SNP shamed over OLD recycled promises for crisis-hit Scottish NHS

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 лют 2025
  • John Swinney was pushed for the SECOND week in a row about the state of the Scottish NHS.
    Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay told the First Minister that the recent SNP plan for the NHS is full of failed OLD recycled ideas from years ago.
    MORE SCOTTISH POLITICS:
    www.thescottis...
    SIGN UP TO OUR POLITICS NEWSLETTER:
    www.thescottis...
    www.theScottish...
    / thescottishsun
    / scottishsun
    #scotland #johnSwinney #politics #snp #fmqs #russellFindlay

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @parlane35735
    @parlane35735 7 днів тому +8

    FYI
    NHS under SMP
    Purchase Carrick glen private hospital in Ayrshire a stone’s throw from Ayr Hospital, paid for oops when it was private, then purchased it and closed it down immediately
    Interesting 🤔

  • @ianscott3180
    @ianscott3180 7 днів тому +21

    Pointless have question sessions if questions are not answering. Scrap this place.

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 7 днів тому

      Scrap Westminster government get rid also of downing Street fourteen years of a tory absolute mess and now labour time Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 ruled itself so we can get our own votes and democracy independence for Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @timstobbs5396
    @timstobbs5396 7 днів тому +28

    Presiding officer is useless, she said the parliament is there to hold govt to account, why does she let Swinney not answer the questions. ?

    • @cremvirus
      @cremvirus 7 днів тому +5

      It's a Devolved Assembly

    • @PRCOM
      @PRCOM 7 днів тому +2

      She is as crooked as the disgraceful snp

    • @wullstat
      @wullstat 6 днів тому

      She's there to deflect and protect her SNP pals

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 6 днів тому

      Better her than the tories or Labour in the position

  • @colinlambert882
    @colinlambert882 7 днів тому +5

    How arrogant to read out out a script that doesn't even mention the question: when does Scotland get an NHS App? And then to say he giving Holyrood some "truth" = no money to build the promised NTCs, because of "Tory austerity" What nobody asked is why the NTCs in England, called surgical hubs, ARE being delivered. 108 in use from 134, all delivered by end 2025. Scotland has 5/11 and no more before 2027. Scotland 45% delivered, England 82% delivered. Swinney doesn't even have a fig leaf to cover the stark contrast in delivery. All he can do is boast, bluster and never answer a question with the actuality.

  • @RobertBirtles-r1y
    @RobertBirtles-r1y 7 днів тому +10

    Let’s have a referendum on whether Mr Swinney has lost the plot !!!

  • @ianmoir5423
    @ianmoir5423 7 днів тому +7

    Swinney with Truth for Parliament. The SNP couldn`t lie straight in bed.

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 7 днів тому

      Same as keir starmer especially on the lead up to the election no promises Kept

  • @dbaberdeen2453
    @dbaberdeen2453 7 днів тому +12

    That’s the SNP. Big on What and Why. Nothing on How and When

  • @Ronald-o9x
    @Ronald-o9x 6 днів тому +2

    Where are all the MSPs? Disgusting and disgraceful. There's more people in the public galleries! What are we paying them for if they don't attend? There must be a record of attendance kept and except in emergency s they must explain their absence. Scrap the place!

  • @RoystonMills
    @RoystonMills 6 днів тому +4

    This place and the Welsh one needs scraping pound land councils

  • @blackislepeastoo
    @blackislepeastoo 7 днів тому +4

    The purpose of this session is for Swinney to waffle not to answer a question and look for a chance to blame someone else.

  • @thomascalder8296
    @thomascalder8296 7 днів тому +2

    Wow,it took 6 mins to blame westminster
    Usually happens after 2 mins
    Still never answered the question

  • @bryzot7242
    @bryzot7242 7 днів тому +13

    Scotland like the rest of the country needs complete REFORM...we can sort Scotland be proud again...how these SNP escapes jail is an absolute disgrace to democracy

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 7 днів тому

      How keir starmer and Rachel reeves escape jail for what they have done especially to the pensioners keir starmer the pensioner starver and pensioner harmer

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 6 днів тому

      I meant to say jail keir starmer and Rachel reeves

  • @alanbowden9760
    @alanbowden9760 6 днів тому +1

    Can we remind the presiding officer she is suspossed to suport the parliament not the snp

  • @duncanmackenzie2410
    @duncanmackenzie2410 7 днів тому +3

    Makes a change for Honest John 🐍 not blaming Brrxit or Margaret Thatcher

  • @Aldothejambo
    @Aldothejambo 7 днів тому +12

    Make non nationals pay for treatment, we need insurance if we are going to another country it’s simple

  • @YvonneCairns-c9u
    @YvonneCairns-c9u 6 днів тому +1

    Humza should be in prison and sleekit Swinney can do one.

  • @iainhair6888
    @iainhair6888 7 днів тому +3

    Utter waffle again, waiting for the apology for another screw up !!

  • @BoydSneddon
    @BoydSneddon 7 днів тому +16

    There liying deluded people the snp🇬🇧😳

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 7 днів тому

      Se as keir starmer

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 7 днів тому

      I meant to say same as keir starmer

    • @BoydSneddon
      @BoydSneddon 6 днів тому

      @ I was not talking about kier starmer only about this snp government who have single handed lay destroyed Scotland and dragged us backwards for the last 15 years if you don’t like my comment don’t respond

  • @alexispaterson814
    @alexispaterson814 7 днів тому +9

    The treatment centres will open when pigs will fly. And I don't mean in a police helicopter.

  • @isabeldiamond3391
    @isabeldiamond3391 7 днів тому +5

    Christine Grahame face full of hatred.woman should think about retiring.NHS will never be same again .Billions of pounds wasted with SNP.They all stick together know to much about each other.

    • @alanelden9025
      @alanelden9025 7 днів тому

      Salary theif is this the best they can do

  • @onedegreewest9303
    @onedegreewest9303 7 днів тому +9

    More of Honest John waffle waffle

  • @andrewmorton2430
    @andrewmorton2430 7 днів тому +4

    Swinney addresses his replies to the carpet in front of him. He cannot make eye contact.

  • @johncurran5077
    @johncurran5077 7 днів тому +5

    He wouldnt😊kn😊w 😊what truth is

  • @alexcull9379
    @alexcull9379 7 днів тому +4

    Swinney spouts out a lot o keek

  • @geoffreyholloway5657
    @geoffreyholloway5657 7 днів тому +6

    Snp answer to everything. Throw money and words at the problem.

  • @jazyuill307
    @jazyuill307 6 днів тому +1

    Youless by name Youless by nature

  • @ramthian
    @ramthian 7 днів тому

    👏👏👏🙏❤️❤️❤️🎉🎉🎉🍾

  • @daffytree2605
    @daffytree2605 7 днів тому +6

    The snp couldn't organize a woodpeckers picnic in a forest,roll on 2026.

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 7 днів тому

      Same as the tories fourteen years of a glorious mess and now labour the pensioner harmer and pensioner starver

  • @onedegreewest9303
    @onedegreewest9303 7 днів тому +7

    Will he bloody answer a question!. The man is a complete joke and ministers should be held accountable for not asnwering and deflection!

    • @634blackrat
      @634blackrat 7 днів тому +3

      He was taught by Sturgeon she could take ten minutes not answering a question

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 7 днів тому

      ​@@634blackratmatches keir starmer

  • @user-ei3dq2dw6i
    @user-ei3dq2dw6i 7 днів тому +2

    About tax us pay to Scotland SNP run our affairs yet they always want more from us thou they SNP cannot deliver any services with out arguments in holyrood who's to blame shameful on them

  • @mickeymcwilliam5930
    @mickeymcwilliam5930 7 днів тому +5

    Not got clue what swindlers saying 😅

  • @bobbycaldwell4132
    @bobbycaldwell4132 7 днів тому +3

    Erm erm erm its no oor fault , erm erm erm tories ur bad , erm erm erm future projects ,erm erm nicola has told me to repeat " Independence "

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 6 днів тому

      Cant wait for independence get rid of Westminster government and downing Street

    • @bobbycaldwell4132
      @bobbycaldwell4132 5 днів тому

      @barbaraurquhart2276 oh yes and have this lot screwing us for our hard earned

    • @bobbycaldwell4132
      @bobbycaldwell4132 5 днів тому

      @barbaraurquhart2276 why is it so hard for people like you to see exactly what this mob are up to , if we were independent when covid hit it would have finished Scotland

  • @crawfordsteven
    @crawfordsteven 7 днів тому +2

    Would be nice to have informative responses, we never.....never get them just unclear repetitive nonsense.

  • @scottishJim80
    @scottishJim80 6 днів тому +1

    snp is finished,vote reformUK,

  • @colincampbell815
    @colincampbell815 7 днів тому +5

    Why not have an independent speaker rather than an snp supporting speaker

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 6 днів тому

      Better her as any tory or Labour

    • @colincampbell815
      @colincampbell815 6 днів тому

      @ really ? Shows you what you think of democracy , yet another bitter snp supporter no doubt . It should be somebody completely impartial .

    • @barbaraurquhart2276
      @barbaraurquhart2276 6 днів тому

      @@colincampbell815 Scotland needs to rule itself and as I said we need our own votes what's the point in voting when your votes don't count

  • @anna-mariehosie7631
    @anna-mariehosie7631 7 днів тому +1

    the Scottish sun should be called the misconception nonsense rag its no more Scottish than little england.

  • @sunrayisdown1690
    @sunrayisdown1690 7 днів тому +2

    YET MORE SUNSHITE