On Bureaucracy with Dr. Hassan Iqbal | Former Federal Secretary | TWT | World Times Institute
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 тра 2024
- In this episode, Dr. Hassan Iqbal graced our studio with his august presence. We talked about: the role of bureaucracy in the country's future, why don't we see improvements in our system despite such learned CSS officers joining it, and ways for improvement.
In this episode we discussed:
- Motivation behind CSS
- Why don't the CSS officers deliver?
- Population explosion
- Do people do CSS for a good lifestyle?
- Relevance and nature of syllabus for CSS
- Polarization in Politics
- Do people do CSS for a good lifestyle?
- So many policies, no implementation
- Best Benchmarking for CSS
- Why bureaucracy is better in other countries
- Why did the British not continue the CSS in this form?
- Practical advice for improvement
00:00 Introduction
1:05 Motivation behind CSS
03:20 Why don't the CSS officers deliver?
07:42 Population explosion
10:00 Do people do CSS for a good lifestyle?
12:42 Relevance and nature of syllabus for CSS
18:54 Polarization in Politics
21:46 Lawmaking and education
24:44 So many policies, no implementation
27:50 Best Benchmarking for CSS
29:25 Why bureaucracy is better in other countries
30:45 Why did the British not continue the CSS in this form?
35:45 Practical advice for improvement
Follow US on:
~ Facebook: / worldtimesinstitute
~ Instagram: instagram.com/?hl=en
~ UA-cam: / jwtcssvideos
~ Twitter: / worldtimesinst1
~ Website: worldtimesinstitute.com.pk/
Do not forget to subscribe, like, and press the bell icon!
He is just defending the system he is a part of
Great interview.
I would say a seasoned bureaucratic mind tells the things in this way.....very good indeed
Brilliant
Great discussion
Great interview. I appreciate and urge to conduct interview like this
I am very much agreed with the tenure policy and performance appraisal
Great person.
The host was looking at bureaucracy in isolation and hence was moving in circles and kept coming back to same question of why it hasn't been able to deliver in Pakistan like in other countries. The guest tried to reiterate that bureaucracy can't be isolated from the society by pointing towards population and political issues. Yes the indigenous problems within the system were discussed at one point but the discussion could have been way more fruitful had the host been more open and more holistic in his approach. He could also have got more from the guest then. It felt more like a mainstream media interview. Css level talks should be more holistic and for that the host must be more trained, mature and open.
This person is probably not willing to explain the root cause of our country which every person of us knows well but people like ashir azeem have the courage to do so
He has only a single-point agenda to blame for the failure. The population pace.
Population ko control karney ka sbsi bihtareen ek he Hal ha k population k leyea resources banaen !
23:00, Sir Hassan has asserted that assembly members need not have a degree to make laws. I always adore your point of view but in this case, I would contradict. Unless a person is educated, one is not able to work in a strategic way. Thus, a proper qualification system should also be developed for politicians. They must clear a test in order to get eligible to contest elections.
Sir i humbly request you kindly do an action on adds bcz its inttrutp into thousands of words which are priceless in ur platform and few adds which are useless also sabottage of all over knowledge videos thanks sir
Css exam to check intelligence and eligibility not for department allocation
Pay them more, a precise mechanism of disqualification from the service if corrupted, take away the protocol and pensions and you will see the change.
Host asked very relevant questions but gust was giving tricky answers
I think the whole discussion is on "kya huna chahiye" ,"ye nahi hu rha" but both of them ignored a very simple fact , what CAN we do and what is NEEDED! No initiative, no will to rethink, reskill and revamp ourselves with the changing times. No strategic thinking, just firefighting the scenarios instead of doing something for the cause that causes the fires at the first place. A firm stance on rule of law is necessary but we as people don't want it. This system seems to be resistive to disruption instead of embracing it. Civil services through out the performing world have work ethics more firm and strong than the private sector but here the work ethics are down the drain, the responsibility is not there. The ownership is missing! Make all the excuses but at the end, the system is aging when it needs reinvigorated reskilling and will!
I think it's a conducive interview.
A bureaucrat is defending the system and is unable to present any critical analysis towards improvement or suggest changes in the system for improvement.
Enabling environment make them to choose for serving the people/country or siding with politicians and make money & establish their families abroad.
If bureaucracy works honestly the country would progress but this is a void. The reasons must be many but major one is the political influence and postings within days if they do not come up/aligne with the local politicians/ministers. So political dependance of bureaucracy must be finished on the lines of Judiciary and Army.
That would help bureaucracy work independently and resist unlawful practics by the politicians. There must be separate system of checks and accountability for the bureaucracy but they must be free of political wheeling dealing.
Off course a assembly member must have qualified... But unfortunately they are sitting in assemblies with no degrees.. and bureaucracy forced to work under them
A short answer to the host for all his questions, "Beggars can't be choosers"
If you will try to make an enabling environment, then a BLACK VIGO will come and will give you an enabling environment of disappearance.
Sir ap population ko Pakistan ki taraqi ka issue kion bata rahi hen agar esa he tu China ne apni population k leyea Kis tarah resources banai hen ?
This is not honest talk. This whole css thing has gone redundant. Passing 12 general papers and getting allocated into very technical departments is a joke.
So introvert
Interview was good but unfortunately, guest/his mindset of status quo & not a person to reform. Only population is not an issue. Where is India & China? The world's top two countries in terms of population?? The host should have ask & give example.
nothing but a waste of time, if you're here for academic learning.
Host is immature,always starting his question with لیکن، تو which is kind of childish and it is not a productive conversation.He should open his mind and try to understand what he is saying and should listen.He is just thinking what he would ask while he is answering his question.He should prepare himself before this interview.
Thank you for your feedback. The reason I am starting my questions with IFs and Buts is because we are trying to reach the root of the problem. The questions are always prepared alongwith some extempore ones. If I just agree with the guest it creates what is known as an "echo chamber". That stops the learning process.
@@osamarizvi7083 totally satisfied with u sir
This guy is a kid. He doesn't know how to get max out of this bureaucrat. Moreover, Bureaucrat lacks will to give more fruitful insights of this system. Whole discussion rounds about population explosion and Political interference instead of capacity enhancement. Useless.
Make any of single video just even of 2 second then say......, basically the problem is the people like you does't value anybody's effort you people are there only for discourage the others, if you can't tell about anybody's goodness then you have no right to say bad about that person, hope so will got it!!!!!
Tt
This man is telling lies n lies n lies
This interview has no purpose, proved useless and nothing could have concluded out of it
Not satisfied by the host
The person conducting interview does not know how to sit ethically.
Who is usama rizvi
An analyst, a writer and an editor as well ,basically he is a versatile personality in himself😇 and i have running short of words to explain about him because he has helped me a lot even we don't know each other but still......... May Allah help and bless him always.
@@atikaabid1102 help me too the way he helped you
@@stu1246 Thanks
@@atikaabid1102 Thank you!
@@osamarizvi7083 My pleasure sir and u deserve more than this...
Questions are authentic but answers are not.... He is not able to give proper answer
Great discussion