Jean Paul Gaultier SCANDAL POUR HOMME EDT vs SCANDAL POUR HOMME LE PARFUM

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 108

  • @ThePerfumeGuy
    @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +13

    🔥🔥🔥Watch Most Boring Fragrances Video here: ua-cam.com/video/EZ7LCpz79nw/v-deo.html 🔥🔥🔥

  • @amazighyacine
    @amazighyacine Рік тому +31

    I really don’t understand how you cannot love this smell I have the EDT and the PARFUM and they bring me a lot of compliments they smell sweet but not agressive and people around me love it and I do too

  • @acevedobrooklyn
    @acevedobrooklyn Рік тому +6

    I'm ready for this
    Lets go Sébastien

  • @zenobiasanchez4658
    @zenobiasanchez4658 Рік тому +6

    My husband love the EDT and I steal some spray from him. It smell good on me too. The caramel is bomb. But too light. I want stronger.

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +2

      Oh that's cool. Yes it's not so beefy to me.

  • @hojichung6997
    @hojichung6997 Рік тому +14

    The EDT is a popular club scent here in Germany. Although longevity and silage could be better, it still lasts and projects whole a lot better than most of recent releases of the designer fragrances in my opinion.

  • @silverrise83
    @silverrise83 Рік тому +7

    I respectfully disagree with you, im a big fan here i have edt which is beastly mode and got me lots of compliments than my nich fragrances. In terms of longevity i sprayed at 09:00AM and now 09:36PM and wow it still around me. JPG did an amazing job here. Regards

  • @augustinefaithdefender
    @augustinefaithdefender Рік тому +22

    These scandal fragrances are beast mode, like fill up a room. I ride scooter around the city wearing a jacket, I don’t spray it on the jacket and people would still smell it on the street. They are so strong that you are nose blind 💁🏻‍♂️
    They are young clubbing fragrances, they do not mean to be serious. You are old so you don’t like it for sure. I am young but I don’t like them either but for clubbing, they do the work! 🤭

  • @KingDavid4Christ
    @KingDavid4Christ Рік тому

    Thank you for the review, your only the second person to review it since I’ve been on the fence about purchasing

  • @harveytrevino2257
    @harveytrevino2257 5 місяців тому

    I have only purchased one refill bottle. I bought the 10oz Dior Sauvage Parfum refill. So far, been worth it to refill my 100ml bottle.

  • @olesyakoktyan6713
    @olesyakoktyan6713 Рік тому

    Seb another excellent review. Both are good mass appealing, EDP is a bit smoother. In general JPG fragrances are head and shoulders compared to other mass appealing designers scents. Recently bought Armani Code EDP, and in my opinion it is not an EDT it is some sort of unrecognizable watered down version of 2004 OG. Shame.

  • @crepusculo87
    @crepusculo87 Рік тому +2

    I like both of them- Even though They aren’t my grab and gos. I bought the EDP at the discounters and the Le Parfum in Spain (while visiting )

  • @AbdulWakil87
    @AbdulWakil87 7 місяців тому

    I haven’t copped it yet. This was an interesting review. I need samples now because Im definitely tired of designer.

  • @majstorgile
    @majstorgile Рік тому +1

    I love smell of Scandal EDT. I wonder how it compares to Tero Nishane.

  • @jeremywhite5108
    @jeremywhite5108 Рік тому +6

    I love them both... I live in Ohio and got a lot of compliments with the edt but the le parfum has a tad bit smother smell yet don't project nearly as much as the EDT

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +3

      It was so subdued in regards to the EDP. I prefer the EDT between the two! :)

    • @shave-a-thon3415
      @shave-a-thon3415 Рік тому

      What kind of performance do you get with the edt?

  • @christopherames6967
    @christopherames6967 Рік тому +5

    Your crazy this fragrance is unbelievable power

  • @blankmandastankman
    @blankmandastankman Рік тому +1

    The edt last forever on clothes. I bet it would smell great layered with the original Le Male

  • @dzingunyte
    @dzingunyte Рік тому +1

    of course you're not a fan. you're past that stage of perfumery. for young folks it's ok and not breaking the bank

  • @refreshyourpage._.0
    @refreshyourpage._.0 Рік тому

    I have edt and it’s pretty much like le beau, but for some reason I like the edt better it gives me non-heavy vibe that I enjoy.

  • @vincentsanta8937
    @vincentsanta8937 Рік тому

    I recently purchased the EDT, 100ML at Discount site, Gift Express ! I like the EDT better than the EDP version. Very nice scent, Longevity it decent on my skin. I have a decant of the EDP dont care for it!

  • @somogyi1973
    @somogyi1973 Рік тому

    JPG bottles and adverts are great, however the fragrances are not. None of them work for me. The worst one is Kokorico, a bitter smoky coconut concoction.

  • @armentutundjian6800
    @armentutundjian6800 Рік тому

    Seb I strongly agree with everything you mentioned very boring not worth the prices. The house released much better fragrances in the past like over 10 years ago.

  • @leftyrighty5777
    @leftyrighty5777 Рік тому

    I do remember Kokorico, I still have a backup bottle and pull it out once in a while. This doesn't sound to interesting to me. I appreciate your honest though. Thank you.

  • @mohsinchoudhury85
    @mohsinchoudhury85 Рік тому

    I know how you feel. I grew up on attars and niche fragrances are no different to designers.

  • @pamelabrown8467
    @pamelabrown8467 Рік тому

    Thanks 😇

  • @extraordinary_scents6806
    @extraordinary_scents6806 Рік тому +1

    I have the EDT and it’s just ehh to me.

  • @samaat66
    @samaat66 Рік тому

    Q.Bisch Reynaud and Graci-Cetto are the perfumers,still a NO?!

    • @502fragrances8
      @502fragrances8 Рік тому

      It’s corporate style perfumery. They had little to zero input on creating this fragrance. Jean Paul Gaultier told them “Hey you see these fragrances that are selling well? We want you to make something like that”

  • @shahzadghaffar4373
    @shahzadghaffar4373 Рік тому

    Hi Sebastian. Would you recommend nishane munegu over montale patchouli leaves?

  • @nBasedAce
    @nBasedAce Рік тому

    I just got a 20ml bottle of Rokka by Antonia's Flowers. Have you ever smelled it? Do you have it in any videos? I smelled it and I think it's light, and has a nice powdery soapy smell.

  • @viggenone
    @viggenone Рік тому +1

    I don't even bother with designers anymore, unless you say it's good I'll try it, I have a very similar taste as yours. Thanks for the review Sebastian!!!

  • @saramagri6081
    @saramagri6081 Рік тому

    i have never tryed the line.... and now i also don't want to try it in the future😀

  • @TheHertz99
    @TheHertz99 Рік тому

    Great video as always! 😍 You should review some Kerosene fragrances more🥺 I love love love Blackmail and Sweetly Known

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +3

      I'll see if I can. I hope you got your nose on FOLLOWED by Kerosene? So beastly.

    • @TheHertz99
      @TheHertz99 Рік тому +2

      @@ThePerfumeGuy yes ofc🤓 I love it! 😍
      I hope that there would be more beasts like that… So many fragrances are so weak nowadays.

  • @jdmb03
    @jdmb03 Рік тому

    I have 150ml EDT. It's nice, I don't wear it often.

  • @Pandalf82
    @Pandalf82 Рік тому +3

    I totally agree with what you are saying. I love scents and worked my way through to niche over the last 2 decades. Sadly, in my circle and work environment no one really appreciates niche or the depth nor the ingredients in a perfume. Some even think I smell overpowering at times, or medicinal. But when I wear a generic perfume, they give compliments, which I appreciate once in a while. 😬 Maybe I need to find new friends...

  • @raulsaavedra709
    @raulsaavedra709 Рік тому

    Where will you be in Germany, Sebastian? You could probably arrange an informal fragrance enthusiast meet somewhere, specially if near Bonn/Cologne :)

  • @hanniballecter922
    @hanniballecter922 Рік тому

    Just to guage my experience I wear "Mancera Red Tabacco" as my daily go to but did blind buy a refillable bottle EDP when 1st released(thought it was good value for reill 200ml)...I found my bottle longevity actually beastly AF ...**conclusion gives me worst headaches from so syrupy sweet cant wear....Mancera Red Tabacco all day everyday 🤙

  • @sandrarincon2930
    @sandrarincon2930 Рік тому

    Both please! Designers & niche 👍🏼💓

  • @anUntouchable
    @anUntouchable Рік тому +2

    More designers please

  • @western-oud1898
    @western-oud1898 Рік тому

    Arrgh a nice shout out for “Boots” pharmacy/store here in the UK..I buy most of my mainline Chanel fragrances from there

  • @paulprice8541
    @paulprice8541 Рік тому

    Maybe a monthly roundup of the supposed best-of-the-best designers the other channels have been hyping

  • @lafrogmhh
    @lafrogmhh Рік тому +1

    yall trippin this a great fragrance

    • @bodyemcal
      @bodyemcal 8 місяців тому +1

      If it's not niche, this guy won't like it. Everything is generic to him unless its niche.

  • @funeka691
    @funeka691 Рік тому +1

    I don't know how these smell. But I do love the female offering of Scandal - thay thick honey is so cozy.

  • @JMigUK
    @JMigUK Рік тому +2

    Totally agree with this review, tried a sample of the EDT and did not enjoy it, so synthetic, tacky and soulless. To me it smells like the target audience are those who have not experienced real perfume before and also think that this line won’t last -sorry is you like this one, just my humble opinion 🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @anUntouchable
    @anUntouchable Рік тому +2

    Have you tried Azzaro The Most Wanted

  • @rob409BOI
    @rob409BOI Рік тому

    These designers really need to stop making le parfum flankers that are edp concentration

  • @sarahglen1140
    @sarahglen1140 Рік тому

    I just really haven't been interested in trying this house at all. Don't know.

    • @shave-a-thon3415
      @shave-a-thon3415 Рік тому +1

      Try Le Male Le Parfum, Le Beau and Ultra Male. They're all beautiful scents, as is the original Le Male.

  • @jwill8759
    @jwill8759 Рік тому +1

    I found the Edt really dull and tedious. Not tried the Edp.

  • @channelchanelchannel6481
    @channelchanelchannel6481 Рік тому +8

    Not impressed with this series. I respect your opinion and I won't be checking out this collection.

  • @oliverdorrill206
    @oliverdorrill206 Рік тому

    Since they are distributed by puig and not bpi they all smell similar to the paco robanne invictus one million no character anymore

  • @jeffrosenblum5053
    @jeffrosenblum5053 Рік тому +2

    I tested this collection and didn't like it.

  • @acevedobrooklyn
    @acevedobrooklyn Рік тому +3

    Yessirr 👍🏽

  • @bookofmillions
    @bookofmillions 9 місяців тому

    Mr. Kouros here 😂 doesn't like them. Ok. Try... many other ones, including MYSLF 😂 ... this is lasting and refined on a molecular level unexpectedly for THE PRICE.

  • @shave-a-thon3415
    @shave-a-thon3415 Рік тому +2

    1) As far as refills goes, how many do you know in the wild community that even make a dent in a bottle, let alone finish one?!
    2) I'm not a fan of refills because it's too easy for them to be tempared with, especially if buying from a discounter who gets their bottles via the grey market.
    I'm surprised you don't have Ultra Male or the two iterations of Le Beau. Don't you think that it would benefit The Perfume Guy, the El Exigente of the perfume community, to have all the flankers from JPG for clients that come to The Perfume Guy Studio?

  • @akweo
    @akweo Рік тому

    Parf 1 . The M is silent

  • @phyllisiervello
    @phyllisiervello Рік тому

    Yep we can’t win them all. I am pondering over your review for Grand Bow. I really like the other two, but not sure about the stepchild. On another note, I am always more interested in Niche fragrances, even though I still love a few designer ones, but they get fewer all the time.

  • @charmarlie
    @charmarlie Рік тому +3

    l don't understand your reviews on JPG HOUSE and ARMANI. I have them all, over 250 other fragrances including all of the PDMs.
    Scandal le parfum is an absolutley amazing strong fragrance that lasts the whole day on you. Sorry Sebastian but l think you must have some personal reasons against JPG & ARMANI.

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому

      Because they mostly crank out garbage. I don’t like most of them.

  • @jarridsteel6229
    @jarridsteel6229 Рік тому

    I haven't smelled either of them because they're not in stores in Montreal. I refuse to blind buy them, too. So, unless they decide to send some to stores in my city, I won't be smelling them ever. LOL Glad you're covering them because based on what you're saying, I don't really be missing anything anyway.

    • @santidbe400
      @santidbe400 Рік тому +1

      In matter of fact you are indeed missing a lot, Speciakly the edt, strong beautiful sweet fragrance, strong and long lasting, perfect for partying .

  • @Tomatohater64
    @Tomatohater64 Рік тому

    Great review, Sebastian. I'll steer clear of these. (All niche, all the time - pretty please?)

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +1

      Thank you. Yeah there are better fragrances out there for sure. Thanks for stopping by.

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +1

      All niche, all the time? Mostly, yes we will keep it at that!! :)

    • @Tomatohater64
      @Tomatohater64 Рік тому

      @@ThePerfumeGuy Alrighty. I'm only slightly melancholy. 🥺

  • @boogiedaddy3434
    @boogiedaddy3434 Рік тому

    Well I defintiely know to skip these now. I get rather bored with designers now anyway, they all smell the same to me. I did try the JPG Le Beau a while back because I got a sample with an order I made. It was better than I expeected ( a nice beachy summer/island vibe) but it didn't blow me away.
    Regardin what I would like to see more of on the channel, my vote goes for more lesser known brands. I'de like to see more indie stuff like January Scent Project, Rogue, and Darren Alan Perfumes (he makes excellent vintage style scents, his two chypres and his iris called Sweet Repose are stunning.

  • @kadaj7269
    @kadaj7269 Рік тому

    I Prefer your core content, niche & independent. Majority of designers nowadays are very lackluster. Appreciate you. Cheers!

  • @gamalielcenteno4801
    @gamalielcenteno4801 Рік тому +2

    👍👍👍👍

  • @FayeCNL
    @FayeCNL Рік тому

    You might well have hit the nail on the head that these scents might well be designed for the less experienced nose, teenage, tweens etc. and maybe priced for that market too 👍🏻

    • @debusen81
      @debusen81 Рік тому +2

      What 11 year olds wear perfume?

    • @FayeCNL
      @FayeCNL Рік тому

      @@debusen81 you would be suprised my daughter is a teen and has a good collection obviously the designer brands thank god she hasn't found out about niche yet 🤦🏼‍♀️😅💷💷💷💷

  • @melanietadevossian5185
    @melanietadevossian5185 Рік тому

    Hi! Not a fan too but appreciate your honest opinion. Thank you

  • @thefragrancevol753
    @thefragrancevol753 Рік тому

    I don't buy the refills, and I don't like the idea of refills. Why would I want to wear that much of the same fragrance? It'll get boring and I'll miss out on other stuff
    As for the reviews, you can go whichever way you want. I get decants of most of the new releases for both the major designers and the luxury niche stuff, so I'll keep watching and commenting with my thoughts either way

  • @franceiroca
    @franceiroca Рік тому

    Smelled the EDT… ended with a tooth decay… definitely not for me 😅

  • @justaddlight
    @justaddlight Рік тому

    A great comparison here Sebastian. Was this really a highly requested vid from your audience? 🤨I'm genuinely curious!

  • @charlottefragrance771
    @charlottefragrance771 Рік тому

    HI SEBASTIAN DO YOU LIVE IN SAN FRANCISCO XXX

  • @Lostb3
    @Lostb3 6 місяців тому

    My dude, you sound so snobby during this vid lol 😅

  • @sdahismail6327
    @sdahismail6327 Рік тому

    I think Invictus somehow ruined a part of the designer fragrance market by introducing this type of fragrances.

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +2

      YES. You said it. I totally agree. That is one of my WORST, absolute worst fragrances. It's bad. I agree with you.

    • @shave-a-thon3415
      @shave-a-thon3415 Рік тому

      @@ThePerfumeGuy I take it you never bought Invictus Aqua, Invictus Intense, Invictus Onyx, Invictus Platinum, Invictus Legend, or Invictus Victory and the new Invictus Victory Elixir? I'd like to see you try the last two (Victory flankers) as they're different than the rest.

  • @moondust013
    @moondust013 Рік тому

    🌹

  • @cecilia_v
    @cecilia_v Рік тому

    👍

  • @drLiberation
    @drLiberation Рік тому

    It has to be really annoying when you need/have to wear something you don’t enjoy to review it.
    P.S. Visit Austria too when coming in March-April 🙂

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +3

      Yeah. I wanted to like it but just didn't get there. I will be coming to Salzburg on this trip! :)

    • @drLiberation
      @drLiberation Рік тому

      @@ThePerfumeGuy Oh cool! It’s a very nice city, but Vienna is nicer 🙃
      I would love to meet you... maybe in Milan if not in Vienna ☺️

    • @ThePerfumeGuy
      @ThePerfumeGuy  Рік тому +2

      Yeah I want to come to Vienna but not on this trip since it's further away. Going to Munich and Salzburg is close. Another time. But come to Esxence, I'll be there. It's in Milan, I'm sure you know. The last two days are open to the public! :)

    • @drLiberation
      @drLiberation Рік тому

      @@ThePerfumeGuy I will be there for sure! Enjoy your travels :)

  • @davidtisch460
    @davidtisch460 Рік тому

    This was a hard pass for me. I hated both. Poor performing garbage in my opinion.

  • @anUntouchable
    @anUntouchable Рік тому

    I just found out they have discontinued ARMANI CODE PROFUMO. How about a Top frag discontinued list i.e worth hunting down