The testimonies and evidence that had been gathered thus far clearly show that she had committed plagiarism. Therefore, the university where she got her PhD should revoke her degree, which means she is not qualified to be in the position that she is now for Harvard. Harvard Corporation must do the right thing to restore its university's prestigious reputation.
Why wait for her to resign? If a student plagiarised, you wouldn't wait for them to voluntarily drop out; they would immedistely be on academic suspension or even expelled. At the least, her dissertation ought to be reviewed.
@@loopba Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
@@garypatrick7817 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
@@billyhorton5779 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
@@jamesdellaneve9005 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
I have heard several people state that person of Harvard is under such scrutiny because she is a black Woman. Uh no - it’s because you are literally the president of Harvard!! The world renowned Harvard whose legacy is built on academic excellence, integrity, and morality. This is so crazy to me that she has not resigned herself. It says more about her lack of leadership by not resigning then the board forcing her out… Harvard - The pride before the fall!
A first year student would equally be under scrutiny for the same plagiarism, and would probably have been kicked out by now. How much more the Harvard CEO.
Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
Imagine being an unfortunate soul who gets operated on by a brain surgeon who got admitted into medical school and then graduated based not on their merit but on crieria set based on DEI.
Shame on her. She needs to go so someone can come in and get control of what's going on at Harvard. Free speech doesn't mean there are no consequences for calling for the genocide of any group.
We send our young sons and daughters to higher education so that they can learn how to disagree reasonably and responsibly. Promoting genocide is NOT responsible. It is inciting violence and we parents don't want our future citizens to be behaving that way and repeating WWII.
Keep in mind that the Harvard Board that wants to keep her know very well why they're keeping her. The Board itself is representative of what they chose as president - a DEI clown show.
@@rasputinspickledpeepee1976 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
@@josephvanname3377 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
Dr Swain is right. Receiving proper citations and acknowledgement to your work taken from, is the lifeblood for academics. It's a low trick to take and not credit. No excuse.
What will it take for Harvard to take action on this matter? What kind of institution that would have failed so badly in its selection process for the most important position at the institution. Harvard is shamefully arrogant in continuing to support Gay and it’s DEI policy. I’m hoping donors will react accordingly.
This is actually laughable. Reality is stranger than fiction. What in the world is going on in places of education? Remember when integrity was important?
@@Diametricallyopposed00 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
aw cmon, giver her a break all she did was verbatim plagiarize hundreds of lines with not even a SINGLE quotation mark.. look, she is a DEI appt, she can DO NO WRONG!! she is untouchable, in fact we must give her a raise and an endowed chair at Harvard!
Yeah, I give you a few good reasons: (a) it is a private enterprise in which congress has absolutely no business. It is beyond their jurisdiction. (b) the question should have been genocide of a people, it is outrageous to state "genocide of the Jews", given current events (c) Jews have forfeited their "anti-semitic" red flag, because they used that flag to attack anybody in any event (d) Jews are now committing genocide themselves (e) they use the anti-semitic flag now to justify genocide, which is a grave abuse of their privilege (f) congress has made a resolution anti-semitism = anti-Zionism which is simply a falsehood (g) congress has been bought by Israel's election interference (h) no one in congress has called out the genocide of the Palestinians (i) congress is aiding and abetting the genocide of Palestinians (j) Congress is delivering weapons to Israel, not Palestine and thus complicit in war crimes (k) Israel has occupied Palestine illegally (l) Israel has no right to the land based on claims of ancestral people (m) This is Israel's second Nakba. The illegal expulsion of Arabs from their homes. (n) Israel is committing all the war crimes in the book (o) Congress should issue a 'anti-Palestian" privilege (p) Congress should not suppress Palestinian sentiments (q) Congress should rescind the censure of Rashida Tlaib, who is critical of Israel, but not anti-semitic (r) Congress should censure Bachmann for instigating genoicide (s) Congress should have impeached Biden's under the table business with Ukraine (t) Congress should impeach Biden for being complicit in war crimes. (u) Congress should impeach Biden for treason, taking our tax money and funneling it into foreign countries. (v) Congress is in violation of February 2023 Conventional Arms Transfers (CAP) policy etc etc etc I guess as poster none of these things were on your radar. If you are from Harvard the above list of reasons are circumstances to avoid slick trick questions of a corrupt, ignorant congress that does not do its job and starts grandstanding with these mock interviews of people with 3 times their IQ and three times their integrity. People with IQ 3 times lower than Congress, will want regime change in Ivy Leagues, by puppets controlled by Israel.
Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
@stevensica89 You could not be more wrong. Nice try, but you failed spectacularly. I am a multimillionaire because I have a degree from a college that is not woke and ignores crap espoused by Harvard etc. Deal with it.
Not an academic but a retired scientist and science educator with mutiple Australian degrees. I am DISGUSTED at this theft of another person's intellectual property. Fire her before she further darkens the reputation of Harvard irreparably and dishonours the academy in general!
Yeah, I give you a few good reasons: (a) it is a private enterprise in which congress has absolutely no business. It is beyond their jurisdiction. (b) the question should have been genocide of a people, it is outrageous to state "genocide of the Jews", given current events (c) Jews have forfeited their "anti-semitic" red flag, because they used that flag to attack anybody in any event (d) Jews are now committing genocide themselves (e) they use the anti-semitic flag now to justify genocide, which is a grave abuse of their privilege (f) congress has made a resolution anti-semitism = anti-Zionism which is simply a falsehood (g) congress has been bought by Israel's election interference (h) no one in congress has called out the genocide of the Palestinians (i) congress is aiding and abetting the genocide of Palestinians (j) Congress is delivering weapons to Israel, not Palestine and thus complicit in war crimes (k) Israel has occupied Palestine illegally (l) Israel has no right to the land based on claims of ancestral people (m) This is Israel's second Nakba. The illegal expulsion of Arabs from their homes. (n) Israel is committing all the war crimes in the book (o) Congress should issue a 'anti-Palestian" privilege (p) Congress should not suppress Palestinian sentiments (q) Congress should rescind the censure of Rashida Tlaib, who is critical of Israel, but not anti-semitic (r) Congress should censure Bachmann for instigating genoicide (s) Congress should have impeached Biden's under the table business with Ukraine (t) Congress should impeach Biden for being complicit in war crimes. (u) Congress should impeach Biden for treason, taking our tax money and funneling it into foreign countries. (v) Congress is in violation of February 2023 Conventional Arms Transfers (CAP) policy etc etc etc (w) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Native Indians (x) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Blacks (y) Almost 200 year after June teenth, the racism against blacks is still in full steam as Gay was specifically attacked for being "black at Harvard". (z) ant-semitism, specifically protects the Jewish Race. It does not transcend to other races. Laws that single out any race are by definition racistic and thus unlawful Ooops... there is much more but I am out of letters..... I guess as poster none of these things were on your radar. If you are from Harvard the above list of reasons are circumstances to avoid slick trick questions of a corrupt, ignorant congress that does not do its job and starts grandstanding with these mock interviews of people with 3 times their IQ and three times their integrity. People with IQ 3 times lower than Congress, will want regime change in Ivy Leagues, by puppets controlled by Israel.
Yeah, I give you a few good reasons: (a) it is a private enterprise in which congress has absolutely no business. It is beyond their jurisdiction. (b) the question should have been genocide of a people, it is outrageous to state "genocide of the Jews", given current events (c) Jews have forfeited their "anti-semitic" red flag, because they used that flag to attack anybody in any event (d) Jews are now committing genocide themselves (e) they use the anti-semitic flag now to justify genocide, which is a grave abuse of their privilege (f) congress has made a resolution anti-semitism = anti-Zionism which is simply a falsehood (g) congress has been bought by Israel's election interference (h) no one in congress has called out the genocide of the Palestinians (i) congress is aiding and abetting the genocide of Palestinians (j) Congress is delivering weapons to Israel, not Palestine and thus complicit in war crimes (k) Israel has occupied Palestine illegally (l) Israel has no right to the land based on claims of ancestral people (m) This is Israel's second Nakba. The illegal expulsion of Arabs from their homes. (n) Israel is committing all the war crimes in the book (o) Congress should issue a 'anti-Palestian" privilege (p) Congress should not suppress Palestinian sentiments (q) Congress should rescind the censure of Rashida Tlaib, who is critical of Israel, but not anti-semitic (r) Congress should censure Bachmann for instigating genoicide (s) Congress should have impeached Biden's under the table business with Ukraine (t) Congress should impeach Biden for being complicit in war crimes. (u) Congress should impeach Biden for treason, taking our tax money and funneling it into foreign countries. (v) Congress is in violation of February 2023 Conventional Arms Transfers (CAP) policy etc etc etc (w) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Native Indians (x) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Blacks (y) Almost 200 year after June teenth, the racism against blacks is still in full steam as Gay was specifically attacked for being "black at Harvard". (z) ant-semitism, specifically protects the Jewish Race. It does not transcend to other races. Laws that single out any race are by definition racistic and thus unlawful Ooops... there is much more but I am out of letters..... I guess as poster none of these things were on your radar. If you are from Harvard the above list of reasons are circumstances to avoid slick trick questions of a corrupt, ignorant congress that does not do its job and starts grandstanding with these mock interviews of people with 3 times their IQ and three times their integrity. People with IQ 3 times lower than Congress, will want regime change in Ivy Leagues, by puppets controlled by Israel.
I doubt anything will happen to her. She is protected. She has a voice and tone and a story Harvard likes. This voice is the direction the school wants to go.
@@ks351 It won't because the money will never stop completely. I am sure there are donors who will stop, but many others will continue. They have some of the country's wealthiest alumni, if not the world.
@@ks351 And many people do care. Some of the most significant people in American history have attended or graduated from Harvard. The former CEO of UA-cam, Susan Diane Wojcicki, where you and I are having this discussion graduated from Harvard.
Yes! You have to defend a dissertation that has original ideas, and Claudine Gay did not do that... she is NOT a PhD! Well said, Dr, Swain whose work WAS seminal!
One of my friends got kicked out of Harvard as an undergrad because of plagiarism. Yet, the President of Harvard is suspected doing the same. Is it because of EDI?
Shouldn't they be more concerned about how she rose so high at one of the most prestigious universities in the world without anyone calling her out ??? And shouldn't they be more concerned with the ideological rot at America's finest institutions than with whether she copied someone else's words ??
Dr Swain is correct. If Dr Gay copied Dr Swain’s study design, she should have merely acknowledged it. nothing wrong with replicating other’s work. I teach research methods in a Doctorate program.
Why hasn't the victims of this pliagerism brought law suits against this woman? Is there a loophole in the law that's protecting this despicable woman?
Previous behaviour is an indicator of future behaviour. As a uni student, our lecturers hammered into us the importance of applying the correct citation & the impact of not doing so. This Gay has no integrity or respect for the position she inhabits.
Ms Gay could not answer easy questions at the hearing correctly. How can you expect her to produce honest PhD research with that level of incompetence. She is a cheat and got to be fired.
Yeah, I give you a few good reasons: (a) it is a private enterprise in which congress has absolutely no business. It is beyond their jurisdiction. (b) the question should have been genocide of a people, it is outrageous to state "genocide of the Jews", given current events (c) Jews have forfeited their "anti-semitic" red flag, because they used that flag to attack anybody in any event (d) Jews are now committing genocide themselves (e) they use the anti-semitic flag now to justify genocide, which is a grave abuse of their privilege (f) congress has made a resolution anti-semitism = anti-Zionism which is simply a falsehood (g) congress has been bought by Israel's election interference (h) no one in congress has called out the genocide of the Palestinians (i) congress is aiding and abetting the genocide of Palestinians (j) Congress is delivering weapons to Israel, not Palestine and thus complicit in war crimes (k) Israel has occupied Palestine illegally (l) Israel has no right to the land based on claims of ancestral people (m) This is Israel's second Nakba. The illegal expulsion of Arabs from their homes. (n) Israel is committing all the war crimes in the book (o) Congress should issue a 'anti-Palestian" privilege (p) Congress should not suppress Palestinian sentiments (q) Congress should rescind the censure of Rashida Tlaib, who is critical of Israel, but not anti-semitic (r) Congress should censure Bachmann for instigating genoicide (s) Congress should have impeached Biden's under the table business with Ukraine (t) Congress should impeach Biden for being complicit in war crimes. (u) Congress should impeach Biden for treason, taking our tax money and funneling it into foreign countries. (v) Congress is in violation of February 2023 Conventional Arms Transfers (CAP) policy etc etc etc (w) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Native Indians (x) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Blacks (y) Almost 200 year after June teenth, the racism against blacks is still in full steam as Gay was specifically attacked for being "black at Harvard". (z) ant-semitism, specifically protects the Jewish Race. It does not transcend to other races. Laws that single out any race are by definition racistic and thus unlawful Ooops... there is much more but I am out of letters..... I guess as poster none of these things were on your radar. If you are from Harvard the above list of reasons are circumstances to avoid slick trick questions of a corrupt, ignorant congress that does not do its job and starts grandstanding with these mock interviews of people with 3 times their IQ and three times their integrity. People with IQ 3 times lower than Congress, will want regime change in Ivy Leagues, by puppets controlled by Israel.
This woman has not published a single book, and she's president of Harvard. In her whole career, she's published 8 papers, most of them riddled with plagiarism.
I said the same thing Dr. swain said, Harvard should be very concerned that Gay (I won't dignify her by calling her Dr. either) doesn't have an original idea.
If plagiarism is not allowed for students, it should not be allowed for the president. Her antisemitism is causing karma by putting her under the microscope.
The testimonies and evidence that had been gathered thus far clearly show that she had committed plagiarism. Therefore, the university where she got her PhD should revoke her degree, which means she is not qualified to be in the position that she is now for Harvard. Harvard Corporation must do the right thing to restore its university's prestigious reputation.
Thanks captain obvious
What ' prestigious reputation ' ?
She’s still qualified for her position. Just look at her race and gender. Intersectionality, bruh.
The irony is that she got her PhD from Harvard. So they missed it back then and they're doubling down on it now.
And then admit that diversity and inclusion is ruining the country
Why wait for her to resign? If a student plagiarised, you wouldn't wait for them to voluntarily drop out; they would immedistely be on academic suspension or even expelled. At the least, her dissertation ought to be reviewed.
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
Even if they fire her Harvard is just going to hire someone just like her. Harvard has an agenda.
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
Remind you of something? **cough Hamas leaders **cough
Harvard just started a special program to recruit the Houthi
It doesn't matter. They will not live down this DEI disaster. Harvard is not only NOT impeccable. It's a 5-alarm fire.
@@loopba Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
What will it take for Claudine Gay to resign?
In Academia plagiarism is a 'BIG DEAL"!
Regardless @@halomaster9640
It used to be, anyway
@@halomaster9640you are obviously not an academic
@@halomaster9640 can't even type it correctly
The Universities and their administrations definitely see themselves as an "Island unto themselves".@@josephvanname3377
40 examples of plagiarism is just a coincidence I'm sure.
Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
Well…..obviously 😅
Incidentally gay learned a lot from illiterate professor Muhammad SAW pie be upon him
@@garypatrick7817 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
What happens when "diversity" takes priority over hiring someone actually competent.
Unfortunately it is happening everywhere, not just academia.
Kamala Harris comes to mind!
@@billyhorton5779 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
@@billyhorton5779The Vice President has nothing to do with this. Why are you bringing her up?
Harris was chosen to be Biden’s running mate because she was a person of color with a vagina. Not because she had actual merit.
I just looked on Wikipedia for this guest - Carol M. Swain - her story is amazing. Very impressive person for what she went through in her life.
Her story is amazing. But means nothing because she’s conservative.
@@jamesdellaneve9005 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
I have heard several people state that person of Harvard is under such scrutiny because she is a black Woman. Uh no - it’s because you are literally the president of Harvard!! The world renowned Harvard whose legacy is built on academic excellence, integrity, and morality. This is so crazy to me that she has not resigned herself. It says more about her lack of leadership by not resigning then the board forcing her out…
Harvard - The pride before the fall!
A first year student would equally be under scrutiny for the same plagiarism, and would probably have been kicked out by now. How much more the Harvard CEO.
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
Imagine being an unfortunate soul who gets operated on by a brain surgeon who got admitted into medical school and then graduated based not on their merit but on crieria set based on DEI.
Scary you have point
Investigation into malpractice; then sue the hospital out of existence. Send the message this must stop!
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
@@dwightdonnelly8662 good idea but first must make it out of hospital
Shame on her. She needs to go so someone can come in and get control of what's going on at Harvard.
Free speech doesn't mean there are no consequences for calling for the genocide of any group.
Harvard has really low rank in Free Speec h, so that argument is out of the window long ago.
They'll just replace her with another diversity hire anyways.
We send our young sons and daughters to higher education so that they can learn how to disagree reasonably and responsibly. Promoting genocide is NOT responsible. It is inciting violence and we parents don't want our future citizens to be behaving that way and repeating WWII.
@mariefrench44 Schools in the US used to teach children how to think. Now, they teach them what to think.
Keep in mind that the Harvard Board that wants to keep her know very well why they're keeping her. The Board itself is representative of what they chose as president - a DEI clown show.
I hope this incident brings more attention to Dr. Carol Swain and her work.
Sure you do.
Fire her
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
@@rasputinspickledpeepee1976 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
Get rid of her, Harvard, and save yourself.
@@josephvanname3377 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
Plagiarism is theft.
Only if you get caught
Kick this plagiarist out. If the head of Harvard is a plagiarist, how much worse will her students be?
Termination
She’s dirty and corrupt!
Dr Swain is right. Receiving proper citations and acknowledgement to your work taken from, is the lifeblood for academics. It's a low trick to take and not credit. No excuse.
@@ScienceWatch2000-xs5nh Well, the accusation is that she didn't always do so.
Has this woman ever done anything that she actually thought of herself ?
Doubtful. I honestly think she’s played her race card all the way to the top.
What will it take for Harvard to take action on this matter? What kind of institution that would have failed so badly in its selection process for the most important position at the institution. Harvard is shamefully arrogant in continuing to support Gay and it’s DEI policy. I’m hoping donors will react accordingly.
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
This is actually laughable. Reality is stranger than fiction. What in the world is going on in places of education? Remember when integrity was important?
@@Diametricallyopposed00 Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
aw cmon, giver her a break all she did was verbatim plagiarize hundreds of lines with not even a SINGLE quotation mark.. look, she is a DEI appt, she can DO NO WRONG!! she is untouchable, in fact we must give her a raise and an endowed chair at Harvard!
Why not just cover it up like all the Jeffrey Epstein stuff?
@@TimothyDeSomerville yeah why not? Harvard motto used to be VERITAS, what will they have to change it to???
@@TimothyDeSomerville Because the CIA isn't involved.
Verba non acta? @@wwj14
@@DeeSmith001 yes is that your suggestion for Harvard new motto, changing it from VERITAS?
Never going to send my child to these corrupt Universities. Enough is enough.
Yeah, I give you a few good reasons:
(a) it is a private enterprise in which congress has absolutely no business. It is beyond their jurisdiction.
(b) the question should have been genocide of a people, it is outrageous to state "genocide of the Jews", given current events
(c) Jews have forfeited their "anti-semitic" red flag, because they used that flag to attack anybody in any event
(d) Jews are now committing genocide themselves
(e) they use the anti-semitic flag now to justify genocide, which is a grave abuse of their privilege
(f) congress has made a resolution anti-semitism = anti-Zionism which is simply a falsehood
(g) congress has been bought by Israel's election interference
(h) no one in congress has called out the genocide of the Palestinians
(i) congress is aiding and abetting the genocide of Palestinians
(j) Congress is delivering weapons to Israel, not Palestine and thus complicit in war crimes
(k) Israel has occupied Palestine illegally
(l) Israel has no right to the land based on claims of ancestral people
(m) This is Israel's second Nakba. The illegal expulsion of Arabs from their homes.
(n) Israel is committing all the war crimes in the book
(o) Congress should issue a 'anti-Palestian" privilege
(p) Congress should not suppress Palestinian sentiments
(q) Congress should rescind the censure of Rashida Tlaib, who is critical of Israel, but not anti-semitic
(r) Congress should censure Bachmann for instigating genoicide
(s) Congress should have impeached Biden's under the table business with Ukraine
(t) Congress should impeach Biden for being complicit in war crimes.
(u) Congress should impeach Biden for treason, taking our tax money and funneling it into foreign countries.
(v) Congress is in violation of February 2023 Conventional Arms Transfers (CAP) policy
etc etc etc
I guess as poster none of these things were on your radar.
If you are from Harvard the above list of reasons are circumstances to avoid slick trick questions
of a corrupt, ignorant congress that does not do its job and starts grandstanding with these mock
interviews of people with 3 times their IQ and three times their integrity.
People with IQ 3 times lower than Congress, will want regime change in Ivy Leagues, by puppets
controlled by Israel.
Well said, Dr. Swain.
Ever heard about AIPAC? Ever heard about the Russian foreign election interference hoax? You do not find it curious that while there is no poverty in Israel, we subsidise them with 100 billion of our US tax money? This is Israel's foreign election interference in plain sight. The whole US congress are already AIPAC puppies. Now one of the last strongholds is our intelligentia. But AIPAC is now attacking that too, so soon we may just hand over the title to this country directly to Israel. I just cannot believe people are falling for thsi smear campaign. Israel stated 'One down' after the prez of Upenn resigned. Wake up. This is not news. It is AIPAC propaganda.
Diversity hire is embarrassing Harvard. Shocker!
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
Can tell she’s not qualified by the looks of her
Get rid of Gay immediately, what a disgrace for Harvard
Gay can’t stay!!
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
Gay has ensured that Harvard degrees will be viewed with scorn and as a negative.
Sure, but I bet that you would love to have one anyway.
@stevensica89 You could not be more wrong. Nice try, but you failed spectacularly. I am a multimillionaire because I have a degree from a college that is not woke and ignores crap espoused by Harvard etc. Deal with it.
I’m sure when she wrote this she didn’t anticipate AI being able to nail her hide to the wall
It was the self satisfying you can't touch me smirks from Gay that did it for me,a very sanctimonious horrible woman.
Not an academic but a retired scientist and science educator with mutiple Australian degrees. I am DISGUSTED at this theft of another person's intellectual property. Fire her before she further darkens the reputation of Harvard irreparably and dishonours the academy in general!
Why is Harvard focused on race and not excellence?
Yeah, I give you a few good reasons:
(a) it is a private enterprise in which congress has absolutely no business. It is beyond their jurisdiction.
(b) the question should have been genocide of a people, it is outrageous to state "genocide of the Jews", given current events
(c) Jews have forfeited their "anti-semitic" red flag, because they used that flag to attack anybody in any event
(d) Jews are now committing genocide themselves
(e) they use the anti-semitic flag now to justify genocide, which is a grave abuse of their privilege
(f) congress has made a resolution anti-semitism = anti-Zionism which is simply a falsehood
(g) congress has been bought by Israel's election interference
(h) no one in congress has called out the genocide of the Palestinians
(i) congress is aiding and abetting the genocide of Palestinians
(j) Congress is delivering weapons to Israel, not Palestine and thus complicit in war crimes
(k) Israel has occupied Palestine illegally
(l) Israel has no right to the land based on claims of ancestral people
(m) This is Israel's second Nakba. The illegal expulsion of Arabs from their homes.
(n) Israel is committing all the war crimes in the book
(o) Congress should issue a 'anti-Palestian" privilege
(p) Congress should not suppress Palestinian sentiments
(q) Congress should rescind the censure of Rashida Tlaib, who is critical of Israel, but not anti-semitic
(r) Congress should censure Bachmann for instigating genoicide
(s) Congress should have impeached Biden's under the table business with Ukraine
(t) Congress should impeach Biden for being complicit in war crimes.
(u) Congress should impeach Biden for treason, taking our tax money and funneling it into foreign countries.
(v) Congress is in violation of February 2023 Conventional Arms Transfers (CAP) policy
etc etc etc
(w) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Native Indians
(x) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Blacks
(y) Almost 200 year after June teenth, the racism against blacks is still in full steam
as Gay was specifically attacked for being "black at Harvard".
(z) ant-semitism, specifically protects the Jewish Race.
It does not transcend to other races.
Laws that single out any race are by definition racistic and thus unlawful
Ooops... there is much more but I am out of letters.....
I guess as poster none of these things were on your radar.
If you are from Harvard the above list of reasons are circumstances to avoid slick trick questions
of a corrupt, ignorant congress that does not do its job and starts grandstanding with these mock
interviews of people with 3 times their IQ and three times their integrity.
People with IQ 3 times lower than Congress, will want regime change in Ivy Leagues, by puppets
controlled by Israel.
When you pick people bc of their skin color and gender, but not bc of their talent and knowledge
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
Even her name gave her an advantage - gay‼
@@jasperhorace7147not just a name but HE is
Bring back merit based hiring!
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
She is an equity hire.
Fire this unqualified, anti-Semitic DEI hire.
Yeah, I give you a few good reasons:
(a) it is a private enterprise in which congress has absolutely no business. It is beyond their jurisdiction.
(b) the question should have been genocide of a people, it is outrageous to state "genocide of the Jews", given current events
(c) Jews have forfeited their "anti-semitic" red flag, because they used that flag to attack anybody in any event
(d) Jews are now committing genocide themselves
(e) they use the anti-semitic flag now to justify genocide, which is a grave abuse of their privilege
(f) congress has made a resolution anti-semitism = anti-Zionism which is simply a falsehood
(g) congress has been bought by Israel's election interference
(h) no one in congress has called out the genocide of the Palestinians
(i) congress is aiding and abetting the genocide of Palestinians
(j) Congress is delivering weapons to Israel, not Palestine and thus complicit in war crimes
(k) Israel has occupied Palestine illegally
(l) Israel has no right to the land based on claims of ancestral people
(m) This is Israel's second Nakba. The illegal expulsion of Arabs from their homes.
(n) Israel is committing all the war crimes in the book
(o) Congress should issue a 'anti-Palestian" privilege
(p) Congress should not suppress Palestinian sentiments
(q) Congress should rescind the censure of Rashida Tlaib, who is critical of Israel, but not anti-semitic
(r) Congress should censure Bachmann for instigating genoicide
(s) Congress should have impeached Biden's under the table business with Ukraine
(t) Congress should impeach Biden for being complicit in war crimes.
(u) Congress should impeach Biden for treason, taking our tax money and funneling it into foreign countries.
(v) Congress is in violation of February 2023 Conventional Arms Transfers (CAP) policy
etc etc etc
(w) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Native Indians
(x) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Blacks
(y) Almost 200 year after June teenth, the racism against blacks is still in full steam
as Gay was specifically attacked for being "black at Harvard".
(z) ant-semitism, specifically protects the Jewish Race.
It does not transcend to other races.
Laws that single out any race are by definition racistic and thus unlawful
Ooops... there is much more but I am out of letters.....
I guess as poster none of these things were on your radar.
If you are from Harvard the above list of reasons are circumstances to avoid slick trick questions
of a corrupt, ignorant congress that does not do its job and starts grandstanding with these mock
interviews of people with 3 times their IQ and three times their integrity.
People with IQ 3 times lower than Congress, will want regime change in Ivy Leagues, by puppets
controlled by Israel.
Be honest, you have Zero Interest ithe issue of academic integrity. It's the Israel stuff, and nothing else, that concerns you.
I doubt anything will happen to her. She is protected. She has a voice and tone and a story Harvard likes. This voice is the direction the school wants to go.
Defund and boycott Harvard.
Harvard's endowment is $50.7Billion, defunding means nothing
@@muskegontribune it will after 10 years
@@ks351 It won't because the money will never stop completely. I am sure there are donors who will stop, but many others will continue. They have some of the country's wealthiest alumni, if not the world.
@@muskegontribune many people dont care as a long as it takes -- the less Harvard grads we hire the better it is for this world
@@ks351 And many people do care. Some of the most significant people in American history have attended or graduated from Harvard. The former CEO of UA-cam, Susan Diane Wojcicki, where you and I are having this discussion graduated from Harvard.
So you can copy and paste your way to a Harvard PHD. Since Harvard doesn’t mind plagiarism, can I just print myself a Harvard diploma now?
Yes! You have to defend a dissertation that has original ideas, and Claudine Gay did not do that... she is NOT a PhD! Well said, Dr, Swain whose work WAS seminal!
Claudine Gay is an embarrassment to Harvard and Academia in general. In this context, she should be fired.
Get rid of her !!!!!
Why do these interviewers always interrupt the experts? I would like to hear what Dr Swaim has to say and the interviewer keeps interrupting her
Plagiarism is virtue at Harvard.🙂
DEI is a religion, and therefore they can't deny their God.
One of my friends got kicked out of Harvard as an undergrad because of plagiarism. Yet, the President of Harvard is suspected doing the same. Is it because of EDI?
Shame. Karma at work.
Double standard, we do it all the time. - welcome to Harvard.
Diversity Hire
Her true colors are clearly shown, shame on her, she should resign, the world is watching
Gay gotta go
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
Dr. Swain bravo!!!! Board needs to be replesed.
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
DEI is an mechanism for making up the rules to discriminate
Just gonna say I love Dr. Carol Swain. Brilliant woman!
Thanks to Dr. Swain!
Shouldn't they be more concerned about how she rose so high at one of the most prestigious universities in the world without anyone calling her out ??? And shouldn't they be more concerned with the ideological rot at America's finest institutions than with whether she copied someone else's words ??
Dr Swain…brilliant author..would be an amazing Harvard President
Gay can’t stay!!
Good good good. Down with the woke queen.
" This Gay!" Dr. Swain said. Shameless Harvard President!
Dr Swain is correct. If Dr Gay copied Dr Swain’s study design, she should have merely acknowledged it. nothing wrong with replicating other’s work. I teach research methods in a Doctorate program.
I hope this is just the beginning of exposing all these fake dei fraudsters
When did plagiarism go from being assessed on a binary to a spectrum?
Why hasn't the victims of this pliagerism brought law suits against this woman? Is there a loophole in the law that's protecting this despicable woman?
BWorthless paper in a worthless field from a worthless university...and yet..plagiarized! Ms. Gay - perfect for the job.
Carol is one amazing soul! The "Plagiarist" needs to resign. It's an academic embarrassment. And, "duplicate language" is 1984 at its best!
That is so wrong. You should be recognized for your innovative and originality in thought.
Plagiarism smacks of laziness.
Jeez lady, have some dignity and moral rectitude and just go!!!
Her phd should have been a “literature review”! Love it!
Plagiarism, like genocide, depends on context. 😅
"Rules for thee but not for me."
What a shame
This News Nation newscaster is horrible
She kept interrupting Dr Swain
In addition the newscaster missed Dr Swains point altogether .
Hypocrisy at Harvard? I can’t believe it.
Well if copying the other kids homework helped her get high marks in junior high why shouldn't it still help her at university now she is an "adult"
So this lady stole someone else's work and claim it to be her own original worm? That low
Wow😮 how ignorant and sad.
Harvard just started a special program to recruit the Houthi
Get her out. ,!!!!!!!!!
regardless of her horrendous testimony, Congress shouldn't be investigating the charges of plagiarism against her. It's not their role.
She better resign...before it is too late.
Previous behaviour is an indicator of future behaviour. As a uni student, our lecturers hammered into us the importance of applying the correct citation & the impact of not doing so. This Gay has no integrity or respect for the position she inhabits.
Good on Dr. Swain for setting Claudine straight.
Dr Swain should be Harvard’s president.
Ms Gay could not answer easy questions at the hearing correctly. How can you expect her to produce honest PhD research with that level of incompetence. She is a cheat and got to be fired.
Steve Urkel in trouble
OUTSTANDING
Yeah, I give you a few good reasons:
(a) it is a private enterprise in which congress has absolutely no business. It is beyond their jurisdiction.
(b) the question should have been genocide of a people, it is outrageous to state "genocide of the Jews", given current events
(c) Jews have forfeited their "anti-semitic" red flag, because they used that flag to attack anybody in any event
(d) Jews are now committing genocide themselves
(e) they use the anti-semitic flag now to justify genocide, which is a grave abuse of their privilege
(f) congress has made a resolution anti-semitism = anti-Zionism which is simply a falsehood
(g) congress has been bought by Israel's election interference
(h) no one in congress has called out the genocide of the Palestinians
(i) congress is aiding and abetting the genocide of Palestinians
(j) Congress is delivering weapons to Israel, not Palestine and thus complicit in war crimes
(k) Israel has occupied Palestine illegally
(l) Israel has no right to the land based on claims of ancestral people
(m) This is Israel's second Nakba. The illegal expulsion of Arabs from their homes.
(n) Israel is committing all the war crimes in the book
(o) Congress should issue a 'anti-Palestian" privilege
(p) Congress should not suppress Palestinian sentiments
(q) Congress should rescind the censure of Rashida Tlaib, who is critical of Israel, but not anti-semitic
(r) Congress should censure Bachmann for instigating genoicide
(s) Congress should have impeached Biden's under the table business with Ukraine
(t) Congress should impeach Biden for being complicit in war crimes.
(u) Congress should impeach Biden for treason, taking our tax money and funneling it into foreign countries.
(v) Congress is in violation of February 2023 Conventional Arms Transfers (CAP) policy
etc etc etc
(w) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Native Indians
(x) Coincidentally Congress never acknowledged the genocide of Blacks
(y) Almost 200 year after June teenth, the racism against blacks is still in full steam
as Gay was specifically attacked for being "black at Harvard".
(z) ant-semitism, specifically protects the Jewish Race.
It does not transcend to other races.
Laws that single out any race are by definition racistic and thus unlawful
Ooops... there is much more but I am out of letters.....
I guess as poster none of these things were on your radar.
If you are from Harvard the above list of reasons are circumstances to avoid slick trick questions
of a corrupt, ignorant congress that does not do its job and starts grandstanding with these mock
interviews of people with 3 times their IQ and three times their integrity.
People with IQ 3 times lower than Congress, will want regime change in Ivy Leagues, by puppets
controlled by Israel.
4:39 - Of all the places to interrupt...
This woman has not published a single book, and she's president of Harvard. In her whole career, she's published 8 papers, most of them riddled with plagiarism.
The entire system sucks they'd allowed her to do this.
This is not surprising at all.
People think she has been cleared.
I said the same thing Dr. swain said, Harvard should be very concerned that Gay (I won't dignify her by calling her Dr. either) doesn't have an original idea.
If plagiarism is not allowed for students, it should not be allowed for the president. Her antisemitism is causing karma by putting her under the microscope.
What’s taking them so long?
Is she going to blame Jews
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
I can tell she’s not qualified from looking at her
Because Harvard is TOP NOTCH. AIPAC already corrupted everything. Let Harvard not fall for the pathetic AIPAC puppets in Congress.
Sounds like retaliation to me. 😢
plagiarist and incompetent...so disappointed with harvard
I agree with Dr Swain. Congress shouldn’t be investigating this. If Harvard doesn’t take care of this, then it stops there.
The federal government gives money to Harvard. They can investigate Harvard, and decide on cutting the funds.
What a fraud👎🏻