Wendy looks the prettiest with dark hair and no bangs I must say. But FYI Wendy never gained weight, she just has toned thighs now due to the built of muscle, she still has her abs. And her face is prone to swell, just just that type of skin she has.
5678ExoShidae honestly her bangs look really good on her plus she said that she loved them so I don't think she's getting rid of them anytime soon 😂 maybe for the comeback in September though
She has said herself that she goes through a yo-yoing diet, “I’m planning to gain all the weight soon” was her response when asked about how skinny she had gotten
Wendy's body 2016 she's getting little fat but when they debut she's sexy diet Wendy your getting fat again talk about seulgi. seulgi is sexy even know and before ~sorry I'm not good at English
+Mariafelisa Redondo Wendy isn't fat, in fact she has abs. People are only calling her fat because her thighs are made of muscle so they appear likes this, you shouldn't fat shame anyone...
Wendy is not fat, her face still looks the same, like it always was, she just has a round face. And her body is exactly the same. So people need to stop saying she is getting fat, cause she is no where near fat. She looks 10 times healthier now than she does her. Looks like she is actually eating now. She will go back to starving herself if people keep calling her fat. All celebrity's do.
It amazes me how stable they were even during debut era. I'm glad Wendy is happier nowadays because she's unstoppable when she puts her all onstage. She deserves all the best things in life :')
You will know who is the prettiest member when you saw them during their debut era. And honestly i think it's wendy,im not trying to drag other members it's just my opinion.
I'm so tired of all these comments saying they want the old Wendy back, Wendy barely changed. The only noticeable thing is that now she is built of muscle(she still has her abs). I think she is beautiful in all the eras so far, and it's so annoying how some people want her to go back, she's perfectly fine now...
AESLEHC RACSO I pointed out her stomach because people in the below comments were saying how she didn't have abs, but she still did. As u can see by comments I think she's beautiful no matter what and only care that she's healthy, whether she has abs or not
for everyone who call wendy visual hole you must see this video!!!! im totally ok with her visual now (bcs wendy is my bias) but if u haters keep saying wendy is visual hole just wait until the old wendy is back
They changed Wendy's hairstyle and gave her bangs so she wouldn't outshine Irene since she's supposed to be the visual of the group. This is just my speculation. Wendy was more popular than Irene when they debuted and a lot of people think she was the prettiest.
yes. i do think so as well that ssw's more popular than irene in Happiness era. watch videos of idols reacting to their Happiness (mv [like nct] or stages), they really anticipate *Wendy's (SHINE ON ME) part.* examples for a reaction to search are BTS' and EXO's reaction to Happiness live.
"Happiness" is the only red velvet song that i sing without realization, i know the whole lyrics and i didn't even learn it, i just listened to it A LOT :')
its so cute seeing them here, so young especially joy, she literally looks like a baby here 🥺 now they have grown into mature gorgeous women wowowowwow
I’d always love main vocalists who’s commited while dancing as well. Secret Number’s Denise, Red Velvet’s Wendy, EXID’s Solji, GFRIEND’s Yuju and whoever else. The group depended on their vocals but gave us moments where they seem to be the best dancers.
Wow, I was afraid I was the only one noticing it. That Wendy was just DYNAMITE back then, totally a little doll. Then I look at the comments and it turns out everyone is saying it, From 6 years ago right up until now. Nice! I really think if I had been a high-schooler back then, it would have Wendy that I stanned. And.... she's still smokin! No foolin'!
the girls had streaks of their colors in their hair, this was very fun and striking. The dance break is so much fun, I love it!! This remix is great. 👏🏼
무대 진짜..ㅋㅋ 무대 뒤 객석은 ㄹㅇ 맘만 먹으면 나와서 같이 춤춰도 아무도 못막을듯
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌ
춤춰 주세요
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아 개웃겨 도랏ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱㄱ
아 상상했엌ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Wendy's prettiest during this era!
Actually, she's still pretty even now :))
+Savannah Kim agree!
JJ C she's been pretty the WHOLE time. Her bangs look really good too
JJ C always,😍
Carlerblue nah, she was thinner in Red Flavor era, to the point there was lots of concern for her because of how thin she looked
웬디 복근 미쳤다 그것도 그건데 ㄹㅇ 완전 생 라이브네 이게 바로 신인의 쪼다 ㄹㅇ 쩐다
Bring back Wendy's black hair!! She looks like a total goddess with black hair omg
omg ikr??I hate her hair now especially her bangs
+Paulyne Shane Benedicto I wouldn't say I hate them but they're not the most flattering style!
+Xin Lim hmm yeah she still looks beautiful😃
+Alfrian Ramadhan dat red tho it belongs to ronald mcdonald give it back
agree
Wendy looks the prettiest with dark hair and no bangs I must say. But FYI Wendy never gained weight, she just has toned thighs now due to the built of muscle, she still has her abs. And her face is prone to swell, just just that type of skin she has.
5678ExoShidae honestly her bangs look really good on her plus she said that she loved them so I don't think she's getting rid of them anytime soon 😂 maybe for the comeback in September though
5678ExoShidae how would you know her skin type...lol...
Yass
She has said herself that she goes through a yo-yoing diet, “I’m planning to gain all the weight soon” was her response when asked about how skinny she had gotten
i also think it’s because this was before her plastic surgery
이때 진심 웬디가 제일 예뻐서 센터인줄 알았음
전형적인 SM상
웬디지금도 너무이쁜데 이때웬디가 진짜 고급지고 이쁨...
지금도 너무 귀엽구 예쁘고 어린 웬디도 귀여움🥰
웬디 이때 너무 기여워ㅠㅠ눈 땡글땡글
이게 걸그룹 데뷔의 정석이다
Wendy's abs. IM GONNA DIE.
ct kim lol! That's 300th like... That comment though 😂🤣
Woww 5 years agoooo
She was probably starving herself for them. I feel bad for her.
2021
We’re absolutely gonna die if we follow their diet
행복 무대 처음 봤을 때 슬기 포지션 랩인 줄 알았는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이때 의상 깔끔한데 포인트도 살리고 잘 만들었다
슬기 의상 진짜 잘 어울림 코디님 슬잘알 시절
백,청팀 나누는거 진짜 개오랜만이네
ㅇㅈ 진짜 개오랜만
엥 웬디이땨 오ㅑ케이쁨 당황 지금도 이쁜데 근데 제금웬디랑 다른사람같음 스타일차이거 이렇게 ㅡ크구나
성형해서그럼
@@이나영-l1r 뭐래
ㅇㅈ 미국 유학간 존예강윰 ㅠㅠ
@서희주 ㅏ
레벨 빨간 맛 때부터 팬인데 확실히 뭔가 느낌이 다름. 성형한 거 같기도 함.
아니 박수소리 너무 쌩아니냐고ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 의도치않게 라이브했는데 라이브 미쳤다ㅋㅋㅋ 아 당황스러워
내가 진짜 몇번이고 이때 웬디 이쁘다고 말하고 다녔는데 다 모르더라고 ... 다시 저 스타일링한 웬디 존버한다 ... 죽기전에 꼭 한번 더 보여줘 스엠놈들아
Wendy looks so good with that hair, no doubt she looks good with other hairstyles but this one idk why, I really love this one she looks too good
0:15 시작도 전에 뜻밖의 라이브 인증 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 신인시절이라
다들 너무 귀엽네요 ㅠㅠ
짝짝소맄ㅋㅋㅋ
when u miss wendy's forehead, just watch all videos from happiness era and you'll be happy. just like me XD
**happiness era is totally wendy's era*
Omg totally same with me😁
Wendy and Seulgi body 😍
+JANE she gained some weight during dumb dumb promotions
Wendy's body 2016 she's getting little fat but when they debut she's sexy diet Wendy your getting fat again talk about seulgi. seulgi is sexy even know and before
~sorry I'm not good at English
+Mariafelisa Redondo Wendy isn't fat, in fact she has abs. People are only calling her fat because her thighs are made of muscle so they appear likes this, you shouldn't fat shame anyone...
Wendy is not fat, her face still looks the same, like it always was, she just has a round face. And her body is exactly the same. So people need to stop saying she is getting fat, cause she is no where near fat. She looks 10 times healthier now than she does her. Looks like she is actually eating now. She will go back to starving herself if people keep calling her fat. All celebrity's do.
if people think Wendy is fat, then what am i? 😂
It amazes me how stable they were even during debut era. I'm glad Wendy is happier nowadays because she's unstoppable when she puts her all onstage. She deserves all the best things in life :')
You will know who is the prettiest member when you saw them during their debut era. And honestly i think it's wendy,im not trying to drag other members it's just my opinion.
지금은 볼 수 옶는 미자둥둥...진짜 댄브에서 손키스 날리는 부분 너무 사랑스럽다
와 진심 웬디 ㅈㄴ 이쁘다
Wow they're amazing!!! They're really stable and you can clearly hear it's live
아 진짜 저기서 민망해서 어케 춤 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 보는 내가 다 쪽팔려 너무 가까우니까 호응도 안해주고...
웬디 비주얼쇼크네... 진짜 예쁘다
밑에서보면 치마속까지 다 보이는거 아니냐,,,,?? 이딴 무대는 만들지도 말아라,,,,,
속바지라 괜춘지 아늘까여
@@zeros_space1798 밑에서찍는애들때문에
문제요 직캠같은경우나.
돌아다니거든요..ㅜㅜ
그렇게 치면 콘서트 맨앞좌석이나 대학축제 맨앞도 똑같지않나
@@0602-x9i 그런곳은 무대가 넓고, 관객들이랑 띄어져있잖아요
남자가 여자 치마 속 보면 안되는 부분이냐?
I'm so tired of all these comments saying they want the old Wendy back, Wendy barely changed. The only noticeable thing is that now she is built of muscle(she still has her abs). I think she is beautiful in all the eras so far, and it's so annoying how some people want her to go back, she's perfectly fine now...
Preach
AESLEHC RACSO I pointed out her stomach because people in the below comments were saying how she didn't have abs, but she still did. As u can see by comments I think she's beautiful no matter what and only care that she's healthy, whether she has abs or not
we just want that hairstyle which suit her best
I just want a dark no bangs Wendy
misheel dolguun I love her forehead having freedom
for everyone who call wendy visual hole you must see this video!!!! im totally ok with her visual now (bcs wendy is my bias) but if u haters keep saying wendy is visual hole just wait until the old wendy is back
They changed Wendy's hairstyle and gave her bangs so she wouldn't outshine Irene since she's supposed to be the visual of the group. This is just my speculation. Wendy was more popular than Irene when they debuted and a lot of people think she was the prettiest.
Pepi_Chu and now they soften Wendy’s image. It’s been years since her forehead was free 😪
She's the main vocalists thats why but thats what I hate about positions, it limits their growth as an artists.
yes. i do think so as well that ssw's more popular than irene in Happiness era. watch videos of idols reacting to their Happiness (mv [like nct] or stages), they really anticipate *Wendy's (SHINE ON ME) part.* examples for a reaction to search are BTS' and EXO's reaction to Happiness live.
They simply nerf'd her. Wendy is multitalented, can speak English perfectly AND be the visual? So they toned her down. Simple as that. Sad
I like Wendy's bangs
Kang Seul Gi is GOAL OMG SHE'S SO PRETTY!
yes she is. definitely!!
Happiness is definitely Wendy's era!! Gosh just look at her!!
이 노래 너무 좋아요. 초등학생 때부터 대학생 때까지 힘들 때마다 들었는 데 위로해주는 느낌이네요. 레드벨벳 짱
무대연출이 파격적이긴한데 다들 목석같이 쳐다보는 와중에 무대하는 멤버들이 왤케 안쓰러워 보이지...? ㅠ
난 데뷔때부터 웬디픽이었음 이때 스타일링 넘 좋음 그 특유의 부잣집 유학파 느낌 독보적임
wendy visual just🔥
Wendy's body...... uggghhh goalsss
Seulgi looks so pretty 😍😍
she is. always.
웬디 흑갈발긴생머리에 갈매기눈썹 제발요 제발
얼마전 허쉬컷에 갈매기눈썹*스모키 찰떡일것같움 ㅠㅠ
요즘 창백한 백인 메이크업만함ㅠ
나는 웬디얼굴을 빨간맛때 처음 제대로봐서 그다음에해피니스영상을봐서 웬디처음에못알아봄ㅋㅋㅋㅋ이영상스타일링 해줫으면좋겟다 이쁜디
진짜 제일 예쁨... 유학생 느낌이 낭낭해
이 메컵이 깔끔한데 웬디한테 되게 잘어울림 지금메컵도 좋지만 이 메컵이 더 잘받고 유니크한거같은데 제발
Happiness is Wendy's era alright
Seulgi has the ideal body tbh 😍😍
"Happiness" is the only red velvet song that i sing without realization, i know the whole lyrics and i didn't even learn it, i just listened to it A LOT :')
THATS IT Seulgi is officially my bias! She too pretty!!😍
Wow seeing a lot of Wendy compliments 5 years later really melts my heart!❤️
its so cute seeing them here, so young especially joy, she literally looks like a baby here 🥺 now they have grown into mature gorgeous women wowowowwow
Seulgi's body is fire, and she's so pretty here !
everyone talking about how beautiful and perfect Wendy's visual , body and voice here is my reason to live
You can’t deny Seulgi and Wendy’s debut looks are gorgeous
Seulgi is pretty af even from pre debut - present
Back when Wendy had more camera focus than any members...
I want those days back 😆😆😆
Fraire Acupan also the thumbnail
thích RV 4 người như vậy ghê, từ ngày có thêm tvien k xem nữa
Ahh it feels so good to hear the clapping of their hands. It's live and the vocals are amazing. Also, Miss Shon your abs are distracting 🔥
💗💛💙💚💜
저기 바로앞에 앉아서 봤었는데 진짜 대단하더라 몸부서저라 추더라.. 진짜멋잇잇어 레벨
Seulgi's outfit is so cool 💗💕🐻⭐️
I swear, I don't think I will ever see a pretty girl like Seulgi in my life.
You already have
*Cough* Wendy, Irene,Joy, Yeri *Cough*
great live vocals ever since debut and that dance break is cuuute. oh ot4
BOI WENDY'S ABS IS MY GOAL CATDAM 💕😍
I remember an article talking about how freakin small Wendy's waist was. Dang gurl. Wish I could exercise as extensive you did 😢
Wendy’s vocals oh my goddd, her presence, wow! I love her hairstyle without bangs, it lets her beauty shine
I’d always love main vocalists who’s commited while dancing as well. Secret Number’s Denise, Red Velvet’s Wendy, EXID’s Solji, GFRIEND’s Yuju and whoever else. The group depended on their vocals but gave us moments where they seem to be the best dancers.
beautiful and talented seulgi♥
웬디 너무 예뻐
진짜 졸귀다...최근에 나오는 신인들은 다 엄청 길쭉하고 눈빛이 강렬한데 레벨은 아담하고 눈빛도 초롱초롱함ㅋㅋㅋ
Wow, I was afraid I was the only one noticing it. That Wendy was just DYNAMITE back then, totally a little doll. Then I look at the comments and it turns out everyone is saying it, From 6 years ago right up until now. Nice! I really think if I had been a high-schooler back then, it would have Wendy that I stanned. And.... she's still smokin! No foolin'!
I love how the comments regardless of language are all about Wendy lol anyway I love this performance and the dance break is so cute and addicting
i'm not even a reveluv but omg wendy's part??!!? and they're all so pretty?!?! WHAT
Queens of vocal!! Nothing can change my mind
OMG! SEULGI LOOKS GODDESS 😍
the girls had streaks of their colors in their hair, this was very fun and striking. The dance break is so much fun, I love it!! This remix is great. 👏🏼
ㅜㅜㅜ풋풋해 다들 귀여워죽겠넹
와 라이브 박수소리도 들려..
웬디 진짜 조올라 예쁘다...
난 레드벨벳 노래중에 이노래가 제일 좋더라
Red Velvet vocals are the reason why i still figthting ! its worth it!
Irene Slaying As always.!! 🔥🔥😪😪😩😍😍🔥🔥
Seulgi is very pretty 😍😍
Body Goals 🤩
Wendy is so pretty in this Era 🤗
Red Velvet are Vocal Queens 😘😘
Wendy looks so beautiful
I think we can all agree who owned this era
YERI
Seulgi my love my Angle ♥️💖😭
it's 2019 but still watching this
Wendy's voice is so powerful 😍😍😍
Joy and her pigtail ❤❤❤
When they dressed a lot alike it was cute. That was on New Year's 7 years ago. And nothing beats starting the year with a fun song. 💗💛💙💚💜=❤
She's pretty. Everyone pretty.
OKAY IM SICK OF U GUYS SAYING THINGS ABOUT WENDY SHE HAS ALWAYS LOOKED FINE
Omg!! Wendy, the prettiest.
I can't believe wendy is this pretty without those bangs!!!
I'm female but is it weird that I'd rather look at female abs instead of male abs??
I feel. I live for female kpop idol's abs 😂😂😂
I feel you*
it's not weird at all, female abs are pretty, female are pretty, i actually love females.
Thats weird because i literally have the same thoughts 😂
Cuz redvelvet is girl crush
Wendy is the prettiest during this era
WENDY HAPPINESS ALWAYS BE UR ERA!
Seulgi body, that's true asian beauty guys :333
Seulgi issa fitness legend... just wow!
Holy abs
I miss 2015 era oh my god wish i can turn back time.
wendy abs OMG
i love the way they did the colored hair in this performance
Wendy serving
Vocals 🔥
Face 🔥
Abs 🔥
since day 1
웬디 존나 잘부른다 진짜
This dance is so cute
WENDY I LOVE YOU
their vocals!!
Wendy gave off elegance in her moves.