I miss all of their hairs in the first ot4 era, i wish they did the same style for yeri when she joined Edit: those hairstyles could even make baby reveluvs find out who is who easier
For real everybody looks so good and if you give them the right outfits and hair style they all look like visuals.. I mean they already are but you wouldn’t know where to look also Yeri
tbh she rocked every hairstyle she's had since debut and bangs really suit her too, the problem with their stylist is that most red concepts get ugly stage outfits, but their velvet concepts and their award show outfits are always on point
@faiza ahmed Same, she looks good without bangs, but WITH bangs it's just another level, specially with blonde hair like in Psycho god thats's literally my fav hairstyle of her, it look sooo good in her i love it
I agree with everyone saying they thought Wendy was the visual😭 when I first saw her there was something about her that caught my attention and she’s the reason why I got into RV
no hate but without her I wont get into red velvet. her high notes, vocals and visuals got me into red velvet. She really caught my eye Dont get me wrong I love all the 5 of them but when I first knew red velvet , wendy made me like them
They were the first GG group I've followed since debut and Wendy did caught my eye for sure. She instantly became my bias. Wendy has so much potential :(
Wendy was definitely the reason I started stanning; I used to only regularly stream but when I watched their killing voice her visuals and vocals were so eye catching I started stanning
ik it’s just your opinion and for fun, but Wendy’s legendary “shine on me” high note literally screams ‘’main vocalist” lmaooo😂😂 but seulgi’s such a talented vocalist she could easily be a main vocalist in another gg tbh
@@jyr6453 at that time I was 14 and don't know why but I thought she was doing the hardest part for only happiness era, also I was kinda new to kpop. then and now she was/is my bias and I am in love with her voice crazily
I'm really thinking they are meant to have some sort of nct entrance tbh, in the happiness mv Yeri and other rookies appeared and then Yeri got added, some says it's meant to be a nine membered group too but the backlash for Yeri held them back.
I never thought Wendy got so many praises in this era. I'm so happy for it. I'm reveluv since Zimzalabim and when Umpah-Umpah born. Psycho is the first comeback that I witness and Wendy! Love you! 😉 #GetWellSoonWendy
Came here after watching aespa debut stage and wow how far have they come I was there when red velvet debuted I wasn’t a huge fan (I was mad about the fx situation so yeah wasn’t a big RV fan) but seulgi stood out to me sooo much. I think from aespa it’s winter who gives me that type of vibe both have similar positions too 😂 let’s go stream happiness to 100M views MYluvs and black mamba to 50M views
The position i tought in this era Wendy- Visual & Main vocal Seulgi- Main vocal,Lead dancer,Main rapper Joy- Lead vocal,lead rapper Irene- Main dancer,rapper,vocalist
SM used to make red velvet diet very strictly especially during comebacks. of course, this being their debut stage, they probably barely ate for months... :( SM is really trustworthy of red velvet now and lets them diet however they want, moderately watching their weights. i think they were stricter on wendy though (even today) because her body does the yo-yo effect where she loses a bunch of weight and gains it back. in her case it’s worse because she’s known out of the rest of the girls for not eating a lot, and losing a lot of weight super fast. since she’s starving herself, as soon as she eats normally again she will gain everything back, first she looks super bloated but then it goes down and she looks fine. but sm doesn’t want wendy to be healthy 🤬 sick company
I can't believe this video is already 6 y.o. and yesterday we got a new girl group, Aespa. I couldn't be proud more because of these talented girls. GG and f(x) are legends, so does Red Velvet. Aespa will join them later. I love this family
Wendy had vocal nodules during debut day, but for me...her 'Shine On Me' part still iconic till now. Her vocal trainer once said that she forces herself too much, so that she can debut as Red Velvet. I'm so proud of her now. Now, she is one of the best vocalists in kpop industry.
The first time I became a Reveluv I really thought Wendy is the visual. No offense but ai think she is prettier than Irene if they just give here better looks
No doubt Irene is beautiful but I feel like she just doesn't have that something that gets you hooked to her beauty! I know she's considered the ultimate K-pop visual but I can name a dozen girls that I obviously think is more attractive than Irene but it's just my opinion
Why cant i see joy *that* beautiful... like... everbody has their own beauty types but cmon i cant even- Why am i like that And i really think irene is sooo beautiful. (And seulgi too but people wont agree)
Coleen Kim Irene is incredibly beautiful and always will be I think, but i definitely think Wendy really shined during their early eras. I feel SM just wanted Irenes visuals to shine more because obviously she has the package, so they kinda dumbed down Wendys visuals since Dumb Dumb era (though i’d like to think they started bringing it back since RBB) Not to mention their makeup was really different during this time so maybe it suited Wendy more than Irene. Love them both tho (and Wendy is my bias)
Back when I thought Joy is only their rapper and visual. Damn girl proved she can sing and sexy af the following years. Should have realized it in 2:32
I've known redvelvet way back 2015 on wgm, not a reveluv but their vocals dragged me to stan them esp. Wendy.. i rlly mss her voice alot this days thats why listening to their music ease those days.
Back then.. I thought the position would be like this: Seulgi: Center, Leader, Main dancer Wendy: Main vocal, Visual Joy: Main rapper Irene: Lead rapper, Sub vocal 😂
I'm still remember that day when i thought Seulgi is Main vocalist Wendy is visual Irene is Main dancer and rapper and Joy is a cute person Hahahahahah ..
I think its Like Irene gryfindor Wendy Rawenclaw Seulgi Hufflepuff Joy Slytherin. Since there is no purple in hogwarts ı couldnt find anything for Yeri
I miss this hairstyle and brightness on Wendy.
Me too 😣
She definitely rocks the short one though. Queen of versatility
Amisha Kesarwani She rocks anything but looks the prettiest in this era by far.
I miss all of their hairs in the first ot4 era, i wish they did the same style for yeri when she joined
Edit: those hairstyles could even make baby reveluvs find out who is who easier
SM really did wendy dirty...she looks the prettiest during pre debut era and happiness
I remember this was the performance. Sungjae and joy watched together in we got married
Yes my bais wrecker
Yess 😢
Abdul hafeez and he couldnt tell who was Joy 😂😂😂
HEJSJD NO DAMNIT, MY SUNGJOY HEART DIDN'T NEED TO BE REMINDED OF SUNGJOY
and he couldn't tell who joy was, but joy could tell when he was singing in one of btobs songs.
That era when everyone thought Wendy was the visual
Steve G they all are :)
For real everybody looks so good and if you give them the right outfits and hair style they all look like visuals.. I mean they already are but you wouldn’t know where to look also Yeri
This will always be her best era, wish SM would style her more like this. It suits her the best.
Stephvan Gaan i think psycho was also a great wendy era too
@@ahahhahahha5904 Yeah, I liked her styling there, unfortunately we didn't get to see much of it because of her injury.
Wendy looking so pretty here proves that everyone is a visual in Red Velvet just that SM stylists do them injustice
tbh she rocked every hairstyle she's had since debut and bangs really suit her too, the problem with their stylist is that most red concepts get ugly stage outfits, but their velvet concepts and their award show outfits are always on point
Alvaro D Bangs don’t suit Wendy.
@@boojoogoo Bangs definitely suits Wendy.
@faiza ahmed Same, she looks good without bangs, but WITH bangs it's just another level, specially with blonde hair like in Psycho god thats's literally my fav hairstyle of her, it look sooo good in her i love it
wendy looks so pretty here I thought she was the visual of the group
I agree with everyone saying they thought Wendy was the visual😭 when I first saw her there was something about her that caught my attention and she’s the reason why I got into RV
no hate but without her I wont get into red velvet. her high notes, vocals and visuals got me into red velvet. She really caught my eye
Dont get me wrong I love all the 5 of them but when I first knew red velvet , wendy made me like them
They were the first GG group I've followed since debut and Wendy did caught my eye for sure. She instantly became my bias. Wendy has so much potential :(
Wendy was definitely the reason I started stanning; I used to only regularly stream but when I watched their killing voice her visuals and vocals were so eye catching I started stanning
I’ll never understand the “Visual” position. They’re all gorgeous as all hell.
Same
Fr
Wasn't that position for the member who met the most Korean beauty standards?
@@ycgh__xxyes
I will never be the same after Wendy's "shine on me". My ultimate kpop bias get better soon!!!!
my thought about the positions in this era
wendy: lead vocal & visual
seulgi: main vocal
irene: main dancer
Joy says hi
ik it’s just your opinion and for fun, but Wendy’s legendary “shine on me” high note literally screams ‘’main vocalist” lmaooo😂😂
but seulgi’s such a talented vocalist she could easily be a main vocalist in another gg tbh
@@jyr6453 if Seulgi weren't in an SM group she would be a main vocal
@@taeggxk3321 i didn't have interesting, or wrong opinion about joy so...
@@jyr6453 at that time I was 14 and don't know why but I thought she was doing the hardest part for only happiness era, also I was kinda new to kpop. then and now she was/is my bias and I am in love with her voice crazily
RED VELVET SHOWING OFF THEIR STABLE VOCALS ON THEIR DEBUT. sad they don’t let new artists sing live anymore.
I miss when you could hear idol’s breaths and stuff when they sang.
It's not about an era actually, it's depend of the group
Most 4th gen groups are not doing this.
*Sungjae tease Joy*
SJ: BOOYAAAHH
SJ: Happiness
J: *smile*
I remember that episode omg UWU ill re watch it brb
Come here for beautiful Wendy💙💙💙💙
The first time i watched this, i though wendy was the vsual. Iike for real tho, happiness era she just....SHINED
When Wendy said “Shine on me” I felt that 😌😌😌
I remember yook sungjae in this
Sungjae : happiness !!!
Joy : *smiling*
Me:🤣🤣🤣🤣
Wendy has the supreme voice even on the first debut stage.
Wendy's so PRETTY
I'm here just to rewatch Wendy's "Shine on me" over and over again
Did anyone notice that Wendy has orange socks, Seulgi’s color, Seugli has green socks, Joy’s color, and Irene has purple socks, YERI’s color
I'm really thinking they are meant to have some sort of nct entrance tbh, in the happiness mv Yeri and other rookies appeared and then Yeri got added, some says it's meant to be a nine membered group too but the backlash for Yeri held them back.
Maybe the new girl group will be connected to red velvet?
@@craziestguyever3079 the name probably be some kind of cake 😂
I saw a comment about the idea that red velvet was like nct but when they added yeri she gained so much hate so they stoped it with only 5 members
@@daisyfield959 debut song cheese cake
Im here after aespa’s debut, I’m crying bc this feels like it’s been only 1 year of this
nah me too
"SM's failed girl group" to on top of the world!! They were NEVER a failure 💚💗💜
THE BEST GROUP ALIVE LABELED BY BILLBOARD, AND THE NATION'S PRIDE. 😭
0:05
'Sometimes you gotta to be bald'
ANYTHING FOR YOU SEULGI
😂
You won't guess but I started liking Wendy because of 2:57
Same
Same
And she’s become my bias
"Daddy shine on me"
CL Literally everybody liked her because of that iconic moment
This is not my favorite red velvet song but it is my favorite performance. They look so bright and have so much presence.
I never thought Wendy got so many praises in this era. I'm so happy for it. I'm reveluv since Zimzalabim and when Umpah-Umpah born. Psycho is the first comeback that I witness and Wendy! Love you! 😉
#GetWellSoonWendy
Welcome!! 💗
Came here after watching aespa debut stage and wow how far have they come I was there when red velvet debuted I wasn’t a huge fan (I was mad about the fx situation so yeah wasn’t a big RV fan) but seulgi stood out to me sooo much. I think from aespa it’s winter who gives me that type of vibe both have similar positions too 😂 let’s go stream happiness to 100M views MYluvs and black mamba to 50M views
The position i tought in this era
Wendy- Visual & Main vocal
Seulgi- Main vocal,Lead dancer,Main rapper
Joy- Lead vocal,lead rapper
Irene- Main dancer,rapper,vocalist
Same lmao
I thought so too
İrene is the main rapper .
@@anonime4465 Yes,I know. I just tought those were their postion on this era.
ɛtǟɛʀռǟʟ. ɮǟռɢtǟռ ohww ok 👍🏻
I love how this performance is from years ago and many of the comments are from days or from weeks ago. This really show.
Joy is so beautiful!! 😍😍
Is just me or Seulgi especially in this video looks very very thin😮
Shes naturally thin
She’s been always thin
Irene too.. I think she looks thinner here..
Thanks God now she looks healthier 😄
SM used to make red velvet diet very strictly especially during comebacks. of course, this being their debut stage, they probably barely ate for months... :( SM is really trustworthy of red velvet now and lets them diet however they want, moderately watching their weights. i think they were stricter on wendy though (even today) because her body does the yo-yo effect where she loses a bunch of weight and gains it back. in her case it’s worse because she’s known out of the rest of the girls for not eating a lot, and losing a lot of weight super fast. since she’s starving herself, as soon as she eats normally again she will gain everything back, first she looks super bloated but then it goes down and she looks fine. but sm doesn’t want wendy to be healthy 🤬 sick company
sorry i like wrote an essay LMAO
I love Irene haircolor and shes stunning during this era.
Who's here after Aespa's debut stage?
Me
mee
You are not alone
Y r u talking about æspa here? 😀
@@angela-dm7vo Because aespa's debut stage remind me of this stage of Red Velvet:33 They are now like sisters in one family, right? Love both❤
I suddenly remembered that Sungjae watched this in WGM 😂
I can't believe this video is already 6 y.o. and yesterday we got a new girl group, Aespa. I couldn't be proud more because of these talented girls. GG and f(x) are legends, so does Red Velvet. Aespa will join them later. I love this family
Miss Irene's pink hair! 💕🌚❤
2020년에 이 노래 수백번 듣고있는건 나밖에 없을끄야ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 레드벨벳 좀더 빨리 알았으면 좋았을텐데...😭😭 레드벨벳 데뷔때 난 겨우 8살 이였으니ㅠㅠㅠ
레드벨벳 사랑해! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Who’s here after Aespa debut stage?
Me!
the cameraman really went crazy at the end
Wendy's visual just woah 🔥🔥🔥
I miss wendy in this era :(
나만 마지막에 울컥했나 시간이ㅜ너무 빠른것같다
ㅠㅠ 다들 너무 풋풋하다 🍎🍎
노래가 긍정적이라 그런지 나도 행복해진다
딱 신입에 어울리는 상큼한 노래인듯 ,, 🥺💗💛💚💙
Here again after rv comeback announcement. Can we all agree that rv's debut is LEGENDARY.
Wendy had vocal nodules during debut day, but for me...her 'Shine On Me' part still iconic till now. Her vocal trainer once said that she forces herself too much, so that she can debut as Red Velvet. I'm so proud of her now. Now, she is one of the best vocalists in kpop industry.
The first time I became a Reveluv I really thought Wendy is the visual. No offense but ai think she is prettier than Irene if they just give here better looks
Wendy was nerfed. I still believe that up to this day
Ikr when I first saw this video Wendy caught my eye
No doubt Irene is beautiful but I feel like she just doesn't have that something that gets you hooked to her beauty! I know she's considered the ultimate K-pop visual but I can name a dozen girls that I obviously think is more attractive than Irene but it's just my opinion
Why cant i see joy *that* beautiful... like... everbody has their own beauty types but cmon i cant even-
Why am i like that
And i really think irene is sooo beautiful. (And seulgi too but people wont agree)
Coleen Kim Irene is incredibly beautiful and always will be I think, but i definitely think Wendy really shined during their early eras. I feel SM just wanted Irenes visuals to shine more because obviously she has the package, so they kinda dumbed down Wendys visuals since Dumb Dumb era (though i’d like to think they started bringing it back since RBB) Not to mention their makeup was really different during this time so maybe it suited Wendy more than Irene. Love them both tho (and Wendy is my bias)
I remember the very first time i watched this when it came out. I immediately fell in love with irene.
Look at how adorable Joy is in this 😍😍
Joy has shined so brightly since her debut. There is something really special and one of a kind about her.
She can have all positions in the group easily💚💚
they all dyed their hair in same way but with different colours is so cool
I thought that Wendy was the visual when I saw this, I also thought that seulgi is the oldest member
Back when I thought Joy is only their rapper and visual. Damn girl proved she can sing and sexy af the following years. Should have realized it in 2:32
And now ...
Joy:
Rapper✔️
Visual✔️
Vocal✔️
Dancer✔️
Actress✔️
Model✔️
MC✔️
Miss korea?YES✔️✔️✔️
💚💚💚💚💚💚
Seulgi's voice is so strong !
Wendy ❤️
Irene and joy hugging is so cute. espaically when the lyrics that part talk about a daughter :)
Seulgi!
I am still having a fantasy where they still do this color conceot with Yeri in purple dyed hair as well 😘❤
I've known redvelvet way back 2015 on wgm, not a reveluv but their vocals dragged me to stan them esp. Wendy.. i rlly mss her voice alot this days thats why listening to their music ease those days.
Oh yeah let's not forget about Wendy the visual who can hit high notes
Why did this get recommended to me? Lol I miss debut Velvet so much. Reminds me how long I've been stanning RV 🥺❤
UA-cam knows that we miss them a lot, let's work hard for RV's next comeback! They will comeback soon
@@greentea4775 yassss I saw the news too and I can't waitt!!! OT5 forever 😭💙❤💚💛💜
can't believe i watch this on december 2020
Woaa wendy is soo pretty
Back then.. I thought the position would be like this:
Seulgi: Center, Leader, Main dancer
Wendy: Main vocal, Visual
Joy: Main rapper
Irene: Lead rapper, Sub vocal
😂
I love the Reveluv screams
Seulgis right (her right not ours) bun looks like it’s about to fall out and I’m just thinking ISN’T THAT LIKE THE MODT UNCOMFORTABLE THING!?
Wendy is so pretty
I'm still remember that day when i thought
Seulgi is Main vocalist
Wendy is visual
Irene is Main dancer and rapper
and Joy is a cute person
Hahahahahah ..
요즘 여돌들 다 걸크컨셉이라 봐도 뭔가 무거운 느낌만 들고ㅜㅜ 누가 해피니스같은 갬성 다시 들고왔으면.....ㅠ
Remember when i was Shocking too see Irene Beauty ..
I REALLY MISS WENDY!!!
Me of the first time seen Red Velvet I thought: When you can remember their name you can see color of hair...
I feel like crying watching this..aaahh so proud of them!!
I Miss Red Velvet
I wasn't here when they debuted but I'm here now. I'm proud of how well all 5 are doing!
차라리 이때로 돌아갔으면.... 다시 시작했으면...
ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ ㅜㅜㅜㅠㅡ ㅜㅜㅡㅠ
2:16 does anyone else hear that one girl screaming her life out
They are so confident and have the stage presence of a pro despite this being their first stage performance
Seulgi-yahhh♡♡♡
This choreo was MADE for a 5th member to be added
Joy😄
Wow first comment
I’m replying a comment from 4 years ago .......omg
Joy is our miss korea now in 2021,and my bias😊💚
wendy is so pretty 😍
Watching this just to praise wendy's beautiful voice and face
Ahh yess the era where I thought
Wendy was the visual
And irene was the Main dancer
레드벨벳 최고
My Wendy so pretty 💙
Wendy is so beautiful💕
Irenes socks are purple 💜💜 yeri
Naia Khan exactly what i thought instantly
Omfg joy looks so young so cute and there is no red velvet without yeriIIi
The First time I saw Red Velvet, I really thought that Wendy is the Visual 💓
honestly memories of their debut become fuzzy aft so many years but wendy’s iconic shine on me is the one thing i’d never forget
came here because i miss wendy so much ☹️💙
✨ manifesting for this look again,,, soon ✨
They doing this amazing live when they are still rookie and their vocal is superpower
joy looks like a big baby
I think its Like
Irene gryfindor
Wendy Rawenclaw
Seulgi Hufflepuff
Joy Slytherin.
Since there is no purple in hogwarts ı couldnt find anything for Yeri
At 0:51
Seulgis Ireon money jeoreon power is amazing
We watching a histoy right here.
Wannie get well soon we love you 😘😘😘
Iconic Debut❤
Vokal nya ga perlu diragukan lagi. Bagusss banget
Wendy is so beautiful ! :3
yes I’m happy to we have Yeri but Joy’s maknae (cute) style is something