love triangle aspect.... the romantic over the top staring between him and Donna. And then him inevitably looking at Laura's cousin and not being able to look away. And Donna noticing, and her jealousy. LOL. I loved it. I love how David Lynch visualizes those emotions, amplifies the eye contact, unspoken things. So yeah, this scene confused me but then drew me in and now I'm here on youtube watching it over again. Oh David Lynch
Sometimes they forget to open their mouthes when they sing.
And I think that’s part of the surrealness of it all
@@adriansvarela And I think this is a part of very bad editing.
@@Stellarheim It was a spontaneous séance. Laura had taken over Maddy almost entirely at this point, the whole thing was ethereal and out of their time... Where do you think all the other instrumentation came from?
@@Cyborganna Karaoke doesn't usually have a band.
@@aschmitt3395 This is a small jam session, not karaoke.
0:02 in and I don’t know if I can keep going
Красивая песня Джеимса Херли.! Я очень Люблю ТВИН ПИКС! Етот сериал ностальгия моего детства.❤❤❤❤❤👍👍👍👍👍👍
Саме так. Але насправді композитор Ангелло Бадаламенті. ))
@@user-zh5br8jh6u да. Я знаю!
@@user-bu1li3kw1k чудово )))
👍👍👍
@@user-zh5br8jh6u Ага.!👍👍👍👍👍
@@user-bu1li3kw1k у вас як? Спокійно все?
Best scene
This is excatly how everyone looks when they fall in love
El final es epico amigo, alto miedo
I have ear cancer now because of this scene.
James is ok, ok? This is just.....life....BUT, wtf, had happened at the end of this vid??? Oo Damn, what the hell had happened at the end?
I remember in The Return someone said "James was always cool"and I just thought...was he though!? Was he really!?
I never laughed or cringed to this or the Laura's burial scene, never understood what is so funny about them, these scenes were beautiful to me but I guess I'm weird or something
James can't keep it in his pants
I gotta say…. This really drew into question the so-called genius of David lynch. I always figured that he was operating on a plane higher than my own, and that maybe I was missing something due to my own shortcomings. But now…..
Interesting how different people react to this scene. I laughed like hell. It's so cheesy but I enjoyed it and wouldn't like to see it omitted. Others have cringed at it and some have even loved it.
Is the end Howard’s vision from afar?
1:18 rewatching the series on Paramount+. Love the song and the melody.. is there a complete song out there?
Mam wrażenie, że Andrzej Piasek Piaseczny wykorzystał linię melodyczną z tego utworu. Ale może jestem zbyt głuchy 😂😅
Ever wondered who is playing the bass and the side-stick? Also what are their mics going into and how are they doing a live fade out?
its best just not to think about these things.....
James was always cool
Great fooled up ending!!!!
#RIPAngeloBadalamenti
Okay that was pretty good, let's try one more time.
What happened at the end?
Did you see it too??? OO
TOP
this has the same level of awkwardness as skylar whites birthday song
James is literally Dave Gahan🤣
Après Twin-peaks !
The Black Lodge entities are singing this to each other...
Divorce the song from the visuals - it's a perfect early '60s LA-style group harmony song (in its full length) a la The Innocents or The Fleetwoods.
And now back to our regularly scheduled weirdness....
Uff, ja se nebojim rict znovu uff. Ktera z nich je ta prava, tady bych to nedal :-(
I laughed like crazy on this! kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
I actually liked this song...
Reminds me of Ritchie Valens....
The amount I hated James in the first 2 seasons is just about equal to how much I liked him in season 3.
It was Lara Flynn Boyle, she was such a bad actress and made Donna so unlikable. So it was easy to not like James either, since he fell in love with her. And she was by far the worst thing about Twin Peaks. His scenes non-Donna, even then, weren't that bad. James was kinda naive at times, so he was an easy target, but hey, he's a kid... Kids can be pretty naive and stupid.
And then post Donna, in season 2, they gave him an awful storyline with Evelyn, that just sucked...
So it really made it easy to never warm up to James Hurley. But even in the movie, his screen time with Laura (Sherlyn Lee), was miles better than it ever was with Lara Flynn Boyle/Donna. And could see his character had a lot of potential.
They never really gave the James Hurley's character much to work with in the first two seasons.
I liked James in season 1 lol. He was never the BEST character but season 2 just flat out wrecked him.
Filler scene😅. But amazing
Absolutely THE worst thing i have ever experienced
Everyone should play The Everly Brothers "All I Have To Do Is Dream" at the same time this is playing for the ultimate creeeeepy David Lynch video.
damn! the girl at the end stares at you
spotify pleeease
one of the most creepy scene in TV history.
You guys which scene is worse? This one or the scene where Shelly has to feed Leo
That with Shelly. This is a great scene. I don't remember much from the old season but this.
What was even the point of this?? What were they doing?? The Return implies people know about this song bc he plays it at The Roadhouse so did he make it as a musician?
aaaand iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii.........................
I actuaoly love this scene tbh but when it first stsrted playing I was so confused lmao. They never mention wanting to sing together or James playing guitar or even show them setting up first. They just cut to it lmao with the strange vocals?
I actually find it quite sweet and comforting tbh, though the ending exoanding the love hectogon was so odd lol.
How many women does James need to f*ck haha cannot he not just pick one? Or just two even haha?
Donna looks lowkey terrified
Bob plays The Bass
He is Bob, eager for fun. He wears a smile,
everybody run
They first time i Saw this was like, yo WTF it's happening. Very weird vibe
Things are well, go on and get boring, and then hey, there's something amiss; that's interesting enough. Let's go with it. Now Cooper's barfing into a radio. Repeat.
Que sont-ils devenus ?
"Твин Пикс" - навсегда!
"Twin Peaks" - forever!)))
😆😅🤣😂😂😂🥰😍🩷 OH James
The hardest-to-watch scene in the whole series.
*I I I N N n n n l l l L O V E E*